Financial Performance Analysis: Raazia Khatoon Galaria
Financial Performance Analysis: Raazia Khatoon Galaria
Financial Performance Analysis: Raazia Khatoon Galaria
- 2006-2011
GUIDED BY: MR. SURYAPRAKASH DAS (LECTURER IN FINANCE) (ASANSOL ENGINEERING COLLEGE)
This is to certify that Ms. Raazia Khatoon Galaria of ASANSOL ENGINEERING COLLEGE has successfully completed the project work titled FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF GODREJ PROPERTIES LIMITED in partial fulfillment of requirement for the award of BACHELOR OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION (HONOURS) prescribed by the WEST BENGAL UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY. This project is the record of authentic work carried out by her during the sixth semester.
Date: Place:
3
DECLARATION
I, Ms. Raazia Khatoon Galaria, hereby declare that this project is the record of authentic work carried out by me during the even semester 20112012 and has not been submitted to any other University or Institute towards the award of any degree.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
A project is a golden opportunity for learning and self development. I consider myself very lucky and honored to have so many wonderful people lead me through in completion of this project. My grateful thanks to Mr. Suryaprakash Das (lecturer in finance, Asansol Engineering College) who in spite of being extraordinarily busy with his duties, took time out to hear, guide and keep me on the correct path. I do not know where I would have been without him. I shall forever cherish my association with him for exuberant encouragement, perennial approachability, absolute freedom of thought and action I have enjoyed during the course of the project. A humble Thank you Sir. I am very pleased to express my deep sense of gratitude to Ms. Moumita Roy (lecturer in finance, Asansol Engineering College) for her constant guidance from 1st year. I choose this moment to acknowledge her contribution gratefully. My father, Md. Rafique Galaria whose patience I have probably tested to the limit. He was always so involved in the entire process, shared his knowledge, and encouraged me to think. Thank you. Last but not the least there were so many who shared valuable information that helped in the successful completion of this project.
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION (i) Real Estate (ii) Real Estate Sector The India Story 2. GODREJ GROUP 3. GODREJ PROPERTIES LIMITED (i) Introduction (ii) Company Profile (iii) Vision (iv) Value Proposition (v) Accolades (vi) Business Strategy (vii) Corporate Governance (viii) Green Initiatives (ix) Key Events and Milestones 4. OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY 5. DATABASE (i) Balance Sheet of past 5 years (ii) Profit & Loss Account of past 5 years 6. METHODOLOGY
6
7. FINDINGS AND ANALYSIS (i) Liquidity Ratios (ii) Profitability Ratios (iii) Leverage Ratios (iv) Activity Ratios (v) Investment Ratios 8. CONCLUSION 9. BIBLIOGRAPHY
LIST OF TABLES
Topics
1. Corporate houses and their location interest for development of SEZs 2. Hospitality space statistics 3. Fund raising options by developers 4. Balance Sheet of GPL 5. Profit & Loss Account of GPL 6. Calculation of Liquidity Ratios 7. Calculation of Profitability Ratios 8. Calculation of Leverage Ratios 9. Calculation of Activity Ratios 10. Calculation of Investment Ratios
Pg No.
18 19 21 38 39 50 52 55 57 59
7
Topics
1. Cause-Effect scenario leading to emergence of organized real estate market in India 2. Classification of Real Estate space 3. Business strategy of GPL 4. Graphical representation of Liquidity Ratios 5. Graphical representation of Profitability Ratios 6. Graphical representation of Leverage Ratios 7. Graphical representation of Activity Ratios 8. Graphical representation of Investment Ratios
Pg No.
15 18 32 50 53 55 58 60
8
Real estate is "Property consisting of land and the buildings on it, along with its natural resources such as crops, minerals, or water; immovable property of this nature; an interest vested in this; (also) an item of real property; (more generally) buildings or housing in general. Also: the business of real estate; the profession of buying, selling, or renting land, buildings, or housing." It is a legal term used in jurisdictions such as the United States, United Kingdom, Canada, and Australia.
9
International real estate terminology and practice Real estate as "real property" in the U.K.
In British usage, "real property", often shortened to just "property", generally refers to land and fixtures, while the term "real estate" is used mostly in the context of probate law, and means all interests in land held by a deceased person at death, excluding interests in money arising under a trust for sale of or charged on land. As one main object of "probate" is to "prove" title to the real estate interests in the property held by a deceased person at the time of death, and the earliest recorded use the word in this capacity is 1463, it is reasonable to assume this tradition dates back to the death of the first owner of the 'allodial land'
farm property can be sold only after a lengthy entitlement process, but that does not prevent them from being offered for sale. Real estate agents in Costa Rica do not need a license to operate, but the transfer of property requires a lawyer. In Mexico, real estate agents do not need a license to operate, but the transfer of property requires a notary public.
Philippines
In the Philippines, one of the growing businesses in the country is real estate development. Aside from the development and rising of tall buildings and establishment in the metropolitan area, nearby provinces are now on the stage of land development with its continuous expansion in the nearby provinces such as Laguna, Cavite, Rizal, Bulacan, Pampanga and Batangas.
Business sector
With the development of private property ownership, real estate has become a major area of business, commonly referred to as commercial real estate. Purchasing real estate requires a significant investment, and each parcel of land has unique characteristics, so the real estate industry has evolved into several distinct fields. Specialists are often called on to valuate
11
real estate and facilitate transactions. Some kinds of real estate businesses include:
Appraisal: Professional valuation services Brokerages: A mediator who charges a fee to facilitate a real estate
transaction between the two parties. Development: Improving land for use by adding or replacing buildings
Net leasing Property management: Managing a property for its owner(s) Real estate marketing: Managing the sales side of the property business Real estate investing: Managing the investment of real estate Relocation services: Relocating people or business to a different country Corporate Real Estate: Managing the real estate held by a corporation
to support its core businessunlike managing the real estate held by an investor to generate income Within each field, a business may specialize in a particular type of real estate, such as residential, commercial, or industrial property. In addition, almost all construction business effectively has a connection to real estate. Professional university-level education in real estate is primarily focused at the graduate level. Focus in towards the commercial real estate sector, primarily real estate development or investment rather than residential real estate sales conducted by a REALTOR.
Residences can be classified by, if, and how they are connected to neighboring residences and land. Different types of housing tenure can be used for the same physical type. For example, connected residents might be owned by a single entity and leased out, or owned separately with an agreement covering the relationship between units and common areas and concerns.
Major categories in North America and Europe Apartment - An individual unit in a multi-unit building. The boundaries of
the apartment are generally defined by a perimeter of locked or lockable doors. Often seen in multi-story apartment buildings. Multi-family house - Often seen in multi-story detached buildings, where each floor is a separate apartment or unit. Terraced house (a.k.a. townhouse or rowhouse) - A number of single or multi-unit buildings in a continuous row with shared walls and no intervening space. Condominium - Building or complex, similar to apartments, owned by individuals. Common grounds and common areas within the complex are owned and shared jointly. There are townhouse or rowhouse style condominiums as well. Cooperative (a.k.a. "co-op) - A type of multiple ownership in which the residents of a multi-unit housing complex own shares in the cooperative corporation that owns the property, giving each resident the right to occupy a specific apartment or unit. Semi-detached dwellings Duplex - Two units with one shared wall.
Major categories in India and the Asian Subcontinent Housing Societies (CGHS) Condominiums Builder flats Chawls Havelis Lal Dora - Where people carry out commercial and
residential activities both.
14
expected to grow from the current USD 14 billion to a USD 102 billion in the next 10 years. This growth can be attributed to favorable demographics, increasing purchasing power, existence of customer friendly banks & housing finance companies, professionalism in real estate and favorable reforms initiated by the government to attract global investors
Fig. 1: Cause-Effect scenario leading to emergence of organized real estate market in India
The property market in India has traditionally been unorganized and fragmented. However, the recent past has seen a consolidation of positions in the market as developers are stretching their capacities to the maximum in order to meet the growing market demand, which in turn has encouraged large projects with sourced financing. The IPOs by large real estate developers like Sobha, Raheja and DLF have led to organization of the market in the Tier I cities, but the Tier II and Tier III cities still demonstrate the traits of an unorganized market. Whilst the Indian real estate market still lacks transparency and liquidity compared to more mature real estate markets, the increasing requirements of multi national occupiers, as well as the influx of international property consultancies has led to the introduction of greater availability of market information, both in published and private form pushing the sector to an organized market form.
16
Driving Forces
Stated below are the reasons that have led to the real estate boom in the country: Booming economy; accelerated GDP to 8% p.a. Indias emergence as an attractive off shoring destination and availability of pool of highly skilled technicians and engineers ; Development of large captive units of major players include GE, Prudential, HSBC, Bank of America, Standard Chartered and American Express. Rise in disposable income and growing middle class, increasing the demand for quality residential real estate and real estate as an investment option. Entry of professional players equipped with expertise in real estate development. Relaxation of legal rulings and processes by the governing bodies encouraging investments in real estate. Improvement in infrastructure facilities.
Categorization
The demand for new office space in India has grown from an estimated 3.9 million sq. ft in 1998 to over 16 million sq. ft in 2004-05. 70% of the demand for office space in India is driven by over 7,000 Indian IT and ITES firms and 15% by financial service providers and the pharmaceutical sector. In 2005 alone, IT/ITES sector absorbed a total of approx 30 million sq. ft and is estimated to generate a demand of 150 million sq. ft. of space across major cities by 2010. This data clearly demonstrates the growth of the real estate sector in the country. With reference to the availability of infrastructure facilities, following cities are currently attracting MNCs/corporate/real estate developers:
17
Tier I cities, Mumbai (Commercial hub), Delhi (Political hub) and Bangalore (Technological hub): Preferred option for many new market entrants Command the highest international profiles and significant proportion of FDI Offer qualified labor pool and the best infrastructure facilities Exhibit development of sub-urban commercial real estate Yield of 9.5 10% Tier II cities, notably Hyderabad, Chennai, Chandigarh, Kochi, Mangalore, Mysore, Thiruvananthapuram, Goa, Bhubaneshwar, Ahmedabad and Pune Yield of 10.5-11.5% Offer competitive business environments, human resources availability, telecommunications connectivity, quality of urban infrastructure, Attract high value IT, ITES and biotech corporate houses Tier III cities, like Cuttack and Jaipur Low liquidity and still highly unorganized. Special Economic Zones: 28 operational SEZs in the country, including those converted from Export Processing Zones (EPZ) to SEZ Development of SEZs in various segments such as multi-product, Information Technology, Bio-technology, Gems and Jewellery, Textiles and technology intensive industries Attract both developers and corporate houses (refer table for a list of corporate that have shown interest in development of SEZs)
18
Table 1: Corporate houses and their location interest for development of SEZs
Apart for the corporate clientele, the SEZs also attract a number of real estate developers, including DLF, Ansals, Omaxe, Parsvnath, Shipra Estate to name a few. As per utilization, the real estate space can be classified as follows:
Office Space
Backed by strong infrastructure Promoted by increasing demand from IT industry Shift of focus from the traditional CBDs towards secondary centers owing sharply higher land prices in the city centers.
Retail Space
Growth of 25- 30% expected in the organized retail sector (malls and multiplexes) leading to an increased demand in real estate Affected by government policies for foreign retailers Pronounced in the Tier I, Tier II and Tier III cities.
Hospitality Space
Increasing demand of lodging in commercial cities such as Bangalore, Mumbai, Delhi etc. from business travelers. Established brands in this sector include Asian Hotels, Indian Hotels, ITC, Le Meridien etc are in expansion mode with many new players such as Accor Group, Marriot, Choice, IHG Group
20
studies, concept testing, business planning exercises, investment advice, market research and analysis, demand forecasting, financial modeling and project structuring exercises, portfolio optimization and re-engineering strategies, expansion and occupancy, location and entry, brokerage services, legal documentation review, valuations etc. Real estate consultants also ensure that the financing needs of the client are well taken care of by liaising with banking/non banking institutions and providing them with investment and structured finance solutions including securitization and sale & leasebacks, structured finance facilitating equity/debt into development projects on behalf of private and government sector clients, structuring development financing, public - private partnerships, joint ventures, portfolio transactions and privatization exercises. The recent players in the Indian market are Jones Lang Lasalle, Colliers, CBRichard Ellis, Frank Knight and Trammell Crow Meghraj.
FDIs/FIIs
Post liberalization, the investment opportunities in real estate for the FDIs and FIIs have greatly opened up. Foreign investors can now purchase commercial development projects (under construction) over 50,000 sq m (540,000 sq ft), or plotted residential developments with a minimum size of 10 hectares. Foreign investors may purchase an equity stake in an unlisted
23
real estate company and thereby partner in its growth plans across asset classes and cities. Listed real estate companies also offer good liquid investment opportunities routed into designated special purpose vehicles that hold the asset(s) being developed, thereby reducing risk. These investors look for innovative financial products to suit their investing needs.
24
From the perspective of companies who want to sell off assets, securitization schemes provide a greater diversity of alternatives to liquidate real estate. Securitization is primarily used by the corporate houses to convert the corporate real estate to commercial real estate.
Regulatory risks
In terms of property ownership, permission from the Reserve Bank of India is required for foreign investors. For capital repatriation, investors need to apply for approval from the RBI, and foreign direct investment is limited to a limited set of opportunities (e.g. townships). The REMFs work within the SEBI framework. Being a developing and growing sector, the rules, regulations and legalities demonstrate frequent changes, making it seem as a cumbersome investment option to the investors.
25
Macroeconomic risks
Interest rates, inflation and exchange rate risks are amongst the important macroeconomic indicators and have shown decreased volatility. The provision of facilities, is in many regions, still inadequate (education, transport infrastructure). These risk factors are not likely to disappear in the near future, impeding the development of the real estate sector.
Conclusion
The Indian real estate sector promises to be a lucrative destination for foreign investors into the country. The Indian realty sector, if channelized properly, could catapult the growth of several other sectors in India through its backward and forward linkages. However, there are potential constraints for domestic as well as foreign investments in India. Absence of a single regulator to monitor business practices prevailing in Indian real estate market is perceived to be a risk factor by investors. The SEZ guidelines which are issued by the Commerce Ministry are constantly modified, creating uncertainty. Since the liberalization of FDI norms, significant
26
foreign investments have flown into real estate; but availability of suitable exit options for such investments is still constrained. Maturity of the real estate markets will lead to infusion of foreign investment and adoption of international best practices by real estate players. Developers will get more organized, and become more transparent to avail opportunities emerging in the market. With the Indian securities market regulator SEBI allowing real estate mutual funds (REMFs) in India, equity investors will have an exit option available to them. All these factors will contribute in making the Indian real estate market more organized and structured, thus providing better investment opportunities.
GODREJ GROUP
Established in 1897, the Godrej group has grown in India from the days of the charkha to nights at the call centres. Our founder, Ardeshir Godrej, lawyer-turnedlocksmith, was a persistent inventor and a strong visionary who could see the spark in the future. His inventions, manufactured by his brother Pirojsha Godrej, were the foundation of today's Godrej empire. One of India's most trusted brands, Godrej enjoys the patronage and trust of over 400 million Indians every single day. Our customers mean the world to us. We are happy only when we see a delighted customer smile.
27
With 7 major companies with interests in real estate, FMCG, industrial engineering, appliances, furniture, security and agri care - to name a few our turnover crosses 3.2 billion dollars. Though Godrej is a renowned Indian brand, 20% of the business is done overseas. Our presence in more than 60 countries ensures that our customers are at home with Godrej no matter where they go. With brands you can believe in, service excellence that you can count on and the promise of brighter living for every customer, Godrej knows what makes India tick today. Today, we're at a point in Godrej's history when our amazing past is meeting up with its spectacular future head on. Godrej is learning and relishing being young again.
28
29
VISION
We aspire to be among the nation's top 3 real estate companies, while continuing to be the most trusted name in the industry. We shall deliver superior value to all stakeholders through extraordinary and imaginative spaces created out of deep customer focus and insight.
30
Corporate Governance
Godrej Properties ensures transparency in all internal and external processes along with strong conformity to norms.
Professional Management
Godrej Properties is led by experienced leadership and highly qualified cross-functional teams. Strong processes e.g. Concerto (execution), SAP,
31
Performance Review etc are followed. There is a strong focus and high emphasis on employee training & development at all levels.
Quality
Highest quality standards are followed for project execution, materials and services. Godrej Properties collaborates only with the best-in-class associates.
Design
While focusing on customer requirements and incorporating them in design, Godrej Properties ensures unique and innovative designs for all projects.
Project Management
Godrej Properties' constant focus is on core competencies in project management. The company creates scalability and an ideal combination of expertise by associating with the best in respective fields.
ACCOLADES
Godrej Properties has been voted amongst 'Most Trusted Names' and 'India's Best Marketed Company, 2011' in the Real Estate sector by 4Ps-ICMR survey. Planet Godrej received 'Mumbai - 7 Star Rating' by Crisil. This is the highest rating awarded to a project based on several stringent project
32
specific parameters like construction quality, legal quality, financial quality and innovativeness. Godrej Properties was awarded the 'Best Business Practices, 2009 & 2010' award by Accommodation Times. Planet Godrej won the 'Brihanmumbai Mahanagarpalika & Tree Authority Udyan, 2010' award for the best podium garden. Planet Godrej (Tower 1 to 4) declared as the winner in the "Best Residential Project in Western India" category at the CNBC AWAAZ CRISIL CREDAI Real Estate Awards 09. Godrej Properties was ranked No.1 in the construction and real estate industry in 'India's Best Companies To Work For, 2009' survey, conducted by 'The Economic Times' and 'Great Place To Work Institute' Godrej Properties was awarded 'Corporate Governance of the Year, 2008' by Accommodation Times. Godrej Properties featured among the top ten construction companies in India for four consecutive years 2006, 2007, 2008 & 2009 according to a study conducted by 'Construction World' Planet Godrej was awarded 'Project of the Year - Mumbai' for the year 2007 by the Accommodation Times Planet Godrej was also awarded the 'Pinnacle Award, 2006' by ZEE Business for being the best upcoming real estate project in India
33
BUSINESS STRATEGY
34
35
36
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
The corporate governance framework of our organization is based on an effective independent board and separation of the board's supervisory role from the executive management team. The Board has twelve directors, out of which six are independent directors with distinguished careers in government, academia, and business. In recognition of GPL's strong corporate governance practices, Accommodation Times presented Godrej Properties with the 'Corporate Governance of the Year' award for the year 2008.
areas of green buildings, energy efficiency, water management, environment management, renewable energy, green business incubation and climate change activities. The centre sensitizes key stakeholders to embrace green practices and facilitates market transformation, paving the way for India to become one of the global leaders in green businesses by 2015. Godrej's responsible stewardship of the vast mangrove holdings it owns in Vikhroli has been unanimously praised. The vast expanse of mangroves serves as a critical lung to the city. Godrej Properties Ltd. views its upcoming development, Godrej Garden City, which is one of only two projects in India and sixteen worldwide to be chosen by The Clinton Foundation to partner with them in the goal of achieving climate positive development.
1994 Completion of first residential building, Cypress (part of Godrej Edenwoods in Thane) 1996 Awarded the ISO 9002: 1994 certification of Bureau of Veritas Quality International 1997 MGSM 1999 Completion of first commercial project at Bandra, Mumbai Launch of first project in Pune - Godrej Millennium
38
2004
2005 Executed agreement for the first project in Kolkata Godrej Waterside 2006 Tied up with Rallis India Limited for first project in Hyderabad
2006 Planet Godrej received the Pinnacle Award by Zee for the best upcoming real estate project in India 2006 Planet Godrej received the ZEE Business Pinnacle Award for Best upcoming project 2007 Acquired 26.7 acres of land at B. T. Road, Kolkata. Ranked among the top 10 construction companies in India by Construction World 2008 Expansion into several cities across India including Ahmedabad, Chandigarh, Kochi and Chennai. 2008 Ranked one of Indias Top 10 Builders by Construction World 2009 Implemented SAP across all projects
2009 Received award for Corporate Governance of the Year, 2008 From Accommodation Times 2009 Ranked 1st in the Construction & Real Estate category in Indias Best Companies to Work For 2009 awarded by The Great Place to Work Institute, India, in partnership with The Economic Times. 2009 Tied up with the Clinton Climate Initiative for our Godrej Garden City project in Ahmedabad.
39
2009 Executed memorandum of understanding with Godrej Industries Limited to develop one of our Forthcoming Projects in Vikhroli, Mumbai 2009 Ranked one of Indias Top 10 Builders by the Construction World Architect & Builder Awards, 2009.
AIM
To evaluate the performance of the company by using ratios as a yardstick to measure the efficiency of the company. To understand the liquidity, profitability and efficiency positions of the company during the study period. To evaluate and analyze various facts of the financial performance of the company. To make comparisons between the ratios during different periods.
OBJECTIVES
1. To study the present financial system at GODREJ PROPERTIES LIMITED. 2. To determine the Profitability, Liquidity Ratios.
40
3. To analyze the capital structure of the company with the help of Leverage ratio. 4. To offer appropriate suggestions for the better performance of the organization.
DATABASE
BALANCE SHEET OF PAST 5 YEARS:
Table 4: Balance Sheet of Godrej Properties Mar '11 12 mths Sources Of Funds Total Share Capital Equity Share Capital Share Application Money Preference Share Capital Reserves Revaluation Reserves Networth Secured Loans Unsecured Loans Total Debt Total Liabilities Application Of Funds Gross Block Less: Accum. Depreciation Net Block Capital Work in Progress Investments Inventories Sundry Debtors Cash and Bank Balance Total Current Assets Loans and Advances Fixed Deposits Total CA, Loans & Advances Deffered Credit 21.58 9.19 12.39 1.38 78.88 192.43 200.18 12.63 405.24 1,362.30 128.33 1,895.87 0.00 16.55 6.04 10.51 0.00 247.77 143.59 137.71 18.44 299.74 821.69 53.91 1,175.34 0.00 7.50 3.73 3.77 3.25 55.72 52.50 114.02 10.94 177.46 589.16 3.79 770.41 0.00 5.41 2.74 2.67 0.21 55.69 11.56 405.71 2.09 419.36 491.55 4.31 915.22 0.00 4.44 2.03 2.41 0.21 8.36 78.79 219.79 9.36 307.94 103.92 4.01 415.87 0.00 69.85 69.85 0.00 0.00 815.19 0.00 885.04 418.89 397.07 815.96 1,701.00 69.85 69.85 0.00 0.00 745.57 0.00 815.42 128.47 326.43 454.90 1,270.32 60.42 60.42 0.00 0.00 237.79 0.00 298.21 256.69 190.36 447.05 745.26 60.42 60.42 0.00 0.00 181.73 0.00 242.15 98.58 152.98 251.56 493.71 6.44 6.44 0.00 0.00 52.06 0.00 58.50 17.39 113.71 131.10 189.60 ------------------- in Rs. Cr. ------------------Mar '10 12 mths Mar '09 12 mths Mar '08 12 mths Mar '07 12 mths
41
Current Liabilities Provisions Total CL & Provisions Net Current Assets Miscellaneous Expenses Total Assets Contingent Liabilities Book Value (Rs)
42
PBT (Post Extra-ord Items) Tax Reported Net Profit Total Value Addition Preference Dividend Equity Dividend Corporate Dividend Tax Per share data (annualised) Shares in issue (lakhs) Earning Per Share (Rs) Equity Dividend (%) Book Value (Rs)
155.48 49.32 106.24 226.56 0.00 31.43 5.10 698.50 15.21 45.00 126.71
158.54 36.90 121.84 128.69 0.00 27.94 4.64 698.50 17.44 40.00 116.74
105.02 31.30 74.74 78.17 0.00 15.11 2.57 604.20 12.37 25.00 49.36
101.88 39.43 75.89 108.20 0.00 24.61 4.18 604.20 12.56 100.00 40.08
46.09 4.65 41.45 86.97 0.00 27.00 3.79 64.45 64.32 418.95 90.78
METHODOLOGY
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Research Methodology is a way to systematically solve the research problem. It may be understood as a science of study how research is done systematically. This research on liquidity analysis may be referred to as exploratory research in which problems and findings are generated from the calculations. When some deduction is made from data then a problem is located regarding the same and reasons for the same are also searched for. In the end suggestions and recommendations are made to make research meaningful and worthy to improvise on the same.
DATA COLLECTION
The information is collected through secondary sources during the project. That information was utilized for calculating performance evaluation and based on that, interpretations were made.
2. Referring standard texts and referred books collected some of the information regarding theoretical aspects.
LIMITATIONS
Although full efforts have been made to complete the study on ratio analysis of GODREJ PROPERTIES LIMITED, so that the study could present a true and comprehensive picture, inspite of all the care efforts there are some limitations such as: Financial resources are limited. The time of research was not that much sufficient that could be regarded as opportunity to analyze liquidity of such organization. As data taken is secondary, so it cannot be said to give constant conclusions, as its not revised to present situation.
analysed in order to evaluate the past performance of the company and the future prospects. There are many tools of financial statement analysis like: Ratio Analysis Dupont Analysis Trend Analysis Commonsize statements Comparative Analysis
The most widely used tool is Ratio Analysis. And the tool of my research too is Ratio Analysis
RATIO ANALYSIS
It is the most widely used tool since it compares risk and return relationships of firms from various aspects. Ratio analysis is the method or process by which the relationship of items or group of items in the financial statements are computed, determined and presented. It is an attempt to derive quantitative measures or guides concerning the financial health and profitability of a business enterprise. It can be used both in trend and static analysis. There are several ratios at the disposal of an analyst but the group of ratios he would prefer depends on the purpose and objectives of analysis.
Ratios analyze the financial health, operating efficiency and future prospects by inter relating the various financial data found in the financial statements. Ratios are invaluable guides to management. They assist the management to discharge their functions of planning, forecasting, etc. efficiently. Ratios study the past and relate the findings to the present. Thus, useful inferences are drawn which are used to project the future. Ratios are increasingly used in trend analysis. Ratios being measures of efficiency can be used to control efficiency and profitability of a business entity. Ratios play a very important role in security and credit analysis. Ratios assist investors in making sound investment decisions and also the shareholders in evaluating the share performance. Ratios are yardsticks, increasingly used by bankers and financial institutions, in evaluating the credit standing of their borrowers and customers. Functional Classification: The ratios may be grouped in accordance with the purposes they serve of different users of accounting information. On this basis, ratios are classified as follows:
LIQUIDITY RATIOS
47
These ratios analyze short term and immediate financial position of a business organization and indicate the ability of the firm to meet its short term commitments(current liabilities)out of its short term resources(current assets).They are also known as Solvency Ratios. LEVERAGE RATIOS These ratios measure the relationship between proprietors funds and borrowed funds. They indicate the degree of debt financing in a firm. ACTIVITY RATIOS These ratios are designed to indicate the effectiveness of the firm in utilizing its funds, its degree of efficiency, and its standards of performance. Hence they are also known as Efficiency and Performance ratios. PROFITABILITY RATIOS These ratios are intended to reflect the overall efficiency of the organization, its ability to earn a reasonable return on capital employed or on shares issued and the effectiveness of its investment policies.
Leverage ratios give fruitful information to long term creditors. Long term creditors include debenture holders, vendors of fixed assets and term lending institutions. These creditors are primarily interested in the companys long term solvency position.
PRECAUTIONS RATIOS
TO
CONSIDER
WHILE
CALCULATING
Ratio analysis is rightly considered as an invaluable tool of analysis. However, one has to exercise considerable degree of caution while analyzing the financial statements with the help of ratios. The precautions are as listed: It is essential to ensure that the person who uses the ratios understand the terminology and the component figures employed for compiling. The ratios to be compared should be capable of being compared. In other words, the data found in financial statements have to be horizontally consistent over a period of a time. Compilation of ratios has to be done speedily. They have to be worked out and supplied to the different users in time for further action. Ratios have to be presented in an appropriate manner. It is a usual practice to set out the major ratios first followed by less important ratios and then finish with the least important ones. A complete record of ratios is essential.
COMPARATIVE STUDY REQUIRED Ratios are useful in judging the efficiency of the business only when they are compared with the past results of the business or with the results of a similar business. However, such a comparison only provides a glimpse of the past performance and forecasts for future may not prove correct since several other factors like market conditions, management policies, etc. may affect the future operations. LIMITATIONS OF FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Ratios are based only on the information which has been recorded in the financial statements. Financial statements suffer from a no. of limitations; the ratios derived therefore, are also subject to those limitations. For eg. Non financial changes though are important for the business but are not revealed by the financial statements. If the management of the company changes, it may have ultimately adverse effects on the future profitability of the company but this cannot be judged by having a glance at the financial statements of the company.
RATIOS ALONE ARE NOT ADEQUATE Ratios are only indicators, they cannot be taken as final regarding good or bad financial position of business. Other things also must be considered. For eg. A high current ratio does not necessarily mean that the concern has a good liquid position in case current assets mostly comprise of outdated stock. It has been correctly observed, Ratios must be used for what they are- financial tools. Too often they are looked upon as ends in themselves rather than as a means to an end. The value of a ratio should not be regarded as good or bad inter se. It may be an indication that a firm is weak or strong in a particular area but it must never be taken as proof. Ratio may be linked to railroads. They tell the analyst- Stop, look and listen!
50
WINDOW DRESSING The term window dressing means manipulation of accounts in a way as to conceal vital facts and present the financial statements in a way to show a better position than what it actually is. On account of such a situation, presence of particular ratio may not be a definite indicator of good or bad management. For eg. A high stock turnover ratio is generally considered to be an indication of operational efficiency of the business but this might have been achieved by unwarranted price reductions or failure to maintain proper stock of goods. PROBLEMS OF PRICE LEVEL CHANGES Financial analysis on accounting ratios will give misleading results, if the effect of changes in price level is not taken into account. For example, two companies set up in different years, having plant and machinery of different ages, cannot be compared on the basis of traditional accounting statements. This is because the depreciation charged on plant and machinery in case of old company would be at much lower figure as compared to the company which has been set up recently. The financial statements of the companies should, therefore, be adjusted keeping in view the price level changes if a meaningful comparison is to be made. The techniques of current purchasing power and current cost accounting are quite helpful in this respect.
NO FIXED STANDARDS No fixed standards can be laid down for ideal ratios. For eg. Current ratio is generally considered to be ideal if current assets are twice current liabilities. However, in case of those concerns which have adequate arrangements with their bankers for providing funds when they require, it may be perfectly ideal if current assets are equal to or slightly more than current liabilities.
51
RATIOS ARE COMPOSITE OF MANY FIGURES Ratios are a composite of many different figures. Some cover a time period, others are at an instant of time while still others are only averages. It has been said that a man who has his head in the oven and his feet in the icebox is on the average, comfortable! Many of the figures used in the ratio analysis are no more meaningful than the average temperature on the room in which the man sits. A balance sheet figure shows the balance of the account at one moment of one day. It certainly may not be representative of typical balance during the year. Differences in accounting policies with reference to stock valuation, depreciation, etc render ratios useless. Besides there are no standard definitions for certain terms like operating profit, current assets etc. Without further investigations, ratios may not serve the purpose. For eg. A high current ratio is considered desirable, but if inventories (one of the elements of current assets), consist mostly of dead and obsolete stock a company may not be able to meet its current obligations. Ratios are often calculated as rough estimates and are often calculated with the figures as on a particular date. Therefore, they are not accurate and precise. For eg. Solvency ratios, worked out for a firm engaged in seasonal business, whose accounting year ends at a time when the sales are high, may appear quite favorable. It may therefore be concluded that ratio analysis, if done mechanically, is not only misleading but also dangerous. It is indeed a double edged sword which requires a great deal of understanding and sensitivity of the management process rather than the mechanical financial skill.
Compare the calculated ratios with the ratios of the same firm relating to the past or with the industry ratios. It facilitates in assessing success or failure of the firm. Third step is interpretation, drawing of inferences and report writing conclusions after comparison in the shape of report or recommended courses of action.
53
YEAR CURRENT ASSETS CURRENT LIABILITIES CURRENT RATIO INVENTORIE S LIQUID ASSETS QUICK RATIO
2010-11
2009-10
2008-09
2007-06
2006-07
INTERPRETATION
Liquidity ratios are determined to judge the short term liquidity position of the company, that is, how quickly a company can meet its short term obligations. So, from the above table we can see that, in the year 2006-07 and 2007-06, current ratio of the company is not reaching the standard norm i.e. 2:1, so we may say that liquidity position of the company is not so good. But, as we see
54
that quick ratio is almost the standard i.e. 1:1 in those 2 years, the overall short term liquidity of the firm is good and the short term debt repayment capacity is satisfactory. The reason for the non satisfactory current ratio in the above 2 years is due to huge part of current assets locked in inventories which lowers the current ratio. Now, in 2008-09 and 2009-10, both current ratio and quick ratio is above the standard, so in both these years, the company has a high liquidity and short term creditors may feel very secure about the debt repayment capacity of the firm. Again, in 2010-11, we see that both current ratio and quick ratio has dipped a little but it is not a cause of much concern as it is very much near to the standard ratio. Therefore, we conclude that the short term solvency position of the firm is good and the company can meet its short term obligations easily.
PROFITABILITY RATIO: 1. GROSS PROFIT RATIO = (GROSS PROFIT) X 100 SALES 2. NET PROFIT RATIO = (NET PROFIT BEFORE TAX) X 100 SALES 3. OPERATING PROFIT RATIO = (OPERATING PROFIT) X 100
55
SALES 4. EARNING RATIO/ = (NET PROFIT AFTER TAX) X 100 RETURN ON EQUITY NET WORTH 5. RETURN ON CAPITAL EMPLOYED = (NET PROFIT BEFORE TAX) X 100 CAPITAL EMPLOYED Table 7: Calculation of profitability ratios
YEAR SALES GROSS PROFIT GROSS PROFIT RATIO (IN %) OPERATING PROFIT OPERATING PROFIT RATIO (IN %) NET PROFIT BEFORE TAX NET PROFIT RATIO (IN %) NET PROFIT AFTER TAX NET WORTH EARNING RATIO CAPITAL EMPLOYED RETURN ON CAPITAL EMPLOYED (IN %) 2010-11 294.61 70.94 24.08 68.06 23.10 2009-10 142.11 27.57 19.31 13.42 9.44 2008-09 145.17 76.97 53.02 67.00 46.15 2007-08 227.44 128.25 56.39 119.24 52.43 2006-07 137.22 53.26 38.81 50.26 36.63
56
120 100 80 60 40 20 0 2010-11 2009-10 2008-09 2007-08 2006-07 RETURN ON CAPITAL EMPLOYED NET PROFIT RATIO OPERATING PROFIT RATIO EARNING RATIO
INTERPRETATION
Profitability ratios are computed for the purpose of assessing the profitability position of the firm. From the above data, the gross profit of the company reveals an overall good position. The efficiency of the management is very good with respect to earning profit before meeting indirect expenses. The lesser gross profit ratio in 2009-10 is due to lesser sales and more manufacturing expenses incurred as compared to previous 3 years. But still, it is satisfactory as compared to the standard norm of 20% to 30%. Year 2008-09 and 2007-08 shows a very high gross profit ratio as the sales amount has increased a lot with a very less increase in expenses. In the years 2010-11, 2008-09, 2007-08, we see that operating efficiency of the company is very high, resulting in high net profit ratio. Only in the year 2009-10, the operating profit ratio and the net profit ratio shows a contradiction. This may be due to the huge other income received during that year leading to high net profit ratio and a low operating efficiency leading to
57
low operating ratio. Overall, the net profit ratio reveals that the company has a high profitability position after meeting all direct and indirect expenses and a very efficient management team with proper utilization of resources leading to high revenue. As far as earning ratio and return on capital employed is concerned, it is constantly decreasing, the shareholders may get dissatisfied with this situation and may sell their shares. The decreasing ratios may be due to huge amount of interest paid to fixed interest bearers. The management has to be efficient and increase internal funding to satisfy shareholders and reduce the amount of interest paid.
2. DEBT EQUITY RATIO = TOTAL DEBT NET WORTH 3. CAPITAL GEARING RATIO = FIXED INTEREST BEARING CAPITAL EQUITY SHARE CAPITAL+RESERVES AND SURPLUS 4. PROPRIETARY RATIO = NET WORTH TOTAL ASSETS
58
1,701.00 0.52
1,270.33 0.64
745.24 0.40
493.71 0.49
189.60 0.31
59
INTERPRETATION
Leverage ratios are used to analyze the relationship between the financial stability of the firm and the composition of its capital structure. They are used to measure the financial risk and operating risk involved in the activities of the firm. From the above table of leverage ratios, we see that the debt equity ratio and debt ratio in 2006-07 is very high which is a very risky position because of the interest burden of the loan fund in capital structure. But, loan fund is comparatively cheaper due to tax benefits, so, the standard norm of debt equity ratio is 1:1 which helps to have benefits of both loan and internal funding. The company has gradually decreased its loan fund and in the last year it was just around the standard norm which shows moderate risk and satisfied shareholders. In the year 2009-10, the company reduced its debt part to approx. 50% which means it could have realized benefit by increasing debt. So, in 201011, the company increased it. The management of the company has taken a good decision. The capital gearing ratio of the firm shows that it is a low geared firm. Year 2009-10 bears a very low risk as compared to 2008-09 which bears a moderate risk. The company follows a conservative approach. The disadvantage of this is that it cannot avail the benefits of trading on equity. Only in the year 2008-09, we see moderate ratio where the risk is not too high and to some extent benefits of trading on equity can be availed of. Proprietary ratio reveals that more of debt part is used to acquire total assets. This situation is unfavorable for the firm due to high risk, unstable solvency and financial position. Outside investors may not be secured with low proprietary ratio.
60
61
ACTIVITY RATIOS:
1. INVENTORY TURNOVER RATIO = COST OF GOODS SOLD AVERAGE INVENTORY 2. DEBTORS TURNOVER RATIO = CREDIT SALES AVERAGE RECEIVABLES 3. TOTAL ASSETS TURNOVER RATIO = SALES TOTAL ASSETS
0.17
0.11
0.19
0.46
0.72
62
15 10 5
INVENTORY TURNOVER RATIO DEBTORS TURNOVER RATIO TOTAL ASSETS TURNOVER RATIO 2007-08 2006-07
INVESTMENT RATIOS: 0
2010-11 2009-10
2008-09
1. EARNING PER SHARE = NET PAT PREFERENCE SHARE DIVIDEND NO. OF EQUITY SHARES 2. DIVIDEND PAYOUT RATIO = DIVIDEND PER SHARE EARNING PER SHARE 3. PRICE - EARNING RATIO = MARKET VALUE PER SHARE EARNING PER SHARE
( PAT = PROFIT AFTER TAX)
126.71 8.33
116.74 6.69
49.36 3.99
40.08 3.19
90.78 1.41
63
64
INTERPRETATION
Investment ratios supply some sort of information regarding share price, price earning, dividend per share, earning per share which is very important for the investors. On the basis of that they take their investment decision. In the year 2006-07, we see in the above table that the earning per share is very high as number of shares is very less as compared to other years. After that, in the year 2007-08 and 2008-09, number of shares increased leading to lesser earning per share. In 2010-11, the earning per share has decreased as compared to 2009-10 as we see that profit after tax has decreased from 2009-10 to 2010-11. Now, it is seen that dividend payout ratio is very high in 2006-07 but it has gradually decreased. The company gave more dividends to equity shareholders in 2006-07 but after that it started to retain more earnings for internal growth. As the book value of the share increased, the price earning ratio also increased. This means that shareholders will be benefited a lot leading to high reputation of the firm and highly competent management. No doubt, Godrej Properties Limited is a highly reputed company.
CONCLUSION
From the above analysis, the summary of the financial performance of GODREJ PROPERTIES LIMITED can be given as follows: The company has a high short term liquidity and the short term creditors may feel very secure about the debt repayment capacity of the firm. The ratios are complying with the standard norm of the industry.
65
The overall gross profit and net profit of the company is very high showing a very efficient management. But, the earning ratio and return on capital employed shows an alarming situation as it is constantly decreasing. The management has to take effective steps immediately to control it as it may lead to dissatisfied shareholders. In the initial years, the company had a very high loan fund in capital structure which was very risky, so it gradually increased its internal finance to reach the standard norm where the risk is not too high and benefits of trading on equity can b availed to some extent the proprietary ratio shows unfavorable position as external finance is used to acquire assets, which is very risky. The inventory turnover ratio reveals very effective inventory management and proper control over operating cycle. But, the receivables management effectiveness has to increase further as the debtors turnover ratio shows a weak collection policy. Managerial incompetency is also shown in total assets turnover ratio. The company has to proper utilize its assets to increase sales. The investment ratios show that the company retains most part of the earnings for its growth and declares a moderate dividend. The shareholders are satisfied as the price earning ratio is constantly increasing year by year with increase in book value of shares.
66
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. http://www.godrejproperties.com/ 2. http://financenmoney.in/ratio-analysis-uses-of-accounting-ratios/ 3. http://financenmoney.in/ratio-analysis-importance-objectives/ 4. http://www.moneycontrol.com/financials/godrejproperties/balancesheet/GP11#GP11 5. http://www.moneycontrol.com/financials/godrejproperties/profitloss/GP11#GP11 6. http://www.prres.net/papers/Sonia%20_Real_Estate_Sector_The_ India_Story.pdf 7. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_estate 8. Financial Management III by Partha Chatterjee 9. Modern Accounting Theory And Management Accounting by Debasish Banerjee
67
68