Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Year book Ma '15 thesis dwelling supervision EDV.pdf

Two master thesis dealing with the topic of housing are presented shortly in this Graduates Master Book of 2015. The first is of Elise Jacops, dealing with 1970s social housing projects of Alvaro Siza, the second of Kim Van Pelt, dealing with neighbouring houses in Antwerp which strongly contrast in architectural style.

Facult y Of Design S ciences 2015 G R A D UAT E S ARCHITECTURE G R A D UAT E S 2015 Universit y Of Ant werp HOUSING AND THE DOMESTIC SPACE Architecture Graduates 2015 SUPERVISOR STUDENTS ELS DE VOS ELISE JACOPS CO–SUPERVISOR KIM VAN PELT FATIMA POMBO Architecture Graduates 2015 IN BELGIUM AND PORTUGAL ‘I sometimes feel the need to write, so I write. […] When I think about Architecture, I always take my example from writers, and in particular from the Poets, the most skilled inventors of register and sound, the inhabitants of solitude.’ — ÁLVARO SIZA VIEIRA In addition to a Master’s design project, some students also choose to write a Master’s thesis in order to investigate a certain topic in detail. One central theme concerns the interdisciplinary ield of the home, the domestic sphere and the housing environment. The home is an extremely luid and contested site of human existence that relects and reiies identities and values, values related to nationality, social class, interests. By means of their home, and especially the style of the facade, inhabitants express something of their own identity or that which they want to display to others. At the same time, the acquisition of a home is not a completely rational process – a certain contingency emerges. The neighbourhood, the distance from work, etc., inluence the decision to buy a certain house. In this regard, Kim Van Pelt scrutinised a number of pairs of houses in the broad region of Antwerp which stood in various contrasts to each other. In studying these pairs of houses, whose style can roughly be labelled as classical versus modern, she revealed what the styles meant for their inhabitants and how they were perceived. Elise Jacops was more interested in the macro scale. She studied three Portuguese housing projects designed by Alvaro Siza. After framing them in their political and historical context, she showed how the houses are the result of an intelligent combination of the Portuguese vernacular with modernist projects. | 146 | | 147 | Housing and the domestic space in Belgium and Portugal Introduction Housing and the domestic space in Belgium and Portugal NATHALIE VALLET ELISE JACOPS VERNACULARISATION IN THREE PORTUGUESE SOCIAL HOUSING-PROJECTS Housing and the domestic space in Belgium and Portugal Some of the most interesting and best works created under SAAL are three speciic neighbourhoods of differing scale designed by the architect Álvaro Siza: São Victor (Porto/Figures 2 and 3), Bouça (Porto/Figure 3) and Quinta da Malagueira (Évora/Figures 4, 5, 6). On this basis, I will examine vernacularisation in Portugal using a qualitative approach, namely a literature review and a study of experiences on site. It was through Álvaro Siza that I irst came to the notion of vernacularisation. The critic Kenneth Frampton attributed the origin of the architectural movement known as ‘Critical Regionalism’ to Siza’s architecture of the 1970s. In his essay, ‘Towards a Critical Regionalism: Six Points for an Architecture of Resistance’, written in the early 1980s, he discussed: The hallmark of this critical movement is that, on the one hand, the universal aspects of modern architecture are partially applied while, on the other hand, there is a quest to bond with the context. Vernacularisation appears to be an important theme in the Portuguese architecture of the 1970s. Social housing before the 1970s is often synonymous with the stereotypical image of anonymity or the lack of a collective identity. Can the design strategy of vernacularisation deliver character and quality to projects? ‘Vernacularisation’ is an architectural term that refers to a process of recording local elements, such as building techniques, built forms and materials used in a speciic location. Therefore, in its essence vernacularisation is an expression of loyalty to local traditions and regional diversity. It is an outcome of the inluence of historical, social and cultural processes, which involves observing a method for the treatment and preservation of space. A study of landscape and context and the new relationship between both is required. By referencing local archetypes, vernacularisation provides the basis for the creation of new architecture. Furthermore, vernacularisation is considered to be an important factor in addressing the immediate impact of architecture on the collective identity of the inhabitants. It is this new approach to architecture that will ultimately allow the inhabitants to maintain their connection with the location, the architecture and each other. Summerroom — Quinta da Malagueira | 149 | › › › › › | 148 | Culture and civilisation The rise and fall of the avant-garde Critical regionalism and world culture The resistance of the place-shape Culture versus nature: topography, context, climate, light and tectonic shape › Visual versus the tactile Housing and the domestic space in Belgium and Portugal Architecture Graduates 2015 Based on my fascination with Portuguese regional architecture (Figure 1) and an interest in how ‘collective identity’ is created in social housing, I decided to investigate some of the achievements of SAAL (Serviço Ambulatório de Apoio Local, the Portuguese service for social housing) during the economically and politically critical years of the 1970s. In the recent history of social housing, SAAL presents us with one of the most interesting and unique development processes. Among other things, SAAL entailed the innovative involvement in and commitment of residents to development, which also relied on the cooperation and willingness of engineers from across the country and the participation of the SAAL architects. Architecture Graduates 2015 FROM ALVARO SIZA DURING THE SEVENTIES Summerroom — Évora, vernacular context KIM VANPELT From this view, different questions arise about the personal interpretation of the terms ‘modern’ and ‘classical’, the reasons for relocating, the requirements that should be fulilled by the home and its surroundings, the importance of the style in the choice made and different attitudes towards a variety of architectural styles. Although my research question is not a primary or acute problem for today’s society, it demonstrates the importance of the bond between the occupant and their home. In other words, while it is not in the least a current subject of controversy, it is nonetheless one that is worthy of investigation. For my research I went looking for images similar to those of Van den Boom, but located in the districts of Antwerp (Photos 2, 3 and 4). These images are not only expressive, but also possess a certain neutrality, with subjective opinions about the ugliness or beauty of a property left for the reader to decide. The decision to focus on such typical cases was one thing, while determining the research question was quite another. To unravel the spectrum of possible inluences, I initiated in-depth interviews with the residents and systematically collected photos and plans of the buildings. The material gathered from the interviews and the theoretical bases were incorporated into Part I: The Thesis, while all the plan and photo material, accompanied by identity data sheets, were included in Part II: Case Studies. In this autonomous photographic bundling, the ten pairs examined were placed next to each other. Although dealt with in a separate part of the thesis, the photographic material plays a crucial role in the interpretation of the many statements made by the respondents in the interviews. © Herman Van Den Boom © Kim Vanpelt Completing this thesis has been an enriching experience and although no major general conclusions can be made, I hope to have provided some new insights into the debate between diversity, modernity, the occupant and their home. © Kim Vanpelt Housing and the domestic space in Belgium and Portugal Housing and the domestic space in Belgium and Portugal Why do people choose a modern or a classical house and what is their attitude towards other styles on various scales? It was my intention to understand the possible motives regarding the choice or non-choice of a modern or a classical house. Furthermore, I also explored how people look at existing diversity on the scale of the adjacent house, the street and an overall image of living in Belgium. To indicate the given contrast in their appearance, I speak of the modern and the classical house. This does not mean that the dwellings are understood according to one deinition of ‘modern’ or ‘classical’. It was not my intention to restrict the aesthetic of the modernist house to the typical Flemish fermette. The goal was to illustrate the diversity of meanings underlying the debate about modernity. | 150 | | 151 | Architecture Graduates 2015 Starting with an image of Van den Boom (Photo 1), I want to illustrate my fascination with Belgian residential landscape, where many diverse styles and typologies coexist. It is on the basis of this sense of intrigue and the urge to understand the living reality of Belgium that my research question grew. Architecture Graduates 2015 MODERN VERSUS CLASSICAL callaga — modern versus classical