What do you think?
Rate this book
464 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2013
Not the best installment in the series but I still like it.
The Ranger's Apprentice series is one of my favorites so I was very much looking forward to reading the latest installment. Overall, I guess it's my less favorite of all twelve volumes. My biggest problem with the novel? Character development.
The book centers around Will and Maddie who is the daughter of Cassandra and Horace. Maddie is portrayed as a rebellious princess who sneaks out of the castle at night to go hunting. She unselfishly gives the game she hunts to the castle guards so they can help feed their families. When confronted by her parents, Maddie explains how she wants to learn to defend herself, to have some adventure just like her parents did when they were her age. Now, this is where things go off track I think. We know from previous books in the series that Cassandra hated being stuck in the castle learning needlepoint and the other things a princess was expected to do. So you would think she would have some understanding of how her daughter feels. But, no, she does the opposite of what you would expect her to do. It's like Flannagan forgot what Cassandra did in the previous volumes of the series. It's so completely out of character that it's absurd.
So we have Maddie who wants to learn to fight and use weapons, to have adventures like her mother and father did. She's given the chance to be the first female Ranger's apprentice and what does she do? She shows up at Will's with a maid and a ton of fancy clothes thinking she can spend time with the local baron enjoying time at court! Okay, what happened here? It's like someone kidnapped the first Maddie and put a different one in her place before she got to Will's. If this Maddie was back with Cassandra they'd be having a grand time and there'd be no problems at all. It's like Flannagan had to reinvent Maddie so he could create conflict between her and Will. Not good.
Now once we get all that out of the way and the character development is finish the book is quite good. Will and Maddie go off to investigate the accidental death of another Ranger and the action starts there. This part of the story is typical Flannagan and I enjoyed it almost as much as I did the other novels. It was just way too short.
Not sure if Flannagan plans on making Maddie the subject of a new series or not. If so, my suggestion - skip it.