ADA Vincent Day (Warren William) successfully prosecutes a man for murder through only circumstantial evidence, and when his innocence is discovered Day tries to contact the prison before the man is executed, only to be too late. He is torn up about this, resigns, and then oddly tries to right his wrong by becoming a criminal defense lawyer and getting acquittals for people who are very guilty. He does this sometimes just through his great talent, but he also does some dishonest and very risky things.
Day also likes the ladies, and he hires naive country mouse Celia Farraday (Sidney Fox) for his office staff planning to seduce her. But when her reaction to his advances is not what he expects he has a rebirth of conscience. This conscience comes in handy when Celia's fiance is arrested and accused of stealing his employer's bonds though he claims that he was robbed, and he doesn't seem to have a consistent believable story at all. Complications ensue.
This was the part that got Warren William noticed. He had been playing the cad for about a year, but his performances, though enchanting, didn't have the depth and empathy of his role in The Mouthpiece. The success of this film caused him to be placed in similar roles in a string of precode movies to the point he was typecast and had a hard time continuing his career at the leading man level once the precode era ended. Sidney Fox, largely a Universal star, really does well here. It may even be the best thing she ever did, in spite of that rather distracting southern accent. With Aline MacMahon as Day's Girl Friday with her usual witticisms and wise girl attitude, this one is well worth watching 90 years later.
