A-3-6
Proceedings of the 11th ISAIA, Sept.20-23, 2016, Miyagi, Japan
Interdisciplinary Design Approach through Maya
Claudia van Velthooven1, Marc Aurel Schnabel2
1
March(Prof) Student, Architecture, Victoria University, Wellington, New Zealand
Professor, Institute of Architecture, Victoria University, Wellington, New Zealand
2
Abstract
This research uses Wellington’s wind climate as the pivot of inquiry in all of its complexity, and explores
design narratives that best respond to those circumstances in order to generate building forms with the
capacity to emanate communicative energy of the city. The process of using an environmental conditions
with the strongest effect (in this case, wind) as catalyst, takes the vagaries of concepts and plants them into
responsive forms that excel in exploring the possibilities of a hyper-localized architecture based on its
immediate environment. Autodesk MayaTM simulation and dynamic modeling capabilities allow for the
exploration of a new typology that opens up discussion towards the acknowledgment of local climatic
situations. The stimulation of this discussion generates awareness of environmental conditions and leads
towards recognition for resilience, subject to specific locations. Our emergent system described in this
paper, is established through generative computational methodologies. The geneses of complex geometries
are subject to the rules that are defined by the wind dynamics apparent in Wellington.
Keywords: Interdisciplinary; simulation, climatology, Maya, Innovation
methodologies that employ computationally mediated
form generation.
1. Introduction
This research aims to form a design methodology
that recognizes the power and potential of Autodesk
MayaTM in establishing an innovative design
methodology that can provide for diverse and resilient
architectures. This paper suggests that by embedding
data into the design process, enabled through Maya’s
programming editor, a novel design language can be
established that is rich with contextual intelligence
and hence, unique to its environment. It looks at the
role of computation in the design process and its
ability to empower designers to breach into other
fields, including various scientific domains i.e.
climatology, infusing neoteric ideas into design. As a
result, the algorithmic design process will develop
towards an interdisciplinary domain that integrates
different scientific algorithms into architectural
cultures. Computational design has established itself
as a fundamental aspect of critical design thinking and
generation, including the simulation of scientific
phenomena, and their evolution as a basis for
information-based design approaches. To culminate,
this paper will debate how these different domains are
able to integrate with architectural design through the
faculty of Maya by setting up innovative emergent
1.1. Maya
Maya is a powerful design tool for architects. Maya
allows for embedded intelligence and performative
criteria to define complex parametric relationships and
behaviors (Tang, 2014). Its script editor supports
Python programming language in tandem with the
native Maya Embedded Language (MEL), both which
are fully integrated within the interface. This allows
the designer to take advantage of the software by
programming repetitive, complicated, or highly
specific commands that help save valuable time and
also offer a method of sharing with others, allowing
total control over any inputs. Fulvio Wirz, lead
architect at Zaha Hadid Architects (ZHA), describes
Maya as “a form synthesizer, a generator of ideas that
goes beyond any classification if compared to other
traditional 3D tools for architects” (Tang, 2014). Its
simulation engines are capable of virtually
reproducing physical behaviors existing in nature/ the
environment which makes it a powerful tool for
architectural form finding and analysis and
fundamental for this research described in this paper.
Contact Author: Claudia van Velthooven, MArch(Prof)
Student, Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand
Tel: +64 21 833182
e-mail:
[email protected]
1.2. Maya in today’s Architectural Discourse
One of the architectural design strengths of Maya
lies in its computational fluid dynamic (CFD) tools
-86-
and nDynamic tools. CFD is typically used for
scientific analysis and not for design generation which
is where Maya intervenes. Maya facilitates research
by design as it reacts to the design side of research
rather than the evaluation of the endnote design. With
alternative parametric tools such as Grasshopper3D
and Rhinoceros3D, the designer must already have an
outcome in mind whereas, Maya allows for more
free-flow of design and simulation/animation. This
results in more unexpected/emergent and exciting
results.
There are an increasing number of large firms
around the world who utilize autodesk Maya within
their architectural practise. Patrik Schumacher,
architect and partner at ZHA, advocates Maya in its
parametric ability to enable relationships within the
design to respond and interact with each other in the
particular type of computational environment that was
introduced to them through the animation platform of
Maya. He describes how the scripting logic that can
be embedded into Maya allows for forces to lawfully
interact and goes on to state, in relation to Maya, one
“cannot compete at the contemporary stage of
architecture if you're not fully geared up with these
tools” (Zaha Hadid Architects, 2016). Furthermore,
Nils Fischer, associate at ZHA, describes Maya as
follows;
that involved a culmination of various ideas developed
through smaller urban studies. Customized scripts in
Maya were intrinsic for divisions of plots, location of
open space, organising pedestrian networks, shortest
city routes, and more. Shajay Bhoosan, a research
architect at ZHA who worked on the project, explains
how Maya was core to creating the design processes
that involved a fluid algorithm used to drive
parameters that generated the urban mass”. (Zaha
Hadid Architects, 2016)
2. Methods
2.1. Simulation
The research within this paper explores the
simulation capabilities in Maya to extract local
climatic data of Wellington City and embed it into the
design process. This generates computational fluid
dynamics (CDF) as a form generation tool, rather than
an analysis tool, and manifests avant-garde
architectural typologies as depicted in Figure 1.
Within the software platform of Maya, there are many
dynamic tools for simulating natural phenomena such
as wind. A few of these methodologies are
demonstrated in Figure 2.
“Maya allows [the designer] to create a
layer of parametric knowledge allowing one to create
complexity. It has a very wide range of options to
simulate reality. We [ZHA] recognize the benefits of
having a customizable tool with an open interface, so
now we really want to explore these opportunities
further. Looking at what we do, I think we need a tool
like Maya to do it”.(Zaha Hadid Architects, 2016)
Figure 1 depicts an example project from ZHA that
was designed through innovative scripting within
Maya. The project was a competition entry for a
masterplan design in Apur, India.
Fig 2. Outcomes of wind forming processes using a
variety of scripts to generate hyperlocalized
architectural forms.
The behavior and subsequently generated form of
wind have an intricate relationship. The generated
form affects the behavior of further wind dynamics in
the environments. The behavior can be understood as
non-linear and context specific. Of particular interest
to this research’s integration of climatic dynamics are
the Maya nCloth and nParticle tools. nCloth uses rules
Fig.1. Apur, India Masterplan Competition, ZHA,
2008.
The project was derived through Maya simulations
-87-
•
of physics to simulate natural forces. Maya nCloth has
been used to generate these forms that are driven by
external forces (i.e. wind). The nCloth becomes a
dynamic object and a formal expression of this natural
phenomena through its ability to mimic real-life
behaviors. nCloth simulations can be seen in figure 3.
wind speed determines the particle speed.
This simulation was run across a few typical days to
demonstrate the different effects of this applied
process.
Fig 4. 2D visualization of wind data extraction and
application as parameters to Maya nParticle system.
Fig 3. Outcomes of wind forming processes using
nCloth simulations.
2.2. Data Embedment
To exercise further control over this interdisciplinary
simulation (climatology and architecture) the nParticle
function was investigated with unique scripts written
in order to embed local climatic intelligence into the
form generation process.
By utilizing the Maya script editor, a python script
was written that extracts live weather data recordings
of Wellington City and embeds the wind dynamics,
including; wind speed, direction, air density and air
pressure, as parameters into the particle attributes that
are assigned from within the script. The particles
respond accordingly, and from their generated
animated motion path, a nurbs curve can be
formulated and manipulated for the emergence of a
unique, and highly specific synthesised expression,
that is rich with local information.
Initially, this embedded data was visualized in 2D,
as depicted in figure 4. The live data was extracted
and applied to the nParticle system within Maya, for
the same timeframe, as follows;
• air density effects the number of particles
emitted
• wind direction dictates the x, y, z directions
of these particles
Fig 5. Closer look at 2D visualization of wind data
extraction and application as parameters to Maya
nParticle system from Figure 4.
Next, the data was animated within a 3D
environment. Using MEL script, the particle motion
path can be converted into a NURBS curve.
Applications of the processes displayed in Figures 1
can be applied to the curves that emerge, and forms
that are in response to this live weather data are
originated. This involves techniques such meshing,
lofting, animation snapshot. An example of this
process is depicted in Figure 6. This process allows
the data to behave as parameters that can be analysed
within the script for more freedom and improvisation
in the production of multiple localized design
outcomes. This parametric methodology enables the
designer to delve into other fields, such as
climatology, allowing for a unique interpretation of
localized data that generates hyperlocalized resulting
forms.
-88-
for a hyperlocalized architecture.
The above described design process fuses the
domains of climatology and architecture, not in a
scientific manner, but in a creative and
form-synthesizing process that is derived from data
extracted locally. The resulting artifice is the product
of its environment and explicitly unique to its context
from the applied parameters, thus arguing as a
hyperlocalized typology with the ability to generate
discussion towards addressing the issue of diversity
and resilience in architecture, specific to its context.
Fig 6. 3D wind data extraction and embedment as
controlling parameters to generate responsive
architectural reactions to site-specific conditions over
one week (12-17 May 2016 at around 18:00 to 21:00).
The research described in this paper is the starting
point of design generation and design collaboration
with the algorithm and script as well as the instrument,
for an interdisciplinary approach to creative design,
possible through Maya. The two are intrinsic partners
within the design process which will facilitate the
arrival at an architectural expression that are to some
extent ambitious and conceptual, yet allow for the
understanding and development of a novel
architectural typology and expression, that is not
possible otherwise.
3. Conclusions
This paper offers a point of departure for
investigations of how local weather data extraction is
integrated into a design process for the generation of
an innovative typology for hyper-localized forms. The
implicit contribution of this paper lies in its
investigations of interdisciplinary practice between
climatology and architectural discourse for responsive
and innovative hyperlocalized architecture. The
process demonstrates the ability to motivate
discussion that acknowledges the importance of
resilient architecture that specifically responds to its
immediate environmental conditions, achieved
through the novel typology that emerges from this
process.
4. References
1) Usa.autodesk.com. (2016) Autodesk – Design Visualization –
Autodesk Maya for Architects and Designers. [online] Available
at:
http://usa.autodesk.com/adsk/servlet/item?siteID=123112&id=135
91323 [Accessed 6 Jul. 2016].
2) TopTenREVIEWS. (2011). Autodesk Maya Review | Top Ten
Reviews. [online] Available at:
http://3d-animation-software-review.toptenreviews.com/autodeskmaya-review.html [Accessed 6 Jul. 2016].
By extracting climatological data from a specific
local environment and considering its effect on the
social significance of the same environment, an
architectural design manifests itself that can be
validated as hyperlocal and offers a true representation
of its genus locus, beyond what the human
imagination could conceive alone.
3) Tang, M. (n.d.). Parametric building design using Autodesk Maya.
This research continues into a resolved design that
utilizes the interdisciplinary methodology offering a
valuable approach for infusing innovative ideas into
design. The computational process offers the ability to
empower designers to delve into other scientific fields,
i.e. climatology, and embed designs with local
information. Through this methodology we begin to
interpret, represent, and/or express our local
surroundings taken as natural, through the design
process that generates artifices (theory of emergence)
-89-
4) Edulearn.com. (2016). What is Autodesk Maya?. [online] Available
at: http://www.edulearn.com/article/what_is_autodesk_maya.html
[Accessed 6 Jul. 2016].
5) Zaha Hadid Architects, (2016). Design_viz/zaha_video. [video]
Available at:
http://usa.autodesk.com/adsk/servlet/index?siteID=123112&id=13
462298&linkID=13454855 [Accessed 2 Jul. 2016].