VALUTAZIONE IMDb
7,1/10
1184
LA TUA VALUTAZIONE
Edmond Dantes viene accusato ingiustamente da chi è geloso della sua fortuna e viene condannato a trascorrere il resto della sua vita nella famigerata prigione dell'isola, Chateau d'If.Edmond Dantes viene accusato ingiustamente da chi è geloso della sua fortuna e viene condannato a trascorrere il resto della sua vita nella famigerata prigione dell'isola, Chateau d'If.Edmond Dantes viene accusato ingiustamente da chi è geloso della sua fortuna e viene condannato a trascorrere il resto della sua vita nella famigerata prigione dell'isola, Chateau d'If.
- Premi
- 1 vittoria
Louis Seigner
- Le bijoutier Joannès
- (as Louis Seigner de la Comédie Française)
Claude Génia
- La Carconte
- (as Claude Genia)
Jean Témerson
- Le roi Louis XVIII
- (as Jean Temerson)
Julien Bertheau
- L'empereur Napoléon I
- (as Julien Bertheau de la Comédie Française)
Gualtiero Tumiati
- L'abbé Faria
- (as Gualtieri Tumiati)
José Casa
- L'aubergiste
- (non citato nei titoli originali)
Marcel Delaître
- Le geôlier
- (non citato nei titoli originali)
Guy Favières
- Un homme chez M. Morel à la vente du bateau
- (non citato nei titoli originali)
Trama
Lo sapevi?
- QuizFilm in two parts: 1) La trahison / 2) La vengeance
- BlooperWhen de Villefort during the 100 days reign of Napoleon starts writing a letter to release Dantès, he stops to show his visitors to the door. When he returns to his desk and puts the letter into the drawer of his desk, the letter is already finished and signed.
- ConnessioniFeatured in Pelísky (1999)
Recensione in evidenza
The plot of the classic need not be retold here - it was one what we loved in our teen and pre-teen ages about half a century back, along with other classics (of course translated) of Dumas (and his contemporary - of same year of Birth) Hugo, of course along with many others - but these two names strike the mind - the Musketeers (all three of them), Black Tulip, the Hunchback - of recently ravaged Notre Dame, are some of the names I still recall.
This movie is well adapted to the original one, and with Marais in the central role, not much can be improved in acting department. Despite the long duration, about 3 hours - it doesn't bore, of course neither did the huge novels of those times, due to the well paced rendition. Both the parts had been more or less faithfully adapted from the novel.
Some of the factors are of course missing- for example the method of tunnel digging and disposing off the grits, or the way Dante managed to be inside the sack - but probably they were required for the written version, for the screen version they were not mandatory.
Another major difference - again it didn't matter in the adaptation - was foresaking the Baron Dangler - and rather merging it into two avatars - or mainly into the Caderousse role (Villefort only used the name, for his secret affair) - that would be a missing aspect, especially since instead of the four Marseilles, it was brought down to three, but only for those who have read it. And also probably it reduced some running time - that character and the retribution would have brought in at least another half an hour. And it would have been important - since the side-plot of Morel's daughter and Dangler's son also would have to be retained, to keep Dante's level of revenge in control. But over all this had been quite faithful adaptation - in two episodes - probably avoiding the third - which would definitely have cause audience exasperation., and without missing much from the main story line, trimming the branches, and characters where it could be. And it didn't much mess up with history either. Of course neither did the novel. I wonder who was Morel's daughter in (in First part), she was quite pretty, but there is no name in credits or even outside it. She had half the screen time at least, as her father, and may be much more than some other figures - say Emperor Napoleon, King Louise XVIII etc.
Worth watching - if there is still child in you, it won't bore.
This movie is well adapted to the original one, and with Marais in the central role, not much can be improved in acting department. Despite the long duration, about 3 hours - it doesn't bore, of course neither did the huge novels of those times, due to the well paced rendition. Both the parts had been more or less faithfully adapted from the novel.
Some of the factors are of course missing- for example the method of tunnel digging and disposing off the grits, or the way Dante managed to be inside the sack - but probably they were required for the written version, for the screen version they were not mandatory.
Another major difference - again it didn't matter in the adaptation - was foresaking the Baron Dangler - and rather merging it into two avatars - or mainly into the Caderousse role (Villefort only used the name, for his secret affair) - that would be a missing aspect, especially since instead of the four Marseilles, it was brought down to three, but only for those who have read it. And also probably it reduced some running time - that character and the retribution would have brought in at least another half an hour. And it would have been important - since the side-plot of Morel's daughter and Dangler's son also would have to be retained, to keep Dante's level of revenge in control. But over all this had been quite faithful adaptation - in two episodes - probably avoiding the third - which would definitely have cause audience exasperation., and without missing much from the main story line, trimming the branches, and characters where it could be. And it didn't much mess up with history either. Of course neither did the novel. I wonder who was Morel's daughter in (in First part), she was quite pretty, but there is no name in credits or even outside it. She had half the screen time at least, as her father, and may be much more than some other figures - say Emperor Napoleon, King Louise XVIII etc.
Worth watching - if there is still child in you, it won't bore.
- sb-47-608737
- 27 apr 2019
- Permalink
I più visti
Accedi per valutare e creare un elenco di titoli salvati per ottenere consigli personalizzati
- How long is The Count of Monte Cristo?Powered by Alexa
Dettagli
- Data di uscita
- Paesi di origine
- Sito ufficiale
- Lingua
- Celebre anche come
- Il tesoro di Montecristo
- Luoghi delle riprese
- Aziende produttrici
- Vedi altri crediti dell’azienda su IMDbPro
- Tempo di esecuzione1 ora 35 minuti
- Colore
- Proporzioni
- 1.37 : 1
Contribuisci a questa pagina
Suggerisci una modifica o aggiungi i contenuti mancanti
Divario superiore
What is the English language plot outline for Le comte de Monte-Cristo (1954)?
Rispondi