CUN.
CHEM.40/12,
(1994)
2260-2266
#{149}
Molecular
Pathology
Detection of a-Thalassemias by Multiplex Polymerase Chain Reaction
Lemuel
J. Bowie,”4
Poluru
L. Reddy,’
Moolky
Nagabhushan,2
Although a-thalassemia is the most common genetic abnormality in the world, there is currently no routine laboratory method to definitively identify individuals who are
affected. We describea rapid and simple method that
utilizes deletion-sensitive primers to amplify normal DNA
sequences. Deletions involving the regions responsible
for most of the a-thalassemia cases in the US prevent
amplification with these primers. In tests with DNA isolated from small amounts (10 L) of whole blood, the
deletion-sensitive primers gave rise to the expected 248and 375-bp (base pair) amplification products in normal
individuals. These primers, along with primers designed
to bind to a nonaffected control sequence from the hemoglobin p chain, could be amplified simultaneously (multiplex polymerase chain reaction). This made it possible to
detect heterozygotes for a-thalassemia-2 (one a locus
deleted) by determining the ratios of the 248- and 375-bp
amplification products to the product of the control sequence (268 bp). The method is rapid and simple and can
be performed in a routine clinical laboratory.
IndexIngTerms:heritable disorders/hemoglobin
defects/gene
am-
plification/anemia
The mild a-thalassemia
(deletion of one of the
the most common
Thalassemia
can
mutation in the
that leads to reMore than 95% of
a-tha]assemia
conditions are caused by deletions of one or
more a-globin genes (4); structural mutations alone rarely
cause a thalassemic
syndrome
(4,5). The resulting
imbalance between
a and p chain production leads to accumulation of excess 9 chains, which are unstable and precipitate out within the cell, thus altering the membrane and
causing the clinical manifestations
(6, 7).
In a normal individual,
the two a genes along with
three other pseudogenes
(.1’s,,.Ira2, and .fra,) and a gene
on the
of undetermined
function
(Or) are all located
short arm of chromosome
16 in the order: telomere-fi1ia-i/ia1-a-a1-O1-centromere.
If a single deletion occurs
on only one chromosome,
the condition
is clinically
silent. Among black Americans,
this occurs with a
prevalence
of 2 7.5% (8), representing
a gene frequency
of 0.16. Given this prevalence,
>8 million black Amergenotype
four genes for the hemoglobin a chain) is
genetic abnormality
in the world (1-3).
result
from either a deletion or a point
a-globin gene or a controlling
sequence
duced synthesis
of hemoglobin a chains.
‘Department
of Pathology
and Laboratory
Medicine, Evanston
Hospital, 2650 Ridge Ave., Evanston, IL 6020 1-1783, and DepartUniversity Medical School, Chiment of Pathology, Northwestern
cago, IL.
of Pathology, Cleveland, OH 44706.
3Pharmacia
LKB Biotechnology, Inc., Uppsala, Sweden.
4Author for correspondence. Fax 708-570-2969.
Received August 5, 1994; accepted September 12, 1994.
2260
CUNICAL CHEMISTRY, Vol. 40, No. 12, 1994
and Pierre
Sevigny3
icans could be affected by this condition. The majority
of these single deletions
involve a 3.7-kilobase
(kb)
located
primarily
on the right side (-a37;
deletion
“rightward
deletion”) of the a locus (5) [a “leftward
deletion” results in the loss of a 4.2-kb segment,
but
this condition is rare in the overall US population
(9)].
If the deletion occurs on both chromosomes,
a clinically
observable
thalassemia
occurs (a-thalassemia
trait).
This condition
occurs with an incidence of almost 3% in
American
blacks (8). It is, therefore,
likely to be a
significant
cause of microcytic
anemia
that does not
respond to oral iron therapy in black children (4). If
three loci are deleted,
severe thalassemia
occurs (hemoglobin
H disease).
In individuals
from Southeast
Asia and the Mediterranean
areas, the most common
or
deletion is one that involves both a loci (- -SEA
- -MED)
on the same chromosome.
Inheritance
of this
defect on both chromosomes
results in no a chain production, and affected fetuses often die in utero. The
prevalence
of the - - SEA mutation is 3-5% in Southeast Asia (10), and that of the - -MED deletion is <1%
in the Mediterranean
basin (10); the frequency of these
conditions in the US is unknown.
The recent development of simple, sensitive, rapid DNA
technologies
have made it possible to develop useful prodiseases
that were
cedures for the diagnosis of various
previously
impossible or too cumbersome
and costly to
perform.
Because
most a-thalassemia
mutations are due
to deletions of one or more a loci on chromosome 16 (4, 5),
a specific strate’
to detect these deletions (and differentiate them from nondeletional mutations) would be useful.
Thus, several attempts have been made to develop a DNAbased test for diagnosing a-thalassemias
(2,11-13).
These
methods take advantage
of the sensitivity
of polymerase
chain reaction (PCR) techniques, but some also require the
use of restriction enzyme cleavage of the amplified product
(11, 12). In
before analysis for adequate interpretation
addition, none of those methods attempts to reliably and
objectively distinguish
between homozygetes,
heterozygetes, and normal subjects by using quantitative
PCR
techniques
(13, 14). Here we describe
a method to detect
high-frequency
deletional types of a-tha]assemia
(a37,
-SEA, - -MED), using multiplex polymerase
chain reaction (M-PCR) techniques (15,16). The method does not
enzymes
and provides clear
require the use of restriction
analytical
criteria for distinguishing
between various
types of deletions.
Materials and Methods
Materials
The regions of frequent gene deletions for the a1 and
a2 globin loci are represented
in Fig. 1. Primers were
designed to be complementary
to regions affected by
deletions (-a37
and --SEA/-MED; Table 1). In addition, a specific pair of primers was synthesized
to amplify a region surrounding
the 5’ end of the f3-globin
gene and was used as a positive control for amplification
efficiency. Potential
primer pairs were evaluated
for
maximum
specificity, optimal GC content, and freedom
from intramolecular
structures
by use of commercial
software
(OLIGO”;
National
Biosciences,
Plymouth,
MN). The a- and $-globin primers, synthesized
by the
phosphoroamidite
method on a DNA synthesizer
(Gene
Assembler
PlusT”; Pharmacia
Biotechnology,
Piscataway, NJ), were then deprotected
by treatment
with
concentrated
ammonia
for 1 h at 55#{176}C
and passed
through
“NAP 10” spin columns (Pharmacia
Biotechnology) as indicated
by the manufacturer.
The absorbance of primer solutions was read at 260 and 280 nm,
and the solutions were diluted to an absorbance of3.OA
(-1.0 mol/L).
PCR
For PCR amplifications,
we used a Gene Amp”
System 9600 thermal cycler from Perkin-Elmer
Cetus
(Norwalk,
CT). Mononucleotides
(dATP, dCTP, dGTP,
dTTP) for PCR amplifications
were obtained
from Pharmacia Biotechnology.
Recombinant
Taq polymerase
as
well as unlabeled
/3-globin primers
(GH2O and PCO4)
Cetus; agarose was
were obtained
from Perkin-Elmer
from FMC BioProducts
(Rockland, ME). Purified human
placental
DNA was obtained from Oncor (Gaithersburg,
MD). Residual
EDTA-anticoagulated
blood samples
from specimens
collected for hematological
analyses
were used for the PCR DNA amplifications.
We evaluated the reliability of the M-PCR technique with DNA
samples
previously
confirmed
by Southern
transfer
analysis
to have specific
mutations
(obtained
from
Stephen
Thibodeau,
Mayo Clinic, Rochester,
MN).
These samples were coded so that the genotypes were
not known until the analysis and interpretations
were
completed.
Procedures
DNA isolation.
Template
DNA was prepared
by a
modification
of the method of Lewin and StewartHaynes (17). Whole blood (10 L) was hemolyzed
with
500 L of distified water and centrifuged.
The pellet was
then washed two times with 500 L of distilled water in
a 1.5-mL microcentrifuge
tube. We dissolved the DNA
pellet in 10 tL of 0.2 mol/L KOH containing
0.05 mol/L
this at 65#{176}C
for 5 miii in a
dithiothrietol,
incubated
375bp
5’
a2
tIl
water bath, and then added 1 1zL of 1.0 mol/L HC1. After
mixing, we added 10 tL of 0.6 mol/L Tris-HC1, pH 8.3,
containing
0.2 mol/L KC1, followed by 20 L of sterile
distified water and heated the solution at 99.9#{176}C
(on the
System 9600 thermal cycler) for 8 mm to destroy any
residual nucleases. Aliquots (2-4 L) of the above extract were mixed with PCR reaction mixture
components to yield a total volume of 20 L for all amplifications.
PCR amplification.
All of the PCR amplifications
were
performed
with stock PCR amplification
buffer containing (per liter) 500 mmol of KC1, 100 mmol of Tris-HC1,
15 mmol of MgC12, and 0.1 g of gelatin (pH 8.3). The
amplification
reaction mixture contained PCR amplification buffer (10-fold-diluted
stock buffer), 0.2 pmol of
primers, 2.0 nmol of dNTP (dATP, dCTP, dGTP, and
dTTP), DNA template (200-1600
ng), and 0.25 U of Taq
polymerase
in a total volume of 20 pL. No overlaying oil
was necessary.
The primers used to detect
the _a&7
deletion were F37.1F and F37.3 (Table 1), the sense and
antisense
strands, respectively.
The primers for the
Southeast
Asian and Mediterranean
deletions
were
F13F and F14. The cycling sequence was as follows: an
initial DNA denaturation
step of 94#{176}C
for 3 miii followed
by 35 cycles of denaturation
at 94#{176}C
for 30 s, annealing
at 55#{176}C
for 60 s, and extension at 72#{176}C
for 60 s. A final
extension at 72#{176}C
for 3 mm was followed by cooling at
4#{176}C.
Samples were held at 4#{176}C
on the thermal cycler or
in a refrigerator
until used for further analysis
(e.g.,
agarose gel electrophoresis,
polyacrylainide
gel electrophoresis, or cycle sequencing).
The amplified products
resulting from amplification
of a normal specimen with
each of the primer pairs were 375, 248, and 268 base
reaction
pairs (bp) long (Table 1). A blank amplification
containing
all reagents
but without DNA was used as a
negative control. A sample of human placental
DNA or
known normal human leukocyte DNA was also included
in each set of experiments
as a positive control.
Multiplex
PCR amplification.
Using the optimal conditions for the amplification
of individual
DNA fragments as a starting point, we investigated
the conditions required for the optimal amplification
of all three
fragments
in a single reaction. The optimal reaction
conditions were found to be the same as for the individual PCR reactions.
Therefore, we used the same cycling
conditions as described
above, cooling the samples to
4#{176}C
after cycling. To analyze the PCR products,
we used
248bp
al
til
Fig. 1. Diagram
of a-globin gene cluster on chromo-
some 16.
The 01locus does not code
for any known functional protein;
and a1 loci code for identical proteins
but haveminor
differences in their DNA sequences.The codingsequences
are separated by noncodingsequences (introns,
(exons, #{149})
0). The most frequently occurring deletions (-a37,
- -SEA,
and - -MED) are indicatedbythe black bars below thegenes.
Dashed lines at the endof the deletions represent the extent of
the breakpoints (15). The amplification products (and their
lengthsin base pairs)used for detecting these deletionsare
indicated by the hashed bars above the genes. The coding
region on chromosome 11 for the -globin gene andthe binding sites for the control primers GH2O and PCO4 are not
shown.
the
III-3’
-
a
a
3.7jj
-
a
3#{149}7iii
Deletion
-
- MED
-
-
-
Deletion
Deletion
Deletion
SEA Deletion
a2
CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, Vol. 40, No. 12, 1994
2261
Table 1. PrImer sequences.
Am
Am
Pdmsr
Pdm
esqn
F13F
5’-FACTGGAGAGGAGAGCGGGGC-3’
F14
5’-AGGCTGCGGGMGGACATcA-3’
length, bp
248
nans
SENMED
F37.1F 5’-FACcATCCCCCCAA.AAAAcAT-3’
375
F37.3
a
5’-CTCTMCCATGACAcMGTA-3’
GH2OF 5’-FGMGAGCcMGGACAGGTAC-3’
268
Control
5’-CAACTrCATCCACGTFCACC-3’
a The suffix“F” in the primer name indicates that itis a fluoresceinlabeled derivative.
PCO4
on a 2% agarose gel (Metaphor”;
FMC
BioProducts)
with Tris-acetate/EDTA
buffer (40 and 1
mmol/L, respectively,
pH 8.0) containing
ethidium broof DNA. The PCR
mide (0.5 mgfL) for visualization
reaction mixture (6 i.i.L) was mixed with 2 L of loading
buffer (2.5 gIL bromphenol blue, 2.5 gIL xylene cyanol
FF, and 400 gIL sucrose in water) and run on agarose gel
at 100 V for 45 miii at room temperature.
The gel was
viewed
under
ultraviolet
illumination
and photographed.
Fragment
analysis (quantification).
To quantiQy relative peak areas of amplified products, we separated
the
M-PCR reaction
products
with a DNA sequencer
(ALF”‘; Pharmacia
Biotechnology),
using a 6% polyseparation.
Elecacrylamide
gel for the electrophoretic
trophoretic conditions were 1500 V and 34 W, and the
gel was thermostated
at 42#{176}C.
The samples-i
L of
PCR reaction mixture and 1 pL of stop solution (deionized formamidefBlue
Dextran; Pharmacia
Biotechnology)-were
denatured
at 94#{176}C
for 3 mm and then were
loaded on the gel, which can accommodate
40 samples in
each run. The fluorescent
amplified
products were detected with a laser power of 3 mW. Peak areas were
with fragment analysis softdetermined
by integration
ware (Fragment
Manager”‘;
Pharmacia),
and the ratios
of the 248- and 375-bp amplicon
areas
to the 268-bp
control amplicon area were calculated.
To determine
fragment sizes, we included a i00-bp
DNA ladder (Pharmacia
Biotechnology)
in one of the
lanes. The DNA ladder was labeled with fluorescein by
treatment with fluorescein-labeled
12-dUTP (BoehringBiochemicals,
Indianapolis,
IN), as foler Mannheim
lows: We added 2 L each of DNA ladder (1 g/L), fill-inbuffer (200 mmol/L Tris, pH 7.6, containing
500 mmol/L
KC1, 100 mmol/L MgSO4, 40 mmol/L MgCl2, and 0.5 g/L
bovine serum
albumin),
and fluorescein-12-dUTP
(1
mmol/L) to 1 pL of Klenow fragment (Pharmacia)
and
13 L of distilled water. After incubating
the mixture
we stopped the reaction
for 90 mm at room temperature,
with 2 L of 0.4 mol/L EDTA.
The labeled DNA was
precipitated
by adding 2.5 L of 4 moIfL LmCl and 75 jtL
of prechilled
(-20#{176}C)
absolute ethanol and then incuelectrophoresis
2262
CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, Vol. 40, No. 12, 1994
After centrifugation
for 20
bated for 30 mm at - 70#{176}C.
mm at 1200g, the precipitated
DNA was washed with
cold ethanol (700 milL) and dissolved in 50 pL of Tria/
EDTA buffer. This solution is stable for at least 6
months stored at -70#{176}C.
Sequencing
of PCR products.
To confirm that the amplifled products were the result of the binding
of the
primers
to the intended region, we determined the DNA
sequence of each amplicon.
The individual
amplified
products were purified from agarose gels after electrophoresis
by adsorption
onto glass beads (Sephaglas
Band Prep Kit; Pharmacia
Biotechnology).
The yield
and purity of the amplicons were determined
qualitathe fluorescence
of the ethidium
tively by comparing
bromide-stained
bands with that of a standard
DNA
the ratio of
marker and quantitatively
by determining
absorbances
at 260 and 280 nm of samples and DNA
standards
by spectrophotometry.
The DNA cycle sequencing protocol was slightly modified from that of the
fmolm DNA Sequencing
System (Promega,
Madison,
primers
(1.0
WI), by substitution
of fluorescein-labeled
mol/L)
for radiolabeled
primers.
DNA sequence was
determined
with the ALF” DNA Sequencer (Pharmacia Biotechnology).
Results
Figure 1 shows the relationship
between
the genes
(a1 and a2), the most common
that code for a chains
deletions
in the US, and the binding regions of the
deletion-sensitive
primers.
Each a gene has three coding sequences (exons; black bars) separated by noncoding sequences (introns; white bars). The most common
mutations
resulting
in a-thalassemia
in the US give
rise to deletions of -3.7 kb (-a37 deletion). This deletion results in a single hybrid a gene, composed of a 5’ a2
sequence
and 3’ a1 sequence. Three subclasses
of the
-a37 deletion (_a3?i,
_a3#{149}7ii, and
_a37m) have been
detected by Southern transfer hybridization
(18). Individuals from Southeast
Asia and the Mediterranean
have a high prevalence
of deletions that remove both
the a2 and the a1 loci (- -SEA and - -MED, respectively). All five deletions are represented
as black bars
in Fig. 1, with the lines at the ends of the black bars
indicating
heterogeneity
with regard to the exact length
of these deletions. The cross-hatched
double lines above
the genes represent the amplification
products from the
binding
of primers to the target sequences on the sense
and anti-sense
strands of regions affected by the -a37,
-SEA, and - -MED deletions. The primers that bind
to the right of the a2 locus (F37.1F and F37.3) generate
amplification
products only if the -a37 deletion is not
present. Although the other primers generate a 375-bp
product with all three subclasses of -a37 deletions, we
did not attempt to identify the subclasses (e.g., by using
restriction enzymes). The primers that bind to the right
of the a1 locus (F13F and F14) generate
amplification
products only if the --SEA,
--MED,
or other similar
deletions are not present. The primers GH2OF and PCO4
are known to generate a 268-bp product from the region
-200bpS’
to the beginning
of exon 1 of the gene for the
hemoglobin /3 chain and extending through most of exon
1 (19). We used this sequence,
located on chromosome
11, as a control for evaluating
amplification
efficiency.
Figure 2 shows the PCR-amplified
products resulting
from the use of these primers in PCR reactions with
human placental DNA (Oncor) after agarose electrophoresis (Fig. 2, left) or polyacrylamide
gel electrophoresis
(Fig. 2, right). Polyacrylamide
gel electrophoresis
on the
ALF system allows for the determination
of peak areas
and the calculation
of relative amounts from the ratios
of these areas. The identity of the bands was confirmed
by isolating the individual bands from the agarose gel
and sequencing
the DNA with a cycle sequencing
protocol on the ALF (see Materials
and Methods).
Earlyeluting peaks (100-200 bp) represent nonspecific amplification products and do not affect the quantitation
of
target peak areas.
When all three pairs of primers were mixed together
for M-PCR, the three fragments
were amplified
without
significant
production of other products.
Fig. 3 shows
the three amplification
products obtained from various
concentrations
of placental
DNA (10-80
mg/L) in the
M-PCR reaction mixture.
As shown, all three amplillcation products are present and resolved both on agarose and polyacrylamide.
However, reliable quantification of peak areas was achieved
only from the
polyacrylamide
gels (Fig. 3, right). The ratios of amplicon peak areas (248- and 375-bp products) to the area of
the control peak (268-bp product) are summarized
in
Table 2. The ratios of the amplified
products
to the
control were relatively constant but the reproducibility
became unacceptable
(CV >10%) at DNA concentrations <20 mgIL. The presence of the background peaks
at sizes other than 248,268, and 375 bp did not affect the
quantification
of the peaks of interest, and we have not
further characterized
them.
Because
the ratio of the products
from the deletion
amplicons to that of the product of the control sequence
could be reliably determined
for DNA concentrations
>20 mg/L, these ratios were used to check for the presence of one or more of these deletions
in unknown
whole-blood
samples. Preliminary
cutoff criteria (0.10.40 for the 375/268-bp ratio) were established
for the
_aa7
deletion, based on replicate analyses
of a presumed -a37 heterozygote.
No --SEA/--MED
samples were available, so we could not establish preliminary cutoffs for these deletions. Table 3 lists the ratios of
the deletion amplicon areas to the control areas for 15
unknown
samples
whose genotypes
had been determined
by Southern transfer. Values above the cutoff
ranges indicate
that no deletion was present; values
below the cutoffs indicate the presence of deletions on
both chromosomes.
The genotypes
for the a37 locus of all
15 of the specimens were correctly identified by using a
cutoff of 0.1-0.4 for the -a37 heterozygote
ratio. For
(e.g., -a37a/--SEA
or
double heterozygotes
-MED), the data indicate the deletion of both deletion-sensitive
loci because the - -SEA or - -MED deletions affect both the a37 primer binding
region as well
as the region where the SEA/MED
primers
bind (9).
Only ii of the 15 samples had sufficient DNA for reliable quantitation
of the 248/268-bp area ratios for de-
1234
Fig. 2. Electrophoresisof PCR-ampllfiedproductsobtainedfrom 40
mg/L placental DNA: (left) separationon agarose gel; (right) ALF
scans after electrophoresison 6% polyacrylamidegel.
Primers specific for a37, for SENMED, and for exon 1 of the -globin control
regions (Table 1) were used for amplification. Amplification and electrophoretic
conditions are described in Materials and Methods. Lane 1, molecular size
ladder; lane 2, 248-bp amplified product for detecting the - -SEN- -MED
deletion; lane 3, 375-bp amplified product for detecting the -a37
deletion;
lane 4, 268-bp amplified product from hemoglobin a-chain locus serving as a
control for amplification efficiency and area ratio measurements.
300
400
amplicon size (base pairs)
CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, Vol. 40, No. 12,
1994
2263
12345
Fig. 3. (Left) Agarose gel electrophoresis of M-PCR-amplifled products obtained with the use of the deletion-sensitive primers shown in
Table 1 and the same amplification and electrophoretic conditions as
in Fig. 2 except that final placental DNA concentrations were 5, 10,
20, and 40 mg/L in the amplification reactionmixture; (right) polyacrylamideelectrophoresison ALF sequencer of same samples and
as in Fig. 3 (left) except that DNA concentrations were
conditions
slightlyhigherfor more reliable quantitationsand peak areas were
determined
by using FragmentManager software.
Left: Lane 1,molecular size ladder (100 bp); lane2: 5 maJL; lane 3, 10 mg/L;
lane 4.20 mg/L; lane 5,40 mg/L Right: Lane 1,10 mg/L; lane 2.20 mg/L; lane
3,40 mg/L lane 4, 80 mg/L lane 5, molecular size ladder (100 bp).
Table 2. Concentration dependence of area ratios for
248-, 268-, and 375-bp peaks.
Mean
±
SD (n = 8)
conc,
maJL
248/268
375/268
10
0.79
20
0.68 ± 0.03
1.00 ± 0.03
40
80
0.65 ± 0.07
0.60 ± 0.06
0.87
0.95
tecting
--SEA/--MED
±
0.14
deletions.
0.92
This is because
±
±
±
0.27
0.08
0.05
the
genotypes
were determined
by replicate analysis.
The
within-run
mean ± SD for the 248/268-bp and the 375/
268-bp ratios in normal subjects were 0.200 ± 0.032 and
(n = 6). In -a7
heterozy0.790 ± 0.081, respectively
gotes, these ratios were 0.201 ± 0.025 and 0.191 ±
0.026, respectively
(n = 7). The between-run
mean ± SD
(5 runs over 8 weeks at 1-2-week
intervals)
for the
248/268-hp and the 375/268-bp ratios in normal subjects
(n =
were 0.303 ± 0.067 and 0.879 ± 0.163, respectively
5), and 0.268 ± 0.075 and 0.217 ± 0.059, respectively,
in
-a37 heterozygotes
(n = 5).
amplification
efficiency of the SEA/MED locus is significantly less for whole-blood
DNA than for purified placen-
Discussion
tal DNA (Fig. 4). Nevertheless,
the ratios for the 11 samples were consistent with the genotypes of the samples.
Figure 4 shows the actual electrophoretic
separations
after M-PCR amplifications
performed on DNA from
individuals
confirmed by Southern
transfer to have
_aal,
--SEA,
and --MED
deletions. As suggested
above, the differences
in peak heights and areas (compared with those in Fig. 3) probably reflect different
amplification
efficiencies at the different loci because all
of the primers
were in the M-PCR reaction at equal
concentrations.
Peak areas could be made more comparable by changing
primer concentrations,
but this resulted in slightly poorer precision. Therefore, we kept
the primer concentrations
equal while establishing
cutoffs and evaluating
data as shown in Table 3. The within-run and between-run
reproducibility
of the ratios for
normal
and heterozygote
Southern transfer-confirmed
The lack of sensitive
and simple definitive tests for
a-thalassemia
has made the detection of carriers
very
difficult. As a result, its prevalence in local populations,
its effect on other clinical conditions, and accurate data
for genetic counseling
have been absent or deficient.
Therefore, we have developed a DNA-based
method that
provides definitive
data but is simple, sensitive,
and
reliable
enough
to be used in a routine clinical laboratory or other diagnostic
laboratory.
To detect the most common deletions in the a locus in
(-a37, --SEA,
and --MED),
we
the US population
designed
primer pairs that will generate no amplification products or reduced
amounts of the normal product
when the deletions
are present. We have also used
primer pairs that amplify a region of the hemoglobin
/3
locus as a control to check for amplification
efficiency for
each PCR reaction mixture. However,
this amplified
2264
CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, Vol. 40, No. 12, 1994
Table 3. Areas and area ratios for amplified products.
Product size, bp
Sample no.
1 -aa/-aa
2 (aa/aa)/(-O.
248
268
QNSb
6096
1313
10133
5879
13 232
-
(0.01.O.05)a
0.13
QNS
0.29
2003
504
QNS
6111
0.16
3269
0.04
QNS
816
464
12265
10261
7719
10176
12323
1778
QNS
334
12145
QNS
4 (aa/aa)/(/)
5 aaf- -SEA
6 aaa/aa
3901
ONS
2000
457
5319
-
(O.1_O.4)a
QNS
5032
1093
9665
3 -a37q/aa
7 (aa1--SEA)/(#{216})
8 -a31a-a42a
9 aa/aa
10 -a37--SEA
11 -a7a/--MED
375
0.08
0.04
0.03
0.40
0.03
13221
12 -a4’2a/aa
5293
9820
13 (aa/--BRIT)/(-71)
445
13866
1184
14 aa/aa
2322
13561
9624
0.17
15 -a42a1--SEA
494
12655
3222
0.04
a Cutoff range for heterozygotes; higher values indicate no deletion, lower values indicate deletions on both chromosomes.
#{176}
ONS, quantity notsufficient for reliableanalysis.
-
0.50
0.19
0.73
0.25
0.50
0.32
0.23
0.52
-
0.74
0.10
0.71
0.25
if the amplification
product ratios are highly reproducible in an analytical
gel electrophoresis
system. Because the loss of one locus would result in a >50%
reduction
in the value of the corresponding
ratio (Table
3, samples 9 and 14 vs sample 3), the reproducibility
represented
by within-run
SDs of 0.03-0.08
(see Results) is low enough for easy detection
of the deletion of
one locus. Obviously,
if two deletions
occur at the same
the corresponding
band
locus (one on each chromosome),
will be totally absent (Fig. 4).
We used the region surrounding
exon 1 of the /3 locus
for hemoglobin
as a control for amplification
efficiency;
it is not the site of frequent deletions and has been used
in a variety of amplification
techniques
and applications
as a control for amplification
efficiency (11, 19). Although we have not detected any deletions that have
resulted in the absence of amplification
of this region,
mutations
that might
affect amplification
efficiency
would easily be detected
by comparing amplicon
ratios
with those for the controls included in each run. DNA
controls for the - -SEA and - -MED deletions are not
included in each run because of limited supply. However, the multiplex format provides an internal control
for these deletions because each - -SEA or - -MED
deletion also affects the a37 amplicon area. Therefore,
changes
in the 248/268-bp and 375/268-bp ratios are in
the same direction and of similar magnitude.
Deletions
that might affect the control region only would result in
increased
(not decreased)
ratios for both the a37 and
SEA/MED amplicons,
compared with the ratios for control samples. As shown in Table 3, the - -BRIT deletion
(9), which affects both the a37 and the SEA/MED
amplicons in much the same way as the - -SEA
and
- -MED
deletions,
can also be detected
with this
M-PCR procedure.
Although
the method does not distinguish
between
-SEA,
- -MED,
and - -BRIT
deletions, these conditions should be easily distinguished
by family history, ethnic origin, etc.
only
200
amplicon
300
size (base pairs)
Fig. 4. Fragment analysis of M-PCR-amplifled
products from known
deletion mutations obtained with deletion-sensitive primers after
polyacrylamidegel electrophoresison ALF.
Lane 1,molecularsizeladder(100 bp);lane2, aa/aa; lane 3, -a37a/aa;
4, -a37--a37a;
lane 5, -a37a/---SEA;
lane 6, -a37a/- -MED.
lane
product can also be used to quantify
the number of
deletions occurring
at the a loci. By using M-PCR that
incorporates
deletion-sensitive
primer pairs as well as a
control region, one can detect single-gene
deletions involving the a locus in a single reaction. This is possible
CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, Vol. 40, No. 12, 1994
2265
The method we describe is simple enough to be performed in a routine clinical
laboratory.
The use of
M-PCR and automated
fragment
analysis
allows at
least 30-40 samples to be processed
in one day. Although we describe quantification
by using a large polyacrylamide
gel and the ALF system,
the amplicons
could be quantified
on any conventional
fluorescence
densitometer
capable of scanning
thin agarose or acrylamide gels. Analysis
and quantification
by automated
capillary
electrophoresis
systems
should also be feasible. The small quantities of sample (as little as 10 L of
whole blood or 400 ng of purified DNA) make screening
of large populations
more convenient.
Even though
a-thalassemias
resulting
from nondeletion
mutations
(9,20) cannot be detected by this method,
these are very
for population
rare (9) and would not be good candidates
screening
efforts. It is our hope that the availability
of
this
rapid
and
definitive
method
for detecting
a-thalassemia
in US populations
can lead to a better
understanding
of the
various
manifestations
of
a-thalassemia
and how they may affect the clinical presentation of other conditions.
the loan of the ALF DNA sequencer by Pharmacia in support of this work. We are grateful to Stephen Thibodeau
(Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN) for providing specimens that had
been confirmed by Southern transfer analysis. We also gratefully
acknowledge the assistance of William Wilkens and Tracy Roberts
in the preparation
of some of the figures.
We appreciate
References
1. Kan YW. Development
of DNA analysis for human diseases:
sickle cell anemia and thalassemia as a paradigm. J Am Med
Assoc 1992;267:1532-6.
2. Baysal E, Huisman THJ. Detection of common deletional
a-thalassemia-2 determinants by PCR. Am J Hematol 1994;4fl:
208-13.
3. Liebhaber
SA. a-Thalassemia.
Hemoglobin 1989;13:685-731.
4. Kazazian HH. The thalassemia syndromes: molecular basis and
prenatal diagnosis in 1990. Semin Hematol 1990;27:209-28.
5. Embury SH, Miller JA, Dozy AM, Kan YW, Chan V, Todd D.
Two different molecular
organizations
account for the single
a-globin gene of the a-thalaseemia-2
genotype. J Clin Invest
1980;66:1319-25.
2266 CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, Vol. 40, No. 12, 1994
6. Higgs DR The thalassemia
syndromes. Q J Med 1993;86:559-
64.
7. Schrier SL, Mohandas N. Globin-chain specificity of oxidationinduced changes in red blood cell membrane
properties.
Blood
1992;79:1586-92.
8. Dozy AM, Kan YM, Embuiy SH, Mentzer WC, Wang WC.
Alpha globin gene organization
in blacks precludes the severe
form of a-thalassemia. Nature 1979;280:605-7.
9. Higgs DR, Vickers MA, Wilkie AOM, Pretorius JM, Jarman
AP, Weatherafl
DJ. A review of the molecular genetics of the
human a-globin gene cluster. Blood 1989;73:1081-104.
10. Bowden DK, Vickers MA, Higgs DR. A PCR-based strategy to
detect the common severe determinants of a-thalassemia.
Br J
Haematol 1992;81:104-8.
11. Dode C, Rochette J, Krishnamoorthy R. Locus assignment of
human
a globin
mutations
by selective
amplification
and direct
sequencing. Br J Haematol 1990;76:275-81.
12. Lebo RV, Saiki RK, Swanson K, Montano MA, Erlich HA,
Golbus MS. Prenatal diagnosis of a-thalassemia by polymerase
chain reaction and dual restriction enzyme analysis. Hum Genet
1990;85:293-9.
13. Lundeberg J, Wahlberg J, Uhien M. Rapid colorimetric quantification of PCR-amplifled DNA. BioTechniques 1991;10:68-75.
14. Lubin MB, ElashoffjD, Wang SJ, Rotter JI, Toyoda H. Precise
gene dosage determination
by polymerase
chain reaction: theory,
methodology
307-17.
and
statistical
approach.
Mol Cell Probes 1991;5:
15. Chamberlain JS, Gibbs RA, Ranier JE, Nguyen PN, Caskey
CT. Deletion screening of the Duchenne muscular dystrophy locus
via multiplex DNA amplification. Nucleic Acids Res 1988;1114156.
16. Ballabio A, Ramier JE, Chamberlain JS, Zollo M, Caskey CT.
Screening for steroid sulfatase (STS) gene deletions via multiplex
DNA amplification. Hum Genet 1990;84:571-3.
17. Lewm HA, Stewart-Haynes JA. A simple method for DNA
1992;
extraction
from leukocytes for use in PCR. BioTechniques
13:522-3.
iS. Higgs DR, Hill AVS, Bowden DK, Weatherall
DJ, Clegg JB.
Independent recombination
events between duplicated human
a-globin genes: implications for their concerted evolution. Nucl
Acids Res 1984;12:6965-77.
19. Bauer HM, Ting Y, Greer CE, Chambers JC, Tashiro CJ,
Chimera J, et al. Genital human papillomavirus
infection
in
female university students as determined by a PCR-based method.
J Am Med Assoc 199 1;265:472-7.
20. Honig GR, Shainsuddin M, Vida LM, Mompoint M, Valcourt
E, Bowie U, et al. Hemoglobin Evanston (a 14 Trp - Arg) an
unstable a-chain variant expressed as a-thalassemia. J Cliii Invest
1984;73:1740-9.