Reading the negative review on here is sometimes a chore. Its clear that the people rating this negatively clearly have a political bias that disables them from seeing clearly.
While it's not the greatest acting ever (and was never supposed to be), putting ultra-dry, intractably base Matt Walsh at the helm of getting to say exactly what he wants about absurd morality and idiotic choices that are cheered on in the general 'big machine' media is a gem.
Matt Walsh hates all stupidity and obviously inept decision making and he is never afraid to say so. Additionally, the hilarity of the show is that the fanbase who would watch it all already agree from the outset of a case how stupid it is that people even have to get to this level of the legal system, to need an arbitrator to decide how things should be worked out.
This is a funny show, if you like Matt Walsh or not. But, to enjoy it, you do need some sense of morality.