McDonald's Mein Hai Kuch Baat
McDonald's Mein Hai Kuch Baat
McDonald's Mein Hai Kuch Baat
SYNOPSIS
Can you guess the name of the company which: Is the ninth most valuable brand in the world? Has replaced the US army as the Nations largest job training organization? Controls the market share of more than 3 food chains taken together in America? Its none other than McDonalds Corporation USA. Looking at the above statistics makes one wonder that what is the driving force behind all these achievements? How is it that the chicken burger available in San Francisco is same as the one available in Delhi? Many of these questions have been answered in the book McDonalds: Behind the Golden Arches written by John Love. But are these standards being carried out in India as well? The golden arches of McDonalds are slowly becoming an integral part of the Indian landscapes. Everyone knows McDonalds is big, but very few know just how significant its impact on Indian business really is. The inside of McDonalds remains a mystery. McDonald's India is a joint venture of McDonalds Corporation with Amit Jatia and Vikram Bakshi. Amit Jatia handles the operations in western region whereas Vikram Bakshi in the northern region. McDonald's India is an employer of opportunity, providing quality employment and long-term careers to the Indian people. The average McDonald's restaurant employs more than 100 people in 25 different positions from cashier to restaurant manager. McDonald's world class-training inputs to its employees can be seen in the present close to 2000 employees currently in Mumbai and Delhi.
But the most overlooked fact of McDonalds India is its contribution to the food processing industry. Six years prior to the opening of the first McDonald's restaurant in India, McDonald's and its international supplier partners worked together with local Indian Companies to develop products that meet McDonald's rigorous quality standards. Part of this development involves the transfer of state-of-the-art food processing technology, which has enabled Indian businesses to grow by improving their ability to compete in todays international markets. McDonalds dedication to its suppliers has lead to their growth, beyond the boundaries of the India. These aspects of McDonalds do not get covered and highlighted by the news hungry press. But when the false news of using beef tallow in the french fries hit the market, the press did not leave a chance to exaggerate it. Despite the fact that right form the beginning; no beef ingredients have been used in any of the products in India. The marketing agency of McDonalds, Mudra comes to its rescue in such times. The advertisements created by Mudra are a rage all over the nation, especially amongst the children. Who can forget the little kid who gets nervous in the school competition, but becomes happy again when his father takes him to McDonalds? McDonalds India has tried not to leave any stone un-turned in its objective to satisfy the Indian customer. But in Amit Jatias words, Customers are generally not forgiving. According to the survey conducted, customers demand low prices, more seating space, more variety, home delivery, and the list is endless. The fundamental secret to McDonalds success is the way it achieves uniformity and allegiance to an operating regimen. McDonalds India has to adhere to many rules and regulations laid down by the parent company, and it still has to cater to the Indian customer and his needs. McDonalds India is a case study on how to mix conformity with creativity.
1. HISTORY OF MCDONALDS
In 1954, a fifty-two-year-old milk-shake machine salesman saw a hamburger stand in San Bernardino, California, and envisioned a massive new industry: fast food. In what should have been his golden years, Raymond Kroc, the founder and builder of McDonald's Corporation, proved himself an industrial pioneer no less capable than Henry Ford. He revolutionized the American restaurant industry by imposing discipline on the production of hamburgers, french fries, and milk shakes. By developing a sophisticated operating and delivery system, he insured that the french fries customers bought in Topeka would be the same as the ones purchased in New York City. Such consistency made McDonald's the brand name that defined American fast food.
4 Unlike so many food-service operations Kroc had come across, this joint hummed like a finely tuned engine. They offered a nine-item menu -- burgers, french fries, shakes, and pies -- eliminated seating, and used paper and plastic utensils instead of glass and china. They had also devised the rudiments of a hamburger assembly line so they could deliver orders in less than sixty seconds. And the prices were remarkably low: fifteen-cent burgers and ten cent fries. Kroc instantly knew he had seen the future. 1.1 Ray Kroc Kroc felt sure the McDonald brothers' operation could succeed wildly if it expanded. So the next day, he offered them a proposition. At root, the McDonald brothers were indifferent businessmen, satisfied with the $100,000 they earned annually and unwilling to invest the energy to build a chain. But Kroc was a veteran salesman with more that thirty years of experience. Using every ounce of persuasion he could muster, he finally convinced the brothers to cut a deal: Kroc would sell McDonald's franchises for the low price of $950. In exchange, he would keep 1.4 percent of all sales and funnel 0.5 percent back to the brothers. Because franchisees kicked back such a meager percentage of total sales -- just 1.9 percent -- the corporate parent made very little money.
5 ounce. Kroc even built a laboratory in suburban Chicago to devise a method for making the perfect fried potato in the late 1950s. Instead of simply supplying franchisees with milk-shake formula and ice cream, Kroc wanted to sell his new partners an operating system. In other words, he branded a service. And this was the revolutionary means McDonald's would use to create a chain in which a store in Delaware and a store in Nevada could serve burgers of the exact same size and quality, each containing the same number of pickle slices and topped with the same-size dollops of mustard and ketchup, each arrayed on similar tray alongside potatoes deep-fried for the exact same length of time. As Kroc recalled, "Perfection is very difficult to achieve, and perfection was what I wanted in McDonald's. Everything else was secondary for me." But the exacting demands served a strategic goal. "Our aim, of course, was to insure repeat business based on the system's reputation rather than on the quality of a single store or operator," Kroc said.
Deep in hock and with no profit growth in sight, Kroc faced a classic dilemma. He couldn't afford to expand. And he couldn't afford to tread water. Fortunately, Harry Sonneborn came up with a solution. He thought McDonald's could make money by leasing or buying potential store sites and then subleasing them to franchisees initially at a 20 percent markup, and then at a 40 percent markup. Under this plan, McDonald's would scout out sites and sign twenty-year leases at fixed rates.
6 Franchisees would then pay McDonald's either a minimum rate or a percentage of sales, whichever was greater. As sales and prices inevitably rose over the years, the company would collect more and more rent, as its costs remained virtually constant. Embracing Sonneborn's idea, in 1956 Kroc set up a subsidiary, the Franchise Realty Corporation, to execute the new strategy. In the years thereafter, he flew around the country in a small airplane, scouting suburban neighborhoods dotted with tract housing, schools, and churches -- which he regarded as fertile ground for the planting of new "Golden Arches." In this pre-strip-mall era, real estate along well-traveled byways was both cheap and plentiful. And in a short period of time, the real estate operation became a high-margin contributor to McDonald's bottom line. As Kroc noted: "This was the beginning of real income for McDonald's." The real estate strategy played perfectly into Kroc's larger goal of control. Rather than sell blanket geographic franchises, which would grant the holder the right to build as many or as few stores as he chose in a particular area, Kroc sold only individual franchises, for a low fee of $950. This insured that operators unwillingly to play by his rules could open no more than one outlet. As a landlord, Kroc could compose legal documents guaranteeing further control. And by writing leases that would force tenants to conform to corporate policy, he could more easily insure that the look, feel, and taste of McDonald's would be identical in Bangor, Maine, and Butte, Montana. Although Kroc stepped down as chief executive in 1968, giving way to Fred Turner, he remained a vital symbol of the company's roots, and an enduring influence over day-to-day operations. Though he killed the competition, the competition didn't kill Ray Kroc. He passed away from old age in January 1984, at the age of eighty-one, just the ten months before McDonald's sold its 50-billionth hamburger.
original menu of hamburgers, cheeseburgers, fries and old-fashioned milkshakes. Also available are more recent McDonald's items such as Big Macs and Happy Meals. McDonald's reopened the facility as it was with walkup windows and outdoor seating. They also constructed and addition housing a museum, gift shop, restrooms and more outdoor seating.
2. STRATEGY OF MCDONALDS
McDonalds Corporation, the world's largest and best-known global food-service retailer, has demonstrated positive momentum with a growth potential of opening 2,000 restaurants per year worldwide. Total stores in 1998 exceeded 23,000, with over 12,000 in the United States and 11,000 in company's strategic priority providing exceptional customer care, remaining an efficient and quality producer, offering high value, and effectively marketing McDonald's brand on a global scale. The future success of McDonald's is based on strategically managing its strengths and competitive advantages today to develop increasingly profitable positions in its global markets tomorrow. McDonald's strategy has the following core elements.
Growth Strategy
Add 2000 restaurants annually, some company owned and some franchised, with about two-thirds outside the United States. Promote more frequent customers via the addition of breakfast and dinner menu low price specials, and Extra Value Meals. Dominate the global food-service industry. Global dominance means setting the performance standard for customer satisfaction while increasing market share and profitability through the firm's convenience, value, and execution strategies. Improve an already strong position. The firm's strategies are simple and emphasize making customers happy with everyday low prices and outstanding restaurant operations so they visit more frequently. Further strategies are to increase market share by attracting more customers more often to increase profitability by being more efficient, and to create economies of scale.
10 equipment, sophisticated computer technology and new operation procedures will enable delivery of food "Made for You" at the speed of McDonald's.
Store Operations
Establish stringent product standards, strictly enforce restaurant operating procedures (especially concerning food preparation, store cleanliness and friendly courteous counter service), and build close working relationships with suppliers to assure that food is safe and of the highest quality. McDonald's' first priority is to improve restaurant operations. Strategic initiatives encompass realigning its structure and reducing its operations as a reaction to economic turmoil in certain international regions. Furthermore, the next generation of quality food preparation is being introduced to support its industry leadership into the next century. Relationships with its global network of suppliers add a dimension to its leadership position.
11
The opportunity for U.S. food companies in India's food service market is small but growing. Sales by Indian food service companies totaled approximately $6 billion in fiscal year 1998. Restaurants account for approximately 55 percent of Indian food service sales. The institutional sector consists of hospitals, prisons, defense establishments, schools, company canteens, railways and airlines.
3.1 Indian Food Service Sub-Sector Sales FY 1998 100 percent = $6 billion Hotels 5%
Restaurants
Institutes 40%
Restaurants 55%
Institutes Hotels
12
A growing number of specialty restaurants, fast food outlets, home delivery and take-away restaurants have opened in the last few years. A number of foreign restaurant chains (e.g. Domino's, Pizza Hut, Pizza Express, McDonalds, TGIF, KFC and Baskin Robbins) have started operations in India and have achieved success.
13
4. MCDONALDS IN INDIA
McDonald's India is a joint-venture company managed by Indians. McDonalds India, a subsidiary of McDonalds USA, has expanded its presence in India via 2 joint venture companies Connaught Plaza restaurants and Hardcastle restaurants. McDonalds (India) has a 50 per cent equity stake each in both joint venture companies. Connaught Plaza restaurants manages operations and expansions across North India (Delhi, Jaipur and Punjab) led by Vikram Bakshi and Hardcastle restaurants, which is headed by Amit Jatia, manages operations and expansions across Western India (Mumbai, Pune, and Gujarat). Around the world, McDonald's traditionally operates with local partners or local management. In India too, McDonald's purchases form local suppliers. McDonald's constructs its restaurants using local architects, contractors, labour and - where possible local materials. McDonald's hires local personnel for all positions within the restaurants and contributes a portion of its success to communities in the form of municipal taxes and reinvestment. Six years prior to the opening of the first McDonald's restaurant in India, McDonald's and its international supplier partners worked together with local Indian Companies to develop products that meet McDonald's rigorous quality standards. Part of this development involves the transfer of state-of-the-art food processing technology, which has enabled Indian businesses to grow by improving their ability to compete in todays international markets.
14 McDonald's worldwide is well known for the high degree of respect to the local culture. McDonald's has developed a menu especially for India with vegetarian selections to suit Indian tasted and culture. Keeping in line with this McDonald's does not offer any beef and pork items in India. McDonald's has also re-engineered its operations to address the special requirements of a vegetarian menu. The cheese and cold sauces used in India is 100% vegetarian. Vegetable products are prepared separately, using dedicated equipment and utensils. Also in India, only vegetable oil is used as a cooking medium. This separation of vegetarian and non-vegetarian food products is maintained throughout the various stages of procurement, cooking and serving.
15 The company has invested Rs 450 crore so far in its India operations out of its total planned investment of Rs 850 crore till 2003. With its India operations showing signs of success, the US food chain McDonalds Corporation has sought its pound of flesh. The global food chain major has claimed an initial franchise fee of $45,000 and five per cent royalty fee of the gross sales from its operations in India. McDonalds India Pvt Ltd has moved an application to the government seeking permission for payment and remittance of the initial franchise fee and royalty to Mc Donalds Corporation. The permission has been sought on two grounds: McDonalds India would pay an initial franchise fee of $45,000 on each of the McDonalds restaurants already franchised or to be franchised, in the future, in India; and a royalty equal to 5 per cent of the gross sales from the operations of all its Indian restaurants on a monthly basis to McDonalds International. The company hopes to break even in 2003. They currently serve around 3 million customers a day and hope to grow at the rate of 50% to 70% a year.
16
17 The McDonalds in India is following the same tradition. Long before the first Maharaja Mac was served up, McDonalds was here in India, setting up the elaborate cold chain that supplies all the restaurants in the country. It took six years from 1991 when the work started, until the system was in place. We spent Rs.50 crore even before the first restaurant was set up in 1996, Amit Jatia confesses.
18
5 .1 T h e M c D o n a ld s S u p p ly C h a in S u p p lie rs
M c D o n a ld s R e sta u ra n ts
M c D o n a ld 's R e sta u ra n t ( V a sh i)
19 After they receive the stock from the suppliers, they implement on planning for material requirement as per the demand from the McDonalds restaurants and send orders to suppliers. A similar copy of the order is also sent for advanced intimation to be made to the third party logistics company Air Freight Ltd. The DC will consider stock in hand, present consumption, shelf life of the products, truck capacity and lead-time. Meanwhile, suppliers produce and keep products ready as per the demand from the DC. McDonalds post-harvest facilities include a cold chain consisting of a vacuum precooling room to remove field heat, a large cold room and a refrigerated van for transportation where the temperature and the relative humidity of this crop is maintained between 1 degree Celsius and 4 degree Celsius and 95 per cent, respectively. Vegetables are stocked in the pre-cooling room within half an hour of harvesting. The pre-cooling room ensures rapid cooling to two degrees Celsius within 90 minutes. The pack house, pre-cooling and cold room are located at the farms itself, ensuring no delay between harvesting, pre-cooling, packaging and cold storage. Thus, zero percent spoilage and freshness are being maintained. McDonalds India sources food products through 45 different suppliers and 10 key local companies. The key local suppliers include: Vista Processed Foods (VPF), Trikaya Agriculture, Dynamix Dairy Industries, Radhakrishna Foodland, Cremica, Shah Bector and Sons, Global Green Company and Bector Foods. Another striking factor of McDonalds is that it never has any written contracts with the suppliers. The relationship is only based on trust. The McDonalds team help the suppliers develop, and hence they are assured that McDonalds will stick to them through thick and thin.
20
patties are processed through the latest food processing technological plant at Vista. Vista has installed hi-tech equipment for the purpose of deboning, blending, coating, passing the patties through the stern breading machine, frying and freezing. Vistas pie line has the sophisticated, computerized Rondosheeter (the machine where processing takes place) in operation, which includes hi-tech refrigeration plants for the manufacture of frozen foods at temperature as low as minus 35 degrees.
21 Dynamix Dairies: In some cases, the Indian suppliers had the technology but no market for the products they produced. For example, Dynamix Dairies through its relationship with McDonald's was introduced to a large consumer to supply milk casein and other milk derivatives. The two companies entered into a business relationship resulting in an initial export order of approximately US $12 million per year with the potential to increase. After the food products are processed at their respective companies, they are received and stocked at the McDonalds distribution partner the Rs 80- crore Radhakrishna Foodland Ltd to ensure that all McDonalds restaurants are supplied without interruption. The company however failed with potato farming, despite spending $10 million in Uttar Pradesh. But it claims that by 2004, McDonalds will source potatoes from India for French fries. With all 80 restaurants in place, we expect our consumption of French fries to be 10,000 metric tones and then it makes economics sense to grow processed grade potatoes in India, says Jatia. However, the newly introduced potato wedges are being made from potatoes grown in Gujarat.
HACCPs
There is a concept known as the HACCPs followed in McDonalds. HACCPs stands for Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points. There are some key areas identified by McDonalds for e.g. the patties for the burgers have to be stored at a certain level of temperature. A list of these HACCPs is given to all the suppliers and they have to strictly adhere to them. Surprise checks are made by the McDonalds employees to check if all the quality standards are being followed.
22
You deserve a break today, so get up and get away to McDonalds. The above break commercial was one of the initial commercial themes adopted by McDonalds USA which became the best known commercial song on television and, in fact, the most identifiable advertising themes of all time. Needham was one of the first advertising agencies of McDonalds, which made many revolutionary advertisements for the company. Needhams advertising formula became known in McDonalds as food, folks, and fun, and it remains the backbone of al the chains advertising campaigns. McDonalds is now, one of the worlds mightiest consumer marketers. Its brand valuation is $25 billion, making it the ninth most valuable brand in the world.
23
McDonalds also have to have a thorough understanding of their competition. They consider 3 basic areas:
1. The Total Eating Out Market gives the broadest competitive context and includes all restaurants, hotels, pubs, and any other outlet where people eat 2. They also focus on the Quick Service Restaurant sector. This includes all the obvious competition and also fish and chip shops, and sandwich shops any outlet where food is served quickly. 3. The final sector that they focus on is defined as the Burger House Sector. This looks only at restaurants serving hamburgers including Burger King, Wimpy, Wendy's and all independent burger bars.
A useful way to gaining knowledge of all aspects of the competition is the examination of the four Ps of the marketing mix: Price, Promotion, Place, and Product. Competitive Promotion: Before they communicate with their customers they must be aware of what the competitors are communicating so that they can create a beneficial difference between McDonalds and them. Competitive Pricing: Being in touch with the pricing of their competitors allows them to price their products correctly, balancing quality with value. Competitive Product: Quick Service Restaurants are constantly expanding their menus. This can be done on a short-term promotional basis or as a long-term expansion strategy. Competitive Place: Distribution is key to any retailer or brand.
24
25
The marketing strategy of McDonalds in India has gone through manly 3 stages: Stage I: Building the Brand Stage II: Awareness of the products Stage III: Gunning for market share.
26
27 instances where parents come in with their children; they are playing while the parents are also enjoying themselves. There was this lady I met and she asked me, "What is this that you do to children?" So I said, "What do we do meaning?" She said, "My two year-old recognizes McDonalds. When I took her to Wimpy's the other day she refused to enter the place, saying it was not McDonalds."
28
29
Miscellaneous Advertisements
There were many other advertisements made by McDonalds emphasizing on the schemes, the prices and various other aspects. Some of them were: The Itch Karo Scheme: This advertisement was to promote the scheme of McDonalds wherein you could win prizes right from a small Cadbury to a television and bike. Soft Serve Cone: There were many advertisements focusing on the Rs.7 soft serve cone. One of them was of a traffic policeman who gets tired of directing the customers to the McDonalds outlet. This advertisement if of the most liked and remembered advertisements of McDonalds. Happy Meal: There are various advertisements relayed during children programmes on television and also children channels emphasizing on the happy meals and the toys you get with them.
30
31
The very first Ronald McDonald was the famed weatherman Willard Scott. In the very first Ronald McDonald commercial, with Willard Scott as Ronald(c.1960), he actually says something to the effect of "I know you're not supposed to talk to strangers, kids, but it's okay to talk to me, because I'm Ronald the hamburger-loving clown!" Originally he wore shoes made of buns, a cup on his nose, and a hat with a hamburger meal on it. Soon, this was dropped for the more familiar clown outfit. But in India, none of the advertisements currently focus on Ronald McDonald. The main reason for this being, the Company is still trying to build the brand loyalty and awareness in India. It is still in its developing stage and cannot focus on many aspects at the same time.
32
Social Marketing
McDonalds believes in giving back to the community in which they do business. Besides commercial marketing McDonalds also undertakes many social drives to build brand loyalty among the customers. Ronald McDonald House Charities (RMHC) works to improve the health and well being of children by awarding grants to organizations and supporting 206 Ronald McDonald Houses worldwide. RMHC has not yet been established in India. But McDonalds India has undertaken many social activities like: Supporting Health drives like Pulse Polio since 1998. McDonalds Spotlight, an inter-school performing arts competition started in 1998 for schools all over Mumbai and Navi Mumbai to provide the students with an atmosphere for healthy competition. Over 120 schools participated in 1998,1999 and 2000. McDonalds has tied up with Nehru Science Centre, Mumbai (NSCM) in 2000 for a period of three years to bring the students of Mumbai a science quiz. This quiz has been conducted by NSCM for the past ten years. With McDonalds, it hopes to get the contest to a new level. Having cleanliness drives with the BMC like the one on 15th August 1997 for making Mumbai garbage free and joined in celebrating 50 years in Indias independence.
33
With more than 500,000 people on the payroll at any one time, the McDonalds System is easily one of the largest employers in the United States. One out of every 15 American workers got his or her first job from McDonalds. It was at McDonalds where they first learned about work routines, job discipline, and organizational teamwork. McDonalds by now had replaced the U.S. Army as the nations largest job training organization. An unwritten rule during McDonalds first decade prohibited the hiring of women in the restaurants. It was rationalized on the grounds that many tasks such as carrying hundred-pound sacks of potatoes from the basement were too strenuous for the women. But that was a thinly veiled disguise for the real reason: Kroc feared that female employees would attract too many teenage males who would convert McDonalds into another high school hangout. But Krocs worst fears that attractive female crewmembers would convert McDonalds into a teenage hangout proved unfounded and today, McDonalds crews are 56 percent female, and fully women manage 46 percent of all units.
34
Hamburger University
Hamburger University is McDonald's worldwide management training center located in Oak Brook, Illinois. Designed exclusively to instruct personnel employed by McDonald's Corporation or employed by McDonald's Independent Franchisees in the various aspects of the business. All training programs begin with one essential ingredient: The Basics of McDonald's Operations. Founded in 1961, Hamburger University's has come a long way since McDonalds opened their first training facility in the basement of a McDonald's restaurant in Elk Grove Village, Illinois. Since that time they've moved Hamburger University twice and watched the size of classes grow from an average size of about 10 to more than 200 per class. 7.1 Hamburger University Today, more than 65,000 managers in McDonald's restaurants have graduated University, from now Hamburger located in a
130,000 square foot, state-of-the-art facility on the McDonald's Home Office Campus in Oak Brook, Illinois, with a faculty of 30 resident professors. Because of McDonald's international scope, translators and electronic equipment enable professors to teach and communicate in 22 languages at one time. McDonald's also manages ten international training centers, including Hamburger Universities in England, Japan, Germany and Australia.
35
36
Outlets in India
McDonald's India is an employer of opportunity, providing quality employment and long-term careers to the Indian people. The average McDonald's restaurant employs more than 100 people in 25 different positions from cashier to restaurant manager. McDonald's world class-training inputs to its employees can be seen in the present close to 2000 employees currently in Mumbai and Delhi. Manpower Planning: The Scheduling Manager is in charge of the manpower planning in the outlet. They have full timers who work for 9 hours and part timers who work for 3-4 hours. If they expect more customers (during holidays etc) then more part timers are recruited. Recruitment: Done by reference of the employees in the outlet or other outlets. Organization and Salary Structure:
R e s ta u ra n t M a n a g e r (R s .1 8 ,0 0 0 - 2 0 ,0 0 0 )
1 s t A s s is ta n t M a n a g e r (R s .1 1 ,5 0 0 )
2 n d A s s is ta n t M a n a g e r (R s .1 0 ,4 0 0 )
S h ift R u n n in g F lo o r M a n a g e r (R s .6 ,5 0 0 )
F lo o r M a n a g e r (R s .5 0 0 0 )
T r a in in g S q u a d (R s .2 1 p e r h o u r)
C re w M e m b e r (R s .1 4 .5 p e r h o u r)
37 Training and Development: Training is a continuous process at the McDonalds. It is the responsibility of the training squad to train the other employees. The training squads maintain training logs of the employees, which clearly states that which employee is to be trained, and on what station. The 3/30 Plan: According to this plan, the training squad has to train 3 people on three different stations in a month. One employee is trained on one station, say the vegetarian station for 10 days, and then for the non-vegetarian station for the next 10 days and so on. This is done till the employee becomes proficient on the station and is capable of handling the station on his own. Performance Appraisal:
Every employee joins in as a Trainee Crew where he is given the Green Badge. After a period of 3 months, the employee is checked for the health safety, cleanliness and sanitation after which he is given the Yellow Badge. After receiving the Yellow Badge, there are 5 stations that the employee has to be proficient in: 1. Backroom Cleaning This includes mopping the floors, clearing the tables, maintenance of the machines etc. 2. Fried Products This involves frying of the French Fries, Pizza Puff etc. to the right degree. 3. Buns, Dress and Grill (BDG) This includes grilling the bun and dressing them properly. There is a time limit given to perform every function and the employee has to perform it efficiently, with minimum wastage. 4. Counter The last station is of the counter handling. The employee should be able to converse with the customers courteously and take proper orders.
38 5. Personality The last criteria is the overall personality of the employee. McDonalds being in the service industry, having smart and courteous employees is of utmost importance to them. The productivity record has to show 90+ points. The productivity is checked in various ways. For example McDonalds has a policy if serving each customer within one minute on an average. The productivity at the counter is checked by the time taken by an employee to complete the order. For E.g.: If Freda (A service-counter in charge) has taken 2.5 minutes on a average to serve each customer in her shift, at the end of the shift, the shit running manager will speak to her and ask her the reason and accordingly ask her to try and improve. If this trend continues, Freda is trained further. After the productivity record shows 90+ points, the employees have to appear for a documented written test where they must get more than 90 marks. Having got a 90+ average of the two, the employee is promoted to the next hierarchy level. Shifts:
McDonalds have different shifts for managers, full time employees and part time employees. Their main shifts consist of: Open Shift 7:00 am to 4:00 pm Mid Shift 12:00 am to 9:00 pm Close Shift 3:00 am to 12:00 pm McDonalds have a special night shift where the managers have to account for the days transactions, inventory, wastage etc. The night shift for the mangers is from 11:00 pm to 8:00 am.
39 They also have a night shift for the employees where the scrubbing of the entire outlet takes place. Also, each and every machine is opened and cleaned. The night shift for the employees is from 7:00 pm to 4:00 am. Both the night shifts i.e. for the managers and the employees are done on rotation basis. Female employees are generally not allowed to do the night shifts. Holidays and Breaks: Managers can take 6 holidays in a month. If an employee is working for the 7-hour shift, he gets a break for 1 hour after 4 hours and if an employee is working for less than 7 hours, then he gets a break for hour. Employee Grievances:
The crew members are allowed to take 4 holidays in a month and the
McDonalds call it as the RAP SESSIONS. Once in a month, the employees can vent their problems to the Area Sales Manager or the Operations Manager. The Branch Manager is not included in the Rap Sessions.
40 The employees feel that there is very slow growth in the company. It takes you 3 months just to get the yellow badge, and even after that, the promotions come very slow. The salary packages are not very attractive.
41
2001
To ice-creams, fries, shakes and pizza Less spicy, non-oily, crisp, fresh and different Affordable family restaurant, money well spent Mature, calm, cultured, straightforward for families Childlike, and young at heart
42
43
Survey of Customers
Objective of the survey: To find out the perception of McDonalds in the minds of the customer. Methodology: Primary data was collected as it gives first hand information and also the data can be adjusted according to the needs. The tool used was the questionnaire method. This method was chosen as it obtains standardized results that can be tabulated and treated statistically. A broad category of the questions asked were: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Frequency of visit Favorite Product Favorite Advertisement Is McDonalds value for Money? French Fries Issue Unique Selling Proposition of McDonalds Suggestions to improve McDonalds
(A copy of the detailed questionnaire has been attached in the Annexure) Sample: We conducted a survey of around 100 customers of McDonalds. The profile was mainly distributed in 3 categories:
Processing of Data: The data collected from the questionnaires was tabulated and the percentages were derived. For e.g.: If out of 100 customers, 54 are veg and 46 are non-veg, the percentages where taken and analyzed.
44
Non-Veg 46%
Veg 54%
The percentage of vegetarian people visiting the restaurant is slightly more than the non-vegetarians. The vegetarian customers feel a lack of choice in the products as compared to the non-vegetarians who seemed to be comparatively satisfied. Since McDonalds has an equal footfall of vegetarian customers, it would be advisable to increase its vegetarian product line.
Even after the big issue over french fries, they remain to be the most favorite product of most of the customers of McDonalds. Some of the customers love to visit McDonalds just to have the French fries. The McChicken Burger and the McVeggie Burger are the second favorites.
40%
39%
32%
29%
Yes
No
Its okay
45
Only 32% of the customers find the product line satisfactory. Rest all of them find it either okay or not satisfactory at all. Customers would like to have more variety to choose from. They feel that McDonalds should include more deserts and more items like the Pizza McPuff besides the burgers.
7%
7%
8%
Stage Fright
None
The first advertisement of McDonalds (Stage Fright) remains to be the most popular and recalled advertisement. While these advertisements are very popular amongst the children and teenagers, 26% of the customers, mostly consisting of the elders failed to remember any of the advertisements or simply said that they didnt like them.
46
Most of the parents gave a positive answer to this question, but the teenagers and customers below the age of 25 didnt find McDonalds value for money at all. The main reason for the parents preferring McDonalds is because their childrens like it and hence they dont mind paying any amount. The customers below 25 years find it a good place to hangout and like the food, but dont find it worth the cost.
24% 9% 3%
21%
Long Queues
Wrong Order
Bad Music
Long queue was a major problem of all the customers. They said that the waiting period was too long, especially in the evenings and weekends. They felt that even thought the service is fast; McDonalds could do with increasing the number of counters. Wrong order was an issue with the Jain customers who had to change their burgers at least twice to get a Jain burger. The customers below the age group of 25 felt that the outlets played outdated music, which irritates them. But nearly 43% of the customers said that they havent had any problems at all in any of their visits. Even if they had some small issues, the employees of McDonalds solved them very well.
8.8 Did the French Fries issue make you hesitant from visiting McDonalds?
No 64%
Yes 21%
47
64% of the customers said No to this question. They felt that a Multi-national company like McDonalds would never make such a big blunder in a religious country likes India.
26%
24%
19%
17% 6% 8%
Others
Food
Hygiene
Ambience
Quick Service
Location
Food remains to be the favorite part of McDonalds. Hygiene ranks the next with 24%. This was a popular answer amongst mothers as they found it to be a very hygienic place for their children. The young and energetic ambience of McDonalds is also liked by all. Other USPs of McDonalds include good crowd and courteous employees.
48
No Suggestions Better Music More Space Home Delivery More Variety Low Prices
0%
22% of the customers were very satisfied with McDonalds and said that it is fine the way it is. On the other hand, 24% of the customers want the prices to be reduced and also have more variety to choose from. Some of them would even like to have home delivery. Surprisingly, none of the Indian customers suggested starting drive-ins which are extremely popular in the other countries. Recommendations based on the survey are: 1. More items should be added to the product line, especially in the vegetarian category. 2. The prices need to be slashed down. The french fries, chicken burger and the veg burger are the most popular items, so their process can be reduced to attract more customers. 3. The advertisements can also focus on the hygiene factor of McDonalds, for e.g.: McDonalds can stress on the fact that they do not serve any burger, which has been prepared but not consumed for 10 minutes. 4. The peak time management should be improved. More counters should be opened during the peak hours. 5. The music played at the outlet should not be outdated.
49
50 that. The customer has got to be happy in the end and thats the bottom line. Companys policy should not restrict a customer from being happy. The company has to organize its life around the customer and not that the customer organizes his life around the company. But customers are generally not forgiving. The customer perception has changed a lot over a period of time. In the beginning, customers used to despise the idea of selfservice, but now, the same idea of self-service attracts them as they feel theres nobody standing on their heads and they can do whatever they want. By and large, the perception of customers is fairly positive. In the next 10 years, he wishes that McDonalds in India would touch every Indians life in some manner, in every community.
51
52 McDonalds will have to face competition from the more affordable dhabas, the roadside eateries that dot highways all over the country. The companys confidence stems from a model already in place in north India. McDonalds has a 170-seater restaurant at Noida near Delhi. The restaurant at Noida attracts a lot of drive through business. Around 30 per cent of sales at this outlet is from drive through clientele like tourist buses and passenger traffic, that is, the business traveller, said Vikram Bakshi, managing director, McDonalds restaurant, New Delhi. McDonalds is closely looking at options on National Highway. One as it is considered to be one of the busiest highways in India. In the immediate future, we plan to have three restaurants on this highway one each at Delhi-Jaipur highway, Delhi-Ambala Highway and DelhiLudhiana highway, Bakshi added. While, an extension to expressways may be a recent development, it has been arrived at after looking into the business prospects, logistics and supply chain. Jatia says, Drive through restaurants are only one of the options to meet McDonalds target of 80 restaurants across India by 2003 with an investment of Rs 850 crore. Internationally, 40 per cent of the companys business is from express highways. With a strong backing of reliable supply chain, extensive advertising and efficient employees, McDonalds is trying to fulfill all the customer challenges. Hence, we can truly say that McDonalds mein hain kuch baat!
53
Websites
http://www.mcdonalds.com http://www.financialexpress.com http://www.indiainfoline.com http://www.psi-world.com http://www.mcspotlight.com http://www.brandquiver.com http://www.bized.ac.uk/compfact/mcdonalds/ http://www.expressindia.com http://www.adageglobal.com http://www.wiley.com http://www.planetcustomer.com