User reviews

Whether you love it, hate it, or just plain like it, you can't deny that The Blair Witch Project was a landmark in the horror genre and paved the way for a new sub-genre in the category. The found footage genre of horror has now greatly expanded in present day and now, the franchise getting the Blair Witch treatment is Paranormal Activity.

But this isn't a history lesson of the genre. This is a review of Sticks and Stones: An Exploration of the Blair Witch Legend, a direct-to-VHS documentary released the same year as the film The Blair Witch Project. The thirty minute documentary documents the legacy, the aftermath, the response, and the myth of the Blair Witch who supposedly inhabits a woodsy area in Maryland.

I say "supposedly" because this isn't a documentary. It's a collection of fictionalized events with actors playing fictionalized people in efforts to further that the myth and the film are real. Why do I say this? Because a quick look on IMDb proves this is all quackery. We supposedly get interviews from "Bill Barnes, Burkittsville historian." A quick search of that name pulls up "Bill Dreggors, actor" who has appeared in a number of other Blair Witch films/documentaries playing the same character.

Same thing goes for "Charles Moorhouse" who is said to be Professor of Folklore, Hampshire College. Quick search tells me it's a man by the name of "Charlie Carlson" who has written screenplays and books about the paranormal and has played the same character in other Blair Witch films, as well.

The tape, Stick and Stones, was not only to try and further the accusations and events in the film to be of a true nature, but to try and increase rental sales of the feature film. Some people actually believed it. There was no formal and consistent use of the internet in 1999 like there is today, and it surely wasn't blessed with as much information as we have today.

So why am I awarding a fairly high rating to a fictional documentary? For a few reasons. Not only is it persistent in its efforts to try and make us believe this myth, but it captures a more naive time in the horror world. When people believed everything they heard about this film. The film is rather convincing, as it also gets interviews from Blair Witch Project star Joshua Leonard's father and Michael C. Williams' brother Tom talking about their reactions to each of their relative's disappearance.

Now, the hype and questions brought from The Blair Witch Project have greatly simmered, information is in barrels online and the false nature of this film has been exposed. Because of all that, I can't exactly really recommend Sticks and Stones: An Exploration of the Blair Witch Legacy with my head held high. All I can do is stand on the sidelines and watch in amazement how one movie, shot for less than a million dollars, unintentionally changed the face of horror and made untold millions at the box office.

NOTE: Oh, and don't fall for the faulty newscasts shown in the film too. I was skeptical, but it turns out Joseph Nagy isn't with the Channel 11 News and Minette Marcial not with the Channel 6 News either. Just with the "impressively fake actor committee." Starring: Heather Donahue, Joshua Leonard, and Michael C. Williams, Joe Nagy, Minette Marcial, Bill Dreggors, and Charlie Carlson.

This short film was originally offered by Blockbuster Video to promote the rental and sales of THE BLAIR WITCH PROJECT video when it was first released. There is an amusing comment at the beginning of STICKS & STONES indicating that Blockbuster didn't go looking for the added footage because "You'd have to be crazy to go into those woods."

Much of the film is scenes from THE BLAIR WITCH PROJECT and CURSE OF THE BLAIR WITCH. But two new pieces of film are tacked on at the end, one of which provides a provocative added clue or misclue to the mystery. This clue adds support to one of the many theories of what happened in THE BLAIR WITCH PROJECT, namely that there was some sort of time warp involved which prevented the search party from seeing the three missing college students even though the searchers covered the same territory where the students disappeared.

STICKS & STONES isn't particularly important except for the two new pieces of film. If the viewer has no interest in the Blair Witch myth, then this film will be of no interest either. But for fans, it's another piece in the puzzle.

This one was so exciting that I fell asleep about half way through, and it only runs for 30 minutes. Viewed the remainder later. What a crock of s.... The film danced around so much as to be unable to see anything. Like its trying to say, I want to show you this but you can't look at it. The melodrama of the talking heads is pathetic at best. I rated it awful just because there was nothing lower. Be glad you missed it. Its not a documentary, but a contrived piece to make you believe it is. A movie you definitely will want to miss.

This is the concluding trilogy of the original "The Blair Witch Project". Quite frankly, both "The Blair Witch Project" and "The Curse of the Blair Witch Project" are better.

"Sticks and Stones: Investigating the Blair Witch" seems/seemed to just be another way to cash in on the The Blair Witch Phenomenon, a phenomenon that is being totally milked dry.

I guess the film is ok, if you absolutely loved the first one, but this continuing trend of finding lost footage and of more interviews is/was getting annoying. There essentially is nothing new here and the performances and writing are nothing special. It is a short film that will be easily forgotten and I doubt it will be redistributed when the next line of Blair Witch 2 products come out.

As a side story, and possibly showing how doomed "Sticks and Stones: Investigating the Blair Witch" was, Blockbuster originally gave this as a free rental to "The Blair With Project". Then it was a PVT and there were so many of them that eventually the local store was selling them for 1cent with any purchase. I thought 1cent, what the heck? My recommendation to you though is to save your penny.

VOTES: The Blair Witch Project-->3: Curse of the Blair Witch Project-->6: Sticks and Stones: Investigating the Blair Witch-->2

Viewed: The Blair Witch Project--> Theatre: Curse of the Blair Witch Project--> VHS: Sticks and Stones: Investigating the Blair Witch--> VHS

At only a half hour of running time, STICKS AND STONES is something that you can afford to watch. It was originally released as a Blockbuster Exclusive to promote rentals of THE BLAIR WITCH PROJECT. There are some notable scenes in here, considering that the whole "documentary" was faked in the first place.

Most of the footage contained here is lifted from the Discovery Channel documentary CURSE OF THE BLAIR WITCH, which is probably a better watch. But, this film is better in the sense that it is shorter and has some footage not contained in CURSE OF THE BLAIR WITCH (some of the new footage is even pretty interesting).

All in all, this film is worth the watch. And even if you don't think it is, you'll only be wasting a half hour. I really do feel that this film is a good addition to the mythology of the Blair Witch...but, remember...it's just a movie.

STICKS AND STONES gets 4/5.