5 3 Gapss Review Artifact
5 3 Gapss Review Artifact
5 3 Gapss Review Artifact
PROFESSIONAL LEARNING- Professional learning is the means by which teachers, administrators and
other school and system employees acquire, enhance and refine the knowledge, skills, and commitment necessary to create and
support high levels of learning for all students.
Emergent
Operational
Page 1 of 24
Fully
Operational
All teachers participate in
learning teams throughout the
year and meet regularly to
plan for instruction (e.g.,
develop lesson plans, examine
student work, monitor student
progress). The collaborative
work is aligned with the school
improvement goals.
EVIDENCE: Subject areas/Grade levels should have the opportunity to collaboratively plan common performance
assessments through weekly planning days. Team meetings were originally on the school calendar. Currently
department heads are required to schedule the meetings, but admin does not follow up. There is an agenda all
departments are supposed to use. The meetings usually cover the agenda, however, actual development of lesson
plans, examining student work, or monitoring student progress as a department is not evident. Not everyone on the
team always attends meetings. Group expectations are not clear.
Quarterly collaboratively team meetings take place and include not only the grade level lead teachers, but also the
connections teachers and all administration.
RECOMMENDATIONS: The group should agree on a day to meet that works for everyones schedule. Designated
collaborative planning time should be protected, so no other meetings should be scheduled during that time frame. A
copy of the SIP to refer back to during planning would be helpful. Specific objectives should be laid out and assessed as
of whether they are being met. Lesson plans should be a group effort, and all should contribute to help with uniformity.
Summer work to develop common lesson plans.
Emergent
Operational
Page 2 of 24
Fully
Operational
The principal,
administrative team, and
other human resources
periodically support the
creation and maintenance
of an effective learning
community to support
teacher and student
learning. In key aspects of
the school, these
individuals work
collaboratively to reinforce
collaborative forms of
professional development
and learning for staff
members. Although this
process is operational, it
would improve if greater
emphasis were given to
monitoring its impact on
school improvement goals
and student achievement.
EVIDENCE: The administration verbally support learning communities and have it in writing that they support it,
however, they seldom attend meetings. On the small chance they show up they often have their own agenda. There is
an agenda to help create school structure, however professional development has not been provided- and is not
modeled by leadership. Professional learning opportunities are not directly aligned with the school improvement goals.
RECOMMENDATIONS: Train leaders in professional development how to facilitate collaborative learning. Offer
professional development on the collaborative process. Create a system to monitor impact of collaborative process.
Offer incentives, which would promote more teacher involvement in effective learning communities.
Page 3 of 24
Emergent
Operational
Fully
Operational
A variety of teachers take
advantage of opportunities to
participate in instructional
leadership development
experiences and serve in
instructional leadership roles
(e.g., instructional coach,
mentor, facilitator). They plan,
advocate for support of, and
articulate the benefits and
intended results of
professional learning.
EVIDENCE: Opportunities are offered through an application process for leadership roles. There are several
opportunities; however the feedback from the school leaders does not seem to influence the professional learning in the
school. Professional development is mandatory when they have it, however does not appear to be followed through on.
On an individual volunteer basis, classroom teachers who are proficient in technology will coach other colleagues in
implementing technology within their classrooms. Each grade level subject area has a representative on the Leadership
team. Other staff members are given leadership roles in different areas.
RECOMMENDATIONS: Create a Google form to record input- Create Professional Learning choices Have colleagues
recommend leadership roles- Ensure follow-up after implementing a new strategy or skill.
Page 4 of 24
Emergent
Operational
Fully
Operational
The principal and other
leaders support a school
culture that reflects ongoing
team learning and continuous
improvement. The principal
and other leaders plan for
high-quality professional
learning, articulate intended
results of school-based
professional learning, and
participate in professional
learning to become more
effective instructional leaders.
EVIDENCE: Team learning is supported through the creation of teams. The plan for implementation is lacking- direction
for teams and leaders of the team is unknown. In the Professional Learning Descriptors for the school, a course
competency listed is to provide models and enhance knowledge and implementation of instructional technology which
will have a goal alignment of having teachers collaborate in grade level meetings to evaluate student work and adjust
instruction. There is no follow up on how to do this. A school calendar lists all meetings scheduled but they often get
cancelled.
Page 5 of 24
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Professional learning opportunities should be directly connected to the School Improvement Plan and teachers should
understand the results that are expected to be achieved from professional learning. Have forms such as Table 7.2Critical Thinking Checklist (Knight, 2007, pg 153) or 7.1 Unit Organizer (p 154-155). Meetings should be scheduled with
feedback given by both the leaders on the teams, and the administration.
Page 6 of 24
Emergent
Operational
Fully
Operational
Teachers spend a significant
part of their work-week in jobembedded learning and
collaboration with colleagues
addressing curriculum,
assessment, instruction, and
technology. They receive
sufficient support resources
(e.g., materials, time, training)
and assist with securing
additional resources
necessary (e.g., funding, time,
technology) to sustain their
learning. (NSDC Standards
recommend that formal and
informal job-embedded
learning take place during at
least 25% of educators
professional time. Such time
can be devoted to lesson
study, peer observations and
coaching, modeling,
conferencing, teacher
meetings, mentoring.)
EVIDENCE: Common subject area teachers often meet unofficially to share ideas. Common planning is present for the
majority of the curriculum area team- Meetings have to take place after school due to not all teachers having the same
planning. During collaborative planning time, teachers work together to address curriculum, student learning concerns,
and common assessment data, but it is not consistently productive. RtI meet8insg take place monthly.
Page 7 of 24
RECOMMENDATIONS: Specific collaborative planning times need to be set. Common planning needs to be provided.
Peer observations with coverage to be offered- so teachers can see the subject area/grade level they teach, which cant
be done if the only time to observe is during common planning. There is an over-abundance of data collection which has
no meaning or relevance. The focus is not specific as there are too many concepts being looked at. Staff needs to stay
up to date about classroom and school wide data related to student outcomes.
Page 8 of 24
Emergent
Operational
Fully
Operational
Resources are allocated to
support job-embedded
professional learning that is
aligned with high-priority
school improvement goals and
technology supporting student
learning. There is sustained
commitment to ensuring that
these professional
development activities result
in successful classroom
implementation. There is also
a process in place to
determine the value-added of
key strategies and processes,
i.e., how they impact student
achievement and related
organizational short- and longrange goals.
EVIDENCE: For the most part, professional learning resources appear to focus on the needs listed in the school
improvement plan. PBIS is implemented school wide. Additional professional learning opportunities are offered both
after-school or off campus and are not job-embedded. The SIP isnt a widely spoken about document, so it is unknown
how much teachers actually refer to it when looking at PL.
RECOMMENDATIONS: An evaluation system for accountability needs to be in place to make certain that the professional
development strategies are being implemented, and document the impact it has on student achievement.
Page 9 of 24
Emergent
Operational
Teachers and/or
administrators work in
isolation or with limited
representation to review
student summative data and
determine student and adult
learning needs and goals.
Student and teacher data is
collected and analyzed at the
end of the year to monitor
the accomplishment of
classroom and school goals.
Page 10 of 24
Fully
Operational
Teachers and administrators
collaboratively analyze
disaggregated student
learning, demographic,
perception, and process data
to identify student and adult
learning needs and goals.
They continuously (minimum
of 4 times a year) collect and
analyze relevant student and
teacher data (e.g. action
research, analyzing student
work, classroom observations,
Awareness Walks, and
surveys) to monitor and revise
school and classroom
improvement strategies.
Accomplishments are
celebrated and results are
regularly reported to family
and community.
EVIDENCE: There is very little collaborative analysis of data. There is a data team; however there is no feedback from
them. The Data Team Process beginning at the school but is in the infant stages. Grade levels/subject areas present
their team-wide data quarterly. Current classroom data is collected at the end of the year in a TKES notebook to be
reviewed by administration. Previous years data are are posted in the staff hallway.
RECOMMENDATIONS: The focus need to be clearer with knowledge of what information is to be continuously. Information
needs to be presented to provide a model of what the data should look like. Common assessments should be created
prior to teaching the lesson, and determined to be used during weekly collaboration. Communication needs to be clear
in how to use the data to drive instruction.
Page 11 of 24
Emergent
Operational
Fully
Operational
The principal and other
leaders develop and
implement a comprehensive
plan for conducting ongoing
(both formative and
summative over a threetofive-year period)
evaluation of the impact of
professional development on
teacher practices and
student learning. Evaluation
also emphasizes changes in
school culture, organizational
structures, policies, and
processes. Teachers
contribute to the evaluation
by collecting and analyzing a
variety (student learning,
demographic, perception,
and process) of relevant
data. The plan specifies the
evaluation question(s), data
sources, data collection
methodology, and data
analysis processes.
EVIDENCE: A professional development plan is established and maintained through the School Strategic Plan. The plan
has not been accessible to teachers unless specifically requested. The evaluation of professional learning focuses on
participation and yearly standardized test scores; therefore, there is no evidence of change in teacher practice. Teachers
contribute by providing summative student data through a common assessment notebook which is collected at the end
of the year.
Page 12 of 24
RECOMMENDATIONS: The impact of the professional learning on teacher practices and student learning needs to be
monitored and evaluated to see effectiveness of PL. Evaluation questions need to be put into practice within the
professional learning plan, and teachers should see the benefits of the professional development. School staff needs to
stay knowledgeable about classroom and school wide data related to student outcomes. Data use should be used to
make instructional decisions and to communicate to stakeholders.
Page 13 of 24
Emergent
Operational
Fully
Operational
The principal and other
leaders demonstrate
advanced skills in
determining appropriate
research design, interpreting
research results, and
determining whether results
can be generalized. They
ensure that teachers and
community members learn
to use educational research.
They work with them to
conduct extensive reviews of
research to make informed
instructional decisions
regarding the adoption of
professional development
and school improvement
approaches.
EVIDENCE: School-wide instructional strategies are based on educational research of best practices. It is uncertain
where the research is derived from. Teachers have few opportunities to learn to use educational research and are
seemingly uninterested. Every new idea that passes is jumped on as being the best. There is not follow-up or
evaluation on whether the practice is based on data.
RECOMMENDATIONS: Teachers should be presented articles and different resources to have more opportunities to use
educational research on the instructional practices t are expected to use. There needs to be an extensive in-depth
review of the research before an informed instructional decision is made.
Page 14 of 24
Emergent
Operational
Page 15 of 24
Fully
Operational
Teachers participate in long-term
(two- to three-year period), indepth professional learning that
engages learning teams in a
variety of appropriate
professional development
designs including the use of
technology. The various designs
are aligned with the intended
improvement outcomes. They
include but are not limited to
extensive, follow-up support for
implementing new classroom
practices (e.g., collaborative
lesson design, professional
networks, analyzing student
work, problem solving sessions,
curriculum development,
coursework, action research, and
coaching with feedback). A major
focus of ongoing professional
development is a commitment to
maintaining and updating all
teachers knowledge and
understanding of the content
they are teaching and changes
occurring in their field(s).
EVIDENCE: Professional learning doesnt outwardly appear to have a specific focus, though there is professional learning
each year. Professional learning days, sessions, or workshops are provided on the same topic but the sessions do not
have follow up support, and the sessions are often fast paced and confusing to the ones who need extra coaching- They
are more of a lecture type setting rather than active learning. Teachers often learn the most through their own
experiences. For example, the school is working on a STEM program to become STEM certified, which accounts for some
PL. The STEM lessons are created and supplies bought but there is no carryover from the staff or follow up by admin.
RECOMMENDATIONS: Teachers should be offered follow up training that continues to reinforce their learning. If the focus
is to become a STEM accredited school, then teachers should be sufficiently trained before they are required to
implement STEM lessons within their classrooms. They should be provided with the opportunity to peer observe and
have the STEM projects modeled.
Page 16 of 24
Emergent
Operational
Fully
Operational
The principal and other leaders
align a variety of professional
development designs with
expected adult learning
outcomes (e.g., collaborative
lesson design, professional
networks, analyzing student
work, problem solving sessions,
curriculum development,
coursework, action research, and
coaching with feedback). They
ensure that teams of teachers
are engaged in long-term (twoto-three year period), in-depth
professional learning with
extensive school-based support
for the implementation of new
practices. They clearly
communicate the expectations
for implementation with
collaboratively developed rubrics
describing desired classroom
practices and communicate how
those practices connect to the
school improvement goals.
EVIDENCE: The School Strategic Plan is the guiding factor in the written professional development and has specific
outcomes in mind. The purported activities are aligned within the School Strategic Plan. However, the actual
implementation of the professional development is lacking. Expectations of implementation are not discussed and
minimal support is provided. Professional learning is usually short-lived with no connection or follow-up to the outcome
of using material from the professional development.
Page 17 of 24
RECOMMENDATIONS: Professional learning should be continual over a two to three year time frame. The intended
outcomes should be revisited throughout the year with data being used as evidence, and there should be follow up
dialogue to how the implementation of the strategies learned are working.
Page 18 of 24
Emergent
Operational
Professional development is
planned using research
about adult learning needs
and how individuals
experience the change
process. The professional
development sessions
demonstrate classroom
practices through videotapes
and simulations. The
experiences focus on
procedural learning -how to
do it- rather than on
developing deep
understanding of concepts
and problem solving
strategies. Some professional
development is specialized
for new and mentor
teachers.
Professional development is
planned using research
about adult learning needs
and individual and
organizational change
processes. The professional
development sessions
include modeling and
demonstrations of expected
classroom practices. The
experiences impact
teachers depth of
understanding enabling
them to use the new
strategies routinely. Some
professional development is
specialized to reflect career
stages of new teachers,
mentor teachers, and
teacher leaders.
Fully
Operational
Professional development
builds the capacity of the
staff to use research about
adult learning needs and
individual and organizational
change processes as they
implement new strategies.
Professional development
sessions consistently employ
the same instructional
strategies that are expected
to be used in their
classrooms. The experiences
impact teachers depth of
understanding enabling
them to solve problems and
adapt new strategies to
classroom circumstances.
Professional development is
differentiated to reflect
career stage needs and
interests (e.g., mentoring,
leading learning teams,
coaching, utilizing
technology, and curriculum
development).
EVIDENCE: Professional learning is presented in a practical procedural learning environment such as lectures instead of
using modeling and new strategies to teach adult learners, especially in regards to technology-related professional
learning. New Teacher Institute has training but not in technologyrelated areas. It is often not immediately relative to
what they need to be successful in the classroom.
Page 19 of 24
RECOMMENDATIONS: Professional learning needs to move beyond procedural learning and focus on implementing
strategies within the classroom. Research driven best practices should be used in presenting the professional learning to
teachers, as well as modeling the best practices we are focusing on for teachers to see.
Page 20 of 24
Emergent
Operational
Page 21 of 24
Fully
Operational
Teachers and administrators
have knowledge and skills to
monitor and improve group
processes (e.g., group
decision-making strategies,
stages of group development,
effective interaction skills, and
conflict resolution) that are
necessary to accomplish tasks
and satisfy the interpersonal
expectations of the
participants. As a result, the
school culture is characterized
by trust, collegiality, and
collective responsibility for
student learning where
colleagues work
collaboratively in established,
ongoing learning teams.
Technology (e.g., online
discussions, web casts, and
seminars, educational blogs,
listservs, downloadable
resources) is used to support
collegial interactions and to
ensure effective and sustained
implementation.
EVIDENCE: Group processes are supported by the teachers and administration, using effective interaction skill;
however, they lack skill in group process strategies needed for productive collaborative work. Teachers work on
collaborative teams but it is not effective and efficient. Though common planning times are supported and advocated
through the administration, not everyone on the team is actually assigned a common planning time. Technology
supports some collegial interactions. There is disconnect between teachers and administrators in their collective
responsible for student learning. Lesson sharing using technology such as Google, is seen throughout each grade level
RECOMMENDATIONS: As a school unit there needs to be more unity in effectively producing collaborative work. There
needs to be more collective responsibility between teachers and administrators need to make sure everyone
understands how we are interconnected with everything we do.
EVIDENCE: Classroom practices of teachers express high expectations of all students. Student academic needs are met
through differentiated classroom placement and further by differentiated lesson plans. Learning environments are safe
and all children are taught the code of conduct and are part of a PBIS program. The ESOL program is being expanded to
reach the cultural needs of the growing Hispanic population. All students are encouraged to be respectful, responsible
role models.
RECOMMENDATIONS: Continued professional learning should be provided that focuses on the cultural needs of all
students, i.e. ESOL, Sped, and African American children.
EVIDENCE: Teachers use an assortment of research based instructional strategies to promote student learning such as
guided reading and math, workshops, centers, and assistive technology as needed. Assessment strategies are varied
using differentiated testing items, rubrics, prompts, and performance tasks. Units and lesson plans are created in
somewhat of a collaborative manner. supporting your rating above
RECOMMENDATIONS: More collaboration amongst teachers in planning interdisciplinary units and should provide a
rationale for why specific instructional strategies and assessments are appropriate.
Page 22 of 24
EVIDENCE: Teachers are provided weekly common planning time for most teachers in common content areas. Due to
the schedules, there is some isolation and individual practice rather than a collaborative effort. Schedules were
planned with the focus to ensure teams teaching the same students meet together rather than the subject areas being
the focus. It does provide that grade level teams can work together collaboratively. Training is done large-scale, usually
full-staff trainings are provided during staff meetings (which may not meet all the needs of the participants).
RECOMMENDATIONS: Large-scale, full-staff trainings should be avoided as much as possible and replaced with
professional learning that meets the needs of teachers. Teachers weekly collaborative planning times need to be
respected and not replaced with another meeting, especially unplanned meetings.
Emergent
Operational
Page 23 of 24
Fully
Operational
There is no collaboration
with parents or the
community in developing
activities to support
learning. Communication
through only written
correspondence is limited to
encouraging parents to
attend school functions,
yearly conferences, and
performances.
Partnerships among
teachers, families, and the
community are maintained
to develop programs that
support learning and
enhance student skills and
talents. Strategies are
implemented to increase
family involvement such as
providing parent education
workshops with information
on child development and
supporting student learning
at home and communicating
with families about school
programs and student
progress (e.g., information
about report cards, grading
practices, (student work,
homework, and school
events) through an
interactive website, phone,
email, voice mail and written
correspondence.
EVIDENCE: The school climate committee and parent teacher coordinator develop and implement programs to support
families and the community. The SIP includes goals to improve participation in family involvement (an increased focus
on ESOL this year), increase the percentage of families participating at workshops designed to improve student learning,
and improving family involvement. Teachers are required to provide a bi weekly newsletter which can sent home and/or
e-mailed. Classroom teachers have created and maintained websites to communicate with families, as well as using the
App Remind to keep the families and community informed. The school website is available for parents to receive
additional school information as well as the school having SchoolCast to push out important messages to the parents.
RECOMMENDATIONS: The parent education workshops should continue to be provided to give parents information and
strategies on supporting student learning. Take homes should also be available.
Page 24 of 24