Academia.eduAcademia.edu

A final reply to Carrie Roy

Fornvännen 2012:3, 217-219

Abstract

In Fornvännen 2012:1, we responded to criticism that Carrie Roy had directed towards us [http://uu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:540982/FULLTEXT01]. The matter appeared especially urgent as Roy's account contained errors of fact and misquotations that did injury to fellow researchers. Thus, the main focus of our reply was on academic craftsmanship. Reading Roy's reply in Fornvännen 2012:2, we note with regret that she remains set in her ways, rather than admitting human error. Therefore, the following is intended to be our final reply.

Lars Liedgren

Silvermuseet

Box 10 SE-930 90 Arjeplog [email protected]