The New York Review of Books Magazine

Triumphs of Skepticism

A Memoir of My Former Self: A Life in Writing by Hilary Mantel, edited by Nicholas Pearson. Henry Holt, 419 pp., $40.00

If it is true, as Saint Augustine says, that the dead aren’t absent but merely invisible, then somewhere round about, as I write about her and you read about her, Hilary Mantel is present. Or perhaps it’s more accurate to say that she is present not only if Augustine’s statement is true but if I believe it, or if you do. Mantel believed it: she quotes it twice in her 2017 BBC Reith Lectures on the art of historical fiction, which are included among the essays and reviews that make up A Memoir of My Former Self. Elsewhere she says, apropos Princess Diana, “For some people, being dead is only a relative condition.” And I want to believe it too. I imagine her raised eyebrow, her incredulous laugh, as she looks over my shoulder at the computer screen.

I met her only twice: the first time when she was awarded an honorary degree by the University of London and I was asked to give the oration in her honor. The pomposity of the proceedings was beyond parody, and as we bowed and scraped, wearing our silly hats and gowns (royalty was present, in the form of Princess Anne, chancellor of the university), Mantel managed simultaneously to project genuine warmth and gratitude, and enormous skepticism. Not long afterward I went with a friend to the opening run of the adaptation of Wolf Hall in the West End, and as we sidled into our seats, there she was, sitting with her husband, Gerald McEwen, directly behind us. We whooped and giggled like teenagers meeting by accident in an unfamiliar setting (What? You here?) as she raised an eyebrow at her own royal entertainment. Mantel died suddenly and unexpectedly at the age of seventy in September 2022, a week before a planned move to Kinsale in Ireland—not far from my own patch. I would have liked to have got to know her better, but maybe, as Augustine suggests, I still can.

Born in 1952 in the small town of Glossop in the north

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The New York Review of Books Magazine

The New York Review of Books Magazine11 min read
The Shoals of Prose
My Poetics by Maureen N. McLane. University of Chicago Press, 268 pp., $99.00; $22.50 (paper) Watch Your Language: Visual and Literary Reflections on a Century of American Poetry by Terrance Hayes. Penguin, 214 pp., $20.00 (paper) The great defenses
The New York Review of Books Magazine1 min read
Snow Elegy
Wild petunias slowly goblind and a starched nurseraces to your bed to findyour quick hawk gazefixed on a blue mahoe branch scraping the louvre glass,its cellophane sound blursa gesture of recoil or beckonthat transmits the gingerlily’s rage and the c
The New York Review of Books Magazine13 min read
Look Who’s Talking
The Language Puzzle: Piecing Together the Six-Million-Year Story of How Words Evolved by Steven Mithen. Basic Books, 534 pp., $36.00 By any standard we human beings are unusual creatures. Just for a start, our bizarre upright locomotion is reflected

Related Books & Audiobooks