African Rhythm
African Rhythm
African Rhythm
African Rhythm
Author(s): A. M. Jones
Reviewed work(s):
Source: Africa: Journal of the International African Institute, Vol. 24, No. 1 (Jan., 1954), pp.
26-47
Published by: Cambridge University Press on behalf of the International African Institute
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1156732 .
Accessed: 31/08/2012 19:15
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
Cambridge University Press and International African Institute are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize,
preserve and extend access to Africa: Journal of the International African Institute.
http://www.jstor.org
[ 26]
AFRICAN RHYTHM
A. M. JONES
I. SIMPLEHAND-CLAPPING
AFRICAN RHYTHM
27
Whatever be the devices used to produce them, in African music there is practically
always a clash of rhythms:this is a cardinal principle. Even a song which appears to be
mono-rhythmic will on investigation turn out to be constructed of two independent
but strictly related rhythmic patterns, one inherent in the melody and one belonging
to the accompaniment. The usual and simplest accompaniment to a song is handclapping: so a study of hand-clapping is our best entry into African rhythmic technique. We take first Single Clapping.
SINGLEHAND-CLAPPING
The simplest rhythmic background to a song is a steady succession of regular claps;
this may take three forms: slow, about 60 to a minute, medium, about 84, or quick,
about z20 to I40 to the minute. Hand-claps are always absolutely and inexorably
accurate in their time: they never give way even by a hair's breadth to the exigencies
of either melody or words. Indeed, as we shall see when we consider drumming, they
must be metronomic in their accuracy.
A party of people starts clapping and then someone starts the song and all join in
singing: the clapping continues right through the song. With a regular clap, the
fundamental African principle is that there shall be either 2 pulses to a clap or 3 pulses.
The whole song must be either a 2-pulse song (duple) or a 3-pulse one (triple): it
cannot have a mixture of the two, except as an occasional interpolation of z against 3
to accommodate the words.
Ec
Each cclap
lp = ,J
~~
Nsenga Children'sSong-Masowela
J1,
40.
= 4o.4
6
Claps
PI
II
ti
8
I
g_.(r, iJ z_LvT-r^.t!-1
C. Wi-line - o
C. Wi-li ne - o Ch.Chumbwachamwa
- na .......,
- Ch. - a
rKr> ir
Be - ti, Be - ti,
-I--1
6
I
Chum-bwacha mwa - na
FIG. I
C = Cantor;Ch. = Chorus
Fig. I was chosen as a starting-point because, while showing African characteristics, it is also comfortable to the European sense. It might have been barred in 2/4
time but this would have been a misleading introduction to African rhythm: it would
imply the presence of alternate strong and weak accents. But in our example, and
indeed in all cases where clapping is used, the claps are all of equal intensity. Note
that the claps divide naturally into phrase groups of 6 and 8: this is another important
principle in African rhythmic phrasing. A third important feature revealed in Fig. I
is that the song does not start at the beginning: in other words, we can see by the
phrase groups that to the African this song starts at the chorus, and the cantor's part,
AFRICAN RHYTHM
28
--I20.
3 D.C. al Segno.
Claps
t' |t
a -fwivaku ma - u- mba - e.
FIG. 2
The first half of Fig. 2 has been barred in 3/8 time for ease in reading but the timesignature is purposely omitted. The whole song has a regular 3 quavers to a clap and
therefore is essentially triple, but while the first half is triple in the European sense,
with the claps falling on accented melody notes, the second half, while triple in the
African sense, is not so to the European. The melody sounds to a casual observer to
be in 3/4 time at this point, thus:
giSo'i
Wa-fwa
r-l==,F,
ku
ma - u - mba - ee
but this is not accurate and is a misleading way of thinking about it. The example used
in Fig. 2 exhibits fundamental African practice which is this-that an African song
which has a clap is constructed so that either 2 pulses or 3 pulses go to one clap right
through the song, irrespective of word division, word accent, or melodic accent. The
claps do not indicate any sort of stress: their function is to act as an inexorable and
mathematical background to the song. The song itself is usually in free rhythm,
judged as a melody, and no one not acquainted with clap technique would realize that
it is completely in a strait-jacket and that its time-values are mathematically controlled
by the claps. But that is the case and it is part of the genius of African music that it
succeeds in giving an astonishing freedom of melodic rhythm within the strict limits
of the claps which do not usually betray their fundamental duple or triple nature.
The observer hears a free-rhythm melody punctuated by claps which apparently fall
AFRICAN RHYTHM
29
in the most impossible places. But once the principle is grasped, the claps are seen
to be the real backbone of the song and to fall always in the musically correct place.
All African songs with simple regular claps are of this type. It is often very difficult
for the European transcriber to observe exactly where the claps fall, but it is perfectly simple to the African, though he cannot explain it to the transcriber.
We are now ready to look at the scores of this type of song, where the background
is a regular z-pulse or 3-pulse clap, serving a very free melody.
LALATRIBE. Each clap =
SingleClap. Triple
=
120.
Claps
C. Ni-ne' Te - mbwe
8
I
8
i
i - se - mo,
6
I
.
I
,
I
_
_,
Af
-o
4.l
J - Itd _ -J-1-J-^-
1 .
Zql.~.4
X-Jlz
ta - bu - nga-ca,
le - lo
Na
, 4
jI J.J__. -J
mu-lo-ku- la - la pe - so - nde.
?C
FIG. 3 (a)
J.
I20.
8
Claps
IT jI
jb^
- FjT
Mu-li - ie
i
lI
- l
mu- ku - nga
m -
hu -
l-
.....
rIm--------
nga
I
Hunter's Song
SingleClap. Triple
Mu - li - tee - le - le
Let us take the 3-pulse clap first (Figs. 3a and 3b). We have attempted, in all these
examples, to convey the rhythm of the melody itself by grouping the quavers, by
using ties, accent marks, and phrasing, and by the use of bars, not in order to divide
the piece into metrical sections but purely from the practical point of view of helping
AFRICAN RHYTHM
30
the reader to get the lilt of the song as it is sung by the Africans. The songs are always
sung very legatoand fairly fast: they just swing along in a very smooth and apparently
free rhythm: but the melodic rhythm is strongly present and exists in its own right
quite apart from the claps. This is no case of shapeless tunes: if the songs are sung
by an African without their claps they appear to be delightful free-rhythm pieces
often with a good deal of imitation in the melody line.
Single Clap. Duple
Canoe Song
d= 52.
Paddle-strokes
I-5
-L~--.
;-t-M IJ
Ch. wa - ci - pa -ya
I
sya - ni
we
mu - ko-mbo-lal
FIG. 4
AFRICAN RHYTHM
3I
melody of this song, the natural syllables on which to give an emphasis with the
paddle, and yet preservethe smooth flow of the song, would be:
wa-LA-lamumiabuwa-TA-mbalala:
CO-fwemalemba!
We-CA-kubeji,
syaniwemu-KO-mbola!
wa-CI-paya
But in so saying we betray a fundamentalerror in thinking of the paddle-strokes.
They do not mark any emphasiseither on melody or in words: they just exist as an
essentialundercurrentto the song. This fact must be thoroughlygraspedif the more
complex exampleswhich we shall considerlater are to be comprehended.
Note how well this tune is built. It is repeatedadinfinitum
but wearswell. Although
it contains triple motifs it is essentiallyneither triple nor duple. But its backboneis
duple, 4 quavers to each paddle-stroke. We observe that the paddle-strokesare
grouped in two sets of four, and that the cantor'sphraseplus the chorusin each half
of the song total four strokes. Yet, on the score, the stroke for the cantor'swords is
phrased as the last and not the first of a phrase of four strokes. The reason is that
though the clap in the cantor'sfirst phraselooks like the start of the song, it is not.
When they want to end the song, the paddlerswill sing to the end of the chorus and
then the cantor sings ' CofiYe
malemba'to bring the song to a close, thus establishing
the phrasingwe have used.
Thus far we have dealtwith the simple,regularlyspacedhand-clap:before leaving
the simple clap there is one otherand very generaltripleclappingto be described.In
this case the claps are not equidistantin time, but are manifestlytriple. The clapping
may be in either of these two forms:
(a)
(b)
J
J. !
rTiJ rPJ
r
IJ.
&
&c.
r
&c.
In neither case does the clap indicate that the song melody itself is triple in construction.This style of clapping is merely another way of providing the song with
a metronomic background.There is no reason to expect that either word stresses
or melody stresseswill coincide with the accented clap. Sometimesit happens that
they do coincidebut thatis merelyaccidental.The examplewe quote is, in the chorus,
unusually' European' in this respect, but revealsits true Africannatureat the very
firstclap.It would be easyto quote exampleswhere the clapaccentand melody accent
are more disparate.
Here, then, in Fig. 5 is a song with a triple clap.
A whole verse consists of the first half of the song repeated,plus the second half
also repeated.It is importantfor the researcherto take note of repeatsand how they
are made, for they are not made anyhow, and their occurrenceis controlled by the
clap-phrases.For example,see the differencein time-valuegiven to the last syllableof
the word ' cikolola' on its first appearanceand on its repeat. To neglect the repeats
would lead to an inaccuratescore. Thus, in Fig. 5 the whole song is made up of two
clap-phrases,the first containing 8 clap-motifs,and the second 4, computed in this
way:
Firsthalf repeated 4 motifsX2
8 motifs
2 ,,
Second, , ,
2
4 ,,
AFRICAN RHYTHM
32
Girls' Song
NSENGATRIBE
_ ?
z-ip?F-Tr
Jtt
J,___ o
g
r___
i
Ch.Ya-ya,
kve ci - to-la
o_J
Jo
.J
.^-i-J +->
b-
Ya - e
o- i-ye
ya - ya,
<
J7
d_
I
-
:
nte-nda li-ze ya
ci-ko-lo-
la.
JJo
rr-Ii--
Ya - e
o- i -ye
ya-ya!
FIG. 5
To sum up: we have considered so far only the simplest form of African rhythmic
technique, namely the single hand-clap, and we have found four patterns of clapping:
I. Two-pulse; 2. Three-pulse; 3. Triple (a); 4. Triple (b).
We have seen that this clapping is not beating time in the European sense, but is an
undercurrent providing the free rhythms of the song with a metrical basis. No African
could be satisfied with such simple claps for very long: he wants something more
interesting. The next step in complexity will be considered in the next section where
we shall deal with clapping patterns.
II. CLAPPING PATTERNS
A. Single ClappingPatterns
An interesting rhythmic pattern is the spice of life to the African. So far we have
considered steady, equally spaced claps and the equally steady ordinary triple clap.
In such types, the African secures his rhythmic interest by making his melodic
accents lie athwart the claps. We must now examine a kind of clap which has an
inherent rhythmic interest of its own. It is here that we see one of the significant
characteristics of African music as distinct from that of the West. There is, of course,
no reason why music should be governed by a steady, equally spaced beat as in 3/4,
4/4, 6/8, time or arnyother of the conventional time forms. We in the West have a way
out in the juxtaposition of bars of unequal length or in free rhythm. We have not hit
on the African's method which is this: he takes a little rhythmic pattern, usually of
I -pulse length, and this he repeats over and over again as the rhythmic background
of his song. The pattern chosen for demonstration is of particular interest owing to
its widespread distribution: it occurs in West, Central, and East Africa. There are
AFRICANRHYTHM
33
in
other patternsbut the characteristictechnique of them all is illustrated the one
given.
J=
.I
140.
;.
. !..
.,J.
&c.
This pattern, which is thrice repeatedin the example above, consists of twelve
pulses, with the claps falling thus:
1
10
11 12
AFRICAN RHYTHM
34
ILA TRIBE
Single Clap-Pattern
J= I40.
Clap
J4
7w
:^
J?
.J
J__J
rA
#!J:1
J2~
JJ.
~+
J.~
C. Mu-sha-ba-ngi-lo
J J
J Q J4
ba- sa, mu-sha- ba- ngi- lo, . . Ch.Kwee- ndamu- sha-ba- ngi - lo,
- J J J~
Kwee - nda mu - sha - ba- ngi - lo
mbu-sha- ka - wi - la
J.
i
J
ngo-mbe na- mu -ya - nzya
ka -lu- wa,
J . .J
J.
_;
~J
J,
(kweenda)
FIG.6
Men's Song, 'Inyimbo' class
ILA TRIBE
I40
,=
Clap
e, . J
JI'
_0I.
J !'
C. Shi - baa - ya
J. J
! .
J
-
na
la,
ma - sa- ka - a - le - le Mpi-nda oo
!~
2J.
hu- mbo,
J?
1r1
ye,
FIG. 7
.
_
yel
!1
AFRICAN RHYTHM
35
not only said they knew this clap-patternwell, but demonstratedit: yet it was transcribedin CentralAfrica.
There are more of these clap-patterns:but having examinedone in isolation, we
shall study others in a setting in which they so often occur, that is, in combination.
B. CombinedClappingPatterns
LALATRIBE
io6.
J.=
Clap I
I.2 .
!.
-X.
--
Clap 2
Resultant
1 J
? A
C. Cu -lu
JJ.
IJ
INJ
IJ.
J
L
A-3
ca
nsa - ngwa,Ch. I-
ya-
ya
:?
ya
|'
ka-mu-
J_.
lu- bu
se,
D.C. al Segno
J.
,
oJj
J.
C'lJ.
IJ
|.
1.I J
IJ
A
A`^-
f^__
C Le - lo
mwa - ci
r-
ya - ya,
11
Il I,J aIl.
A^`
bo-na. Ch.I - ya
J3r
ka-mu-lu - bu -
-A
se.
FIG. 8
JeJ
Resultant3
J.
| I.
AFRICANRHYTHM
36
Resultant4
J.
!.
!.
J1
Ij
These two patterns,the one tripleand the other duple, emergefrom the same constituents simply becauseone of the contributingpatternsis clappedlouder than the
other. They would be counted as two entirelydifferentclap-patternsby Africans: I
doubt if any African,unless he had had trainingin Europeanmusic at college level,
would be able to recognizethat these two resultantsarecompoundedof two identical
clap-patterns.
Looking againat Fig. 8 we see thatthis song stressesthe 4-claprhythmand,as there
are z quaversto the complete phrase,the resultantis in triple time. It is clear that
the point of entryof the chorusis the importantplacewherethe clap-phrasesand song
start off together. The remarkablefeatureis the way in which the chorusphraseends
not on the last clap of a clap-phrasebut on the first, and the cantor'swords are used
to completethe clap-phrasebeforethe entryof the chorusagain.The song is repeated
ad libitumas it is the accompanimentof a girls' play-dance.Fig. 8 is a simpleexample
of combined clapping.
Another simple form of the Citeleleclap is this:
1. = I40.
ist clap
J.
2nd clap
Resultant8
JI
J
\I
J.
J.
J.
J
.1
I J.
fJ
I.
FIG.9
AFRICANRHYTHM
Combined
Rhythm.Axe-Blades
37
BEMBATRIBE
J.== I3.
Ist Aixe
8
..
IJ.
J.
- 8J
IJ.
J.
I J.
J.
2nd Axe
IJ
.j
J j.
IJ
IJ
3rd Axe
A
12
OJ
Aj
J
J
J
2 J
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
IJX
Resultant
0 Or^N
i1IJ
f Axes
I
ba - ka - ntwa
J.
j
iJ
*d
J
p-0
21a---="PJ.-t j
I ;2
jJ g;j - >
I n ].1
ist Axe I
C. Ba - na
J.
J*
la
ma -- ee -- la
IJ.
J
J.
IJ
Ja
0
.3
'
e
J
--
^* or"7
I jwrM;
LJ-
nkala
la-pi
- la -- la-pi
nha
IJ.
I1
Ie
Ch.
M-mi-la
Ch. Mlu-mi-la
!.
J
I
-
I
mbo, ba - na
II
IJ
J.
J
IJ
* .3
,r j
IJ
,J
1,j
-rr;
-- I
mbo,
II
11
i-t i
mu-mi-la
of Axes
of Song =
r-"
.
lr
Jj IJ
Song =
J;
I "17
J.
J J,
II
:
.u
'i
ba - ha - nwa
ma-e
- la.
FIG. I0
AFRICAN RHYTHM
38
them, though in fact its prime backgroundis the patternof the first axe-blade.As to
the phrasingof the piece, here againwe find two distinct series,one belonging to the
axes and one to the song. While the axes are phrasedin four groups of 4 of the first
axe-bladebeats, the song is dividedin three phrasescontaining6, z, and 8 of the first
axe-bladebeats respectively.The whole song has a strong rhythmof its own in these
three phrases, and in no way does it reflect either the individual or the resultant
rhythms of the axes. These, though they contributeso much to the charmingeffect
of the whole, merely act in relation to the song as its metronomic background.
However many times the song is repeated,its syllablesfall on identicalbeats of the
axes.
We did this because our African players did. But they can equallywell treat it as a
differentpatternby reversingit and putting the shortermotif in front in this way:
,N
18
7r I
11
Ist clap
2nd clap
: J
= I20.
J.
3rdclap 3 :
Resultant :3
J.
J.
IJ
I J1 .d
J
I 1 J
I
FIG. II
Although some of the accentedclaps in the clap-patternsare seen to occur on unaccented notes of the resultant,in practicethe stresses on these accented claps are
only slight and they exist more in the mind of the performerthan in his clapping.
One important clue in unravelling African music is to discover how the African
thinks'about his music, andin the caseof these combinedclap-patternshe is intent on
producing the resultant.
I Compare the 2nd and 3rd clap in Fig. xI. The
sequence of claps is identical in both cases, but the
organization of the sequence in the mind of the per-
AFRICANRHYTHM
39
We have here been dealingwith more complexpatternsand their combinationand
use with songs. One featureshould linger in the mind,namely,that in hand-clapping,
as a generalrule, all the various clap-rhythmshave a common beat on which to start.
In the next section, which is concernedwith drumming,we shalldiscovera technique
that is radicallydifferentand in which this particularfeatureis not found.
III. DRUMMINGTECHNIQUE
J.I40o.
&c.
lJ
I .
IJ
Jl
:11&c.
AFRICAN RHYTHM
40
I40.
Drum
I
I
Drum 2
J'
.i
IJ
J.
,J.
Here the mainbeat of the bar of the second drumfalls on the secondbeat of the bar of
the first: hence the main beats can never coincide.
3 ,I J
(b) Drumi
Drum2
21
.3JJ
21IJ
SI J
2I J
Here the mainbeat of the bar of the second drumcoincideswith the thirdbeat of the
bar of the first: the main beats again can never coincide.
We call this process ' crossing the beats ': it is absolutelyfundamentalto African
drummingtechnique.This crossingof the beat mustbe established;afterthat is done,
additionaldrums may be added with main beats of the bar coinciding with one or
other of those alreadybeating, but with a differentrhythm-pattern;or, in the case
of the masterdrum,once the firsttwo drumshave establisheda cross-rhythm,he may
just do what he likes: he usuallycreatesa seriesof rhythm-patternswhose main beat
crosses at least one of the other drums. Yet it is rathermisleading to speak of the
main beat of the master drum,because,though at times he uses short motifs which
could be barredin the Europeanway and given a time-signature,yet he is mostly
using longer and irregularrhythm-patternswhich have unequallyspaced points of
emphasis.When he uses such patterns,his stressedbeats are quite unrelatedto the
main beats of the bar of the other drums: they may coincide or they may not-it all
depends on the pattern he is using; and clearlyif the pattern is irregularsome of
his stressedbeats may happen to fall on stressedbeats of another drum, in which
case others will not.
Let us take an example with an extremelysimple pattern played on the master
drum. It is a Bemba dance called ' Ibeni '.
Drum I plays 2> ie
4eI
J*
oN
Ie.
&c
&c.
Drum 2's patternis interesting;it is a mixtureof duple and triple and one wonders
at the ingenuity of the Africanin using triple time to cover a rhythmicphraseof 6
quavers,which is the overall patternof the phrasingof the dance.
Drum
32
e[i82J
1~
*trJ
,, 1~J
J I[
AFRICAN RHYTHM
4I
Referringto the full score below, we see the ingenious way in which drums i and 2
are combined.
The simplestform of the masterdrummer'spatternsis this:
2
N JI ~ 41 lip I
f;T
"
JII
_
J"~J&c.
but the remarkablefact is that instead of starting his pattern approximatelyat the
same point as drum 2, he actuallystartsit neartheendof that drum'spattern.So here
we see another fundamentalfeature of African drumming, and African music in
general, namely, the staggeringof the points of entryof combined rhythm patterns.
Arrangingthe score as the Africanactuallyplays it, and noting the resultantrhythm,
which is the predominantsound heard by anyone standingnear the dance, and the
rhythmwhich the three drummersare intending to produce, we get:
d= 96.
Drum
DJ.
DrumzzJ
MasterDrum4
JJ
SI
I
2:
I3 I
1,
7T=
J;9
. 1 J
IA
Resultant
SJ
o, 1I
I J-I"
A
'
!J
I Ji
,T
:
A
FIG. 12
If the readerthinks the resultanta mere dull repetitionof the masterdrumlet him
of the masterdrum'spatternbecomes the effecreflecton the phrasing: the beginning
tive andheavy-soundingendof the resultant.He mayalso note thatthe two unaccented
introductorybeatsof the resultantarecompoundedof the firsttwo beatsof the second
drum'striplepattern,togetherwith the firstbeat only of the firstdrum,superimposed
and staggered.We have, then, a triple rhythmcross-beatingwith a duple rhythm,to
which the masterdrum adds a duple rhythmwhose phrasestartsnear the end of the
second's phrase,all producing a resultantwhose phrase (in duple time) startsat the
beginning of the second drum'striple phrase.
In order to isolate the principlesof drummingwe have so far omitted the handclapping and also the song from the score. In actualpracticethe dance Ngwayihas
four drums, all with differentrhythm-patterns,a hand-clap, and a song. Having
establishedthe essence of drummingtechniquewe are now ready to consider how
clapping and singing are integratedwith it. We shall again take a simple example;
it is only fair to the African playersto draw attention to this point because the exampleswe are using are so short and so rudimentarythat they do scant justiceto the
rhythmicpowers of an Africanmusician.As we went to the Bemba tribefor the last
examples,let us now go to the Nsenga who live some 500 miles to the south-east
of them.
Fig. 13 is a Beer Dance in which there are two drums,one hand-clapping,and a
song. Most African drumminggoes as a rule at about 7 beats per second, that is at
AFRICAN RHYTHM
42
about the speed of an old English Sword Dance tune. But Nsenga drumming is
always quicker: it sounds so rapid that one wonders how the drummers can keep it
up. It goes at 480 unit beats per minute.
Drums,Claps,andSong
J. == 6o.
ist Drum
n,J
{-^=LTr-n-=
-
1-,~--
-4
Beer Dance
NSENGA TRIBE
d =20.
-T-
2nd Drum
A -X
-A...^
Claps
A'"
ne -
C. Ni
Ch. Ni
ne- o
ka
-'A
--3
wa
na
i,
l
g.=:JH~z
,A
C"
ne
C. Ni
b
1-
An
ne -
ka
3.
Ch. Ni
na
iI
II
t_
......
ni,
a.
d-_
_
w
A '
T -
- --g
3
A
wa
'
Ps
i~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~01
:7
-irC
~
~
~
A
.
_r1'
Ma
Looking at the score in Fig. I 3 we see that the first drum presents no difficulties:
it is a steady triple time throughout. The second drum sets up a cross-beat by beating
AFRICAN RHYTHM
43
in duple time. It has a phraseof 12 quavers,the last but one being stronglyaccented;
the last quaveris very quiet and unaccentedand is a sort of reboundfrom the strong
accent precedingit: we have indicatedthis by inverting the quaver.Now it is very
necessary to remarkthat in drumming, normally, there is never any beating of 2
against 3 or 3 against 4 in the European sense. Many people, having heard of the
intricaciesof Africandrumrhythms,think of it in terms of this sort of complication.
One may concedethat the masterdrummerdoes on occasionfor just a few successive
crossbeatsplay, say, z against3, but this is by way of embellishment.Thefundamental
beating of the drumsis not producedby these means. Thus one can neverget a combination like this:
Drum i
8 2
Drum 2
r
.
r.
*.
AFRICAN RHYTHM
44
plain sentence really means that the very basis of African rhythmic technique is
differentfrom ours. We shall never understandit, let alone masterit, if we approach
it from the point of view of our own musicalsystem.For this reason,any attemptto
write Africanmusic in the Europeanmanner,with bar lines runningright down the
score and applying to all the contributinginstrumentssimultaneously,is bound to
lead to confusion.It gives the impressionthat all but one of the contributorsis highly
syncopated,and the multitudeof tied notes and off-beataccentsmakesthe mind reel.
We put forth a plea that those transcriberswho have been using this Europeantechnique will think seriouslyabout it. Looked at from the point of view of each player,
African music is not syncopatednor is it complicatedexcept for the master-drum
rhythms.The business of transcriptionis to produce a readablescore which reflects
faithfullywhat is being played.To use Europeanmethodsis to producea scorewhich
is nothing short of a travestyof what the Africanis doing even though it accurately
presentsthe incidence of each note played.
We choose as our last example something a little more complicated,though in
two respectsit sounds as if it has a Europeanconstruction.It is neverthelessgenuine
Africanfolk musicandits Europeanflavouris accidental.We referto Fig. 14. Having
cited the Bemba and the Nsenga tribes and found their drummingtechniquesto be
identical,we now set out a music of the Lalapeople in the centre of Rhodesia; once
more we find the same technique. But what an arrayof rhythms! Let us examine
them: we shalldo so in the orderin which the Africanperformersenterand therefore
we must startwith the drums.
LALATRIBE
d=io5.
Clap I
X
J
Clap 2
'?
Clap 3
:11
I
^
^A
^A
: [J
II
d1o
Resultant
2.[,tlJ
,J
,' !J
I}2J ,I,,
vI: II
I1,
Drum I
TIor:
A
Master drum
3.
N fs
A
jS
|l J
5|'
A
tu-nwe
^A
Ch. Mu- li
*N j
'i-ko
FIG. 14
>
A
A
C o
C. Tu-bi- -r l--t
C. Tu-bi-la
I g ! O=
o, V r I
I
- i - sa
mu
mpa - nga.
AFRICAN RHYTHM
45
The first drum is the underlying current of the piece and beats in 3/4 time. He has
two rather strongly accented beats: all the others are weak, and especially the last
quaver of his phrase which we have inverted to show that it is merely a sort of rebound
from the strong beat preceding it. His essential pattern without the filling-in beats is:
A
J3
IJ
&c.
IJ
J_
When the first drum has got going, the master drum enters. His time is 3/8 and so
we have a 3/8 time set against a 3/4 time. But there is more to it: omitting his weak
filling-in beats, the master drum's essential pattern is:
31
IJ
J.
IaJ 2l.
II
An attempt has been made on the score to indicate this by inverting all the filling-in
quavers. All the beats in the essential pattern are strongly accented in practice. Now
the master drummer must set up a cross-beat, and he does this by entering with his
first beat, which is a strong one, on the second beat of the bar of drum i. The essential
crossing is therefore this:
Drumi
I|J
Masterdrum
8I r r
r
r
r
r
r
r
That is to say, after each two master-drum bars, the sequence of crossed main beats
repeats itself. Now no amount of juggling with the score can alter this prime and
fundamental fact. That is what the African is trying to do. Were one to bar the score
with lines running right through from top to bottom, as if each performer had the
same main beat in the bar, it would not represent what the African is doing or how
he is thinking. He deliberately sets out to cross the main beats in the manner described
and the score must show what the performer has to do.
We see, then, that the two drum rhythms and their bars are well and truly crossed.
When this is going smoothly, the first clap is introduced. It is a slow regular clap.
We have phrased it in sets of three, but the African is not aware of this grouping:
we do it to show the relation between the first clap and the second and third claps.
This first clap, considered in relation to the drums, is seen to be essentially duple,
there being four quavers to each clap. Therefore in the nature of the case it is crossed
with the main beats of the drums which are triple. This may be regarded as clapping
in 3/2 time, i.e. at half the speed of drum I, with its main beat of the bar falling on the
third beat of the first drum's bar, but in practice the clap-pattern has no accented claps
and therefore the way we have scored it is more accurate.
The third clap now joins in. This charming pattern is, like the second one, widely
distributed in Africa, occurring at least in the Gold Coast, in Central Africa, and in
Tanganyika. Both the second and the third clap-patterns consist of a phrase of i z
quavers, but it must be evident that they cannot be forced into a European timeframework and called 12/8, for that would suggest that the patterns are deliberately
revolting against a steady
12
.
8 *o *.
J'
AFRICAN RHYTHM
46
which is not the case. They exist as a rhythm-pattern entirely in their own right: we
think it best to show their stressed claps and to phrase them but to leave them unbarred.
Clap 3 like 2 has its first main beat on the third beat of the bar of drum i and a
scrutiny of the score will show that every one of its stressed beats is crossed with the
first drum's accented beats.
We note that, in accordance with African technique, all three claps have the same
beat for their starting-point, whereas the drums do not. The whole phrasing of the
claps is staggered with the phrasing of the first drum and lies right athwart the
phrasing of the master drum, in spite of the fact that both phrases are of i z-quaver
length. The sceptic might accuse us of having mistaken the phrasing of the master
drum. 'Be reasonable,' we hear him saying, 'and make it agree with the clap
'
phrases: there is no need to be so complicated.' The answer would have to be: Go
and listen, and question the African.'
In dealing with the claps we omitted to point out the resultant rhythm which is a
very jolly one; but it is convenient to mention it here as we now refer to the song, and
the song takes its time from the resultant of the three clap-patterns. Now the resultant, compounded as it is of a regular clap plus two irregular patterns, emerges as a
duple one and the song is duple too. In this it is seemingly un-African because it
sounds so European in its four-squareness: most African songs set to drums are
much freer in their rhythm, but it just happens that in this case the typical African
cross-beatings yield a four-square tune.
There is no point in being complicated where simplicity will serve. We have tried
to analyse this dance in the simplest possible way. The individual rhythms used are
seen to be fairly simple. When we review the piece as a whole, however, we must
admit that it is a little complex, for it is seen to be constructed essentially of 2/4 time
which is staggered against 3/4 time which itself is staggered against 3/8 time.
One minor point should be made about the scoring of the songs. In all the examples,
unless specifically stated to be for women's voices, the songs are for both men and
women and are sung in unison: where harmony occurs it is doubled in both parts.
The treble clef has been used by itself for simplicity.
We have carried our investigation far enough for the present purpose. Much more
remains which could be said. The performance of the master drum is a study in itself.
We have given in each case one only of the many variations which the master drummer uses in actual practice: when these drummings were transcribed, in the case of
the earlier ones the writer did not know the extent of the master drummer's technique
nor had he devised means to investigate the matter; in the other cases he lacked
opportunity to do more than record one variation. What the master drummers really
do at any ordinary village dance is a veritable tour deforce; those who wish to pursue
this matter will find it treated in detail in The Icila Dance by the present writer.'
There are other matters which have not been noticed. We have said nothing of the
use of Nonsense Syllables in delineating drum rhythms; we have ignored in our scores
the fact that the drums are not merely beating time, for each note has to be beaten
on its own correct pitch, each drum being capable of producing notes of different
pitch and timbre. But it is hoped that this limited survey of African rhythms may have
I TheIcilaDance,oldstyle: A study in African music
and dance of the Lala tribe of Northern Rhodesia, by
A. M. Jones and L. Kombe, London, 1952. Obtainable from the African Music Society, Johannesburg.
AFRICAN RHYTHM
47
served to indicate the essential principles on which they are made and combined and
that it will help towards a juster appreciation of African musicianship. Their rhythmic
technique is in several respects much more highly developed than is ours.
Resume
LE RYTHME DE LA MUSIQUE AFRICAINE
LE rythme est reconnuetre le trait caractdristiquede la musique africaine.Dans cet article,
l'auteur se base sur plusieurs enregistrementsde l'execution de la musique africainepour
effectuerl'analysedes cadences produites en claquantles mains, en frappantensemble des
fers de haches, et en battant des tambours.II demontre comment, par la combinaison d'un
certain nombre de simples rythmes, il est possible de produire un ensemble de cadences
extremementcomplique. Les battementsdes tambours, ou les claquementsdes mains, sont
employes comme accompagnementsde chansonset de danses,mais ne serventpas seulement
pour battre la mesure. L'ensemble rythmique ainsi obtenu possede un charme recherche
qui lui est propre, en dehors de la melodie des voix, et tandis que les battements des tambours, ou les claquements des mains, n'ont aucun rapport avec l'accentuationprovenant
des paroles ou de la melodie, ils contribuent a definir un cadre mdtriquepour la cadence
libre de la chanson. L'auteur affirmeque la realisationde cet assemblage rythmiqueest le
but primordialdes musiciens africains.
plusieurs etudes.