Twenty-Second International Water Technology Conference, IWTC22
Ismailia, 12-13 September 2019
GREENHOUSE MANAGEMENT AND BEST PRACTICE IN EGYPT
M. A. A. Abdrabbo1, Abdelazim Negm2, Hassan E. Fath3 and Akbar Javadi4
1
Central Laboratory for Agricultural Climate, Agriculture Research Center, Giza, Egypt, Email:
[email protected]
2
Water and Water Structures Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering, Zagazig University,
Zagazig, Egypt, Email:
[email protected],
[email protected]
3
Egypt Japan University of Science and Technology (E-JUST), Alexandria, Egypt, Email:
[email protected]
4
Department of Engineering, University of Exeter, Exeter, EX4 4QF, UK, Email:
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
Management of greenhouses and protected cultivation requires proper knowledge of the climate
and suitable environmental conditions for the cultivated crops. To achieve good management
practices for greenhouses, the impacts of climate variables on plant growth and production during
different seasons should understood. Autumn is the major cultivation season for greenhouse activities
in Egypt, especially for vegetable crops production. Crops which are cultivated during autumn
continue until winter or spring. Protected cultivation sector plays a significant role in terms of food
security in Egypt and provides wholesale markets with fresh vegetable leafy and fruits during the
winter season with a proper quantity and reasonable price. Using soilless culture techniques for
commercial production of vegetable crops under greenhouses has started to expand in the last ten
years, especially producing leafy crops during summer season. Producing tropical fruits under
screenhouse has also started to expand commercially during the last five years due to increase in the
extreme weather events (heat waves) during critical phenological stage especially for mango trees.
The protection of mango trees by using white screen net cover and cheap wooden greenhouse
structure has become one of the good management practices for producing high yield and good
quality products. Greenhouse irrigation water management for vegetable crops is considered one of
the most important practices related to proper production. An example involving the estimation of the
irrigation water schedule during the autumn season in the Delta region is illustrated in this paper. The
irrigation schedule was done based on the climate conditions of the Delta region which is
demonstrated in the current work. The objective of the this paper is demonstrate the current status of
the greenhouse management and practices in Egypt as well as review some efforts which developed
during the last two decades such as local soilless culture technique and cultivate the tropical fruits
under greenhouses which needed for the different stakeholders in the greenhouse sector in Egypt. On
the other hand, the current work emphasis on the dominated climate in Nile Delta region and how to
estimate the irrigation requirements for plants under greenhouse according to climatic data with
review the researchers’ efforts in this topic.
Keywords: Protected cultivation – screen net – tropical fruits – soilless culture – climate
modification.
1
INTRODUCTION
Greenhouse production of fresh leafy vegetables and fruits is an important agricultural practice.
The use of greenhouse leads to an increase in production per land, water and nutrient units, higher
fruit quality, enhance production for each unit of water and nutrient, longer production periods, and
ability of off-season production. According to Pardosi et al. (2004), Egypt has 1350 ha of
polyethylene greenhouses, 50,000 hectares of walk-in tunnels as well as 10 ha of hydroponics
systems. Greenhouse production helps to meet the local market needs for vegetables and ornamental
plants. Besides supplying the local markets, the production of greenhouses should be greatly valued
369
Twenty-Second International Water Technology Conference, IWTC22
Ismailia, 12-13 September 2019
for its export potential which plays an important role in the foreign trade balance of several national
economies in Egypt. However, high relative humidity in air with continuous production under
greenhouse creates proper conditions for pests and diseases which could result in an increase in the
application of pesticides to protect the crops and the investment. On the other hand, legislative
measures and standards requirements of fresh food safety have become increasingly demanding in
national and international levels. Food safety issues are the main barriers of export of produce to
European Union countries according to the GLOBALGAP legislations (El-Gayar et al., 2019).
Egypt's President inaugurated a major greenhouse project to establish 100,000 acres of modern
greenhouses in seven new reclaimed areas. The national greenhouse project aims to provide the local
market with safe products of fresh fruits and proper quantities of organic products, as well as
enhancing the agricultural production of land and saving water. The pressure of increased competition
among many countries and the import restrictions imposed by the European and some other countries
have intensified the development of greenhouse production in Egypt and other Mediterranean
countries. Protected cropping was introduced in Egypt as a technique of production in 1980 and has
rapidly expanded in the last three decades. The goals behind this expansion were to enhance the offseason production of vegetables and fruits, to produce earlier than open field crops and to improve the
yield and quality of the agricultural products. This article presents a brief review of the greenhouse
best practice in Egypt.
2
DOMINATED CLIMATE IN EGYPT
Egypt is subjected to a Mediterranean climate characterized by variability in the air temperature.
It has been divided into several agro-climatic regions according to the average temperature values.
The most important agro-climatic regions are the Nile Delta; and Middle and the Upper Egypt region
(Farag et al., 2014). Due to mismatch of the borders of the governorates inside these regions with the
latitude lines, we can characterize the approximate location of Upper Egypt region between (24oN –
28oN), Middle Egypt region between (28oN – 30oN) and Delta region between (30oN – 31oN).
Generally, the climate in Egypt is characterized by a dry summer season associated with low
precipitations and high temperatures and a winter season with light rain. Rainfall gradually decreases
with the latitude, from the North to the South (Abdrabbo et al., 2012). The influence of the altitude on
the rate of rainfall is also considerable since the rainfall increases on high mountains on the red sea
coastal area and Saint Catherine Mountains. Table (1) presents the average climatic data including air
temperature (average, maximum and minimum), relative humidity, wind speed, rainfall, and
evapotranspiration. The data show that lowest maximum and minimum air temperatures occur during
December and January; temperature gradually increases from February to reach the highest average
temperature during June and July (Saleh et al., 2017). Evapotranspiration follows almost the same
trend as air temperature. Air relative humidity increases during January to reach about 70%, decreases
from April to about 50% and then increases again during August until December.
3
CURRENT STATUS OF THE GREENHOUSE STRUCTURE AND COST
The traditional greenhouse structure in Egypt is a single span greenhouse with dimensions 40 m
length, 8.5 m width, and 3.3 m height. The single span structure is considered a “walk-in” greenhouse.
There are many other structures that were developed in Egypt during last 25 years. The most popular
structure is a double span structure. Growers in Egypt have found that double span has a better
structure as it has better ventilation and easier management, especially in case of using machines to
prepare the land for greenhouse construction and operation and harvesting of vegetable fruits (see
Table 2). With the start of high investment projects from the private sector by the middle of the 1990s,
the multi-span greenhouses started to be used as they are not suitable for the small or moderate size
growing firms. During the last fifteen years, the Parron system, which uses for support of grape trees,
was transferred to the protected agriculture sector by another design (see Fig. 1). The wooden
greenhouse uses the same structure with greater height and more ventilation. The farmers adopted this
technology for vegetable and tropical fruit production. This structure is more attractive than the steel
370
Twenty-Second International Water Technology Conference, IWTC22
Ismailia, 12-13 September 2019
structure due to its low cost. With similar protection for the cultivated crops, the cost of wooden
greenhouses is five-times lower than steel greenhouses. Although the durability of wooden
greenhouse structure is less than steel, it reduces the capital cost for the grower, which can encourage
new investors to adopt such structure.
During the 1980s, the cultivation under protected greenhouses and low tunnels shifted activity
from traditional systems to a modern intensive one. The intensive agriculture using modern
technologies includes greenhouses, new cultivars, and verities with high yielding as well as new
fertilizers and agricultural chemicals. The pressures exerted on the developing countries natural
resources created environmental hazards such as soil fertility degradation and groundwater pollution
by nitrates and pesticides which are typical consequences of this agricultural intensification
(Abou-Hadid et al., 1993). Therefore, good management of modern protected agriculture is one of
the most important options in the Mediterranean countries such as Egypt which need to improve the
productivity from the agricultural sector to meet the gradually increasing demand for food for the
increasing population and conserve the natural resources and environment. The present work provides
information and some suggestions and measures that can be used by farmers to better manage the
greenhouse production under environmental control systems.
4
CULTIVATION OF TROPICAL FRUITS UNDER SCREENHOUSE
Greenhouses covered by screen nets or shade nets are widely used in Egypt to reduce the radiation
intensity in the greenhouse, especially during hot summer days. The reduction of air temperature
under screen net cover depends on the shading factor of the material. Screen shade net can be applied
outside on top of the greenhouse (using proper construction) which will be more effective in reducing
the heat load of the crops cultivated under the greenhouse. However, the screen net should consider a
good cover which permits sufficient ventilation through screen openings.
Medany et al., (2009) conducted a study on the effectiveness of a white screenhouse for growth of
mango Keitt cultivar. They found that the maximum air temperature under screenhouse was 2°C
lower compared to the open field conditions during the summer season because of lower interception
of solar radiation. The minimum air temperature took another trend; minimum air temperature under
screenhouses was 1°C higher than in the nets because of the greenhouse effect of the cover material
(Abulsoud et al., 2014). The average air relative humidity was increased under the screen net by 4-8%
compared with ambient conditions. The increase in the air relative humidity can be associated with
the use of the white net cover. On the other hand, Hasanein et al. (2014) reported that evaporation
under the net house was lower than outside. The three major factors affecting evaporation are: (a)
wind speed is lower under the screenhouse compared to outside; (2) interception of solar radiation is
lower under the net house and (3) air relative humidity is higher which reduces the evaporation under
the protection of white net.
5
VEGETABLE CROPS
Vegetables are of essential importance for food security in Egypt. Egypt is self-sufficient in most
of vegetable crops. The sector regenerates a high added value in the Egyptian financial statement
through meeting the demand of Egyptian people from the variety of vegetable species and exports to
European countries, Arabian Gulf, and Africa.
Given the relatively high investment and operational costs of a greenhouse production system,
only high-value crops will result in a viable business case. Vegetable crops such as tomatoes,
cucumbers, peppers, peas, and other field vegetables are the main greenhouse horticulture crops; and
recently, higher value crops such as broccoli, lettuce and other new species have been introduced
especially for modern greenhouses which use soilless culture techniques. Also, the acreage of flowers
can be increased to supply, for instance, the urban market. Other crop options include celery, sweet
371
Twenty-Second International Water Technology Conference, IWTC22
Ismailia, 12-13 September 2019
fennel, and lettuce. An interesting option is the production of high-quality seedlings and grafted plants
for domestic use (Sabir and Singh 2013).
Vegetable fruit crops were the earliest to be grown in Egypt under greenhouse. After ten years
from the introduction of this technology in Egypt, production of fruit trees seedlings under
greenhouses started by the mid of 1995s such as banana, orange, and citrus. The area of organic
vegetables under greenhouses in Egypt does not exceed 500ha. The protected crops include cucumber,
tomato, pepper, zucchini, eggplant, and green beans, among others (Hanafi & Kenny, 2001). Data in
Table (3) show the most commercial cultivated crops under greenhouse during the year and their daily
irrigation water requirement.
6
SELECTION OF SITE LOCATION
Selection of a proper site for greenhouse construction is considered the first step for sustainable
greenhouse production. The main factors determining the proper location and site selection of a
greenhouse production area are cost of production, quality of the produced yield, and cost of
transportation to targeted markets. Cost and quality of vegetable fruits are dependent on the prevailed
climate and the greenhouse growing conditions. The level of investment in technology, depends
primarily on the prevailed climate in the concerned area (Castilla et al., 2004). The national project of
100000 acre greenhouses considers different criteria of site selection. Most of the sites are in the
desert (new reclaimed areas). However, some sites were selected close (60 to 70 km) to the highly
populated residential areas to enable the development of new communities around the greenhouse
sites, helping with redistribution of the population to the desert areas (Abdrabbo et al., 2012).
7
CLIMATE UNDER GREENHOUSES
Greenhouse design in Egypt should manage the high daytime temperatures during summer, low
nighttime air temperatures during winter and low air humidity especially in the south of Egypt during
the whole year due to the higher temperatures in the south of Egypt (El-Afandi and Abdrabbo.,
2015).
Under Egyptian climatic conditions, the high daily air temperature occurs for the large part of the
year; therefore greenhouse design and operation have to deal with these climatic conditions (Zakher
and Abdrabbo, 2014). The high air temperature during summer season has led many protected
cultivation growers to avoid this by not cultivating any crops in the period from May to August. Such
management declines the yearly productivity of the protected cultivation units. The cooling of the
greenhouses during most of the year is commonly accomplished through ventilation which can be
applied in many ways including natural ventilation that depends on the natural movement of air for
reducing greenhouse temperature around cultivated area (Abou-Hadid et al., 1995). The natural
ventilation of greenhouse is installed on the sides with nets, as well as one or two-sided ventilation
openings on the top. The top openings can be flexible to allow it to open or close according to weather
conditions. Fogging can be applied for cooling and increasing air relative humidity inside
greenhouses. It is useful to relieve peak temperatures during hot summer days. Applying a fogging
system can also reduce crop evapotranspiration, but the total water use may be the same because
fogging itself requires water (Abulsoud et al., 2014).
8
SOILLESS CULTURE IN EGYPT
Though the soil is still the main predominant growing medium in Egypt, continuous cropping in
open field or plastic houses results in soil-borne diseases. This problem is difficult to solve in plastic
houses using conventional rotations because the plastic house is a high investment facility and should
not be used to grow low value crops such as onion, carrot, and cabbage. Tomato, cucumber, pepper,
eggplant, and melon can achieve good returns, but these crops require plant rotation. As a result,
372
Twenty-Second International Water Technology Conference, IWTC22
Ismailia, 12-13 September 2019
protected cultivation for vegetable production in the greenhouse should gradually change from soil to
soilless systems. The need for soilless culture systems does not only depend on the green house, but
also the use of soilless culture in open field becomes much more urgent especially when relating to
the water subject, fertilizers and pesticides use efficiency. Different systems were developed in Egypt
for simplifying the soilless culture techniques to be implemented by householders as well as small
farmers. The production of fresh vegetables from roofs of buildings has been applied in Egypt from
20 years ago by a team of Egyptian researchers belonging to Central Laboratory for Agricultural
Research Center and Ain Shams University Under FAO umbrella to accomplished a project titled
“Green Food from Green Roofs (GFGR) in Urban and Peri-urban Environments in Egypt”
TCP/EGY/0166(A), FAO, UN. This technique is still applied by many private companies that are
working on establishing and managing soilless culture systems above the roof of buildings. They
developed different simple systems to apply in the roof of the buildings in Cairo and Alexandria. On
the other hand, the commercial soilless greenhouse culture in Egypt began slowly in the last two
decades. Commercial farms are less than 2 % of the total cultivated area using different soilless
culture systems. Deep water culture is a technique which is most widely used in Egypt. Nutrient film
technique is used via “A” shape of pipes. Until now, the use of proper soilless culture has not
received enough attention from the growers except the growers who provides leafy crops for large
restaurants, hotels, and hypermarkets. Researchers in Egypt have been in the forefront of this field
from the beginning of 1990s.
Some researchers have investigated the integrated management of the vegetable crops cultivated
in soilless culture. El- Beltagy et al., (1992) reported that vegetative growth rate of some vegetable
plants has different trends according to substrate media used. Cucumber is grown in peat moss +sand
+vermiculite (1:1:1) substrate mixture and yields a higher vigorous plant compared with other
substrates mixtures. Medany et al. (1995) also investigated using local substrate materials for
producing vegetables in Egypt. They used a date - palm fibers (Leaf) dried shredded date - palm
leaflet fibers, nylon threads, rockwool, and the control "cultivate in soil". They reported that the leaf
and palm leaflet fibers treatments gave 50 % higher cucumber yield than the rockwool media and 100
% higher than the control. They also reported that the increase of the yield with the reduction of
production cost by changing the expensive imported rockwool which led to make the palm fiber
reasonable alternative local media substrate for growing vegetable plants. AL-Harbi et al., (2006)
studied different reates of nitrogen with head and romain lettuce grown in coconut fiber, and found
that increase in nitrogen rate led to increase in the fresh weight of lettuce whereas nitrate
concentration in the lettuce leaves will increase the nitrogen doses. El-Sayed et al. (2016) used
different substrates and nutrient solutions for vegetative growth, mineral content, production, and fruit
quality of strawberry production. The authors used three substrate mixtures including perlite:peatmoss (1:1 V/V) M1, perlite:plant compost (4:1 V/V) M2, and perlite: vermicompost (4:1 V/V) M3,
while the three nutrient solutions were vermicompost-tea, animal compost-tea and mineral nutrition
(control). The highest significant values of vegetative growth, yield and its component, fruit quality
and chemical characteristics were recorded for plants grown in perlite: peat-moss mixture and
fertigated with the mineral nutrient (control), while plants grown in perlite: vermicompost mixture
and with animal compost-tea as nutrient showed the highest values of fruit firmness, TA and heavy
metals. Finally, several works have been conducted under Egyptian conditions which are now for
commercial use. There has been significant amount of work in agriculture in Egypt and the use of
different soilless techniques and different nutrient solutions based on crop age, season, etc is well
established.
Cucumber is one of the major crops which requires warm temperature to grow and gives good
yield (Abdrabbo, 2001). Most of cucurbitaceous vegetables grow in warm temperate and cool
tropical climate. The optimum daytime temperature ranges between 22oC and 30oC )Grubben,
1997). On the other hand, Papadopoulos et al., (2000) studied the effects of daytime and nighttime
air temperature on growth of cucumber during the spring season. They indicated that cucumber
growth rate was increased linearly with increasing average daytime air temperature. Also, the authors
added that plant growth and development rates were increased with increasing air temperature
regardless of daytime temperature or nighttime temperature. Abdrabbo et al. (2010) reported that the
373
Twenty-Second International Water Technology Conference, IWTC22
Ismailia, 12-13 September 2019
cover soil with transparent mulch led to higher soil temperature, which in turn resulted in increasing
plant growth rate and yield. Air temperature fluctuations in subsequent years modify the course of the
occurrence of phenological phase dates and, thus, affect the size and quality of the yield of crop plants
(Ahmed et al., 2004). Farag et al. (2010a) studied the effect of different periods for covering the low
plastic tunnels on average air temperature under unheated greenhouses. The authors reported that
covering the growing beds with white polyethylene significantly and consistently raised air and soil
temperatures compared to untreated beds. The highest air temperature was obtained by plastic tunnel
treatment. Using polyethylene tunnel inside the unheated plastic house during the cold days increased
the air temperature by about 1-1.5oC compared with plastic house weather; while air temperature
inside the plastic house was increased about 1.5-2 oC above the temperature outside green-house
during the daytime (Zakher and Abdrabbo., 2014).
Air relative humidity is the ratio of the actual air vapor pressure of water vapor to the air vapor
pressure of air saturated with moisture at the same temperature. Relative humidity affects plant
transpiration by affecting the air vapor pressure difference between plant leaves and surrounding air
(Abdrabbo et al., 2009). A relative humidity (RH) at 75% is considered to be optimal under plastic
greenhouses. Sufficient relative humidity would help to produce good quality fruits without coloring
defects (Bakker et al., 1995). Relative humidity under plastic cover or under screen net is higher than
the open field by different amounts, depending on several factors (Medany et al., 2009). Air relative
humidity increases under the polyethylene houses, not only because of the polyethylene cover but also
due to the vegetative mass of the plants which grow inside the house (Abou-Hadid et al., 1988).
Relative humidity increases according to the shading density; a higher shading density would lead to a
higher air relative humidity (El-Gayar et al., 2019). Local studies under Egyptian conditions of single
typical polyethylene house with side and top ventilation has shown that permanent natural ventilation,
by opening the windows during the nighttime during spring and summer seasons, reduced relative
humidity inside the greenhouse, and it also affected other climatic variables that enhanced crop
productivity (Farag et al., 2006).
Polyethylene mulching under greenhouse has some effects: it increases soil temperature,
conserves soil moisture, and inhibits weed growth (Hanada and Adams 1991). Abdrabbo et al.
(2010) reported that transparent and/or black plastic films created favorable conditions for increasing
soil temperature compared to the soil under greenhouse without mulch cover. They added that the soil
temperature was by 2–3 °C higher under clear polyethylene mulch. A significant difference in plant
growth characteristics under mulch was reported for pepper and eggplant which grow under
greenhouses by enhancing the water and fertilizers availability in the plant root zones (Farrag et al.,
2016, and Abou-El-Hassan et al., 2014). Farag et al., (2010) studied the effect of different mulches
of growing beds. The data obtained showed that the highest vegetative growth characters were
obtained when the growing beds were mulched. On the other hand, the lowest vegetative growth
characters were obtained when growing beds without mulching (control). Putting a clear mulch on the
growing beds gave a significantly positive effect on stem diameter when compared with plant on the
bed without mulch. Farag et al., (2010) measured the air temperature under a covered tunnel which
was constructeded under unheated greenhouses. The authors found that air temperature under clear
mulch increased about (1.5-3 oC) more than the control. The results showed that air temperature under
the covered tunnel was higher than the other treatments. The clear mulch gave the highest soil and air
temperature followed by without soil mulch in comparison with the other treatments.
9
IRRIGATION REQUIREMENTS UNDER GREENHOUSES
Drip irrigation is the main irrigation system which is used under greenhouses in Egypt. The
calculation of the daily irrigation requirement for cucumber under greenhouse in Egypt is illustrated
in Table (4) as an example for the irrigation schedule using drip irrigation in greenhouses under
Egyptian conditions based on climatic data. Many researchers studied the irrigation management
under greenhouse in Egypt and Mediterranean. EI- Karam et al. (2002) studied the effect of different
irrigation levels (100%, 80%, and 60% of ETc) on lettuce plants. The results showed that water stress
374
Twenty-Second International Water Technology Conference, IWTC22
Ismailia, 12-13 September 2019
caused by the deficit irrigation levels significantly reduced leaf number, leaf area index, and dry
matter accumulation. Several totally mature leaves reached harvesting time in the 80% and 60%
treatments were 8% and 14% lower, respectively than the control treatment. Abdrabbo et al. (2009)
applied different polyethylene mulch colors and irrigation levels on cucumber plant under
polyethylene greenhouse. The 0.80 ETc treatment produced the highest vegetative growth and
production. 1.00 ETc came in the second order followed by 1.20 ETc, while 0.60 ETc produced the
lowest vegetative characteristics. Singer et al. (2003) studied water-stress treatments on growth stage
and production of snap bean. They found that vegetative growth represented by plant height and
number of leaves was significantly reduced by water-stress treatments. Wang and Zhang (2004)
studied the effect of different irrigation water treatments on plant growth of cucumber in greenhouse
and found that water supply was one of the most common limiting environmental factors for plant
growth. Deficit water budgets lead to numerous physiological changes, such as altered root to shoot
ratio, reduced leaf area or number of leaves, and finally reduced leaf area index. Gaafer and Refaie
(2006) investigated the effect of different irrigation regimes (80%, 100%, and 120% of ETc) on
cantaloupe. The results showed that water stress significantly reduced plant height. The highest
irrigation levels (120% of ETc) increased plant height. Abdrabbo et al., 2009 found that the mulch
colors and irrigation levels significantly affected plant height in the two growing seasons. 0.80 ET c
treatments produced the highest vegetative characteristics. 1.00 ET c came in the second order,
followed by 1.20 ETc, while 0.60 ETc produced the lowest vegetative characteristics. The results also
indicated that transparent polyethylene mulch resulted in the highest vegetative characteristics
followed by black mulch. The lowest plant height, number of leaves, and total leaf area were obtained
by no soil cover (control). Abdrabbo et al. 2010 studied the effect of different irrigation regimes on
vegetative growth of eggplant and found that the irrigation level 1.00 ET c recorded by far the highest
vegetative growth followed by 1.20, 0.80 and 0.60 irrigation levels in both seasons. Vegetative growth
under a black net was significantly higher than that under a white net in both seasons; the lowest plant
length was recorded under open field conditions. The interaction between greenhouse cover and
irrigation level showed that the highest significant value was for 1.00 irrigation levels, with a
significant difference between greenhouse cover, while the lowest value was obtained for 0.60
irrigation level under open field conditions in both seasons.
10 GREENHOUSE TECHNOLOGIES AVAILABILITY IN EGYPT
The availability of the greenhouse technology is not a critical issue for the small farmers who use
small greenhouse with a simple technology to produce some vegetables such as cucumber, tomato,
eggplant, Okra and Molokhia for the local market during winter season by using polyethylene
greenhouses to make a significant profit. The big investors in Egypt who are looking for new
technologies such as environmental control, soilless culture techniques and the new species and
varieties which the consumer in Egypt or outside are looking for. As mentioned above, the soilless
culture technology is available in Egypt, especially for leafy crops (such as new varieties of lettuce,
celery, among others) with a good profit margin for the greenhouse sector. The soilless culture in
Egypt still suffers from missing automation technology for monitoring the quality of water and
modifying the nutrient solution. There have been some efforts to address these issues but, until now,
there are no significant improvements in the field. The second real challenge for expansion of soilless
culture in Egypt is the availability of the market; regular local market does not recognize the
differences between the production from soilless culture techniques and conventional farms. The
production cost from soilless culture is much higher compared to the traditional production process,
while, the price of the both products is always the same in the wholesale markets. The same is true for
the environmental control; many growers use shading net with fogging system for production of leafy
crops during the summer season for continuous supply of large hotel, restaurants and hypermarkets
but the manufacturing technology of environmental control inside Egypt is still not well developed.
In this aspect, agriculture sector needs an integrated cooperation with the other scientific communities
such as engineering and electronics sectors to produce a prototype of local integrated system to
produce local environmental control greenhouses.
375
Twenty-Second International Water Technology Conference, IWTC22
Ismailia, 12-13 September 2019
11 GREENHOUSE TRANSFER TO EGYPT
Egypt imported a variety of greenhouses from highly developed countries in greenhouse
technology such as the Netherlands, Spain, China and Hungary in the national project for 100000
greenhouses. The decision makers in Egypt studied the suitability of these greenhouses for Egyptian
conditions based on the experience of the agriculture sector in imported greenhouse structures. Most
of the greenhouses which were imported during the last ten years have a moderate or simple
technology which is easy to construct, install, and mainteain at reasonable cost according to the
production plan. The Egyptian decision makers learn the lesson of transfer the greenhouse technology
from the Northern Europe countries during 1980s which was suitable for cold weather with poor
natural ventilation. All of the imported technology for governmental or for private sector, even the
local manufacturing, concern about good ventilation system of the new greenhouses because the cold
weather in Egypt is only during December, January until mid February (Table 1) which means a short
cold season with long hot season which need good ventilation and good protection from high
temperature during the summer season.
Table 1. Forty year averageof climatic data for Zagazig as a sample of the climatic data in the Nile Delta
region (Source: Central Laboratory for Agricultural Climate)
Month
Temperature
Humidity Windspeed Sol.Radiat. Rainfall
Aver
Min
Max Temp
Temp
Temp
Jan.
Feb.
Mar.
April
May
June
July
August.
Sept.
Oct.
Nov.
Dec.
Average
13.20
14.10
16.40
19.80
23.50
25.30
27.30
26.30
25.60
23.40
19.40
14.90
21.10
19.70
21.00
23.60
27.60
31.40
35.00
37.40
34.20
32.50
30.20
25.70
21.20
28.00
6.60
7.10
9.20
12.00
15.50
18.60
20.20
20.40
18.60
16.60
13.00
8.60
13.90
%
km/day
71.00
66.00
62.00
55.00
50.00
52.00
59.00
64.00
65.00
65.00
69.00
73.00
63.00
136.00
139.00
139.00
168.00
163.00
151.00
124.00
96.00
99.00
124.00
104.00
124.00
131.00
ETo
Penman
MJ/m2/day (mm) mm/day
12.10
14.90
19.30
23.20
26.20
28.90
28.10
25.90
22.80
17.90
13.40
11.40
20.30
6.70
5.60
3.80
2.00
2.60
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.80
4.30
6.10
32.90
1.70
2.20
3.20
4.50
5.60
6.30
6.10
5.40
4.50
3.50
2.30
1.70
4.45
Table 2. Different structures of greenhouses and total cost for each unit*
Greenhouse type
Dimension (m)
(Length – width
– height)
Total cost
(L.E.)
1
Single span
40 x 8.5 x 3.30m
36000
Cost for
square
meter
(L.E.)
100
2
Double span
40 x 16 x 3.25m
80000
120
3
Double span
30 x 16 x 3.30m
75000
130
376
Twenty-Second International Water Technology Conference, IWTC22
4
Multi span
5
6
Ismailia, 12-13 September 2019
40 x 104 x 4m
400,000
96
Wooden GH
64 x 140m
200,000
22
Single span
(Nursery)
30 x 8.5 x 3.3m
56,000
220
* Source: greenhouse sector- Agriculture Research Center, Ministry of Agriculture and Land
Reclamation.
Table 3. Common crops under greenhouse in Egypt, life period for each crop, average irrigation
requirements, and cultivation season based on Delta region.
Crop
Life period /days
lettuce
Celery
Red cabbage
Tomato
Pepper
Squash
Broccoli
Dwarf Mango
Cucumber
Average irrigation
requirements (L/m2/
day)
10
8-10
7-9
8-16
8-12
8 – 10
8-10
6-14
4-12
70 - 85
75-90
90 - 110
240-300
120-160
75-100
80-100
Perennial
90-120
Suggest growing
season
Summer
Summer
Winter
winter
winter
All year
Winter
All year
winter
Table 4. Irrigation schedule for cucumber under greenhouse in the Nile Delta region during the autumn
season.
ETo
Week
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
GH
5.5
5.1
4.9
4.8
4.3
3.9
3.5
3.2
3.1
2.9
2.9
2.8
2.7
2.6
2.6
2.2
2.1
1.9
Kc
ET
crop
0.45
0.52
0.58
0.64
0.70
0.77
0.85
0.92
1.10
1.11
1.01
0.96
0.95
0.94
0.94
0.80
0.65
0.50
2.48
2.67
2.85
3.04
3.00
3.02
2.97
2.93
3.37
3.26
2.89
2.68
2.59
2.49
2.46
1.78
1.35
0.96
377
+
leaching
req.
1.55
1.84
2.14
2.47
2.63
2.83
2.97
3.29
3.80
3.67
3.26
3.02
2.91
2.80
2.77
1.11
0.93
0.72
period
IR (L/
Plant/ day)
0.87
1.03
1.20
1.39
1.48
1.59
1.67
1.85
2.14
2.06
1.83
1.70
1.64
1.58
1.56
0.63
0.52
0.41
Minute
26
31
36
42
44
48
50
56
64
62
55
51
49
47
47
19
16
12
Twenty-Second International Water Technology Conference, IWTC22
Ismailia, 12-13 September 2019
Figure1. Cultivate vegetable crops under wooden structure greenhouse (Private farm – Cairo –
Alexandria Desert Road)
6 months
after
cultivation
10 months
after
cultivation
18 months
after
cultivation
Figure 2. Mango under wooden greenhouse structure (El-Bosaily Farm – Behira Governorate–
Agricultural Research Center).
Fig. 3 Commercial hydroponics commercial farm in Egypt farm location Cairo – Alexandria
Desert Road.
Figure 3. Hydroponics in a commercial farm in Egypt - location Cairo, Alexandria Desert Road.
378
Twenty-Second International Water Technology Conference, IWTC22
Ismailia, 12-13 September 2019
12 CONCLUSIONS
Protected cultivation of horticultural crops in Egypt has had significant development in many
aspects. The national project to establish 100000 greenhouses has been one of the major motivations
to improve the protected cultivation sector during recent years. There have been significant trials for
both commercial and research sectors in terms of improving greenhouse production and using new
technologies such as soilless culture at commercial scale. Improving the knowledge of the people who
work in this sector is the real challenge which protected agriculture faces with availability of new
technology and advanced techniques. The current work is one of the practical trials for improving
knowledge of this sector for short term. Further scientific studies are needed for every subject
mentioned in this paper such as simple estimation of irrigation schedule (using Excel sheet), tricks of
using soilless culture technique, climatic study of the microclimate under white screen net in different
climatic regions in Egypt and growth, productivity and economic feasibility of major vegetable crops
under modern greenhouses for local market and exportation.
13
RECOMMENDATION
The current work demonstrated some of good management practices related to production under
various greenhouse structures in terms of selection of appropriate site location, irrigation water
management, proper climate conditions under greenhouses, and proper management using soilless
techniques. Enhancing the food safety under greenhouses will help to meet legislation of EUREPGAP
and open the window to export bigger volumes of excess greenhouse production of vegetables and
fruits to European countries. Food safety is related to all elements of greenhouse management such as,
greenhouse structure, ventilation, cover material, seed and rootstocks, irrigation management,
fertilization management and pest and disease control. The integrated crop management for all
stakeholders of greenhouse sector is a vital need for improving food safety of produced vegetables,
fruits and leafy plants.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We acknowledge the British Council (BC) and science & technology development fund (STDF),
Egypt for supporting this research through funding the project titled "a novel standalone solar-driven
agriculture greenhouse - desalination system: that grows its energy and irrigation water" via the
Newton-Musharafa funding scheme (grants ID: 332435306 from BC and ID 30771 from STDF).
REFERENCES
Abdrabbo, M. A. A.;
Farag A.A.; Hassanein M.K. and Abou-Hadid A.F. (2010). Water
consumption of eggplant under different microclimates. J. Boil. Chem. Environ. Sci., 5:239-255.
Abdrabbo, M. A. A.; A. A. Farag and M. K. Hassanein. 2009. Irrigation requirements for
cucumber under different mulch colors. Egypt. J. Hort., 36:333-346
Abdrabbo M. A.; A.A. Farag; M. Abul-Soud; Manal M.H. Gad El-Mola; Fatma S. Moursy; I. I.
Sadek; F. A. Hashem; M. O. Taqi; W.M.S. El-Desoky and H.H. Shawki. 2012 . Utilization of Satellite
Imagery for Drought Monitoring in Egypt. World Rural Observations;4(3):27-37
Abou-Ali, H., and H. Kheir-El-Din. 2010. “Economic Efficiency of Crop Production in Egypt.”
The Egyptian Center for Economic Studies, Working Paper No. 155 (Publication Number:
ECESWP155-E).
379
Twenty-Second International Water Technology Conference, IWTC22
Ismailia, 12-13 September 2019
Abou-El-Hassan S., M.A.A. Abdrabbo and A.H.Desoky. 2014. Enhancing Organic Production of
Cucumber by using Plant Growth Promoting Rhizobacteria and Compost Tea under Sandy Soil
Condition. Research Journal of Agriculture and Biological Sciences, 10(2): 162-169
Abou-Hadid, A.F., M.A. Medany and A.S. El-Beltagy. (1993). Productivity and Pre-economical
Studies on the use of Drip Irrigated Low Tunnels in Egypt. Egypt. J. Hort., 20(2):111-117.
Abou-Hadid,
A.F., A.
S.
El-Beltagy &
H.
M.
El-Saied.
(1988).
Potential
evapotranspiration and water consumption use patterns under plastic house conditions in Egypt.
Egypt.J.Hort., 15(1):1-12.
Abou-Hadid, A.F., El-Beltagy, A.S., Mohamedien, S.A., Saleh, M.M. and Medany, M.A.
(1995). Options for Simple greenhouse heating systems. Acta Hort. (ISHS) 399:87-94.
Abul-Soud, M.A., M.S.A. Emam and M.A.A. Abdrabbo. 2014. Intercropping of Some Brassica
Crops with Mango Trees under Different Net House Color. Research Journal of Agriculture and
Biological Sciences, 10(1): 70-79.
AL-Harbi, A.R., M. A.Abdrabbo, A.A. Farag, M. A. Medany and E. M. Abd-Elmoniem. 2008.
Comparison of Open and Closed Hydroponic Systems on Lettuce Yield. 2006. Egypt J. of Agriculture
Research. 86, (2) 695 - 702.
Bakker, J. C., G. P. A. Bot, H. Challa and N. J. Van de Braak. Greenhouse climate control -- An
integrated approach. Wageningen Pers, The Netherlands, 1995. 279 pp.
Castilla, N., Hernandez, J. & Abou Hadid, A.F. 2004. Strategic crop and greenhouse management
in mild winter climate areas. Acta Hort., 633: 183–196.
El-Afandi G., M. Abdrabbo. 2015. Evaluation of Reference Evapotranspiration Equations under
Current Climate Conditions of Egypt. Turkish Journal of Agriculture - Food Science and Technology,
3(10): 819-825.
El-Beltagy, A. S., A. F. Abou-Hadid and S.A. Gaafar (1992). Interaction between root
media and fertilizer for cucumber crops grown in greenhouses. Acta Hort., 323:235-240
El-Gayar, Safya, A. M. Negm and M. A. A. Abdrabbo.2019. Greenhouse Operation and
Management in Egypt. Handbook of Environmental Chemistry: Volume 74, 2019, Pages 489-560
EL-Sayed, S.F. H.A. Hassan, M. Abul-Soud, D.A.M. Gad. 2016. Effect of substrate mixtures and
nutrient solution sources on Strawberry plants under closed hydroponic system. Journal Production
Development 21 (1), 97-127
Farag A. A. , M. A. A. Abdrabbo and M. S. M. Ahmed . 2014. GIS Tool for Distribution
Reference Evapotranspiration under Climate Change in Egypt. ; IJPSS, ISSN: 2320-7035, Vol.: 3,
Issue.: 6: 575- 588.
Farag A. A. , M. A. A. Abdrabbo and M. S. M. Ahmed . 2014. GIS Tool for Distribution
Reference Evapotranspiration under Climate Change in Egypt. ; IJPSS, ISSN: 2320-7035, Vol.: 3,
Issue.: 6: 575- 588.
Farag, A .A.; M .A .A .Abdrabbo and M .K .Hassanein. 2010. Early production of cucumber
under plastic house. J. Biol. Chem. Environ. Sci., Vol.5 (2): 133-145.
380
Twenty-Second International Water Technology Conference, IWTC22
Ismailia, 12-13 September 2019
Farrag, K., M. A. A. Abdrabbo and S. A. M. Hegab.2016. Growth and Productivity of Potato
under Different Irrigation Levels and Mulch Types in the North West of the Nile Delta, Egypt. Middle
East Journal of Applied Sciences,6 : 774-786.
Gaafer, S. A. and K. M. Refaie. 2006. Modeling water effects on growth and yield of melon cv.
Reticulates. Egypt. J. Appl. Sci., 21:682-693.
Hanafi A. and Kenny L. (2001), ”Integrated production and protection as a tool in organic
greenhouse crops”, Mediteranean organic agriculture, pp 347-364, international syposium on arganic
agriculture, Agadir, Morocco, 7-10 October 2001.
Hasanein, N. M., M. A. A. Abdrabbo and Y. K . EL-Khulaifi .2014. The Effect of Bio-Fertilizers
and Amino Acids on Tomato Production and water productivity under Net-House Conditions. Arab
Univ.J. Agric. Sci., Ain Shams Univ.,cairo, 22(1):43-54.
Karam, F.; O. Mounzer; F. Sarkis and R. Lahoud. 2002. Yield and nitrogen recovery of lettuce
under different irrigation regimes. J. Appl. Hort., 4:70-76.
Medany M. A., M. A. A. Abdrabbo, A. A. Awny, M. K. Hassanien and A. F. Abou-Hadid. 2009.
Growth and productivity of mango grown under greenhouse conditions. Egypt. J. Hort. 36, 373-382.
Pardossi, A., Tognoni, F. and Incrocci, L. 2004. Mediterranean Greenhouse Technology. Chron.
Hort. 44(2):28-34.
Sabir N. and B. Singh.2013. Protected cultivation of vegetables in global arena: A review Indian
Journal of Agricultural Sciences 83 (2): 123–35,
Saleh, S. M., M. A. M. Heggi, M. A. A. Abdrabbo and A. A. Farag. 2017. Heat Waves
Investigation During Last Decades in Some Climatic Regions in Egypt. Egypt. J. Agric. Res., 95 (2),
Singer, S. M.; Y. I. Helmy; A. N. Karas; A. F. Abou-Hadid. 2003. Influences of different waterstress treatments on growth, development and production of snap bean (phaseolus vulgaris L.). Acta
Hort., 614.
Wang, S. and F. Zhang. 2004. Effect of different water treatment on photosynthesis characteristics
and leaf ultra structure of cucumber growing in solar greenhouse. Acta Hort., 633:397-401.
Zakher, A.G., and M. A. A. Abdrabbo. 2014. Reduce the harmful effect of high temperature to
improve the productivity of tomato under conditions of newly reclaimed land. Egypt. J. Hort. Vol. 41,
No.2, pp.85 -97 (2014)
381