Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Crafting Before and After the Collapse: Mycenaean Eleon in Boeotia

2016, RA-PI-NE-U Studies on the Mycenaean World offered to Robert Laffineur for his 70th Birthday, Aegis 10

AEGIS 10 šactesšdešcolloquesš RA-PI-NE-U Studies on the Mycenaean World offered to Robert Laffineur for his 70th Birthday Edited by Jan Driessen RA- -- S   R  o     o  o   o  o  t o  !" #$udies %n $he Mycenaean W%rld %ffered $% &%ber$ Laffineur f%r his 70'( Bir$hday E)*+,) ./ 123 45*,66,3 © Presses universitaires de Louvain, 2016 Registration of copyright: D/2016/9964/36 ISBN: 978-2-87558-512-7 ISBN PDF version: 978-2-87558-513-4 Printed in Belgium by CIACO scrl – printer number 94366 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, adapted or translated, in any form or by any means, in any country, without the prior permission of Presses universitaires de Louvain Graphic design: Marie-Hélène Grégoire Cover photo : Brussels Gold Cup (A.2249) (© MRAH/KMKG ; photo R. Pessemier) Volume set in Adobe InDesign CS6 by Nicolas Kress Distribution: www.i6doc.com, on-line university publishers Available on order from bookshops or at Diffusion universitaire CIACO (University Distributors) Grand-Rue, 2/14 1348 Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium Tel: +32 10 47 33 78 Fax: +32 10 45 73 50 [email protected] Distributor in France: Librairie Wallonie-Bruxelles 46 rue Quincampoix 75004 Paris, France Tel: +33 1 42 71 58 03 Fax: +33 1 42 71 58 09 [email protected] C89:;9:< F=>?@=>D GH JIK NOPQTTQK  5REHUW/DI¿QHXUD%LR%LEOLRJUDSK\   'LPLQL$Q8UEDQ6HWWOHPHQWRIWKH/DWH%URQ]H$JHLQWKH3DJDVLWLF*XOI   2ULJLQVRIWKH0\FHQDHDQ/XVWURXV'DUNRQ/LJKW3RWWHU\7HFKQRORJ\  UPVXIOY ZQ[mPQOT ZITP\P]P ^YO[mP_`PTmIKP gXP\Pp gj kQqIKVvwOqx `wTIK zj {QOOQKVQx ZP\P ^pvTqv\I]vwx |XvmIT }j kOv~IKx \QKP €vYIOvwx {\vOQKVQ `jzj Tw  7KHµ0LQRDQLVDWLRQ¶RIWKH$UWVLQ/&,$NURWLULDQG/+,0\FHQDH6LPLODULWLHVDQG'LIIHUHQFHV  {OPq‚ k\I]v\mQO  &UDIWLQJ%HIRUHDQG$IWHUWKH&ROODSVH0\FHQDHDQ(OHRQLQ%RHRWLD   &RQVXPHULVP'HEWDQGWKH(QGRIWKH%URQ]H$JH&LYLOLVDWLRQVLQWKH(DVWHUQ0HGLWHUUDQHDQ  kOQKYIK kwO]Q kO[IK kwOKT }IO[ ƒj NI„KQ[  7KH%UXVVHOV0\FHQDHDQ*ROG&XS  JIK NOPQTTQK  &\OLQGHU6HDO,PSUHVVLRQVRQ6WRUDJH9HVVHOVDW0DD †‡†ˆ‰Š†‹Œ‰Ž(OXFLGDWLQJDQ,GLRV\QFUDWLF /DWH&\SULRW0HFKDQLVP ^OqQmPT QvO~Pvw   3XOS)LFWLRQ7KH6HD3HRSOHVDQGWKH6WXG\RIµ0\FHQDHDQ¶$UFKDHRORJ\LQ3KLOLVWLD   0\FHQDHDQ7HUUDFRWWDVIURP)XQHUDU\&RQWH[WVLQ7URH]HQLD  vwPTQ ^j PqVXVvV] ^OQK }j }IQPO \QKP ƒvKTv\I]P_‘IKKvpvw\vw  *HWWLQJRXWRID'HDG(QGLQ)LQDO3DODWLDO&UHWH$SSO\LQJ6SDFH6\QWD[$QDO\VLVWRWKH&DVDGHL 9DQL$JJLXQWL3URJUHVVLYDPHQWHDW+DJKLD7ULDGD ’wQKqPK QqQTTvK `IKqv gOP“PqQOI  $JDLQVWWKH&XUUHQWVRI+LVWRU\7KH(DUO\WKF%&(5HVXUJHQFHRI7LU\QV JvTQpX }IOIK   ”•–—˜–—™  6SLQQLQJ*ROGDQG&DVWLQJ7H[WLOHV }IOPQ_vwPTQ €vTVX   7ZR/LQHDU%7UDYHOLQJ,QVFULSWLRQVIURPWKH8QLYHUVLW\RIWKH6RXWKLQ6HZDQHH7HQQHVVHHDQG WKH,PSDFWRIWKH'HFLSKHUPHQWRI/LQHDU%RQWKH6FKRODUO\DQG3XEOLF,PDJLQDWLRQ |XvmIT j gI\IPmI zXOPTqvpXQO }j }VNvKvw~X   7HFKQRORJLFDO6WXG\DQG,QWHUSUHWDWLRQRI5KRPERLG$FFHVVRULHVIURP*UDYH&LUFOH$0\FHQDH  €P]v\IT gIpIYPmPqOPvw \QKP ƒvKTqIKqPKPYP_`[“OPYP ^]PT vwmIT  +XPDQ+HDGVDQG&UDZOLQJ6QDNHV5LWXDO9DVHVLQ3RVWSDODWLDO0\FHQDH   *ORZLQWKHµ'DUN¶$*ROG3HQGDQWIURPD0LGGOH+HOODGLF6HWWOHPHQW $VSLV$UJRV   QKI gIpI‚v~\vw_}IKPvwYI]P ^KKI gXP\PppI_|vwVXIPT P\\QT |vwVXIPT  $ 3LFWXUH LV :RUWK D 7KRXVDQGV :RUGV 3LFWRULDO 3RWWHU\ DV D 0DUNHU IRU 6RFLR(FRQRPLF (QWDQJOHPHQWVEHWZHHQWKH&RDVWDQG+LQWHUODQG7KH&DVHRI+DOD6XOWDQ7HNNHDQG.ODYGKLD LQ6RXWK(DVW&\SUXV }Q\PTTI `ImIQT JIK zvQKIQOqT ƒIOPK €[T   0DUDWKRQLQWKH0LGGOHDQG/DWH%URQ]H$JH1HZ(YLGHQFHIURPDQ2OG([FDYDWLRQ3UHOLPLQDU\ 5HVXOWVIURPWKH([FDYDWLRQRIWKH8QLYHUVLW\RI$WKHQVDW3ODVL €I[I gv\[VXOvKI]vw_`~vwOPqTI ‘PIKKPT gIpIYIqvT ^KqXP kI\PqTIOP \QIKKI gOQ“QYvOvw   3HWVDV+RXVH3RWWHU\3URGXFWLRQDQGWKH0\FHQDHDQ3HRSOHLQ/+,,,$   &RQQHFWLQJWKH3LHFHV(J\SW'HQGUDDQGWKH(OXVLYHµ.HIWLX¶&XS  ƒPm `j `XQ\qvK €IKV[ Uj |XvmIT  )RUHLJQDIIDLUV'LSORPDF\7UDGH:DUDQG0LJUDWLRQLQWKH0\FHQDHDQ0HGLWHUUDQHDQ  %&  QOq JIK “IK ›PœK~IIOYQK  %H\RQGWKH9HUVDLOOHV(IIHFW0\FHQDHDQ*UHHFHDQG0LQRDQ&UHWH }I\Vv\m j ›PQKQO š   ž Ÿ ¡¢£¤¥¦ 5$3,1(86WXGLHVRQWKH0\FHQDHDQ:RUOGRIIHUHGWR5REHUW/DI¿QHXUIRUKLV  7KH7ZR*RGGHVVHVDQGWKH)RUPDWLRQRID3DQWKHRQLQ3KLOLVWLD   7KH*RXUQLD0HJDURQ  ^TTI¨ ‘ITwO_IKYIw JvXK j ‘vwK~QO § ©ª C«¬­:®9¯ °;­8«; ¬9± ²­:;« :³; C8´´¬µ<;¶ ·¸¹;9¬;¬9 º´;89 ®9 °8;8:®¬ »¼½¾¿À¾ »Á¼Â½ »¼ÃÀ¾ »Á¼¾Ä ÅÆÇÈÉÆÊ ËÌÉÍÆ ÎÏÐ ÑÉÉÆ ÊÎÉ ÒÍÇÓÐ ÍÒ ÊÎÉ ËÏÐÊÉÔÆ ÕÍÉÍÊÈÏ ÅÔÇÎÏÉÍÌÍÖÈÇÏÌ ×ÔÍØÉÇÊ ÐÈÆÇÉ ÙÚÚÛÜ ÝÎÉ ÐÈÊÉ ÍÇÇÓÞÈÉÐ DÀDWWRSSHGDFURSROLVZLWKLQDQDJULFXOWXUDOSODLQVWUHWFKLQJHDVWIURP7KHEHVWRWKH(XERHDQ*XOI )LJßÜ àÈÐÈÆÖ ÊÍ Ï ÎÉÈÖÎÊ ÍÒ Ùáâ ãÉÊÉÔÐ ÏÑÍäÉ ÐÉÏ ÌÉäÉÌå ÊÎÉ ÐÈÊÉ ÎÏÐ ÏÆ ÉæÇÉÌÌÉÆÊ äÈÉç ÈÆ ÏÌÌ èÈÔÉÇÊÈÍÆÐå ÈÆÇÌÓèÈÆÖ ÆÍÔÊÎ ÊÍçÏÔèÐ ÊÎÉ éÞÏÊÍÐ ãÍÓÆÊÏÈÆ ÔÏÆÖÉ ÏÆè ÊÎÉ ÔÍÓÊÉÐ ÌÈÆêÈÆÖ ÝÎÉÑÉÐ ÊÍ ëÎÏÌêÈÐ ÏÆè ÍÊÎÉÔ ÇÍÏÐÊÏÌ ÐÈÊÉÐ ÍÆ ÊÎÉ ÈÐÌÏÆè ÍÒ ËÓÑÍÉÏÜ ìÓÔÈÆÖ ÊÎÉ íÏÊÉ ÕÔÍÆîÉ ÅÖÉå ÈÆ ÑÍÊÎ ÞÏÌÏÊÈÏÌ ÏÆè ÞÍÐÊïÞÏÌÏÊÈÏÌ ÞÉÔÈÍèÐå ÊÎÉ ÍÇÇÓÞÏÆÊÐ ÍÒ ËÌÉÍÆ ÊÍÍê ÏèäÏÆÊÏÖÉ ÍÒ ÊÎÈÐ äÈÉç ÐÎÉè ÊÍ ÒÍÔÖÉ ÇÍÆÆÉÇÊÈÍÆÐ ÑÍÊÎ ÉÏÐÊ ÏÆè çÉÐÊÜ ÝÔÏÆÐÈÊÈÍÆÈÆÖ ÒÔÍã ×ÏÌÏÊÈÏÌ ÊÍ ×ÍÐÊÞÏÌÏÊÈÏÌ SHULRGVZHVHHFUDIWLQJDFWLYLWLHVDW(OHRQUHÀHFWODUJHUFKDQJHVRILQWHUHVWDQGDI¿OLDWLRQDV(OHRQ¶VQHWZRUNRI ÈÆÊÉÔÏÇÊÈÍÆ ÐÎÈÒÊÐ ÒÔÍã ÞÏÌÏÊÈÏÌ ÝÎÉÑÉÐ ÊÍ ÊÎÉ ÉãÉÔÖÉÆÊ ÆÉÊçÍÔêÐ ÒÍÇÓÐÉè ÍÆ ÊÎÉ ËÓÑÍÉÏÆ ðÓÌÒ ñòÆÍèÉÌÌ ÙÚóôßÜ M E B (EBAP E ) õö÷ø ùøúø ÝÎÉ ËÏÐÊÉÔÆ ÕÍÉÍÊÈÏ ÅÔÇÎÏÉÍÌÍÖÈÇÏÌ ×ÔÍØÉÇÊ ñËÕÅ×ß ÈÐ Ï T[KQO~ITPI ÒÍÔ ÐÓÔäÉû ÏÆè ÉæÇÏäÏÊÈÍÆ ÑÉÊçÉÉÆ ÊÎÉ ëÏÆÏèÈÏÆ éÆÐÊÈÊÓÊÉ ÈÆ ðÔÉÉÇÉ ÏÆè ÊÎÉ ËÞÎÍÔÏÊÉ ÍÒÅÆÊÈüÓÈÊÈÉÐ ÍÒ ÕÍÉÍÊÈÏå ÒÍÔãÉÔÌû ÊÎÉ ýþÿ ËÞÎÍÔÏÊÉÜ SÈÆÇÉ ÙÚóÙ ÊÎÉ T[KQO~ITPI ÎÏÐ ÑÉÉÆ ÇÍïèÈÔÉÇÊÉè Ñû ÅÌÉæÏÆèÔÏ ëÎÏÔÏãÈå ÕÔûÏÆ ÕÓÔÆÐ ÏÆè ÕÔÉÆèÏÆ ÕÓÔêÉå çÈÊÎ ÖÔÉÏÊ ÎÉÌÞ ÒÔÍã OÌÖÏ òûÔÈÏîÈ ÍÒ ÊÎÉ ËÞÎÍÔÏÊÉ1Ü ÝÎÉ ÞÔÍØÉÇÊ ÈÐ ÇÓÔÔÉÆÊÌû ÉæÇÏäÏÊÈÆÖ ÊÎÉ ÐÈÊÉ ÍÒ ÏÆÇÈÉÆÊ ËÌÉÍÆå ÌÍÇÏÊÉè ÈÆ ÊÎÉ äÈÌÌÏÖÉ ÍÒ AP OF ASTERN OEOTIA XCAVATIONS :HDUHYHU\JUDWHIXOIRUWKHVLJQL¿FDQWUHVHDUFKIXQGLQJUHFHLYHGIURPDQ,QVLJKW*UDQW  IURPWKH6RFLDO6FLHQFHV H R C   o C (HRC   I o A P       L b C   Lb   F      ! f ""#$% &') *"   ÅÔãÏå ÏÑÍÓÊ +Ú êã ÆÍÔÊÎ ÍÒ ÅÊÎÉÆÐå óÙ êã ÉÏÐÊ ÍÒ ÝÎÉÑÉÐÜ ÝÎÈÐ ÈãÞÍÔÊÏÆÊ ÐÈÊÉ ÎÏÐ ÆÍÊ ÑÉÉÆ ÞÔÉäÈÍÓÐÌû ÉæÇÏäÏÊÉè ÏÌÊÎÍÓÖÎ ÊÍÞÍÖÔÏÞÎÉÔÐ ÏÆè ÊÔÏäÉÌÉÔÐ ÎÏäÉ ÌÍÆÖ ÏÐÐÍÇÈÏÊÉè ÊÎÉ ÉÌÉäÏÊÉè ÞÌÏÊÉÏÓ çÈÊÎ ÊÎÉ ëÌÏÐÐÈÇÏÌ ÊÍÞÍÆûã ÍÒ ËÌÉÍÆ ñ,ÍÐÐÉû óý++- +ýïýâßÜ ÅÆÇÈÉÆÊ ËÌÉÍÆ çÏÐ ÊÎÉ ÇÉÆÊÔÉ ÍÒ ÏÆ ÏÔÉÏ ÐÉÌÉÇÊÉè ÒÍÔ ÐûÐÊÉãÏÊÈÇ ÔÉÖÈÍÆÏÌ ÇÍÌÌÉÇÊÈÍÆ ÐÓÔäÉû ÑÉÊçÉÉÆ ÙÚÚÛ ÏÆè ÙÚÚýÜ ÝÎÈÐ óÚ Ñû óá êã ÞÍÔÊÈÍÆ ÍÒ ÊÎÉ ÏÖÔÈÇÓÌÊÓÔÏÌ ÞÌÏÈÆ ÉÏÐÊ ÍÒ ÝÎÉÑÉÐ èÍÇÓãÉÆÊÉè ÏÆÇÈÉÆÊ ãÏÊÉÔÈÏÌ ÏÔÍÓÆè ÊÎÔÉÉ äÈÌÌÏÖÉÐ – ËÌÉÍÆÏÐå ÅÔãÏå ÏÆè ÝÏÆÏÖÔÏ ñÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐ Qq I\PP ÙÚóáßÜ ÝÎÉ ÐÓÔäÉû ÏÌÐÍ ÈÆÇÌÓèÉè ÕÔÍÆîÉ ÅÖÉ ÝÏÆÏÖÔÏå çÎÉÔÉ ÉæÇÏäÏÊÈÍÆÐ ÍÒ ÊçÍ MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÇÉãÉÊÉÔÈÉÐå ÌÍÇÏÊÉè ÏÊ ðÉÞÎûÔÏ ÏÆè ìÉÆèÔÍÆå ÞÔÍèÓÇÉè ÊÎÉ çÉÌÌïêÆÍçÆ ÞÏÈÆÊÉè ÌÏÔÆÏêÉÐ ÆÍç ÈÆ ÊÎÉ ÅÔÇÎÏÉÍÌÍÖÈÇÏÌ MÓÐÉÓã ÍÒ ÝÎÉÑÉÐå ÊÎÉ SÇÎÈãÏÊÏÔÈ MÓÐÉÓãå ÏÆè ÞÔÈäÏÊÉ ÇÍÌÌÉÇÊÈÍÆÐ ñ.ÉÔãÉÓÌÉ óýáâ/ éÏêÍäÈèÈÐ óýáá/ éããÉÔçÏÎÔ óýýÚ/ óýý+/ MÏÔÈÆÏÊÍÐ óýýÛ/ ëÏäÏÆÏÓÖÎ 0 MÉÉ óýý+/ ÕÓÔêÉ ÙÚóÚßÜ éÆ ÅÔãÏå ÊÎÉÔÉ ÏÔÉ ÐÈãÈÌÏÔ ÔÍÇê ÇÓÊ ÇÎÏãÑÉÔ ÊÍãÑÐ ÈÆ ÊÎÉ ÐÌÍÞÉÐ ÐÍÓÊÎ ÍÒ ÊÎÉ ÉÌÉäÏÊÉè ÐÈÊÉ ÍÒ ÏÆÇÈÉÆÊ ËÌÉÍÆå çÎÈÇÎ çÉÔÉ ÊÎÍÔÍÓÖÎÌû ÉãÞÊÈÉè ÑÉÒÍÔÉ ÍÓÔ ÐÊÓèûÜ ,ÔÍã ÍÓÔ ÐÓÔäÉû ËÌÉÍÆ ÐÊÍÍè ÍÓÊ ÒÍÔ ÈÊÐ ÍÇÇÓÞÏÊÈÍÆ ÞÎÏÐÉÐ ÒÔÍã ÊÎÉ ÕÔÍÆîÉ ÅÖÉ ÊÍ ÊÎÉ ëÌÏÐÐÈÇÏÌ ÞÉÔÈÍèÐå ÈÆÇÌÓèÈÆÖ ÏÑÓÆèÏÆÊ ÉäÈèÉÆÇÉ ÒÍÔ ×ÏÌÏÊÈÏÌ ÏÆè ×ÍÐÊÞÏÌÏÊÈÏÌ ÍÇÇÓÞÏÊÈÍÆÜ ÝÎÉÔÉÒÍÔÉ ÈÊ ÐÉÉãÉè ÏÆ ÈèÉÏÌ ÌÍÇÏÊÈÍÆ ÊÍ ÈÆäÉÐÊÈÖÏÊÉ ÊÎÉ ÇÎÏÆÖÈÆÖ ÔÉÌÏÊÈÍÆÐÎÈÞÐ çÈÊÎ ÝÎÉÑÉÐ èÓÔÈÆÖ ÊÎÈÐ ÊÔÏÆÐÈÊÈÍÆ ñ)LJßÜ õö÷ø ùø2ø ANCIENT ELEON, AERIAL PHOTOGRAPH OF NORTHWEST COMPLEX (EBAP EXCAVATIONS) :HDOVRDSSUHFLDWHWKHGHGLFDWHGHIIRUWVRIWKHVWXGHQWVDQGDI¿OLDWHGVFKRODUVZKRFRQWULEXWHVRPXFKWRRXUUHVHDUFKHVSHFLDOO\'U %DUWáRPLHM/LV ,QVWLWXWHRI$UFKDHRORJ\DQG(WKQRORJ\3ROLVK$FDGHP\RI6FLHQFHV DQG7UHYRU9DQ'DPPH &RWVHQ,QVWLWXWH o A   UCLA o   x   w k w   p       W   pp p           w k ZKLFKFRQFHUQV0\FHQDHDQMHZHOOHU\PDQXIDFWXUHDPRQJRWKHUFUDIWLQJLQKRQRXURI5REHUW/DI¿QHXU š 8 ž Ÿ ¡¢£¤¥¦ 5$3,1(86WXGLHVRQWKH0\FHQDHDQ:RUOGRIIHUHGWR5REHUW/DI¿QHXUIRUKLV E3456579:;< =e>9;;9;> 9; ?@BB h56e u;4:6eDeG =u9JG9;> Der59;< 7h57 5De =e<7 4h5D547eD9<eG 5< Ku;eD5DNQ D97u5JQ 5;G G:re<794 T)LJVXY ZuD [:D\ 9< :;>:9;> 5;G [h57 K:JJ:[< 9< 5 G9<4u<<9:; :K :;JN 5 Ke[ :K :uD De<uJ7< T<ee ]D565;79;:< ^_ a`cc ?@B?d gh5D5r9 ^_ a`cc ?@BiX7KHVLWHKDVWZRPDMRUSHULRGVRIRFFXSDWLRQ¿UVWDSUHKLVWRULF jh5<e <j5;< <e6eD5J <u=jh5<e< :K 7he lN4e;5e5; jeD9:G TE5DJN lN4e;5e5;Q m5J5795J 5;G m:<7j5J5795JQ nqs Bt@@v B@i@ ygXY zD:r 7he E5DJN lN4e;5e5; jeD9:G Tl{ |||v}{ ||X [e h56e e69Ge;4e K:D 7he 4:;<7Du479:; 5;G u<e :K 5; eJ5=:D57e De475;>uJ5D Ku;eD5DN 4:rjJe3 [h94h [e 45JJ 7he yJue ~7:;e ~7Du47uDeQ J:457eG 9; 7he 4e;7De :K :uD e3456579:; >D9GY EJ<e[heDe m5J5795J Je6eJ< 5De 9;G9457eG =N 9<:J57eG Gej:<97< 7h57 9;4JuGe r57eD95J DeJ57eG 7: 4D5K7 jD:Gu479:;Y ye77eD jDe<eD6eG Je6eJ< KD:r 7he }{ |||g jeD9:G< jD:69Ge e69Ge;4e K:D 7he e;GuD5;4e :K lN4e;5e5; 4uJ7uDe 57 EJe:; 5K7eD 7he 4:JJ5j<e :K 7he j5J5795J 4e;7De 57 he=e<Y he 54D:j:J9< 57 5;49e;7 EJe:; <eer< 7: =e 5=5;G:;eG =eK:De 7he E5DJN |D:; ]>eY ] <e4:;G r5€:D jh5<e :K 5479697N 57 7he <97e G57e< 7: 7he ]D4h594vgJ5<<945J jeD9:G<Y ]J7h:u>h <4577eDeG e69Ge;4e K:D ‚ƒvt‚ƒFHQWXU\SRWWHU\DWWHVWWRWKHUHXVHRIWKHDFURSROLVLQHDUOLHUSHULRGVPLQLDWXUHYHVVHOV¿QHGULQNLQJ FXSVDQGWHUUDFRWWD¿JXULQHVDUHIRXQGLQDEXQGDQFHIURPWKH‚ƒ 7hD:u>h i‚ƒ 4e;7uD9e<Y he 4:;<7Du479:; :K 7he J5D>e j:JN>:;5J [5JJ 5J:;> 7he e5<7eD; <9Ge G57e< 7: 7he J57e ]D4h594 jeD9:G 5;G 9< 7he r:<7 9rjDe<<96e <75;G9;> r:;ure;7 57 7he <97eY he D94h Gej:<97 :K 6:796e r57eD95J 9;G9457e< 5479697N 7hD:u>h:u7 7he gJ5<<945J jeD9:GQ =u7 7h9< 9< K:JJ:[eG =N 5;:7heD J:;> jeD9:G :K 9;5479697N u;79J 7he leG9e65J :44uj579:;Q [h94h 9< 9;G9457eG =N 9<:J57eG 4eD5r94 Gej:<97< 5;G <45;7 5D4h97e47uD5J Der59;<Q jJu< 7he =e77eD jDe<eD6eG <7:;e 7:[eD 7h57 r5D\< 7he [e<7eD; e;G :K 7he <97e 5;G :KKeD< 5 69<u5J 4:;;e479:; [97h he=e<Y he 4:;;e479:; =e7[ee; EJe:; 5;G he=e< GuD9;> 7he }57e yD:;„e ]>e 9< 4h5D547eD9<eG =N DeKeDe;4e< :; 7[: }9;e5D y 75=Je7<Q z7 B @Yi 5;G †YBii KD:r 7he ‡5Gre9:; T]D565;79;:< ˆ‰ qŠ‹‹ ?@@Bd ]D565;79;:< ?@@d ?@B@Œ ivŽ@d eJ zDe: ?@B@Œ iv Žd ‡9JJe; ?@@ŽXY 5=Je7 z7 B @ KD:r 7he ]D<e;5J 9< :K \eN 9rj:D75;4e K:D De4De579;> 7he >e:>D5jhN :K 7he lN4e;5e5; e4:;:rN 5;G <u>>e<7< 7h57 EJe:; [5< 5 <e4:;G5DN 4e;7De 5Gr9;9<7eDeG =N WKHSDODFH7KLVSDJHVKDSHGWDEOHWUHFRUGV¿YHGLIIHUHQWWRSRQ\PVLQWKHQRPLQDWLYHRUGDWLYHORFDWLYHFDVH IROORZHGE\VXEVWDQWLDOTXDQWLWLHVRIZKHDWDQGRQDOOEXWOLQHROLYHV7KUHHRIWKH¿YHWRSRQ\PVKDYHEHHQ LGHQWL¿HGZLWKNQRZQDQFLHQWVLWHV ‰ˆ‘q‹ The=e<X 9; J9;e BQ ˆ’‰ˆ“ˆ’ TEu7De<9<X :; J9;e ?Q 5;G :; J9;e iQ ˆ“ˆ”•‹ TEJe:;XY he 9;9795J ju=J94579:; :K 7h9< 75=Je7 9;7eDjDe7eG 97 5< 5 753579:; G:4ure;7 <h:[9;> 7he 5r:u;7< :K >D59; 5;G :J96e< 7h57 e54h J:4579:; [5< e3je47eG 7: >96e 7: 7he j5J54e 57 he=e< T]D565;79;:< ˆ‰ qŠ‹‹ ?@@BŒ ?Ž—v?Ž XY 7KHFRPPRGLW\OLVWHGLQWKH¿UVWOLQHKRZHYHULV*5$3( PR˜ˆ™qX re5;9;> >D59; :D [he57Q DeKeDD9;> 7: 7he šu5;797N :K >D59; <eeG< 7: >eDr9;57eQ 7hu< <h:[9;> 5 45J4uJ579:; :K J5;G 5< 5 re5<uDe :K 97< jD:Gu4796e 45j5497N T‡9JJe; ?@@ŽXY ›œ žŸ ¡¢£¤ ¤£¥ žŸ¦ §¨©¨ ª¨© «Ÿ¨¬ ª­® |; 5GG979:; 7: 7he 5>D94uJ7uD5J jD:Gu479:; :K EJe:; [e ;:[ h56e e69Ge;4e DeJ57eG 7: G96eD<e 4D5K7 jD:Gu479:; GuD9;> 7he m5J5795J jeD9:GY E3456579:;< 9; 7he ¯:D7h[e<7 šu5GD5;7 :K :uD e3456579:; 5De5 h56e u;4:6eDeG 7he UHPDLQVRISDODWLDOOHYHOVVWUDWL¿HGEHQHDWKDPXOWLURRPFRPSOH[IURPWKH3RVWSDODWLDOSHULRG )LJ°XY ]< 5 De<uJ7Q 7he j:77eDN 9< u<u5JJN 6eDN KD5>re;7eGQ =u7 De4:>;9<5=Je }{ |||] 5;G }{ |||y r57eD95J 9;4JuGe< 5; DEXQGDQFHRIPHQGDEOH¿QHSDWWHUQHGRSHQVKDSHV$UFKLWHFWXUDOEORFNVRIWKH3DODWLDOSHULRGVHHPWRKDYH =ee; DejuDj:<eG 9; 7he ruJ79vD::r 4:rjJe3 =N 7he }{ |||g :44uj5;7<Y ] <eD9e< :K <J5=< j:<979:;eG 5J:;> 7he [e<7 57 7he Je6eJ :K 7he 9;9795J 4:;<7Du479:; jh5<eQ 5< [eJJ 5< €:9;< =e7[ee; m5J5795J 4eD5r94<Q <u>>e<7 5 G9KKeDe;7 5D4h97e47uD5J J5N:u7 =e7[ee; 7he 7[: jeD9:G<Y zJ::D Je6eJ< 5<<:4957eG [97h 7h9< jh5<e 5J<: jDe<eD6e <:re e69Ge;4e K:D 4D5K7 54796979e< J9\e 4J:7h jD:Gu479:; 5;G 5 <7e5797e r:uJGQ 5 D57heD D5De 7::J K:u;G :u7<9Ge j5J5795J 4e;7De<Q K:D 7he jD:Gu479:; :K €e[eJJeDNY 7KH(OHRQVWRQHMHZHOOHU\PRXOGLVDÀDWIUDJPHQWRIUHGVWHDWLWHPHDVXULQJ[FPZLWKDWKLFNQHVVRI ?Y? 4r T)LJ± 5;G )LJXY eejJN 4u7 r57D94e< 5De jDe<eD6eG :; =:7h K54e<Q [97h 5 7:75J :K <e6e; Ge<9>;<Y Z;e K54e jDe<eD6e< 5 J5D>e [5„ J9JNQ j5jNDu<Q 4:4\Je <heJJQ 5;G je;G5;7 <j9D5JQ [h9Je 7he <e4:;G K54e :KKeD< 65D9579:;< :; 7hDee :K 7he<eŒ 5 <r5JJeD [5„ J9JNQ 5 J5D>eD j5jNDu<Q 5;G 5 4:4\Je <heJJ [97h r:De Ge759JeG >D::6e<Y z96e :K 7he r57D94e< Ke57uDe <h5JJ:[ 4h5;;eJ< 7h57 [:uJG K549J9757e 7he r5;uK547uDe :K <7D9;> h:Je< 9; <:J9G :D;5re;7<Q <: 7h57 7heN 4:uJG =e r:De e5<9JN [:D; 5< €e[eJJeDNY 8 §    ! f ""#$% &') *"   õö÷ø ùø²ø 88 PLAN OF ANCIENT ELEON, 2015 (G. BIANCO) ž Ÿ ¡¢£¤¥¦ 5$3,1(86WXGLHVRQWKH0\FHQDHDQ:RUOGRIIHUHGWR5REHUW/DI¿QHXUIRUKLV õö÷ø ùø´ø STEATITE JEWELLERY MOULD (B. BURKE) D (T. R ) õö÷ø ùøùø ÝÎÉ ËÌÉÍÆ èÉÐÈÖÆÐ ÏÔÉ ÏÌÌ ÒÏãÈÌÈÏÔ ãÍÊÈÒÐ ñµÉÆÏêÈïSÏêÉÌÌÏÔÈÍÓ óý+â- ÙýÙïôóÙå ÉÐÞÉÇÈÏÌÌû ÆÍÐÜ âýå Ûôå óÚÛå óóóßå RAWING STEATITE JEWELERY MOULD OSS DSSURSULDWHIRUÀDWEDFNRUQDPHQWVWKDWDUHPRVWFRPPRQO\PDGHRIJODVVDQGRIWHQSURGXFHGLQFRQMXQFWLRQZLWK JROGYHUVLRQV /DI¿QHXU 1HLWKHURIWKHWZR0\FHQDHDQJODVVRUQDPHQWVIRXQGWKXVIDUDW(OHRQ±RQHÀDW ÑÏÇêÉè ÔÍÐÉÊÊÉå ÍÆÉ ÖÔÍÍäÉè ÇÍÆÈÇÏÌ ÑÉÏè – ãÏÊÇÎ ÊÎÉ èÉÐÈÖÆÐ ÞÔÉÐÉÔäÉè ÍÆ ÊÎÉ ãÍÓÌèÜ ÕÓÊ äÏÔÈÍÓÐ ÇÌÍÐÉ ÞÏÔÏÌÌÉÌÐ ÏÔÉ ÒÍÓÆè ÏãÍÆÖ ÊÎÉ ØÉçÉÌÌÉÔû ÒÍÓÆè ÈÆ ÆÓãÉÔÍÓÐ ÊÍãÑÐ ÏÆè çÍÔêÐÎÍÞÐ ÏÊ ÝÎÉÑÉÐå ÏÐ çÉÌÌ ÏÐ ÈÆ ÊÎÉ ÇÎÏãÑÉÔ WRPEVRI7DQDJUDHDVWRI(OHRQ7KH¿QLVKHGRUQDPHQWVIURP7KHEHVLQFOXGHERWKJODVVDQGJROGSLHFHVWKDWPDWFK ÊÎÉ ãÍÊÈÒÐ ÒÍÓÆè ÍÆ ÊÎÉ ËÌÉÍÆ ãÍÓÌèå ÐÓÇÎ ÏÐ ÖÌÏÐÐ ÇÍÇêÌÉ ÐÎÉÌÌÐ ÏÆè ÖÍÌè ÞÉÆèÏÆÊ ÐÞÈÔÏÌÐ ñÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐ ÙÚóÚÏÛâï+óßÜ ÝÎÉ ãÏÆÓÒÏÇÊÓÔÉ ÍÒ ØÉçÉÌÌÉÔû ÏÊ ÝÎÉÑÉÐ ÈÐ çÉÌÌïÉÐÊÏÑÌÈÐÎÉè Ñû ÊÎÉ ÆÓãÉÔÍÓÐ çÍÔêÐÎÍÞÐ ÊÎÏÊ ÇÍÆÊÏÈÆÉè 8³    ! f ""#$% &') *"   UDZ PDWHULDOV DQG XQ¿QLVKHG SLHFHV LQ D YDULHW\ RI YDOXDEOH PDWHULDOV LQFOXGLQJ RQ\[ DJDWH DQG ODSLV OD]XOL ñìÉãÏêÍÞÍÓÌÍÓ ÙÚó·ßÜ ÝçÍ ÐÊÍÆÉ ãÍÓÌèÐ ÎÏäÉ ÏÌÐÍ ÑÉÉÆ ÔÉÇÍäÉÔÉè ÈÆ ÝÎÉÑÉÐ- Ï ÇÌÍÐÉè ãÍÓÌè ÒÍÔ ÇÏÐÊÈÆÖ ãÉÊÏÌ ÔÈÆÖÐ ÏÆè ÏÆ ÍÞÉÆ ãÍÓÌè ÞÔÉÐÉÔäÈÆÖ ãÍÐÊ ÍÒ Ï ÔÍÐÉÊÊÉ ãÍÊÈÒ ÏÞÞÔÍÞÔÈÏÊÉ ÒÍÔ ÖÌÏÐÐ ÏÆè ÖÍÌè ÍÔÆÏãÉÆÊÐ ñ×ÈÊÉÔÍÐ óý+óóýóå ÞÌÜ óÙÚȖ/ ÝÍÓÔÆÏäÈÊÍÓ óýýÛ- Ù·ôï·âßÜ ÝÎÓÐ ËÌÉÍÆ ÏÆè ÝÎÉÑÉÐ ÎÏäÉ ÇÍãÞÌÈãÉÆÊÏÔû ÉäÈèÉÆÇÉ ÊÎÏÊ ÈÆèÈÇÏÊÉÐ Ï ÊÈÖÎÊ ÇÍÆÆÉÇÊÈÍÆå ÈÆ ÊÉÔãÐ ÍÒ ÊÎÉ ÊûÞÉÐ ÍÒ ÍÔÆÏãÉÆÊÐ ÊÎÏÊ çÉÔÉ ÈÆ ÇÈÔÇÓÌÏÊÈÍÆ ÏÇÔÍÐÐ ËÏÐÊÉÔÆ ÕÍÉÍÊÈÏÜ ÝÎÈÐÊûÞÉÍÒÍÞÉÆÐÊÍÆÉãÍÓÌèÎÏÐÑÉÉÆÒÍÓÆèÈÆí¸ éééÕÇÍÆÊÉæÊÐÏÊäÏÔÈÍÓÐ MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆÐÈÊÉÐåÏÌÊÎÍÓÖÎÇÍÆÇÌÓÐÈäÉ HYLGHQFHIRUD0\FHQDHDQJODVVZRUNVKRSKDV\HWWREHDUFKDHRORJLFDOO\LGHQWL¿HG7KHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWH[WXDO UHIHUHQFHVDQGWKH¿QGVRIHTXLSPHQWIRUJODVVZRUNLQJIRXQGDW$UJROLGVLWHVRIIHUVDSDUDOOHOIRUDQHZ%RHRWLDQ ÞÏÊÊÉÔÆ çÎÉÔÉ ÍÆÌû Ï ÒÉç ÌÈãÈÊÉè ÌÍÇÏÊÈÍÆÐ ÏÔÉ ÌÈêÉÌû ÞÔÍèÓÇÊÈÍÆ ÇÉÆÊÔÉÐÜ ÝÎÉ ÎÈÖÎÉÐÊ ÇÍÆÇÉÆÊÔÏÊÈÍÆ ÍÒ ÉäÈèÉÆÇÉ ÇÍãÉÐ ÒÔÍã MûÇÉÆÏÉå çÎÉÔÉ ÉæÇÏäÏÊÈÍÆÐ ÎÏäÉ ÔÉÇÍäÉÔÉè ÐÈæ ÐÊÍÆÉ ãÍÓÌèÐ ÈÆ äÏÔÈÍÓÐ ÇÍÆÊÉæÊÐå ÏÆè ÏÆÍÊÎÉÔ ÆÍç ÏÊ ÊÎÉ MÓÐÉÓã ÍÒ ,ÈÆÉ ÅÔÊÐå ÕÍÐÊÍÆå çÎÈÇÎ ÈÐ ÐÏÈè ÊÍ ÑÉ ÒÔÍã MûÇÉÆÏÉ ñ.ÉÔãÉÓÌÉ óýáÛ/ ÝÍÓÔÆÏäÈÊÍÓ óýýÛßÜ ÝÎÉ PRVWVLJQL¿FDQWRIWKHVHPD\EHWKHVWHDWLWHPRXOGIURP$UHDRIWKH&LWDGHO+RXVHDUHDZKLFKZDVFDUYHG ÍÆ ÏÌÌ ÐÈæ ÒÏÇÉÐ ÏÆè ÞÔÉÐÉÔäÉè ÑÈÊÐ ÍÒ äÈÊÔÉÍÓÐ ãÏÊÉÔÈÏÌ ÈÆ ÍÆÉ ÍÒ ÈÊÐ ãÏÊÔÈÇÉÐ ñËäÉÌû 0 àÓÆÆÉÌÐ óýýÙßÜ Å ÐÉÔÈÉÐ ÍÒ íÈÆÉÏÔ Õ ÊÏÑÌÉÊÐ ÒÍÓÆè ÆÉÏÔÑû ñM¹ OÈ ÛÚóïÛÚâß ÔÉÇÍÔè ÐÉäÉÔÏÌ ]w_ºI_Kv_ºv_]vPx MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÇÔÏÒÊÐãÉÆ çÎÍ çÍÔêÉè çÈÊÎ ][IKvTå ãÍÐÊ ÌÈêÉÌû ÇÍÌÍÓÔÉè ÖÌÏÐÐ ñëÎÏèçÈÇê óýáÙßÜ ÝÎÈÐ ÇÍãÑÈÆÏÊÈÍÆ ÍÒ ÉäÈèÉÆÇÉ ÒÔÍã MûÇÉÆÏÉå SOXVSLHFHVRIXQ¿QLVKHGJODVVLQOD\VIRXQGDW7LU\QV 3DQDJLRWDNLQq I\PP ÙÚÚâßå ÉÐÊÏÑÌÈÐÎ ÖÌÏÐÐïçÍÔêÈÆÖ ÏÐ Ï ÇÔÏÒÊ ÈÆèÓÐÊÔû ÍÒ ÞÏÌÏÊÈÏÌ ÍäÉÔÐÈÖÎÊÜ ÝÎÉ ÞÔÉÐÉÆÇÉ ÍÒ ØÉçÉÌÌÉÔû ãÏÆÓÒÏÇÊÓÔÈÆÖ ÑÉûÍÆè ÞÏÌÏÊÈÏÌ ÇÉÆÊÉÔÐå ÎÍçÉäÉÔå ÈÐ êÆÍçÆ ÒÔÍã ÊÎÉ ãÍÓÌè ÒÔÏÖãÉÆÊ ÒÍÓÆè ÏÊ MÈèÉÏ ñìÉãÏêÍÞÍÓÌÍÓ Qq I\PP¿J  7KHUHDUHQXPHURXVSRVVLEOHXVHVIRUWKH(OHRQPRXOGEXWVLQFHLWZDVDQLVRODWHG¿QGZHFDQQRWEHFHUWDLQRI çÎÏÊ ÊûÞÉ ÍÒ ØÉçÉÌÌÉÔûÜ ËäÉÆ ÈÒ ÈÊ çÏÐ ÓÐÉè ÞÔÈãÏÔÈÌû ÒÍÔ ÖÌÏÐÐ ÍÔÆÏãÉÆÊÐå ÔÏÊÎÉÔ ÊÎÏÆ ÖÍÌèå çÉ ÐÎÍÓÌè ÑÉ ãÈÆèÒÓÌ » ÊÎÏÊ ÊÎÈÐ ÊÍÍ çÏÐ ÏÆ ÈãÞÍÔÊÉè ãÏÊÉÔÈÏÌ Ü MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ äÈÊÔÉÍÓÐ ãÏÊÉÔÈÏÌÐ çÉÔÉ ÌÈêÉÌû ÇÍÆÐÈèÉÔÉè Ï ÐÓÑÐÊÈÊÓÊÉ ÒÍÔ ÐÉãÈïÞÔÉÇÈÍÓÐ ÐÊÍÆÉÐå ÉÐÞÉÇÈÏÌÌû ÌÏÞÈÐ ÌÏîÓÌÈÜ OÔÆÏãÉÆÊÐ ÒÔÍã ÊÎÈÐ ÑÌÓÉ ÐÊÍÆÉå ÎÍçÉäÉÔå çÉÔÉ ÈÆÇÔÉèÈÑÌû ÔÏÔÉ ÈÆ WKH0\FHQDHDQZRUOG\HWWKHPRVWVLJQL¿FDQWFRQFHQWUDWLRQZDVIRXQGDWWKH.DGPHLRQDW7KHEHVQRWRQO\WKH çÉÌÌïêÆÍçÆ ÇÏÇÎÉ ÍÒ ÈãÞÍÔÊÉè ÇûÌÈÆèÉÔ ÐÉÏÌÐå ÑÓÊ ÏÌÐÍ MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÍÔÆÏãÉÆÊÐ ÞÔÍèÓÇÉè ÈÆ ÊÎÉ ÞÏÌÏÇÉ çÍÔêÐÎÍÞ ñSûãÉÍÆÍÖÌÍÓ óýÛô- ááïáý/ ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐ ÙÚóÚÏßÜ ¼ÍÆÉÊÎÉÌÉÐÐå ÊÎÉ ÇÔÉÏÊÈÍÆ ÍÒ ÍÔÆÏãÉÆÊÐ ÐÓÖÖÉÐÊÉè Ñû ÊÎÉ ËÌÉÍÆ PRXOGZDVDUDUL¿HGIRUPRIFUDIWLQJWKDWZDVRIVSHFLDOLQWHUHVWWRWKHUXOLQJHOLWHVDW7KHEHV ½¾ ¿ÀÁÂÃÄÅÄÂÆÄÅ ÇÀÈÂÆÈÉÆÂÆÊÁ ÄÈË ÌÆÁÍÉÃÂÆÀÈÁÎ ÏÐ ÑÑÑÇ ÒÎÈÌÉ ÊÎÉ ãÍÓÌè ÎÉÌÞÐ ÓÐ ÇÎÏÔÏÇÊÉÔÈÐÉ ÊÎÉ ×ÏÌÏÊÈÏÌ ÞÎÏÐÉÐ ñí¸ éééÅïéééÕß ÍÒ ÊÎÉ ÐÈÊÉ ÍÒ ÏÆÇÈÉÆÊ ËÌÉÍÆ ÈÆ ÊÎÉ ÍÔÊÎçÉÐÊ ÇÍãÞÌÉæå ÊÎÉ ãÍÐÊ ÇÍÎÉÔÉÆÊ ÞÎÏÐÉ ÍÒ ÍÇÇÓÞÏÊÈÍÆ ÈÆ ÊÎÈÐ ÏÔÉÏ èÏÊÉÐ ÊÍ ÊÎÉ í¸ éééë ËÏÔÌû ÞÉÔÈÍèÜ ÒÉ ÎÏäÉ LGHQWL¿HGWZRVXESKDVHVZLWKLQ/+,,,&(DUO\LQWKLVTXDGUDQW±DVWUDWL¿HGXQEXUQWOHYHOWKDWLVIROORZHGE\D ÑÓÔÆÊ èÉÐÊÔÓÇÊÈÍÆÜ ÝÎÉ ÏÔÇÎÈÊÉÇÊÓÔÏÌ ÞÎÏÐÉÐ ÍÒ ÊÎÉ ÇÍãÞÌÉæ ÏÔÉ ÇÓÔÔÉÆÊÌû ÓÆèÉÔ ÐÊÓèû ÑÓÊ ÊÎÉ ÖÉÆÉÔÏÌ ÞÌÏÆ ÈÐ ÇÌÉÏÔ ñ)LJGßÜ ÝçÍ ÌÏÔÖÉ ÔÍÍãÐå ÞÔÍäÈÐÈÍÆÏÌÌû ÆÓãÑÉÔÉè á ÏÆè Ûå ÉÏÇÎ ÒÉÏÊÓÔÉ Ï ÇÉÆÊÔÏÌÌû ÞÍÐÈÊÈÍÆÉè ÎÉÏÔÊÎÜ ,ÔÍã ÊÎÉ çÉÐÊ Ï ÔÏãÞ ÌÉÏèÐ ÊÍ ÍÆÉ ÍÒ ÊÎÉ ÎÉÏÔÊÎ ÔÍÍãÐ ÏÆè ÏÔÍÓÆè ÊÎÈÐ çÉÐÊÉÔÆ ÎÉÏÔÊÎ ÈÆ ÙÚóâ çÉ èÈÐÇÍäÉÔÉè ÊÎÔÉÉ ÇÍÌÓãÆ ÐÓÞÞÍÔÊÐ çÈÊÎ Ï ÒÍÓÔÊÎ ÌÈêÉÌû ãÈÐÐÈÆÖÜ ÝÎÉ ÐÊÔÓÇÊÓÔÉ ãÉÏÐÓÔÉÐ ÏÞÞÔÍæÈãÏÊÉÌû óó ñËïÒß Ñû ó· ãÉÊÉÔÐ ñ¼ïSß – ÊÎÍÓÖÎ ÈÊ ÇÌÉÏÔÌû ÇÍÆÊÈÆÓÉÐ ÊÍ ÊÎÉ ÆÍÔÊÎ ÍÆ ÈÊÐ çÉÐÊÉÔÆ ÐÈèÉÜ 7KH EXUQW SKDVH LQ WKH 1RUWKZHVW OHIW D FROODSVHG GHSRVLW RI ZDOO VWRQHV PXGEULFNV DQG URR¿QJ PDWHULDO ÇÍÆÇÉÆÊÔÏÊÉè ÈÆ àÍÍãÐ ôïô¼Ü ËæÇÏäÏÊÈÍÆÐ ÈÆÙÚó· ûÈÉÌèÉè ÙÙâ êÖ ÍÒ ÑÓÔÆÊ ÇÌÏûÜÝÎÈÐ ÈÆÇÌÓèÉè ãÓèÑÔÈÇêÐ ñÊûÞÈÇÏÌÌû ãÉÏÐÓÔÈÆÖ ôÚ æ ÙÚ æ ý Çãßå ÐÌÏÑÐ ÍÒ çÏÌÌ ÞÏäÉãÉÆÊå ÏÆè ÇÎÓÆêÐ ÍÒ èÏÓÑ çÈÊÎ ÔÉÉè ÈãÞÔÉÐÐÈÍÆÐÜ ÒÉ ÏÌÐÍ ÎÏäÉ ÉäÈèÉÆÇÉ ÒÍÔ ÞÈÊÇÎÉè ÔÍÍÒÐÜ ÝÎÉ ÔÉãÏÈÆÐ ÍÒ ÞÏÆ ÊÈÌÉÐå ÏÐ çÉÌÌ ÏÐ ÇÍÔÔÉÐÞÍÆèÈÆÖ ÇÍäÉÔ ÊÈÌÉÐå çÉÔÉ ÔÉÇÍäÉÔÉèÜ SÉäÉÔÏÌ ÒÔÏÖãÉÆÊÐ çÉÔÉ ØÍÈÆÉè ÊÍÖÉÊÎÉÔ ÊÍ ÞÔÉÐÉÔäÉ ÊÎÉ ÒÓÌÌ èÈãÉÆÐÈÍÆÐ ÍÒ Ï ÞÏÆ ÊÈÌÉå âôÜâ æ ··Üâ ÇãÜ ÝÎÉ ãÍÔÞÎÍÌÍÖû ÍÒ ÊÎÈÐ ÊÈÌÉ ÈÐ èÉãÍÆÐÊÔÏÑÌû ÇÍÆÐÈÐÊÉÆÊ çÈÊÎ ÊÈÌÉÐ ÒÍÓÆè ÏÊ ÝÎÉÑÉÐå MÈÊÔÍÓå ÏÆè ðÌÏ ñéÏêÍäÈèÈÐ óýý+- ÞÌÏÊÉ ·â-ȕïȖßÜ ¼ ,QWHUPVRIFRPSDUDWLYHPDWHULDOWKHEXUQWGHVWUXFWLRQVKDYHJRRGSDUDOOHOVLQWKHJURXQGÀRRUDVVHPEODJHVRI /HINDQGLKRXVHKROGVLQSKDVHEOLNHZLVHGHVWUR\HGE\¿UH 9DQ'DPPHIRUWKFRPLQJ (YLGHQFHIURP(OHRQ ÐÓÖÖÉÐÊÐ ÊÎÏÊ ÊÎÉ ÊçÍ èÉÐÊÔÓÇÊÈÍÆÐ ÏÔÉ ÔÍÓÖÎÌû ÇÍÆÊÉãÞÍÔÏÔûå ÞÉÔÎÏÞÐ ÈÆèÈÇÏÊÈÆÖ ÔÉÖÈÍÆÏÌ ÈÆÐÊÏÑÈÌÈÊû ÏÊ ÊÎÈÐ ÊÈãÉÜ 7KHÀRRUOHYHOEHQHDWKWKLVFROODSVHFRQWDLQHG¿QHZDUHFHUDPLFVFRRNLQJZDUHVDQGVWRUDJHYHVVHOVFRSSHU ÏÌÌÍû ÑÌÏèÉÐå ÏÆè ÊÉæÊÈÌÉ ÊÍÍÌÐÜ éÆ àÍÍã âå ÏÆ ÏèØÏÇÉÆÊ ÐÞÏÇÉ ÊÍ ÊÎÉ ÉÏÐÊå ãÍÔÉ ÈÆèÓÐÊÔÈÏÌ ÏÇÊÈäÈÊû ÈÐ ÈÆèÈÇÏÊÉè Ñû Ï Ó A    Ô Õ         o  Öp  × p    o   b o  Ö  w o Ø b   ×  o    w   Ùk Ú H   ÓÛÛÜÝ H   Þß àáââ ÓÛ Û ³¶ ž Ÿ ¡¢£¤¥¦ 5$3,1(86WXGLHVRQWKH0\FHQDHDQ:RUOGRIIHUHGWR5REHUW/DI¿QHXUIRUKLV ÐÉÔÈÉÐ ÍÒ ÐÈæ ÎÉÏÔÊÎÐ ÞÍÐÈÊÈÍÆÉè ÏÔÍÓÆè Ï ÇÉÆÊÔÏÌ ÐÊÍÆÉ ÊÎÏÊ ãÏû ÎÏäÉ ÑÉÉÆ Ï ÞÍÐÊ ÐÓÞÞÍÔÊÈÆÖ ÊÎÉ ÔÍÍÒÜ ×ÔÉÐÓãÏÑÌû ÊÎÉ ÐÍÓÊÎÉÔÆ ÎÏÌÒ ÍÒ ÊÎÉ ÔÍÍã çÏÐ ÓÆÔÍÍÒÉèå ÐÈÆÇÉ ÊÎÉ ÌÏÔÖÉÐÊ ÎÉÏÔÊÎÐ ÏÔÉ ÇÌÓÐÊÉÔÉè ÎÉÔÉå ÈÆÇÌÓèÈÆÖ ÊÎÔÉÉ ÊÎÏÊ ÏÔÉ ÑÓÈÌÊ èÈÔÉÇÊÌû ÓÞÍÆ ÊÎÉ ÍÊÎÉÔÜ ÒÎÈÌÉ ÈÊ ÈÐ ÊÉãÞÊÈÆÖ ÊÍ ÌÈÆê ÊÎÉ ÞûÔÍÊÉÇÎÆÈÇ ÒÉÏÊÓÔÉÐ ÊÍ Ï èÉèÈÇÏÊÉè ÏÇÊÈäÈÊûå ÏÐÐÍÇÈÏÊÉè ¿QGVGRQRWLQGLFDWHVSHFL¿FFUDIWLQJ5HSHDWHGEXLOGLQJRIWKHKHDUWKVVXJJHVWWKDWWKHURRPVXVWDLQHGGRPHVWLF ÏÆè ÞÍÐÐÈÑÌû ÈÆèÓÐÊÔÈÏÌ ÒÓÆÇÊÈÍÆÐÜ 7KHEXLOGLQJ¶VVHFRQGSKDVHSUHVHUYHVWKHEHVWHYLGHQFHIRULWVFRQVWUXFWLRQXVHDQGGHVWUXFWLRQLQD¿HU\HYHQW èÏÊÉè ÊÍ ÊÎÉ í¸ éééë ËÏÔÌû ÞÉÔÈÍèÜ éÆ àÍÍã óå ÏÐ èÉÌÈãÈÊÉè Ñû çÏÌÌÐ ÍÆ ÊÎÉ ÆÍÔÊÎ ÏÆè çÉÐÊå çÉ ÓÆÇÍäÉÔÉè Ï ÐÓÆêÉÆ ÑÏÐÈÆ ÏÆè ÊÈÌÉ ÎÉÏÔÊÎÜ ÒÈÊÎÈÆ çÏÐ ÏÆ ÉæÊÉÆÐÈäÉ ÇÉÔÏãÈÇ ÏÐÐÉãÑÌÏÖÉ ÊÎÏÊ ÈÆÇÌÓèÉè ó+ ÇÍãÞÌÉÊÉ ÍÔ çÉÌÌ ÞÔÉÐÉÔäÉè ÞÍÊÐ – ÊÎÔÉÉ ØÓÖÐ ÏÆè Ï ÎûèÔÈÏå ÒÍÓÔ èÉÉÞ ÑÍçÌÐå ÊÎÔÉÉ êûÌÈêÉÐå ÊçÍ ÇÍÍêÈÆÖ ÞÍÊÐå Ï èÈÞÞÉÔå ÏÆè Ï êÏÌÏÊÎÍÐÜ ÝÎÉ ÊÎÔÉÉ OLQHDUN\OLNHVPD\KDYHIDOOHQIURPDVKHOIDERYHWKHOHNDQHLQWKH¿QDOGHVWUXFWLRQÝÎÉ ÌÏÔÖÉ ÆÓãÑÉÔ ÍÒ ÐÉÔäÈÆÖ ÏÆè èÔÈÆêÈÆÖ äÉÐÐÉÌÐ ÐÓÖÖÉÐÊ Ï ÇÎÏÆÖÉ ÈÆ ÒÓÆÇÊÈÍÆå ÍÆÉ ÔÉÌÏÊÉè ÊÍ ÇÍããÉÆÐÏÌÈÊû ÔÏÊÎÉÔ ÊÎÏÆ ÇÔÏÒÊÈÆÖÜ ÅÌÐÍ ÞÔÉÐÉÆÊ DUHSDWWHUQHGNUDWHUVDQGZKDWLVWKHHDUOLHVW/+,,,&SLFWRULDONUDWHULGHQWL¿HGDW(OHRQIHDWXULQJDELUGWXFNHG EHQHDWK D SUREDEOH DQWLWKHWLF VSLUDO7KHVH VSHFLDO YHVVHOV DV ZHOO DV IUDJPHQWV RI EXOO ¿JXUHV SRLQW WR ULWXDO DFWLYLW\DVZHOOLQWKH¿QDOSKDVHVRIWKH%URQ]H$JHDW(OHRQ ÝÍ ÇÍÆÇÌÓèÉå ÊÎÉ MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÍÇÇÓÞÏÊÈÍÆ ÓÆÇÍäÉÔÉè ÏÊ ËÌÉÍÆ ÒÉÏÊÓÔÉÐ ÏÔÇÎÈÊÉÇÊÓÔÏÌ ÓÆÈÊÐ çÈÊÎ ÌÏÔÖÉ ÔÍÍãÐ ÏÆè ÊÈÌÉè ÔÍÍÒÐÜ ëÍÆÊÈÆÓÍÓÐ ÍÇÇÓÞÏÊÈÍÆ ÈÐ ÏÐÐÍÇÈÏÊÉè çÈÊÎ èÉÞÍÐÈÊÐ èÏÊÉè ÊÍ ÊÎÉ í¸ éééÕÙå í¸ éééë ËÏÔÌû ÏÆè í¸ éééë MÈèèÌÉ ÞÉÔÈÍèÐÜ ÒÈÊÎÍÓÊ ÊÎÉ ãÏØÍÔ èÈÐÔÓÞÊÈÍÆ ÔÉÇÍÔèÉè ÏÊ ãÏÆû ÍÊÎÉÔ MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÐÈÊÉÐå ÊÎÉ ÞÍÞÓÌÏÊÈÍÆ ÍÒ ËÌÉÍÆ ÇÍÆÊÈÆÓÉè ÊÍ ÑÉ ÏÇÊÈäÉ ÈÆ ÏÖÔÈÇÓÌÊÓÔÏÌå ÞÏÐÊÍÔÏÌå ÏÆè ÈÆèÓÐÊÔÈÏÌ ÏÇÊÈäÈÊÈÉÐå ÏÐ ÐÓÖÖÉÐÊÉè Ñû ÖÔÍÓÆè ÐÊÍÆÉÐå ÐÊÍÔÏÖÉ äÉÐÐÉÌÐå ÏÆè ÊÉæÊÈÌÉ ÊÍÍÌÐÜ ÅÖÔÈÇÓÌÊÓÔÏÌ ÞÔÍèÓÇÊÈÍÆ ÍÒ ÊÎÉ ×ÏÌÏÊÈÏÌ ÞÉÔÈÍè ÊÍÍê ÞÌÏÇÉå ÏÊ ÌÉÏÐÊ ÊÍ ÐÍãÉ ÉæÊÉÆÊå ÓÆèÉÔ ÊÎÉ ÇÍÍÔèÈÆÏÊÈÍÆ ÍÒ ÊÎÉ ÝÎÉÑÏÆ ÏèãÈÆÈÐÊÔÏÊÈÍÆÜ ÝÎÉ ÐÊÍÆÉ ØÉçÉÌÌÉÔû ãÍÓÌè ÐÓÖÖÉÐÊÐ ËÌÉÍÆäÐ ÞÏÔÊÈÇÈÞÏÊÈÍÆ ÈÆ Ï FUDIWLQJV\VWHPWKDWPD\KDYHEHHQDGPLQLVWHUHGE\7KHEHVWKURXJKWKHH[FKDQJHRIUDZPDWHULDOVDQG¿QLVKHG ÍÔÆÏãÉÆÊÐ ÞÍÊÉÆÊÈÏÌÌûÜ ÒÈÊÎ ÊÎÉ ÇÍÌÌÏÞÐÉ ÍÒ ÊÎÉÝÎÉÑÏÆ ÇÉÆÊÔÉå ÊÎÉ ÇÍããÓÆÈÊû ÍÒ ÇÔÏÒÊÐÞÉÍÞÌÉ ÏÊ ËÌÉÍÆ ÐÎÈÒÊÉè ÊÎÉÈÔ ÒÍÇÓÐ ÊÍçÏÔè ÍÊÎÉÔ ÏÇÊÈäÈÊÈÉÐ ÏÆè ÍÊÎÉÔ ÞÏÔÊÆÉÔÐÜ åÊæÊÍÊÈçÊÁ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐ ÙÚÚ+ è .Ü ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐȉĮIJȠʌȦȞȣȝȚțȐIJȦȞĮȡȤİȓȦȞīȡĮȝȝȚțȒȢǺIJȦȞĬȘȕȫȞLQǼʌİIJȘȡȓȢIJȘȢ ǼIJĮȚȡİȓĮȢǺȠȚȦIJȚțȫȞȂİȜİIJȫȞj ǻǯǻȚİșȞȑȢȈȣȞȑįȡȚȠǺȠȚȦIJȚțȫȞȂİȜİIJȫȞå ÉèÈÊÉè Ñû .Ü ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐå ÅÊÎÉÆÐ ñÙÚÚ+ßå óÙôïó+ÚÜ ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐ ÙÚóÚÏ è .Ü ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐå ȉKH$UFKDHRORJLFDO0XVHXPRI7KHEHVå ÅÊÎÉÆÐ ñÙÚóÚßÜ ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐ ÙÚóÚÑ è .Ü ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐå MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÝÎÉÑÉÐ- ÍÌè üÓÉÐÊÈÍÆÐå ÆÉç ÏÆÐçÉÔÐå ÈÆ TpIVQ VP“P\x QTpIVQ OQ\P~PQwé QK ê~ëQ YwOIKq \I pëOPvYQ m[VëKPQKKQì ^ppOvVXQT ëpP~OIpXPíwQx \PK~wPTqPíwQ Qq IOVXëv\v~PíwQx Éèï ÈÊÉè Ñû éÜ ÕÍÉÎã 0 SÜ MîÌÌÉÔïëÉÌêÏå íûÍÆ ñÙÚóÚßå âóïÛÙÜ ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐ Qq I\PP ÙÚÚó è .Ü ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐå íÜ ðÍèÏÔÊ 0 ÅÜ SÏÇÇÍÆÈå |Xï„QTì {vwP\\QT YQ \I zIYmëQ ðì QT qI„\QqqQT QK \PKëIPOQ k YQ \I ñYvT gQ\vpPYvwx òèÈÊÈÍÆ ÉÊ ÇÍããÉÆÊÏÈÔÉå ×ÈÐÏ 0 àÍãÉ ñÙÚÚóßÜ ÅÔäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐ Qq I\PP ÙÚÚý è .Ü ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐå ÕÜ ÕÓÔêÉå ÕÜ ÕÓÔÆÐå ¹Ü ,ÏÞÞÏÐ 0 SÜ íÓÞÏÇêå ÝÎÉ ËÏÐÊÉÔÆ ÕÍÉÍÊÈÏ ÅÔÇÎÏÉÍÌÍÖÈÇÏÌ ×ÔÍØÉÇÊå ÙÚÚÛïÙÚÚ+å ÈÆ ǹȡȤĮȚȠȜȠȖȚțȩǼȡȖȠĬİııĮȜȓĮȢțĮȚȈIJȑȡİĮȢǼȜȜȐįȠȢ óå .ÍÌÜ Ùå ÉèÈÊÉè Ñû ÅÜ MÏîÏÔÏêÈÐïÅÈÆÈÏÆå .ÍÌÍÐ ñÙÚÚýßå ý·âïýâôÜ ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐ Qq I\PP ÙÚóá è .Ü ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐå ÕÜ ÕÓÔêÉå ÕÜ ÕÓÔÆÐå ¹Ü ,ÏÞÞÏÐå SÜ íÓÞÏÇê 0 ëÜ MÏÇòÏûå ÝÎÉ ËÏÐÊï ÉÔÆ ÕÍÉÍÊÈÏÅÔÇÎÏÉÍÌÍÖÈÇÏÌ ×ÔÍØÉÇÊ ÙÚÚÛïÙÚóÚ- ÝÎÉ éÆÊÉÆÐÈäÉ SÓÔÒÏÇÉ SÓÔäÉû – ËÌÉÍÆå }vwTQPvK SÉÔÈÉÐ éééå óô ñÙÚóáßå óïâáÜ ÕÓÔêÉ ÙÚÚÛ è ÕÜ ÕÓÔêÉå MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ãÉãÍÔû ÏÆè ÕÔÍÆîÉÅÖÉ ÌÏãÉÆÊå ÈÆ ImQKqì `qwYPQT PK qXQ ^KVPQKq }QYP_ qQOOIKQIK ›vO\Y IKY kQ[vKYå ÉèÈÊÉè Ñû ÅÜ SÓÊÉÔå OæÒÍÔè ñÙÚÚÛßå ÛÚïýÙÜ ÕÓÔêÉ ÙÚÚý è ÕÜ ÕÓÔêÉå ËÏÐÊÉÔÆ ÕÍÉÍÊÈÏ ÅÔÇÎÏÉÍÌÍÖÈÇÏÌ ×ÔÍØÉÇÊ ÙÚÚý àÉÞÍÔÊå |QPOQTPITì ^ UQ“PQº IKY kP„\P_ v~OIpX[ v¨ kvPvqPIK `qwYPQT ôý ñÙÚÚýßå óóïóôÜ ÕÓÔêÉ Qq I\PP ÙÚÚÛ è ÕÜ ÕÓÔêÉå ÕÜ ÕÓÔÆÐå SÜ íÓÞÏÇê 0 .Ü ÅÔÏäÏÆÊÈÆÍÐå ÝÎÉ ËÏÐÊÉÔÆ ÕÍÉÍÊÈÏ ÅÔÇÎÏÉÍÌÍÖÈÇÏÌ ×ÔÍØÉÇÊ ñËÕÅ×ßå |QPOQTPITì ^ UQ“PQº IKY kP„\Pv~OIpX[ v¨ kvPvqPIK `qwYPQT ôÛ ñÙÚÚÛßå ÙâïÙÛÜ ÕÓÔêÉ Qq ôõöö ÙÚó· è ÕÜ ÕÓÔêÉå ÕÜ ÕÓÔÆÐå 0 ÅÜ ëÎÏÔÏãÈå ÝÎÉ ÞÍÌûÖÍÆÏÌ çÏÌÌ ÏÊ ÏÆÇÈÉÆÊ ËÌÉÍÆ ÏÆè ÊÎÉ ËÏÐÊÉÔÆ ÕÍÉÍÊÈÏÅÔÇÎÏÉÍÌÍÖÈÇÏÌ ×ÔÍØÉÇÊå ÈÆ }QYPqIqPvKT vK qXQ NP“QOTPq[ v¨ qXQ kwP\q K“POvKmQKq PK qXQ ^Q~QIK kITPKì ^ zv\\víwPwm PK }QmvO[ v¨ {OQYQOPV] j ›PKqQOx JwKQ ÷÷_÷ó ÷øù÷x ÉèÈÊÉè Ñû ìÜÒÜ àÓÞÞ 0 úÜËÜ ÝÍãÌÈÆÐÍÆå ÅÊÎÉÆÐ ñÙÚó·ßå Ù·ýïÙá·Ü ³ã    ! f ""#$% &') *"   ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ³û ëÏäÏÆÏÓÖÎ 0 MÉÉ óýý+ è ÒÜ ëÏäÏÆÏÖÎ 0 ëÜ MÉÉå ^ gOP“IqQ g\IVQì NQIqX PK gOQXPTqvOPV OQQVQ ñ`qwYPQT PK }QYPqQOOIKQIK ^OVXIQv\v~[ óÙâßå ñóýý+ß úÍÆÐÉÔÉèÜ ëÎÏèçÈÇê óýáÙ è úÜ ëÎÏèçÈÇêå |XQ }[VQKIQ |I„\QqT ððð ñ|OIKTIVqPvKT v¨ qXQ ^mQOPVIK gXP\v\v~PVI\ `vVPQq[ âÙå ×ÏÔÊ Ûßå ×ÎÈÌÏèÉÌÞÎÈÏ ñóýáÙßÜ ëÎÏÔÏãÈ üý ôõöö ÙÚóâ è ÅÜ ëÎÏÔÏãÈå ÕÜ ÕÓÔêÉ 0 ÕÜ ÕÓÔÆÐå ËÏÐÊÉÔÆ ÕÍÉÍÊÈÏÅÔÇÎÏÉÍÌÍÖÈÇÏÌ ×ÔÍØÉÇÊ ÙÚóâ àÉÞÍÔÊå þüöÿüsöôs: A üeöü ô öõögÿôphy f öýöô ýtöüs ·â ñ×ÏÔÊ Ùßå ñÙÚóâßå áïóÙÜ ìÏêÍÓÔÈï¸ÈÌè ÙÚóÚ è ÅÜ ìÏêÍÓÔÈï¸ÈÌèå ÝÎÉ ¸ÍÓÐÉ ÍÒ òÏèãÍÐ ÈÆ MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÝÎÉÑÉÐ àÉÇÍÆÐÈèÉÔÉè- ÅÔÇÎÈÊÉÇï ÊÓÔÉå ëÎÔÍÆÍÌÍÖû ÏÆè ëÍÆÊÉæÊå k`^ ýá ñÙÚóÚßå +óïóÙÙÜ ìÏêÍÓÔÈï¸ÈÌè ÙÚÚâ è ÅÜ ìÏêÍÓÔÈï¸ÈÌèå ‘ÕÔÉÏêÈÆÖ ÊÎÉ MÍÓÌèMä ×ÔÍèÓÇÊÈÍÆ ÏÆè ÉÇÍÆÍãû ÈÆ ÊÎÉ ÝÎÉÑÏÆ ÐÊÏÊÉå ÈÆ ^wqvVXqXvKì gIpQOT gOQTQKqQY qv ñj|jgjƒj NPV]PKTvK vK qXQ ñVVITPvK v¨ XPT UQqPOQmQKqx ÉèÈÊÉè ÑûÅÜ ìÏêÍÓÔÈï ¸ÈÌè 0 SÜ SÎÉÔÔÏÊÊ ñk^U ð` ó·ôÙßå OæÒÍÔè ñÙÚÚâßå ÙÚÛïÙÙ·Ü ìÉÌ ,ÔÉÍ ÙÚóÚ è MÜ ìÉÌ ,ÔÉÍå ÝÎÉ ðÉÍÖÔÏÞÎÈÇÏÌ ¼ÏãÉÐ ÈÆ ÊÎÉ íÈÆÉÏÔ Õ ÊÉæÊÐ ÒÔÍã ÝÎÉÑÉÐå gITPpXIQì UP“PTqI YP {P\v\v~PI Q ^KqPVXPqn ~QQ ô ñÙÚóÚßå ·óïáÛÜ ìÉãÏêÍÞÍÓÌÍÓ Qq I\PP óýýá è òÜìÜ ìÉãÏêÍÞÍÓÌÍÓå ¼Ü ìÈäÏÔÈï.ÏÌÏêÍÓå ×Ü .ÐÊÔã 0 ðÜ ÒÏÌÑÉÔÖå ËæÇÏäÏÊÈÍÆÐ ÈÆ MÈèÉÏ óýý·å ñp^qX Ùó ñóýýáßå óôïôÙÜ ìÉãÏêÍÞÍÓÌÍÓ ÙÚó· è òÜ ǻȘȝĮțȠʌȠȪȜȠȣå ȂȣțȘȞĮȧțȐ ĮȞĮțIJȠȡȚțȐ İȡȖĮıIJȒȡȚĮ ıIJȘ ĬȒȕĮå ÈÆ  ȋȡȩȞȚĮ ǹȡȤĮȚȠȜȠȖȚțȠȪDzȡȖȠȣıIJȘĬȒȕĮȅȚʌȡȦIJİȡȖȐIJİȢIJȦȞİȡİȣȞȫȞțĮȚȠȚıȣȞİȤȚıIJȑȢIJȠȣȢå ÉèÈÊÉè Ñû ǺǹȡĮȕĮȞIJȚȞȠȢ 0ǼȀȠȣȞIJȠȣȡȘ$WKHQV   ËäÉÌû ÙÚÚá è ìÜ ËäÉÌû ñÉèÜßå Q¨]IKYP ðZì |XQ kOvK‚Q ^~Qì |XQ IqQ Q\\IYPV ðððz `Qqq\QmQKq Iq XQOvpv\PTx ñk`^ SÓÞÞÌj ôýßå íÍÆèÍÆ ñÙÚÚáßÜ ËäÉÌû 0 àÓÆÆÉÌÐ óýýÙ è àÜìÜðÜ ËäÉÌû 0 ëÜ àÓÆÆÉÌÐå ›Q\\ kwP\q }[VQKIQ ÙÛ- OvwKY `qvKQx ÒÏÔãÈÆÐÊÉÔ ñóýýÙßÜ ,ÍÐÐÉû óýý+ è úÜ ,ÍÐÐÉûå |vpv~OIpX[ IKY gvpw\IqPvK v¨ ^KVPQKq kvPvqPIå ëÎÈÇÏÖÍå éí ñóý++ßÜ ¸ÉÆèÉÔÐÍÆå ËäÏÆÐ 0 ¼ÈêÈÊÏ ÙÚóÚ è úÜ ¸ÉÆèÉÔÐÍÆå úÜ ËäÏÆÐ 0 òÜ ¼ÈêÈÊÏå éÐÍÊÍÞÈÇ ÉäÈèÉÆÇÉ ÒÍÔ ÊÎÉ ÞÔÈãÏÔû ÞÔÍèÓÇÊÈÍÆå ÞÔÍäÉÆÏÆÇÉ ÏÆè ÊÔÏèÉ ÍÒ íÏÊÉ ÕÔÍÆîÉÅÖÉ ÖÌÏÐÐ ÈÆ ÊÎÉ MÉèÈÊÉÔÔÏÆÉÏÆå }QYPqQOOIKQIK ^OVXIQv\v~[ IKY ^OVXQvmQqO[óÚ ñÙÚóÚßå óïÙ·Ü ¸ÍÞÉ SÈãÞÐÍÆ óýáâ è àÜ ¸ÍÞÉ SÈãÞÐÍÆå ^ I‚QqqQQO IKY ^q\IT v¨ }[VQKIQIK `PqQTx ñkðz` SÓÞÞÌÉãÉÆÊ óáßå íÍÆèÍÆ ñóýáâßÜ ¸ÍÞÉ SÈãÞÐÍÆ óý+ó è àÜ ¸ÍÞÉ SÈãÞÐÍÆå }[VQKIQIK OQQVQå ×ÏÔê àÈèÖÉå ¼ú ñóý+óßÜ ¸ÍÞÉ SÈãÞÐÍÆ 0 ìÈÇêÈÆÐÍÆ óýÛý è àÜ ¸ÍÞÉ SÈãÞÐÍÆ 0 OÜÝÜ×ÜòÜ ìÈÇêÈÆÐÍÆå ^ I‚QqqQQO v¨ ^Q~QIK zP“P\P‚I_ qPvK PK qXQ kOvK‚Q ^~Q ðì |XQ }IPK\IKY IKY qXQ ðT\IKYTx ñ`ð}^ âÙßå ðÊÉÑÍÔÖ ñóýÛýßÜ ¸ÍÞÉ SÈãÞÐÍÆ 0 íÏîÉÆÑû óýÛÚ è àÜ ¸ÍÞÉ SÈãÞÐÍÆ 0 úÜ,Ü íÏîÉÆÑûå |XQ zIqI\v~wQ v¨ qXQ `XPpT PK vmQO ’T ð\PIYå OæÒÍÔè ñóýÛÚßÜ éÏêÍäÈèÈÐ óýáá è SÜ éÏêÍäÈèÈÐåÅ MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ MÍÓÔÆÈÆÖ ëÓÐÊÍãå ^J^ ÛÚ ñóýááßå ·ôïâÚÜ éÏêÍäÈèÈÐ óýý+ è ȈÜ ǿĮțȦȕȓįȘȢīȜȐȢǿǿǾĮȞĮıțĮijȒåÅÊÎÉÆÐ ñóýý+ßÜ éããÉÔçÏÎÔ óýý+ è SÜ éããÉÔçÏÎÔå ìÉÏÊÎ ÏÆè ÊÎÉ ÝÏÆÏÖÔÏ íÏÔÆÏêÉÐå ÈÆ |XQ ^~QT v¨ vmQOì ^ |OP„wqQ qv mP\[ |vºKTQKY ZQOmQw\Qx ÉèÈÊÉè Ñû úÜÕÜ ëÏÔÊÉÔ 0 SÜ×Ü MÍÔÔÈÐåÅÓÐÊÈÆå ݵ ñóýý+ßå óÚýïóÙóÜ òÈÌÌÉÆ ÙÚÚá è úÜÝÜ òÈÌÌÉÆå ÝÎÍÓÖÎÊÐ ÍÆ ÊÎÉ ÒÓÆÇÊÈÍÆÐ ÍÒ ÊÎÉ ÆÉç ÝÎÉÑÉÐ ÊÏÑÌÉÊÐå ÈÆ NPQ €QwQK PKQIO k_|QéqQ IwT |XQ„QK- PXO ^w¨TVX\wTTºQOq ¨üO YPQ }[]QKPTVXQ `pOIVXQ wKY ƒw\qwOx ÉèÈÊÉè Ñû SÜ ìÉÖÉÔïúÏÌêÍÊîû 0 OÜ ×ÏÆÏÖÌå .ÈÉÆÆÏ ñÙÚÚáßå ÛýïóóÚÜ òÆÍèÉÌÌ ÙÚóô è ÅÜ òÆÍèÉÌÌå `mI\\_ºvO\Y KQqºvO]T IKY }QYPqQOOIKQIK Y[KImPVT PK qXQ w„vQIK w\¨ì IK IOVXIQv\v~[ v¨ Vvmp\QéPq[ PK IqQ kOvK‚Q ^~Q IKY IO\[ ðOvK ^~Q OQQVQå ×Îìå ÕÔÍçÆ ÆÈäÉÔÐÈÊû ñÙÚóôßÜ /DI¿QHXU   5 /DI¿QHXU &UDIWVPHQ DQG FUDIWVPDQVKLS LQ 0\FHQDHDQ *UHHFH )RU D PXOWLPHGLD DSï ÞÔÍÏÇÎå ÈÆ gv\PqQPIì `vVPQq[ IKY `qIqQ PK qXQ ^Q~QIK kOvK‚Q ^~Q HGLWHG E\ 5 /DI¿QHXU :' 1LHPHLHU ñ^Q~IQwm  /LqJH $XVWLQ   MÏÔÈÆÏÊÍÐ óýýÛ è ¼Ü MÏÔÈÆÏÊÍÐå MÈÆÍÏÆ ÏÆè MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÌÏÔÆÏêÉÐ- Å ÇÍãÞÏÔÈÐÍÆå ÈÆ I zOïqQ }[VëKPQKKQì ^VqQT YQ \I qI„\Q OvKYQ PKqQOKIqPvKI\Q vO~IKPTëQ pIO \’Vv\Q ¨OIKrIPTQ Y’^qXïKQT ñkz SÓÞÞÌÜ ôÚßå ÉèÈÊÉè Ñû úÜ ìÔÈÉÐÐÉÆ 0 ÅÜ ,ÏÔÆÍÓæå ÅÊÎÉÆÐ ñóýýÛßå Ù+ôïÙýÙÜ ¼ÈÖÎÊÈÆÖÏÌÉ óýý+ è ðÜ ¼ÈÖÎÊÈÆÖÏÌÉå ðÌÏÐÐ ÏÆè ÊÎÉ MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÞÏÌÏÇÉÐ ÍÒ ÊÎÉ MÉèÈÊÉÔÔÏÆÉÏÆå |XQ gOQXPTqvO[ IKY PTqvO[ v¨ \ITTmI]PK~ |QVXKv\v~[å ÉèÈÊÉè Ñû ×Ü MÇëÔÏûå ñzQOImPV IKY zP“P\P‚IqPvK +ßå ÒÉÐÊÉÔäÈÌÌÉå O¸ ñóýý+ßå ÙÚâïÙÙáÜ ž Ÿ ¡¢£¤¥¦ 5$3,1(86WXGLHVRQWKH0\FHQDHDQ:RUOGRIIHUHGWR5REHUW/DI¿QHXUIRUKLV ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ƒ ÈêÈÊÏ ÙÚÚô è òÜ ¼ÈêÈÊÏå MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÖÌÏÐÐ ÑÉÏèÐ- ÊÉÇÎÆÍÌÍÖûå ÒÍÔãÐå ÏÆè ÒÓÆÇÊÈÍÆå ÈÆ ñOKImQKqT ¨Ovm qXQ gITq ¼ÈêÈÊÏ 0 ¸ÉÆèÉÔÐÍÆ ÙÚÚá è òÜ ¼ÈêÈÊÏ 0 úÜ ¸ÉÆèÉÔÐÍÆå ðÌÏÐÐ ÏÆÏÌûÐÉÐ ÒÔÍã MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÝÎÉÑÉÐ ÏÆè ËÌÏÊÉÈÏÇÍãÞÍÐÈÊÈÍÆÏÌ ÉäÈèÉÆÇÉ ÒÍÔ Ï MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÖÌÏÐÐ ÈÆèÓÐÊÔûå JvwOKI\ v¨ \ITT `qwYPQT ·+ ñÙÚÚáßå ÛóïóÙÚÜ ×ÏÆÏÖÈÍÊÏêÈ Qq I\PP ÙÚÚâ è MÜ ×ÏÆÏÖÈÍÊÏêÈå íÜ ×ÏÞÏîÍÖÌÍÓïMÏÆÈÍÓèÏêÈå ðÜ ëÎÏÊîÈïSÞÈÌÈÍÞÍÓÌÍÓå ËÜ ÅÆèÔÉÍï ÞÍÓÌÍÓïMÏÆÖÍÓå ¹Ü MÏÆÈÏÊÈÐå MÜSÜ ÝÈÊÉ 0 ÅÜ SÎÍÔÊÌÏÆèå Å ÖÌÏÐÐ çÍÔêÐÎÍÞ ÏÊ ÊÎÉ MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÇÈÊÏèÉÌ ÍÒ ÝÈÔûÆÐ ÈÆ ðÔÉÉÇÉå ÈÆ ^KKI\QT Yw ù1 zvK~OïT YQ \’^TTvVPIqPvK ðKqQOKIqPvKI\Q pvwO \’PTqvPOQ Yw ZQOOQx vKYvK ÷øøóå ¼ÍÊÊÈÆÖÎÏã ñÙÚÚâßå ó·ïó+Ü ×ÈÊÉÔÍÐ óý+ó è ëÜ ×ÈÊÉÔÍÐå OèÍÐ OÉèÈÞÍèÍÐ ó ñìÜ íÈÏÆÖÏÐ ÞÌÍÊßå ^OVXNQ\q ôá Õó ñóý+óßå ýóÜ SÎÉÔÔÏÊÊ ÙÚÚá è SÜ SÎÉÔÔÏÊÊå í¸ éééë íÉÒêÏÆèÈ- ÅÆ ÍäÉÔäÈÉçå ÈÆ Q¨]IKYP ðZj |XQ kOvK‚Q ^~Qj |XQ IqQ Q\\IYPV ðððz `Qqq\QmQKq Iq XQOvpv\PTx ÉèÈÊÉè Ñû ìÜ ËäÉÌûå íÍÆèÍÆ ñÙÚÚáßå ôÚôïôÚýÜ ÝÍÓÔÆÏäÈÊÍÓ óýýÛ è éÜ ÝÍÓÔÆÏäÈÊÍÓå úÉçÉÌÌÉÔÐä ãÍÓÌèÐ ÏÆè ØÉçÉÌÌÉÔÐä çÍÔêÐÎÍÞÐ ÈÆ MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ðÔÉÉÇÉ- ÏÆ ÏÔÇÎÏÉÍÌÍÖÈÇÏÌ ÓÊÍÞÈÏå ÈÆ |OIYQ IKY gOvYwVqPvK PK gOQmvKQqIO[ OQQVQì gOvYwVqPvK IKY qXQ zOI¨qTmIKå ÉèÈÊÉè Ñû ëÜ ðÈÌÌÈÐå ëÜ àÈÐÑÉÔÖå 0 ÕÜíÜ SØÑÉÔÖå ñ`ð}^_gk ó·ôßå úÍÆÐÉÔÉè ñóýýÛßå ÙÚýïÙâáÜ .ÏÆ ìÏããÉ ñÒÍÔÊÎÇÍãÈÆÖß è ÝÜ .ÏÆ ìÏããÉå ËÓÑÍÉÏÆ ÇÍÆÆÉÇÊÈÍÆÐ çÈÊÎ ÉÏÐÊÉÔÆ ÕÍÉÍÊÈÏ- ÇÉÔÏãÈÇÐ ÏÆè ÐûÆï ÇÎÔÍÆÈÐãÐ ÑÉÊçÉÉÆ íÉÒêÏÆèÈ ÏÆè ÏÆÇÈÉÆÊ ËÌÉÍÆå ÈÆ ^K ðT\IKY „QqºQQK |ºv ›vO\YTì |XQ^OVXIQv\v~[ v¨ w„vQI IURP3UHKLVWRULFWR&ODVVLFDO7LPHV7KH3URFHHGLQJVRIWKH,QWHUQDWLRQDO6FLHQWL¿F&RQIHUHQFHKHOGLQ(UHWULD OQQVQx Jw\[ ù÷_ù x ÷øùóå ÉèÈÊÉè Ñû Ü ÝÏÆêÍÐÈÇå MÜ òÍÐãÏå 0 ,Ü MÏäÔÈèÈÐåÅÊÎÉÆÐ ñÒÍÔÊÎÇÍãÈÆÖßÜ .ÉÔãÉÓÌÉ óýáâ è ËÜ .ÉÔãÉÓÌÉå ×ÏÈÆÊÉè MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ÌÏÔÆÏêÉÐå J` +â ñóýáâßå óÙâïó·+Ü .ÉÔãÉÓÌÉ óýáÛ è ËÜ .ÉÔãÉÓÌÉå Å MûÇÉÆÏÉÏÆ ØÉçÉÌÉÔ äÐ ãÍÌèå kw\\QqPK v¨ qXQ }wTQwm v¨ {PKQ ^OqTx kvTqvK áâ ñóýáÛßå óýïôóÜ µÉÆÏêÈïSÏêÉÌÌÏÔÈÍÓ óý+â è ÅÜ µÉÆÏêÈïSÏêÉÌÌÏÔÈÍÓå ñP |XI\ImvqvP |IpXvP qvK }[]QKvKì ^KIT]IpXQT zXOj |TvwKqIx ù _ù å ×ÏÔÈÐ ñóý+âßÜ ¼ – kQIY `qwYPQT I¨qQO kQV]å ÉèÈÊÉè Ñû éÜ ëÜ ðÌÍäÉÔå ¸Ü ¸ÓÖÎÉÐïÕÔÍÇê 0 úÜ ¸ÉÆèÉÔÐÍÆå íÍÆèÍÆ ñÙÚÚôßå ÙôïôÛÜ 9 ³ AEGIS šš šš rapportsšdešfouillesš thèsesšdešdoctoratš monographiesš actesšdešcolloquesš The content This volume, in honour of one of the Odysseuses in Aegean archaeology, Professor Robert Laffineur, comprises a combination of papers presented during a seminar series on recent developments in Mycenaean archaeology at the Université de Louvain during the academic year 2015-2016. These were organised within the frame of the ARC13/18-049 (concerted research action) ‘A World in Crisis?’ To these are added a series of papers by friends of Robert Laffineur who were keen to offer a contribution to honour him foremost as a friend and scholar in his own right but also as editor of a respected international series founded by him – Aegaeum – and as the driving force and inspiration behind the biannual Aegean meetings that have travelled the world. Several papers within touch scientific domains close to Robert’s heart while others present new excavations or new interpretations of known data. The authors Vasiliki Adrymi-Sismani, Villy Apostolakou, Anthi Balitsari, Philip Betancourt, Fritz Blakolmer, Thomas Brogan, Brendan Burke, Bryan Burns, Jan Coenaerts, Mary Dabney, Jan Driessen, Susan Ferrence, Artemis Georgiou, Akis Goumas, Louise Hitchcock, Florence Hsu, Eleni Konsolaki-Yannopoulou, Eleni Konstantinidis-Syvridi, Quentin Letesson, Aaron Maeir, Joseph Maran, Christopher M. McDonough, Eleni Nodarou, Marie-Louise Nosch, Karin Nys, Tom Palaima, Yiannis Papadatos, Nikolas Papadimitriou, Lena Papazoglou-Manioudaki, Anna Philippa-Touchais, Naya Polychronakou-Sgouritsa, Eleanna Prevedorou, Santo Privitera, Melissa Samaes, Kim Shelton, Nancy Thomas, Gilles Touchais, Malcolm Wiener, Gert Jan van Wijngaarden, Richard Veymiers, Assaf Yassur-Landau, John Younger The series AEGIS (Aegean Interdisciplinary Studies) attempts to make the results of new archaeological research on Aegean and especially Minoan societies available to the scientific and wider public at a rapid pace. Monographs, PhD dissertations, proceedings of scientific meetings and excavation reports complete each other to offer a general view of this time frame which is of primary importance to understand the ancient world and its historical, political, symbolical and social sequences.