ACS - Standard Costing
ACS - Standard Costing
ACS - Standard Costing
STANDARD COSTS
TRUE-FALSE STATEMENTS
1. Inventories cannot be valued at standard cost in financial statements.
4. Standard costs may be incorporated into the accounts in the general ledger.
5. An advantage of standard costs is that they simplify costing of inventories and reduce
clerical costs.
8. Actual costs that vary from standard costs always indicate inefficiencies.
9. Ideal standards will generally result in favorable variances for the company.
10. Normal standards incorporate normal contingencies of production into the standards.
11. Once set, normal standards should not be changed during the year.
12. In developing a standard cost for direct materials, a price factor and a quantity factor must
be considered.
13. A direct labor price standard is frequently called the direct labor efficiency standard.
14. The standard predetermined overhead rate must be based on direct labor hours as the
standard activity index.
15. Standard cost cards are the subsidiary ledger for the Work in Process account in a
standard cost system.
16. A variance is the difference between actual costs and standard costs.
17. If actual costs are less than standard costs, the variance is favorable.
18. A materials quantity variance is calculated as the difference between the standard direct
materials price and the actual direct materials price multiplied by the actual quantity of
direct materials used.
19. An unfavorable labor quantity variance indicates that the actual number of direct labor
hours worked was greater than the number of direct labor hours that should have been
worked for the output attained.
8- Test Bank for Managerial Accounting, Second Edition
2
20. Standard cost + price variance + quantity variance = Budgeted cost.
21. The overhead controllable variance relates primarily to fixed overhead costs.
22. The overhead volume variance relates only to fixed overhead costs.
23. If production exceeds normal capacity, the overhead volume variance will be favorable.
24. There could be instances where the production department is responsible for a direct
materials price variance.
25. The starting point for determining the causes of an unfavorable materials price variance is
the purchasing department.
*28. A credit to a Materials Quantity Variance account indicates that the actual quantity of
direct materials used was greater than the standard quantity of direct materials allowed.
*29. A standard cost system may be used with a job order cost system but not a process cost
system.
*30. A debit to the Overhead Volume Variance account indicates that the standard hours
allowed for the output produced was greater than the standard hours at normal capacity.
Item Ans. Item Ans. Item Ans. Item Ans. Item Ans. Item Ans.
1. F 6. F 11. F 16. T 21. F 26. T
2. F 7. T 12. T 17. T 22. T 27. T
3. T 8. F 13. F 18. F 23. T *28. F
4. T 9. F 14. F 19. T 24. T *29. F
5. T 10. T 15. F 20. F 25. T *30. F
Performance Evaluation Through Standard Costs 8-3
35. Budget data are not journalized in cost accounting systems with the exception of
a. the application of manufacturing overhead.
b. direct labor budgets.
c. direct materials budgets.
d. cash budget data.
40. Which of the following is not considered an advantage of using standard costs?
a. Standard costs can reduce clerical costs.
b. Standard costs can be useful in setting prices for finished goods.
c. Standard costs can be used as a means of finding fault with performance.
d. Standard costs can make employees "cost-conscious."
41. If a company is concerned with the potential negative effects of establishing standards,
they should
a. set loose standards that are easy to fulfill.
b. offer wage incentives to those meeting standards.
c. not employ any standards.
d. set tight standards in order to motivate people.
42. A standard which represents an efficient level of performance that is attainable under
expected operating conditions is called a(n)
a. ideal standard.
b. loose standard.
c. tight standard.
d. normal standard.
44. The final decision as to what standard cost should be is the responsibility of
a. the quality control engineer.
b. the managerial accountants.
c. the purchasing agent.
d. management.
45. The labor time requirements for standards may be determined by the
a. sales manager.
b. product manager.
c. industrial engineers.
d. payroll department manager.
53. The direct labor quantity standard is sometimes called the direct labor
a. volume standard.
b. effectiveness standard.
c. efficiency standard.
d. quality standard.
54. A manufacturing company would include setup and downtime in their direct
a. materials price standard.
b. materials quantity standard.
c. labor price standard.
d. labor quantity standard.
8- Test Bank for Managerial Accounting, Second Edition
6
55. Allowance for spoilage is part of the direct
a. materials price standard.
b. materials quantity standard.
c. labor price standard.
d. labor quantity standard.
56. The total standard cost to produce one unit of product is shown
a. at the bottom of the income statement.
b. at the bottom of the balance sheet.
c. on the standard cost card.
d. in the Work in Process Inventory account.
58. If actual direct material costss are greater than standard direct materials costs, it means that
a. actual costs were calculated incorrectly.
b. the actual unit price of direct materials was greater than the standard unit price of direct
materials.
c. the actual unit price of raw materials or the actual quantities of raw materials used was
greater than the standard unit price or standard quantities of raw materials expected.
d. the purchasing agent or the production foreman is inefficient.
59. If actual costs are greater than standard costs, there is a(n)
a. normal variance.
b. unfavorable variance.
c. favorable variance.
d. error in the accounting system.
61. A company developed the following per-unit standards for its product: 2 pounds of direct
materials at $6 per pound. Last month, 1,000 pounds of direct materials were purchased
for $5,700. The direct materials price variance for last month was
a. $5,700 favorable.
b. $300 favorable.
c. $150 favorable.
d. $300 unfavorable.
62. The per-unit standards for direct materials are 2 gallons at $4 per gallon. Last month,
5,600 gallons of direct materials that actually cost $21,200 were used to produce 3,000
units of product. The direct materials quantity variance for last month was
a. $1,600 favorable.
b. $1,200 favorable.
c. $1,600 unfavorable.
d. $2,800 unfavorable.
Performance Evaluation Through Standard Costs 8-7
63. The per-unit standards for direct labor are 2 direct labor hours at $12 per hour. If in
producing 1,200 units, the actual direct labor cost was $25,600 for 2,000 direct labor
hours worked, the total direct labor variance is
a. $960 unfavorable.
b. $3,200 favorable.
c. $2,000 unfavorable.
d. $3,200 unfavorable.
64. The standard rate of pay is $10 per direct labor hour. If the actual direct labor payroll was
$39,200 for 4,000 direct labor hours worked, the direct labor price (rate) variance is
a. $800 unfavorable.
b. $800 favorable.
c. $1,000 unfavorable.
d. $1,000 favorable.
65. The standard number of hours that should have been worked for the output attained is
8,000 direct labor hours and the actual number of direct labor hours worked was 8,400. If
the direct labor price variance was $4,200 unfavorable, and the standard rate of pay was
$9 per direct labor hour, what was the actual rate of pay for direct labor?
a. $8.50 per direct labor hour
b. $7.50 per direct labor hour
c. $9.50 per direct labor hour
d. $9.00 per direct labor hour
73. A company uses 6,300 pounds of materials and exceeds the standard by 300 pounds.
The quantity variance is $900 unfavorable. What is the standard price?
a. $1.00.
b. $2.00.
c. $3.00.
d. Cannot be determined from the data provided.
74. A company purchases 15,000 pounds of materials. The materials price variance is $3,000
favorable. What is the difference between the standard and actual price paid for the
materials?
a. $1.00.
b. $.20.
c. $5.00.
d. Cannot be determined.
75. A company uses 20,000 pounds of materials for which they paid $4.50 a pound. What is
the materials price variance?
a. $.50.
b. $1.00.
c. $2.50.
d. Cannot be determined from the data provided.
76. If the materials price variance is $1,200 F and the materials quantity and labor variances
are each $900 U, what is the total materials variance?
a. $1,200 F
b. $900 U
c. $300 F
d. $1,350 U
Performance Evaluation Through Standard Costs 8-9
86. An overhead volume variance is calculated as the difference between normal capacity
hours and standard hours allowed
a. times the total predetermined overhead rate.
b. times the predetermined variable overhead rate.
c. times the predetermined fixed overhead rate.
d. divided by actual number of hours worked.
87. Manufacturing overhead costs are applied to work in process on the basis of
a. actual hours worked.
b. standard hours allowed.
c. ratio of actual variable to fixed costs.
d. actual overhead costs incurred.
89. If the standard hours allowed are less than the standard hours at normal capacity,
a. the overhead volume variance will be unfavorable.
b. variable overhead costs will be underapplied.
c. the overhead controllable variance will be favorable.
d. variable overhead costs will be overapplied.
92. The overhead controllable variance is calculated as the difference between actual
overhead costs incurred and the budgeted
a. overhead costs for the standard hours allowed.
b. overhead costs applied to the product.
c. overhead costs at the normal level of activity.
d. fixed overhead costs.
Performance Evaluation Through Standard Costs 8-11
93. If the standard hours allowed are less than the standard hours at normal capacity, the
volume variance
a. cannot be calculated.
b. will be favorable.
c. will be unfavorable.
d. will be greater than the controllable variance.
94. The budgeted overhead costs for standard hours allowed and the overhead costs applied
to product are the same amount
a. for both variable and fixed overhead costs.
b. only when standard hours allowed is less than normal capacity.
c. for variable overhead costs.
d. for fixed overhead costs.
96. The difference between overhead budgeted and overhead applied is the
a. budget variance.
b. controllable variance.
c. total overhead variance.
d. volume variance.
97. The overhead variance that indicates whether plant facilities were efficiently used is the
a. budget variance.
b. controllable variance.
c. spending variance.
d. volume variance.
98. Each of the following may cause an unfavorable controllable variance except
a. higher than expected use of indirect materials.
b. greater than expected use of indirect labor.
c. increases in indirect manufacturing costs.
d. inefficient use of direct labor.
99. The difference between actual overhead costs and overhead costs applied is the
a. budget variance.
b. controllable variance.
c. total overhead variance.
d. volume variance.
Item Ans. Item Ans. Item Ans. Item Ans. Item Ans. Item Ans. Item Ans.
31. c 43. c 55. b 67. b 79. a 91. b 103. d
32. c 44. d 56. c 68. d 80. d 92. a 104. a
33. d 45. c 57. d 69. c 81. c 93. c 105. a
34. a 46. b 58. c 70. b 82. c 94. c 106. d
35. a 47. c 59. b 71. b 83. b 95. b *107. d
36. b 48. a 60. a 72. c 84. a 96. d *108. d
37. a 49. d 61. b 73. c 85. b 97. d *109. b
38. d 50. a 62. a 74. b 86. c 98. d *110. c
39. c 51. c 63. b 75. d 87. b 99. c
40. c 52. c 64. b 76. c 88. b 100. c
41. b 53. c 65. c 77. b 89. a 101. b
42. d 54. d 66. a 78. a 90. c 102. b
8- Test Bank for Managerial Accounting, Second Edition
1
4 EXERCISES
Ex. 111
Betty Short manufactures and sells a nutrition drink for children. She wants to develop a standard
cost per gallon. The following are required for production of a 100-gallon batch:
1,960 ounces of lime Kool-Drink at $.15 per ounce
40 pounds of granulated sugar $.60 per pound
63 kiwi fruit at $.80 each
100 protein tablets at $.90 each
4,000 ounces of water at $.0025 per ounce
Betty estimates that 2% of the lime Kool-Drink is wasted, 20% of the sugar is lost, and 10% of the
kiwis cannot be used.
Instructions
Compute the standard cost of the ingredients for one gallon of the nutrition drink.
Ex. 112
The following direct labor data pertain to the operations of Laird Manufacturing Company for the
month of November:
Actual labor rate $9.20 per hr.
Actual hours used 10,000
Standard labor rate $9.00 per hr.
Standard hours allowed 9,500
Instructions
Prepare a matrix and calculate the labor variances.
Performance Evaluation Through Standard Costs 8-15
Total
Labor Variance
$2,000 U $4,500 U
Total
Labor Variance
$6,500 U
8- Test Bank for Managerial Accounting, Second Edition
1
6 Ex. 113
The following direct materials data pertain to the operations of Jenson Manufacturing Company
for the month of December.
Standard materials price $5.00 per pound
Actual quantity of material purchased and used 16,400 pounds
The standard cost card shows that a finished product contains 4 pounds of material. The 16,400
pounds were purchased in December at a discount of 5% from the standard price. In December,
4,000 units of finished product were manufactured.
Instructions
Prepare a matrix for materials and calculate the materials variances.
Total
Materials Variance
Total
Materials Variance
$2,100 F
Performance Evaluation Through Standard Costs 8-17
Ex. 114
Sweet Dreams, Inc. makes down pillows. Each king pillow requires 4 pounds of down and takes .
3 hours of direct labor. The standard cost of the down used by Sweet Dreams is $8 per pound
and the standard labor cost is $10 per hour. In January, Sweet Dreams purchased 7,500 pounds
of down for $60,375. During the year, the company manufactured 2,000 king pillows. Payroll
reported a total of 740 direct labor hours at a cost of $7,030.
Instructions
a. Compute the materials price and quantity variances and indicate whether the variances are
favorable or unfavorable.
b. Compute the labor price and quantity variances and indicate whether the variances are
favorable or unfavorable.
Total
Materials Variance
$3,625 F
Total
Labor Variance
$1,030 U
(1) ($64,000 + $1,600) / $2
(2) ($65,600 – $1,640) / $32,800
Instructions
a. Calculate the materials quantity variance.
b. Calculate the actual price paid per foot of wood.
Total
Materials Variance
$40 F
Ex. 116
Cattybrook Brick Company makes fired clay bricks for construction. The company uses a
standard costing system that calls for 2.75 pounds of clay at $.10 per pound for each brick. The
standard cost for labor is .075 hour at $16 per hour for each brick. In September, Cattybrook
anticipates production to be at a level of 200,000 bricks. During September, Cattybrook
manufactured 201,000 bricks. The company purchased 553,000 pounds of clay at a cost of
$66,365. The cost of direct labor was $242,530 for 15,350 hours.
Instructions
a. Compute the materials price and quantity variances and indicate whether the variances are
favorable or unfavorable.
b. Compute the labor price and quantity variances and indicate whether the variances are
favorable or unfavorable.
Performance Evaluation Through Standard Costs 8-19
Total
Materials Variance
$11,035 F
Total
Labor Variance
$1,330 U
Ex. 117
Fryer Company has developed the following standard costs for its product for 2002:
FRYER COMPANY
Standard Cost Card
Product A
Cost Element Standard Quantity × Standard Price = Standard Cost
Direct materials 4 pounds $3 $12
Direct labor 3 hours 8 24
Manufacturing overhead 3 hours 4 12
$48
The company expected to produce 30,000 units of Product A in 2002 and work 90,000 direct
labor hours.
8- Test Bank for Managerial Accounting, Second Edition
2
0 Ex. 117 (cont.)
Actual results for 2002 are as follows:
• 31,000 units of Product A were produced.
• Actual direct labor costs were $759,000 for 92,000 direct labor hours worked.
• Actual direct materials purchased and used during the year cost $352,800 for 126,000
pounds.
• Actual variable overhead incurred was $155,000 and actual fixed overhead incurred was
$205,000.
Instructions
Compute the following variances showing all computations to support your answers. Indicate
whether the variances are favorable or unfavorable.
(a) Materials quantity variance.
(b) Total direct labor variance.
(c) Direct labor quantity variance.
(d) Direct materials price variance.
(e) Total overhead variance.
Ex. 118
Greene Company developed the following standard costs for its product for 2002:
GREENE COMPANY
Standard Cost Card
Instructions
Compute the following variances for Greene Company for 2002 and indicate whether the
variance is favorable or unfavorable.
1. Direct materials price variance.
2. Direct materials quantity variance.
3. Direct labor price variance.
4. Direct labor quantity variance.
5. Overhead controllable variance.
6. Overhead volume variance.
Ex. 119
American Sporting Goods Company manufactures aluminum baseball bats that it sells to
university athletic departments. It has developed the following per unit standard costs for 2002
for each baseball bat:
Manufacturing
Direct Materials Direct Labor Overhead
Standard Quantity 2 Pounds (Aluminum) 1/2 hour 1/2 hour
Standard Price $4.00 $10.00 $6.00
Unit Standard Cost $8.00 $5.00 $3.00
In 2002, the company planned to produce 40,000 baseball bats at a level of 20,000 hours of
direct labor.
Instructions
(a) Compute the following variances:
Direct materials price.
Direct materials quantity.
Direct labor price.
Direct labor quantity.
Total overhead variance.
*(b) Prepare the journal entries to record the transactions and events in 2002.
Performance Evaluation Through Standard Costs 8-23
Ex. 120
The standard cost of Product 245 manufactured by Starr Company includes 2 pounds of direct
materials at $5.00 per pound. During September, 40,000 pounds of direct materials are
purchased at a cost of $4.80 per pound, and 37,000 pounds of direct materials are used to
produce 19,000 units of Product 245.
Instructions
(a) Compute the materials price and quantity variances.
*(b) Journalize the purchase of the materials and the issuance of the materials, assuming a
standard cost system is used.
Ex. 121
Lankford Company's standard labor cost of producing one unit of product is 2 hours at the rate of
$14.00 per hour. During February, 38,500 hours of labor are incurred at a cost of $13.80 per
hour to produce 19,000 units of product.
Instructions
(a) Compute the labor price and quantity variances.
*(b) Journalize the incurrence of the labor costs and the assignment of direct labor to production,
assuming a standard cost system is used.
Performance Evaluation Through Standard Costs 8-25
Ex. 122
The following direct labor data pertain to the operations of Foster Manufacturing Company for the
month of November:
Standard labor rate $10.00 per hr.
Actual hours incurred and used 4,500
The standard cost card shows that 2.5 hours are required to complete one unit of product. The
actual labor rate incurred exceeded the standard rate by 10%. Two thousand units were manu-
factured in November.
Instructions
(a) Calculate the price, quantity, and total labor variances.
*(b) Journalize the entries to record the labor variances.
Total
Labor Variance
$500 F
8- Test Bank for Managerial Accounting, Second Edition
2
6 Solution 122 (cont.)
*(b) Factory Labor .............................................................................. 45,000
Labor Price Variance ................................................................... 4,500
Wages Payable .................................................................... 49,500
Ex. 123
Reagan Company planned to produce 25,000 units of product and work 100,000 direct labor
hours in 2002. Manufacturing overhead at the 100,000 direct labor hours level of activity was
estimated to be:
Variable manufacturing overhead $ 700,000
Fixed manufacturing overhead 300,000
Total manufacturing overhead $1,000,000
At the end of 2002, 26,000 units of product were actually produced and 107,000 actual direct
labor hours were worked. Total actual overhead costs for 2002 was $1,015,000.
Instructions
(a) Compute the total overhead variance.
(b) Compute the overhead controllable variance.
(c) Compute the overhead volume variance.
Ex. 124
Stone Company planned to produce 20,000 units of product and work at the 50,000 direct labor
hours level of activity for 2002. Manufacturing overhead at this level of activity and the
predetermined overhead rate is as follows:
Predetermined
Overhead Rate per
Direct Labor Hour
Variable manufacturing overhead $300,000 $6
Fixed manufacturing overhead 150,000 3
Total manufacturing overhead $450,000 $9
At the end of 2002, 22,000 units were actually produced and 53,700 direct labor hours were
actually worked. Total actual manufacturing overhead costs were $475,000.
Instructions
Using a two-variance analysis of manufacturing overhead, calculate the following variances and
indicate whether they are favorable or unfavorable:
(a) Overhead controllable variance.
(b) Overhead volume variance.
Ex. 125
The following information was taken from the annual manufacturing overhead cost budget of
Olson Company:
Variable manufacturing overhead costs $124,000
Fixed manufacturing overhead costs $93,000
Normal production level in direct labor hours 62,000
Normal production level in units 31,000
Instructions
(a) Compute the total, fixed, and variable predetermined manufacturing overhead rates.
(b) Compute the total, controllable, and volume overhead variances.
Ex. 126
Presented below is a flexible manufacturing budget for Waner Company, which manufactures fine
timepieces:
Activity Index:
Standard direct labor hours 2,000 3,200 3,600 4,000
Variable costs
Indirect materials $ 4,000 $ 6,400 $ 7,200 $ 8,000
Indirect labor 2,300 3,680 4,140 4,600
Utilities 3,200 5,120 5,760 6,400
Total variable 9,500 15,200 17,100 19,000
Fixed costs
Supervisory salaries 1,000 1,000 1,000 1,000
Rent 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000
Total fixed 4,000 4,000 4,000 4,000
Total costs $13,500 $19,200 $21,100 $23,000
Instructions
(a) Compute the controllable and volume overhead variances.
*(b) Prepare the entries for manufacturing overhead during the period and the entry to recognize
the overhead variances at the end of the period.
Ex. 127
Voss Company uses a standard cost accounting system. During March, 2002, the company
reported the following manufacturing variances:
Material price variance $2,000 F
Material quantity variance 2,400 U
Labor price variance 800 U
Labor quantity variance 1,200 U
Overhead controllable 500 F
Overhead volume 3,000 U
In addition, 15,000 units of product were sold at $18 per unit. Each unit sold had a standard cost
of $12. Selling and administrative expenses for the month were $10,000.
Instructions
Prepare an income statement for management for the month ending March 31, 2002.
Variances:
Materials price ............................................................................. $(2,000)
Materials quantity ........................................................................ 2,400
Labor price .................................................................................. 800
Labor quantity .............................................................................. 1,200
Overhead controllable ................................................................. (500)
Overhead volume ........................................................................ 3,000
Total variances (unfavorable) ............................................. 4,900
Gross profit (actual) .............................................................................. 85,100
Selling and administrative expenses .................................................... 10,000
Net income ........................................................................................... $ 75,100
*Ex. 128
Norris Company developed the following standards for 2002:
NORRIS COMPANY
Standard Cost Card
The company planned to produce 30,000 units of product and work at the 30,000 direct labor
level of activity in 2002. The company uses a standard cost accounting system which records
standard costs in the accounts and recognizes variances in the accounts at the earliest
opportunity. During 2002, 29,000 actual units of product were produced.
Instructions
Prepare the journal entries to record the following transactions for Norris Company during 2002.
(a) Purchased 147,000 pounds of raw materials for $4.90 per pound on account.
(b) Actual direct labor payroll amounted to $527,000 for 28,500 actual direct labor hours
worked. Factory labor cost is to be recorded and distributed to production.
(c) Direct materials issued for production amounted to 147,000 pounds which actually cost
$4.90 per pound.
(d) Actual manufacturing overhead costs incurred were $288,000 in 2002.
(e) Manufacturing overhead was applied when the 29,000 units were completed.
(f) Transferred the 29,000 completed units to finished goods.
130. Standards which represent optimum performance under perfect operating conditions are
called _______________ standards, but most companies use _________________
standards which are rigorous but attainable.
131. In developing a standard cost for direct materials used in making a product, consideration
should be given to two factors: (1) __________________ per unit of direct materials and
(2) the __________________ of direct materials to produce one unit of product.
132. The difference between actual hours times the actual pay rate and actual hours times the
standard pay rate is the labor _________________ variance.
133. The standard number of hours allowed times the predetermined overhead rate is the
amount of ________________ to the products produced.
134. The difference between actual quantity of materials times the standard price and standard
quantity times the standard price is the materials ________________ variance.
135. If the actual direct labor hours worked is greater than the standard hours, the labor
quantity variance will be ___________________, and the labor rate variance will be
____________________ if the standard rate of pay is greater than the actual rate of pay.
136. A two-variance approach to analyzing overhead variances requires the calculation of the
overhead _________________ variance and the overhead ________________ variance.
137. The overhead ______________ variance is the difference between total overhead
budgeted and total overhead applied.
138. In using variance reports, top management normally looks for _________________
variances.
MATCHING
139. Match the items in the two columns below by entering the appropriate code letter in the
space provided.
____ 1. The difference between actual overhead incurred and overhead budgeted for the
standard hours allowed.
____ 2. The hours that should have been worked for the units produced.
____ 3. The difference between the actual quantity times the actual price and the actual
quantity times the standard price.
____ 4. The difference between total actual costs and total standard costs.
____ 5. The difference between actual hours times the standard rate and standard hours times
the standard rate.
____ 7. The difference between overhead budgeted for the standard hours allowed and the
overhead applied.
____ 8. Standards based on an efficient level of performance that are attainable under
expected operating conditions.
____ 9. Standards based on the optimum level of performance under perfect operating
conditions.
____ 10. A double-entry system of accounting in which standard costs are used in making
entries and variances are recognized in the accounts.
Answers to Matching
1. H 6. B
2. J 7. I
3. F 8. D
4. A 9. E
5. G 10. C
8- Test Bank for Managerial Accounting, Second Edition
3
4 SHORT-ANSWER ESSAY QUESTIONS
S-A E 140
Rand Company computes variances as a basis for evaluating the performance of managers
responsible for controlling costs. For several months, the labor quantity variance has been
unfavorable. Briefly explain what could be causing the unfavorable labor quantity variance and
indicate what type of corrective action, if any, might be taken.
Solution 140
Since labor quantity variances relate to the efficiency of labor, the cause of an unfavorable
variance could be poor training, poor maintenance of machinery, fatigue, carelessness, or similar
problems that affect efficiency.
The management of Rand Company would need to identify the likely causes of the variance and
correct the situation with additional training, improved maintenance, better scheduling or similar
appropriate actions.
S-A E 141
In reviewing the activities of the Mixing Department for the month of June, the manager of the
department notices that there was an unfavorable materials price variance for the month and
there was an unfavorable materials quantity variance. Under what circumstances, if any, can the
responsibility for each variance be placed on (a) the purchasing department and (b) the
production department?
Solution 141
(a) Purchasing department. The investigation of a materials price variance usually begins with
this department. If the price standard has been properly set, purchasing is responsible.
However, it should be recognized that in a period of inflation, prices may rise faster than
expected. Also, there may be extenuating circumstances such as oil cartel price increases.
(b) Production department. Ordinarily, responsibility for an unfavorable quantity variance rests
with the department. For example, production is responsible if the variance is caused by
inexperienced workers, faulty machinery, or carelessness.
The production department may be responsible for an unfavorable price variance when the
materials must be ordered on a rush basis at a higher price than planned.
Performance Evaluation Through Standard Costs 8-35
The argument continued. Finally, the standards were prepared. All standards were prepared
according to normal expected performance, except that for materials, an ideal standard was
used. Mary, still maintaining the unfairness of the system, refused to hold her workers
accountable for materials quantity variances.
Required:
1. Are ideal standards unethical? Explain briefly.
2. Is it unethical for Mary to refuse to support the standards? Explain.
Solution 142
1. Ideal standards are not necessarily unethical. They may be used unethically, such as in the
case in which employees are denied bonuses or other rewards because of not meeting a
standard which was out of their reach. If they are used as a guide to maximum attainable
performance, however, and not tied directly to the reward system, they may be ethical.
2. It is unethical for Mary simply to refuse to accept a particular standard. However, if the
company intends to use the standard unethically, she may refuse to hold her workers
accountable while she pursues a permanent disposition of the matter. If she simply refuses to
accept it, she may be indirectly sabotaging the company by hindering it from accomplishing its
legitimate objectives. This would be unethical.
Required:
Write a short note to Mike explaining the probable cause of the unfavorable labor efficiency
variance.
8- Test Bank for Managerial Accounting, Second Edition
3
6 Solution 143
Mike,
Last month was a tough one for all of us, wasn't it? Your workers certainly did go
the extra mile, no doubt about it.
You asked about your efficiency variance. When we calculate it, we count the
number of hours it took to get good output. Since we had such high spoilage, we
got fewer units, but used more hours. That is why your efficiency variance was
negative. It does not imply that you didn't do your best. It just means that we
investigate to see what happened.
Good luck, and I hope this month is a better one for all of us.
(signed)