Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 139 views

    Perencanaan Transport Metode Rata2 Detroit Furness

    Uploaded by

    Kurnia Utami
    The document describes the application of two methods - the average method and Detroit method - to determine the optimal location of zones in an area. Over multiple iterations, the methods calculate the demand and supply for each zone, and the efficiency index, with the goal of minimizing differences between demand and supply across zones. The Detroit method converges faster than the average method, reaching stability after 6-7 iterations compared to over 7 iterations for the average method.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Perencanaan Transport Metode Rata2 Detroit Furness

    Uploaded by

    Kurnia Utami
    139 views17 pages
    The document describes the application of two methods - the average method and Detroit method - to determine the optimal location of zones in an area. Over multiple iterations, the methods calculate the demand and supply for each zone, and the efficiency index, with the goal of minimizing differences between demand and supply across zones. The Detroit method converges faster than the average method, reaching stability after 6-7 iterations compared to over 7 iterations for the average method.

    Original Description:

    transportasi - civil engineering - Universitas Tadulako Palu

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The document describes the application of two methods - the average method and Detroit method - to determine the optimal location of zones in an area. Over multiple iterations, the methods calculate the demand and supply for each zone, and the efficiency index, with the goal of minimizing differences between demand and supply across zones. The Detroit method converges faster than the average method, reaching stability after 6-7 iterations compared to over 7 iterations for the average method.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as xlsx, pdf, or txt
    139 views17 pages

    Perencanaan Transport Metode Rata2 Detroit Furness

    Uploaded by

    Kurnia Utami
    The document describes the application of two methods - the average method and Detroit method - to determine the optimal location of zones in an area. Over multiple iterations, the methods calculate the demand and supply for each zone, and the efficiency index, with the goal of minimizing differences between demand and supply across zones. The Detroit method converges faster than the average method, reaching stability after 6-7 iterations compared to over 7 iterations for the average method.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as xlsx, pdf, or txt
    of 17

    a.

    metode rata-rata
    tabel 2

    iterasi 1

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    250
    250
    175
    125

    2
    220
    200
    350
    450

    3
    325
    350
    250
    175

    4
    275
    300
    275
    350

    Dd

    800

    1220

    1100

    1200

    Dd'

    1000

    1450

    1150

    1500

    Ed

    1.25

    1.189

    1.045

    1.25

    oi
    1070
    1100
    1050
    1100
    4320
    4320

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.192
    1.364
    1.048
    1.136

    5125
    5100
    1.185
    1.184

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    305.250
    326.750
    201.075
    149.125

    2
    261.910
    255.300
    391.475
    523.125

    3
    363.513
    421.575
    261.625
    190.838

    4
    335.775
    392.100
    315.975
    417.550

    Dd

    982.200

    1431.810

    1237.551

    1461.400

    Dd'

    1000.000

    1450.000

    1150.000

    1500.000

    1.018

    1.013

    0.929

    1.026

    Ed

    oi
    1266.448
    1395.725
    1170.150
    1280.638
    5112.961
    5112.961

    iterasi 3
    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.007
    1.075
    0.940
    0.976

    5125
    5100
    1.000
    0.997

    1
    309.0660
    341.9440
    196.8520
    148.6780

    2
    264.5290
    266.5330
    382.2750
    520.2480

    3
    351.8810
    422.4180
    244.4890
    181.7730

    4
    341.3150
    411.9010
    310.6030
    417.9680

    996.5400

    1433.5850

    1200.5610

    1481.7870

    1000.0000

    1450.0000

    1150.0000

    1500.0000

    1.0030

    1.0110

    0.9580

    1.0120

    oi
    1266.7910
    1442.7960
    1134.2190
    1268.6670
    5112.4730
    5112.4730

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.0060
    1.0400
    0.9700
    0.9850

    5125
    5100
    1.0000
    0.9960

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    310.4570
    349.2960
    194.1950
    147.7860

    2
    266.7780
    273.3300
    378.6430
    519.2080

    Dd

    1001.7340

    1437.9590

    Dd'

    1000.0000

    1450.0000

    0.9980

    1.0080

    Ed

    iterasi 4
    3
    345.5470
    421.9960
    235.6870
    176.5930

    4
    344.3870
    422.6100
    307.8080
    417.3410

    1179.8230

    1492.1460

    1150.0000

    1500.0000

    0.9750

    1.0050

    oi
    1267.1690
    1467.2320
    1116.3330
    1260.9280
    5111.6620
    5111.6620

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.0060
    1.0220
    0.9850
    0.9910

    5125
    5100
    1.0010
    0.9970

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    311.0780
    352.7890
    192.5440
    146.9730

    2
    268.6450
    277.4300
    377.3180
    518.9480

    3
    342.2640
    421.3630
    230.9730
    173.5910

    4
    346.2810
    428.3150
    306.2690
    416.5060

    Dd

    1003.3840

    1442.3410

    1168.1910

    1497.3710

    Dd'

    1000.0000

    1450.0000

    1150.0000

    1500.0000

    0.9970

    1.0050

    0.9840

    1.0020

    Ed

    oi
    1268.2680
    1479.8970
    1107.1040
    1256.0180
    5111.2870
    5111.2870

    iterasi 5
    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.0050
    1.0140
    0.9940
    0.9950

    5125
    5100
    1.0020
    0.9970

    iterasi 6

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    311.3890
    354.7290
    191.6780
    146.3850

    2
    269.9880
    280.0660
    377.1290
    518.9480

    3
    340.3820
    420.9420
    228.4320
    171.7680

    4
    347.4930
    431.7420
    305.6570
    415.8810

    Dd

    1004.1810

    1446.1310

    1161.5240

    1500.7730

    Dd'

    1000.0000

    1450.0000

    1150.0000

    1500.0000

    0.9960

    1.0030

    0.9900

    1.0000

    Ed

    oi
    1269.2520
    1487.4790
    1102.8960
    1252.9820
    5112.6090
    5112.6090

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.0050
    1.0080
    0.9970
    0.9980

    5125
    5100
    1.0020
    0.9970

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    311.5450
    355.4390
    191.0070
    145.9460

    Dd

    1003.9370

    Dd'

    1000.0000

    Ed

    0.9960

    iterasi 7
    2
    271.0680
    281.6060
    377.1290
    519.2080

    3
    339.5310
    420.5210
    226.9470
    170.7370

    4
    348.3620
    433.4690
    305.1990
    415.4650

    1449.0110

    1157.7360

    1502.4950

    1450.0000

    1150.0000

    1500.0000

    1.0010

    0.9930

    0.9980

    oi
    1270.5060
    1491.0350
    1100.2820
    1251.3560
    5113.1790
    5113.1790

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.0040
    1.0060
    1.0000
    0.9990

    5125
    5100
    1.0020
    0.9970

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    311.5450
    355.7970
    190.6250
    145.5810

    2
    271.7460
    282.5930
    377.3180
    519.2080

    3
    339.0220
    420.3130
    226.1530
    170.0540

    4
    348.7100
    434.3390
    304.8940
    414.8420

    Dd

    1003.5480

    1450.8650

    1155.5420

    1502.7850

    Dd'

    1000.0000

    1450.0000

    1150.0000

    1500.0000

    0.9970

    0.9990

    0.9950

    0.9980

    Ed

    oi
    1271.0230
    1493.0420
    1098.9900
    1249.6850
    5112.7400
    5112.7400

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.0030
    1.0050
    1.0010
    1.0000

    5125
    5100
    1.0020
    0.9970

    b. metode detroit
    tabel 2

    iterasi 1

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    250
    250
    175
    125

    2
    220
    200
    350
    450

    3
    325
    350
    250
    175

    4
    275
    300
    275
    350

    Dd

    800

    1220

    1100

    1200

    Dd'

    1000

    1450

    1150

    1500

    Ed

    1.25000 1.18900 1.04500 1.25000

    oi
    1070
    1100
    1050
    1100
    4320
    4320

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.19200
    1.36400
    1.04800
    1.13600

    5125
    5100
    1.18500
    1.18400

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    314.34600
    359.70500
    193.46000
    149.78900

    2
    263.12500
    273.72100
    368.03800
    512.92600

    3
    341.63100
    420.99800
    231.04600
    175.31300

    Dd

    1017.30000

    1417.81000

    1168.98800

    Dd'

    1000.00000

    1450.00000

    1150.00000

    Ed

    0.98300

    1.02300

    0.98400

    iterasi 2
    4
    345.78100
    431.64600
    304.00800
    419.40900
    1500.84400

    1500.00000
    0.99900

    oi
    1264.88300
    1486.07000
    1096.55200
    1257.43700
    5104.94200
    5104.94200

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.00800
    1.00900
    1.00300
    0.99400

    5125
    5100
    1.00400
    0.99700

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    310.23300
    355.35100
    189.98200
    145.77600

    2
    270.24900
    281.41100
    376.12800
    519.49700

    3
    337.50400
    416.32500
    227.12300
    170.79000

    4
    346.81100
    433.36200
    303.40200
    414.81600

    Dd

    1001.34200

    1447.28500

    1151.74200

    1498.39100

    Dd'

    1000.00000

    1450.00000

    1150.00000

    1500.00000

    Ed

    0.99900

    1.00200

    0.99800

    1.00100

    oi
    1264.79700
    1486.44900
    1096.63500
    1250.87900
    5098.76000
    5098.76000

    iterasi 3
    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.00800
    1.00900
    1.00300
    0.99900

    5125
    5100
    1.00500
    1.00000

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    310.848
    356.409
    189.414
    144.761

    2
    271.598
    283.096
    376.130
    517.428

    3
    337.834
    417.146
    226.218
    169.431

    4
    348.194
    435.522
    303.101
    412.752

    Dd

    1001.43200

    1448.25200

    1150.62900

    1499.56900

    Dd'

    1000.000

    1450.000

    1150.000

    1500.000

    Ed

    0.999

    1.001

    0.999

    1.000

    oi
    1268.47400
    1492.17300
    1094.86300
    1244.37200
    5099.88200
    5099.88200

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.005
    1.005
    1.005
    1.005

    5125
    5100
    1.00500
    1.00000

    iterasi 4

    iterasi 5

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    310.537
    356.053
    189.225
    144.616

    2
    271.870
    283.379
    376.506
    517.945

    3
    337.496
    416.729
    225.992
    169.262

    4
    348.194
    435.522
    303.101
    412.752

    Dd

    1000.43100

    1449.70000

    1149.47900

    1499.56900

    Dd'

    1000.00000

    1450.00000

    1150.00000

    1500.00000

    Ed

    1.000

    1.000

    1.000

    1.000

    oi
    1268.09700
    1491.68300
    1094.82400
    1244.57500
    5099.17900
    5099.17900

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.005
    1.006
    1.005
    1.004

    5125
    5100
    1.00500
    1.00000

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    310.537
    356.407
    189.225
    144.472

    2
    271.870
    283.661
    376.506
    517.430

    Dd

    1000.64100

    1449.46700

    Dd'

    1000.00000

    1450.00000

    Ed

    0.999

    1.000

    iterasi 6
    3
    337.496
    417.144
    225.992
    169.094

    4
    348.194
    435.955
    303.101
    412.341

    1149.72600

    1499.59100

    1150.00000 1500.00000
    1.000

    1.000

    oi
    1268.09700
    1493.16700
    1094.82400
    1243.33700
    5099.42500
    5099.42500

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.005
    1.005
    1.005
    1.005

    5125
    5100
    1.00500
    1.00000

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    310.226
    356.051
    189.036
    144.328

    2
    271.870
    283.661
    376.506
    517.430

    3
    337.496
    417.144
    225.992
    169.094

    4
    348.194
    435.955
    303.101
    412.341

    Dd

    999.64100

    1449.46700

    1149.72600

    1499.59100

    Dd'

    1000.00000

    1450.00000

    1150.00000 1500.00000

    Ed

    1.000

    1.000

    1.000

    1.000

    iterasi 7
    oi
    1267.78600
    1492.81100
    1094.63500
    1243.19300
    5098.42500
    5098.42500

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.006
    1.005
    1.005
    1.005

    5125
    5100
    1.00500
    1.00000

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    310.535
    356.051
    189.036
    144.328

    2
    272.141
    283.661
    376.506
    517.430

    3
    337.832
    417.144
    225.992
    169.094

    4
    348.540
    435.955
    303.101
    412.341

    Dd

    999.95000

    1449.73800

    1150.06200

    1499.93700

    Dd'

    1000.00000

    1450.00000

    1150.00000

    1500.00000

    Ed

    1.000

    1.000

    1.000

    1.000

    oi
    1269.04800
    1492.81100
    1094.63500
    1243.19300
    5099.68700
    5099.68700

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.005
    1.005
    1.005
    1.005

    5125
    5100
    1.00500
    1.00000

    c. metode furness
    tabel 2

    iterasi 1

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    250
    250
    175
    125

    2
    220
    200
    350
    450

    3
    325
    350
    250
    175

    4
    275
    300
    275
    350

    Dd

    800

    1220

    1100

    1200

    Dd'

    1000

    1450

    1150

    1500

    Ed

    1.25000 1.18900 1.04500 1.25000

    oi
    1070
    1100
    1050
    1100
    4320
    4320

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.19200
    1.36400
    1.04800
    1.13600

    5125
    5100
    1.18500
    1.18350

    tid*ei

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    298.000
    341.000
    183.400
    142.000

    2
    262.240
    272.800
    366.800
    511.200

    3
    387.400
    477.400
    262.000
    198.800

    Dd

    964.40000

    1413.04000

    1325.60000

    Dd'

    1000

    1450

    1150

    1500

    Ed

    1.037

    1.026

    0.868

    1.054

    4
    327.800
    409.200
    288.200
    397.600

    oi
    1275.44000
    1500.40000
    1100.40000
    1249.60000
    5125.84000
    1422.80000
    5125.84000

    ITERASI 2
    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4
    Dd

    5125
    5100
    1.00000
    0.99625

    tid*ED
    1
    309.026
    353.617
    190.186
    147.254

    2
    269.058
    279.893
    376.337
    524.491

    iterasi 3
    3
    336.263
    414.383
    227.416
    172.558

    4
    345.501
    431.297
    303.763
    419.070

    oi
    1259.84800
    1479.19000
    1097.70200
    1263.37300
    5100.11300
    1000.08300 1449.77900 1150.62000 1499.63100
    5100.11300

    Dd'

    1000

    1450

    1150

    1500

    Ed

    1.000

    1.000

    0.999

    1.000

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.012
    1.014
    1.002
    0.989

    5125
    5100
    1.00425
    0.99975

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    312.734
    358.568
    190.566
    145.634

    Dd

    1007.50200

    Dd'

    1000

    Ed

    0.993

    tid*EI
    2
    272.287
    283.812
    377.090
    518.722

    ITERASI 4
    3
    340.298
    420.184
    227.871
    170.660

    4
    349.647
    437.335
    304.371
    414.460

    oi
    1274.96600
    1499.89900
    1099.89800
    1249.47600
    5124.23900
    1451.91100 1159.01300 1505.81300
    5124.23900
    1450

    1150

    1500

    0.999

    0.992

    0.996

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    310.545
    356.058
    189.232
    144.615

    2
    272.015
    283.528
    376.713
    518.203

    3
    337.576
    416.823
    226.048
    169.295

    4
    348.248
    435.586
    303.154
    412.802

    Dd'

    1000

    1450

    1150

    1500

    Ed

    1.000

    1.000

    1.000

    1.000

    Dd
    5125
    5100
    1.00000
    0.99500

    tid*ED

    oi
    1268.38400
    1491.99500
    1095.14700
    1244.91500
    5100.44100
    1000.45000 1450.45900 1149.74200 1499.79000
    5100.44100

    ITERASI 5
    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.005
    1.005
    1.004
    1.004

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4
    Dd

    5125
    5100
    1.00450
    1.00000

    tid*EI

    1
    312.098
    357.838
    189.989
    145.193

    2
    273.375
    284.946
    378.220
    520.276

    ITERASI 6
    3
    339.264
    418.907
    226.952
    169.972

    4
    349.989
    437.764
    304.367
    414.453

    oi
    1274.72600
    1499.45500
    1099.52800
    1249.89400
    5123.60300
    1005.1180 1456.8170 1155.0950 1506.5730
    5123.60300

    Dd'

    1000

    1450

    1150

    1500

    Ed

    0.995

    0.995

    0.996

    0.996

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4
    Dd

    5125
    5100
    1.00000
    0.99550

    1
    310.538
    356.049
    189.039
    144.467

    2
    272.008
    283.521
    376.329
    517.675

    1000.0930 1449.5330

    Dd'

    1000

    1450

    Ed

    1.000

    1.000

    tid*ED
    3
    337.907
    417.231
    226.044
    169.292
    1150.4740

    ITERASI 7
    4
    348.589
    436.013
    303.150
    412.795

    oi
    1269.04200
    1492.81400
    1094.56200
    1244.22900
    5100.64700
    1500.5470
    5100.64700

    1150

    1500

    1.000

    1.000

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.005
    1.005
    1.005
    1.005

    5125
    5100
    1.00500
    1.00000

    tid*EI

    zona
    1
    2
    3
    4

    1
    312.091
    357.829
    189.984
    145.189

    2
    273.368
    284.939
    378.211
    520.263

    3
    339.597
    419.317
    227.174
    170.138

    4
    350.332
    438.193
    304.666
    414.859

    Dd

    1005.0930

    1456.7810

    1156.2260

    1508.0500

    Dd'

    1000

    1450

    1150

    1500

    Ed

    0.995

    0.995

    0.995

    0.995

    oi
    1275.38800
    1500.27800
    1100.03500
    1250.44900
    5126.15000

    OI
    1275
    1500
    1100
    1250

    EI
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000

    5125
    5100
    1.00000
    0.99500

    You might also like