Discover new books on Goodreads
Meet your next favorite book
Sebastian Gebski's Reviews > The Identity Trap: A Story of Ideas and Power in Our Time
The Identity Trap: A Story of Ideas and Power in Our Time
by
by
Standard disclaimer: this is not a review (& star rating) of the author's political viewpoint. I do rate & review the book.
Solid four stars, maybe even slightly more. What did I like?
1. The structure is very logical, and the approach is very thorough, methodical & well-balanced (no all-out emotional rants). The author applies mainly to logos, not ethos or pathos.
2. The chapter on the origins of the IS is very informative (but still, I value information from "Cynical Theories" more!)
3. I was afraid that the author would dedicate a lot of space to numerous examples of woke fallacies, but that was not the case -which is good news, as there are many publications doing that already
4. I like part III - because of how it tackled the topics of free speech & meritocracy - a lot of good argumentation, very reasonable & to the point
Is there anything I didn't like?
1. Well, some sections felt tedious and hard to get through. Not because they were so complicated or the topic required a lot of consideration. I attribute this to insufficient editing - some sections could have been made more concise & more to the point. Unfortunately, this issue manifests in the very beginning of the book, which may discourage some readers from giving it a proper go.
2. It's OK that Mounk haven't "americanized" the book with too many repetitions, but ... the book nearly screams for some punchlines & expressive models. Yes, there are summaries (after each chapter), but that is not enough IMHO.
3. I don't agree with some thesis in the appendix - and I think that some argumentation the author used was even ... naive? I'm not sure what his intentions were - maybe it's his own sentiments (he has referred to the past of his family & the beliefs of their youth).
In the end, it's a very solid, well-balanced book that doesn't use outrage but reason as an argumentation. Recommended (together with Cynical Theories). 4.2 stars.
Solid four stars, maybe even slightly more. What did I like?
1. The structure is very logical, and the approach is very thorough, methodical & well-balanced (no all-out emotional rants). The author applies mainly to logos, not ethos or pathos.
2. The chapter on the origins of the IS is very informative (but still, I value information from "Cynical Theories" more!)
3. I was afraid that the author would dedicate a lot of space to numerous examples of woke fallacies, but that was not the case -which is good news, as there are many publications doing that already
4. I like part III - because of how it tackled the topics of free speech & meritocracy - a lot of good argumentation, very reasonable & to the point
Is there anything I didn't like?
1. Well, some sections felt tedious and hard to get through. Not because they were so complicated or the topic required a lot of consideration. I attribute this to insufficient editing - some sections could have been made more concise & more to the point. Unfortunately, this issue manifests in the very beginning of the book, which may discourage some readers from giving it a proper go.
2. It's OK that Mounk haven't "americanized" the book with too many repetitions, but ... the book nearly screams for some punchlines & expressive models. Yes, there are summaries (after each chapter), but that is not enough IMHO.
3. I don't agree with some thesis in the appendix - and I think that some argumentation the author used was even ... naive? I'm not sure what his intentions were - maybe it's his own sentiments (he has referred to the past of his family & the beliefs of their youth).
In the end, it's a very solid, well-balanced book that doesn't use outrage but reason as an argumentation. Recommended (together with Cynical Theories). 4.2 stars.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Identity Trap.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
December 5, 2023
–
Started Reading
December 5, 2023
– Shelved
December 12, 2023
–
Finished Reading