DOI https://doi.org/10.36059/978-966-397-118-6/18-37
BEHAVIOUR PECULIARITIES OF ADOLESCENTS
WITH INTELLECTUAL DISABILITIES
IN CONFLICT SITUATIONS
Bystrova Yu. O.
INTRODUCTION
This study is highly relevant as there is a need to organise
conditions for the socialization of children with special educational
needs in special and inclusive education institutions. This particularly
includes school psychological support for adolescents with intellectual
disabilities, who find themselves in difficult-to-solve conflict
situations on an everyday basis. For such children, the process of
socialisation occurs with particular complications. A number of
scholars, such as S. Konoplyasta, M. Pevzner, O. Proskurniak,
L. Rudenko, D. Shulzhenko, V. Syniov, substantiate that intellectual
disability negatively affects the state of emotional and volitional
sphere; moreover, it facilitates social behaviour violations. Such wellknown scientists as O. Ahavelian, I. Dmytriieva, S. Myronova,
M. Matvieieva, O. Romanenko, O. Sievierov, V. Syniov state that
weak self-regulation or lack of it in relations with other people
reduces the possibility of choosing the right way to overcome
difficulties, control actions, and keep proper awareness of the
situation. A particular aggravation of these problems occurs in
adolescence, which can be easily explained by the instability of
nervous system during puberty 1. Bozhovich (1995) emphasized that
the combination of two factors – disharmony and tension during the
occurrence of sexual metamorphosis, as well as decompensation of
various types of CNS insufficiency – leads to the fact that the
pathological temper features and mental deviations, which are
associated with decompensation of organic insufficiency of the CNS,
come to the boil and, consequently, conflicts arise in the teenage
Бистрова Ю.О. Забезпечення наступності в процесі професійно-трудової
соціалізації осіб з вадами інтелектуального розвитку : монографія. Луганськ : Вид-во
ДЗ «ЛНУ імені Тараса Шевченка».2012. С. 156-217.
1
18
phase of development more often than in other critical age phases of
childhood2.
In this regard, one of the important elements of the socialisation of
adolescents with intellectual disabilities is to prevent their conflict
behaviour and to facilitate conflict resolution both with their peers and in
their relations with those around them.
Taking into account the negative impact of conflicts on the social
adaptation of children and adolescents with intellectual disabilities, we
would like to emphasize the relevance of the research problem for special
psychology. Such issues as determining the causes and dynamics of
conflict behaviour require particular attention in order to define the
possibilities and methods of correctional influence aiming to prevent and
resolve conflicts in the behaviour of students with intellectual disabilities.
1. Analysis of Subjective Psychological Preconditions
for the Emergence of Conflicts in the Behaviour
of Adolescents with Intellectual Disabilities
The study took place throughout 2017-2019 and included two
stages. 120 adolescents studying in special educational institutions, and
120 adolescents from general education schools of Luhansk, Kiev,
Cherkasy and Ternopil Oblasts participated in the experiment.
60 younger teens with intellectual disabilities from 5th to 7th grades
(30 girls and 30 boys) and 60 senior teens from 8 th to 9th grades (30 girls
and 30 boys) participated in the study.
At the first stage, the research team identified the main issues faced
by adolescents with intellectual disabilities in terms of interpersonal
communication, acknowledged the specific situations causing conflicts
and peculiarities of behaviour in these cases. After analysing relevant
psychological literature, the team selected appropriate methods /
techniques.
At the second stage, the team identified experimental groups and
conducted a confirmatory experiment. Its main task was to study the
causes and characteristics of conflict behaviour in adolescents with
intellectual disabilities.
Божович Л.И. Избранные психологические труды. Проблемы формирования
личности. / под ред. Д.И. Фельдштейна. М. : Международная педагогическая
академия, 1995. 349 с.
2
19
The selection of methods and techniques was based on
understanding of the essence of conflict and the dependence of the
peculiarities of conflict behaviour on the factors of its occurrence. In
order to cover the entire spectrum of issues, the researchers applied the
following methods / techniques:
(1) studying subjective assessment, objective causes of conflicts and
behaviour peculiarities of adolescents with intellectual disabilities in
conflict situations;
(2) studying behaviour strategies, emotional responses in conflict,
ways of overcoming and solving difficult life situations.
Adolescents with intellectual disabilities find it difficult to perceive
many formulations of personality questionnaires. Considering this fact,
the researchers selected the tests that were equally easily perceived by
adolescents from general and special schools. When working with tests
and questionnaires for adolescents with intellectual disabilities, the
primary focus was on instructions: first, they explained the general
terms, and then gradually provided other information. The surveyed
teenagers performed the tasks individually and this process was
accompanied by a conversation between a student and a psychologist.
During the conversation with adolescents, the expert revealed their
understanding of conflict and conflict behaviour, the ability to assess
conflictual relationships with peers and teachers. It was vital to identify
the types of adolescents’ reaction to teachers’ pedagogical influence in a
particular conflict situation. In order to study the prevailing strategies of
conflict behaviour and ways to overcome difficulties, we used the
adapted version of K. Thomas model3 and the S.Rozentzweig pictureassociation method4. We studied the emotional state of adolescents in
conflict interaction using the Phillips School Anxiety Questionnaire
(SAQ)5, Coping Strategies5 and Hand Test5. The projective techniques
commonly known as incomplete sentences or sentence completion
Бистрова Ю.О., Синьов В.М. Діагностика індивідуально-психологічних рис
особистості як початковий етап процесу професійно-трудової соціалізації учнів з
особливими освітніми потребами. Nowoczesna edukacja: flozofa, innowacja,
doświadczenie. Nr1. Łódź : Wydawnictwo Naukowe Wyższej Szkoły Informatyki i
Umiejętności, 2015. Р. 120-129.
4
Лукин С.Е. Суворов А.В. Тест рисуночной ассоциации Розенцвейга
(руководство по использованию). СПб., 1993. 62 с.
5
Спеціальна психолого-педагогічна діагностика / за ред. Ю.О. Бистрова,
В.Є. Коваленко. Харків: Майданс, 2018. 170 с.
3
20
method and René Gilles film test (Le Test-Film)5 aimed at identifying
images and subjective psychological preconditions for conflicts in the
closest social environment (family and school), at studying personal
orientations (goals, values), individual and typological features of
emotional sphere (fears, expectations, anxieties) of teenagers with
intellectual disabilities. The ascertaining experiment also included the
observation of adolescents during the classes and in the communication
period not regulated by the teacher. In the process of observing the
adolescents, the researchers carried out a thorough record of teenagers’
actions, statements, emotional manifestations, the nature of response to
the direct action of another adolescent or teacher, and typical ways of
responding to various conflict situations. In addition to the
abovementioned, the method of ascertaining experiment included
analysis of school and medical documentation (medical records and
inspection cards).
Basing on general concepts, one of the tasks was to identify the
subjective psychological preconditions for the emergence of conflicts
in adolescents with intellectual disability, because psychologists,
particularly G. Lozhkin and N. Poviakel, confirm that subjective
factors, above all, can transform the potential conflict into a real one 6.
In the course of the study, the researchers discovered that most often in
adolescents with intellectual disabilities relationships with peers, less
often with adults become the cause of negative emotional states that
lead to conflict behaviour. At the same time, as adolescents grow a
little bit older, they experience increasing dissatisfaction with relations
in the system of "teacher – student", moreover, this feeling is both
subjective and objective. The very personality of the teacher becomes a
subject that is undesirable for contacts and communication. Difficult
situations of interaction with a teacher cause anxiety in younger
adolescents (76.7%) and convert into aggression and rejection in older
teenagers (86.7%). Many teens expect negative assessment from a
teacher (20% of younger ones, 36.7% of older ones). Comparing both
adolescent groups, we should note that older teens feel less anxiety in a
number of school-related issues, such as the fear of a knowledge test
(p<0.001), but they are more likely to be afraid of not meeting the
Ложкин Г.В., Повякель Н.И. Практическая психология конфликта. К. :
МАУП, 2002. С. 66-74.
6
21
expectations of others (p<0.05). Unlike the general secondary school,
in the special school anxiety grows towards senior grades due to the
worsening of their relationships with peers (from 10% in younger teens,
up to 20% in older ones). The responses of adolescents reflect asocial
forms of behaviour (cruelty, substance abuse) as one of the possible
negative aspects of adolescent communities. Many students with
intellectual disabilities experience negative attitude of their peers (20%
of younger ones, 30% of older ones). Besides, they note the terrible
habits of their mates: "My friends often beat me", "... like to drink
vodka", "... carry knife","... sniff glue". There is an increase in the
number of cases of negative evaluation of their relationships with peers
in senior grades, due to the increase in conflicts among the older
adolescents with intellectual disabilities. This is linked to the later
personality formation of an adolescent studying in a special school in
comparison with the adolescent of a general secondary school. Closer
to senior grades an adolescent with intellectual disabilities begins to
realise both his/her personal and social inferiority. This awareness
prevents him/her from succeeding in various fields that attract the
teenager, and thus increases anxiety in this regard (p<0.01).
In the course of the study, the researchers studied the factors of
school life that influence the formation and predominance of a strategy
of conflict behaviour in adolescents with intellectual disabilities. The
factors that shape positive behaviour include adequate teachers’
requirements for an adolescent, the satisfaction of the adolescent with
his/her activities and relationships with others, increased motivation to
study, the lack of conflict-related conditions during the classes and in
extra hours. The negative factors that shape the destructive behaviours of
adolescents with intellectual disabilities include peers and teachers
ignoring the individuality of the adolescent, the lack of increased
motivation to study, aggression from peers, the use of conflictogens and
the negative assessment of teachers7.
The research showed that family education plays a great role in the
formation of positive or destructive behaviour of adolescents with
Бистрова Ю.О. Забезпечення наступності в процесі професійно-трудової
соціалізації осіб з вадами інтелектуального розвитку : монографія. Луганськ : Вид-во
ДЗ «ЛНУ імені Тараса Шевченка». 2012. С. 156-217.
7
22
intellectual disabilities in conflict situations8. The scientists determined
that reasons causing conflicts in the family include the family neglect of
a teen (by parents), the abuse of alcohol in the family, immoral
behaviour of family members, anxiety and fear of family members, the
fear of losing one of the parents. Often, younger teenagers with
intellectual disabilities say that the family members shout at them (42%),
scold them (44%), call them all names (17%), undeservedly offend them
(33%), can beat them (15%); 17% of older teens and 9% of the younger
ones have heard from their father or mother that they do not love them.
It is important to note the fact that in individual conversations, 20-25%
of adolescents say that their parents take it out on them. This means that
every fourth teenager experiences pressure because of parental problems.
Thus, family discomfort is reflected in adolescents by displaced
aggression, often stressed by scientists while considering types of
psychological protection9. Factors weakening and preventing conflicts
are positive relationships with parents, the inclusion of a teenager with
intellectual disabilities, help that s/he gets in difficult situations,
confidence in love, protection and support from the family. The study
found that in the majority of cases the personal traits that were laid down
by the family upbringing determine the behaviour strategy of the
adolescent with intellectual disabilities in a conflict – family shapes and
consolidates certain stereotypes of behaviour: dependent (adaptation),
detached (avoidance) and aggressive (destructive rivalry).
2. Strategies for Behaviour in the Conflict
of Adolescents with Intellectual Disabilities
The next task, solved in the research, was to study the influence of
the level of mental development, age characteristics and gender
differences of adolescents on the choice of strategies for behaviour in
difficult situations that are difficult to solve. The scholars clarified it by
the method of comparative analysis of various groups of adolescents
(teenagers with intellectual disabilities and adolescents with normal
development type).
Бистрова Ю.О. Забезпечення наступності в процесі професійно-трудової
соціалізації осіб з вадами інтелектуального розвитку : монографія. Луганськ : Вид-во
ДЗ «ЛНУ імені Тараса Шевченка». 2012. С. 156-217.
9
Ложкин Г.В., Повякель Н.И. Практическая психология конфликта. К. :
МАУП, 2002. С. 66-74.
8
23
While examining the study results based on the adapted version of
American social psychologist K. Thomas model, we noted that there were
no reliable quantitative differences in the ways of responding to a conflict
situation as a result of comparison of groups of adolescents with different
levels of mental development, except for cooperation strategy (see Fig. 1).
30
25
20
15
10
5
adaptation
avoidance
compromis
e
cooperation
rivalry
0
adolescents with intellectual disabilities
adolescents with normal development
Fig. 1. The Most Preferred Strategies of Conflict Behaviour in
Adolescents with Intellectual Disabilities and Normal Development
The choice of cooperation strategy of in a general education school
is almost twice as high as in a special school. We should clarify that this
comparison was taken as a percentage from the number of all choices in
the group. In the future, for more explicit data, we will use the average
quantitative indicators of the intensity of the feature in points for each
strategy of behaviour. The most preferred behaviour strategies, both for
the younger and for the older adolescents with intellectual disabilities,
are rivalry, adaptation, and avoidance (see Fig. 2).
The behaviour of teens with intellectual disabilities in the choice of
rivalry is characterised by the desire to insist on his/her own, willingness
24
to engage in an open struggle for his/her own interests, neglecting the
interests of another person, accusing others, demanding solving the
problem for him/her. This indicates an unformed personality and selfawareness of teens with intellectual disabilities. It also emphasizes the
discrepancy between personal expectations and the requirements of the
social environment for this category of children. The fact that the level
of rivalry from younger teens to the older ones practically does not
change (t=-1.59, p=0.11) testifies to the later formation of the
personality of the adolescents with intellectual disabilities.
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
younger adolescents
adaptation
avoidance
compromise
cooperation
0
rivalry
1
older adolescents
Fig. 2. Types of Behaviour of Adolescents with Intellectual
Disabilities in Conflict Situations (Quantitative Indicator
of the Feature Intensity in Points)
In children with normal development, the level of rivalry over the
years reduces (t=2.68, p=0.021), since their social status and personal
expectations adequately correlate, whereas self-awareness increase leads to
higher tolerance, i.e. acceptance of other people's opinions, and selfcontrol. Thus, the difference in the dynamics of rivalry from younger to
senior adolescents in general education and special school reveals
qualitative differences in these groups. Avoidance of the conflict and
partial refusal to seek alternative solutions indicates passive social position
of adolescents with intellectual disabilities. The main reason here lies in the
underdevelopment of the cognitive and personal spheres of these students.
25
When the emotional and volitional manifestations of adolescents with
intellectual disabilities experience enormous social and emotional burden,
which is a conflict, they prefer to avoid this conflict situation. Adolescents
from general education schools are also characterised by avoidance of the
conflict, but the number of avoidants decreases significantly (t=3.12,
p=0.003) for senior classes, which indicates an increase in the degree of
personality activity of the surveyed students.
The adaptation strategy is expressed in the desire to preserve the
relationship, the willingness to give up and obey contrary to their
interests. The quantitative indicator of adaptation in the conflict is not
different among adolescents of general education and special schools.
However, observations show qualitative differences in this feature in
different groups. In adolescents with intellectual disabilities, this is due
to the underdevelopment of the volitional sphere, the inability to defend
their point of view, with pronounced conformity. One more reason for
the avoidance and adaptation of such adolescents in the conflict is the
immatureness of moral norms + forced submission to the requirements
of others. The only factor that restrains their aggressiveness is the fear of
punishment (a high sense of guilt). Thus, they are characterised by a
constant conflict between conscientiousness and a sense of guilt, which
leads to the increase in negative emotional states. Adolescents with
normal development, more prone to reflection and responsibility, tend to
obey to stereotypes and rules. They often occupy a passive submission
position basing on moral norms, and the level of electoral adaptation
increases before high school age (t=-2.44, p=0.018).
There is a tendency towards the reduction of socially passive forms
of response in the situation of conflict in adolescents (avoidance,
adaptation) till senior classes of special school, but it is not significant
(t=1.93, p=0.056; t=1.68, p=0.095).
In the interpersonal sense, the ability of the group members to
compromise in a conflict situation, to strive to bridge differences, to
cave on in exchange for a climb-down, to seek a middling solution has a
great importance, especially when it comes to dyadic communication.
The choice of this strategy is most often used when the object of conflict
is not of great importance to the parties, there is no depth of
understanding of his/her purpose, then teens are ready to cave on if the
"opponent" gives in to them. This strategy is equally inherent in
adolescents from both groups.
26
Extremely rarely, for the resolution of conflict situations,
adolescents with intellectual disabilities use collaboration. The main
reason lies in the weakness and inertia of the neural processes in these
adolescents compared with the norm, which prevents them from making
quick switching, taking into account both the situation and perceptions,
as well as the understanding of their own and others' behaviour in it.
Consequently, taking into account the aforementioned and the relevant
quantitative data, we can state that adolescents with intellectual
disabilities have poorly developed actualisation of social experience, the
awareness of the situation, the ability to regulate their behaviour and the
activation of reference formations, which are necessary for compromise
and cooperation. Moreover, without any corrective work, the level of
cooperation and compromise from younger to senior adolescents does
not change (t=0.06, p=0.95; t=-1.52, p=0.13). Teens from general
education schools are more likely to cooperate (p<0.01), i.e. in a conflict
situation they are ready to realise the need to understand the claims of
another person in dyadic communication and adequately assess the
positions of the other side.
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
boys
adaptation
avoidance
compromise
cooperation
rivalry
0
girls
Fig. 3. Behaviour Types of Adolescents with Intellectual Disabilities
in Conflict Situations (Quantitative Indicator
of the Feature Intensity in Points)
27
It should be noted that there are gender differences in the
manifestation of different behaviour strategies of adolescents with
intellectual disabilities in a conflict situation (see Fig. 3).
Thus, boys with intellectual disabilities demonstrate higher
competition in a difficult situation (p<0.01), than girls, indicating
potential readiness for conflict. An unsolvable situation for them
becomes a trigger for aggressive behaviour. Whereas girls are inclined to
avoid open confrontation, adapt to the situation, compromise. In addition
to that, girls are more likely to cooperate in conflict (p<0.01) than boys,
they even show responsibility for the occurrence and correction of this
situation. There is a similar situation in general education school, but it
is interesting that the ability to compromise there is more pronounced in
boys than in girls (p<0.05). Furthermore, in the same group, there is a
slight decrease in compromise indicators for senior classes in favour of
cooperation.
Answers received for the adapted version of K. Thomas model were
thoroughly checked with observation protocols regarding the behaviour
of adolescents in conflict situations. In the observation, the researchers
used a scheme basing on the principles of critical or frustrating situation
as described by S. Rosenzweig 10.
In order to find out the differences in the types of manifestations of
the same behaviour strategy in adolescents and the direction of these
strategies, the team used Rosenzweig's projective technique11.
S. Rosenzweig highlights three ways of behaviour in a critical
situation – a response with concentration on ego defence, obstruction
and satisfaction of needs. Considering the direction the scientist
distinguish extra, intra-and intuitive responses. While examining the
results of the research based on Rosenzweig Picture Association Test, it
was revealed that there are no reliable differences in the methods of
response in a conflict or critical situation in groups of adolescents with
normal development and with intellectual disabilities (see Fig. 4).
Extra-punitive responses (E) prevail in both older and younger
adolescents. This result can be interpreted as follows: many of them are
more likely to blame others in an unsuccessful situation then than
Лукин С.Е. Суворов А.В. Тест рисуночной ассоциации Розенцвейга
(руководство по использованию). СПб., 1993. С. 43.
11
Там же. 62 с.
10
28
themselves or objective circumstances, therefore they demand meeting
their needs from others. It turned out that in adolescents, non-punitive
responses (M) were developed to a lesser extent, when the conflict
situation itself was seen as insignificant and inevitable. As for the
responsibility of the teenager himself/herself for the incident (I), this
response is quite pronounced in all adolescents. There is a uniform
distribution of responses with fixation on the satisfaction of continued
need (NP), on ego defence (ED) and on obstacle dominance (OD) in a
group of teenagers with normal development, and this distribution is
preserved from younger grades to senior ones. In the group of young
adolescents with intellectual disabilities, the response with obstacle
dominance (OD) prevails over the response with continued need (NP),
whereas the situation for the older adolescents is exactly the opposite.
The response with fixation on ego defence (ED) does not significantly
change with age.
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
E
I
M
OD
ED
NP
adolescents with intellectual disabilities
adolescents with normal development
Fig. 4. Types and Directions of Behavioural Responses
to Conflict in Adolescents with Intellectual Disabilities
and Normal Development (Quantitative Indicator
of the Feature Intensity in Points)
29
It should be outlined that there are gender differences in the
manifestation of these responses both in adolescents with intellectual
disabilities and in adolescents with normal development. For instance,
intra-punitive (I) responses are more typical for girls (p<0.01) than for
boys, with the responsibility for the occurrence and correction of this
situation. On the contrary, boys more often demonstrate extra-punitive
(E) responses (p<0.01 for those with intellectual disabilities, p<0.05 for
those with normal development).
In other words, boys more often than girls choose tactics of
behaviour blaming the outside environment, while girls more often
shoulder the blame and take responsibility. Thus, girls, in contrast to
boys, are more oriented towards the rules and regulations in their
behaviour. Boys most frequently demonstrate ego defence responses
(p<0.01 for those with intellectual disabilities, p<0.05 for those with
normal development), blaming someone, shouldering the blame or
avoiding the blame – all actions are aimed at protecting their own ego.
For girls who are more inclined to blame themselves, a conflict
insurmountable situation can become the cause of leaving or adapting
with subsequent neuroticism. For boys who are more prone to look for
causes of failure outside, the insurmountable conflict situation is the
impetus for rivalry with manifestations of aggression and violations of
social norms.
This explains easier and more comfortable socialisation of girls
both in general education and in special school, as girls' activities are
largely aimed at subordinating to the norms and stereotypes that ensure
the resolution of many conflict situations.
We would like to emphasize how the responses of adolescents with
intellectual disabilities to failure and difficult insurmountable situations
and ways of resolving these conflict situations are interrelated. The
rivalry among younger and older adolescents correlates with extrapunitive (E) responses (r=0.83; r=0.81 correspondingly) and ego defence
(ED) responses (r=0.63; r=0.31 correspondingly). When trying to cope
with the conflict, the teenager blames others, requires them to solve the
problem, protects his own Self, goes on an open clash, typically with
equal ones, defends his/her positions, seeks to prove that the other
person is wrong, trying to overturn him/her, to use physical violence, to
call for the help of others. In addition to that, extra-punitive responses
30
and ego defence responses (ED) are interrelated in younger (r=0.61) and
older (r=0.43) adolescents.
In younger and older adolescents with intellectual disabilities,
adaptation correlates with intra-punitive (I) responses (r=0.39; r=0.43,
respectively) and obstacle dominance (OD) responses (r=0.43; r=0.37
respectively). The situation seems to be insurmountable to adolescents,
they suppress their negative emotions more often because of fear, bear
with what is happening, in order not to disturb peace, transfer aggressive
emotions into the inner sphere, worry, often cry, silent, harbouring
thoughts of revenge. Intra-punitive responses have inverse correlations
with the extra-punitive ones (r=-0.79; r=-0.81, respectively). Intrapunitive responses are interconnected with responses of continued need
in both younger (r = 0.62) and older (r = 0.48) adolescents. They also
have inverse correlations with ego defence responses (r = -0.54) in
younger teens.
In case of choosing avoidance strategy, there is not enough
correlation with the directions and types of responses in older
adolescents; there is a tendency to interrelate only in girls. Here, the
avoidance correlates with the intra-punitive (I) response (r = 0.44) and
the response with obstacle dominance (r=0.37). Avoidance typically
includes demonstration removal, abused care, tears, concealed anger,
ignorance of the offender, complete abandonment of relationships.
Younger adolescents show a tendency of interrelation between
avoidance and non-punitive (M) responses (r=0.42). This suggests that
they tend to avoid conflicts more often in cases of insignificance,
superficiality of goals and interests in the situation.
While examining the results of the correlation of compromise and
cooperation with the types and directions of response, younger
adolescents did not have explicit preferences in the choice. In older
teenagers with intellectual disability, the compromise correlates with the
non-punitive (M) response (r=0.35), collaboration – with intra-punitive
(M) response (r=0.5) and response with fixation on continued need
(r=0.5). It should be noted that the non-punitive (M) response correlates
with the response aiming to satisfy continued need (NP) in older
adolescents (r=0.37) and in older and younger girls (r=0.37).
The obtained results allow us to talk about the choice of behaviour of
a teenager with intellectual disabilities as a result of his/her socialisation.
Hence, on demand: "Give me the push scooter!" we often saw such
31
answers as: "I will not give it!", "You wish, it's mine" or "You can wait",
less often, more preferable for girls: "Take it!" or "Let's roll together".
The phrase: "Finally I caught you!" provoked such answers as: "Leave me
alone!", "It's their fault!", "I've simply passed by, catch the other ones" or
"Sorry, please, I will be good", "Let me go, I'll tell my mom".
A teenager solves a difficult situation basing on the norms
facilitated by the family, school, and closest entourage. An adolescent
show his/her worth aggressively, submissively or independently. On the
basis of these materials, we can talk about the mechanisms of
socialisation in overcoming conflict situations, namely active-offensive
(aggressive or constructive) and passive-defensive (obedient or
responsible). If, due to intellectual underdevelopment, moral norms are
not mastered sufficiently, control over their actions and actions is not
developed, the situation is not perceived adequately, then it is possible to
speak more about affective responses towards what is happening, and
these responses were included as the elements of extra-, intra- and nonpunitive responses. We will deal with the aggressive or subordinate
mechanism of socialisation. Let's say, some teens with intellectual
disabilities showed such prevailing responses: "Let me sit quietly. Leave
me alone", "Please, let me swing, too, you got some nerve!", "Look
who's talking!", "You wish! I'll be drumming", "You would fall like
that!" Other answers included: "I'm sorry, I did not want to do it", "I'm
sorry, I will be good", "Okay", "Oh well…" It is curious that in some
cases these responses were intermittent in the same adolescents.
After analysing the data obtained, one can conclude that a high level
of aggressiveness or submissiveness is due to low socialisation in the
peer group. The average rate of adaptation to social environment
according to Rosenzweig's technique in the group of younger teens is
GCR = 33.3%, among older teens it is = 42%. These children place high
demands on others, this often serves as a sign of inadequate and unstable
self-esteem and impedes interpersonal contacts with other adolescents.
We should underline that in the group of adolescents from general
education schools GCR = 51% in junior classes and 69% – in senior
ones.
At the same time, normal teenagers also quite often conflict with
each other, subsequently explaining it by the fact that refusal from
rivalry can be perceived as a concession and a path to defeat. Moreover,
in critical and conflict situations, adolescents from general education
32
schools often choose continued need (NP) response (search for a way
out, a constructive solution, desire to meet the needs, not to leave the
situation unresolved) along with ego defence (E).
Therefore, in teenagers with intellectual disabilities, the choice of
behaviour in conflict depends on the level of their socialisation and is
conditioned by their conflicting relationships between internal and
external behaviour regulators. Namely, on the one hand, they are
characterised by the immaturity of moral norms, but, on the other hand,
they are compelled to obey the requirements of others. The only factor
that restrains their aggressiveness is the fear of punishment (a high
sense of guilt). Thus, they are characterised by a constant conflict
between conscientiousness and a sense of guilt, which leads either to
rivalry with the strengthening of negative responses, or to avoidance
and adaptation with suppression of their emotions due to fear of an
opponent or punishment.
The study also intended to detect the influence of the peculiarities
of neurodynamics and the defect structure on the behaviour of
adolescents with intellectual disabilities in the conflict. In order to do
this, all study subjects were divided into groups according to the clinical
behaviours described by M. Pevzner12. When comparing, we noted
behavioural patterns characteristic for each group and revealed the fact
that the dominant strategy is rivalry. Nevertheless, the research has
shown that this strategy manifests itself differently in adolescents from
different groups. During the correlation and comparative analysis
between the groups, the scholars found that in some cases there was
verbal and nonverbal aggression, open struggle and confrontation, the
desire to achieve the own goals in any way, to meet the own needs. In
other cases, rivalry turned out to be a stumbling block in the conflict. We
marked this strategy with the same name. It is characterised by extrapunitive resistance and resolving responses: fixation on the purpose and
problem, inability to distract, break in the activity, inability to make any
decision, affective-dynamic reactions (irritation, anger of high intensity,
self-aggression and aggression directed towards outsiders or objects,
crying, feeling of helplessness, rigidity of emotions, desire for
immediate changes in everything). When a teenager is stuck, s/he cannot
Певзнер М.С. Дети с интеллектуальными нарушениями: Изучение детей в
процессе их обучения и воспитания. М. : Педагогика, 1959. 489 с.
12
33
get out of a problem situation, s/he wants to solve it, end it, but at the
expense of another person, regardless of who actually created the critical
situation. With such typical behaviours, a teenager can cry for a long
time, scream, "go nuts", scatter things, and demonstrate no response to
the actions of others, who are trying to shift his/her attention. Most
often, a stumbling block is found in a group of adolescents with
psychopathic manifestations (64.61% of all rivalry choices), with a lack
of frontal lobes (50% of all rivalry choices), as well as adolescents with
neurodynamic violations (with excitation superiority of 30.32%;
inhibition – 52.97%, with the weakness of both processes – 25.29% of
all rivalry choices).
The compromise also manifests itself in different ways in
adolescents with intellectual disabilities. In some groups, this was a
conscious strategy of behaviour, the ability to regulate their actions. In
others, it was a patterned stereotype of behaviour, not motivated by
circumstances. The adolescents of the main group and adolescents
with a violation of the analysers appeared to be more capable of a
conscious compromise in the conflict situation (6.91 and 6.64 out of
30 correspondingly).
The choice of cooperation is highest in the first (main) group of
adolescents without extreme violations of neurodynamics and analysers
(3.27). A fairly high level of cooperation and compromise in adolescents
with an uncomplicated form of oligophrenia can actively influence the
formation of a productive behaviour strategy among students in this
group. The fact of high (in comparison with other groups) cooperation in
adolescents with a predominance of inhibition processes over excitation
(third group) needs a special explanation (3.66 out of 30). The lack of
awareness of the situation by these teenagers makes their reactions to the
conflict monotypic, subordinate, with the choice of an intra-punitive
obstacle-dominant orientation, which is characterised by subordination,
self-accusation, confession that they are a cause of a critical situation,
avoidance or obedience. However, obedience to the norms, requirements
and rules of others in conditions of educational process at school helps
these adolescents to memorize stereotypes, patterns of behaviour that
solve a conflict situation. This explains some increase in cooperation in
this group of adolescents and, as the study shows, this trend becomes
visible in the usual recurring conflict situations at school.
34
We strongly believe that all revealed peculiarities of conflict
behaviour in teens with intellectual disabilities compose sufficient
material necessary for creating a complete psychological picture and
organising productive corrective work on prevention and constructive
resolution of conflicts in the behaviour of adolescents at special school.
CONCLUSIONS
1. The developed complex research procedure allows to study the
features of conflict behaviour effectively, its causes and the ways of
resolving conflicts that are typical for adolescents with intellectual
disabilities, which is the basis for the specification of the directions of
psychological and pedagogical work with this category of students.
2. The causes of conflictual behaviour in adolescents with
intellectual disabilities include biological ones, related to the structure of
the defect and the peculiarities of neurodynamics; psychological ones,
associated with the peculiarities of personal development and subjective
perception of the situation; social ones, associated with the conditions of
a teenager development in the immediate social environment (family,
school).
3. Prevailing strategies of conflict behaviour in adolescents with
intellectual disabilities are destructive types (rivalry, adaptation,
avoidance). Teenagers with a predominance of excitation processes, with
psychopathic and frontal syndromes are the most susceptible to rivalry.
Adaptation and avoidance more often appears in torpid adolescents and
adolescents with various violations of analysers. In students with
intellectual disabilities with an uncomplicated form of oligophrenia, the
percentage of selecting cooperation and compromise is rather high,
compared to other groups, and therefore the development of these
strategies is the "zone of immediate development" of such adolescents.
4. There are gender differences in the choice of the behaviour
strategy in conflict by adolescents with intellectual disabilities. Boys are
more likely to use rivalry in conflict than girls; for girls, passive forms of
behaviour (adaptation, avoidance) are more typical, as well as
productive strategy, i.e. cooperation.
5. For teenagers with intellectual disabilities, there is a special
distinctive type of behaviour in conflict, which is a so-called stumbling
block. When this behaviour type floats to the surface, the teenager is not
able to cope with the situation on his/her own. More often, a stumbling
35
block is found in a group of adolescents with psychopathic
manifestations, as well as in adolescents with neurodynamic violations.
6. The obtained psychological information allows determining
directions and conditions of differentiated, individualised corrective
work, in particular, group psychocorrection with the aim of preventing
conflicts and conflicting behaviour among adolescents with intellectual
disabilities, and creates psychological preconditions for socialisation.
The conducted study does not exhaust all aspects of the issue.
Conflicts between younger students with intellectual disabilities, as well
as youth, and the peculiarities of their behaviour, which determines
conflict situations require further study. Furthermore, research should
focus on the in-depth study of family conflicts among students of special
schools.
SUMMARY
The research is devoted to the study of biological, psychological
and social causes of conflicts in adolescents with intellectual disabilities,
as well as the peculiarities of their behaviour in conflict situations. To
this end, the authors revealed subjective preconditions for the emergence
of conflicts. The results of the study showed the dependence of conflict
behaviour on the level of well-being of the family, the attitude of family
members towards the adolescent, and the style of family education,
which affects the formation of particular stereotypes of behaviour:
dependent, detached or aggressive. The paper revealed the objects of
positive and negative appraisals of adolescents with intellectual
disabilities of their family status.
During the study, the scholars noted positive and negative factors of
school life, influencing the formation and predominance of behaviour
strategies of adolescents with intellectual disabilities in conflict
situations.
The article discovered the dependence of the choice of different
strategies of conflict behaviour on the level of mental development, the
structure of the defect, as well as the age and gender characteristics of
adolescents. The authors named prevailing strategies in the behaviour of
teenagers with intellectual disabilities. The research included a more indepth analysis of the types of behaviour distinctive for adolescents with
intellectual insufficiency in difficult-to-solve situations, and after taking
36
into account the structure of their defect and neurodynamics they
identified this type of behaviour in conflict as a stumbling block.
REFERENCES
1. Бистрова Ю.О. Забезпечення наступності в процесі
професійно-трудової соціалізації осіб з вадами інтелектуального
розвитку : монографія. Луганськ : Вид-во ДЗ «ЛНУ імені Тараса
Шевченка». 2012. С. 156-217.
2. Бистрова Ю.О., Синьов В.М. Діагностика індивідуальнопсихологічних рис особистості як початковий етап процесу
професійно-трудової соціалізації учнів з особливими освітніми
потребами. Nowoczesna edukacja: flozofa, innowacja, doświadczenie.
Nr1. Łódź : Wydawnictwo Naukowe Wyższej Szkoły Informatyki i
Umiejętności, 2015. Р. 120-129.
3. Божович Л.И. Избранные психологические труды.
Проблемы формирования личности. / под ред. Д.И.Фельдштейна.
М. : Международная педагогическая академия, 1995. 349 с.
4. Ложкин Г.В., Повякель Н.И. Практическая психология
конфликта. К. : МАУП, 2002. С. 66-74.
5. Лукин С.Е. Суворов А.В. Тест рисуночной ассоциации
Розенцвейга (руководство по использованию). СПб. 1993. 62 с.
6. Певзнер М.С. Дети с интеллектуальными нарушениями:
Изучение детей в процессе их обучения и воспитания. М. :
Педагогика, 1959. 489 с.
7. Спеціальна психолого-педагогічна діагностика / за ред.
Ю.О. Бистрова, В.Є. Коваленко. Харків: Майданс, 2018. 170 с.
Information about the author:
Bystrova Yu. O.
Doctor of Psychological Sciences,
Professor of the Department of Psychocorrectional Pedagogics
National Pedagogical Dragomanov University
9, Pyrohova str., Kyiv, 01601, Ukraine
37