The screenplay of Jacques Feyder is very modern:in its own way,it predates , by 25 and more than 40 years respectively Hitchcock's "Vertigo" and Bunuel's "object of desire" .
A man has to join the legion étrangere to avoid a scandal.He leaves his lover,a selfish spoiled woman he is always in love with and heads for the desert:there ,in the brothel,he meets a hooker who extremely resembles her former woman.Is she THE ONE?Sometimes it seems she is and sometimes she isn't.Marie Bell's voice was dubbed for the part of the prostitute,so there were actually two actresses almost like in Bunuel's last film.
However,it seems to me that when you watch the movie some 70 years after something is lacking and it is madness.The silent era could create it and whereas we would need folie à deux,amour fou,we're left with melodrama.Pierre Richard-Wilm was a rather bland handsome actor while Marie Bell had not enough presence,not enough ambiguity.Françoise Rosay ,the madam who draws cards ("the major arcana" is the meaning of the title)and discovers very strange things about the future,-which does nothing but accentuates the melodramatic side-,and Charles Vanel as the "house"'s owner easily outstrip both of them.There is one scene Luis Bunuel would not have disowned: Marie Bell,taking flypaper down with Vanel's lustful eye on her legs.
The Légion Etrangère as a way out when you were threatened in your native country was a permanent feature in the years before WW2:that was also the subjects of "Beau Geste" and Duvivier's "la bandera" .But whereas the two other works focus on every aspect of a Légionnaire's life,in Feyder's movie ,we almost never move out of the brothel.I hardly exaggerate.It's not surprising it was stigmatized by the Catholic Office of Cinema :what else could they do? Marcel Carné was influenced by Jacques Feyder.Not only he was his assistant,but he also met his favorite actress Arletty while they were making "pension mimosas".And Feyder's wife Françoise Rosay starred in Carné's first real movie "Jenny".
Robert Siodmak made a remake in 1954,Jean-Claude Pascal,Gina Lollobrigida and Arletty taking on Richard-Willm's ,Bell's and Rosay's parts.It was a disappointment.
