Wake Up: Hip-Hop, Christianity, and the Black Church

Wake Up!

Hip Hop Christianity and

the Black Church

Cheryl Kirk-Duggan

and

Marlon Hall

Abingdon Press

Nashville

WAKE UP!

HIP HOP CHRISTIANITY AND THE BLACK CHURCH

Copyright © 2011 by Abingdon Press

All rights reserved.

No part of this work may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, except as may be expressly permitted by the 1976 Copyright Act or in writing from the publisher. Requests for permission should be addressed to Permissions, The United Methodist Publishing House, P.O. Box 801, 201 Eighth Avenue South, Nashville, TN 37202-0801, or e-mailed to [email protected].

This book is printed on acid-free paper.

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

Kirk-Duggan, Cheryl A.

Wake up! : hip-hop Christianity and the Black church / by Cheryl Kirk-Duggan and Marlon Hall.

p. cm.

Includes bibliographical references.

ISBN 978-1-4267-0301-0 (pbk. : alk. paper)

1. African American youth—Religious life. 2. Hip-hop—Religious aspects—Christianity. I.

Hall, Marlon. II. Title.

BR563.N4K585 2011

248.408996073—dc22

2010054429

All scripture quotations are taken from New Revised Standard Version of the Bible, copyright 1989, Division of Christian Education of the National Council of the Churches of Christ in the United States of America. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20—10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1

MANUFACTURED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

To the bards, young and not so young,

whose contributions in the form of Hip Hop

made this volume possible

To our immediate, intimate sojourners,

who've listened, encouraged,

and loved us well

Contents

Preface: It's Bigger Than Hip Hop

Acknowledgments

I'm Bound to Wreck Your Body and Say Turn the Party Out: Physical Bodies and Embodiment

Hip Hop Is Dead: Musical Characteristics

I Used to Love Her: God, Hip Hop, and Spirituality

G.O.D. (Gaining One's Definition): Black Church and Black Culture

Put Down the Pimp Stick to Pick Up the Pulpit: The Impact of Hip Hop on the Black Church

Jesus Walks: Youth, the Church, and the Need for Transformation

Epilogue

Notes

Preface

It's Bigger Than Hip Hop

Divine synchronicity, human curiosity, and a commitment to creativity framed by faith launched the inception, process, and creation of Wake Up! Hip Hop Christianity and the Black Church. This collaborative project brought together the lived experiences of Marlon Hall and Cheryl Kirk-Duggan. Hall, a missionary, columnist, anthropologist, filmmaker, and pastor, helped found The Awakenings Movement, a grassroots Christian church and movement that holds worship in coffee shops, art galleries, and bars in Nairobi, Houston, and Detroit. The Awakenings Movement is designed to challenge and equip ordinary people to live extraordinary lives through the love and power of Christ. Hall grew up in Hip Hop culture as a participant and an observer, living and loving its music. Interdisciplinary scholar/minister/musician Cheryl A. Kirk-Duggan—a prolific author, preacher, professor, poet, performer, prophet, and priest—came to Hip Hop as a professor/ learner. Synchronicity emerged during the spring of 2008, when one of Kirk-Duggan's students, then-Minister Leon Parker, came to her asking if she would teach a class on Hip Hop. She responded that if he could get eight people to sign up for the course, she would teach it as a readings course in fall 2008. In the summer of 2008, Abingdon Press editor Kathy Armistead phoned Kirk-Duggan and asked her if she would be interested in writing a book on Hip Hop. Kirk-Duggan initially stated that she had already made a commitment to say no to any new projects. However, since she had just agreed to teach a course on Hip Hop, she was willing to invest in the project.

Armistead went on to introduce Kirk-Duggan to Hall by emailing a couple of articles written from Hall's column in Outreach Magazine, Awakening Faith, which talked about his passion for people and his work at Awakenings as a cultural provocateur: one who provokes culture from a life of mediocrity to dream, believe, and then live out his dreams. One article stated how the Awakenings Movement community is a group of Social Visionaries who are called by God to make an indelible mark on humanity that no one can erase. Our community is a dynamic Christ-Centered movement that discovers God in unorthodox public settings. At Awakenings, we learn to excavate God's extraordinary presence from the remnants of ordinary life and spaces. This movement allows us to share the never changing story of Christ's life, love, death, and resurrection to an ever-changing world. Curiosity was ever present once Kirk-Duggan's interest as a musician and scholar was piqued earlier when she wrote an article, The Theopoetic Theological Ethics of Lauryn Hill and Tupac Shakur, for the volume Creating Ourselves: African Americans and Latino/as, Popular Culture, and Religious Expression, edited by Anthony Pinn and Ben Valentine (Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press, 2009). Students' curiosity moved the course with engaged and creative dialogue, which brought in speakers and a local radio producer. Mid-semester, Hall spoke to the Hip Hop class via teleconference. Kirk-Duggan revised her course content in conversation with Hall, and they crafted the table of contents and began the writing process. The two have yet to meet face to face.

For the dialogue partners, the process has been one of growth and discovery. Hall's mission and anthropological study in Kenya and work in the Awakenings community have supported his commitment to this project. Kirk-Duggan's work with her students and the interest that arises when she talks about the project have fueled her joy in this venture. Both authors acknowledge that music has always been central to the African and African diasporan lived experience, central to community, worship, and praise. Historically, traditional African people did not have a sense of performing music for others; music was participatory. Both writers were primed to engage in this work as a next step in their understanding of who God wants them to be and how they are to engage in ministry in the worlds of the church and the academy.

Hall's most memorable experience of hearing It's Bigger Than Hip-Hop, by underground rap group Dead Prez, was in a crowded movie theater while watching Dave Chappelle's concert documentary, Block Party. It's Bigger Than Hip-Hop is a song that honors a movement in music that has become a culture. Hall and his friends were all stuffed in a movie theater, and not one seat was open. Dead Prez slowly and deliberately walked onto the stage, and as soon as the first few chords of the song were heard, everyone in the movie audience stood as if the film screen had come to life and they were experiencing a concert in real time. Some jumped, others bounced, but everyone stood to honor this musical anthem that lyrically celebrates the potential of Hip Hop music as a cultural phenomenon and not just a fad marked by gold teeth and baggy pants.

M1, a member of Dead Prez, once described Hip Hop as one word with two meanings. The music is Hip because it is sensitive and vulnerable to relevant issues and Hop because it is a dynamic movement not bound by conventional processes and practices. This music has its finger on the pulse of human possibility and pain. Hip Hop is a viral phenomenon that has reached an internationally diverse populace in a matter of years.

In many ways, this is like the movement of Christ. In a matter of years, a message of love, redemption, and self-sacrifice became a cultural phenomenon. The good news of God in the flesh moved across continents in a matter of years. From Africa to Asia to Europe, what began as a message became a movement.

For Hall, no phenomenon has the potential to mirror the gospel of Christ like Hip Hop. The church of Christ and the Hip Hop movement share a passion for human interest and sensitivity to human pain. They have an influence that stretches like a rubber band beyond cultural contexts, continents, and time. When it comes to human development, they have a connection that is indivisible and a future that is undeniable.

Some, like Brad Jordan, also known as Scarface, argue that Hip Hop is not a culture but only a fad. It is a gag. It is a get-rich-quick scheme. The powers that be got involved and turned it into a gag gift. Hip Hop was intended to be a gift to the world but now it is a gag. Our stories were so blunt and to the point that they had to be dumbed down. Those in power had to dumb down our method of communicating to the masses. It should be a way of life. Hip Hop will continue to be a gift to listeners who want to hear our story.

Kirk-Duggan got involved with exploring the complexities of Hip Hop while researching the life and times and music of Tupac Shakur and in work on Lauryn Hill. Shakur's complicated life— moving more than twenty times before his teen years, his intellectual prowess, and his Machiavellian, self-destructive nature toward the end of his life—invoked such a sense of tragedy that the disjointedness of such a reality was an intriguing lens through which to read his life story and explore the theological implications of his music. When Lauryn Hill received a Grammy for her CD The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill, her use of this term first made popular by historian Carter G. Woodson in his 1933 classic, The Miseducation of the Negro, also struck a chord. As an interdisciplinary scholar, Kirk-Duggan often uses cultural artifacts and cultural productions to do research in theology, ethics, Bible, music, and women's studies. When the opportunity to teach a class on Hip Hop presented itself, it was an opportunity to do further research on the music, the culture, and the influence this music and culture have on youth in general and in particular on the youth at the church where she serves on staff as an associate minister. Young Missionary Temple Christian Methodist Church, Raleigh, North Carolina, has helped produce a quartet of young men known as Leviticus, who sing Christian Hip Hop music. Leviticus is on the move and has made their national debut at Apollo Theatre in Harlem, New York, in August 2010. Time spent watching them grow up and do keyboard work with their mentor, Reginald Caldwell, has coalesced many ideas around Christian Hip Hop for Kirk-Duggan.

The process of coauthoring this volume has mirrored some of the experiences of Generation X and the Millennial Generation. Kirk-Duggan and Hall have communicated via texting and e-mail, with an occasional phone conversation. Kirk-Duggan retrieved articles through Epsco, part of the ATLA religious database. No time was spent going through library shelves or microfiche, which was the practice in times past. Books were accessed through online orders or through interlibrary loan. VH1 and BET were sources for viewing Hip Hop videos. This process has been a dialogical spiritual journey. Both writers have dealt with professional issues and perx sonal and family health issues while working on this project. And so, we offer Wake Up! as a testimony and witness to the phenomenal creative grace of God and of God's children who take their gifts and their talents and produce marvelous songs of praise and worship of social commentary and of angst, pain, and celebration.

When we fail to listen to someone who is different, whether that person is dressed in the garb of a different age, gender, race, sexuality, class, or creed, we diminish a cosmological sense of the holy. Since the earth is the Lord's and the fullness thereof, the entire world is God's sanctuary: everything that has breath is to praise God; thus we ought not dismiss those capable of praise. According to sociocultural critic Derek Greenfield, over the last thirty years, Hip Hop has provided a venue of voice for many of the voiceless. This cultural praxis has also engaged movement, spoken word, and graffiti to acknowledge and affirm the presence of persons forgotten and overlooked, initially in the bowels of Bronx ghettos. Greenfield distinguishes between Hip Pop and Hip Hop. Hip Pop is the capitalistic, consumerized, idiomatic, and formulaic diatribe fraught with misogyny, violence, and objectification of female bodies. Hip Hop is a revolutionary force for acknowledging human capacity and frailty. To say I feel you is an engagement of heart and head, which permeates Hip Hop.

Hip Hop is a complex culture, in which boomers have left a legacy and Generation Xers are engaged in making a statement amid an ethos that claims democracy and freedom are available to all even though they are not. Many, particularly the young and the poor of all colors, cannot access transformative education, decent pay, and a promise for the future. Since persons of African descent were stolen from the continent, they have been able to survive and often flourish through community solidarity, using music as a bolster and therapeutic process toward healing and change. The music of Hip Hop culture, just as blues, rock and roll, boogiewoogie, and rhythm and blues before, has engaged the social and sacred life of the people. What became gospel music emerged from the Spirituals and other so-called secular black music, and the same with Hip Hop. Today, many youth music ministries have created, developed, and included Hip Hop music as part of the worship liturgy. Like gospel music before it, Hip Hop music has not entered worship without contention. Some adults say that Hip Hop musicis too secular and is ill suited for saving souls. Some youth contend that adults just do not understand their worldview, their music, and the way they connect with God.

Wake Up! Hip Hop Christianity and the Black Church is a book that invites a conversation, which uses the culture, particularly the music, to create opportunities for new, intergenerational conversations toward building community inside and outside of churches around the experience of salvation in Christ Jesus. The text employs the language of today's youth and that of baby boomers who helped found Hip Hop to wrestle with faith and life in their totality. Engaging this topic involves exploring questions regarding theology, ethics, anthropology, music, and spirituality. Interdisciplinary methods and perspectives frame our discussion of theory and praxis toward effecting social change.

Chapter 1 describes the methodology used, and provides an analysis of terms, contexts, and the role of violence, generational tensions, and Hip Hop as a response; and it explores the experience and placement of physical bodies and embodiment, the emotional engagement and objectification of the body, physicality and rhythm, the body in Christian thought, sexuality, and the devastation of sexism and misogyny.

Chapter 2 explores musical characteristics from African roots, the use of language, and the technical aspects of music to major Hip Hop artists, their signatures, and music as a vehicle of the sacred.

Chapter 3 wrestles with the connections among God, Hip Hop, and spirituality: matters of ontology, existential realities, salvation, freedom, sin, salvation, and prophetic Hip Hop voices within communal life.

Chapter 4 reviews lived theology in the disciplines of black and womanist theologies and explores the role of music and the history of denominations, matters of justice, liberation, and generational tensions around faith and liturgy.

Chapter 5 reflects on the effect of Hip Hop on the black church.

Chapter 6 explores the needs of youth and the intergenerational church for transformation. Specifically, the chapter investigates youth, their worldviews, and their pain and angst; intergenerational and youth challenges in the world; developing youth minxii istries and practicing faith with those deemed other; and the intergenerational future of mission, movement, and evangelism.

The volume closes with an epilogue. We give thanks for the opportunity to signify for a generation that wants to testify and incarnate Jesuz!

For those who remain skittish about Hip Hop, it seems that this culture and music, notably in its Christian genre, is here to stay. Hip Hop is not just for thug life. Numerous poets and scholars participate in spoken word. Philosopher Cornel West has produced several Hip Hop projects, and many projects honor his work: for example, Sketches of My Culture and The Cornel West Theory. Courses that include Hip Hop culture abound in universities and seminaries. Churches are opening their doors and hearts to Hip Hop worship just as they used coffeehouses in the 1960s for outreach. We invite you to read Wake Up! and to listen to Hip Hop music with your kids and grandkids, if you need translation. Note that there are censored and milder versions of some tunes. Listening with your children, youth, and young adults might open up some doors that you have long desired would not remain closed.

Acknowledgments

Coauthors' Tribute

Our sincerest thanks to Kathy Armistead, our project editor/sojourner at Abingdon Press for her support. Her vision and energies made this book possible. For her great ideas, helpful critique, and genuine passion and compassion for a healthy exchange of ideas, we give thanks.

Marlon Speaking

While developing this book, Cheryl taught me to use metaphors as a way to energize my writing. When it came to these acknowledgments, I was exhausted by the task of thanking the right people the right way so I decided to use metaphors to inspire the words for the people who inspire me.

So here goes. To my writing partner and mentor, Cheryl: you are the Peacock; beautiful, humble, yet bold. To the Awakenings Movement (Houston, Detroit, and Nairobi): you are Still Waters; reflecting heaven, restoring our cities, and teeming with life beneath the surface. To my first teacher and Mommy: you are the Minor Chord Triad; intervals of passionate patience, educated wisdom, and infinite support. To my first coach and Dad: you are a Warrior's Cry; courageous, vulnerable, and piercing to the soul. To my sister and inspiration Chelsey: you are the Needle and Thread; you get straight to the point and always keep us in stitches. To my sister and crying partner Nikole: you are the Flamingo; pretty, elegant, and always found in Miami. To my sister and heart Tiff: you are the Psalm; prayerful, a powerful statement, and a song. To my nephew and comrade Cody: you are the smallest Anchor ever; deep, strong, and agelessly insightful. To my beloved friend, editor, and ministry partner, Danielle: you are the Drawing Compass; sharp like the point, creative like the pencil, and well rounded. To my sweet wife and ride-or-die chick, Regina: you are the Sun; radiant, life giving, and super hot! To our daughter, Phoenix: you are God's promise fulfilled and a little girl who resurrected our burned expectations from the ashes. I love you all.

Cheryl Speaking

My deepest thanks to students in THE 591: Readings in Theology and Ethics, who engaged in significant dialogue about Hip Hop culture, life, and music; who grew with me, taught me, and encouraged me to press forward with this manuscript: Macy Jones, Gregory Messick, Craig Neill, Leon Parker, Christopher Paul (interviewed for the volume), James Utley, and Michael Whiting. Colleagues from Shaw University, and particularly from Shaw University Divinity School, have been incredibly supportive. Special thanks and kudos go to Lizette Tapp, research and interlibrary loan librarian at the James Cheek Library at Shaw University. Kudos and gratitude to the group Leviticus (Timothy Caldwell, Jared Caldwell, Joseph Ragland, and Ashton Howard) and to their mentor, Reginald Caldwell, who embody the best of Christian Hip Hop, and to our church family, Young Missionary Temple CME Church, who serves as an incubator for their creativity. Many thanks go to persons willing to share their experience around Hip Hop through interviews, contacts, and conversations of support, including: Derek Greenfield, James Stackhouse, Kevin White, Pamela P. Martin, Carl Kenney, Chanequa Walker-Barnes, Tina Pippin, Dedurie Kirk, Deborah Boatner, Latanya Sanders, Edward Thomas, Lilipiana Darensburg, Allison Franzetti, and Rona Drummer. Special thanks to my beloved, my sweet potato pie, the Honorable Mike Kirk-Duggan, who, even during his recent illnesses, has always supported my work and loved me when I had to be away—my first editor and biggest champion.

CHAPTER ONE

I'm Bound to Wreck Your Body and Say Turn the Party Out

¹

Physical Bodies and Embodiment

Hip Hop as Cultural Phenomenon

Historian Carter G. Woodson, in his classic volume Miseducation of the Negro, warned us of the generational problems and traumatic loss that occur when society and the church miseducate their own. Miseducation affords distraction, loss of focus, lack of critical thinking, and irresponsible actions or passiveness. Miseducation creates an enslaved mentality. When slave runners stole God's children from Africa and brokered in human cargo, they did not believe that the slaves had souls or could even think. So slave runners were content to limit their restraints to the physical. However, allowing enslaved persons to read or write was illegal once they were on shore in the United States. Limited and segregated life and education mades miseducation a systemic reality. Similarly, Jesus' disciples were miseducated, for they did not listen well, interpret, or process information given to them, either.

In Matthew 16, after a confrontation with the Pharisees and Sadducees, Jesus had to deal with his disciples who, yet again, did not get Jesus or his message; particularly, they did not understand Jesus' use of bread as a metaphor after feeding the five thousand with five loaves and two fish. Later, when Jesus took his disciples to Caesarea Philippi, he asked them about the identity of the Son of Man. They tried to dodge the question by stating what some say. But