Safety of Ships in Yard
Safety of Ships in Yard
Safety of Ships in Yard
PART A
SAFETY OF SHIPS IN YARD GENERAL SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS
List of Contents
Why is Shiprepairing an inherently hazardous operation The ships special condition in the Shipyard Safety becomes an important factor in selecting a shipyard Shipyard selection principles Requirements for a Health, Safety and Environment Management System (OCIMF Guidance Notes) Conclusion: MOST IMPORTANT
4
SHIPYARD SELECTION Geographical location, size of ship, economics and knowledge of a Yards ability are obviously major factors to be taken into account during the selection of a Shipyard. However, because of the potential impact on Companys personnel and assets, the manner, in which a Yard manages and controls the safety of repair operations should receive particular attention during the selection process and as a part of the tender process. (Continues)
SHIPYARD SELECTION
OCIMF recommends that if a Company intends to assign a contract to carry out the work, whether construction or repair, it should be ensured that potential Shipyards have an HSE (Health, Safety and Environment) Policy and perform all work under a formal HSE Management System. This System should be adequately documented with an HSE Manual and be shown to be effective in implementing the aims and objectives of the Shipyard HSE Policy.
It is also recommended that during the shipyard selection process , Shipowners should undertake an audit of the shipyards, which includes their HSE Management Systems and available data on HSE performance.
MOST IMPORTANT
TO REALISE THAT SAFETY OF THE SHIP DURING REPAIRS IS A RESULT OF A COMBINED EFFORT OF TWO PARTIES
12
PART B
SHIPYARD SAFETY INFORMATION
OIL COMPANIES INTERNATIONAL MARINE FORUM (OCIMF)
13
LIST OF CONTENTS
A)INTRODUCTION 1. Essential Rules for Shipyard Safety 2. General Safety Considerations 3. Contractual Aspects of Safety B)PRIOR TO ENTRY INTO THE SHIPYARD 1. Arrival Condition 2. Removal of Oil Residues 3. Non Gas-Free Repairs 4. Verification of Ship Status 5. Fuel and Lubricating Oil Tanks
14
LIST OF CONTENTS
C)DURING REPAIRS IN THE SHIPYARD 1. Safety Factors 2. Initial Safety Information 3. Fire Fighting Capability 4. Ship Status Board 5. Atmosphere Monitoring 6. Status of Spaces 7. Permit to Work Systems 8. Combustible Materials and Solvents 9. Control of Industrial Gases 10. Safety Inspections 11. Staging and Scaffolding
15
LIST OF CONTENTS
12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. Personnel Lifting Equipment Lifting Equipment Smoking Regulations Ventilation and Lighting Subcontractors Transfer of Liquids Testing Equipment and Systems Earthing of Welding Equipment Access to the Ship Moorings Double Banking
16
LIST OF CONTENTS
D)COMMUNICATIONS 1. Managing Communications 2. Monitoring of Repair Activities 3. Daily Safety and Progress Meetings E)PERSONAL SAFETY 1. Management of Safety 2. House Keeping 3. Openings 4. Slip and Trip Hazards 5. Ladders and Walk Ways 6. Hazards from Above 7. Confined Space Entry 8. Personal Protective Equipment 9. Respiratory Protection
17
LIST OF CONTENTS
18
INTRODUCTION OCIMF ESSENTIAL RULES FOR SHIPYARD SAFETY To ensure that safety of both the ship and the personnel is maintained during a Shipyard repair or construction, it is essential that: Shipyard and Company personnel are conversant with each others systems and requirements All work is carefully coordinated so that there is no risk or danger from conflicting demands, and There is continuous communication between Shipyard and Company personnel in respect of all repair and Safety matters
19
OCIMF CONTRACTUAL ASPECTS OF SAFETY The repair Contract should clearly define certain key responsibilities in respect of Safety. As a minimum it should specify:
The arrival condition of the ship with respect to condition of cargo tanks etc. The Yards responsibility for certifying the status of all tanks and spaces and for maintaining and documenting this status throughout the repair period How fuel and lubricating oil tanks are identified Ship access requirements Allocation of Shipyard Safety and Medical support The Yards responsibility for assessing, supervising and monitoring all aspects of work prior to and after each individual job
20
OCIMF CONTRACTUAL ASPECTS OF SAFETY The Yards and Ships responsibility to properly isolate the work site from any potential hazards and to ensure that the work site remains properly isolated for the duration of the job The Yards responsibility for regular cleaning of and removal of debris especially hazardous material such as asbestos from the ship, The Yards responsibility to issue proper hot work and entry permits prior to commencing a job and for ensuring regular updating, The level of Safety awareness and particular Safety requirements that the Owner expects from the Shipyard.
21
24
safe for entry criteria are defined as: Oxygen content of 21% by volume Hydrocarbon vapours not more than 1% of the Lower Flammable Limit (LFL) and Toxic gases (e.g. hydrogen sulfide, etc.) below the relevant permissible exposure limit It is imperative that a qualified chemist inspect and certify the vessel to be gas free prior to entry into the Yard. It is important to note that this initial test may only be to verify that the status of the ship is suitable to enter the shipyard.
26
29
30
Safety Factors Once the ship is in the Yard, the main areas of concern with respect to safety are the following: Establishing and maintaining safe working conditions. Ensuring that all parties involved are aware of what work is being done, by whom, where and when. Securing the personal safety of the ships personnel and others. Ship officers and Yards Safety Staff should have the authority to stop any work which is considered unsafe. Shipyard should ensure that its personnel and contractors comply with all relevant national statutory requirements and approved codes of practice are complied with. Protection of the environment.
31
Ship Status Board The Yard should establish a protected location where an overall picture of work in progress can be easily determined by means of a status board which should indicate: Where work is being carried out The nature of the work (hot, blasting, chemical cleaning etc.) Who is doing the work (shipyard or ship personnel) The expected duration of the work What permits have been issued (hot work, confined entry, etc.) and are in effect
34
OCIMF SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS IN THE SHIPYARD DURING REPAIRS Atmosphere Monitoring The atmosphere of all tanks, pump-rooms and machinery spaces should be monitored at least once a day for oxygen, hydrocarbon gas and any toxic gases which may be present, by a competent and qualified person The results of these inspections should be clearly marked at each entrance and the central status board Ships staff should be alerted for opening of pipes lines or valves, introduction of chemicals or paints etc., which could make the atmosphere of the space hazardous or unhealthy Status of Spaces The status i.e. safe for entry, safe for hot work, do not enter etc. must be clearly displayed at each entrance and the central status board
35
OCIMF SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS IN THE SHIPYARD DURING REPAIRS Permit to Work Systems The Yards safety system should incorporate a permit to work system to control and coordinate key repair activities. This as a minimum, should address: The control of hot work The control of entry into tanks and other confined spaces The use of solvents and other flammable materials The control of pressure testing, transfer of hydrocarbons etc. The need to verify that opening of any system will not result in any release of liquids or vapours
Ships personnel should be advised of permit systems in use by the Yard and copies of the permits to be available in central board
36
Combustible Materials and Solvents Strict control should be maintained over the introduction of combustible materials into work sites Before any combustible or hazardous material is brought on board, the company representative should review its product hazard identification bulletin to confirm that hazards from both fire and health point are well understood Hot work must not be carried out in any space where combustible liquids or vapours are being used i.e. painting etc.
37
Control of Industrial Gases Company representatives should assure themselves that: A procedure should exist to assure the safety of main supply or bottled gas used for heating, gas welding or cutting Gas cylinders should be secured against accidental falling Hoses used for acetylene, liquefied flammable gas and oxygen are fitted with flash back arrestors and have been recently pressure tested Hoses should be deployed in a manner where they are not liable to physical damage and do not obstruct walkways Whenever there is a break, torches should be physically disconnected from hoses and hoses leading into a tank should be disconnected from the gas supply
38
Safety Inspections The Yard should have a system of regular inspections to ensure that safe working conditions are maintained including: Inspection of work areas during each shift The monitoring of unsafe acts A daily house keeping inspection to ensure that all walkways are clear from obstructions A regular inspection of all the gas hoses
39
Staging and Scaffolding The Yard should have procedures for scaffolding and staging standards including: The use of two course rails The use of toe boards The use of diagonal bracing Staging boards in good condition, not burnt or split The prevention of overload etc. The use of tags to indicate that scaffolds and staging are safe for use and for recording the regular inspections performed. Scrap steel and replacement steel not to be stored on scaffolding platforms
40
Personnel Lifting Equipment The Yard should be ready to present evidence to the Master that any lifting equipment such as lifts, cherry pickers etc. utilized by the company personnel or contractors:
Is certified for lifting personnel Is regularly inspected and tested and the Certficates/Approval of the inspections should be available Is operated by operators properly trained in its use Is marked with the permissible weight to be carried etc.
Lifting Equipment The Yard should have procedures which address: The regular maintenance, inspection and checking of the SWL of lifting wires, slings, chain blocks, shackles etc. Safe lifting practices The marking of equipment with its SWL
41
Smoking and Alcohol Consumption Regulations Smoking should be prohibited except in specifically identified areas. Ships personnel should observe these restrictions. The consumption of alcohol during working periods should be discouraged Ventilation and Lighting Adequate ventilation and safe lighting should be provided and maintained in all work sites. Subcontractors The Yard safety management system should include procedures to ensure that subcontractors employed by both Yard and Ship will comply with the yards requirements The Master and Company should advise the Yard where work is to be carried out by contract personnel
42
Transfer of Liquids Ship and Yard personnel should be aware of any transfer of liquids (ballast, fuel, lubricants) within the ship and proper notification should be given to any potentially affected work activities Loading of fuel and lubricating oil in bulk should be avoided. If this is not possible then all hot work activities should be suspended until loading is completed Testing Equipment and Systems It is essential that both ship and yard personnel are aware of all tests which are to be carried out and coordinate their activities All systems should be visually inspected by ships personnel prior to commencement of the test
43
Earthing of Welding Equipment The shipyard must ensure that all transformers for arcwelding equipment are adequately earthed Access to Ship There should always be two separate points of access located as far apart as practicable and where possible on opposite sides and ends of the ship Where gangways are used a safety net should be positioned beneath each gangway, unless fully enclosed Cutting a side opening should be considered, if necessary
44
Moorings The ship should be securely moored throughout the repair period. The yard should have a system for mooring lines to be tightened if required. Both ship and yard should monitor the moorings on a regular basis to meet any adverse weather conditions. Double Banking In case double banking is necessary, although not desirable, the Master and Company should be advised of any repair activities on the other ship which might affect safety of their own ship and personnel A clear way should be marked across the deck of the vessel being crossed
45
COMMUNICATIONS
Managing Communications The Company representative must ensure that communication links between the yard staff, ships personnel and Companys contractors are well established and maintained throughout to avoid conflict between jobs. Battery operated equipment such as mobile phones and pagers represent a potential ignition source and their use on the worksite should be regulated.
Monitoring of Repair Activity Ships personnel should closely monitor all repair activities undertaken by the yard and report to the repair manager any infringements of safety requirements Conversely the yard should be invited to monitor all work being carried out by ships personnel
46
Daily meetings on Board should be attended by: The Ship Repair Manager Ship Officers and Supervisory personnel Yards Supervisory personnel Yards and Companys Subcontractors Yards Safety Officer and Safety Staff
47
DAILY SAFETY AND PROGRESS MEETINGS The purpose of the meeting is to: Verify the ship gas status and the validity of gas free certificates Review all work permits which have been issued Coordinate all work done by the Yard, contractors and ships crew in order to ensure that safe working conditions prevail in all areas Review all systems and equipment tests and coordinate these Define priorities in case a conflict exists between various activities Identifying the locations where blasting or painting is carried out
48
DAILY SAFETY AND PROGRESS MEETINGS Identify the pipes or valves which have to be dismantled within areas where people are working Verify that opening of lines or valves will not result in the flow of fluids into an area where safety might be compromised Review all system or equipment tests and coordinate these Inform vessels crew of any ultrasonic, X-ray or hydrostatic testing which has to be done during the day Discuss any violation of safety measures noticed during the previous day, identify the cause of the incident and the action to be taken to prevent reoccurrence Confirm any changes in location of all bulk liquids on board including ballast, bunkers and slops Review any own or other vessel movements that could impact on safety or progress of the repairs
49
PERSONAL SAFETY
Management of Safety A ship in a shipyard presents unique combination of hazards in addition to the routine on board hazards, therefore all ship and Company personnel must be particularly diligent about ensuring their safety and contractors. House Keeping The Master and Company representatives should establish house keeping standards in conjunction with the shipyard. These standards should include: Maintaining walkways clear of hoses, scrap steel and waste material Routine patrolling of work areas to maintain standards Keeping chemical and paint containers closed when not used Wiping up spilled oil or water etc.
50
PERSONAL SAFETY
Openings Substantial guards and notices around or over each and every opening (tank cleaning openings, access holes etc.) should be used. Slip and Trip Hazards Risks from slippery surfaces due to cargo residues, water etc. or hazardous due to scrap metals, welding rods, dunnage etc. should be minimized through use of good housekeeping Ladders and Walkways All personnel should verify that ladders and handrails are safe to use, properly secured and that their footing is secured
51
PERSONAL SAFETY
Hazards from Above Ship and Yard personnel should be alert to the threat of falling objects. Safety helmets should be worn by all personnel at all times that work is in progress. Confined Space Entry Entry into tanks and confined spaces should be carefully controlled for atmospheric conditions and means of rescue. A personnel tracking system for any ship or Company personnel entering a tank or a confined space should be established by either the shipyard or the Master.
52
PERSONAL SAFETY
Personal Protective Equipment The Master and Company representative should insist that ships personnel and all contractors wear appropriate PPE including boiler suits, gloves, safety footwear, helmets, safety spectacles and hearing protection in areas exceeding 85dbA. Respiratory Protection If the work being done causes contamination of the atmosphere by material that is inhalation hazard (asbestos, paint mist, boiler cleaning chemicals, blasting dust etc.) respiratory protection should be worn. Use of sand for blasting is not acceptable.
53
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
Particular attention should be paid to ensure that environment pollution does not occur during shipyard repair period. Issues to be addressed should include: All tank cleaning residues, including slops and tank sludge, must be disposed of properly in accordance with governmental regulations and MARPOL 73/78 Deck scuppers are plugged or led to reception facilities Any and all transfers of liquids within the ship are planned so as to avoid the accidental discharge of oil mixtures Opening of any system should not release any fluids or ozone depleting substances, and Ships sewage should be disposed of in accordance with governmental regulations and MAROL
54
COMPLETION OF REPAIRS
All personnel must be vigilant to ensure that all the ships systems have been restored to their optimum seagoing condition and properly recommissioned prior to final testing The recommissioning is the direct responsibility of the responsible officers on board, regardless of who carried out the repair work, and therefore ships personnel should establish prior to start up: That is safe to start the machinery The integrity of the machinery and any systems attached to it That there is adequate supply of fuel, lubrication, cooling water, etc. A Hazard Analysis Form associated with the activity should be worked out.
55
COMPLETION OF REPAIRS
A predetermined machinery start up plan should be worked out to establish: The respective responsibilities of yard and ships personnel The appropriate protective equipment should be worn Prior to refloating from a dry dock, ships personnel should carry out an external examination to ensure that all openings in the hull are properly secured
56
OCIMF CHECKLISTS
Control of Industrial Gases Fire Fighting Capability House Keeping Lifting Equipment Loading/Transfer of Liquids Permit To Work System Scaffolding/Staging Site safety Ship Repair Pre-Docking Hot Work Non-Gas Free Pre-Test FAT and Offsite Inspection
57
Is equipment , including rigging, marked with its maximum safe working load (SWL)?
Is the equipment regularly inspected and tested?
Is all equipment including lifting wires, slings, chain blocks, shackles and associated equipment regularly inspected and proof tested?
Are crane fail-safe devices and limit switches regularly tested? Are safe lifting practices in use?
58
Emergency exit/access from/to ship in place and maintained (two routes at opposite ends of worksite are recommended)
Openings in decks platforms and other structures are to be properly and adequately indicated and fenced (including corroded areas that will no longer support any weight). Adequate guarding must be in place at sides and ends of raised platforms. Particular attention should be paid to the removal of ship side rails and rails in the engine room. Lighting in all areas should be adequate. Note: Slips, trips and falls mainly occur due to bad lighting. Is all waste including scrap steel, welding rod ends, rags and other waste, etc being removed from the worksite?
Are all chemical and paint containers closed when not in use?
Is split oil, chemical and/ot water mopped up? Hazardous materials. e/g/ asbestos, chemicals, radio active materials etc, should be handled in a safe and controlled manner
59
Comment
Are all scaffolds/stages suitably tagged to indicate that they are safe for use and for recording the regular inspections?
Has scaffolding been inspected and passed by competent inspectors from a recognised body?
Are safety nets rigged when required? Are the staging boards in good condition, i.e. Not burnt or split? Are scaffolding platforms free from scrap and replacement steel? Is securing of the access ladders and maximum heights of straight run ladders without safety rails or rest platforms within the standards required? Steel tube scaffolding not used for earthing welding equipment? Is there a system to prevent overloading of the scaffold/staging?
60
61
List of References
1. OCIMF Shipyard Safety Information Final Draft Paper, 1997 2. OCIMF Health, Safety and Environment at Newbuilding and Repair Shipyards, 2003 3. International Safety Guide for Oil Tankers and Terminals, ISGOTT 1996 4. A.C. Antoniou, Safety of Ships in Yards during Repairs , Training Course for Shipping Companies.
62
63