Film review: 'The General's Daughter'
Well on his way to becoming a new action hero, John Travolta's burly Army investigator battles a vicious gun smuggler and flirts with an attractive enlisted woman before Paramount's "The General's Daughter" turns into a fairly routine murder mystery set in the hothouse environment of fictitious Fort MacCallum, Ga.
Based on the novel by Nelson DeMille -- tailored by screenwriters William Goldman and Christopher Bertolini to draw the viewer into a heavy drama of potentially West Point-destroying crimes and other nasty secrets among our men in uniform -- "General's Daughter" doesn't look to be a huge winner at the boxoffice, but it should march off to a strong opening and finish with a healthy theatrical run.
James Cromwell is Joe Campbell, a U.S. vice president-bound, much-loved general with a big problem. His daughter Elisabeth (Leslie Stefanson) is a captain on the same base, and her beguiling skill while changing the tire of cigar-chomping Army-dick-in-disguise Paul Brenner (Travolta) is tame behavior. A psychological operations instructor and researcher, Elisabeth never recovered from a horrible incident she barely lived through years earlier during training at West Point, when she was one of very few women cadets.
When she finally chooses a dramatic and dangerous way of confronting her cowardly father about his role in her past, Elisabeth is apparently raped and strangled, left naked and dead in the road near the shot-up fake buildings where soldiers practice urban warfare. A Vietnam War survivor who served under Campbell, Brenner swings into action but never quite drops the Old Boy shtick.
This don't-screw-with-me maverick is able to uncover the truth about Elisabeth's death without much trouble. Along to make sure the investigator remembers he's a cop first and soldier second -- and to provide minimal sparks in a nearly romanceless date-night flick -- Sarah Sunhill (Madeleine Stowe) is also an Army sleuth who had a fling with Brenner years before.
The two crusaders for truth and justice suspect, investigate and practically have to blow the noses of a trio of weepy, remorseful colonels: Elisabeth's shifty boss in psy-ops (James Woods), Brenner's old buddy and the current provost marshal (Timothy Hutton) and Campbell's menacing adjutant (Clarence Williams III).
Travolta squints nastily and snarls his lines, while Stowe bats her eyes and flings out a few helpful observations. Travolta plays the hero like a heavy but not too roughly. Both do what they can with the characters, but they're the least interesting of a pretty dull group to begin with.
Be it the source material or director Simon West's much-too-kind approach to it, "General's Daughter" is also mangled storytelling, with the revelations growing progressively more kinky, felonious and preposterous. While the murder in question keeps changing in nature, with the leads stumbling into helpful witnesses and a few macho unfriendlies, the identity of the perpetrator is a too-well-guarded secret until near the end.
In its tone and serious subject matter, "General's Daughter" strives to be a political nail-biter in the tradition of Fred Zinnemann, Alan J. Pakula and Oliver Stone -- director John Frankenheimer even has a small role -- but there's really no comparison.
THE GENERAL'S DAUGHTER
Paramount Pictures
A Mace Neufeld and Robert Rehme production
Director:Simon West
Producer:Mace Neufeld
Executive producer:Jonathan D. Krane
Co-producer:Stratton Leopold
Screenwriters:William Goldman, Christopher Bertolini
Based on the novel by:Nelson DeMille
Director of photography:Peter Menzies Jr.
Production designer:Dennis Washington
Editor:Glen Scantlebury
Costume designer:Erica Edell Phillips
Music:Carter Burwell
Color/stereo
Cast:
Paul Brenner:John Travolta
Sarah Sunhill:Madeleine Stowe
Gen. Joe Campbell:James Cromwell
Col. William Kent:Timothy Hutton
Col. Robert Moore:James Woods
Col. George Fowler:Clarence Williams III
Capt. Elisabeth Campbell:Leslie Stefanson
Running time -- 116 minutes
MPAA rating: R...
Based on the novel by Nelson DeMille -- tailored by screenwriters William Goldman and Christopher Bertolini to draw the viewer into a heavy drama of potentially West Point-destroying crimes and other nasty secrets among our men in uniform -- "General's Daughter" doesn't look to be a huge winner at the boxoffice, but it should march off to a strong opening and finish with a healthy theatrical run.
James Cromwell is Joe Campbell, a U.S. vice president-bound, much-loved general with a big problem. His daughter Elisabeth (Leslie Stefanson) is a captain on the same base, and her beguiling skill while changing the tire of cigar-chomping Army-dick-in-disguise Paul Brenner (Travolta) is tame behavior. A psychological operations instructor and researcher, Elisabeth never recovered from a horrible incident she barely lived through years earlier during training at West Point, when she was one of very few women cadets.
When she finally chooses a dramatic and dangerous way of confronting her cowardly father about his role in her past, Elisabeth is apparently raped and strangled, left naked and dead in the road near the shot-up fake buildings where soldiers practice urban warfare. A Vietnam War survivor who served under Campbell, Brenner swings into action but never quite drops the Old Boy shtick.
This don't-screw-with-me maverick is able to uncover the truth about Elisabeth's death without much trouble. Along to make sure the investigator remembers he's a cop first and soldier second -- and to provide minimal sparks in a nearly romanceless date-night flick -- Sarah Sunhill (Madeleine Stowe) is also an Army sleuth who had a fling with Brenner years before.
The two crusaders for truth and justice suspect, investigate and practically have to blow the noses of a trio of weepy, remorseful colonels: Elisabeth's shifty boss in psy-ops (James Woods), Brenner's old buddy and the current provost marshal (Timothy Hutton) and Campbell's menacing adjutant (Clarence Williams III).
Travolta squints nastily and snarls his lines, while Stowe bats her eyes and flings out a few helpful observations. Travolta plays the hero like a heavy but not too roughly. Both do what they can with the characters, but they're the least interesting of a pretty dull group to begin with.
Be it the source material or director Simon West's much-too-kind approach to it, "General's Daughter" is also mangled storytelling, with the revelations growing progressively more kinky, felonious and preposterous. While the murder in question keeps changing in nature, with the leads stumbling into helpful witnesses and a few macho unfriendlies, the identity of the perpetrator is a too-well-guarded secret until near the end.
In its tone and serious subject matter, "General's Daughter" strives to be a political nail-biter in the tradition of Fred Zinnemann, Alan J. Pakula and Oliver Stone -- director John Frankenheimer even has a small role -- but there's really no comparison.
THE GENERAL'S DAUGHTER
Paramount Pictures
A Mace Neufeld and Robert Rehme production
Director:Simon West
Producer:Mace Neufeld
Executive producer:Jonathan D. Krane
Co-producer:Stratton Leopold
Screenwriters:William Goldman, Christopher Bertolini
Based on the novel by:Nelson DeMille
Director of photography:Peter Menzies Jr.
Production designer:Dennis Washington
Editor:Glen Scantlebury
Costume designer:Erica Edell Phillips
Music:Carter Burwell
Color/stereo
Cast:
Paul Brenner:John Travolta
Sarah Sunhill:Madeleine Stowe
Gen. Joe Campbell:James Cromwell
Col. William Kent:Timothy Hutton
Col. Robert Moore:James Woods
Col. George Fowler:Clarence Williams III
Capt. Elisabeth Campbell:Leslie Stefanson
Running time -- 116 minutes
MPAA rating: R...
- 6/11/1999
- The Hollywood Reporter - Movie News
IMDb.com, Inc. takes no responsibility for the content or accuracy of the above news articles, Tweets, or blog posts. This content is published for the entertainment of our users only. The news articles, Tweets, and blog posts do not represent IMDb's opinions nor can we guarantee that the reporting therein is completely factual. Please visit the source responsible for the item in question to report any concerns you may have regarding content or accuracy.