When the truck crashes into the boat, Elizabeth is knocked unconscious inside the truck. After her flashback, she wakes up several feet outside the truck.
When Andy runs from the fog, the sky is light blue. When he runs inside the house and the fog climbs up the door, the sky is black. A shot or two later, the sky is dark blue.
When the old beach-comber finds the dining room table set up on the beach, the table and chairs are alternately well above the water line and several inches deep in still water between shots.
When Stevie goes into the lighthouse to work, the bulletin board in the background shows her son's drawings and pictures. They're in different places in the next shot. When they catch fire, they're in different places again.
In a flashback, when the founding fathers put their hands together, three of them stand side by side. When the fourth puts his hand in, a shot from below shows them at 90 degree angle to each other.
Elizabeth notes on the photographs that "something happened" in 1871, and the town sprung up from a few shacks to a thriving community. Elizabeth's photos predate 1871. Many Western US towns started as collections of shacks around springs, mines, or railroads. The "founding" could be the day a collection of shacks became a formal town.
In the end credits, the actor playing the role of Mr Machen, the beachcomber, has been listed as "RNELSONBROWN", without spaces.
When the bodies are reeled in from the sea grass, the bottom body blinks for a second.
Elizabeth uses a lighter on the lid of the old watch , and right away she wipes away the soot with her thumb , the metal would not only still be hot but would have burned her thumb pretty good .
When Elizabeth wakes up in the night at Nick's house, she is making a pencil rubbing of the "scales of justice" hallmark she has been researching. But there is nothing for her to be taking the rubbing from.
At the start of the boat party scene, Spooner is holding the camera. He say "Hey, yo Sean." to get Sean's attention, followed by "Get your ass up here and take the helm." However, the line "Hey, yo Sean." is clearly dubbed in place of a different phrase.
Tom Malone's stunt double is clearly visible when he's being attacked on the church. The stunt man wears a wig that proves to be unsuited for the character who is slightly bald while the wig has longer hair when he moves.
There are no large islands off the Oregon coast.
Nick hands Elizabeth a camera he found on the Seagrass. She says "It's evidence." Nick responds "I know, it might prove that Spooner is innocent." For that reason, Nick should have given the camera to the police instead of hiding it from them.
Spooner suddenly reappears in the church where a few people are reunited to escape the fog, and among the people there's Tom Malone, who a few scenes earlier had asked for the arrest of Spooner after the deaths on the boat. Yet when Spooner enters the place, Tom isn't worried about his presence neither says anything to the guy.
Why is Elizabeth pounding on the church door calling for the father, when the door is padlocked on the outside. Obviously no one could be inside. **Why not? Most churches have more than one door.**
When the lighthouse notice board catches fire, Stevie puts it out with a CO2 fire extinguisher. She holds the nozzle, which isn't recommended with CO2 extinguishers; her hand should've frozen to the nozzle.