Merritt Patterson is one of my favorite actors and I also like Trevor Donovan. My main complaint with this movie is the plot device of showing the characters lives only around successive Christmases. This device has been used several times, but it isn't as overused as many other premises.
The background for it all is a cornucopia of the usual stuff. Addie just broke up after a long term relationship. What little family she has is off jet setting for the holidays. Grandma decides to do some matchmaking. Both Addie and James will be leaving town soon after Christmas dinner. There were many other echoes of other Christmas movies, especially early on.
My problem is that there is too much jumping forward into next year and not enough spending time together and getting to know each other. Between Christmases their lives move on and we get brief recaps at the beginning of the next season. I thought it showed in the acting. Donovan and Patterson did a movie together last year and should have had great chemistry but I didn't really see it. It seemed like they were going through the motions to get on to the next Christmas.
Many Christmas movies have a cute kid that adds a spark and forms a bond with one of the leads. Paige did not play a big role in that sense. And two years after we first see her, she hasn't changed which isn't noticeable in an adult, but should be obvious in an early teen.
The movie is family friendly but might not have a lot to attract small children.
I continue to hope for great things from Great American Family, but it is not a good sign if two of their best veteran actors fail to deliver in one of the first premieres of the season.