The American Puritans

THE

AMERICAN

PURITANS

Dustin Benge and Nate Pickowicz

Reformation Heritage Books

Grand Rapids, Michigan

The American Puritans

© 2020 by Dustin Benge and Nate Pickowicz

All rights reserved. No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles and reviews. Direct your requests to the publisher at the following addresses:

Reformation Heritage Books

2965 Leonard St. NE

Grand Rapids, MI 49525

616–977–0889

[email protected]

www.heritagebooks.org

Printed in the United States of America

20 21 22 23 24 25/10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

Names: Benge, Dustin, author. | Pickowicz, Nate, author.

Title: The American Puritans / Dustin Benge and Nate Pickowicz.

Description: Grand Rapids, Michigan : Reformation Heritage Books, 2020. | Includes bibliographical references.

Identifiers: LCCN 2020008336 (print) | LCCN 2020008337 (ebook) | ISBN 9781601787736 (paperback) | ISBN 9781601787743 (epub)

Subjects: LCSH: Puritans—New England—Biography. | Puritans—New England—History—17th century.

Classification: LCC BX9358 .B46 2020 (print) | LCC BX9358 (ebook) | DDC 285/.9092274—dc23

LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020008336

LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020008337

For additional Reformed literature, request a free book list from Reformation Heritage Books at the above regular or email address.

This book is dedicated to

all the families who fled persecution

and braved the perilous journey across

the Atlantic Ocean to seek the freedom

to worship the Lord Jesus Christ

with a clear conscience.

Contents

Foreword – Michael A. G. Haykin

Acknowledgments

Time Line

Introduction: Who Are the American Puritans?

1. William Bradford

2. John Winthrop

3. John Cotton

4. Thomas Hooker

5. Thomas Shepard

6. Anne Bradstreet

7. John Eliot

8. Samuel Willard

9. Cotton Mather

Epilogue

Foreword

Iain H. Murray has observed that without New England the history of the United States would have followed a very different pattern. What made New England different from the other British colonies formed in North America was the desire of its settlers to have a distinctive Christian character. Murray reckoned that of the 102 passengers on the Mayflower it is probable that ninety-eight belonged to the congregation of John Robinson which had been in exile in Holland since 1608. And the majority of the settlers who came to New England in successive waves between 1620 and 1640 were also ardent Christians. The ultimate failure to achieve a city upon a hill, as John Winthrop once described Puritan New England via his use of Matthew 5:14, should not blind us to these believers’ passion, their remarkable achievements, and the way that their lives and thought have shaped the American psyche.

Yet even those who love the Puritans today and have benefited from the current revival of interest in Puritania seem to have forgotten many of those who figured large in colonial New England—men such as Thomas Shepard (whom Jonathan Edwards often cited) and John Eliot (not to be confused with the martyr Jim Elliot!). Of course, Baptists remember and love that subversive Puritan, Roger Williams, as Mostyn Roberts has recently called him in his marvelous biography, but we who love church history should know many more of these figures. I am therefore deeply grateful to Dustin Benge and Nate Pickowicz for this prosopographical primer of New England Puritanism, and I hope it gets an extensive reading.

—Michael A. G. Haykin

Chair and Professor of Church History

The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary

September 3, 2019

Acknowledgments

We owe a debt of gratitude to several people for their inspiration, encouragement, and assistance. In addition to writing the foreword, Michael A. G. Haykin gave his wisdom and mentorship when we were getting cold feet during the process. Thank you, Rick Kennedy, for your insight on the Cotton Mather chapter, as well as for your endorsement. Heartfelt thanks go to Steven Lawson, Conrad Mbewe, Michael Reeves, Reiner Smolinski, Derek W. H. Thomas, and Geoff Thomas for endorsing the project. We could not be more overjoyed and thankful for Joel Beeke, Jay Collier, Dave Woollin, and Annette Gysen at Reformation Heritage Books for their tireless labors to make this project happen. We’re grateful to Andrew Buss for providing us with a thorough and meticulous edit. Additionally, we want to thank our wives and families for their unending support in this research-intensive project, which required many late nights and early mornings. Finally and foremost, we want to thank our glorious God for graciously allowing us to write this book. Whatever fruit this bears belongs solely to Him!

Time Line

1534 King Henry VIII officially breaks with the Roman Catholic Church and appoints himself as the official head of the newly established Church of England, thus establishing the foundation of the Reformation in England.

1547 Henry VIII dies, and his son Edward VI becomes king, furthering the English Reformation under the advisement of Thomas Cranmer.

1553 Edward VI dies; Mary I ascends the throne and attempts to reestablish Roman Catholicism in England, thus persecuting Protestants. This leads to the arrest and execution of leaders such as John Hooper, Hugh Latimer, Nicholas Ridley, and Thomas Cranmer; many flee England and seek asylum in places like Geneva.

1558 Mary I dies; Queen Elizabeth ascends the throne and restores Protestantism to England. She later establishes the Acts of Uniformity, followed by the adoption of the Thirty-Nine Articles.

1590 Thomas Cartwright is arrested for his activities in seeking to further reform the Church of England beyond the Elizabethan Settlement.

1603 Queen Elizabeth dies; King James I ascends the throne; although sympathetic to the cause of the English Reformation, James opposes all Separatist activities.

1609 The congregation in Scrooby flees England for Holland.

1620 The Scrooby congregation, now residing in Leyden, Holland, joins with Thomas Weston and the Merchant Adventurers to sail to the New World aboard the Mayflower.

1625 King James I dies; Charles I ascends the English throne.

1629 The New England Company receives a royal charter for a new settlement in America; the Massachusetts Bay Colony is officially formed.

1630 The Great Migration begins with the sailing of a small fleet, led by the Arbella, from England to America. John Winthrop travels with them.

1633 William Laud is appointed the Archbishop of Canterbury and begins arresting nonconformists. John Cotton, Thomas Hooker, and Samuel Stone flee England and arrive in Massachusetts.

1636 Harvard College is founded; the Pequot War begins; the Antinomian Controversy commences; Roger Williams, having been convicted of sedition by the General Court in October 1635, sets out for Rhode Island. The following year, along with Ezekiel Holliman, Williams establishes the first Baptist church in America at Providence.

1637–1638 Anne Hutchinson and John Wheelwright are banished from Massachusetts.

1640 Charles I is forced to call the Long Parliament; petitions for reforms are introduced; Archbishop Laud is imprisoned; with turmoil in England increasing, the Great Migration effectively comes to an end.

1642 With tensions mounting between Charles and the English Parliament, the English Civil War begins.

1643 The Westminster Assembly of Divines is established in order to make recommendations for religious reforms; Thomas Hooker, John Davenport, and John Cotton decline an invitation to appear at the assembly.

1648 Having surrendered two years earlier, Charles I regroups and launches an unsuccessful attack against the New Model Army. He is tried and executed the following year.

1658 The Congregational ministers in England gather for the Savoy Conference, adopting the Savoy Declaration of Faith and Order. Oliver Cromwell dies in England.

1662 Parliament passes the Act of Uniformity. More than two thousand English ministers refuse to sign and are banished from their pulpits. In America the Synod of 1662 adopts the Half-Way Covenant.

1675 The Indian chief Metacom (King Philip) attacks the English residents in New England. King Philip’s War ensues and lasts for nearly three years.

1679 The New England Reforming Synod adopts the Savoy Declaration.

1684 The Massachusetts charter is revoked by King Charles II, who later dies in 1685.

1686 Sir Edmund Andros arrives in Massachusetts, appointed as the royal governor of New England. A rebellion begins to mount, led by the Mathers.

1689 New England citizens stage a revolt against Andros; he is arrested and deposed. Andros is eventually deported back to England. William and Mary are crowned as England’s monarchs.

1690 John Eliot, the apostle to the Indians, dies.

1692 Witch Trials begin in Salem; Increase Mather returns from England with a revised charter.

1702 Cotton Mather publishes Magnalia Christi Americana, the most important work of early American church history.

1703 Jonathan Edwards is born in East Windsor, Connecticut.

1723 Increase Mather dies at age eighty-four.

1728 Cotton Mather dies in Boston.

INTRODUCTION

WHO ARE THE AMERICAN PURITANS?

"There is no such thing as an American Puritan is a sentiment we have often heard. By all rights, Puritanism as we know it was a movement for church reform, pastoral renewal and evangelism, and spiritual revival" that took place in England from around 1560 to 1660.1 However, over the course of the seventeenth century, it is estimated that nearly a hundred Puritan ministers migrated to America, along with tens of thousands of English believers, all to pursue lives of faithfulness to the gospel of Jesus Christ.2 The earliest settlers in New England were cut from the same cloth as many of the Puritans in England. But to understand who they were and why they came, we first need to go back a hundred years to the birth of the English Reformation.

The English Reformation

When most people think of the Protestant Reformation, their minds often latch on to the image of Martin Luther nailing his Ninety-Five Theses to the door of the castle at Wittenberg on October 31, 1517. However, the movement that began in Germany quickly spread like wildfire throughout all of Europe. It arrived in England by way of an unlikely champion, King Henry VIII (1491–1547). When Pope Clement VII failed to grant Henry a divorce from his first wife, Catherine of Aragon, he responded by severing ties with the Roman Catholic Church and attached himself to the fast-growing Reformation movement. In 1534, he influenced Parliament to pass the Act of Supremacy, effectively decreeing the English monarch as the head of the Church of England. Thus, the English Reformation was born.

With the advent of the Church of England came a wave of ecclesiastical reforms. Henry appointed Thomas Cranmer (1489–1556) to the highest ministerial office—the archbishop of Canterbury. As the first Protestant to hold the coveted position, Cranmer ushered in sweeping changes, removing icons and images from the church buildings and replacing the Roman Catholic Missal (service book) with the Book of Common Prayer.3 Upon King Henry’s death in 1547, his young son, Edward VI (1537–1553), ascended the throne with Cranmer by his side to guide him in the ways of Reformation.

In 1549 Parliament passed the Act of Uniformity, which effectively institutionalized Protestantism into the Church of England. All vestiges of Roman Catholic imagery were officially removed from the churches, the clergy were no longer required to be celibate, and the Book of Common Prayer was required to be used in worship services. Whatever progress was made toward Reformation under King Edward VI came to an abrupt halt upon his death on July 6, 1553, at age fifteen. His replacement would not be a sympathetic Protestant but an embittered Roman Catholic monarch named Mary.

After her father, Henry VIII, divorced her mother, Catherine, Mary I (1516–1558) vowed to remain faithful to Roman Catholicism and oppose her father’s apostasy. When her stepbrother, Edward, had attempted to bypass Mary from the line of succession by appointing his cousin, Lady Jane Grey (1537–1554), to the throne following his imminent death, Mary promptly deposed her and had her beheaded only nine days into her reign. For the next three years, Bloody Mary systematically reversed every Protestant element from England, lashing out vehemently. When she had 283 Christians martyred in 1555, many Protestants went into hiding. Several hundred leading Protestant leaders fled to Geneva, Switzerland, where they were warmly received by the Reformed pastor and theologian John Calvin (1509–1564). This short stint in Calvin’s Geneva would set the course in England for the next hundred years.

The Emergence of Puritanism

By November 1558, Mary I was dead and Queen Elizabeth I (1533–1603) had ascended the throne. This change of power signaled the safe return of many Protestant exiles from hiding. However, Elizabeth had a difficult challenge on her hands. Sympathetic to their causes, she worked to provide toleration for the dissenting Protestants. At this time, she established the Elizabethan Settlement, which would draw together "Reformed or Calvinistic doctrine, the continuation of a liturgical and…Catholic form of worship, and an episcopal church government."4 Essentially, this move was designed to keep all parties happy by incorporating key elements from each major group, but many of the English Reformers would have nothing of it. Having spent time in Geneva, many of the Protestants had seen an example of a fully Reformed city and purposed to bring about its fruits in their homeland.

While the term Puritan was initially used as a derogatory term in the 1560s, it came to refer to a large contingent of Protestants who were seeking to purify and further reform the Church of England. However, not all Protestants who bore the name of Puritan believed and practiced the same way. According to Everett Emerson in his book Puritanism in America, four groups emerged within the Church of England in response to the Elizabethan Settlement.5

The first group sought only mild reforms (the elimination of vestments, more emphasis on preaching, etc.) within the church and largely conformed to Elizabethan standards. Adherents to this position included John Foxe, Edmund Spenser, and Edmund Grindal.

The second group sought to reform the episcopal structure and diminish the hierarchy of church power; their efforts were focused on parliamentary changes, which proved unsuccessful. This movement included strong leaders such as Thomas Cartwright and John Field.

The third group also opposed the Church of England’s hierarchy but sought more passive, grassroots reform that they would practice in their local churches. Further, they were committed to nonconformity—dissension and opposition to the Elizabethan standards spelled out in the Act of Uniformity (1559). A large group of Puritans rejected many of the practices listed in the Book of Common Prayer (owing to their similarity to Roman Catholic dogma) and adhered to their convictions, citing the offense of their own consciences. Key leaders in this movement were men such as Laurence Chaderton, Richard Greenham, and William Perkins, along with the leaders of the Massachusetts Bay Colony.

The fourth group grew frustrated with the lack of reformation within the Church of England and withdrew from it completely. They sought to form their own congregations and were maligned as Separatists and persecuted vigorously by church officials. Key leaders in this movement included men such as Richard Clyfton, John Smyth, William Brewster, and William Bradford.

Of the four main groups, the latter two practiced various degrees of nonconformity, and many of their adherents fled persecution to America.

Nonconformity

When the Marian exiles returned to England, they had hoped they would be able to pick up where Edward VI had left off and further reform the Church of England. However, Queen Elizabeth was quite content to demand strict observance to the Book of Common Prayer and the Articles of Religion, which many Puritans believe left the church only half reformed. Believing many of the Elizabethan standards to be eerily similar to Roman Catholicism, many Puritans vowed not to conform.

Furthermore, having experienced the feast of biblical preaching and sound doctrine in Geneva, the Puritans were appalled at the quality of ministry that was being streamlined. Some English preachers were so unskilled and ignorant, and others so puffed up and pretentious, that they could barely lead the congregation in any sort of way of godliness. Historian Edmund S. Morgan notes, In England, they said, too many ministers substituted an affected eloquence for sound knowledge and indulged themselves ‘in [fond] fables to make their hearers [laugh], or in ostentation of learning of their Latin, their [Greek], their [Hebrew] tongue, and of their great reading of antiquities.’ Worse than these dilettante preachers were the ignorant and evil ministers, incapable of preaching at all.6

Not only were the ministers awful but corruption in the church was prevalent. Church membership was not reserved for those who maintained a credible profession of faith but was freely granted to many unregenerate persons. And since all disciplinary power was maintained solely by the bishops, there was no way for a church to rid itself of sinning members, making the task of purification nearly impossible.

The reigns of James I (1566–1625) and Charles I (1600–1649) brought increased opposition against nonconformity. While King James focused much of his energy on weeding out the Separatists, King Charles very quickly took to uprooting the nonconformist movement. In 1633, Charles appointed William Laud (1573–1645) as the archbishop of Canterbury and tasked him with enforcing the standards of the Church of England. For the next decade, Laud systematically investigated, pursued, arrested, and prosecuted every nonconformist minister he could lay his hands on. While many Puritans were imprisoned, others fled to Holland and America.

Separatism

The most radical of all the English Puritans were the Separatists. They believed that the Church of England had become apostate and that their only course of action was to remove themselves and begin their own independent churches. When King James I came to power in 1603, he set out to uproot all opposition to his rule as head of the Church of England. No group angered King James more than the Separatists. He famously vowed to make them conform or harry them out of the land!7 He not only drove out the Separatists but threw them into prisons whenever he could. In 1609, a group of Puritan Separatists in Scrooby, England, decided to flee to Holland. Very quickly they realized that life was not much better there, and their children were still being exposed to the same revelry they found in England. Finally, they decided to set sail for the New World.

The New England Way

Strictly speaking, the first arrivals to New England were not regarded as Puritans but as Separatists. However, their devotion to Scripture, sound preaching, Reformed doctrine, and visible piety places them within the sanctified realm of Puritanism. The Separatists in Plymouth fled from England in order to establish churches of their own in which the membership would more closely approximate that of the invisible church.8 The Church of England, they believed, though technically Protestant in designation, still did not value faithfulness, righteousness, and individual soul liberty. Much of English religion was politicized. They observed that the fires of English Reformation had simmered down to lukewarm coals. All told, while many migrated to America in the early 1600s for various reasons, many residents writing back to England argued that the only valid reason for migrating to Massachusetts was religion.9 In short, the Puritans’ primary focus was to establish pure churches.

When the Massachusetts Bay Colony became populated with ten thousand people in the 1630s, the leaders sought to perfect what had begun in England. Unlike the Plymouth Separatists, they still regarded the Church of England as their dear sister but desired to purify what remained in America.

The New England Puritans believed they were in covenant with God and needed to honor the terms of that covenant through their faithfulness. It is evident, declared John Cotton, by the light of nature that all civil relations are founded on covenant.10 Further, they recognized that there needed to be a way to govern themselves civilly as well as religiously. With the help of leaders such as John Cotton, they established The New England Way. At its core, the Way was an expression of Congregationalism that sought to impact all areas of public life. American church historian Mark Noll writes, "New England was, thus, no theocracy, where ministers exercised direct control of public life. It was, however, a place where magistrates frequently called upon the reverend fathers for advice, including how best they might promote the religious life of the colonies. The churches were also