The Atlantic

The TV Shows That Don’t Solve Their Mysteries

True Detective was the last straw: I’m done with the mystery-box genre.
Source: PictureLux / The Hollywood Archive / Alamy

This is an edition of The Atlantic Daily, a newsletter that guides you through the biggest stories of the day, helps you discover new ideas, and recommends the best in culture. Sign up for it here.

It’s Friday, and we’ve probably all had enough of political news, so instead I’m going to gripe about the decline of my favorite kind of television: “mystery box” shows that center on a secret or a conspiracy. The conceit has gotten out of control.

First, here are three new stories from The Atlantic:


Show Us the Monster

This article contains spoilers for True Detective, Lost, Dark, Jericho, Stranger Things, Timeless, and a few other shows that are so old that you already know how they end.

In 1996, the Fox network exploited our worries about the coming of the year 2000 with a show titled , and it was, initially,followed the adventures of a possibly psychic former FBI agent who seemed to be on the trail of a rising tide of mayhem sparked by the approaching new era. But wasn’t a crime procedural: Something was going on in the show, something that involved demons, a shadowy group (maybe Nazis, maybe not) searching for chunks of the cross of Jesus Christ, and deranged killers shouting things like “The thousand years is !”

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic10 min readWorld
The Cost Of Lawlessness On The West Bank
It was a normal morning during the autumn olive harvest. On a hillside northeast of Ramallah, on November 8, a group of roughly 15 or 20 Palestinians from the village of Deir Jarir were picking dark olives, the most important agricultural product in
The Atlantic11 min read
How Liberal America Came to Its Senses
A decade ago, cultural norms in elite American institutions took a sharply illiberal turn. Professors would get disciplined, journalists fired, ordinary people harassed by social-media mobs, over some decontextualized phrase or weaponized misundersta
The Atlantic5 min read
Bob Dylan’s Carnival Act
Everything, as Charles Péguy said, begins in mysticism and ends in politics. Except if you’re Bob Dylan. If you’re Bob Dylan, you start political and go mystical. You start as an apprentice hobo scuffing out songs of change; you become, under protest

Related Books & Audiobooks