BBC History Magazine

STILL THE GREATEST?

f0046-01.jpg
GETTY IMAGES/BRIDGEMAN/ALAMY

Cover story / Churchill at 150

In a much-publicised poll in 2002, the BBC asked viewers to rank figures from British history, as part of the television series 100 Greatest Britons. The poll was in no way scientific, but simply reflected votes – more than 1.6 million of them – from people who chose to contact the BBC, following presentations championing famous individuals ranging back in time from the 20th century to William Shakespeare and Queen Elizabeth I.

As is well known, Winston Churchill came out a clear first, garnering close to 457,000 votes. Two decades later, as we mark 150 years since he was born, it's interesting to revisit that moment, and to reflect on how perceptions of Churchill have changed over time – and also on what is meant by historical ‘greatness’. Because Churchill's craving to make himself ‘great’ lies at the heart of his extraordinary story.

In the run-up to the BBC poll, politician Mo Mowlam – Churchill's advocate – insisted that “he was the greatest Briton because he showed the determination and courage to protect Britain from invasion, and without his inspiring leadership the outcome of World War II may have been very different”.

Let's unpack that claim a bit. Did Churchill really make such a difference in 1940 – and, if so, how? The answer to the first part is surely: yes – most of all through his energy and drive. Although the tempo in Whitehall would have intensified anyway with the end of the ‘Phoney War’ and the German invasion of France, Churchill's appointment as prime minister had a galvanising effect, dramatically symbolised by his famous red labels stuck on urgent documents: ACTION THIS DAY.

f0048-01.jpg

Churchill injected a new urgency into government during his premiership, introducing ACTION THIS DAY labels to prioritise key tasks

Equally important, Churchill took a firm grip on military strategy. Mindful of the confusion and infighting of 1914–18, he appointed himself minister of defence. There was no ministry

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from BBC History Magazine

BBC History Magazine1 min read
The Classic Book
It was my mother who first introduced me to this book. She was moved by the moment at which Carolyn Steedman discovers that her birth certificate erroneously records her parents as married. As a family with its share of historical illegitimacy and wr
BBC History Magazine2 min read
Hidden Figures
“Our secretaries need only two things: good legs and a good upbringing,” said MI6 chief Dick White in 1956. Claire Hubbard-Hall's well-researched and eloquently written book gives the lie to this misogynist fallacy, telling the oft untold stories of
BBC History Magazine2 min read
Medieval Sambocade
RECIPE For shortcrust pastry For filling You might assume that the rich and creamy cheesecake so popular in the UK hails from New York, but the ancient Greeks have a good claim to its invention. A source from Greece written in AD 230 describes mixing

Related Books & Audiobooks