International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
Cultural tourism on a changing paradigm
©António dos Santos Queirós
Centro de Filosofia. Faculdade de Letras da Universidade de Lisboa
Alameda da Universidade 1600-214, Lisboa Portugal
[email protected]
Abstract
The main terms, such Culture, Cultural Landscape, Heritage or Cultural Tourism are not
neutral scientific objects. They are academic constructions emerging in historical contexts.
The concept of “motivation” is consensual for understand and explain the nature of the
tourism demand, but is sufficient? We think no. We need enlarging the hermeneutic of
tourism with the concept of “taste”.
They are linked to a consensual paradigm.
This paper wants to discuss this conceptual framework, discovering at the same time if we are
in presence of some anomalies, observe multiple, unexplained or unexpected events and if a
rival paradigm emerges.
The second line of debate is about the connection between cultural tourism and tourism
economy. Researching how is create and reproduced the capital of tourism and recognising
the cultural values and products penetration in the tourism activity.
Their propose: Restructuring tourism for more competitiveness and productivity (and
sustainability) meaning to offer new Route and Circuits integrating cultural heritage and
patrimony of nature.
The third line want to discuss the idea of Cultural Tourism based on built heritage, views and
lifestyle, as well as events and happenings, from a critical view.
Our goal will be to build a conceptual framework to design the identity of Cultural Tourism
and different types of tourism. This theoretical framework must be the same. Those principles
must be commons.
Our thesis is that those principles are the different organic structures and products. Different
organic structures and products can to distinguish tourism cultural from tourism of nature;
tourism of nature from rural tourism…and so one.
A new conceptual research framework emerges and a new tourism paradigm: Environmental
Tourism.
Keywords: Paradigm. Taste. Economy. Types tourism. Circuit. Route
1
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
INTRODUCTION
The paradigm concept and the critique of traditional categories of Tourism
The general definition of paradigm comprises a "disciplinary matrix", a constellation of
beliefs, values and techniques shared by a Community (Kuhn, 1962). The presence of some
anomalies is not enough to abandon the previous paradigm. This only happens when, in the
framework of phenomenological study, you can observe multiple unexplained or unexpected
events and when a rival paradigm emerges. This does not happen suddenly. The paradigm
remains stable when can increase the accuracy of their observations and assessments; and can
be extend to study new phenomena; determine the values of universal constants; is competent
to formulate quantitative laws which allow a better understanding of the linkages between the
different phenomena; and create new processes to apply the paradigm into new areas.
But the recognition of the existence of two competing paradigms need that their researchers
use the same conceptual framework, which, in the area of tourism, isn’t easy, because there
are a large proliferation about fundamental tourism concepts. Becomes imperative to make
more universal the academic and scientific language tourism, to build the maximum
consensus and rigor on the concepts operated in the study of tourism phenomenology.
In this research programme we will use the two methodological routes pointed by Lakatos, the
negative heuristics, which let to reject the propositions about tourism already denied and a
positive heuristics, which consent to build a new core of scientific propositions not falsifiable.
Tourism has been studied as an economic activity, from their products and businesses
activities. But why are travelling peoples and for what? The WTO, from a conceptual model
based on services and products offered by the market and in what appears to be the
“motivation” and purpose of the various tourist segments, created a matrix of categories
classifying their products and activities, the Tourism Satellite Account _TSA.
Our proposal was to study the evolution of this conceptual model services and products
offered by the XXI century market evolution, classified in the Tourism Satellite Account.
We focused our research at Iberian market, considering the development and high quality of
tourism data in Spain, and their significant ITA ranking and incomes.
In the first step of our research we found objective contradictions in the inquire results about
the motivation for tourism traveling and the real activities do for the same international
tourists in Spain. In this context, we want to give a contribution to build a new framework
concerning the tourism phenomenology, adding the concept of “taste” to the concept of
“motivation”.
And develop the research route to categorize the complex nature of the tourism
phenomenology.
Without depreciate the economic dimension of tourism activities and the theoretical progress
achieved to understand the nature of tourism business, their apparent transformation in
“industry” and to rebuild a sustainable tourism model, we depart from a critical perspective to
that conventional matrix.
NEW CATEGORIES OF TOURISM PRODUCTS AND ACTIVITIES
Signs of crisis on the "model of sun and beach"
The activity of tourism through the Mediterranean basin is haunting by the phantom of the
crisis of the "model of sun and beach" and the put in question of the hedonistic paradigm of
travelling and leisure.
2
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
In recent years, the optimism returns: hotels and resorts added extras or even alternatives to
this model, new types of animation and cultural tourism and ecotourism products, designing a
kind of matrix redeeming.
However these designations proliferated without consensus about those conceptual definitions
built on scientific foundations and technically gauged by tourism economy.
What are cultural tourism and tourism of nature (ecotourism?) and how we can distinguish the
different “categories” or types of tourism?
And what are the principles, scientific and economic, that shall obey the Tours and Circuits
making off, which also proliferate without rules or contours, set?
And, in this context, what is the validity of traditional guides, packages and agents mediators?
The offer of the Chains of Values_ hotels, restaurants, merchandising, animation, transport
and mediation, needs to incorporate new products and even other values?
Finally, what is the historical assessment of heritage and cultural landscapes, scientific,
literary and artistic tradition, to distinguish the tourist identity destination?
The result of this vagueness, it is in many occasions, a confusing and imprecise amalgam of
concepts and products, where mingle tourism, culture, sociology, anthropology, heritage, and
in another plan, the economic inefficiency.
Because is always the same question: how to increase the residence time of tourists? How
transform the excursionists in tourists, increasing the level of consumption of quality products
and satisfaction degree, which induces the promotion and return? How to increasing the
productivity and sustainability of the "Tourism Industry", as the motor of global, synergic and
sustainable development projects!?
What’s happen in the tourism world under the iron hand of the modern market, analysed from
the both sides, demand and offer, with the emergence of the society of knowledge and
information, with their new middle class growing with more education and culture, a young
people predisposed to the e-learning and a increasing segment of tourists who anticipate the
middle-aged and retire? What’s come about when tourists gain a new mobility through the
international market, which has become at the same time more enlarged and closer, in reason
of the increase of air transport and low cost flights, massive roads, quick railways and colossal
sea transports?
What’s turn out with the dissemination of information and communication technologies?
The conceptual framework of tourism as scientific object
In parallel, the tourism theory seems to touch only the surface of tourist phenomenon’s
complexity, in constant delay face the evolution of tourist praxis or focusing its controversy
and confrontation of ideas into the academic infield, fruitful but limited debate.
A theoretical labour that could detect, prevue and solve the conjuncture problems, the crises
of the dominant tourism paradigm and the emerging of a new paradigm, will give more
authority to the tourism academy concerning political and economic stakeholders.
Their scientific validation depends from the capability to transform conceptual framework
into applied research.
Tensions between the business world and the public administration, financial, epidemic and
environmental impacts and crises, new risks of wars and terrorism, ethical problems, needs to
be includes on the conceptual framework of tourism research.
However, the conceptualization of the tourism phenomenon complexity and their dialectic of
change and crisis remain obscure to many of the main actors and decision-makers, including
ourselves, the researchers.
3
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
To develop the conceptual framework of tourism and trying to distinguish scientific concepts
from common sense in the tourism language, we adopt here the conceptual structure proposed
in the essay "Cultural Tourism and Heritage Economy":
"The whole scientific theory has as support a set of axioms. The methodology of
scientific work consists in the development of these axioms for obtain from them
"physical" consequences, in the case of tourism, to analyze his Phenomenology. That
means, in the study of the evolution of tourism activity, which be able to explain and
predict their results, through the practice of observation of those phenomena or
experimentation of those processes.
With the propose designing the formal conceptual framework of tourism in
accordance with the construction of a scientific hermeneutic, she should be able to
establish a dialogical relationship between observation and mathematical concepts (in
broad sense) and struggle hard to identify the phenomena that correspond to abstract
concepts, elaborated by the research in the area of tourism.” (Queirós, 2014:107)
It is obvious that the dimension of a paper should limit the research scope and the author must
circumscribe the number of axioms.
We drive the theoretical development of the article in two directions: first, to the academic
community, but also to political and economic decision-makers, seeking to demonstrate that
we are in the presence of theoretical questions of vital importance for the progress of their
governance and successful business.
Three axioms will be discussed:
_ There are emerging in the tourism market "strange phenomena", not explainable by the
traditional laws of the market, indicating the emergence of a new paradigm of tourism!?
_ Therefore, these new phenomena affect the reliability of the Tourism Satellite Account and
leads to conceptualizing new categories or types of tourism!?
_ What is the relevance of cultural tourism category in the new tourism paradigm?
Tourism has been studied as an economic activity, from its products and their businesses. But
why are travelling peoples and for what? The WTO, from a conceptual model that is based on
services and products offered by the market and in what appears to be the motivation and
purpose of the various tourist segments, created a paradigm of categories and classified their
products and activities:
Table 1. List of categories of tourism characteristic consumption products and tourism
characteristic activities
List of categories of tourism characteristic consumption products and tourism characteristic activities
Products
Activities
1. Accommodation services for visitors
1. Accommodation for visitors
2. Food and beverage serving services
2. Food and beverage serving activities
3. Railway passenger transport services
3. Railway passenger transport
4. Road passenger transport services
4. Road passenger transport
5. Water passenger transport services
5. Water passenger transport
6. Air passenger transport services
6. Air passenger transport
7. Transport equipment rental service
7. Transport equipment rental
8. Travel agencies and other
8. Travel agencies and other reservation
services
activities
9. Cultural services
9. Cultural activities
10. Sports and recreational services
10. Sports and recreational activities
11. Country-specific tourism
11. Retail trade of country-specific tourism characteristic services
goods
12. Country-specific tourism
12. Country-specific tourism
characteristic services
characteristic activities
Source: 2008 Tourism Satellite Account: Recommended Methodological Framework (TSA: RMF 2008)
4
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
This conceptualization, if appropriate to distinguish tourism services, doesn’t make easily
distinction about the products that are specifically consumed by tourists from those that are
services provided to general society, like transport and cultural offer, for example. But,
beyond that, not includes many activities that configure contemporary tourism offer and
demand, far way Cultural Tourism, as Tourism of Nature (Ecotourism), Rural Space Tourism,
Tourism of Idiom, Tourism of Congresses and Business, Tourism of Gastronomy and
Oenology, Tourism of Sea and River, Itinerant Tourism Auto-Caravan, Tourism Long-Term
Residential, School and Scientific Tourism, Sport Tourism and from Sport, Tourism of
Gaming and Entertaining.
We propose two conceptual criteria to establish different typologies of tourism:
differentiation from the categories of tourism by their specific and organic structures and by
those distinct products of tourism. (Queirós, 2007)
A conceptual approach to the categories of tourism
1. Cultural Tourism, organized by the museums and monuments and their material and
immaterial heritage and offer products (collections, visits), animation and events. Include
tourism of religion.
The collections and exhibitions of museums, from the Louvre to the Prado, monuments and
archaeological and historical sites, particularly those which are Human Heritage, festivals and
celebrations with a value of identity, in the local, regional, national or international level, as
the Theatre Classic Festival in Spain roman heritage, the celebration of Holy Week in Castilla
or religious celebrations at Portuguese Fatima sanctuary. But also the architectural value of
these structures and cultural landscapes, for instance, the Côa Valley Museum and Prehistoric
Rock Art Sites in the Côa Valley and Siega Verde, the iconic attraction capacity of the
architecture of Guggenheim Bilbao Museum or the monumental complex of the Alhambra in
Granada.
2. Tourism of Nature, or Ecotourism, structured with parks and reserves, paleontological and
nature interpretation Centres, in the context of cultural and “wild” landscapes, especially
those who are classified by UNESCO as Word Heritage, discovering geodiversity and
biodiversity, and cultural landscape diversity, offering products as observation of the birds
and protects species...
Including “Health Tourism” with Health Spa and some sports of nature, like walking,
climbing, canoeing, caving…skiing and rackets… motorised journeys ... shared with Rural
Tourism.
3. Rural (Space) Tourism, organized from farmers, villages and rural hotels, using the
products of terroir, eating, chasing, fishing… offering several “sports of nature”, like golf or
rafting… equestrian activities or hang gliding… landscape promenades… and enjoying
“functional food” (healthy food).
The accommodation at traditional home but also the discovery of humanized landscapes
(cultural landscapes, the French “terroir” concept) and/or participation in the agriculture work
cycles, associated with the “active tourism”: car rides, hikes, TT, horseback riding, hunting
and fishing, and Golf Tourism...
Unusually this typology is not applied to Golf, but, golf practice implies, as a rule, to create a
cultural landscape in the rural space not in urban or virgins landscapes, who modify
traditional landscape to news leisure functions. Golf, like tennis, will be gradually
democratized and accessible to the middle class, for the reason of their social value, which
attracts youth and promote fitness healthy and active ageing. The current breakdown among
5
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
Golf and Rural Tourism is a problem of deficient integration of tourism products in the same
destination.
Rural (Space Tourism) share products related with “Health Tourism”, sharing fresh air
activities and clean waters, woods and springs without pollution, the traditional and organic
food, but their products are very different from the Tourism of Nature: we observe the birds
on the Tourism of Nature activities and we hunt them on the Rural Tourism.
4. Tourism of Idiom, school exchanges heading for the promotion of knowledge of the
language and culture among foreigners, their holiday’s camps and programs.
5. Tourism of Congresses and Business, meetings in the form of seminars, symposia,
conferences, workshops and those social programs. International fairs and exhibitions.
6. Tourism of Gastronomy and Oenology, with their restaurants, shops, wineries and
vineyards and cellars, linked to the concept of “terroir”. Wine and gastronomy, with
particular emphasis on degustation of wine, sausage, cheese and gastronomic icons menus and
restaurants, as the Spanish El Bulli or the Portuguese, Port Wine (Vinho do Porto). Those are
the structures of tourism gastronomic and oenological, but we must include fairs and specialty
museums, festivals and related events and a new multimedia literature that won important role
in the promotion and the optimization of their market.
7. Tourism of Sea and River, with their leisure activities and characteristic sports, especially
water sports, sailing and diving, beaches inland waterways, providing the sport fishing and
boating...
The coastline also offers a wide range of products typically associated with ordinary concept
of touring; walking and boating, enjoying the sun and the sand, geological and biological
diversity and the aesthetics of landscape, the waterfront (and river) “promenades” , a tradition
that came back from the beginnings of tourism use, in the 19th century reserved to the high
class.
8. Long Term Residential Tourism, which is expanded from the coast into the interior,
involving mainly senior tourists with its old members, but also young couples with great
mobility.
9. Itinerant Tourism Auto-Caravan new practices , which corresponds to the over coming
of a new class of users of modern auto-caravan, demanding and using the infrastructures
available for cultural tourism and nature tourism, but also a new type of parks, for refueling
and waste treatment, endowed with regional information, shop and supplementary housing.
10. School and Scientific Tourism, which corresponds to the models of study visits or
finalists travels extend beyond a journey, but also associate to nature, scientific and cultural
expeditions, markedly increased by the emerging of Museum and Science Centers of the 2rd
an 3rd generation, thematic parks and the museums of industrial archaeology.
11. Sport Tourism and from Sport, considering the first as the displacement of the athletes
and their teams and the second the travel of supporters and spectators. That category includes
Olympic Games, world championship and others competitions, including professionals and
amateurs who perform regularly a sport activity.
It is obvious that some sport activities are shared with the Tourism of Nature and Rural
Tourism offer, which is the case of Golf, or sea and river leisure. His distinction type can be
6
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
made through their main motivation and “taste”: enjoy diversity of or the rural environment,
or searching a particular sport: that is the case of "white tourism” to practice sky or the
tourism groups affiliated in golf clubs to practice this sport championship.
12. Tourism of Gaming and Entertaining, organized from the casinos and thematic parks,
with their own animation.
Those categories have in common several activities, but preserve their own identity, different
organic structures and diverse products.
However, it is not easy to measure their impact in the Tourism Satellite Account.
CRITICAL FACTORS OF PARADIGM CHANGE
1. A new middle class educated and cultivated. And their importance for the
consolidation and prosperity of tourist destination
The prosperity of a region-destination must be based on the raising of the target audience of
middle-middle class and upper middle class, considering his economic relevance and social
influence capacity and her role as "modeler social consumption".
Their young people are spreading the new paradigms of cultural tourism and tourism of nature
in society and face others juveniles class groups.
And their teachers are the first vehicles for information and training of social taste and the
most important “informal tourism agents", when they promote and organize the scholar study
trips, during every studies cycles.
The weight of this middle class and their cultural level and education, emerges in parallel with
the emancipation of women by the job, a youngness increasingly educated and info educated
and the anticipation of active reform in middle-class segments, generating a change in the
category of "taste" and "motivation" of the travels.
Taking Spain as "case study", until 2008 the second market in the world, we found 87.8% of
international tourists who come to Spain with a level of income ranked among the middle
class and the upper middle class, 46.5% female tourists, 50.7% of tourists with higher studies
and 42.3% with more than 45 years.
Table 2. International Tourists, Social and demographic characteristics. 2007 and 2008
7
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
Gender
Total Tourists
Male
Female
Thousand
2007
2008
% 2008
2008/2007
57.414 55.762
100%
-2,9%
30.822 29.773
53,4%
-3,4%
26.593 25.989
46,6%
-2,3%
Age
Total Tourists
57.414 55.762
100%
-2,9%
-15 old
3.225
3.089
5,5%
-4,2%
15_24
5.507
5.587
10,0%
-4,1%
25_44
24.504 23.504
42,2%
-9,6%
45_64
19.139 18.017
32,3%
-5,9%
-64 old
5.565
5.565
10,0%
0,0%
Income level
Total Tourists
57.414 55.762
100%
-2,9%
High
2.465
2.903
5,2%
17,8%
Upper middle class
13.864
12.684
22,7%
-8,7%
Middle
37.263
37.326
65,1%
-2,5%
Low middle class
3.087
2.889
5,2%
-6,4%
Low
726
990
1,8%
36,5%
Economic Activity
Total Tourists
57.414 55.762
100%
-2,9%
Employed, middle position
33.186
30.705
55,1%
-7,5%
Entrepreneur, independent professional
8.800
8.706
15,6
-1,1%
Employed, high position
6.625
6.685
12,3%
3,9%
Employed
3.516
3.756
6,7%
6,8%
Others
5.287
5.708
10,2%
8,0%
Academic training
Total Tourists
57.414 55.762
100%
-2,9%
Primary
5.047
4.603
8,3%
-8,8%
Secondary
24.727 22.885
41,0%
-7,5%
Higher
27.641 28.274
50,7%
2,3%
Professional Status
Total Tourists
57.414 55.762
100%
-2,9%
Working
44.966 42.951
77%
-4,5%
Retired
6.883
6.815
2,2%
-0,3%
Student
3.099
3.202
5,7%
3,3%
Residents tourists
1.789
2.129
3,8%
19,0%
Unemployed
328
288
0,5%
-12,1%
Other (military service, living from rents…) 400
377
0,7%
-5,8%
Source: Movimientos en Fronteras (Frontur). IET. International border traveling. Tourism Studies Institute
(Spain)
In the year 2011, statistics show that is continuous the raising in the level of education of
international tourists arrivals to Spain: 62% with higher education, 33% with secondary
education and 5% with basic education (Egatur, 2011). The middle class with average income
stood at 60% (slight dip) and the middle-high class at the 29%, bringing together their weight
in Spain tourist destination to 89%, while the class with high income climbed slightly to 6%.
And we observed the highest rate of growth in spending of tourists seniors, 12.6%, bring them
to the top gains per capita, 1,009 €.
2. The rising of cultural tourism as mass tourism
The debate concerning ecotourism put in question the same controversy and dilemma that
occur in the field of Cultural Tourism
If we consider the definition of ecotourism from the International Ecotourism Society, which
stands for: "Responsible travelling to natural areas, where the environment is conserved
which improves the well-being of local people." (TIES, 1990), we can conclude that this
8
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
concept refers not only to a segment of tourism, tourism of nature, but it constitutes an
alternative proposal development model, based on the philosophy of nature (Ziffer, 1989).
Let´s examine their principles: “Ecotourism is about uniting conservation, communities, and
sustainable travelling. This means that those who implement and participate in ecotourism
activities should follow the following ecotourism principles:
•Minimize impact.
•Build environmental and cultural awareness and respect.
•Provide positive experiences for both visitors and hosts.
•Provide direct financial benefits for conservation.
•Provide financial benefits and empowerment for local people.
•Raise sensitivity to host countries and their political, environmental, and social climate.”
The center of the controversy led some authors to raise polemic towards the ethics of tourism
(Butcher, 2011), emphasizing particularly the contradictions between mass tourism and
ecotourism, identified as a small niche of customers, especially by its limited financial size
and inappropriate to the markets needs.
This template, justified by the identifying of the profile of the contemporary tourist with the
consumer of entire freedom and pleasure, corresponds to the hedonistic vision of philosophers
as Jeremy Bentham.
In our opinion the debate about the relationship between tourism and ethics cannot be reduced
to the controversy about ecotourism, focused as a reaction to the negative impact that the
traditional model of “sun and beach and leisure hotel” produce in the “cultural landscape”.
In recent decades new paradigms emerges and coexist in different markets and in the same
market.
In fact, Cultural Tourism or Ecotourism opposed to mass tourism lost real sense today, with
the changes that happened in the offer and demand of international tourist market and
considering the crisis of the Sun and Sea model.
Democratization and socialization of education and culture and the evolution of big markets
of the world solved some of those opposing issues: Cultural Tourism has become a mass
tourism, such as Tourism of Nature, in America, Europe and Asia. This new reality became
clear when the research on the “motivations” of tourism travelling was completed with the
research of the real activities carried out by tourists, that’s depends of their “taste”. Spanish
tourism data gives a complete statistical evaluation about tourist activities, which clearly
explains this evolution:
Consulting Table 4, the data of “Movimientos Turísticos en Fronteras (IET) _ 2008”, the
statistics about cultural tourism reveal that they represent 55% (30.665 from 55.762 thousand)
of all international tourists activities and those tourists correspond to 60% of tourism rent;
they stayed about 10,3 days, a number that exceeds the national average; return frequently,
79,6% and more than 10 times 30,5%. Didn't acquire a “vacation package” 73,4% Their main
group is among 25 and 44 years, 42,2%) and have higher education degrees 50,7% (Table 2).
(Source: IET. International border travelling. International Tourists Activities. 2007 and 2008.
Tourism Studies Institute Spain). The dominance of cultural tourism has a parallel with the
fall down of traditional activities in the beach _bar, clubs, entertainment and disco sound, but
is not in opposition; co-exist with them and with the shopping visits.
9
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
Table 4. International Tourists Activities. 2007 and 2008
Activities
Thousand
Total Tourists
1. Cultural Activities
Cultural spectacle assistance
Other cultural activities
Cultural visits
2. Recreation, discotheques, clubs…
3. Sport Activities
_Nautical sports
_Other sports
_ Walking, mountain sports
_Golf
_Adventure sports
_Ski-snow
_Hunt
4. Family visits
5. Gastronomy
6. Thematic Parks Visitation
7. Baths, SPAs, thalassotherapy
9. Sport spectacle assistance
10. No activities
2007
57.414
31.209
4.550
3.925
29.764
13.556
7.710
2.204
4.497
1.425
1.005
261
52
88
6.700
5.427
3.999
1.650
1.245
14.779
2008
% 2008
55.762
100%
30.665
55,2%
5.084
9,1%
5.196
9,3%
29.228
52,4%
13.601
24,4%
7.246
13,0%
2.422
4,3%
4.066
7,3%
1.542
2,8%
935
1,7%
231
0,4%
68
0,1%
57
0,1%
6.559
9,2%
5.582
10,0%
5.148
3,5%
1.935
1,3%
1.162
2,1%
12.904
23,1%
2008/2007
-2,9%
-1,2%
11,7%
32,4%
-1,8%
0,3%
-6,0%
9,9%
-9,6%
8,2%
-6,9%
-11,4%
-29,5%
-35,0%
2,1%
2,8%
28,7%
17,3%
-6,7%
-12,7%
Source: Movimientos en Fronteras (Frontur). IET. International border traveling. Tourism Studies Institute
(Spain). 2009
10
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
Cultural activities occupied more than half of international tourists and reveal another
phenomenon of great social and economic importance, confirmed by developments in recent
years: the rising of cultural tourism.
Table 4. Cultural tourism activities become dominant in the occupation of international
tourists in Spain
Source: ITE. Egatur 2013
On a conceptual level, the insufficiency of investigations that use only the concept of
“motivation” is the fruit of their dissociation of another concept, which should be in the heart
of empirical data collection and research, the concept of “taste”, which is associated originally
to the fields of Aesthetics and Sociology. “Ocio, Vacaciones”, Leisure and Holidays, are
concepts unclear and superficial. As we can observe, comparing the next table with the
precedent.
Table 5. Motivation for traveling of international tourists in Spain.
Source: ITE. Frontur. 2013
11
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
In the score of 86% classified as “Ocio, Vacaciones”, Leisure and Holidays, the inquire get 8,
3 million that consider the main motivation to visit Spain the discovery of their cultural
heritage. However, when we search what they really do during holidays we can find more of
31.000 millions occupied with cultural activities.
Returning the data of “Movimientos Turísticos en Fronteras (IET) _ 2008”, the broader
classification of occupational activities of tourists, need to be reformulate because is not
correct included in the same category sporting activities that requires skill and technique as
the Ski and others, like the walking, intrinsic attributes of human being. It is necessary to
disintegrate and typify categories as Others Sports, 4,066 million and visits to Thematic
Parks, 5.148 million. What kind of Parks? They are Parks of Nature, Cultural Parks,
Entertainment Parks?
We must too distinguish in this numbers, the activities that offer the Tourism of Nature,
include perhaps in the category of Sport Tourism activities.
And, the last but not the least, we don’t believe that a large percentage of tourists (almost 14.8
million) does nothing (il dolce far niente), not perform any activity; what really meaning this
response is that they have not self-awareness concerning the significance of their own rides in
the landscape, and about the existence objective of a new cultural landscape in their tourist
destination, that they can´t “read”.
We must realize that economic data of tourism don’t distinguish the contribution from these
different categories of tourism for their Value Chains.
Is time for researching the deep changing in the social base of tourism, in the context of the
society of knowledge and information: we can recognized the graduation of the new middle
class stratum, the woman emancipation, the autonomy, multiculturalism and e-learning of the
young people, the increasing of senior tourists retired, the new international mobility, with
low cost flights, modern roads, railways and large sea transports and the dissemination of
communication skills.
After 2008 in Spain, the dominant tendency to choose cultural tourism activities - visiting
museums and monuments, cultural events assistance and others - is confirmed and
consolidated: 2009: 53,5 % of international tourists; 2010, 51,3% Growing again 10% in
2011 and 5% in 2012, to 54% (Source: IET_EGATUR).
The French Louvre can be considered the great cosmologic observatory of tourism and
tourists and their metamorphosis market:
The growth of visitors: 8 413 000 in 2010 to 9.334.000 at 2013. 70% are international
tourists. 68% pay their ticket entrance.
Origin: 30% France, 70% from other countries: USA, 13%. Italy 5% and China 5%. Spain 5%
and Germany 4%, Brazil 4%, UK 4% and Russian 4%...Australia 3%...
Age: 50% young people under 30 old.
Over 14.000.000 on Louvre web site. Loading 480.000 audio guide and 103.000 mobile
application charged.
The emerging of a new middle class from China, Brasil and Russian is patent.
The growth of the museum offer, in all the countries and the development of the museum
concept can also explain this change in the demand from the middle class: “A museum is a
non-profit, permanent institution in the service of society and its development, open to the
public, which acquires, conserves, researches, communicates and exhibits the tangible and
intangible heritage of humanity and its environment for the purposes of education, study and
enjoyment.” (ICOM Statutes, adopted by the 22nd General Assembly (Vienna, Austria, 24
August 2007)
12
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
The scientific-technical revolution creates a dynamic of innovation in this sector, with the
development of the museums and science centers of 2nd and 3rd generation, design under the
sign of participation and interaction of their audiences.
The new museums using of modern technologies of restoration, conservation, information and
communication, reduce the negative impacts of mass tourism.
Looking now to the Tourism of Nature, or the ecotourism, there are no clear and accurate
statistics, but we can establish their relevance, for example, by considering the number of
visitors of Spanish national parks ( and take note that several national parks not have visitors
date) , which represent only a fraction of the tourists who seek all the parks, reserves and the
cultural landscapes of Spain: more than 10.618.284, in 2007! And more of 12.252.000 in
2010!
This phenomenon leads to the need to determine the impact of visitors on the environmental
conditions of the sites, monuments and landscapes, evaluating their load capacity: and,
consequently, promote a policy of conservation and sustainable management of heritage.
World tourism statistics confirm, since the decade of 80 of the 20th century, the growing
demand of cultural tourism on the motivations of the tourists trip, but they significance
probably has been dumb, because the methodology of the survey not include the activities
really carried out in the place of destination, and also because the research in this area does
not associate the concept of "motivation" to the concept of "taste." The first allows us to
gauge the expectations of tourists, but only the second truly informs about the products
consumed. Motivation reflects how the "trade name image" of the tourist destination is
accepted by its audiences, but it's the taste that determines ultimately the development and
evolution of products offered by their destination and it becomes essential to monitor this
development to prevent the curve of decay (Butler, 1980) and for anticipating they renewal
cycle.
3.3 The concept of Taste, from Art, Aesthetic and Sociology to the heritage and tourism
products
Critique of Art and conceptual evolution of Taste, had a parallel evolution in the last three
centuries.
Critique of the Form found a new scientific discipline, when establish in the XIX century the
principle of analysis of the art objects in their stylistic and technical context. The partiality of
historicist tendency, which reduced the art to the reconstitution of the artistic personalities of
the authors and Maecenas, artificially isolated from life and socio cultural influences, was
being surpassed by this new scientific perspective. This standpoint integrates the art in the
field of history of culture, create their own methodologies and value their contribution to the
civilization progress.
At the same time, combat prejudices against the artistic forms considered barbaric or smaller,
surpassing the not scientific distinction between classic and decay periods. This different
perspective brings to the cultural tourism new products, not only the great classic creations,
but also the art of the people, the ethnography.
This new theoretical framework open the way for formal revolution that marks the advent of
modern art and painting. In this sense, Critique of Sociology, which originally conceived the
art works as a mere reflection of society, gives a new contribute for a better understanding of
the art, through the study of economic and social conditions of the artistic process and the
establishment of historical and cultural relations between artistic techniques and social
technologies. Critique of Sociology against the positivist determinism about art, open the
fields to discover their autonomous aesthetic and cultural values.
13
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
Social and personal taste became not only a product of schools of art but the result of a
complete interaction between artists and the social dynamic of art, from the market to the
imaginary, with plural scientific and cultural conceptions.
In this field, the contributions of Marxist Critique and Critique of Psychology of Art gives
new methodologies to study the art objects that surpass sociological determinism, in the
context of the social production system, but, at same time, penetrating in the individual
indeterminism of creation process and in the aesthetic taste.
Marxist Critique accentuates the role of social tensions and cultural values of different
classes, the influence of ideology on the art social process. Using the concepts of Production
Mode and Historically Determined Social Formation, provided new tools to understand the
themes and meanings of the of the art works, and social taste.
Psychology of Art, not just behavioral psychology, but also the psychology of perception
phenomenon’s and psychoanalysis, allowed understanding the process of creation and
enjoyment of art objects, as something extremely complex, in their genesis and assimilation
by different levels of individual and social consciousness. In addition they provided a
stimulus to the birth of modern artistic currents, such as surrealism and postmodern arts, as
the informal art.
Semiotic Critique, made a new reflection about the Iconography and Iconology of images,
leading to the creation of their own methodology, particularly in the exploitation of content,
themes and meanings. The new signs found their specific identity in open meaning plans,
representations and expressions. At least, the recognition that the new artistic universe
expansion (or already in entropy?), include innumerable tendencies and idiolects, having
lowest units of meaning, artistic, anti- artistic and non-artistic currents.
International art critique, as Carlo Argan, when analyze relations between forms and sign,
placed the abandonment of representation in favor of the sign at the end of the period between
the two world wars, making clear that this issue should not be confused with the distinction
between figurative and non-figurative.
Art is Object and Other, allegory and symbol. The interpretation of things by the material
form comes from the middle ages (founded in faith) to the modern age, the Kantian
transcendental. To the art is not the instrumental character of the object that has importance.
The art work opens a world and keeps it open. The essence of aesthetic true is the disclosure
(Heidegger).
Clement Greenberg considered shallow plate painting and the monolithic of sculpture-objects,
like a revolution to finish the illusionism visual and tactile, in the context of a postmodern
continuity line dating back to Monet, which renews but maintains separate the different art
representations, in quest of neutrality, self-definition of art simply itself.
Is the end of mimesis and the coup of mercy on the traditional art, not only in the religious
aspect but in the plane of rationalism, which announced three centuries before the modernity
of Western culture. This time is completely different from the past.
The new scientific paradigm brings a revolution in art concepts and technologies. Aesthetics
changed their principles clinging desperately to the ideas of autonomy, pluralism of reading
and meaning offered by art craft and landscape, accepting the role of the observer as a partner
of the revelation of its components _ space, light, perspective, content ... in the same way, that
the role of the observer was became one of the fundamental principles of modern quantum
and relativistic physics.
The door is open to the relevance of self experience and feelings, in the context of cultural
tourism and tourism of nature. Indeed, aesthetic from art and landscape are two new elements
of the social taste of the middle class, the landscape taking not only a productive and
merchandising value, but including their own aesthetics categories: beautiful, sublime,
mysterious, wonderful, monumental, epic, tragic…And art being available to a growing
14
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
middle class with more knowledge and culture, in the museums and monuments, but also in
the cultural landscape.
The modern social taste of the middle class includes moral and ethics values face to nature
and heritage, by the influence of Environmental Philosophy in every scientific domains and
development process.
After Atenas Charter (1932) to UNESCO promoting the “World Heritage”, material and
immaterial, to the United Nations Environmental Conferences: since Stockholm (1972),
passing by Rio (1992) and Kyoto (1999), to Copenhagen, defends a new sustainable way to
our common and millenary cultures and civilizations.
The economic paradigm of traditional tourism, base in the “tourism industry” concept, can
ignore this revolution.
3.4. Predominance of air travel and the expansion of proximity airports (and ports) and
regional low cost
International tourists arrive in Spain mainly through airports-destination or airports of
proximity (less than an hour distance away the destination). This tendency was accentuated in
the last decade with the arrival by plane, in 2008, from 77.5% of tourists, 20 percent in
automobile, 2.7% by sea and only 0.2% by railways.
Table 6. The crucial importance of airports of proximity
Source: ITE. Frontur. 2009
According this table only 5,4% of international tourists that choose an initial destination do a
new trip, during the same holidays, to a second destination. The importance of airports of
proximity is crucial to promote a tourism destination.
The existence of those network of airports in Spain, together with the increased offer of
cultural tourism, were decisive factors to halt the fall in the number of tourists and to increase
15
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
their added value, especially increasing low-cost flights (low coast). According to records of
Aeropuertos Españoles y Navegación Aérea (AENA), the Spanish airports received in 2012,
63.1 million international passengers. Of which 58.5% travelled by low cost companies.
In the year of 2011, arrived in Portugal 12.2 million passengers of international flights (+ 966
thousand, representing 57%) and 830 cruises with 1,149 .1 thousand passengers, an increase
of 79 cruises and nearly 152 thousand passengers. The flights low cost predominate in Faro,
74.3% and 60.2% in Oporto. Your weight in Lisbon is relevant, reaching 14.4% and 13.5% in
Madeira.
3.5. Expansion of Internet and cyber culture and decline of "packages"
Standing again in the Spanish market, the graphic representation documents the growing
importance of info technologies and networks that the Internet propitious (65% using
Internet), for tourist information (Consulta), but also to reserve (Reserva)_ transport,
accommodation, activities and made payments (Pago).
Table 7. The three functions of the Internet, on the perspective of tourism demand:
information, reserve and payments
Source: ITE. Egatur. 2013
From the analogical information to cyber culture, the universal pass-word is the dominant
tendency in our time: tourism destinations needs be structured with the modern structure of
fiber-optic and broadband Internet, as vital condition for tourism development.
16
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
Table 8. Decline of packages
Source: ITE. Egatur. 2013
Within the framework of the society of information and knowledge, the demand for personal
programmes of visits, independently selected, prevail above the packages. International
tourists traveling to Spain without package (Sin paquete) are 69%
At same time the search for information, reservation and payment via Internet and the various
info technologies, tends to prevail over travel agencies traditional services.
Travel agencies need to search for new degrees of specialization and qualification of their
products.
The entities that compose the structure the Value Chains of tourism must pass from analogical
culture to digital culture, both integrated in their offer.
3.6. Functional inversion of the relationship between Chains Values and Heritage
Chains Values of tourism_ accommodation, catering, merchandising, animation, transport,
guides and agencies needs to incorporate new products and even other values and what its
historical relationship with the heritage (s)?
For many years hotels was the main from tourism attraction. What's changed since then?
Taken a as the variable of the accommodation and p the variable which represents the
patrimony (cultural heritage and natural heritage). In the past p=f(a).
The mathematic law is based on the correlation between a and p, univocal correspondence in
the direction a → p. We say that the variable p is a function of the variable of a and we write
symbolically p = f (a), which mean that a is the independent variable and p the dependent
variable.
In the field of mathematics, rigorously, each value of p corresponds one value of a; but, in the
tourist market, the same monument, site or landscape is accessibility from the existence of
several hotels, relatively close.
However, what result from the appearing of a new middle class cultured, from the
emancipation of work women, a new young generation increasingly educated and the
anticipation of active retire in growing segments of the middle class, is a change of taste and
motivation in travel, resulting in a functional inversion in the variables p=f(a).
Currently a = f (p), the majority of hotel units, uniforms in those architecture and services,
cease to be the center of tourism attraction, tending to become dependent in their functional
market area from the existence of heritage values, well preserved, attractive and accessible.
17
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
This new relationship transform accommodation on a variable dependent from heritage and
makes imperative the resolution of the conflict of interest between the construction of tourist
infrastructures and the preservation of the natural heritage and cultural heritage.
3.7. The predominance of income from the tourists face the income of excursionists
The supremacy of tourism income from international tourists balanced with the expense of
excursionists can be illustrated using again the Spanish market
Table 9. Spending tourists and excursionists compared board in Spain.2008.
Economic framework of international tourism in Spain 2008
Tourists
Excursionists
57,3 millions_58,6%.
40,5 millions_41,4%
Income: 51.897 millions €_91,2%.
Incomes: 4.455 millions €_8,8 %
Average expenditure: 907 €/9,2 nights.
Average expenditure: :101 €
Source: IET Source: ITE. Egatur. 2009
Observing the Table 10 we can see that increasing productivity of the tourism activity
depends substantially from on our ability to transform the excursionist segment in new
tourists, because tourists income is 10 time higher from excursionists income.
Em 2012 a Espanha recebeu 57,7 milhões de turistas, que permaneceram naquele país uma
noite ou mais e 41,5 milhões de excursionistas, os viajantes que não pernoitam.
In 2012 Spain received 57.7 million international tourists, who remained in that country for a
night or more and 41.5 million excursionists, travelers who do not spend the night.
Table 10: Income from tourists and excursionists, series 2004-2012, in Spain
Source: ITE. Egatur. 2013
3.8. A strange competition: Creating scale. Giving priority to cooperation: cross-border,
interregional and inter municipality cooperation
The new tourist products, from Cultural Tourism and Tourism of Nature, as merchandise that
they are, have an added value and an exchange value, comparable to common goods.
However, the products of Cultural Tourism and Tourism of Nature in the market competition
18
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
have a strange behavior. This competition, for differentiation, generates complementary and
cooperative networks, without exclusion of the competitor.
Indeed, the tourist consumer of Cultural Tourism and Tourism of Nature products tends to
visit all the museums and monuments, different protected areas and cultural landscapes and
not to settle unique a product, or icon or mark.
But the concentration of organic structures of Cultural Tourism and Tourism of Nature at a
specific location, for example Paris, focus 80% of international tourism to the France capital.
Louvre becomes a microcosm of the world tourism. The same phenomena in Madrid or
London…
From the expansion of low-cost flights, all cultural destinations are competing among
themselves and if a city or municipality wants to become a pole of attraction, must consider
the cooperation with neighbors, cities and regions, to create scale in the competition with the
consolidated tourism destinations. They need to organize common Routes and Circuits
justifying at least a journey visit (a day and one night) and several journeys crossing their
territory.
3.9. The reorganization of tourism offer based on the concepts (scientific and technical)
of Route and Circuit, oriented to international tourism
In the framework of phenomenological conceptualization of tourism are predominant linear or
two-dimensional definitions. To familiarize the reader with another type of definition, which
we call circular or multidimensional in their relational dialectic, we depart from the concept of
heritage drawn up by engineer Vasco Costa, at the time Chief Executive Officer of DGEMN_
Direção Geral dos Edifícios e Monumentos Nacionais ( General Direction of Buildings and
National Monuments) de Portugal.
Figure 1. Concept of heritage
19
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
"Visually put the accent on the idea, for us obviously, that this system, articulated as a set of
databases interoperable is constituted as the key piece for any action and qualitative
intervention in safeguarding and enhancement of heritage, in compliance with the
internationally accepted concepts and normative.
We believe that the achievement of a global society, in economic terms and in lifestyle, will
lead to the improvement of cultural diversity.” (Costa, 2008)
The concepts of Tourist Circuits and Routes are based on the need to use a scientific
methodology, based on an inter- and multi-discipline, to interpret and organise the visit to the
territory, which allows the tourists to read and interpret their cultural landscapes.
This conception lead to a philosophy born in the observation and reading of the landscape and
from the synthesis of Earth and Human Being that dwells and transforms the 'cultural
landscape', but at the same time threatening to degrade or destroy. That contradiction justifies
the need for an ethics of tourism, built from the new Environmental Ethics and based on the
critic of anthropocentrism and ethnocentrism.
We define “tourist Circuit as a road integrating all heritage products, short-lived (should not
exceed one day/night), accessible to all audiences but segmented in an autonomous and
distinctive identity, organized in the context of discovery and enjoyment of the landscape
ecology (in the sense of interdisciplinary contribution to reading the landscape) and the
metaphysics of landscape (immaterial heritage, imaginary erudite and popular), and using the
20
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
communication/emotional principle of "montage of attractions", created to sustain and
develop value chains of tourist activity.”(Queirós, 2009)
We define “tourist Route as an organized set of Circuits to discover and enjoy all heritages,
with a unique identity, based on ecology and landscape metaphysics, accessible to all
audiences but with different products according their segments, organized to serve the
development of tourist activity and their value chains.” (Queirós, 2009)
This new concept is built upon the conceptual contributions of geography, selective
observation and significant description of the cultural landscape - its historical, natural,
ethnographic heritage; the philosophy of nature and the philosophy of the environment,
“ecology and metaphysics of landscape"; communication sciences, involving the psychology
of feels and the cinema (the montage of attractions is a concept from Eisenstein); economy,
“value chains”. And its methodological construction consists in recycle traditionally concepts
used in another scientific fields and reprocess them to a new subject of study
THE FOUR DIMENSIONS OF THE CONCEPT OF TOURISM
Cultural landscape
Ecotourism is about conserving the “natural areas”, which improves the well being of local
people. We remain in the field of the anthropocentrism if not responding to the question what
is the definition of “natural areas?”
Central conceptual terms, such as ‘culture’, ‘nature’ or ‘cultural landscape’, are far from being
neutral scientific objects. They are academic constructions, which need to be understood as
they emerge across their historical contexts.
The landscape concept, born in IV China century and in the Western Renaissance centuries, it
means a sensitive and symbolic cultural view, a different collective subjectivity from the high
classes, engaged in an aesthetical contemplation and the peasants, that occupies and transform
the land, in the struggle for life.
Augustin Berque, concerning landscape, developed the concepts of Écoumène (1993) and
trajection (trajectivity), representing the interactive relationship between culture and nature,
between the collective and the individual, and between subjectivity and objectivity in actual
societies in Europe and in Japan.
Re-thinking nature and landscape means that every landscape is a human artifact, the
historical human presence brings certain values to the landscape, not only the positive
categories of beauty experiences in nature and new biotopes but also the negative categories
and the extinction of species: the disgusting, the ugly, the repulsive, the abhorrent... In a
moral and esthetical perspective we must recognize that “if such practices also offend our
sensibility; that is, they have aesthetic as well as moral consequences”. (Berleant, 2011).
This new vision of the landscape, multi and interdisciplinary, which is at the same time an
instrument operating its hermeneutics and a category in the field of Philosophy of Nature, is
named:
Landscape ecology. In our definition it represents a structural and systemic view that
encompasses the large natural landscape, characterized and differentiated not only by
the various fields of science (environmental sciences and exact sciences), but also but
also social sciences because it was created with the help of Man in his daily effort as
a farmer, a shepherd and a landscape architect. (Queirós, 2003, 2013: 108 a)
But the interpretation of the landscape, from the perspective of the philosophy of nature and
the environment philosophy, would be incomplete without the use of another category of
elements, which we define as:
21
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
Metaphysics of landscape. It represents the domain of the "spirituality", "soul" of
things, the categories of aesthetic emotions and feelings, "beauty" and "beautiful", the
"sublime", "wonderful" and "mysterious", “monumental”, "epic" and "tragic."
(Queirós, 2003, 2013:110 a)
Including the negative categories: the disgusting, the ugly, the repulsive, the abhorrent...
Categories parallel-aesthetics in the field of tourism
A simple question, what constitutes a tourist resource?, becomes a more complex problem. In
our opinion, what constitutes a tourism resource is the humanized cultural landscape (urban
and rural landscape). Reading and interpreting the cultural landscape is the basis for the
creation of the tourism products and its first metamorphosis of value.
The ecology of the landscape (material heritage) and the metaphysics of landscape
(immaterial heritage), compose the essence of tourism resource, but only and when their
interpretation and reading gives it a new increase as a cultural value and as an economic
value.
The human’s labor on the land change and rebuilt the landscape, creating new biotopes and
destroying biodiversity, geodiversity and traditional cultures, but also creating new landscape
cultural values:
“We can find in the landscape a set of categories that we call “parallel-aesthetics”,
carrying an intrinsic moral value and touristic attraction capacity: "the unique",
setting this concept as susceptible to express the landscape attributes of an uncommon
Place. ”The single” define the own identity of a common landscape object. "The
authentic” attribute applicable to the conservation of objects and original landscape
contexts. "The genuine and rare", objects and Places of Humanized landscape, that in
its process of evolution tend to disappear or become corrupt… And the “Systemic
Parallel-Aesthetics Categories” (Queirós, 2013: 109 a).
Systemic because concerning types of landscape, as riparian vegetation, chestnut forest, cork
forest, “paysage du bocage” (bocage landscape), grasslands, heathlands…
Capital of tourism: genesis of value, reproduction and circulation
The concept of “tourism industry" has led to search for local resources - biological and
geological, livestock and forestry, etc. as their basic material. In fact the first are used and
processed by other industries, and in many cases require its conservation. And as for the
second, its consumption is shared between residents and travellers.
What constitutes a tourist resource is the cultural landscape. Reading and interpretation of the
cultural landscape is the basis for the creation of the tourist product and its first
metamorphosis of value.
It’s the “ecology of the landscape” (material heritage) and its “metaphysics of landscape”
(immaterial heritage), which constitute the essence of tourist resource, but only when their
interpretation and reading gives it a new increase in cultural and economic value,
transforming use value on in a exchange value:
The landscape is not an open book, intelligible empirically. Their transformation into
a tourist product goes through its readability, which gives it a used value; it’s a
22
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
metamorphosis that generates economy value, and it’s also a process of cultural
literacy, mediated by the construction of a language for tourist communication; the
result of this process changes the shape and the essence of traditional concepts of
resources and tourist products. (Queirós, 2013: 109 a)
The paradox of the new economy of tourism
.
The new functional relationship a = f (p), accommodation is a mathematic function
depending from heritage, establish that are Routes and Circuits, integrating all the heritage,
which attract tourists from middle and upper class, generating the main values of tourism
activities.
However they're not the structures that organize these Routes and Circuits, the museums,
monuments and parks that collect the highest values; the tourism income is collected outside
the structures of Cultural Tourism and Tourism of Nature on the aforementioned value chains:
accommodation, catering, shopping and merchandising, animation, transport, freight
forwarding and animation. It is the phenomenon of positive externalities.
The misunderstanding of this economic paradox is the cause of the historical conflict between
tourism and development, but is also at the same time the key to overcome it.
We must built new economic tools to enquire the real economic impact of Cultural Tourism
and Tourism of Nature.
Then, the growth of competitiveness of the tourism economy destination will result mainly
from the ability to organize their Routes and Circuits, which gradually enlarge the current
urban attraction poles, giving a dynamic visit regional, inter-regional and even cross-border.
Routes and circuits promotes the passage of the economic status of excursionist into tourist,
growing time of permanence and the desire/need to return, surpassing the seasonality and
encourages the consumption of quality, increasing productivity.
In this new context is imperative planning and organizing tourism to transform the
excursionist in tourist, taking into account the concepts here synthesized of Externalities,
Competitiveness and Productivity
THE NEW PARADIGM: ENVIRONMENTAL TOURISM
Environmental Tourism, in our concept and in the synthesis of Philosophy, is really the
integration of nature and culture in the concept of landscape, and their metamorphosis in
Cultural Tourism and Tourism of Nature (Ecotourism). Environmental Tourism includes
material and immaterial patrimony, physical an metaphysical values ( aesthetical and ethical
values).
However, this perspective of tourism as an economic phenomenon, but also anthropological
and socio-cultural, conduce to a third dimension, historic and politic. In the national heritage
and social consciousness of humanity and in their collective unconscious, is recorded the
journey of the early hominid crossing the Mediterranean from Africa, passing the Bosporus
and journeying to America and the Arctic polar ice; the memory of the first hunter-gatherers
who followed the march of the rivers and valleys open by tectonics of Earth; lather builders of
“dolmen and menhirs”, which limited the journey to surrounding agricultural and pasturing
lands, in a eternal return; already in the modern age, navigators and explorers from all corners
of the planet, with the birth of capitalism and those successive globalizations.
After be created political and social conditions, with the advent of modern democracies and
socialisms, the conquest of social leisure by new social classes, and the containment of war,
all the humanity continue his historic walk and made global world the place of trampling of
human animal.
23
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
Involving the others three dimensions, we arrive to a fourth dimension of human being, in the
perspective of the philosophy of nature and the environment philosophy: the human being
separate from Nature and distinct human cultures by the anthropocentric and ethnocentric
conceptions, has a common origin and belong to the same and single Human family.
And stay ecologically linked to the biological, geological and cosmological environment,
connect to all beings and things.
Contemporary Ethology do the demonstration that the ability to feel pain and pleasure is not
unique attribute of Man, and also the intelligence or even the ability to work and the making
of their tools, such as the social labor, are common to other species. But the aesthetic feeling
and taste, not only to artistic creation but also to the relationship with the nature, seem to be
exclusive attributes of descendants of the homo sapiens sapiens. Maybe the tourist of the
working classes, in short holidays, or the financial speculator in business trip, doesn't
distinguish the” beautiful” from the “sublime”, two categories of aesthetics fields, but none of
these human beings can ignore the presence of these values in the landscape, even their
reaction could be the silence, the human silence of those who contemplate the mystery or the
wonderful.
And we got four dimensions of the tourism concept.
From this perspective, that is beyond economic and traditional definitions, we must to study
and research the phenomenology of tourism as a strange economy, a process of socio-cultural
anthropology and also in their historic-political conditions; finally, in the new framework of
environmental philosophy and their environmental ethics ….
Ethics and Tourism. The philosophical approach
The authors involved in the research of Ethics and Tourism, propose three ethical paradigms
with particular relevance to that area: the Aristotelian paradigm of virtue ethics, eudaimonia;
the Kantian paradigm of the categorical imperative respect for the person and the paradigm of
the utilitarian ethics of the greatest good (Jamal and Menzel 2011).
They scientific and ethical approach is humanist: “Ethics should be an expression of what it
means to be a human…we are ethical beings by nature (Fennell, 2009:211)”, what mean an
anthropocentric perspective, and their studies object it is the “tourism industry”, the
sustainable tourism.
The outlook of environmental ethics is systemic; man is not in the center of their values. In
the perspective of environmental ethics, each human activity, including tourism activities,
may accept the prevalence of the “ biotic community and non-biotic community”, the Land
Ethic with their values, in the sense of philosophy, Ethics and Aesthetics.
“Land use ethics are still governed wholly by economic self-interest, just as social
ethics were a century ago.” (Leopold, 1947: 245)
In the last century, moral reflection has turned itself to a new object: the environment. The
philosophical synthesis concept of environment is culture more nature.
Nature shall be included in our field of moral reflection, our duties, which were previously
limited to human beings, and will now be extended to other natural beings - the concept of an
enlarged community of natural beings. That is the perspective of the critique to the
anthropocentrism. The second principle of the Environmental Philosophy is the critical
perspective toward the ethnocentrism:
"Ethnocentrism is an emotionally conditioned approach that considers and judges
other societies by their own culture’s criteria. It’s easy to see that this attitude leads to
24
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
contempt and hate of all ways of life that are different from that of the observer. "
(Dias, 1961)
The critique of ethnocentrism not only justifies the respect for all national cultures and all
forms of classical and popular cultural expression, but also rejects any notion of superiority
from a certain model of society, race or ethnicity.
In this sense, it expands the concept of products of cultural goods far beyond the great
museums, master oeuvres, classic heritage… including cultural landscape.
The "environmental reason" formulates a new categorical imperative for human action,
beyond the Kant maximum of forming individual ethics of acts with the principle of a
universal law, a new ethical framework, which stems from the need to configure the human
conduct within the limits that safeguard the continuity of life and its diversity (Hans Jonas).
Tourism is not only an economic activity, a new “industry” and perhaps its growing economic
importance is inseparable from some of the most profound sociological and political change
that marked the 20th century, the growth of middle class and the institutionalization of
democratic rights of citizens, but also an even more radical change, the repositioning of the
human being promote by the Environmental Philosophy and their Environmental Ethical’s.
The Global Code of Ethics for Tourism, adopted in 1999 by the General Assembly of the
World Tourism Organization, its acknowledgement by the United Nations two years later
expressly encouraged the Organization to promote effective follow-up of its provisions.
Although not legally binding, the Code features a voluntary implementation mechanism
through its recognition of the role of the World Committee on Tourism Ethics (WCTE), to
which stakeholders may refer matters concerning the application and interpretation of the
document. (UNWTO, 2012)
The actuality of the principles set out by the Global Code of Ethics for Tourism, does not
mean that we can not put into question its vagueness and generality. They need to be
confronted with world tourism developments in recent decades, in the perspective of the
environmental crisis that affects our present and future and refocused in the context of the
paradigm of Environmental Philosophy and their Ethics. It is necessary developed the
Tourism Code of Ethics and promote their implementation into the professional stakeholders,
business and public administration.
Tourism concept
The dialectical relationship between Tourism Scientific Corpus and their social status and
functions configure this corpus as the modern Ecology: the best way to delimit the modern
tourism might be consider him in terms of the concept of levels of organization, viewed as a
kind of «spectrum of cultural tourism and tourism of nature» … irradiating a new synergistic
energy.
Cultural Tourism and Tourism of Nature are in the center of the spectrum, representing their
core business; from this center we can found a complex dialectical network with several
levels of organizations: organic, economic, socio-cultural, political… structured as
ecosystems autonomous, but, linked one to each one .
The best definition could be the more sample: Environmental Tourism,
25
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
Figure 2: The new paradigm: Environmental Tourism
New
productive
sectors
Congress and Business
Tourism. Tourism of
Idiom. Tourism of Sea and
River. School and
Scientific Tourism.
SportTourism and from
Sport. Tourism of Gaming
and Entertaining
Monuments,
sites, museums,
Human Heritage,
cultural
celebrations
Structures
Research and
training. Heritage
conservation and
enhancement
Information and
Cybernetic Culture
Strategic
planning.
Synergies
upstream
Cultural
Tourism
Tourism of
Nature
(Ecotourism)
New
productive
sectors
Tourism
Gastronomic and
Oenological.
Tourism AutoCaravan.
Long-term
Residential Tourism
Organics
Parks and reserves,
paleontological
sites, humanized
landscapes
(cultural)
baths
Core business
Rural Tourism:
Golf and nature
sports, health
Strategic
Synergies.
Downstream
infrastructures
tourism
Sustainable territory
organization,
agriculture, forest, and
livestock.
Accessibilities and
regional airports,
Network of info
technologies
Sector
restructuring
Accommodation,
Restaurants,
Guides,
Merchandising
Animation
Travel Agencies
Transport
Traditional
Sector, needing
restructuration
26
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
CONCLUSION
Accurate
Tourism isn't only an economic activity, and perhaps their growing economic importance is
inseparable from some of the most profound sociological and political changes that sign the
twentieth century:
The growth of the educated middle class and their mobility, facilitated by the formidable
scientific-technical revolution, the woman emancipation by the employment, the
institutionalization of the democratic rights of citizens, the contention of the war.
But also an even more radical change, the repositioning of the human being face to face
Nature and inside Nature, made by the Philosophy of Nature and Environment and their
Environmental Ethical’s, if tourist activity have conscience or not, blindly by the appearance
of economic expansion and uninterrupted success over the past fifty years, marked by
empiricism and reducing tourism as an economic activity.
Together, those new phenomenon constitute critical factors of paradigm change.
Consistent and Simple
Our research way could conclude, about the concepts of Cultural Tourism and Tourism of
Nature (Ecotourism) that are organic and productive branch of a new tourism model or
paradigm.
Cultural Tourism and Tourism of Nature (Ecotourism) offers are composed by material and
immaterial products incorporating in the levels of planning, design, organization and
promotion, contents and materials from the domain of culture and scientific culture and
heritage.
The scientific substance of Cultural Tourism, are the Museum and Heritage Sciences.
The scientific core of the Tourism of Nature (Ecological Tourism), are the Environmental
Sciences and Cultural landscapes.
However Cultural Tourism and Tourism of Nature (Ecotourism) offer must be adjusted to the
dynamics and the objectives of the tourism economy, in the framework of the management of
their Value Chains.
Throughout the research process, studying competitiveness, productivity and sustainability,
we set focal point on the debate around the concepts of Cultural Tourism and Tourism of
Nature (Ecotourism), their Routes and Circuits, the "Rosetta Stone" of the question.
Freeing those concepts from the arbitrarily and subjectivity, constitute, the key to build and
sustain the tourist destinations, and the element aggregator of a new philosophy of tourism.
Broad Scope and Fruitful
In our perspective and in the viewpoint of Philosophy, the core of the new paradigm,
Environmental Tourism, is the integration of the diversity of nature and culture, shaped on
the cultural landscape and their metamorphosis in Cultural Tourism and Tourism of Nature
(Ecological), linked to the others branches of tourism activities (12 categories or types of
tourism )
Finally, this perspective considers that tourism have a singular economic, a second dimension
anthropological and socio-cultural, conducing to a third dimension, historical and political.
And is determinate by a four dimension, the reintegration of the human being in Nature
without any privilege, providential destiny and supremacy, the critical cosmovision from the
environment philosophy and environmental ethics ( with aesthetic values).
27
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
REFERENCES
Papers
Berleant, A. (2011) Changing Landscapes, Keynote lecture at “Transition Landscapes/
Paysages en Transition,” International Conference, Lisbon, Portugal
Berque, Augustin (1993).”L’écoumène, mesure terrestre de L’Homme, mesure humaine de la
Terre: pour une problématique du monde ambiant”, L’espace géographique 4. (pp. 299-305)
Butler, R.W. (1980) The Concept of a Tourist Area Cycle of Evolution: Implication for
management of resources, Canadian Geographer.
Gil, F. (2007) Algumas Reflexões Sobre Instituições Museais Científicas, Contributo Para O
Debate Nacional Sobre Educação, Visionarium_Vila da Feira, mc2p.
Queirós, A. (2013) Fields of Demeter: the impossibility of separating the science, ethics and
aesthetics in the hermeneutics of the landscape. In Revue Philosophica nº 40. Department of
Philosophy of FLUL. ISSN: 0872-4784.
Queirós, A. (2014). Cultural Tourism and Economy of the Heritage. In Journal of Tourism
and Development. University of Aveiro. ISSN: 1645-9261 (pp. 107-117)
Books
Action Plan for the Human Environment. B.5. Development and Environment. United
Nations Conference on the Human Environment A/CONF.48/14/Rev.1 -June 1972
Stockholm, Sweden.
Berleant, A. (2004) The Aesthetics of Natural Environments. Co-edited with Allen Carlson
Peterborough, Ontario: Broadview
Caraça, B. (2003) Conceitos Fundamentais da Matemática. Lisboa, Gradiva.
Costa, C. (1996) Towards the Improvement of the Efficiency and Effectiveness of Tourism
Planning and Development at Regional Level: Planning, Organizations and Networks, The
case of Portugal. University of Surrey.
Dias, J. (1961) Estudos de Antropologia, Volume I, Uma introdução histórica à etnografia
portuguesa. Lisboa: Imprensa Nacional-Casa da Moeda.
Dubos, R. ( 1973) Les Dieux de l’écologie, trad. fr.. Paris: Librairie Arthème Fayard.
Espinosa, B. (1960) Ética. Demonstrada à maneira dos geómetras. Parte I. De Deus.
Introdução e Notas de Joaquim Carvalho. Atlântida Editora. Coimbra.
28
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
Heidegger, M. (1977). Der Ursprung des Kunstwerkes, in Holzwege, “Gesamtausgabe”, Band
5, Frankfurt am Main, Vittorio Klostermann.
Johannesburg Declaration on Sustainable Development. World Summit on Sustainable
Development A/CONF.199/20 September 2002 Johannesburg, South Africa
Jonas, Hans (1984) The Imperative of Responsibility. In Search of an Ethics for the
technological Age. Chicago. Chicago & London, The University of Chicago Press.
Lakatos, Musgrave ed. (1970). Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
Leopold, A. (1949) A Sand County Almanac. New York: Oxford University Press.
Kotler, N. and P. Kotler (1998) Museum Strategy and Marketing. San Francisco: Josey-Bass
Kuhn, T.S. (1962) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago
Press.
Spinoza, B. (1988) Éthique. Texte original et traduction nouvel par Bernard Pautrat. Paris :
Éditions Seul
Swarbrooke, (2002), Sustainable Tourism Management, New York: CABI Publishing.
Ziffer, K.A. (1989) Ecotourism: The Uneasy Alliance. Washington DC: Conservation
International.
Book chapters
Butcher, J. (2011) Against Ethical Tourism. Philosophical Issues in Tourism. Edited by John
Tribe. Bristol: Channel View Publications. (pp. 244-260)
Fennell, D. (2011) Ethics and Tourism. Philosophical Issues in Tourism, Edited by John
Tribe. Bristol: Channel View Publications (pp. 211-226)
Jamal and Menzel (2011). Philosophical Issues in Tourism. Edited by John Tribe. Bristol:
Channel View Publications. ( -0)
Queirós, A. (2013a) “A new alliance, environnemental tourisme and cultural landscape”. In
Landscape and Imagination, Towards a new baseline for education in a changing world.
Paysage et Invention. Evolution des enseignements dans un monde en transition.
UNISCAPE. Bandecchi&Vivaldi, Florence ISBN 978-88-8341-548-7 (pp. 107-112).
Queirós, A. (2013) Manual of philosophy and Landscape Architecture. A handbook.
Coordination of Adriana Veríssimo Serrão. "Landscape tourism". Edition CFUL. ISBN 978989-8553-12-6. (pp. 177-187)
Queirós, A. (2013) The economy and ecology of heathlands. “Cultural agents of change and
the sunset of environmental services”. And “Old farming mountain systems”. Published by
29
International Journal of Scientific Management and Tourism, 2015, Vol.2 pp 179-215 dos Santos Queirós, A.
:CULTURAL TOURISMON A CHANGING PARADIGM
Alterra (Wageningen-UR (University and Research Centre). INBO (Belgium) KNNV
Publishing. Neederland. ISBN 978-90-5011-4615. Pages 49-50. (pp. 31-48)
Internet reference
Internet Sources accessed in 03.02.2015
Encuesta
de
Gastos
Turísticos
(EGATUR),
Instituto
de
Estudios
Turisticos,
www.iet.tourspain.es
Informação Estatística, www.ine.pt
ICOM, http://archives.icom.museum/definition.html
La fréquentation du musée du Louvre. Chiffres clés 2015 http://www.louvre.fr/rapports
La Gestión en la Red de Parques Nacionales. Ministerio de Medio Ambiente.
http://reddeparquesnacionales.mma.es
EROSKI CONSUMER http://parquesnaturales.consumer.es/
Movimientos Turísticos de los Españoles (FAMILITUR), Instituto de Estudios Turisticos,
www.iet.tourspain.es
Statistics & Economic, Measurement of Tourism http://www.world-tourism.org/
www.iet.tourspain.es
30