IGNOU Gender Issues of Development
IGNOU Gender Issues of Development
IGNOU Gender Issues of Development
Structure 26.0 Objectives 26.1 Introduction 26.2 Female Literacy 26.3 Sex Ratio 26.4 Gender Issues in Labour Market 26.5 Maternal Health 26.6 Women Empowerment 26.7 Panchyati Raj Institutions, 73rd and 74th Constitution Amendments 26.8 Self Help Groups and Micro Finance 26.9 Let us Sum up 26.10 Key Words 26.11 Suggested Books for Reading 26.12 Answers/Hints to CYP Exercises
26.0 OBJECTIVES
After reading this unit, you will be able to:
l
explain the position of women in India in terms of their sex ratio and literacy levels; discuss the gender issues in labour market vis--vis labour force participation rates and wage differentials; discuss issues like female foeticide/infanticide and the importance of women empowerment measures to combat such social evils; bring out the measures taken in uplifting the level of women in society in terms of institutional measures like formation of Self Help Groups and Micro Finance; and explain the governmental initiatives by way of enactment of constitutional amendments to improve the position of women in the Indian society.
26.1 INTRODUCTION
Equality between men and women is recognised by all members of United Nations Organisation (UNO) as a fundamental right and citizenship.
53
Equality between sexes is explicitly extended by the constitutional guarantees of many countries. Yet, despite such formal commitments, and demonstrated benefits of gender equality to societies and economies, gender inequalities remain pervasive in many countries. Gender equality and the empowerment of women to fully participate in social, economic and political life is recognised as an important developmental need. This is reflected in the national development plans of many countries including India. In line with these legislative and constitutional provisions, specific policies and action plans for reducing the gender gaps have been initiated. In spite of these measures, discrimination against females have continued in one form or another. Common gender concerns relate to discrimination against female in respect of hunger, malnutrition, healthcare needs, opportunities for education and income earning avenues, etc. Gender linked discrimination against females, thus, pervade both the social and economic spheres of societal attitude and behaviour. In this context, the present unit deals with the various gender dimensions of Indian economy. Specifically, it deals with the issues of female literacy, sex ratio, labour market features, maternal health, and women empowerment.
54
India. In particular, all formal and informal education and training programmes have been opened to both women and men. Separate provisions exclusively for women/girls have also been made by opening separate institutions for them. Education is free for girls up to the higher secondary stage. Several states have made education free for girls up to university level. There are other incentives like free midday meals, free books, free uniforms, scholar-ships for good attendance, bicycles, etc. Legislation for reservation of seats in institutions of higher learning are also made. Even with all these initiatives taken, India still has a long way to go in bridging the gap between the male and female literacy levels even after more than 5 decades of its independence. Table 26.1 shows the progress made and the disparity that still exists in respect of female literacy in India during the period 1951-01. Though there still exists disparity in male female literacy rates, post-1981, the gender gap is slowly reducing. Table 26.2 shows details of progress in female enrolment in primary, upper primary, secondary/high secondary and higher education stages. The trends show that the various measures initiated have contributed significantly to reduce the gender inequality in education although to reach the mid-mark of 50 percent level, there is still a long way to go. Table 26.1: Literacy Levels (%) by Gender in India: 1951-2001 Year 1951 1961 1971 1981 1991 2001 Persons 18.3 28.3 34.5 43.6 52.2 65.4 Males 27.2 40.4 46.0 56.4 64.1 75.9 Females 8.9 15.4 22.0 29.8 39.3 54.2 Male-Female Gap 18.3 25.1 24.0 26.6 24.8 21.7
curb the social evil of female foeticide. To reinforce, the various measures required to fight this social evil are:
l l l
more effective implementation of PC and PNDT Act; active monitoring of birth ratios; detailed medical audits of all ultra sound examination carried out by registered clinics including sale-purchase records of ultra sound machines and to make these record public; sustained social campaigns, financial incentives to parents giving birth to female child, free educational scholarships, reservation for females in educational institutions and jobs; and active involvement of community, NGOs and other voluntary organisations and SHGs with support from government are needed.
Infant and Child Mortality Another critical gender dimension of economic development is the survival and health of female child. On the basis of biological factors, the survival ratio of female to male child would ordinarily be less than one. Many developing countries in East Asia and South Asia have female infant mortality ratio, compared to that of male infants, more than one. In India also female infant mortality rate is more than that for male as seen from Table 26.3. The ratio of male-female mortality ratio has increased from 1:1.02 to 1:1.09 over the years. The present trend of female foeticide along with relatively high female infant mortality is contributing to this adverse ratio. The trend needs to be arrested and reversed if the consequences of adverse ratio is to be checked. State Governments are taking number of measures like providing financial incentives to parents of female child. These include: payments for each female child in instalments until the girl reaches schooling age, a lump sum amount deposited in the name of child to meet the cost of higher education or marriage expenses, etc. Table 26.3: Infant Mortality Rate in India by Sex: 1980-2005 Year 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 Male 113 96 78 73 67 56 Female 115 98 81 76 69 61 Ratio (male:female) 1:1.02 1:1.02 1:1.04 1:1.04 1:1.03 1:1.09 Male + Female 114 97 80 74 68 58
57
One, the availability of well paying, secure jobs for educated women is low. Hence, educated women belonging to the high socio economic strata, prefer to opt out of the labour force. Two, cultural factors prevent many households from allowing women to go out and work.
In case of poor households, mainly in rural areas, their ability to participate in labour market is influenced by many factors like:
l
Remoteness of work site from habitations requiring long travel. These will affect womens work participation, as they need to combine their outside work with household work chores like child care; Lack of education and skills marginalise poor women from opportunities outside their home compelling them to confine themselves to low wage work in agriculture and allied activities many times on their own farm which is often unpaid; Discrimination in labour markets affects women, not only due to wage differentials, but also due to social norms restricting womens participation in labour market. Quite often, certain types of work are labelled as inappropriate for women. Such typification makes it discriminatory in nature.
58
levels. Wage differential based on gender, however, exists in unorganised sector jobs, especially in manual works. Since most manual workers have minimum education, exploitation based on wage differentials becomes easier. Research has revealed that about 30 percent malefemale wage differences are explained due to productivity differences and the residual, amounting to a majority of 70 percent, is based on discrimination due to gender.
59
Targeting expectant mothers directly include arranging for: (a) antenatal care, (b) tetanus toxoid vaccination, (c) providing iron and folic acid tablets, and (d) encouraging institutional deliveries. Antenatal care refers to pregnancy related health care provided by a doctor or a health worker before the birth of the child in a hospital or at home. It includes advice on correct diet and the provision of iron and folic acid tablets to pregnant women. Antenatal care can contribute significantly to the reduction of maternal mortality. Further, improved nutritional status can help reduce the incidence of low birth weight babies and thus reduce prenatal, neonatal and infant mortality deaths. The tetanus toxoid immunisation programme for expectant mothers in India was initiated in 1975-76 and was integrated with the expanded programme of immunisation (EPI) in 1978. An important cause of death among neonates in India is neonatal tetanus which is caused by infection of the new born (usually at the umbilical stub) by tetanus organisms. Neonatal tetanus is most common when the delivery takes place in an unhygienic environment using unsterilised instruments. The tetanus toxoid immunisation programme was integrated with the Universal Immunisation Programme (UIP) in 1985-86. The UIP, the objective of which was to vaccinate all the pregnant women against tetanus by 1990, was recognised as a technology mission. Proper maternal nutrition is important for the healthy intrauterine growth of a baby and can affect the birth weight of the baby. In India, 33 per cent of babies are low birth weight, suggesting a nutritional deficiency among many expectant mothers. Improvement in mothers nutritional status, coupled with proper healthcare during pregnancy, can substantially increase birth weight of the children. Provision of iron and folic acid tablets to pregnant women to avoid nutritional anaemia is an integral part of mother and child health activities. It is recommended that a woman take 100 tablets of iron and folic acid during pregnancy. Encouraging institutional deliveries in which at least one trained worker is involved is another important measure planned under the programme of reaching out to the targeted expectant mothers directly. Check your progress 1 1. Briefly state the progress made in female literacy in India. .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... 2. What are the causes for decline in juvenile sex ratio? .................................................................................................................... ....................................................................................................................
60
.................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... 3. In which sector and type of work wage discrimination is rampant and why ? .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... 4. Explain briefly the maternal healthcare measures instituted in India. .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... ....................................................................................................................
empowerment. A more vigorous thrust in this respect is particularly given since the 8th Five Year Plan in India. Since overall empowerment of women is crucially dependent on earnings of women, policy makers have time and again reinforced government intervention at different levels to ensure removal of discrimination as a step towards enhanced earnings for women. These include focused development projects that enhance income earning capacity of women through appropriate and specific skill formation, capacity building, and increased access to institutional credit. In this context, the efforts of many non-government organisations and social workers who have supplemented the government efforts in bringing women into the mainstream of economic development need to be appreciated. The 73rd and the 74th constitutional amendments effected in 1994 marks a significant step in the direction of providing legislative provision for women empowerment in India.
elections not being held regularly; lack of adequate transfer of powers and resources; lack of power to generate their own resources; and
62
In 1989, the Government of India took two major initiatives to enhance the role of panchayats. First, it initiated the Jawahar Employment Plan (Jawarhar Razgar Yojana) which provided funding directly to village councils to create jobs for unemployed through public woks. Second, it also proposed the 64th Constitution Amendment Bill to make it mandatory for all states to establish a three tiered (village, block and district ) system of Panchayats in which representatives would be directly elected for five year terms. Panchayats were to be given expanded authority and funding over local development efforts. Despite the popular appeal of transferring power to panchayats, the 64th amendment bill was rejected by Rajya sabha.
tolls and fees in accordance with laid down procedures and limits; b) assign to a panchayat such taxes, duties, tolls and fees levied and collected by the state government to be used for specific purposes subject to specified conditions and limits; and c) provide grants-in-aid to the panchayats from the consolidated fund of the state. The amendment also empowers the governor of the state to review the financial position of the panchayats and make suitable recommendations for distribution of resources between the panchayats in the state. Further, Article 243-I provides for the constitution of a state finance commission to review the financial position of panchayats and make suitable recommendations for sharing the resources, between the state and the PRIs.
64
Development Programme (UNDP) as a response to the Dhaka declaration of the SAARC summit on Eradication of Poverty and Reduction of Gender Inequalities. The major elements of the SHG approach to micro credit include the following: a) provide a cost effective approach to formal institutions for expanding and reaching out to poor; b) offer an effective alternative to pursue the objective of growth by facilitating the empowerment of rural poor women; c) make available micro finance to cater to the consumption and production needs of poor women; d) provide a platform for poor women to participate in mainstream economic activity; and e) help in capacity building by providing greater awareness on various development and welfare programmes relating to women and child health in general and education of children in particular. The SHGs, by providing access to financial services and informing the women members about the various welfare programmes especially targeted to women and children, truly empower women by making them partners in bringing about the needed social and economic transformation. The efforts of SHGs are thus, to a very great extent, contributing to address the gender issues of economic development in India. Check your progress 2 1. What are the general and specific causes for women disempowerment? .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... 2. What are the main problems that adversely affected the functioning of Panchayat Raj Institutions in India? .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... ....................................................................................................................
65
3. What are the major elements of the SHG approach to micro credit? .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................................... ....................................................................................................................
Women empowerment : Providing control over resources and decision making to women by legislative and institutional guarantee Self Help Groups : Women groups in villages from poor families who organise themselves to support each other in various ways
Bina Agarwal (1994), Gender and Command Over Property: A Critical Gap in Economic Analysis and Policy in South Asia.
Ajay Tankha (2002), Report on SHGs and Financial Intermediaries in India: Cost of Promotion, Sustainability and Impact. G. Ramachandrudu and C. Appa Rao (2007), Female Deficit in IndiaFacts and Factors, Associated Publishers. S. B. Agnihotri (2001), Rising Sons and Setting Daughters, Provisional Results of the 2001 Census, Rainbow Publishers, New Delhi. Chandan Saha (2003), Gender Equity and Equality, Rawath Publishers, New Delhi. Rajib Lochan Panigrahy (2007), Panchayati Raj Institutions: Issues and Challenges, Discovery Publishing House, New Delhi.
67