United States Bankruptcy Court Western District of Texas San Antonio Division

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT

WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS


SAN ANTONIO DIVISION
In re:
DELTA PRODUCE, L.P.,
Debtors,
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
Chapter 11
Case No.: 12-50073-LMC

Jointly Administered
Hon. Leif M. Clark
KINGDOM FRESH GROUPS RESPONSE TO
SPECIAL PACA COUNSELS CLAIMS
Kingdom Fresh Produce, Inc. (Kingdom Fresh), I. Kunik Company, Inc. (I. Kunik) and
Five Brothers Jalisco Produce Co. Inc d/b/a Bonanza 2001 (Five Brothers) (collectively the
Kingdom Fresh Group), through their undersigned counsel, and pursuant to Amended Order
Establishing a Deadline to File PACA Trust Claims, For Procedures To Resolve Those Claims (D.E.
#124)., responds to Special PACA Counsels Objections to Claims (D.E. # 159) and the R&Js
Group Omnibus Objections to Certain PACA Trust Claims (D.E. # 184)in connection with the
Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act, 7 U.S.C. 499a-t (the PACA), and in support of such,
the Kingdom Fresh Group states as follows:
I. KINGDOM FRESHS RESPONSE TO SPECIAL PACA COUNSELS OBJECTIONS TO
PACA PROOF OF CLAIM
Kingdom Fresh concedes certain aspects of Special PACA Counsels objection. First, the
offset of $3,545.00 owed to Delta is valid. Second, the claim of $3,696.00 on invoice #10524 is
valid. Third, to Kingdom Freshs ability to recover 6% per annum pre-judgment interest pursuant
to Tex.Fin.Code 302.002. Kingdom Fresh consents to the modified PACA trust amount of
$62,327.00 including its right to statutory interest of 6% APR.
12-50073-lmc Doc#207 Filed 04/16/12 Entered 04/16/12 17:33:18 Main Document Pg 1 of
4
2
II. I. KUNIKS RESPONSE TO SPECIAL PACA COUNSELS OBJECTIONS TO PACA
PROOF OF CLAIM
Counsel for the Kingdom Fresh Group and Special PACA Counsel discussed the objection
to I. Kuniks claim for costs associated with pallets and temperature recording used to ship wholesale
quantities of perishable agricultural commodities ("Produce") in interstate commerce to Delta. Special
PACA Counsel agrees to withdraw the objection and allow I. Kunik to collect the costs associated
with the sale of Produce. Attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit A is Special PACA
Counsels confirming the withdrawal of the objection. Special PACA Counsel never filed any
objection to other parts of I. Kuniks claim on or before the March 22, 2012 deadline. Therefore
I.Kunik is entitled to a valid PACA trust claim for $22,779.52, including contractual interest at 18%
per annum and its contractual right to attorneys fees and costs.
III. FIVE BROTHERS RESPONSE TO SPECIAL PACA COUNSELS OBJECTIONS TO
PACA PROOF OF CLAIM
Five Brothers consents to the statutory pre-judgment interest rate of 6% APR., pursuant to
Tex.Fin.Code 302.002. Special PACA Creditor and the R&Js Group objected to Five Brothers
right to attorneys fees is wholly without merit because Five Brothers does not have a contractual
right to attorneys fees. Five Brothers consent to the modified claim amount of $32,534.84,
including statutory interest at the rate of 6% APR.
12-50073-lmc Doc#207 Filed 04/16/12 Entered 04/16/12 17:33:18 Main Document Pg 2 of
4
3
WHEREFORE the Kingdom Fresh Group requests this Honorable Court to deny Special
PACA Counsels objections and grant; (1) Kingdom Freshs modified claim of $62,327.00 including
its right to statutory interest of 6% APR; (2) I.Kunks claim of $22,779.52, including contractual
interest at 18% APR and collection costs, including attorneys fees; (3)Five Brothers modified claim
amount of $32,534.84, including statutory interest at the rate of 6% APR, and; (4) provide such other
and further relief as the Court deems appropriate upon consideration of this matter.
Date:April 16, 2012 Respectfully submitted,
KINGDOM FRESH PRODUCE, INC.,
I.KUNIK CO., INC., and FIVE BROTHERS
JALISCO PRODUCE CO. INC d/b/a
BONANZA 2001
By: /s/ Kevin P. Kelley
One of Their Attorneys
Kevin P. Kelley, Esq.
KEATON & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
1278 W. Northwest Highway, Suite 903
Palatine, Illinois 60067
Tel: 847/934-6500
Fax: 847/ 934-6508
Email: [email protected]
Louis T. Rosenberg, Esq.
LAW OFFICES OF LOUIS T.
ROSENBERG, P.C.
De Mazieres Building
322 Martinez Street
San Antonio, Texas 78205
Tel: 210/ 225-5454
Fax: 210/ 225-5450
E-mail: [email protected]
12-50073-lmc Doc#207 Filed 04/16/12 Entered 04/16/12 17:33:18 Main Document Pg 3 of
4
4
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on April 16, 2012, I electronically filed the foregoing with the Clerk of the
Court using the CM/ ECF system which will send a notice of electronic filing to all parties of record.
By: /s/ Kevin P. Kelley
Kevin P. Kelley, Esq. - IL Bar #6304839
KEATON & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
1278 W. Northwest Highway, Suite 903
Palatine, Illinois 60067
Tel: 847/934-6500
Fax: 847/934-6508
E-Mail: [email protected]
12-50073-lmc Doc#207 Filed 04/16/12 Entered 04/16/12 17:33:18 Main Document Pg 4 of
4
12-50073-lmc Doc#207-1 Filed 04/16/12 Entered 04/16/12 17:33:18 Exhibit Special PACA
Counsel Withdrawl Pg 1 of 2
04/12/2012 03:23 2108222595
STOKES LAW OFFICE LP
LAW OFFICE, LLP
9155 s. Blvd.
Centre, Suite 1208
Miami, Fl33155
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
VOice 305.447,5655
rax 305.447,8855

Via E-Mail [email protected]
Via Facsimile (847) 934-6508
Kevin P. Kelley, Esq.
Keaton & Associates, P .C.
April 12, 2012
1278 WNorthwest Highway, Suite 903
Palatine, IL 60067
Re: In re Delta Produce, L..P.
Objection to I. Kunik Inc.' PACA Proof of Claim.
Dear Mr. Kelley:
PAGE D2.iD'2
3330 Oakwell Court
Suite 2.25
5.1in Antonio, Texas 78218
voice 210.804.0011
fax 210.822.2595
www.stok.:!!Siawofl'lco.:.com
We will withdraw our objection as to temperature recorders and pallets. We do not
withdraw the objection to the claim for attorney's fees as Judge Clark's order calls for such
claims to be brought later in the proceedings. This objection was made as to all claimants.
If you need another copy of Judge Clark's order, please let me know and we will provide
one.
Very truly yours,
12-50073-lmc Doc#207-1 Filed 04/16/12 Entered 04/16/12 17:33:18 Exhibit Special PACA
Counsel Withdrawl Pg 2 of 2
04/12/2012 03:23 2108222595
STOKES LAW OFFICE LP
PAGE i [1:?
STOKES LAW OFFICE LLP
9155 South Dadeland Boulevard
Dadeland Suite 1208
Miami, FL 33156-2737
Telephone (305) 447-6655
Facsimile (305) 447-8855
Attorneys at Law
3330 Oakweil Court
Suite 225
San Antonio) TX 78218
Te]ephone (21 0) 804-0011
Facsimile (210) 822-2595
FACSIMILE TRANSMISSION
FROM: Craig A. Stokes Date: April12, 2012
RE: In re Delta Produce, L.P. Pages (Including Cover Sheet): :z..
NAME FACSIMILE NUMBER TELEPHONE NUMBER
MR. KEVIN KELLEY (847) 934-6508 (847) 934-6500
MESSAGE:
ORIGINAL: _Mailed _By Courier in File
Note: If you do not receive the correct number of pages, please call (21 0) 804-0011 as soon as possible.
This transmission is intended for the exclusive use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed. It may contain
infonnation that is privileged, confidential and exempt from disclosure under appl.icable law. If the reader of the
message is not the intended recipient. or the employee or agent responsible for deliverins the message to the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying ofthis communication is strictly pro-
hibited and may result in legal sanctions.
i

You might also like