Common Chord Modulation
Common Chord Modulation
Common Chord Modulation
ASystematicMethodofCommonChordModulation
byDerekRemes
ThefollowingmethodwasdevelopedbyNadiaBoulangerasasystemof
modulationtonearbykeysusingcommonchords.Nadiawroteallthecadences
herself,andtaughtthemethodtoDavidConte,amongothers.Davidgavealecture
onthesubjectattheEuropeanAmericanMusicalAllianceinParisin2010,whichis
whereIwasintroducedtoit.
PartI:ThetableofCommonChords
TRIAD
TYPE
Major
Minor
I,IV,V
ii,iii,vi
vii
none
Harmonic
Minor
SCALE
V,VI
i,iv
ii,vii
III+
TYPE
Ascending
MelodicMinor
IV,V
i,ii
vi,vii
III+
Descending III,VI,VII
MelodicMinor
(Natural)
i,iv,v
ii
none
Major
Diminished Augmented
Acrossthetoparethefourbasictriadtypes:major,minor,diminished,and
augmented.Ontheleftarethefourscaletypes:major,harmonicminor,ascending
melodicminor,anddescendingmelodicminor(ornaturalminor).Thesystem
worksbestwhenthetableismemorizedaccordingtotheverticalcolumns(by
triad).Forinstance,whenyouhaveamajortriad,memorizethatitcanbeI,IV,Vina
majorscale;V,VIinaharmonicminorscale,etc.
PartII:ConstantTonic,ChangingTriadType
Thenextstepistolearnallofthefollowingcadencesinallofthe12keys
onecadenceforeachtriadinthetableabove.Noticethatallthechordsareinfour
voicesandinrootposition.Alsonoticethatthethreeuppervoicesarealwaysin
closeposition,exceptforthedeceptivevi.Trytomemorizetheoutervoices,which
usuallymoveincontrarymotion,andthenfillinthemiddlevoicesbelowthe
soprano.
IhavearbitrarilychosenDMajor/DMinorforexample.ThetonicDwill
remainconstantwhilethestartingharmonieswillchange.Thecadencesare
identifiedbythefirstchord,whichislabeledwithromannumerals.Therhythmis
alsoarbitrary;whatmattersistheprogression.
Themostimportantaspectofthissectionisthatthelastchordisalwaysthe
same.
MajorTriadsinMajorScale:
MajorTriadsinHarmonicMinorScale:
MajorTriadsinAscendingMelodicMinorScale:
MajorTriadsinDescendingMelodicMinorScale:
MinorTriadsinMajorScale:
MinorTriadsinHarmonicMinorScale:
MinorTriadsinAscendingMelodicMinorScale:
MinorTriadsinDescendingMelodicMinorScale:
DiminishedTriads(inRootPosition)inMajorandMinorScales:
Diminishedtriadsalmostalwaysappearinfirstinversiontoeliminatethe
tritonebetweenthebassandtheothervoices.Therefore,Ihaveincludedthe
followingcadencesmyself.Noticethatregardlessoftheinversion,diminished
chordsalwaysdoublethethird.
DiminishedTriads(inFirstInversion)inMajorandMinorScales:
AugmentedTriadinHarmonicMinorandAscendingMelodicMinorScales:
PartIII:ConstantTriad,ChangingTonic
Thissectionswitchesthevariablesoftheprevioussection.Before,weused
chordsallderivedfromtheDMajororDMinorscale,alwaysendingwithDMajoror
DMinorasourtonic.NowwebegintomodulatebykeepingaDMajororDMinor
chordasthefirstchordineachoftheaboveprogressions.Noticethatthefirst
romannumeralofeachcadenceisstillthesamebecausethechordfunctionhasn't
changedthecadencehassimplybeentransposed.
Themostimportantaspectofthissectionisthatthefirstchordisalwaysthe
same(majororminor).
MajorTriadsinMajorKey:
MajorTriadsinHarmonicMinorScale:
MajorTriadsinAscendingMelodicMinorScale:
MajorTriadsinDescendingMelodicMinorScale:
MinorTriadsinMajorScales:
MinorTriadsinHarmonicMinorScales:
MinorTriadsinAscendingMelodicMinorScales:
MinorTriadsinDescendingMelodicMinorScales:
DiminishedTriads(inRootPosition)inMajorandMinorScales:
DiminishedTriads(inFirstInversion)inMajorandMinorScales:
AugmentedTriadinHarmonicMinorandAscendingMelodicMinorScales:
PartIV:Application
Onedisadvantageofthismethodisthatthe"targetkey"hastohaveatonic
chordwhichisacommonchordtothe"originalkey"scale.Modulationstomore
distantkeyscanbeachievedthroughconnectingthecadencestogetherlikelinksof
achain.Thefollowingisasimpleapplication.AMajorbecomesIIIinF#Minor,F#
MajorbecomesIIinC#Minor,F#MinorbecomesIIIinDMajor.(Amodechange
fromF#MinortoF#Majorinmeasure5facilitatesmodulationtoamoredistantly
relatedkey.)
Thenextexampleisamoreartisticapplicationusinginversions,suspensions,
andseventhchords.TheGMinortriadchangesfromivinDMinortoiiinFMajorin
measure4.Noticetheaugmentedtriadonthethirdbeatofm.6thatresolvesdowna
fifthtoBflatMajor(asitdoesintheabovecadences).TheDMinortriadinm.9
becomesiiiinBflatMajor.Alsonoticehowtheaugmentedtriadonthethirdbeatof
m.11resolvesdownafifthtoaNeapolitan6inDMinor.Theunusualprogression
(vi6vii6i)fromtheabovecadencesoccursinGMinorbeginningonthethird
beatofm.14.TheFaugmentedtriadreturnsonelasttimeasahybriddominant
chordinthethirdbeatofm.15,andresolvesbrieflydownafifthtoBflatMajor
beforechangingtoDMajor.Thisexamplestaysinmorecloselyrelatedkeys.
PartV:Conclusion:
Theappealofthissystemisnotsomuchinitsoriginalityasinits
thoroughness.However,itisbynomeanscomplete.Anewchartcouldclassifyall
theseventhchordsinthefourbasicscaletypes,orcouldbranchouttoincludenon
standardscales.Thissystemcouldbeappliedinanalysis,composition,or
improvisation.Whateveryourinterests,Ihopethatyouhavefoundthismethodof
commonchordmodulationtobeinterestingandofvalue.