Heia Position Paper Home Economics Australian Curriculum
Heia Position Paper Home Economics Australian Curriculum
Heia Position Paper Home Economics Australian Curriculum
HomeEconomicsInstituteofAustraliaInc.
Position paper
Home economics and the Australian Curriculum
October 2010
Fast facts
The central focus of home economics is the wellbeing of individuals and families in their
everyday living. Home economics education takes an action-oriented, empowerment
approach that enables students to build capacity for critical and creative approaches to
decision-making and problem-solving related to fundamental needs and practical
concerns of individuals and families, both locally and globally. In an ever-changing and
ever-challenging environment that puts centre stage issues such as food security,
emotional health, sustainability, consumer excesses and a widening poverty gap, one of
home economics educations unique strengths is that it prepares students to respond to a
range of real-life challenges. Its other unique strength is its practical orientation, which for
many students provides opportunities for concrete achievements and increased selfesteem.
Home economics makes a valuable contribution to secondary education across Australia
and should be recognised by ACARA and the schooling sector as a discipline area in its
own right.
The Home Economics Institute of Australia Inc. (HEIA) recommends that the Australian
Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) develops national guidelines
for home economics education in Years 710 in Australian schools to support quality
practice in home economics education.
These guidelines would:
use a home economics lens to integrate and build on learning in ACARAs Health and
Physical Education and Design and Technology syllabi
include specific home economics concepts, content and processes not necessarily
accommodated in these learning areas.
The guidelines would enable sectors and/or schools to develop home economics-related
courses to meet local needs.
HEIA offers its services in the development of these guidelines.
1.0 Introduction
The Home Economics Institute of Australia (HEIA) is the peak professional body for home
economics professionals in Australia. Formed in 1993, the Institute has a growing
membership of approximately 1500, with members in every state and territory. The majority
of members are teachers. In addition, there are state-based home economics professional
associations.
This position paper has been developed for ACARA to inform its thinking on matters related
to home economics education and the upcoming Australian Curriculum. The paper is a result
of wide consultation with members of HEIA through paper and electronic questionnaires,
face-to-face focus groups held in every state and territory and web conferencing.
The statements made about home economics education in this paper do not necessarily
reflect current practice across Australia. Rather, they reflect the essence of what practice
should be like in a new era, with new guidelines to guide this practice.
Typically, across all Australian states and territories, it is a school-based decision whether to
offer a holistic home economics subject, or specialisations within home economicsfor
example, Food for Living, Food Technology, Fashion by Design, Human Development, Early
Childhood Development, Family Studies.
Since the inception of national approaches to curriculum dating back to the mid 1990s, home
economics education has traditionally been aligned with two learning areas: Health and
Physical Education, and Technology. States and territories differ in the formal curriculum
documents that are used in home economics faculties. In some, teachers work from Health
and Physical Education and Technology curriculum documents. In others, specialist home
economics-related curriculum documents are used.
The past fifteen years has shown that offering home economics through Health and Physical
Education and Technology is fraught with difficulty. In some cases it has become splintered
and fragmented and most importantly, lost its interdisciplinary nature and, in some cases,
itsfocus on the wellbeing of individuals and families. Home economics is best implemented
in a way that not only draws from elements of Health and Physical Education and
Technology, but also draws on those aspects of home economics not accommodated in
these learning areas.
HEIA offers its services to write the proposed guidelines. HEIA has a wealth of expertise in
curriculum development with its members having been involved in the Curriculum
Corporation projects Home Economics in Secondary Schools and Family Studies, and the
development of curriculum documents across Australia. HEIA has produced its own
resources Home economics education: Making it work, A curriculum framework for home
economics in the junior secondary school, as well as the highly successful school text
NutritionThe inside story. It has a culture of consultation and a commitment to collaborative
development of resources. Members of HEIA have been invited to speak at international
forums on the future of home economics, as well as on home economics pedagogy and
elearning.
is brought sharply into focus. Food literacy education approaches food and nutrition
education from a positive orientation of encouraging healthy eating, rather than fixing
problems that arise from unhealthy eating.
Current local and global issues related to food security and nutritional health include the
following:
The 2007 Australian National Childrens Nutrition and Physical Activity Survey
(Department of Health and Ageing, 2007) found that the children surveyed
demonstrated a low level of observance of the Dietary guidelines for children and
adolescents in Australia.
Allergies, additives and reading food labels continue to confound some families, with
unethical marketing making it even more difficult to make wise consumer choices.
Research indicates a decline in cooking skills and a possible links with food security.
Food accounts for approximately 30% of Australias ecological footprint.
Availability of better nutrition choices declines with remoteness of location in
Australia.
Diet-related diseases continue to be a major lifestyle issue and economic concern in
Australia. The following indicate the severity of the outcomes of diet-related diseases:
Approximately 23% children aged 216 years and 62% adults were considered
overweight or obese in 2007 surveys (Department of Health and Ageing, 2007;
ABS 2009b), with Australia now being ranked as one of the fattest developed
nations.
Obese young Australians are subject to bullying and social exclusion.
Heart, stroke and vascular diseases kill more Australians than any other disease
group, with Australians in the most disadvantaged groups most vulnerable.
The proportion of Australian adults with diet-related risk factors for cardiovascular
disease is high: 60% overweight, 51% high blood cholesterol, 30% high blood
pressure and 8% diabetes and in 2007 it was estimated that one-third of cancers
were attributed to poor diet, inadequate physical activity, alcohol and overweight
and obesity (WCRF, 2007).
In the 200405 National Health Survey, 699 600 Australians reported having
diabetes, with rates increasing in all age groups. Rates of Type 2 diabetes in
some Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities are among the highest in
the world.
In an era when much food preparation occurs outside the home and for some, an unhealthy
reliance on fast food, the home economics classroom provides opportunities for students to
develop cognitive and practical skills to support a healthy lifestyle and come to understand
the importance of food and nutrition for physical, social, emotional and intellectual
development.
5.3 Consumerism
Consumer trends are the concern of home economics, especially as they pertain to food,
fashion and household expenditure. The following points indicate the need for informed and
ethical consumer decision-making and the need to challenge marketing that creates social
pressures and promotes unsustainable and unhealthy consumption patterns.
In Australia in 2004, food and non-alcoholic beverages were the biggest single household
expenditure item, with an average $153 spent per week (17% of goods and services). 25%
($42) of this expenditure was on meals out and takeaway food whilst only 5% ($11) was
spent on vegetables (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2006).
At the same time, the fashion industry has created a culture of the throw-away society,
promoting new clothing for every season, with many not understanding the implications for
the environment, or the impact of cheap clothing on people in sweatshops or in the clothing
trade in other countries.
As personal and household consumption grows, environmental pressures also grow (OECD,
2002) with increased use of natural resources, energy, transport, packaging, overall waste,
pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. Home economics education is ideally placed to
promote the concept of good citizen along with being a good consumer so that ethical
decision-making takes account of wider societal impacts, especially as they pertain to food
consumption (packaging, food miles, processed and take-away foods), textile consumption
(disposable fashion, low-impact fibres and processing, recycling, biodegradability,
packaging), the use of energy within the home and overall waste.
In the October 2009 Nielsen Global Online Consumer Survey, when asked which of a list of
items respondents would continue to do when the economic conditions improved, the top
three items were:
try to save on gas and electricity (50%)
cut down on takeaway meals (37%)
switch to cheaper grocery brands (32%).
There is no indication that these trends have discontinued, and are all items that are the
concern of home economics.
5.4 Generation Y (born 19822002) social and consumer trends
The fascination of young Australians with the internet and digital social networking comes
with advantages and disadvantages, and runs parallel to changes in the way relationships
are conducted, changes in purchasing options and increasing number of young Australians
experiencing mental health issues. At the same time, young Australians are often confident,
optimistic, team-oriented and achieving. With discussions about families, peers, interpersonal
relationships and a range of social issues related to people, food and textiles, the home
economics classroom provides a unique context for Gen Y to channel their optimism into
collaborative discussion about values and choices related to real-world, important issues.
As reported in the Herald Sun (July 2008) Gen Ys, our students and young professional
colleagues, are great consumers. Of the record 3.7 million new credit-card applications in
2007, almost a third were from those aged 18 to 27. However, a third of people failing to pay
their bills are Gen Ys. At around the same time, The Age (2008) reported Gen Ys have an
urge to update and seek instant gratification with new fashion, fast food, brand names etc, all
adding to unnecessary and often unwise consumption patterns. With two of its content bases
being food and nutrition and textiles and fashion, home economics is ideally placed to
challenge instant gratification and promote ethical and responsible consumer and financial
literacy with this young generation.
there is reason to believe that these shifts have also occurred in Australia.
The table below provides examples of how the general capabilities, as cited by ACARA, are
developed in home economics contexts.
General
capabilities
Literacy and
numeracy
Thinking skills
ICTs
Creativity
Self-management
Teamwork
Intercultural
understandings
Ethical behaviour
Social competence
10
11
Students develop understandings about relationships both within the family and outside the
family, learning a number of skills that help establish and maintain relationships among peers
and within families. They develop a range of interpersonal, communication and conflict
resolution skills. They come to understand how diverse social, cultural and environmental
factors influence relationships and self-management and shape personal development.
Students develop skill in the use of both written and verbal communication.
Students explore contemporary issues and social trends related to identity, families and
interpersonal relationshipsfor example, the impact of the digital world on relationships,
youth homelessness, consumer trends, double shifts, mens and womens roles in the family
and same-sex marriages.
Nutrition and food
Students learn how to make healthy food choices that take into account social, economic and
cultural influences. They learn how to use food selection tools and dietary guidelines to
critique and design a range of meals and meal plans that support health and minimise foodrelated health risks. With a focus on, but not exclusive to adolescence, they consider the
macro- and micro-nutrients important for development (for example, kilojoules, saturated fat,
calcium, folate, omega-3 fatty acids). The importance of food for brain development is also
explored.
They design, prepare and present nutritionally balanced, aesthetically appealing and costappropriate foods and come to realise that a wide range of practical skills is empowering for
sustainable food choices. They develop food preparation skills and techniques based on an
understanding of the scientific, sensory and aesthetic properties of foods that enhance the
quality of the food. They adapt recipes to maximise the nutritional value and/or costeffectiveness of the recipe, manage resources when choosing and preparing food, and
practise food safety and hygiene methods.
Students analyse and evaluate their own diets, and importantly they use empowerment
processes to make health-promoting, culturally-appropriate, sustainable changes to their
diets. This necessarily means that they develop the ability to think critically about the wide
range of influences on food choices, including contemporary issues such as Gen Y
characteristics, the fast food industry, advertising and marketing practices. They come to
understand the interplay between food and all dimensions of health (physical, social,
emotional and intellectual) and how the interplay among personal, social, cultural and
environmental factors influences health behaviours.
Students explore issues such as inequities and sustainable food futures both locally and
globally. They explore how their consumer choices related to, for example, packaging,
organic farming, non-meat options, impact on their health as well as the local and global
environment. They engage in social inquiry to challenge those practices that run counter to
healthy lifestyles, healthy self-image, food security and food accessibility.
Textiles and fashion
Students explore design, fibres and fabrics as well as fashion marketing and the social
messages of clothing. This enables them to make wise consumer decisions and choose
and/or create their own designs that respect their own personalities and needs, taking into
account aesthetic, design, functional, environmental and economic dimensions of their
purchases.
They explore how textiles and fashion choices impact on their identity, self-esteem and body
image, and how various fashion and textile industries use marketing and advertising to
promote inappropriate consumption patterns in the interests of their businesses. Students
engage in practical and design skills that enable them to develop their creativity in order to
12
enhance and embellish textile articles and to create unique pieces that make a statement
about their identity.
At the same time they learn how to make ethical decisions to ensure that their decisions do
not impact negatively, or encourage practices that impact negatively on others in both local,
national and global communitiesthey consider, for example, sweat shops, fairwear, fast
fashion, nanotechnology and sustainability issuesleading to socially-just, environmentally
responsible choices.
They explore how innovations and emerging textile technologies are impacting on
communications, social practices and health and wellbeing.
13
14
Technology practice
Technology processes are used to meet challenges designed to promote health and
wellbeing. Home economics education promotes an approach where this technology process
is an iterative process, with activity moving back and forth through the process and not as a
series of steps or stages progressing in a linear fashion. Having developed processes and/or
products that promote wellbeing, students are encouraged to promote use of these products.
When students apply the technology process to design/create technologies they consider the
beliefs and values of both the developer of the technology and the user of the technology
for example, the aesthetic, social, environmental, cultural and economic values and beliefs.
The following illustrate some possible home economics learning experiences:
Using a range of information communication technologies to illustrate the impact of
television on how families function
Developing, testing, evaluating and justifying a range of food products to meet predetermined family needs
Investigating, devising and evaluating an interactive web-based article targeting a
teenage audience, entitled Living with (students to decidefor example, parents,
grandma).
Developing, testing, evaluating and justifying a range of recycled and rebadged
fashion items that reflect their personality.
Conclusion
There is clearly a need for home economics education in the 21st century. HEIA urges
ACARA to develop national guidelines for home economics education in Years 710.
Extensive consultation with the profession has provided overwhelming support for this
position. This consultation has evidenced a powerful commitment to a futures-driven home
economics curriculum that maximises opportunities and provides skills to prepare students
for living in the 21st century. Home economics education offers a unique context of bringing
together transdisciplinary theoretical and practical learning. It builds capacity for students to
become active and informed members of society who are empowered to design their social
futures, contribute to the wellbeing of themselves and others, and to examine and take action
on matters of personal, community and global significance.
References
Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2010). 1301.0 - Year Book Australia, 200910. Retrieved 16
August 2010 from www.abs.gov.au
Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2009a). 3201.0 - Population by Age and Sex, Australian
States and Territories, Jun 2009. Retrieved 16 August 2010 from www.abs.gov.au
Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2009b). 4364.0 - National Health Survey: Summary of
Results, 2007-2008 (Reissue) Retrieved 16 August 2010 from www.abs.gov.au
Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS). (2008a). 3307.0.55.001Divorces, Australia, 2007.
Retrieved 16 August 2010 from www.abs.gov.au
Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2008b). 3306.0.55.001 - Marriages, Australia, 2007.
Retrieved 16 August 2010 from www.abs.gov.au
Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2008c). 4719.0 - Overweight and Obesity in Adults,
Australia, 200405. Retrieved 16 August 2010 from www.abs.gov.au
Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2006). 6530.0 - Household Expenditure Survey, Australia:
Summary of Results, 2003-04 (Reissue). Retrieved 16 August 2010 from
www.abs.gov.au
Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority. (2009). The Shape of the
Australian Curriculum. Retrieved 16 August 2010 from www.acara.edu.au
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW). 2004. Heart, stroke and vascular
15
diseasesAustralian facts 2004. AIHW Cat. No. CVD 27. Canberra: AIHW and National
Heart Foundation of Australia (Cardiovascular Disease Series No. 22).
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. (2010a). CancerAustralian cancer statistics
update, May 2010. Retrieved 16 August 2010 from www.aihw.gov.au
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. (2010b). Diabetes. Retrieved 16 August 2010 from
www.aihw.gov.au
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. (2010c). Australias health 2010. Retrieved 16
August 2010 from www.aihw.gov.au
Caraher, M. & Seeley, A. (2010). Cooking in schools: lessons from the UK. Journal of the
Home Economics Institute of Australia, 17(1), 29.
Department of Health and Ageing. (2007). 2007 Australian National Children's Nutrition and
Physical Activity Survey. Retrieved 16 August 2010 from www.health.gov.au
Hayes, A., Weston, R., Qu, L., & Gray, M. (2010). Families now and then 19802010.
Australian Government: Australian Institute of Family Studies.
Heart Foundation. (2010). www.heartfoundation.org.au
Herald Sun. (2008). A-Z of Generation Y. Retrieved 16 August 2010 from
www.heraldsun.com.au
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. (2008). Towards Sustainable
Household Consumption? Trends and Policies in OECD countries: Policy brief.
Retrieved from http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/28/49/1938984.pdf
Queensland Studies Authority. (2010). Home Economics Senior Syllabus, 2010. Brisbane:
The State of Queensland (Queensland Studies Authority).
Street, P. (2006). Home Economics education in New Zealand: A position statement. From
TKI | NZ Curriculum Marautanga Project | Health and physical education | Home
Economics Education in New Zealand: A Position Statement. Accessed 13 August
2010 from: http://www.tki.org.nz/r/nzcurriculum/draft-curriculum/health_physical_e.php
World Cancer Research Fund and American Institute for Cancer Research. (2007). Food,
nutrition, physical activity and cancer prevention: a global perspective. Retrieved from
www.dietandcancerreport.org
16