"The Golden Arrow" has a plot that had real potential for a top comedy. But, unfortunately the film doesn't have a screenplay or script that will do the job. Instead, the story is lame at times, with holes in places, and generally weak in performances. Johnny Jones can't love a rich Daisy Appleby, but he can love her if she's not that person. That part is very old and warn out in movies. The surprise twist in this film might have saved it yet, but for the weak script, and especially weak and limp performance by George Brent as Jones.
Bette Davis was known and made her mark as a dramatic actress. She didn't do much comedy, but she was very capable in some comedy films. Hers is the only real good role in this film, but it's not nearly enough to overcome the weak screenplay. And, this is the worst I've ever seen Brent. His character is almost lifeless. He showed a little promise in the opening scene with Davis's Daisy Appleby, but he just went limp and nearly listless after that. His acting like a heel was more that of a blasé or dull character. It was almost as if he were drugged and barely able to be aware of where he was or what he was doing.
This film wouldn't rate six stars but for Davis and Eugene Pallette's role as Mr. Meyers. Pallette always adds something to films he is in - maybe for no other reason than that his persona, with build and voice are so unusual and stand out. And, he was very good at his craft of acting with that persona.
Except for die hard fans of Davis, and maybe one or two others, most others would probably have a hard time sitting through this film to the finish.
Here's the best line that comes close to comedy in the film. Johnny Jones, to his butler, "If you tip me off if I forget to be a heel, I'll keep you."