Social History and Occupational
Mobility: A Study of Khem Karan Town
In Punjab (1950-2011)
Thesis Submitted for the Award of the Degree of
DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY
In
History
By
Ashwani Kumar
Registration Number: 41800968
Supervised By
Dr. Mohammad Ashraf Dar
(Assistant Professor-History)
Lovely Professional University
LOVELY PROFESSIONAL UNIVERSITY, PUNJAB
2023
.
Abstract:
Social history and occupational mobility is an important field of investigation in modern
India. As human history has gone through long run-in occupational mobility, passing through
various stages of the evolution, discarding and adopting the new techniques and tools for the
better life and living, thus the history of occupational mobility is as historical as human
civilization itself is. The present work is an effort to understand the same from Khem Karan,
the border town of Punjab in context to
Social History and Occupational Mobility from
1950-2011.Khem Karan has seen the wrath of two wars 1965 and 1971. In addition to the
wars, it remained the hot spot for the insurgency 1980 to 1992. In addition, it also experienced
the tremors of the later Kargil war in 1999. Insurgency and the wars have affected this zone
both in social aspect as well as the occupational aspect. The occupational development and
social history of Khem Karan has been shaped by these features.
Present work traces these developments in a historical manner, surveying from
national to local level. It begins with historical development of Khem Karan Town of Taran
district of Majha region in Punjab. It explores the town from independence (1947) to last
decade (2011).Beginning with the basic meaning of the terms, exploring their theoretical base
and understanding the same from the cited region employing the qualitative method of
research, surveying the different corners of the Khem Karan and collecting the data in terms
of population, literacy rate, sex ratio, occupational details. In addition to field survey, the
census reports from 1951 onwards have been extensively used to understand the shifts and
fluctuations in the social history as well as the occupational mobility. Mobility especially for
better living, education, social status and white-collar employment remain the major factors.
Evaluating the factors, consequences, finally the work comes up with suggestions in this
context.
Acknowledgement
I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my Supervisor Dr. Mohammad Ashraf Dar for
continuous support throughout my PhD research with her patience, motivation, enthusiasm,
and immense knowledge. He is an inspirational figure from whom I could learn so much
during my Ph. D. research work. His guidance helped me throughout my research journey
and will always help me in my future academic life.
I would also like to thank the Hon‘ble Chancellor of the Lovely Professional University
Phagwara, Sh Ashok Kumar Mittal, for his kind blessings. My sincere thanks also go to Dr.
Pritpal Singh, Dean School of Social Science, and Lovely Professional University Phagwara.
He guided me many times during my research work. I would like to thank Dr. Manu Sharma
Head of Department of Social Science Lovely Professional University Phagwara
My sincere thanks also go to Dr. Santosh Kumar, Assistant Professor Amity University
Lakhnow, Mr. Suraj Kumar Lakhnow, Mr. Radhay Sham, Dr, Pooja Kansra Professor Mittal
School of Business Lovely Professional University Phagwara, Dr. Ripudaman Singh
Assistant Professor Lovely Professional University Phagwara and Dr. Tariq Sheikh Assistant
Professor Lovely Professional University Phagwara for providing the intellectual support.
I would like to thank Librarian and the rest of the library staff of Lovely Professional
University Phagwara for their help accessing the books and articles during my research.
I would also like to offer my special thanks to my loving parents Natha Ram and Darshna
Rani, Arvind Passi English Teacher Govt. High School, BhuraKohna (Tarn Taran), Vaneet
Kumar vice Principal Shri Bala Ji Sr. Sec. School Khem Karan, Sukhraj Sharma, Ashok
Kumar Sharma, and Shashi Sharma.
Above all, also I would like to thank my beloved wife Mamta Sharma for her love and
constant support, for all the late nights and early mornings and keeping me sane over the past
few months.
Last but not least I would like to mention the support of my parents, my brothers and all my
family members. Without their motivation, my efforts would have been meaningless.
Ashwani Kumar
TABLE OF CONTENT
CHAPTER
TITLE
PAGE NO.
Introduction
1-25
CHAPTER 1
Geographical Profile of Khem Karan
26-47
CHAPTER 2
Theories of Social and Occupational Mobility
48-68
CHAPTER 3
Occupational Mobility: Factors
69-80
CHAPTER 4
Consequences of Occupational Mobility in Khem 81-160
Karan
CHAPTER 5
Conclusion
161-165
REFERENCE
166-179
APPENDIX
180-199
Dedicated to my Parents
INTRODUCTION
“Studying the social history of India is as complex as it is interesting”. 1
India, the land of unity in diversity has seen the evolution of civilization, culture and empires.
It has witnessed the glory of the Indus Valley Civilization, the first Urbanization, the
tranquillity of the Vedic hymns, the radiation of the age of Buddha, the glory of the Mauryan
Empire, the invasions from the central Asia, the beauty of Mathura and Gandhara art. It has
witnessed the glory and the gloom in the long course of history. One of the prominent features
that evolved in the later Vedic age but continue even till date, the social stratification on
Varna and caste lines. Towards the early medieval period, with the coming of Turks, the
social fabric and the cultural horizon of India was further enriched.
With the onset of so called modernity, the colonialism engulfed India and altered the existing
social structure with the all new middle class. After independence, the partition came like a
catastrophe disturbing the age old social fabric altogether. The occupation played a very
decent role in deciding the Jati. The changing social and economic conditions of India led to
the change in the occupations as new occupations were creeping in. With the transition from
medieval to modern, the coming of technology and science, use of machines, political
upheavals etc. further provided impetus to the occupational mobility2. In addition to these, the
partition of India in 1947, led to large scale human loss due to communal riots that engulfed
the India after partition, especially the north western region, Punjab being the prime victim of
it. Though the migration of Punjabi Muslims was reported from many parts of Punjab, the
regions that still bear the scar of the partition line are the border regions of which Khem
Karan is important as it witnessed the post-partition wars between the two nations. Being at
the border has many implications in the domain of society and the occupations. From 1950 to
2011, the town of Khem Karan has seen many changes in view of the societal history and
occupational domain. The factors influencing these aspects of India in general and a border
region like Khem Karan in particular are both internal as well as the global 3. The world's
social development had been geared up in the last century. The socio, economic and political
movements and upheaval not only affected the traditional values but the challenged the moral
values of the world. This type of milieu affected developing nations like India too.
1
Roy, Anwesha, and Social History of Colonial India: 1800-1947, https://www.southasia.ox.ac.uk/socialhistory-of-colonial-india-1800-1947 retrieved on 10th of October 2022.
2
Cregan, K. (2006). The sociology of the body: Mapping the abstraction of embodiment. Sage.p2-4
3
Smith, D. E. (2015). South Asian politics (Vol. 2374). Princeton University .p11-12
1
Occupational mobility refers to the alteration in the existing occupation of an individual.
This might also be Intra-generational and intergenerational occupational mobility. It has its
own consequences in socio-economic terms. Increased intra-generational occupational
mobility gives a scope of specialization of works‘ very own choice. In brief, upward
occupational mobility offers folks and chance to increase their family‘s general of living.
But the extent and sample of occupational mobility rely upon insurance policies affecting the
training area and the labor market.
As we are specifically concerned with the understanding of the supra peripherally discussed
themes in Khem Karan town of Punjab, a very small town located in the Tarn Taran district
of Punjab. Guru Teg Bahadur (1621–1675) also visited the region once. Before the partition
of British India in the year 1947, before partition it was part of Lahore (Pakistan). After the
partition it was merged into Amritsar.4Now it is in Tarn Taran (Punjab) district which is
situated in the north of Punjab state5. Many residents of the city migrated or migrated from
nearby villages, such as Nathuwala, Qadiwind, Rohiwal, and Sahajra, in the contemporary
war of Pakistan between 1947 and 1965. Many of the city's Muslim residents/communities
migrated mainly to the metros. Kasur is situated in the Pakistan border about 8 km away.
The city was easily accessible from Kasur, Pakistan, only 8 km away, and Firozpur (Punjab,
India), 30 km away, although India and Pakistan implemented border controls and limited
visits at several places in 1965 because the situation Due to the tracking strategic dispute.
However, the residents of the city Khem Karan or people from each town are decreasing,
while the roads to Ferozepur pass through Pakistan, making a drive of more than 70 km. The
people of the city and those of the surrounding villages now had to travel very long distances
to Patti, Amritsar or Tarn Taran to buy any basic goods or necessary essentials, causing great
inconvenience and financial stagnation.
According to the 2011 Indian census data, Khem Karan town had a population of 13,446
(approximately fourteen thousand), and adult males represented 55% of this population and
females (female) represented 45 percent of this population. The literacy rate in the town is
61.55 percent, which is considered to be very low compared to the country. The general
literacy rate is 7.84 percent, the male literacy is 67 percent and the female literacy rate is
54.85 percent. This town is also the special place where the tomb of a popular Sufi saint is
4
Kaang, S. K. Guru Tegh Bahadur: An Apostle of Human Rights and Supreme Sacrifice. L. Fjswg Who Killed
Guru Tegh Bahadur?p55-58
5
Levine, D. B. (1974). The Victoria and Albert Akbar-Nama: A Study in History, Myth and Image.(Volumes I
and IIi). University Of Michigan.p27-30
2
acknowledged as Baba Sheikh Braham whose tomb is situated here. Every year around twice
a year, a traditional event is held there. The town is generally an agricultural area and a rural
area.
The nature of social history and occupational mobility is as long as the nature of the
development of human civilization. It is regularly recognized as a very important topic for
research and an interesting fact. These lookups aim to assess the history, social, political,
economic and occupational dynamics of the Khem Karan town. In the year 1965 and 1971,
town Khem Karan had to face two battles between India and Pakistan. It also faced major
terrorism incidents from 1980 to 1992.
Social change signifies a change in social behavior, social structure and social and cultural
values. It includes the change in attitudes or beliefs, in so far as they sustain institutions and
change with them6‖. In fact, sociatical change is normal and continuously, but in various
directions, at various rates, and at all multiple levels of social life. Change is a characteristic
of all societies be they primitive or modern. No society ever remains changeless. It is a
difficult matter whether societies change slowly or experience revolutionary changes. It is any
alteration in cultural, structural, demographic or ecological characteristics of a social system
such as a society.
Moreover, the social device is usually in the manner of change. Change is natural, directional,
immanent, non-stop, and necessary. The main social alternate may also be a very effective
factor of inventive reality. It refers to modifications in the installed patterns of social
relationships, for example, in family, social and monetary lifestyles, and the corresponding
social behavior.
Social change is the product of some variables, some single cause and that not only is every
change attributable to that cause, but every change in that cause will produce a attendant
change in society7. Social change takes place when there is a structural change in society with
technological and institutional as well as in the aspirations of the people. The directions of
social change can be overhead or over. It can do in the form of forgotten and retrogression.
Therefore, it frequently refers to shifts in the structure and culture of a given society. Where
artistic changes, as well as changes in social morals, take place in response to the new
6
Pahl-Wostl, C.,Tàbara,D., Bouwen, R, Craps, M., Dewulf,A., Mostert,E., & Taillieu, T. (2008). The importance
of social learning and culture for sustainable water management. Ecological economics, 64(3), 484-495.
7
Homer-Dixon, T. F. (1991). On the threshold: environmental changes as causes of acute conflict. International
security, 16(2),76-116.
3
situation, social change may take place easily8. Else, there may be rebellion and social
complaint.
So, social change is not a specific event that has a specific cause, it is more like an ongoing
activity. Through most of recorded history men have clearly recognized that change is
intrinsically undesirable and that the ideal social condition is stability. Whether society as
they know it has remained stable or whether it is undergoing rapid change, they need to
maintain or achieve continuity of social life in order to preserve for their descendants what
they inherited from ancestors through folklore, myth, legend, theology. ,
Social philosophy, moral and aesthetic standards, and other symbolic constructs have, for the
most important part, reflected general modes of social conduct and operated as social
controls, forcing individual members of society to develop traditional ways of life. Subtly or
openly forced to. Sustainability has been not only the social norm but also the general social
condition. Quantitatively and qualitatively, social change has been unusual, if not
extraordinary.
It was not until the close of the eighteenth century AD, that the idea emerged in Western
Europe that per se desired change; and it was well before the further idea emerged in the
nineteenth century that even desirable social change was inevitable. The former was the
product of French intellectualism; the latter, of British science. Understanding social change
has been a continuous challenge for human beings. He has searched every corner of his
universe for an explanation. With all of his science and technology, modern man is still
baffled by the complexity of age-old challenges. Factors of social change are demographic,
technological, economic, cultural, legal and political. The Indian society, living in this vast area
of territorial and geographical diversity, is one of the most ancient societies in the world. This country
of different languages and dialects is full of quirks in the social life of many tribal9. Several Scholars
studying Indian society have tried to find the main structural features of Indian society. M.N.Srinivas
has described the main feature of Indian social structure, its socio-cultural diversity. Daumo has
considered category as the main feature of Indian society. Yogendra Singh has given some of the main
structural and traditional features of Indian society: Holism, Continuity, and Transcendence. In the
present unit, various features of Indian society have been discussed. India is a plural society in
8
Shove, D. (2011). Beyond the ABC: Climate change and theories of social change. Environment and planning
A, 42(6), 1273-1285.
9
Knight, D. B. (1982). Identity and territory: geographical perspectives on nationalism and regionalism. Annals
of the Association of American Geographers, 72(4), 514-531.
4
principle and in reality10. It would be appropriate to understand India by its unity and
diversity. Even after foreign invasions, Mughal and British rule, India remained a blend of
cultures, religions, languages and unity and harmony between people of different castes and
communities. Although sharp economic and social inequalities hindered the emergence of
homo-social relations, national unity and integrity remained intact. Through this combination,
India has remained a unique mosaic society. In fact, India is a unique frontier whose parallel
form is not visible in other continents. Indian culture is not only tolerant due to foreign
invasions, immigration from different parts of the world, existence of different languages,
cultures and religions, but it is also a unique continuous and vibrant culture with its
uniqueness and historicity.
India is the 7th larger and 2nd most densely populated country in the world, it 2.4% of the
world's total area. Here about 15%.3 of the world population lives between different social,
economic, geographical and ecological conditions. Along with this there is also the past of
human life of a period of 5000 years, which includes the years before 3000 BC and after 2000
years. This country also has the cultural heritage that it got from the immigrants, Aryans (who
came here from across Himachal) and the original Dravidians and invaders civilizations. The
social, economic and cultural diversity of India is clearly visible in its rural and urban living
conditions. The total population of the urban area of 21718 million (according to the 1991s
census report) and even the whole number of population of the 4 metropolitan cities (Delhi,
Madras, Calcutta, Bombay) (about 40 million) is much more than the population of most
developing countries11. There are settlements of one thousand people here, then there are also
settlements with a population of up to one crore.
From religious perspective, although our nation does not have a nation religion, but
the freedom of trust and exercise of all sorts of religions is assured here. Major religions
consist of Hinduism (which in accordance to the 1991 census has 69.77 million people,
consisting of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, or about 82.69% of the country's
population), Islam (which has 11.35% of its populace or 9.58 million people). ), Christianity
(which has 2.43% of the populace or 2.05 million followers), Sikhism (which has 1.96% of
the populace or 16.5 million people), Buddhism (which has 0.71% of the populace or 0.41
million followers), and different religions (which is accompanied by means of 0.38% of the
populace or 0.38 crore people). Hinduism advocates the ideas of karma (duties), dharma,
10
Wiarda, H. J., & Kline, H. F. (2018). A concise introduction to Latin American politics and development.
Routledge.p77-78
11
Singer, M. (1966). Religion and social change in India: The Max Weber thesis, phase three. Economic
Development and Cultural Change, 14(4), 498-505.
5
reincarnation (an individual takes eighty four lakh births), immortality of the soul,
renunciation and moksha (freedom from beginning and death). The faith of Islam got here
with the Muslim invasion of India. It is an absolutely monotheistic faith which preaches
'God's will' as destiny. This faith does no longer agree with in idol-worship and considers
Hazrat Muhammad as Prophet and 'Quran Sharif' as the most holy book. According to this
there are 5 most important responsibilities of each religious Muslim; Belief in Allah,
supplying namaz 5 times, giving charity/zakat, fasting for one month each years and making
pilgrimage to Mecca at least as soon as in a lifetime. Sikhism originated in the fifteenth
century. Guru Nanak Dev, the founder of this faith and 9 different authorities of his disciple
tradition, gave sermons towards hypocrisy, ostentation, falsehood in religion. There are 5 non
secular symbols of Sikhism: hair, comb, kada, kirpan and kachcha. Castes: Castes are
endogamous organizations primarily based on heredity, having precise occupations, following
meals restrictions and social restrictions on interaction. There are about 3000 castes in India.
These castes are divided into three categories: higher castes (such as Brahmins, Rajputs,
Banias, Kayasthas etc.), center castes (such as Ahirs, goldsmiths, Kurmis etc.) and decrease
castes (such as washer men, barbers etc.).
Apart from this, many untouchable castes also exist of the different parts of the
country (like Chuda, Bhangi, and Raigar etc.). That type castes are generally out of the fold of
4 varnas (Brahmins, Kashatriyas, Vaishyas and Shudras) and are thus assigned the menial
jobs at the bottom strata in the hierarchy of the caste 12. In addition to these lower castes, India
is dotted with the tribal as well.13So, we come across the tribal under the title of Santhal, Bhil,
Meena, Gond, Naga, Khasi, Oraon, Garo and 'Ho'. Some important states account for about
2/3 of the country's tribal population. Such states are Madhya Pradesh, Orissa, Bihar, Gujarat
and Maharashtra. The tribes with a population of 20 lakhs are located in three states
(Rajasthan, West Bengal and Andhra Pradesh). There are 5 states and union territories where
tribes represent 70 to 95 percent of the total population. It mainly resides in Mizoram,
Nagaland, Meghalaya, and Arunachal Pradesh also.
Racially, India is also diverse. Indian population is polygenetic or a combine of
various species. According to Guha, the Indian populace is shaped up of six ethnic groups:
Negrito, Proto Australis, Mangoloid, Mediterranean or Dravidian, Brachycephalic and Nordic
12
Kumar, V. (2009). Dalit diaspora: Invisible existence. Diaspora Studies, 2(1), 53-74.
Ramirez, B. K. (2007). Native hubs: Culture, community, and belonging in Silicon Valley and beyond. Duke
University Press.p66-68
13
6
Aryan. Brachycephalic nigroid are the main human beings to come to India from Africa. 14
They‘re now discovered as hill tribes of South India and in the Andaman Islands the place
they have nevertheless retained their language. In phrases of numbers they're now negligible.
Proto Australis or Austria, kingdom of medium height, darkish complexion, lengthy head,
thick jaw, small chin, and flat nose, are enormous all through India. Especially in eastern,
central and southern India and from right here they visited Burma and Malaya. In fact, these
humans laid the idea of Indian civilization and they started out the cultivation of sugarcane,
rice and inexperienced vegetables. Their language nonetheless survives inside the Munda and
Kol languages. The Mediterranean genus has three subtypes: real Mediterranean, Paleo
Mediterranean and Oriental Mediterranean. These humans added the city Indus Valley
Civilization to the height of fame, the stays of which we have bought from Mohenjo-Daro and
Harappa. The Dravidian human beings would have unfolded in all places India15. The humans
of the Yellow race have extensive heads, medium stature, brownish or yellowish complexion,
quick nose, and lips thick, flat face, cheek bones are protruding and that they are discovered
in Assam, Arunachal Pradesh, Nagaland and Mizo hills. The Nordic Aryans obtained right
here from Central Asia between 2000 and 15000 BCE and settled in north-west Punjab and
unfold from there to the Gangetic plain. These Aryans fought with the human beings of the
pretty civilized Indus Valley who had been already settled. The people of the Negrito race had
blended with the Aryans and step by way of step adopted their cultural features also.16
Unity is an important cohesive thread between these diversities, which binds the entire
Indian society as a vast society and the country as a nation of high quality. MN Srinivas is of
the view that India's harmony is always secular unity17. Indians are known to have worshiped
many gods and goddesses, the Puranas, the Brahmanas, the epics and consequently the Vedas
form a vast spiritual society, in which various disparate agencies are woven together and
make them feel the holiness of their country. Devotees visit more than a few pilgrimage sites,
although all aim to reap the non-secular benefits of visiting holy places. People from many
regions, languages and customs are regularly considered collectively in pilgrimage sites and
all have a consistent goal, the attainment of 'moksha'. India struggled for independence as a
united entity18. After independence, India as a state faced Chinese invasion and Pakistani
14
Guha, B.S et al, (1996) Anthropology of B.S. Guha: A Centenary Tribute- A Review,Anthropological Survey
of India, Ministry of Human Resource Development, Department of Culture, Government of India. p.83.
15
Nehru, J. (2008). Discovery of India. Penguin UK.p374
16
Opcit, Guha. Pp. 80-85.
17
Migheli, Matteo (2016). "Minority Religious Groups and Life satisfactory in India". Australian Economic
Review. Vol. 49, Issue. 2, pp. 117- 125.
18
Nehru, J. (2008). Discovery of India. Penguin UK. p.81.
7
invasion thrice. Our economic, social and political ideologies support secularism, reason,
honesty, liberty and equality. Our legal guidelines adhere equally to all or anyone except
discrimination. Our charter provides equal protection to all or anyone; our schemes are
designed with the intention of uplifting all types of weaker sections. Consistency of repeated
customs and social values preserves our distinctive lifestyle. There is also unity among
Hindus in observing the prohibitions of the caste system. Similarly humans can say that they
sleep in a certain area, although the idea of place is relevant. A linguistic milieu may also
show a great deal of rapprochement which is often the union of all or any caste (from
Brahmins to untouchables) living in that area. While there may also be an indication of castebased sentiment that transcends linguistic territory.19 Brahmins across a state (such as Uttar
Pradesh) may no longer share the beliefs of neighboring Dalit humans (such as Bhangis, Pasi,
etc.) but still have a presence in society, although they share some association with Brahmins
throughout India from the north. Want to share cultural values from south and east to west.
Similarly, humans can communicate and exchange only one language of their kind in many
areas, although they often use a language such as Hindi or English to communicate with each
other. Hindi has been established in non-Hindi speaking areas. First it was the English
language deposit which often played a role as a medium of verbal exchange between the
people about the extraordinary components of the country, although it also created a barrier
between the enlightened and consequently the common man. The idea of linguistic states and
schools, faculties and universities educating through regional language is the end result of
independence. But now it cannot be said that linguistic differences will create disease in the
society. The classification form gave a new dimension to the Indians, which they have also
provided the general cultural ideology20. While it is also true that the caste system has pushed
the inter-caste conflicts upwards, created problems like untouchability, and created a rift
between the upper and untouchable castes, it is also working to eliminate them gradually,
butthefacility members of the family of exceptional castes have modified in the ultimate few
decades. The financial forces and socio-political modifications that have are handy the
ultimate forty-seven years have extended the energy of the majority castes. The leaders of
these castes or institutions are well aware of their social work in the political power enmity at
the local, regional and central, town, city level. The leaders of these castes give attention and
suggestions on the big problems like upliftment of weaker sections, untouchability, land
19
20
Jaffrelot, C. (2011). Religion, caste, and politics in India. Primus Books. pp. 22-66.
Ibid. p.65
8
development etc. This ethnic solidarity will become necessary from time to time in taking up
countrywide and regional problems and will not contribute directly to the reform vision but
will be linked to them. Thus though religion, caste and language create some issues within the
society, but India's team spirit is rooted in these three factors. It is these three which bind the
human beings of India in one thread on many levels. Although it is no longer claimed that
these three elements (religion, caste and language) are going to be decisive and essential in
the unification of man in India and in connecting them in many ways, it is cautioned that over
time people will be able to will respect the fact. According to Virginia Xaxa:
―It is obvious that the spirit of the Constitution recognizes the distinct cultural features of tribes
especially in respect to language. Therefore, it talks of protection and promotion of this aspect. At the
same time as a part of the integrating process into the larger Indian society and polity, tribes are
conferred citizen- ship rights. As citizens, tribes too had fundamental rights like members of any other
group. Tribal‘s, therefore, have a right to freedom of expression and faith as a part of their civil rights.
And yet, the actual social reality has often denied such rights. I shall illustrate from the contexts of
tribal language and religion. According to Article 29 of the Constitution, a cultural or linguistic
minority has the right to conserve its language and culture. The article provides protection to scheduled
tribe communities to preserve their language, dialects and cultures. It also says that the state would not
by law enforce upon it any other culture or language. Further, Article 350a provides for facilities for
instruction through the mother tongue at the primary stage of education. Yet, no effort whatsoever has
been made so far by the federal state or the provincial states towards safeguarding tribal languages, let
alone promoting them. Education in all provinces/states, even at the primary level, has been imparted in
the language of the dominant community. There were, of course, instances in states like undivided
Bihar where primers were prepared in some tribal languages for pedagogic purposes in the mother
tongues but these were allowed to rot in government godowns.‖ 21
She further elaborates that
―the 'division' in them may be useless and they will continue to live in harmony with each other, but
their values are important to be citizens of the country, now don't always be inconsistent and
inconsistent and think well and also want to do good. Allegiance to these divided classes cannot be lost.
Yes, although it would not be right to call them anti-nationals, now they need to understand. If a man or
woman believes that he belongs to any caste, village and place or belief, he additionally shows that he is
an Indian and that his obligations and obligations as a citizen are additionally made So that people can
follow it. Such feelings keep the total solidarity among the people and also organize the society‖.
22
With this thought of unity, one want now not worry the range in society. Why the
arrangement? In other words, apart from some modifications, it is often said that the cultural
21
Xaxa, V. (2007). Politics of language, religion and identity: Tribes in India. Economic and political weekly,
Vol. 40, No. 13, p. 1367.
22
Ibid. pp. 1368-70.
9
and social and guide cultural activities. That‘s why it is said that change has taken place in the
system and not in the system. The individuality of Indian society is not only meant by its
esoteric nature, its historical and contextual have to be studied deeply to understand its true
meaning. The trends of social and cultural change are visible through the processes of
assimilation and assimilation. Aryans and Dravidians lived together. Hindus and Muslims
have lived near each other in social and cultural fields. Then the Christians also kept in touch
with these two. Today all the community like Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, Jains, Christians and
other people of other religions are equal participants in government, governance and other
areas of public life. During this way, we will say that there has been continuous unity in India
even in extreme diversity. This diversity is reflected in thousands of caste groups, each with
different religious rites, rites, rules and customs. We will feel the difference in linguistic,
religious and ethnic differences. There are differences within the ways of the people of every
region, even among different castes and non-secular groups in a village.
Emperor Ashoka tried to bring about the unity of India by achieving cultural and
religious harmony and administrative acumen. The Mughal emperor Akbar implemented the
concept of state religion in the name of Din-i-Ilahi, which is Hindu religion, and was a
synthesis of Islam. Most of the Muslims in the villages had become so converted that it was
difficult to distinguish them. In all spheres of social life except marriage, Muslims freely
mingled with Hindus23. Hindu kings and Muslim emperors respected literary and artistic
talent in both communities24. Kabir and Nanak were greatly influenced by the teachings of
Islam. The adoption of Islam, Christianity and Buddhism led to the emergence of a "mixed"
culture in India. Mahatma Gandhi, the father of the nation, tried to achieve national unity and
integrity throughout his life by promoting communal harmony, upliftment of the poor and
downtrodden and promoting a just social order. Colonial India had two histories. One was the
history of colonialism built by the colonists and the other of the culture and civilization of
India which was based on its intellectual and philosophical zeal 25. The history of India, which
includes its architectural treasure, literature and philosophy, music, theatrical science, dance
and Lalita art, etc., which have a definite contribution in the social life of India, the British
Raj could not destroy them. This second history remained dormant in the English period.
Mahatma Gandhi wanted to bring about a radical change keeping in mind the tradition and
cultural heritage of India. Jawaharlal Nehru, the architect of modern India, respected the
23
Mansingh, S. (2006). Historical dictionary of India. Scarecrow Press. p.244.
Rao, R. N., & Thombre, A. (2014). Intercultural communication: the Indian context. SAGE Publications India.
pp. 15-147.
25
Kulke, H,&Rothermund, T. (2016). A history of India. Routledge.p13
24
10
tradition of India despite being a man of modern and secular ideology. According to Nehru,
―The past is always with us and whatever we are and have with us is all a product of our past.
We are a product of it and remain immersed in it. Connect the past to the present
And to carry it to the future where this union is not possible, to leave it there and to make it all
vibrate and swell for thought and action is life." In another place, Nehru wrote about India's
cultural heritage. ―The emerging middle class wanted to stick to the cultural heritage, because
it made them realize their importance and to some extent also reduced the sense of defeat and
humiliation which had arisen in them due to foreign conquest and rule. India's past, which is
full of cultural diversity and greatness, is a common heritage of Hindu, Muslim, Christian and
all other Indian peoples, and the contribution of all these ancestors in its creation. But Nehru
was against the domination of the redundant elements of the past over the present. In fact,
Nehru was a man with a very democratic spirit and a modern outlook26.
India is said to be a synthesis of diverse social and cultural elements. It is a fusion of Aryan
and Dravidian cultures. As a result of this synthesis, unity is found in the village, family, caste
and legal system. The continuity of Indian society from ancient times to the present day is
maintained by this synthesis. From Mohenjodaro (2500 BC) to Buddhism, Jainism, Islam and
British rule and post-independence India, there is continuity through the process of
sattification and synthesis in the fields of art, painting, music and religion etc. of. M.
Panikkar, a staunch nationalist, taking into account the historicity of synthesis and
assimilation, writes: "I regard culture as a bundle of ideas, concepts, developed qualities and
organized relationships and chivalry which are often found in a society." Panicker says in this
context that equality of thought, uniformity in conduct and behavior and universally accepted
approaches to understanding fundamental problems are based on shared traditions and ideals.
There has been a way of life of Indian culture, due to external contact, it is constantly
modified, but due to being based on indigenous principles and ideas, this system remained
basically "Indian"27. These forms and approaches to Indian culture are reflected in literature,
art and architecture. India has a tradition of religious and social tolerance. This tradition has
contributed to the richness and diversity of social and cultural life in India. The main literary
sources of antiquity are: (1) Sanskrit language and cultural languages, and (2) Dravidian
languages. Vedas, Puranas and Mahabharata and Prakrit and Pali languages are mentioned in
these. Sri Lanka's Itivritta, Buddhicharita and Jain literature are the main historical writings.
The famous works about these three dynasties are Vikramadeva Charita, Prithviraj Vijay and
26
27
Smith, V. A. (1999). The early medival history of India. Atlantic Publishers & Dist.p24
Thapar, R. (2004). Early India: From the origins to AD 1300. University of California Press.p33
11
Ramcharita respectively. The Rajatarangini of Kashmir and the Chronicles of Gujarat are the
other main works. Important texts were written in Tamil, Kannada, Telugu and Malayalam
languages from 1206 to 1761 AD28. Parsi and Arabic languages got a lot of encouragement.
The prehistoric and proto-historic periods are divided into Stone Age, copper age and Iron
Age. This type of classification gives an idea of the physical and technological progress of
man. There is a greater need to acquire knowledge about the economic and social status of
man and his environment. Adequate understanding cannot be obtained from this epochclassification. The following evolutionary process is more informative for understanding the
stages of human progress29.
1. Primitive food storage stage or Adi and Middle Stone Age.
2. Advanced food storage stage or Late Stone Age/Stone Age
3. Early Food Production Transition.
Objectives of the research
To explore the history and society of Khem Karan town in Punjab.
To analyze the occupational mobility among the people of Khem Karan.
To examine the status of generational and intergenerational occupational mobility
within caste and social groups of Khem Karan.
To analyze the factors responsible for socio-occupational mobility
To trace the pattern of upward, downward and static occupational mobility in Khem
Karan town.
SCOPE OF THE STUDY
The present study will be based on the data to be drawn from primary as well as secondary. A
number of scopes available in the form of administrator Accounts, books, journals magazines,
newspapers etc., will be taken into account to enrich the present study. There are two books
Ain-i- Khem Karan and Sitare-e-Khem Karan. A questionnaire will be developed in which
there will be questions with different variables from a specific targeted audience based on this
primary and original information, and the scientific analysis will be carried out to make this
study more authentic and credible.
RESEARCH GAP
Through literature review, it has been discovered that very little lookup has been completed
on generational occupational mobility. This is a very vital theme for lookup this lookup
28
29
Sen, S. N. (1999). Ancient Indian history and civilization. New Age International.p12
Thapar, R. (2017). The Penguin history of the early India: From the origins to AD 1300. Penguin UK.p33
12
purpose is to find out about the History, Society, and Work-related Mobility of Khem Karan.
Khem Karan confronted two wars in 1965 and 1971. It has additionally faced terrorism 1980
from to 1992. Finally, in the 1999 Kargil war, this vicinity once more confronted tragedy.
Due to these wars, this city has been destroyed. This affected their Occupation. This has
undertaken learn about to lengthen or to locate out what precisely is missing in occupational
mobility. This lookup is very new due to the fact it is focusing on the border town.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
This framework is purely inter-disciplinary and multi-disciplinary in social science research
methodology. The historical, descriptive, analytical and critical methodology will be used.
The nature of this exploration work is both qualitative and quantitative. Various methods and
techniques were used in gathering qualitative and quantitative data related to the learning. For
this study analytical study is used for the analysis of data collected from field surveys in the
study area. The IBM 20, SPSS descriptive analysis is used the interpret data. It is based on
both primary and secondary sources. The emphasis is on primary sources. Since there is very
less research in this field has been done, this study had to build the framework and order the
sources.
It will use the report of the pre-colonial and post-colonial period, files of the public and social
welfare department, political department, reform department, home department files,
industrial department, police department, appointment department, legislative and irrigation
department. Gazetteers of Punjab; District gazetteers, Government commission report on
schedule caste and schedule tribes; Census reports and personal interviews and field survey
carried out in the selected regions for the authentic research. For this research, primary field
data have been collected through structured questionnaires with both close and open-ended
questions. The primary data will be collected from 13 wards of the Khem Karan town of
Punjab.
The aforementioned sources are available in the following place, National Archives New
Delhi, Royal Asiatic Society Archives Kolkata, Punjab State Archives and Regional Archives
sources, Nehru Memorial Museum and Library, Central Library at Jawaharlal Nehru
University, New Delhi Central Library, Indian Institute of Advanced Studies, Ratrapati Nivas
Shimla and Lovely professional University central Library etc.
In order to hint out the critical position of this kind of standard gadget in the context of social
as well as occupational mobility in Khem Karan, following methodology used to be adopted:
The above referred to steps had been occurred from addition to the endeavor made by means
of going via Land Settlement Reports, Land-living Circulation and Census reports, more than
13
a few applicable records, journals and lookup reports, accessible in the libraries in Punjab,
National Library in New Delhi and the different causes like private public library of scholars.
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Review of the relevant literature related to inter and intra-generational mobility and related
literature available for Punjab, India and other countries was done. These literatures are the
founding stones of the empirical methods and are helpful in validating our research findings.
Thorough and sincere literature review is important since it helps to appraise, compare,
examine and contrast, and correlate various aspects, several books and other relevant sources
which are directly related to inter and intra-generational occupational mobility as well as
social mobility. Here a systematic effort is made to present a complete picture of inter and
intra-generational occupational mobility and its correlates. We have made every effort to
incorporate most of the work done for the estimation of inter and intra-generational
occupational mobility and its correlates in Punjab.
Some scholarly literature not directly focusing on Punjab has also been listed for the purpose
of better understanding of tools and methods used in the estimation and examining social and
occupational mobility. The chapter also deals with classifying our literature which is
impactful to understand the present condition of social mobility in India.
Syallfors, S. (2007), in this book analyzing Inequality summarizes key problems in today`s
theoretically guided empirical studies on social inequality, lifestyles course, and cross-country
wide comparative sociology. It describes the development made in phrases of statistics
sources, each cross-sectional and longitudinal; the brand new units that make inequality
studies possible; new approaches of questioning and explaining; and empirical findings or
essential contributions of rigorous empirical studies to our understanding. The chapters, every
written with the aid of using a prominent social scientist, are a hobby for each student and
student. This is the most effective-e-book thus far to take inventory of the country of the
artwork in stratification studies, inspecting statistics, methods, theory, and new empirical
findings. Analyzing Inequality gives a strangely and impressively extensive insurance of
sizeable subjects inside the field.
Hertel, F. R. (2016) book "Social Mobility in the 20th Century: Class Mobility and
Occupational Change in the United States and Germany" is primarily based totally on a
singular elegance scheme and a completely unique compilation of German and American
data, this e-book famous that intergenerational elegance mobility elevated over a maximum of
the beyond the century. While of variations in intergenerational mobility is enormously small,
14
gender, regional, racial and ethnic variations had been first of all big but declined over time.
At the cease of the twentieth century, however, mobility possibilities grew to become the
more serious in each nation. In mild of those findings, the e-book develops a story account of
historic socio-political trends which can be possible to have pushed the fundamental
resemblances throughout nations however additionally account for the preliminary decline
and the extra current boom in intergenerational inequality.
Bottomore, T. B. (2010) first published in 1962, this seminal painting is an advent to
sociology in an international context, and a complicated manual to the foremost subject
matters, issues and controversies in cutting-edge sociology. The ee-e book stays precise in its
enterprise and presentation of sociological thoughts and issues, in its loss of insularity (its
huge insurance of various styles of society and of sociological idea from diverse cultural
traditions), and in its systematic connection of sociology with the extensive subject matters of
contemporary-day social and political idea.
Three most vital concepts of combat stand out: struggle ought to be seen as an instrument of
politics; the military ambitions in a battle that information one's political desires fall into two
types: "war to get restrained aims" and hostilities to "disarm" the enemy; and the route of the
fighting will scope to favor the birthday social gathering with the higher emotional and
political motivations and philosophical, on the other hand in particular the defender.
This model is the classical translation of On War (1873) by way of the use of Col. J.J.
Graham, with a commencing and notes via way of Colonel F.N. Maude, posted in three
volumes. A must-read for military historians and theorists, policymakers, and all people
involved in hold close the philosophy and ideas of war.
This version is the classical translation of On War (1873) by means of Col. J.J. Graham,
with a beginning and notes by using Colonel F.N. Maude, posted in three volumes. A mustread for navy historians and theorists, policymakers, and everybody involved in grasp the
philosophy and ideas of war.
Bisht, R. (2014), talk about the thought related to mobility why does a team of stranded
paratroopers name for Bofors' hearth upon its personal position? Why is an historic man in
Palampur combat for justice for his lifeless soldier son? What makes a martyr's father go to a
younger Kashmiri woman each and every year? Kargil takes you into the treacherous
mountains the place some of the Indian Army's bloodiest battles have been fought. The end
result will be confronted like social and occupation mobility on conflict place. Interviewing
struggle survivors and martyrs' families, Rachna Bisht Rawat tells testimonies of exceptional
human courage, of now not simply guys in uniform however additionally these who cherished
15
them the most. With its gritty testimonies of incomparable bravery, Kargil is a tribute to the
527 younger braves who gave up their lives for us-and the many who had been equipped to do
it too.
Colonel S. C. Tyagi (1999), wrote the e book The Kargil Victory: Battles from Peak to Peak
and all through this e book they highlighted Early in May 1999, when phrase got here from a
shepherd looking for his strayed yak that some mysterious guys in black garments have been
clambering around on the frozen hilltops of Kargil, no one should have predicted that it would
be the precursor to a full-fledged armed battle between India and Pakistan. Over the
subsequent a number of weeks, the Indian Army answered with courage, center of attention
and tremendous professionalism to craft a complete victory, recapturing all the posts that had
been occupied by means of stealth via the Pakistani Army.
This Himalayan showdown is added alive in those pages via the phrases of a veteran Indian
Army officer who become gift for the duration of the struggle are and, for the primary time,
recounts each his very own stories and the tales of the heroic infantrymen who fought and
gained fierce battles from one height to another. He narrates the man or woman and collective
acts of bravery and the astute navy techniques that gained the conflict for India. Containing
specified maps, eye-witness debts and photographs, The Kargil Victory is a thorough,
inspiring and this book for all folks that need to understand the actual tale of the Kargil War.
Hoskins, K., & Barker, B. (2014) e book Education and Social Mobility describe the
Government's plans to enhance upward mobility in European international locations and
considers the probabilities of success in the highlights of qualitative interviews with 88
college students. The fifteen to nineteen years historical in two country secondary and senior
secondary have been interacted to replicate on their lives, schooling and goals of the future.
Their rapid responses provide captivating insights into younger people's aspirations, picks and
decisions, and they recommend that governments constantly underestimate the resistances to
mobility that are embedded in social and occupational structures. This school-based lookup is
mixed with energetic evaluation of the standards and troubles entailed in perception social
mobility and change. It is vital studying for the coverage makers and every person who is
fascinated in the extent to which schooling can trade and enhance in society on a international
level. It provides records and theoretical insights for lecturers and practitioners, and is an
authoritative advice for undergraduate and post-graduate college students following
publications on the other hand these publications deal with adolescence identities, schooling
research and social justice. The e book raises essential doubts about contemporary coverage
and proposes a optimistic choice for all our children.
16
Turner, F. C. (Ed.). (1992) explain in his book Social Mobility and Political Attitudes:
Comparative Perspectives, which discusses the social mobility in different levels of social
areas that symbolize countries across the world. Yet till recently, we've got had few empirical
investigations and no systematic global comparisons of the way mobility has affected the
political attitudes of residents in one of a kind countries. Scholars have assumed that mobility
have to be affecting attitudes, however they've now no longer examined their assumptions. As
Lipset notes in his starting remarks: "The key problem which the essays on this quantity deal
with higher and greater very well than any preceding paintings is the impact of experiencing
social mobility, each upward and downward, at the politics of individuals. "This quantity
examines what kind of effect social mobility has on mass politics, and past that, from what
reasserts and with what results. It seeks solutions to this interrelationship with the aid of using
going past the everyday reasserts in Europe and the United States, into research of the
mobility enjoy in Asia, Africa, and Latin America. An important end is that peoples` attitudes
are decided with the aid of using their popularity of vacation spot some distance greater than
with the aid of using their popularity of starting place or with the aid of using the system of
transferring popularity to other. Turner holds that mobility does now no longer actually boom
thru the system of monetary improvement. It additionally works to rationalize and allocate the
human assets which might be essential factors on this system. The query of facilitating
monetary increase with the aid of using permitting humans of expertise to upward push to
positions of authority brings into awareness now no longer best troubles of social mobility
and political attitude, however the very foundations of fairness dreams in capitalist, socialist
and blended economies. This quantity offers a essential rethinking of the vintage literature on
mobility and politics, and a reassessment of interpretive schemes primarily based totally upon
it Turner's findings imply that a whole lot is to be found out from subjecting even loved
assumptions to the pains of survey studies and analytical techniques. The nature of the
mobility enjoys and its political effect relies upon at the particularities of the kingdom
studied. These instances allow appreciation of the function of occupational differentiation and
monetary improvement in any respect degrees of the political and social system.
Smelser, N. J., &Lipset, S. M. (Eds.). (1966), this book is based on Social Structure and
Mobility in Economic Development, the notion of this extent is the appreciation that the
several strategies of alternate constituting economic and social enchantment are
systematically interrelated. The essence of enchantment is the arrival of rapid expenses of will
extend in a lot of particular indices output in preserving with capita, political participation,
literacy and the like. These quantitative changes are, however, normally located with the
17
resource of the use of extensive changes within side the social form markets emerge, political
bureaucracies arise, and new educational constructions appear. Written with the useful
resource of the use of the predominant authorities at the subject, this business enterprise of
papers tackles the motives and outcomes of social mobility. Each author brings his particular
abilities to bear on several factors of the hassle in lookup of human beings moving from rural
to town settings, from one kind of corporation to each different and from one fame stage to
each other. Several of the papers contrast the theoretical and methodological troubles worried
in comparative studies on social mobility at the same time as others consider and evaluation
traditional and contemporary-day stratification structures. Various papers find out the
financial, non-secular and intellectual basis of social mobility, concluding with enquiry into
the outcomes of fast mobility, in specific in phrases of the political stability of developing
nations. Because social mobility is a major interest in any have a look at of monetary and
social alternate, every pupil of alternate will use this pioneering reference grant as a textual
content material for all future studies. Contributors consist of quite a few scholars, writers for
example- Otis Dudley Duncan, Harold L.
Shah, G. (Ed.) (2004), this book is elaborating contribute in the field of caste as well as
democratic political in India, the Indian constitution seeks to prevent the perpetuation of caste
and build a casteless social system.
But in over half a century since Indian independence, this has not been achieved and does not
seem likely in the near future. Therefore, no understanding of Indian politics is possible
without a thorough understanding of the complexities of the caste system. The aim of this
four-part book is to bring about such an under stable.
Chaman (2020) in his paper Social and occupational mobility‘s in India: Determinants and
Recommendations for Change‖, suggested that occupational mobility is the process by which
one person moves from one position to another, and accordingly, their rewards and
opportunities are attached to that. During their lifetime, they move up or down in the socioeconomic strata. Overall, there is progress in Indian society, but in terms of social mobility,
India lags behind compared to other countries; it is due to the unequal access to opportunities
of all kinds. They also explored occupational and income in India, and suggested
recommendations for increasing social mobility. While comparing intergenerational mobility
with between generations, it was found that in terms of education, occupation and income;
children are (growing up) earning more than their parents. By comparing cohort wise social
mobility among scheduled caste/scheduled tribe with non-scheduled caste/scheduled tribe,
they found that scheduled caste/scheduled tribe mobility was declining as compared to non18
scheduled caste/scheduled tribe.
Otis Dudley Duncan (1965) written the book and in his study ‗The set of Occupational
Mobility in the United States tried to analyze Inter and intra-generational mobility matrices
for 1962 may be used to infer the occupation distributions of certain cohorts in 1952, 1942,
and 1932, on the assumption that patterns of mobility to these dates were the same, for men of
comparable age, as the patterns observed in 1962.
Devendra B. Gupta (1968) in his study A Comparison of Consumption Patterns in Uttar
Pradesh and Madras-A Study of Inter-regional Variations with Reference to India tried to
attempt to examine the possibility of inter-regional variations in consumer behavior in India,
taking into account the influence of household size. For this purpose, two major states of
India, Uttar Pradesh (briefly, U.P.) and Madras, have been selected. These two states are
known to exhibit interesting economic, social and cultural differences. Further, the
conclusions based on the study of these two states are likely to be indicative in some measure
of the consumption habits of the people in the rest of the country, as the former constitutes a
predominantly wheat-consuming state and the latter a rice-consuming state. This analysis is
carryout separately for urban and rural households in the two states.
N.K.Nijhawan (1969) in his work ―Inter-Generational Occupational Mobility‖ attempted to
estimate the over-representation of persons of certain origins and under-representation of
others. This study is based on data from the general election of 1967 conducted by CSDS
Delhi and 1593 male cases were selected for the analysis. Rogoff‘s index is a ratio of actual
mobility to its expected value. The extent and pattern of mobility of sons of various social
origins vary from class to class, the extent of in mobility in various occupational classes
differs quite appreciably and last the system does not offer equal occupational opportunities to
sons of all origin.
I P Desai (1971) in his work Understanding Occupational Change in India tried to analyze
occupational change as change in the activities of the members of a society to earn their
livelihood. The terms changes in the distribution of these activities in the socio-economic
structure of society. As the social implications of these occupational changes are concerned,
generally recourse is taken to study of occupational groups, their social characteristics, etc. In
these types of study, social mobility is a favorite subject. This feeling of inadequacy can be
pinpointed to activities being made the central point of observation and analysis and their
being related to some of the economic, social and psychological attributes of different
occupational groups. It is suggested that irrespective of the number and variety of
occupational activities and the number of persons engaged in them, there could be
19
occupational change if there is a change in social relationships. In India occupational change
in this sense is taking place more widely than statistics of change in the number and variety of
activities suggested.
Robert M. Hauser and David L. Featherman (1973) in his work there have been shifts
toward the ranks of salaried experts and managers and professional personnel and away from
the ranks of proprietors, personnel and farmers. This changes may additionally be described
as a shift from information to non-manual occupations blended with shifts from minimize to
higher reputation occupations internal every the information and no information groups.
Changing occupational origins money owed for a modest upgrading of the occupation
distribution, while changes in mobility to first jobs have no systematic effect.
The ancient vogue of upward mobility amongst U.S. guys is neither uniform nor inevitable.
There used to be more alternate in occupational mobility patterns in 1962-1970 than in 19521962, on the other hand a good deal much less than in 1942- 1952. The continuation of
ancient features of occupational mobility is strictly constrained by means of way of the
depletion of occupation groups-service workers, humans and farmers-which have till now
served as sources of recruitment into increased repute occupations.
Patric M. Horan (1974) in his study ―Structure of Occupational Mobility: Conceptualization
and Analysis‖ explored the conceptual and theory base of existing mobility research and
proposes a new approach to the analysis pattern in occupational mobility. This study used
data from socioeconomic survey of Puna city in west-central India in 1954. This study takes
only adult males for consideration. He has used the occupational classification originally
developed by Gokhale Institute which constitutes an ordinal measure of the socioeconomic
status of the occupational classification. Prestige has not been considered the sole basis for
intergenerational movement between occupations.
Gary S. Becker and Nigel Tomes (1979) in his work An Evenness Theory of the
Distribution of Income and Inter-generational Mobility tried to work on the theory of
inequality and intergenerational mobility presented in This essay assumes that every own
circle of relatives maximizes a software characteristic spanning numerous generations. Utility
relies upon at the intake of mother and father and on the amount and nice in their kids. The
earnings of kids are raised once they get hold of greater human and nonhuman capital from
their mother and father. Their earnings is likewise raised via way of means of their
"endowment" of genetically decided race, ability, and different characteristics, own circle of
relatives recognition and "connections," and knowledge, skills, and desires supplied via way
of means of their own circle of relatives environment. The fortunes of kids are connected to
20
their mother and father now no longer best via investments however additionally via those
endowments received from mother and father (and different own circle of relatives members).
The equilibrium earnings of kids is decided via way of means of their marketplace and
endowed luck, the very own earnings and endowment of mother and father, and the 2
parameters, the diploma of inheritability and the propensity to spend money on kids. If those
parameters are each much less than unity, the distribution of earnings among households
techniques a desk bound distribution. The desk bound coefficient of variant is greater, the
bigger the diploma of in heritability and the smaller the propensity to spend money on kids.
Intergenerational mobility measures the impact of an own circle of relatives at the wellness of
its kids. We display that the own circle of relatives is greater vital while the diploma of
inheritability and the propensity to make investments are larger. If each those parameters are
much less than unity, a growth in own circle of relatives earnings in a single era has negligible
outcomes at the in- comes of plenty later descendants. However, the earning of kids,
grandchildren, and different early descendants ought to drastically growth; indeed, if the sum
of those parameters exceeds unity, the modifications in earnings upward thrust for numerous
generations earlier than falling, and the most growth in earnings ought to exceed the
preliminary growth.
Dirk Van de Gaer; & Michel Martinez; & Erik Schokkaert, (1998) in his study
"Measuring Intergenerational Mobility and Equality of Opportunity tried to explores the
hyperlink among the size of intergenerational mobility and the perception of equality of
possibility. He indicates how currently proposed theories of equality of possibility may be
meaningfully tailored to the intergenerational context. This take a look at throws new mild on
the translation of current mobility measures. This can be thrilling to degree mobility as
movement; however they're insufficient to seize the perception of equality of possibility. He
proposed a few new mobility measures, which begin from the concept that the
intergenerational transition matrix offers beneficial statistics approximately the possibility
units of the kids of various social classes. These measures are utilized in an empirical instance
to assess the diploma of inequality of possibility within side the US, Great Britain and Italy.
Abhiman Das (1999) in his work socio-economic enchantment in India: a regional contrast
tried to showcase enchantment is a multi-dimensional phenomenon. Some of its important
dimensions include: the stage of economic growth, diploma of education, stage of health
services, diploma of modernization, reputation of women, diploma of nutrition, exceptional of
housing, distribution of gadgets and services, and get admission to dialog in India, the
improvement of socio-economic improvement amongst most important states is now not
21
uniform. These discover out about examines the current variability of inter-state enchantment
and thereby figuring out the signs guilty for the change in development. as a replacement of
inspecting the variability of a particular variable for the duration of states, a composite index
based totally definitely on a wide variety of warning signs and symptoms has been developed
the use of vital problem assessment and states are prepared in accordance to the indices
derived the utilization of four considerably famous components: (a) economic manufacturing
and monetary state of affairs or in exclusive phrases stage of monetary development; (b)
regularly occurring minimal needs; (c) health and health-related choices and (d)
communication. The findings of the assessment assist the common draw close about the
states. The states in India are marked with massive disparity in socio-economic development.
the factors, which are decided out to be larger quintessential for the regular enchantment
process, relate to most important needs like education, availability of food, minimal shopping
for electrical energy and offerings like tightly closed consuming water, health care
infrastructure, etc. it is moreover located that enrollment ratio cannot be raised till minimal
wishes of the ordinary human beings are satisfied. Therefore, true enchantment requires
authority‘s action to decorate vital education, blanketed eating water services and health care,
and to dispose of boundaries in opposition to social minorities, in unique women. The role of
social enchantment such as literacy (and in precise of female literacy) in marketing
quintessential knowledge emerges as the prerequisite to everyday development. These
consequences truly emphasize the role of well-functioning public strikes in improving the
fashionable living conditions of the people. Although monetary growth in the ride of growing
gross united states of America extensive product and one-of-a-kind related variables is one of
the most critical inputs to the normal enchantment process, the principal purpose of
enchantment need to core of interest on the increase of human knowledge which has been left
out for prolonged in India.
James Mclntosh& Martin D. Munk (2007) in their study ―Social Class, Family Background
and Intergenerational Mobility‖ tries to examine the various approaches taken by economist
and sociologist for analyzing intergenerational mobility. Probability model, Logit model and
Regression model has been used to analyze Danish sample survey data in this study.
Homogeneity test and likelihood ratio test fails in Denmark case for Erickson- Gold Thorpe
(EG) classification system. The individual‘s family background has a small significant impact
on impact on lifetime chance.
Ashish Singh (2010)written a book and in his study social justice of opportunity in India tries
to analysis inequality of opportunities with final results variations that may be accounted
22
through predetermined instances which lie past the manipulate of an individual, which
includes parental training, parental career, caste, faith and vicinity of birth. The ordinary
possibility proportion estimates (parametric) of overall intake expenditure inequality because
of a fixed of instances comprising of caste, faith, geographical location, parental training and
parental career range from 16% to 25% in city India. The corresponding figures for rural
regions stand at 20% and 23%. The evaluation in addition famous that, parental training is the
fundamental contributor to the possibility proportion of intake expenditure inequality in city
India, however caste and geographical location additionally play a similarly critical function
while rural India is considered.
Rajarshi Majumder (2010) in his work ―Intergenerational Mobility in Educational and
Occupational mobility: A Comparative Study of Social Class in India‖ examined how teens
schooling and occupation is associated to parental standard. In this study, mobility matrix,
OLS regression, logistic regression and correlation have been used as tools. Two quintal
surveys of NSSOs fiftieth and 61th spherical carried out in the year 1993 and 2004
respectively has been used as facts source. Author tries to quantify the diploma of
intergenerational upward mobility in training and occupation. In findings, the hierarchy has
remained biased in favor of superior castes even after sixty eight years of independence.
Upward mobility is greater mentioned for whilst parental influences and inertia is lots more
suitable for excluded castes. Occupational mobility is decrease than instructional mobility and
occupational motion is inside wide occupational grades is no longer full-size especially for
ECs.
Hyun H. Son (2011) in his discover out about On the Concept of Equity in Opportunity tried
to measure the equity of risk in a given society is a integral ingredient in the aspects of
insurance plan insurance policies and programs that promote inclusive growth. In this paper,
equity of threat is described and measured by means of the theoretical framework of the social
hazard function, a concept same to the social welfare function. The purposeful and graphical
distribution of opportunity is referred to by way of the generalized Lorenz curve and the
Bonferroni curve, at the same time as a complete ranking of distributions is carried out
through their related numerical indices: the attention index and the Bonferroni index of
opportunity, respectively. The thoughts of relative and absolute measures of equity of chance
are then introduced and a social likelihood index that considers every the volume and
distribution of likelihood is developed. These measures are used to analyze adjustments in the
probabilities for health care and education in the Philippines from 1998 to 2007.
A. Bheemeshwar Reddy & Madhura Swaminathan (2014) in their work ―Intergenerational
23
Work-related Mobility in Rural India: Evidences from Ten Villages‖ examined intergenerational occupational mobility in ten villages across India. Mobility Matrix approach has
been followed for two father son pairs: head of households and their father and head of
households and co-resident adult sons. Author used four-fold occupational classification and
collected data from ten villages in different agro ecological regions in five states of the
country. The major findings of the study suggest immobility among big farmers on the one
hand and rural manual workers on the other. Also immobility has been found higher among
manual workers from Scheduled Caste category in comparison to other caste categories.
Upward mobility out of the category of rural manual work was much lower for SC men than
for the men from other categories.
Joseph Van Matre (2012) in his work he Human Opportunity Index and Income Inequality
in Brazil tried to calculates the Human Opportunity Index (HOI) proposed by de Barros et al.
(2009) and a Gini Index of household income using nationally representative data from Brazil
for the years 2001 to 2008. Macro regional HOIs and Gini Indexes were also calculated for
the years 2001, 2005, and 2008. No statistically significant, linear trends were found over the
eight year period for national HOIs. Also, there was a statistically significant decrease in the
macro regional variance of HOI scores, indicating a convergence of opportunity equity among
macro regions. No such convergence was found for the macro regional Gini Indexes.
Mehtabul Azam (2013) in his work ―Inter-generational Work-related Mobility in India‖
found intergenerational occupational mobility in India among men born during 1945- 1985
and also examined the differential in mobility across social groups. IHDS 2005 data includes
in itself father‘s occupations for majority of adult males. Mobility matrix, Altham‘s statistics
and odd ratio have been used in this study. Study concludes that persistence in transmission of
white collar job from father to sons has declined over time. The probability of someone born
to unskilled father getting a white collar job has been declining.
Priyabrata Sahoo (2020) in his learns about Trends in Consumption Pattern; A Comparative
Study of Odisha and India, Consumption expenditure is an essential indicator of popular of
living. As a u. s. a. turns into extra developed its expenditure share on meals declines and the
expenditure share on non-food increases. Both in Orissa as properly as in India the share on
meals expenditure has been declining whereas the share of the non-food expenditure has been
increasing. The stage of consumption expenditure of Orissa is decrease than India. It is the
middle-income team whose share in the complete expenditure has been declining over the
year. The decrease earnings team indicates a make bigger in the share of expenditure which is
quicker than the pinnacle earnings group. The Rural place indicates amplify in non-food
24
expenditure which is quicker than the city areas. Though the consumption of cereal volume
has declined for all earnings companies in phrases of expenditure share it is growing for the
backside 30% profits crew in rural areas and growing for the backside 30% and pinnacle 30%
due to fantastic version of cereal.
Irene Brunetti and Davide Fiaschi (2019) in his work Occupational Mobility: Theory and
an Application to Italy provides a model the place intergenerational occupational mobility is
the joint end result of profits incentives, equality of probability and occupational shifts, which
rationalizes the use of transition matrices to measure mobility and approves to problematic
three artificial mobility indexes without delay referring to every determinant. The estimate of
the mannequin for a pattern of Italian heads of family born in the duration 1947-1976
suggests that occupational mobility used to be consistent over time, as the end result of a
growing mobility due to occupational shifts, a reducing mobility due to earnings incentives,
and a steadiness of equality of opportunity. The growing value of schooling seems as one of
the foremost elements to give an explanation for the fall in earnings incentives.
25
CHAPTER I
Khem Karan (Punjab): Geographical Profile
The physical earth and its inhabitants, in their intricate and multidimensional connections,
form the true essence of the earth. While human ingenuity, advancements, technological
capabilities, and aspirations undoubtedly have a significant impact on shaping and
transforming places and regions, the physical environment also plays a crucial role.
Therefore, it is essential to acknowledge the significance of the physical environment, despite
the various humanistic and postmodern perspectives. In this regard, having some
understanding of the physical geography of Punjab is relevant for comprehending its history
and culture. Similarly, a meaningful understanding of Punjab's geography can only be
achieved with the aid of its history. The location of Punjab in the north-west of the Indian
sub-continent holds great geographical and historical importance. The region is surrounded by
towering mountains to its west, northwest, and north. Among the various mountain complexes
and barriers encircling the Indian sub-continent, the Pamir Knot, often referred to as the
highest point on earth, stands out as one of the most intricate points from which high
mountain ranges extend in all directions. To the west of the Pamirs lies the Hindu Kush,
followed by a maze of hills on the northwest frontier that merge into the Sulaiman Range
between Punjab and northern Baluchistan. A recess in this barrier, with the Bolan Pass at its
head, separates the Sulaiman Range from the Kirthar Range, which lies between Sind and
southern Baluchistan. The Sulaiman and Kirthar ranges, stretching from the Makran coast
towards the Pamirs, are the primary mountain ranges in the west.
The Himalayan Mountains exert a significant influence on Punjab's soil quality,
climate, and seclusion. It is aptly contended that the linchpin to the sub-continent's geography,
particularly its northwestern precinct, lies beyond rather than within its confines, though its
primary effects are indeed felt within. The Himalayas are undergoing rapid erosion,
contributing fertile loam to the plains below. Rivers transport sediment, replenishing soil
fertility through annual inundations. This alluvial deposit is notably substantial, with borings
having penetrated depths of approximately 1300 feet without reaching bedrock. The plain
exhibits exceptional flatness on the whole. The sub-continent predominantly experiences a
tropical climate. The Himalayan barrier effectively shields the sub-continent from the frigid
northern winds of the Asiatic continental shield, simultaneously channeling and intensifying
the monsoon winds originating from tropical seas. The primary means of traversing the
mountainous frontiers remain reliant on mules and camels during seasons of passability.
Indeed, within these mountainous zones, the topography proves exceedingly challenging and
26
intricate, impeding human mobility and interaction in various sectors, notwithstanding
technological advancements.
Prior to Alexander the Great's conquest in 326 BCE, the northwestern frontier served as the
gateway for invaders. The Khyber Pass leads to Kabul in Afghanistan, while the Bolan Pass
provides access to Quetta in Baluchistan, with the Gomal Pass situated between them. These
gateways hold significant historical import for the region. Despite considerable reduction, the
glaciers of the Himalayas and Tibet, including the Karakoram, still house the largest
remaining glaciers worldwide outside sub-polar regions. The Siachen glacier, of considerable
strategic significance, spans a length of 720 kilometers. Western glaciers, of substantial size,
descend to lower altitudes, reaching as low as 7000-8000 feet in Kashmir.
The British Punjab, centered around the land of five rivers - the Satluj, Beas, Ravi, Chanab,
and Jhelum - covered an expanse of 346,389 square kilometers, nearly seven times the area of
the present-day East Punjab following its reorganization. While the macro-regional
perspective of the land's physical geography has remained largely unaltered, the recent
administrative divisions have brought about localized changes in its landscape, particularly
when viewed from a micro-level vantage. These micro-level alterations in both physical and
non-physical attributes hold significance in the evolving landscapes and ongoing
developmental processes, likely to exert notable influence in the years ahead. Consequently,
references to East and West Punjab‘s in discussions of their physical geography are pertinent
as warranted by the context.
Situated in the northwestern region, bordering states and distant from maritime access points,
East Punjab stands as an inland state par excellence. Its triangular configuration extends from
29°30‘N to 32°32‘N latitude and 73°55‘E to 76°50‘E longitude. The state's proximity to
Pakistan on the west, the critical state of Jammu and Kashmir to the north, Himachal Pradesh
to the northeast and east, and Haryana to the southeast and south underscores its sensitive
geographical location. With a compact area of 50,362 square kilometers, East Punjab enjoys
facile accessibility across its entirety, a factor of substantial import in terms of socioeconomic advancement and defense. Western Punjab (in Pakistan) is flanked to its far north
and northwest by the NWFP, bordered by the snow-clad Hindu Kush mountains and the
towering Karakoram Range.
Relief
Situated amidst the Yamuna River to the east and extending beyond the Indus in the west, the
Punjab region is encompassed by a dissected foothill area and the Shivalik Hills in the
northeast and north. It spans an expansive alluvial plain with a gentle incline, descending
27
from approximately 350 meters above sea level in the northeast and north to about 180 meters
in the southwest. The southwestern periphery exhibits a desertic and undulating terrain,
which, over time, has progressively leveled due to agricultural expansion and irrigation. At a
micro-regional scale, human activities have played a significant role in reshaping surface
topography, notably more so in East Punjab compared to its western counterpart. This region
is characterized by a substantial deposit of alluvial sediment carried down by the Indus and
the five rivers, converging in the southwest at Panjnad, meaning "five streams". Between the
Yamuna and the Satluj in the east, the Ghaggar River and its tributaries have also contributed
to this alleviation process, forming what is now known as the Malwa Tract. With roughly 90
percent of its total area comprising plains, including low-lying floodplains along the rivers
and uniformly flat upland plains interspersed between them, Punjab represents a vast expanse
of level terrain. This topographical feature, among others, has facilitated extensive land
cultivation, widespread irrigation where implemented, and the construction of roads and
railways as far as practicable. Leveraging this favorable topography, East Punjab, covering
84 percent of the total land area, is extensively cultivated, with 95 percent of the total cropped
area being irrigated. Moreover, virtually all villages are connected by paved roads, conferring
a distinct advantage over West Punjab, where significant strides are still needed in these
developmental endeavors. To the west of the Jhelum Chenab flood plain, there is a marked
decrease in the proportion of cultivated land relative to the total land area, corresponding to
heightened arid conditions and a decline in irrigated acreage. Rural access roads are similarly
sparse in the western districts, which grapple with desert-like conditions.
The only exceptions to the alluvial uniformity of the flat plains are small clusters of arid,
rugged hills near Sangla and Kirana, flanking either side of the Chenab. While these
formations occupy a limited extent, they rise in jagged peaks roughly 1000 feet above the
plains, representing significant geomorphologic interest as outliers of the Aravalli system.
Additionally, there is evidence of concealed ridges extending the Aravalli axis between Delhi
and Hardvar. Broadly, on this a gradational surface of the plains, the primary topographical
alterations are linked to the myriad shifts and diversions in the courses of rivers, along with
developmental activities associated with agricultural expansion and irrigation. The floodplains
along the rivers consist of newly deposited alluvium, whereas the upland plains above
comprise older sediment. The interfluves are denoted by composite names derived from their
enclosing streams: Bist Doab (between Satluj and Beas), Bari Doab (between Beas and Ravi),
Rachna Doab (between Ravi and Chenab), and Chaj Doab (between Chenab and Jhelum).
28
Land-form Regions
At the macro-regional scale, the Punjab plain presents itself as a predominantly level expanse
devoid of distinctive features. However, a closer examination at micro-regional levels reveals
a considerable diversity in relief. The entirety of the Punjab region may be categorized into
the following landform types:
NW Himalayas Source: RG
The Shivalik Hills
The region is bordered by the Shivalik hills, encompassing the northwest, north, and
northeast. These hills extend eastward to the Kosi River, tracing the foothills of the
Himalayas. They exhibit notable width in the northwest and north, tapering to a narrow zone
in the northeast. Comprising substantial deposits of Mio-Pleistocene sands, gravels, and
conglomerates, the Shivalik are primarily erosion products of the Himalayas. Relatively
modest in height (often below 1000 meters), they serve as a testament to the youthfulness of
the mountain-building process. These hills are accompanied by a series of discontinuous
longitudinal valleys (duns) along their rear. The front facing the plains is notably even and
regular. Elevations within the Shivalik hills range between 300 to 1000 meters above sea
29
level, presenting a marked contrast to the predominantly level terrain found elsewhere. Their
denudation and dissection, coupled with historical deforestation, have left them sparsely
covered with bush and stunted vegetation. The substantial impact of their denudation persists
in the foot-hill zone below.
The Dissected Foot-hill Zone
Stretching along the base of the Shivalik hills is a narrow, undulating zone spanning 10 to
15 kilometers in width. In East Punjab, a highway connects Chandigarh to Pathankot via
Hoshiarpur. This area is traversed by seasonal streams known locally as "chos," originating
from the Shivalik hills above. Most of these streams emerged subsequent to deforestation
efforts aimed at meeting timber needs. The chos are generally closely spaced, sometimes as
little as one kilometer apart, and their courses are relatively short, typically disappearing as
inland streams after a span of ten to fifteen kilometers. These chos have contributed to
widespread soil erosion, gully erosion, farmland degradation, and a decline in the water table.
Their impacts have reverberated across various aspects of human life throughout the zone to
varying degrees. Part of this foot-hill zone is referred to locally as the "Kandi tract."
Characterized by closely spaced chos and the associated dissection of land, convex interfluves
between the chos, undulating surface configuration, and coarse, stony soils, this region has
presented obstacles to development. Recent efforts have focused on addressing these
challenges, including the bridging of chos, the construction of state highways and rural link
roads, and the restoration of accessibility and mobility in most parts of the Kandi. However,
the water table remains relatively deep, posing challenges for small-scale farmers in installing
their own tube wells. The state government has played a crucial role in providing assistance,
and re-afforestation programs are in need of efficient and expeditious implementation.
The Upland Plains
The upland plains comprise interfluvial tracts sloping gradually westward from the Satluj to
the Indus. These plains consist primarily of ancient alluvial deposits originating from major
rivers descending from the Himalayas. While appearing largely flat and devoid of distinct
features, they generally slope from northeast to southwest, with elevations decreasing by
approximately four meters per kilometer in upper regions, and by less than one meter per
kilometer in lower areas. While the overall surface cover results from river-induced
alleviation throughout the region, wind action has played a significant role in the southern and
southwestern fringe lands. Notably, the southern portion of the Sind-Sagar Doab is part of the
Thal desert, a designation that also applies to the former Bahawalpur state. In these Thal
regions, the surface is characterized by sand dunes, some of which reach heights of about 100
30
feet above the plain level. While the Thal region remains predominantly desertic, concerted
efforts have been made to level and cultivate the Western Malwa tract, which was once
strewn with sand dunes. These efforts, facilitated by canal and tubewell irrigation, have
transformed the area into a well-developed plain. The southern regions of West Punjab,
characterized by a drier climate compared to their eastern counterparts, exhibit different
surface conditions. The southern section of the Sind-Sagar Doab has not been covered by
inundation canal irrigation and retains its former desert relief in parts. Similarly, conditions in
the southern Bari and Rachna Doabs are arid, and these areas are referred to as "Ganji bar"
(dry wastelands) and "Neeli bar" respectively. However, with the extension of canals from the
Triple Canal Project of West Punjab, these former wastelands have been transformed through
planned cultivation and canal irrigation, resulting in some of the most prosperous agricultural
areas. Noteworthy is the fact that despite the addition of the internationally renowned Bhakra
canal, the irrigation canal network in East Punjab remains a pale imitation of the
comprehensive achievements in West Punjab, both in terms of areal coverage and integrated
irrigational planning during the British colonial period. In East Punjab, this deficiency has
been largely compensated by the widespread adoption of tubewell irrigation, which
significantly supplements canal irrigation as needed.
The Flood Plains
Formed from fresh alluvial sediment deposited annually by the rivers during the rainy
season, the flood plains are typically separated from the upland plains by low ridges, and in
some instances, steep cliffs. These flood plains, situated along the rivers, are linear tracts with
widths generally not exceeding 10 to 15 kilometers. Until recently, they remained largely
undeveloped, but now, virtually all are under extensive cultivation. Due to the westward shift
of river courses, the western banks of these flood plains tend to be steeper, affording limited
room for expansion. Conversely, the flood plains on the eastern side of the rivers are
comparatively broader and more expansive. The flood plain of the Satluj extends from the
point where the river enters the plain near Ropar, reaching to the vicinity of Fazilka town in
Ferozepur district. It is notably wider south of the river than to its north, reflecting the
westward shift of its course. A section of the flood plain lies between the Satluj and Buddha
Nala, representing the river's former course. Remnants of oxbow lakes between the old and
current courses serve as tangible evidence of this shift. An extensive flood plain tract forms
near Harike, where the Satluj merges with the Beas. As the river progresses into more arid
areas, water intensity diminishes, leading to a progressively narrower or even nonexistent
flood plain in parts of Bahawalpur State. The Ghaggar River, once believed to be the course
31
of the Satluj in the past, possesses a fairly broad flood plain. It runs along the eastern
perimeters of Patiala, marking the southern extremities of Sangrur and Mansa districts. This
river is prone to frequent flooding during the rainy season, necessitating effective control
measures to protect adjacent farmland. The flood plain of the Beas encompasses a substantial
portion of Dasuya Tehsil in Hoshiarpur district and the western half of Kapurthala Tehsil.
Due to the westward shift of the Beas, the flood plain is much wider east of the river than to
the west. On the western side, it is separated from the upland plain by a relatively steep cliff,
which at times exceeds 50 feet in height. The eastern side of the flood plain extends to the
Black Bein, which is believed to have been the Beas's former course. The flood plain of the
upper Ravi lies between the river and the Sakki-Kiran stream, which is thought to have
represented the river's former course. This flood plain spans 10 to 15 kilometers in width,
though in places like Gurdaspur Tehsil, it narrows to only 3 to 4 kilometers. The flood plain
of the lower Ravi is wider, expanding further with the river's historical westward shift. The
flood plains of the Chenab and the Jhelum are relatively wide on their eastern sides, while the
western riverbanks are steep and lack significant flood plains. After merging, the combined
Chenab and Jhelum rivers maintain a similar orientation of their flood plains, predominantly
situated on the eastern side. However, it is noteworthy that as much of the water in the two
rivers diverts into an extensive canal system before their confluence, floods occur with less
frequency, resulting in narrower and less extensive flood plains relative to East Punjab. The
limited flood plains that do exist have not seen as extensive cultivation as in East Punjab.
Similarly, the Indus River has shifted westward, leaving behind a linear belt of flood plains on
its eastern side. While variations exist in degrees, all the rivers have shifted westward, giving
rise to small-scale relief features of varying dimensions. This westward shift of the rivers is
believed to have been instigated by a tectonic movement that elevated the Yamuna-Satluj
divide. This uplift exhibited a westward inclination, while simultaneously; the eastern portion
of the divide experienced an eastward tilt, propelling the Yamuna eastward to merge with the
Ganga.
Drainage
The drainage network in the Punjab region encompasses five perennial rivers, numerous
seasonal streams, and an extensive network of gullies. The Ghaggar, once a significant
seasonal stream, has been impacted by river capture and diversion due to past tectonic events.
The perennial rivers exhibit substantial fluctuations in discharge, ranging from high flows in
August to reduced levels in April. Notably, the Satluj and other perennial streams are not
solely reliant on monsoon rainfall; they also receive water from the melting of Himalayan
32
snows, particularly in the crucial spring and early summer months of March, April, and May.
While variable, this additional water source extends the availability of irrigation water
throughout a larger portion of the year. Among the five Core Rivers, the Satluj is the most
prominent. It originates in the westerly Mansarovar lake in Tibet, cutting across the
Himalayan ranges as an antecedent stream. The river has carved deep gorges while forming
terraces along the valley sides, indicative of distinct phases of Himalayan uplift. The Bhakra
dam on the Satluj has not only facilitated hydro-electric power generation but also serves to
mitigate flood risks. Additionally, various canals and barrages have been constructed to derive
water for irrigation from the Satluj. The Beas river begins its journey from the southern face
of Rohtang Pass, joining the Satluj at Harike after flowing over a hundred and fifty
kilometers. The construction of the Pong dam has played a pivotal role in flood control and
expanding agricultural cultivation in regions like Dasuya, Gurdaspur, and Kapurthala.
The Ravi river originates in the Kullu district hills, eventually joining the Chenab near
Rangpur. Its course in East Punjab is characterized by a narrow valley with relatively stable
discharge levels. Throughout its history, the Ravi has undergone shifts in course, impacting
areas such as Lahore Fort's location. The Chenab and Jhelum rivers have their sources in the
Zaskar and Kashmir ranges, respectively. They converge at Trimab before ultimately joining
the Indus. The Indus, one of the world's longest rivers, flows through mountainous terrain
before crossing the plains and forming a delta in the Arabian Sea. The Ghaggar, historically
significant, has witnessed significant changes. Once a substantial perennial stream, it has now
been reduced to a seasonal watercourse. Archaeological evidence attests to the existence of
ancient towns along its dried bed, indicating its former prominence. Seasonal streams, known
as "chos," are prevalent in the foothill zone of the Shivalik hills. Originating from the slopes
of the hills, these streams create wide beds filled with sediments. They have been a notable
source of soil erosion, leading to efforts to channelize and divert them for better management
of water resources.
Climate
Punjab's climate is characterized by a continental, semi-arid to sub-humid nature due to its
inland position and sub-tropical location. The changing seasons define its climate, with
distinct contrasts between summer and winter, each associated with primary crop seasons kharif (fall) and Rabi (spring) respectively. Examining in detail, Punjab experiences five
seasons in a year: (i) summer from mid-April to end of June, (ii) monsoon rains from July to
mid-September, (iii) autumn from mid-September to mid-November, (iv) winter from midNovember to mid-February, and (v) spring from mid-February to mid-April. Though some
33
year-to-year variations occur, each season is characterized by either temperature or rainfall
dominance. Summer is marked by intense heat, bright sun, scarce rainfall, low humidity, and
frequent dust storms. Days are hot, particularly in May and June, but nights are comparatively
cooler. The arrival of monsoons breaks the summer heat, transforming the landscape into lush
greenery, primarily crops. Humidity levels are high, sometimes making it uncomfortable. The
post-monsoon autumn brings pleasant, moderate, and dry weather. The cold season peaks in
mid-December, potentially experiencing light rainfall from westward-moving cyclones. Frost
is not uncommon. Spring follows, moderating temperatures but may be interrupted by
hailstorms and some rain. However, it's a brief season before the heat intensifies.
In Punjab, January is the coldest month, with mean temperatures ranging from 20 to 25°C
during the day and dropping below 5°C at night. June, conversely, is the hottest month, with
mean maximum temperatures reaching 45°C and minimum temperatures around 20°C. The
heat intensity is higher in the west and southwest regions. Western Punjab experiences more
extreme temperatures, both hot in summer and cold in winter, compared to eastern Punjab.
During the cold season (mid-November to mid-February), temperatures remain below 20°C.
Mid-December to mid-January is the chilliest period, with a mean temperature of about 10°C.
Spring gradually warms the weather, while the onset of the hot season in early April brings a
rapid rise in temperatures. Mid-May to mid-June is the hottest period, with mean temperatures
around 35°C. Throughout the rainy season, temperatures slightly drop but remain stable,
ranging from 25° to 30°C. High humidity and temperature combine to create oppressive
conditions. The post-monsoon, pre-cold season enjoys pleasant temperatures of 20 to 25°C.
Notably, significant temperature fluctuations occur between day and night throughout the
year. Punjab receives an average of 7 to 8 hours of sunshine daily, with the longest duration
from April to June and the shortest from December to March. This consistent sunshine
supports year-round plant growth. The substantial difference between summer and winter
temperatures allows for the cultivation of tropical, subtropical, and even temperate crops.
Additionally, the abundant sunshine holds potential for future solar energy harnessing.
Punjab‘s climate is semi-arid to sub-humid; with an average annual rainfall of just over 60
cm. Yearly variations can be substantial, about 25 percent above or below the average.
Snowfall is absent in Punjab. There are significant regional disparities in annual rainfall,
affecting land use, agriculture, and population distribution. Rainfall ranges from about 150 cm
in the Shivalik hills to under 25 cm in the west and southwest. Rainfall belts run parallel to
the Shivalik hills, gradually decreasing as one moves away. Rainy days also vary similarly.
34
The Shivalik hills experience rainfall on about 45 days a year, while southwest Punjab has
less than 20 rainy days. Around 70 percent of the annual rainfall occurs during the monsoon
months of July to mid-September. Winter rainfall, linked to western cyclones, contributes to
15 percent of the total. Northwestern Punjab receives more winter rain compared to the east.
Although a smaller proportion, winter rain significantly influences the success of Rabi crops.
Some rainfall may occur in the pre-monsoon months of June and the post-monsoon month of
October. April, May, and November are the driest months annually.
Rainfall in Punjab exhibits a high degree of variability in terms of amount, onset, duration,
and distribution within the rainy season. The amount of rainfall received is inversely
correlated with its variability, indicating lower reliability in arid and semi-arid areas. This
emphasizes the vital role of irrigation, especially in low rainfall regions. Rainfall intensity
varies over time and space. Summer rain is more intense than winter rain, often arriving in
torrents. During the monsoon period, a rainfall of 12.5 cm in 24 hours is not uncommon. In
contrast, winter rain typically comes in lighter drizzles. Additionally, rainfall intensity is
higher near the Shivalik hills and decreases toward the south and southwest. Water
management challenges in Punjab primarily stem from its rainfall patterns - characterized by
insufficiency, seasonal concentration, high variability, and intensity. While western Punjab
receives more winter rain from westerly cyclones, eastern Punjab receives heavier rain from
the southwest monsoons during the traditional rainy season. Relative humidity is influenced
by temperature and rainfall conditions. Morning relative humidity is highest (over 70 percent)
during rainy and winter seasons, lowest (around 50 percent) in the hot season of April to June,
and moderate (50 to 70 percent) during transitional periods. Southwest Punjab experiences
lower relative humidity compared to other regions. High relative humidity, combined with
August heat, creates muggy and uncomfortable weather during the rainy season.
Occasional hailstorms may occur in March and April, influenced by regional atmospheric
conditions defined by high surface temperatures and low upper atmosphere temperatures.
These storms can cause significant damage to standing crops, especially wheat, gram, and
vegetables, as well as to electrical infrastructure and buildings. Predominant wind directions
in Punjab are northwest and southeast. The former prevails from October to May, while the
latter is more dominant from June to September. Southeast winds bring rain. Average wind
speeds range from 3 to 4 kilometers per hour. Winds are generally calm in winter, active in
summer, and moderate during the rainy season. Calm days are most frequent in November,
while wind speeds are relatively higher in May and June, averaging 5 to 6 kilometers per
35
hour. Dust storms occur on average seven days a year in Punjab, mostly during the summer
months of May to June. These storms result from intense low pressure systems at the subregional level or from dusty winds originating in the Rajasthan desert. At times, the sky
remains overcast with dust for two to three days, leading to suffocating conditions. The
situation can improve if a dust storm is followed by rain. These storms are more frequent and
intense in southwest Punjab than in other parts of the region. Multan is particularly known for
hot weather and dust storms.
Khem Karan is old and historical town. Sir Partap Singh's book Ain-i-Khem Karan reveals
that Rai Khem Karan, the Kardar of Jahagir, founded the town in 1621 30. Khem Karan was
built; in the form of a fort. The residence was enclosed by a boundary wall with eight gates
which were dismantled by the Pakistanis during their occupation in 1965. It was named Kasur
GounceGhar, Chita, Mori, Shah Sharf, Bansawala and Talab wala. The doors were locked and
unlocked in the morning by night. Two giant Baolis were in the city. Per city resident, these
Baolis are now drinking water. Water tank was available to water sources in the city. But the
Baolis had been demolished now. A little well and a reservoir on all four sides are outside the
city walls. In these ponds the water of the town was drained. Maharaja Ranjit Singh came to
Khem Karan. Sardar Baba Lakha Singh welcome to Maharaja Ranjit Singh. He had been
pleased with Lakha Singh and donated 900 acres of land and worked well. Today's land
belongs to the family of Kamboj. Khem Karan has a railway station, Police Station, Nagar
Panchayat, Government Girls Senior Secondary School, Government boys Senior Secondary
School, Bus Stand, Government Elementary Schools, Government Civil Hospital, United
Senior Secondary School, and Shri Bala Ji Senior Secondary School, Gurukul Public School,
Tehsil Complex and several Government buildings. There are two Baolis are made in
antiquity. These were very famous and worth seeing. These Baolis are now destroyed. 31the
Town of the Kasur Tehsil of Lahore district, Punjab, situated in 31° 9' North and 74 ° 34' E., 7 miles
from Kasur town, on the North-Western railway station, Population (1901) 6083.
The Kasur branch of the Bari Doab canal flows near the town, and the population, which is mainly
agricultural is well-to-do. The municipality was created in 1867. The income during ten years in 190203 was average rupees 5,200 and expenditure was rupees 4,800. The income for 1903-04 was rupees
5,700, chiefly derived from octroi, and the expenditure was rupees 6,200.The town as a vernacular
middle school, maintained by the municipality.32
30
Ain-i-Khem Karan Tarlok Singh Rai
Census of India 1961
32
Data from Lahore Division 1911
31
36
Map Source Proneta.com Map
The population of the town is divided into three parts, Purana kot, Middle Kot and New Kot.
The old Kot was first inhabited. Sometime later, the middle kot and the Nada Kot were
established by Sang at Rai and Raja Rosh a Rai33.
Khem Karan is located in the south – west area of the Valtoha block. It is strongly linked to
Amritsar via the Amritsar – Khem Karan road and is a major nodal centre in the block. It is
also linked by railway line.
On analyzing the road network within and outside the block it has been found that the
villages that lie along the major transport routes are bigger, both area and population wise and
have better facilities. These villages are namely Valtoha, Rajoke, Ameerke, Asal Uttar,
Mehmood Pura, Bhura Kohna, Nau Douhal, Mehdipur, Rattoke, Macchike and Gazzal.
33
Census of India 1961
37
31°08'42"N74°33'31"E Khem Karan Google Earth
PHYSIOGRAPHIC PROFILE
Physiographic involves the study of topography, climate, soil, drainage, etc. By analyzing the
physiographic of an area it has been found that how various p34physical features of an area
could be used for future development.
38
Source: - www.alamy.comIndia map showing Punjab
The Town is a part of the alluvial plains of Punjab. The average height of the Town from
mean sea level is 216m and the general slope is from North–East to South–West. This plan is
based on the principles laid down in the Civil Defense Hand Book.
SOILS
The soil of the Punjab plains belongs to the typical alluvium of the Indo-genetic plains, which
in itself holds a very important place because it is also fertile. Most of the soil is loam or
sandy loam with clay layers of varying depth. The existing soil is a light reddish-yellow loam,
known to the people as Maria, but as it hardens into Rohi or clay, hardly any profile features
are observed; soluble asana are present in abundance which is very important for crops. The
soil usually has an alkaline reaction and an adequate supply of phosphorus and potash; but
there is a lack of organic matter and nitrogen.
39
Fertile Plains: Like much of Punjab, Khem Karan is primarily characterized by extensive
fertile plains. These alluvial plains are formed by the deposition of sediment carried by rivers
over time. The soil in this region is highly fertile, making it suitable for agriculture.
Irrigation Canals: The region is well-served by an extensive network of irrigation canals that
originate from the rivers flowing through Punjab. These canals play a crucial role in
supporting agriculture by providing a reliable source of water. Presently, the canal is not in
good condition, major source of irrigation is now boring well irrigation.
Groundwater Resources: Groundwater is an essential source of irrigation in Khem Karan.
Tube wells are commonly used to extract water for agricultural purposes. However, it's
important to manage groundwater resources sustainably to prevent over-extraction and
depletion. It is the major source for irrigation and the drinking purpose.
Groundwater being used for irrigation in Khem Karan Source: Field Study
Crops: The major crops grown in Khem Karan include wheat, rice, barley (rare), sugarcane
(rare), and cotton (rare). These crops are well-suited to the fertile soil and the availability of
irrigation. Agriculture is the primary economic activity in the region.
Climate: Khem Karan experiences a typical north Indian climate. Summers are hot, with
temperatures often exceeding 40°C (104°F), while winters are relatively cool, with
temperatures occasionally dropping below 5°C (41°F). The monsoon season (June to
September) brings most of the annual rainfall.
Topography: The district is generally flat with slight undulations in some areas. There are no
40
significant elevation changes or hilly regions. The flat terrain makes it ideal for mechanized
farming practices.
Paddy fields Source: Field Study
41
Natural Vegetation: The natural vegetation of Khem Karan includes grasslands, shrubs, and
scattered trees. However, due to extensive agricultural activities, much of the natural
vegetation has been replaced by cultivated fields.
Drainage System: The area has a well-developed system of natural and artificial drains to
manage excess water during the monsoon season. This helps prevent water logging in lowlying areas.
Flora and Fauna: The region's biodiversity is influenced by its agricultural landscape. While
there are no significant natural reserves or protected areas in Khem Karan, the region may
host various species of birds, small mammals, and insects.
Language
Punjabi is the official language of the Khem Karan Town. However some people can speak
English and Hindi.
CROPPING PATTERN AND CROPPING INTENSITY
Major crops grown in the Town are wheat and paddy. In the town almost 50% of the area is
under wheat and 45% of the area is under rice.
There is a lack of diversification of cropping pattern due to problem of marketing. The belt is
also rich in cotton. In the year 2006 area under cotton was 6000 Ha but in 2007, this has
reduced to 3000 Ha. It has various reasons.35
Small Mills in Khem Karan
In 1917, Lala Ami Chand set up a cotton factory at Khem Karan outside Nawa Kot which was
later sold.
In 1919, Lala Munshi Duggal Khatri established a flour grinder Mill which was later sold.
In 1913 Lala Shankar Mal Budhwar established another flour mill in the Purana Kot which
lasted for a long time.
In 1922, Lala Shankar Mall Puri established fourth floor mill in the middle Kot. He also
planted cotton Willow due to progress.36
Lala Munshi Mal Khatri had set up a dirty Baroja cleaning factory at Khem Karan railway
station which was destroyed in the 1965 war. Factory in Nawa Kot was set up by Muslim
name the Khoja who often a made blankets and knifes. It was very popular and beautiful. The
blankets and knifes were sold far and wide.37
35
(As per Town and Villages Directory of Amritsar 2002).p221
36
Sitare Khem Karan Sir Tarlok Rai
Census of India 1961
37
42
There was small scale industry of grass, baskets, ban making, knifes, blankets and pots was
established in Khem Karan (Source 1961 census)
Notified area committee of Khem Karan
Before independence, four Numbardar and five members were assigned in Khem Karan
Municipal Committee. Kardar Badan Singh was elected as a president in New Kot and he
remained on the position of vice President. Nobody has taken the position of him after his
death and the number owners of committee have reduced and it was very difficult for any
other owner to succeed here. Thanks to the Government which give the owner Kamboj the
right to become a member owner in the Municipal Committee Khem Karan. After the death of
Sardar Badan Singh, Numbardar has been the Municipal Commissioner and vice President of
Municipal Committee Khem Karan among the owner of new kot and old Kot.
This committee has been established in 1868 in United Punjab, which was second Committee
after Lahore. This Committee was working as it was working before independence. If we say
about the work, this Committee used to collect taxes and do the reforms activity like
cleanliness in Khem Karan area. After the war of 1965 the building of this committee was
constructed. The foundation was laid down by ICS officer Sardar Gian Singh Kahlon in 25th
November 1968. This Committee was running successfully till 1980 but in 1981 this was
abolished by the Punjab Government and named it Khem Karan a village. 1981 to 1983
Sardar Harcharan Singh was the head (Sarpanch) of the village. Sardar Raj Karan Singh was
continuously the Sarpanch of Khem Karan current till 1983 to 1993. In 1992 Congress
Government was elected in Punjab. Sardar Beant Singh was chief minister of Punjab. Due to
the demand of Khem Karan's citizens Committee has restored38. Mr Mangat Ram Gulati was
elected as a President of Khem Karan Notified area Committee on 6 August 1993. Sardar
Lakhwinder Singh versus State of Punjab Ors has a case in High court and after that notified
area committee was demolished and Nagar Panchayat was made. First President of Mr
Mangat Ram Gulati was selected and he got this position on 21st August 1993 and he
remained in the same position. Currently Shri Alam Vijay Singh Pattu is President of Khem
Karan. This committee has 13 M C and after five years they are elected by people of Khem
Karan. This committee takes care of the cleanliness of Street.
Amar Kavi (Poet) Sabha Khem Karan
Amar Kavi Sabha was formed in Khem Karan in 1935 AD. The founder of this Sabha was the
headmaster of the middle school Shri Harish Chandra. He invited poet from outside cities. He
38
Census of India 1971
43
used to compete with outsiders poets. He listened to the poems of the poets and also gives
them prizes. There were eight members of this poetics council.
President Baba Bashan Das Gosai
S Darbara Singh Hazir
S Tarlok Singh Rai
Bawa Ram Prakash Bairagi
Pandit Daulat Ram Anjaan
Master Sukhchain Singh Mazboor
Shri Devi Sain Ji
Shri Jagdish Lal Khaana39
Baolis and Well in Khem Karan
The population from Khem Karan to the present day is a few Baolis and Hundreds of wells
will be visible. Many of these wells are uninhabited. The Baolis are worth seeing because of
their antiquity.
Baoli Rai Rai Sangat Rai Sahib
This Baoli was very visible in front of the school near Bazaar in Khem Karan and were
famous far and wide. At that time it was made at a cost of Rs 125,000. But unfortunately
today people have stopped it by pouring soil40.
Baoli Naropat Rai Sahib
This Baoli was situated between the Purana Kot and the New Kot. It was made in a very
beautiful shape. . But unfortunately today people have destroyed it by pouring soil.
Old Well
This well was prepared by Rai Khem Karan. This well was constructed due to lack of water.
This well is built near temple Data Ram Ji. This well is still today but its water has dried up.
EDUCATION
Education play is a vital role to develop the society. By the education people can improve our
social and occupational mobility. The level of educational facilities available in the Town
have been studied and analyzed for different levels of education.
SCHOOLS
The school was started in Khem Karan in 1857. It was started in the village of Tara Garh,
39
40
Book Sitare Khem Karan Sir Tarlok Rai p27
Book Sitare Khem Karan Sir Tarlok Rai p56
44
because the first schools were in operation in the villages of Sehjaran, Valtoha, Tara Garh and
Rajan Jang etc. Unfortunately, there was no school in Khem Karan. No specific reason has
been identified. Why the government did not pay attention to this. Munshi Jamiat Singh
Sahib established a school at Khem Karan. He later quit his job and moved to Hyderabad
South to join the Superintendent of Police. Khem Karan's school was urban. Later enrolled in
Vernacular Middle School and in 1910 became the Anglo Vernacular Middle School. In
1913, another school for girls was established to promote education, where girls were taught
Hindi and Gurumukhi. In 1923, the Muslims had set up a separate school for which they
received a monthly income of three rupees in Municipal Committee funds.
After partition, a girls' school continued in Khem Karan town. There was no boy's school in
Khem Karan. The boys went to Garyala or Valtoha schools. In 1965, Pakistan invaded India.
This caused severe damage to the girls' school building. Boys' school started in 1967. Since
there was no building, he went to a girls' school. On 25 November 1968, Sardar Gian Singh
Kahlo laid the foundation stone of both the buildings and new ones soon followed. Boys 'and
girls' schools began to run separately. At present both these schools are imparting education
in camping.41
Police Station
Police recruitment began in 1865. It was called Tone Police. In 1872, a permanent building
was erected in Middle Kot. The entire income of the land was received from the Government
as compensation to the owner. Until 1911, the salaries of the police personnel were paid from
the Municipal Fund. After some time, the Government started giving from Government
funds. There was one head constable and ten constables posted here. At present time it is
called Khem Karan Police Station. Its head is called SHO. Its job is to maintain the justice
system in Khem Karan 42.
Railway Station
The railway line from Patti to Kasur was released in 1910 AD. This railway line ran from
Amritsar to Kasur. This greatly benefited the people of Khem Karan. After the partition of
1947, this vehicle remained till Khem Karan.
HERITAGE TOURISMTemple in Khem Karan
Mandir Shri Devi Dwara
41
42
Source E Punjab Data of Government Girls. Sen Sec School Khem Karanp.221-233
Source E Punjab Data of Government Girls. Sen Sec School Khem Karan. p23
45
It is an old and historical temple. Before 1965, Pandit Jagannath Tiwari and his family used to
serve this temple. During the 1965 war Pandit Jagan Nath Tiwari and his wife were taken
from temple by Pakistani soldier. Pandit Ji was shot dead in the temple and his wife was taken
by Pakistani soldier. Pandit Ji was shot dead in the temple and his wife was taken to Lyallpur
Jail. Pandit Ji wife died there. Now the Mandir Shri Devi Dwara is being managed by Shri
Sanatan Dharma Sabha Khem Karan. Sanatan Dharma Sabha is the registered institution. It
has 50 to 60 members. The President of the Sanatan Dharma Sabha is elected every two years.
I am giving the details of the President of Sanatan Dharma Sabha Khem Karan -: Lala
Kashmiri Lal Vij, Sh Dyal Shah Mehta, Shri Surinder Kumar Chaudhari, Master Sukhchain
Singh Mazboor, Master Madan Gopal Prabhakar, Master Jodhbir Sharma, Shri Dharmpal
Mehta, Shri Ashwani Manchanda, Shri Pawan Kumar Bedi ,Shri Rajesh Kumar Kapoor
(Sonu) and Shri Shashi Kapoor. Now I am the President of Shri Sanatan Dharma Sabha Khem
Karan. I was elected President by the members in May 5th 2019. Every year Shri Krishna
Janmashtami is being celebrated in August by Shri Sanatan Dharma Sabha Khem Karan
Temple Mata Gouran Ji
This temple is north of Khem Karan. It was built in 1933 by the great ascetic Sant and Lal
Das Ji. He practiced penance in it all his life. After him, Mata Gouran Ji used to do penance in
it. Mela Mai Goran Ji Maghar (November-December)
Temple Thakur Dwara Ji
This temple is built on the bank of the Baolis in the middle of Khem Karan. The priest of this
temple was Bawa Ram Prakash Ji Bairagi. The gumbad was built in this temple
Mandir Baba Sita Ram Ji
This temple is on the other side of Baoli. It is very old temple. It is also called Gaushala
temple. Sant Baba Ram Narayan Ji was serving the cows. He was a great ascetic and
possessed divine vision. Ashwani Kumar Arora is the President of this temple. Twice a year,
there is a langar of Desi ghee is held in this temple.
Dharma Shala Bhai Vasti Ram
The old Kot is built inside the bazaar. It was very interesting. Bhai Vasti Ram Ji has also
become this Mahatma Sadhu. This Dharamshala was built in his memory. The old Kot on the
owner's side also belonged to it. There was very special about this shrine.
Mandir Swami Data Ram Ji
Swami data Ram Ji came to Khem Karan in the late 18th century. It is being said when
Swami Data Ram came to the Khem Karan all the wither trees again get refreshed and
46
greenish. He was living in Lala Nagar mull's garden in Ferozpur, before reaching Khem
Karan. His cell can be seen still in Khem Karan. This can be seen in the picture. He got very
famous in the Khem Karan town. A sacred pond was set up for bath, which can be seen still
over there.
Mandir Ram Bagh Khem Karan
Mandir Ram Bagh is at the back of Gurduwara Shri Chain Sahib. Along with Gurduwara
Chain Sahib was the palace of Rai Ji. They lived in this palace. He built this temple himself.
Rai Ji family used to worship and meditate in this temple. There is a well in this temple. .
Water heals the illness with this water.
Fair Baba Dhigana Fair Chet 1 (March-April) A fair is organized for two days in honor of
Saint Dhigana Ji. Gurduwara Thamm Sahib, near the Kasur Gate, marks the site of a Manji or
preaching center established by Guru Amar Das (1479–1574) at Bhai Kheda, a Brahmin
worshiper of the goddess Durga who performed daily pujas, known as was converted to
Sikhism. The Guru gave a wooden pillar (thamm in Punjabi) to Bhai Kheda, which was
consecrated as a holy relic, giving the temple its name.43
GURDUWARA BHAI CHAIN SAHIB JI
Gurduwara Bhai Chain Sahib Ji situated in Khem Karan. It is old Gurduwara. Guru Gobind
Singh‘s birthday celebrated in every January44.
Gurduwara Gurusar Ji
This Gurduwara is located in the town of Khem Karan, 32 kilometers from Patti City. Shri
Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji, the ninth Sikh Guru, is honored in this Gurduwara. This was the home
of Guru Ji's follower Baba Taghana. Before his death, Guru Ji had assured him that he would
see him. When Guru Ji was imprisoned in Delhi in 1675, he kept his word and via his spiritual
powers manifested on Khem Karan's southern edge. Through intuition, Baba Taghana
discovered the presence of Guru Ji and proceeded to honor him. The Gurdwara is here where
Guru Ji first manifested. Lala Karishi Ram, a wealthy Ferozpur philanthropist, rebuilt the
previous temple in 1903. During the conflict with Pakistan in 1965, this building was
demolished. A modest hall is located next to a domed sanctum in the current construction,
which was built in 1966–1967. The local sangat cares for the Gurduwara. Every full moon
day and all significant Sikh anniversaries are celebrated with special gatherings. Currently, a
new Gurduwara was constructed by Baba Avtar Singh.
43
44
The Sikhs in History by Dr Sangat Singh.p45
The Sikhs in History by Dr Sangat Singh.p116
47
Dargah Peer Baba Sheikhh Braham Ji
Baba Sheikh Brahm, who succeeded Baba Farid Ganjshakar as the eleventh successor, is also
known as Sheikh Farid (II), Farid Sani, Shaikh Brahm Sahib, Salis Farid, Arbitrator Farid,
Shaikh Brahm the Elder, Bal Raja, and Shah Brahm. Visit Sheikh Farid's tomb, a Sufi saint's
mausoleum in Punjab that is close to the India-Pakistan border, to offer respect. On the Indian
side of Punjab's Khem Karan region, close to the village of Mianwali Uttar, is the mausoleum
of Pir Baba Sheikh Brahm. Villagers claim that the Pir Baba was a student of Guru Nanak.
Church in Khem Karan
Saint Peter Church
It is situated in ward no 13. In it the people of Christian community worship the lord Jesus.
Christmas and Good Friday are celebrated with much fanfare.
2. Sundar Singh ChurchIt is situated in ward no 06. It was built in 1970 AD. Raj Masih is the priest of both churches.
The first Priest was Paster Waryam Singh.
India after the independence, the Akali Dal, a Sikh-majority political party operating mainly
in Punjab, south to create a Sikh state, but the idea was not very popular. However, the
reorganization of states on the basis of language was emphasized in many regions of India. In
Punjab, instead of religion, the Akalis launched the Punjabi Suba movement in the 1950s with
48
the aim of creating a Punjabi-majority Suba ('province') in India's then eastern Punjab state,
mobilizing the people of Punjab into them. Awareness about Akali Dal was also increased. In
1966, it was formed i.e. the Punjabi-speaking majority Punjab state, the Haryanvi Hindimajority Haryana state and the Union Territory of Chandigarh.
As a result of the movement, some hilly parts of East Punjab were also merged with Himachal
Pradesh. Punjab District Tarn Taran is one of the important historical cities with a history of
more than 400 years. It is an important Sikh religious city due to its connectivity with the 5th
Sikh Guru Arjun Dev Ji, who founded the city of Tarn Taran.
It is a religious place in the heart of Majha region. There are various interpretations of its
name. According to one it means "salvation", another "clear water" and a third "aid to swim".
This Source: Tarn Taran District Handbook. Is the general belief that Sarovar waters have
miraculous curing power? Therefore the town has been the resort of lepers from all parts of
the country and abroad. Tarn Taran is the administrative headquarter of Tarn Taran district
Tarn Taran district is one of the districts in the state of Punjab in North-West Republic of
India. The main cities are Tarn Taran Sahib and Patti.
The City of Tarn Taran is a holy place for Sikhs. Tarn Taran district was formed in 2006 from
Amritsar District45. The declaration to this effect was made by Captain Amarinder Singh, ExChief Minister of Punjab, during the celebrations marking the martyrdom day of Sri Guru
Arjan Dev Ji. With this, it became the 19th district of Punjab46.
KHEM KARAN RELIGION DATA
Town
Population Hindu
Muslim Christian Sikh
Buddhist Jain Other Not
Stated
Khem
13446
25.26% 0.54%
5.91%
67.70% 0.03%
0.01 0.01
0.53
Karan
45
Kaur, B. (2015). The study on slum and population and improvement programs of in Punjab. Int J Sci Res
Publ, 5(5).
46
Kaur, B. (2015). The study on slum and population and improvement programs of slums in Punjab. Int J Sci
Res Publ, 5(6).p13
49
RELIGIOUS POPULATION AND LITERACY
Religion
Male
Female
Literacy
Hindu
2042
1355
22.51%
Muslim
54
19
0.5%
Christian
420
375
5.91%
Sikh
4827
4276
35.36%
Buddhist
4
0
0.03%
Jain
2
2
0.01%
Other religions and 1
1
0%
31
0.19
Male
Female
Total
Children
883
749
1632
Literacy
59.00
48.10
61.50
Scheduled Caste
2719
2402
5121
Scheduled Tribe
0
0
0
Illiterate
3030
3145
6175
persuasions
Religion not stated
40
Sources- censusindia.gov.in
KHEM KARAN NAGAR PANCHAYAT
Sources- censusindia.gov.in
Total Literacy Rate
Khem Karan
Punjab
Female
54.85
70.73
Male
67.00
80.44
Total
61.55
75.84
Sources- censusindia.gov.in
The Sex Ratio of Khem Karan people are only 819. Thus per every enum1000 men there were
and 819 females in Khem Karan. Also as per Census 2011, the Child Sex Ratio was 848
which are greater than Average Sex Ratio of Khem Karan.
50
WORKING POPULATION OF KHEM KARAN
In Khem Karan Nagar Panchayat out of total population, 4,914 were engaged in work
activities. 91.4% of workers describe their work as Main Work (Employment or Earning more
than 6 Months) while 8.6% were involved in Marginal activity providing livelihood for less
Male
Female
Total
Main Workers
4046
446
4492
Cultivators
410
14
424
Agriculture
984
118
1102
55
9
64
Other Workers
2597
305
2902
Marginal Worker
205
217
422
Non-Working
3139
5393
8532
labourer
Household
Industries
than 6 months. Of 4,914 workers engaged in Main Work, 424 were cultivators (owner or coowner) while 1,102 were Agricultural laborers.
Sources- censusindia.gov.in
HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF KHEM KARAN
Whenthe England rule in Bharat needed to investigateproduction of energy, through which
51
British managed Punjab, and the British managed the entire frontier states. The most
important objective of colonial rule in India was once regulation and exchange as well as
maintaining order and collecting revenue. The British rule formulated and implemented
insurance policies that proved positive and effective to maintain their rule and created a
machine of authority, Source- Tarn-Taran District Handbook47
As a result of technology, the abundance of social wealth in the whole of Punjab and
especially in Amritsar district provided many opportunities. The imposition and renewal of
British rule led to widespread social exchange leading to the current general political and
social order. Change used to happen in all directions which changed the present form of life
people made many social changes in future in their life. The insurance plan policies that have
been adopted, the firms that have been added and the men and women that have handled
matters in extraordinary capacities have participated in bringing about social change.
The administrative organizational structure that the British created in the Punjab was once
based entirely on the frontier factors that contributed to its success in the mid-19th century.
The British have been professional colonial administrators with a proper understanding of the
Indian conditions and as Punjab used to be a contiguous region, insurance policies were very
efficiently adopted by the people to ensure their future. The administration was modeled after
the machine of governance that developed in India a few hundred years ago and clever
insurance policies were drafted and implemented.The social enterprise of the village used to
be of amazing interest to every the Mughal and the British administrations especially for
purpose of profits collection. The British rule in India used to be an aggregate of coercion and
conciliation.
The British dealt with rural as exact as town setting and cantered in particular on rural areas
the location land profits used to be involved. The preferred Indian village with its traditional
caste system was, in large part, a product of the British Raj.
INDIA PAKISTAN RELATION AND KHEM KARAN
The analysis of Indo-Pak relations is the most complex aspect of India's foreign policy 48.
Thus, these relations have been constantly plagued by many troubles and the sensitivity of
public opinion has been highest in these relations, due to which these relations have become
even more complicated. Armed conflicts have taken place between the two countries three
times in 1948, 1965 and 1971 respectively. At present, when both nations are nuclear power
47
48
Censes, Punjab, 1868 table VII
Ganesh, R. N. Nuclear Missile-Related Risks in South Asia. The Next Arms Race, 305-355.
52
nations, then the nature of mutual tension and its effects have changed. However, it is worth
mentioning that there has been no armed conflict between India and Pakistan after 1971 49. In
the last 27 years, there have been many occasions when there could have been opportunities
for armed conflict between the two nations, but due to the diplomatic capabilities of the two
countries and the potential for adverse effects of war, opportunities for armed conflict are
constantly being postponed. Exploring the causes of tensions in Indo-Pak relations is not
unreasonable. The first of these reasons is the historical background of the partition between
the two countries. The reality is that the Indo-Pak partition in 1947 has given rise to tension
between the two countries50. If the partition was with the spirit of peaceful coexistence, then
good relations would have been established, but on the contrary Indo-Pak partition has
happened on mutual distrust, suspicion, bitterness and animosity, hence the tension in the
relations between the two countries has been born from the beginning. Some of the major
disputes that arose between India and Pakistan, such as the international border dispute, the
problem of minorities, the question of the merger of the princely states of the native king and
the Nawabs, and the distribution of military material. Some of these problems were resolved,
but the most difficult was the dispute relating to the merger of the princely states. For this
reason, it was the first war between India and Pakistan took place in 1948. By the way, while
analysing the reasons for mutual resentment between India and Pakistan, there is also a view
that the resentment between India and Pakistan has been due to basic beliefs. It was a basic
basis of the partition between India and Pakistan is the two-nation theory in which there was a
demand for the partition of India-Pakistan on religious lines and in 1947, the partition
between the two nations took place on this basis and it was further strengthened when
Pakistan Declared itself as an Islamic nation and India decided to establish itself as a secular
nation. Recently, Pakistan has tried to push back Pakistani politics once again by making its
rules on the basis of Islam in the border of Pakistan. These efforts reinforce the core sentiment
that India and Pakistan were founded on two different values and this is the root cause of
mistrust and tension. Among the causes of Indo-Pak relations, the psychology of Pakistan has
been mentioned by Mani Shankar Aiyar in his book Pakistani Papers51.
According to him, Pakistan's neighbour India is more politically enlightened than Pakistan,
democratic traditions are more deeply rooted and civilian life is more prosperous and full of
49
Pradhan, R. D. (2009). 1965 War, the Inside Story: Defense Minister YB Chavan's Diary of India-Pakistan
War.p78
50
HASAN, Z. (1965). THE INDIAPAKTSTAN WAR—A SUMMARY ACCOUNT. Pakistan Horizon, 18(4),
344-356.
51
Jaffrelot, C. (Ed.). (2004). ―A History of Pakistan and its Origins. Anthem press.‖ p211
53
facilities. That is why it has been a matter of envy for the Pakistani leadership 52. Taking this
argument further, Mani Shankar clarifies that there is also a reason for resentment in Pakistan
that this fact or this information is related to India and based on India. Underlining another
psychological aspect of Indo-Pak relations, Mani Shankar Aiyar believes that the fact that it is
a small country has very clearly entered the psychology of Pakistan. Although the population
is equal to that of Indonesia, there is a constant feeling that it is a small country and it has to
be constantly striving for its existence and India is a constant threat to its existence. From this
point of view all those efforts for unity and closeness in Indo-Pak relations give rise to a
psychological fear in Pakistan and force Pakistan to more extreme policies for its survival 53.
Indo-Pak relations basically appear to be evolving between disputes and trying different ways
of mutual trust, there has been an attempt to see both these trends in the new diplomatic
environment. On the contrary, there seems to be a consistent understanding and resilience in
the post-2004 efforts, if the talks appear to be passing through a period of mutual mistrust and
tensions. We are trying to see these trends till September 2005 in which an attempt has been
made to understand in detail some developments of the bilateral relations, the effort to
understand the mutual perspectives and problems between the two countries is more
remarkable and not the result because the mutual Controversy exists in many ways in a
traditional way, the purpose of this analysis is to underline the mutual understanding that is
developing in such situations. India has been repeatedly reiterating to its neighbours
especially Pakistan that India wants a "stable, secure and prosperous Pakistan" in its national
interest54. It wants serious and continuous dialogue with Pakistan to resolve the pending
issues. The idea is to continue the talks on topics ranging from closer cultural and economic
cooperation between India and Pakistan to the consideration of agreements on the Siachen
and Sir Creek disputes. It is clear that they do not expect the Kashmir question to be resolved
immediately. In such a situation, the option remains that we go on reducing the areas of
tension and by starting the process of normalization, which can play the role of easing the
tensions increased by the pressures related to controversial questions, as well as the old IndoPak relations. There is bitterness of his sides and can try to reduce his feeling. For this it is
necessary that India assures its neighbouring country that there is no fear of Pakistan's
geographical integrity from India because Pakistan has always said this, keeps repeating that
Ganguly, Š. (2003). Conflict unending: India-Pakistan tensions in 1947. Columbia University Press.p34
Cloughley, c. (2017). ―A history of the Pakistan army: wars and insurrections.‖ Simon and Schuster.p21
54
Dixit, J. N. (2004). India-Pakistan in war and peace. Routledge.p136
52
53
54
from India to Pakistan the geographical integrity of the country is being affected 55.
INDO-PAK WAR 1965
Fighting in India used to be as specific as it was to no longer involve the Kashmir trouble, and
then resurfaced with the use of devastation in East Pakistan for several important reasons.
After a massive pre-emptive attack through the process of Pakistan, a full-scale fighting
ensued between the two countries as it wanted it to remain its possession and no one could
interfere in it. Within two weeks and a few days of fierce and violent conflict, the enemy‘s
army in India won the submission of East Pakistan., leading to creation of the People's
Republic of Bangladesh and the creation of another new nation56. The battle saw the largest
number of casualties in any Indo-Pakistani conflict.
Since the partition of British India in the year 1947, both the countries, Pakistan and India
have been in opposition on many issues and which were still prevalent. Although the Battle of
Kashmir was once the major challenge dividing nations as redress was not an easy task,
specific border disputes did exist.57The issue first surfaced in 1956, and India eventually took
possession of the disputed territory, leaving a wound behind. Pakistani patrols began
patrolling the territory managed with Indian resources in January 1965, which sparked
controversy as well as put an end to a conflict between the two nations, which once took place
on each other's posts on 8 march 1965 make use of the way to each of the international
locations and strike multiple times for your personal hit. Initially border police from each of
the nations involved, the disputed site rapidly saw intermittent clashes between the armed
forces of the countries which reached a very wide scale. In 1962, India was defeated. Pakistan
considered that in order to start a resistance movement, some infiltrating saboteurs had to
make the people of Kashmir unhappy with Indian control as quickly as possible. Pakistan
tried to ignite resistance action through a covert infiltration capability. On the other hand in
August 5, 1965 between 26,000 and 33,000 Pakistani troopers crossed the Line of Control
dressed as Kashmiri locals headed for pretty a variety areas inner Kashmir. Indian forces,
tipped off by means of the local populace, crossed the give up fire line on August 15. Initially,
the Indian Army met with tremendous success, taking images three essential mountain
positions after a prolonged artillery barrage. By the give up of August, however, every
component had relative progress; Pakistan had made improvement in areas such as Tithwal,
Uri and Poonch and India had captured the Haji Pir Pass, eight km into Pakistan-
55
Singh, L. G. H. (1993). War Despatches: Indo–Pak Conflict 1965. Lancer Publishers llc.p12
Singh, L. G. H. (1992). War Despatches: Indo–Pak Conflict 1965. Lancer Publishers LLC.p11
57
Korbel, J. (1953). Danger in Kashmir. Foreign Aff., 32, 482.
56
55
Administered Kashmir. On 1 September 1965, Pakistan launched a counterattack, referred to
as Operation Grand Slam, with the intention to trap the quintessential town of Akhnoor in
Jammu, which would sever communications and minimize off supply routes to Indian troops.
Ayub Khan calculated that "Hindu morale" (as he acknowledged as Indian Army) would
possibly now not stand increased than two hard assaults at the appropriate time and place;
even though with the useful resource of According to his biographer Altaf Gauhar, Operation
Gibraltar had failed this time, and India had taken control of the Haji Pir Pass. With a
disproportionately large number of troops and the most technologically advanced tanks,
Pakistan launched an assault on the Indian forces, which were caught off guard and sustained
significant losses. India spoke returned by way of the usage of calling in its air strain to blunt
the Pakistani attack. The subsequent day, Pakistan retaliated, its air strain attacked Indian
forces and air bases in every Kashmir and Punjab. India's resolution to open up the theatre of
assault into Pakistani Punjab compelled the Pakistani navy to relocate troops engaged in the
operation to guard Punjab.58. The thrust against Lahore consisted of the 1st Infantry Division
which was well-versed in combat supported through the use of three tank regiments from the
2nd Independent Armoured Brigade; they are fast on their way to the border, operating the
Ichhogil (BRB) canal by 6 September. The Pakistani army, which had held or blown up the
bridges over the canal, could no longer choose to keep them; effectively preventing any
further attacks on Lahore with the resources of the Indians. In which he was also successful,
through his own efforts.
OCCUPATIONAL MOBILITY IN KHEM KARAN
Table1.17. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Status
First Generation (Grand Father)
Status
Quantity
Traditional
Non-Traditional
384
6
Frequency
98.46
1.54
%age
NonTraditiona
l
2%
of Occupation of the
Total
390
100.00
Traditiona
l
98%
Figure 1Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Status of Occupation of the First Generation (Grand Father)
Pandey, H. K., & Singh, M. R. (2017). India’s Major Military & Rescue Operations. Horizon Books (A
Division of Ignited Minds Edutech P Ltd).p10
58
56
As far as the first generation (of grandparents) is concerned, they were in the traditional
occupation of the community to the tune of as high as 98.5 per cent. Thus, a mere 1.5 per cent
of the grandparents of the respondents were reported to have engaged them in the nontraditional occupation.
Table 2.1.18. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Status of Occupation of the
Second Generation (Father)
Status
Quantity
Total
Traditional
Non-Traditional
354
36
390
Frequency
90.77
9.23
100.00
%age
Non-Traditional
9%
Traditional
91%
Figure 2Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Status of Occupation of the Second Generation (Father)
As regards second generation (consisting of parents of the respondents), the percentage of
being in the traditional occupation of the community was still fairly high (at 90.8 per cent),
leaving about 9.2 per cent of the parents engaged in non-traditional occupation.
57
CHPATER II
Theories of Social and Occupational Mobility
Caste as a Factor Affecting Social Mobility
Varna, as it is known in the Vedic period, was the term used to divide society into four
sections. These sections were primarily assigned obligations according to their abilities as can
be seen in the dhanastutis.
59
Some groups continue to adhere to the notion of caste-based
occupational adoption in contemporary India. It hinders inclusivity and forces people with
diverse objectives to be limited to a single profession, which contributes to a life that isn't
fulfilling. An important factor influencing people's mobility in India is the contentious
practice of caste-based hierarchy. The custom that some have long believed to have been
significant in antiquity continues to shape India's socioeconomic development. The Rig Vedic
vertical hierarchy, which states that if society were a human body, Brahmins would be the
head, Kashatriyas would be the arms, Vaishyas would be the torso, and Shudras would be the
feet, still rules today. The main problem is that, despite the fact that lower caste groups are
legally protected, they have come to terms with the higher castes' domination. 60 The table that
follows was taken from a 2002 article in the Economic and Political Weekly. The information
demonstrates the correlation between a person's caste and the proportion of that caste
represented in a particular occupational group. The data contains a little bias toward solely
representing men.61
Social History: A Social History of India is a scientific aim to seem to be at society
beginning with the Aryan invasion. It takes a leap into the pristine past to differentiate
amongst the myths and realities associated to the basis and enchantment of social order and
trust and make a critical comparison of the various schools of philosophical thought in India.
Discussion of the technique of social information interior the senses whereby I use the time
length have hardly ever been extensive. Christopher Lloyd has produced a magisterial survey
of the one-of-a-kind colleges of the philosophy of perception and their massive relationship to
the explanatory mechanisms observed thru effective businesses of social historians. People
and her co-people have theorized about the applications of the comparative approach to social
records. The historiography on a chosen sub-field or university of social data will regularly
59
Initial mention of the Varna system is in the 10th Mandal of the Rig Veda , sukta known as Purusasuktam
Anikeeva, E. N. (2020). Cultural Anthropology, Cast Hierarchy and Religious Values in Modern India.
Atlantis Press, 416(4), 493–496. https://doi.org/10.2991/assehr.k.200316.109
61
Kumar, S., Heath, A., & Heath, O. (2002). Determinants of Social Mobility in India. Economic and Political
Weekly, 37(29), 2983–2987. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4412376?seq=1
60
58
include information at the ambitions which the ones strolling in it have collectively set
themselves, and at the manner thru which they looking for to reap these airs via drawing on
advantageous sorts of belongings of records, strategies, concepts, and theories. But no whole
textual content material at the methodological requirements of social archives has as however
been published, at the least now no longer inner the Anglophone world. Several journals cater
for professional pastimes inside facet the techniques of files collection and processing,
however, there are none that cope with the wider methodological troubles confronted by using
all historians62.
It is commonly estimated in a social archive. Similarly, in the United States within the 1960s
the most important investigations achieved the desirable proper which led to speculation, as
well as social historians everywhere seeking to define their center of entertainment against a
group of skeptical records and Tried to link their activities, were reluctant to cut new topics
and strategies except one doubt, and no longer intended to openly talk about regional subjects
in many cases. This stock developed and became effective during the 1970s, when a changing
face of society was eagerly bound to the needs and opportunities of trainers and others to
define a "new social record" or what was called a "new social record" 63. What they called a
new direction, now a large part increasingly inclined to defend legitimacy, as soon as not
more on the specific hand, the longer positive about which topics and techniques were
incorporated and incorporated. Stop. The mission of the "new cultural turning point" - as
appropriated here in the eighties - became some unique component from the social record that
remained associated with social dynamics that, on the other hand, threatened their negative
and right forms, or On the other hand there was an innovation. Inside and furthermore, attacks
from conservative historians such as Gertrude Hummelfarb, are pleased that social archives
became proper elements of the record in the upliftment of young adults and modern-day
publics through examples of heroic motion and an emphasis on political ideals Huh. Social
history now joins the search for a multidimensional discussion over the next few years that
have some specific basis. There are more than a few purposes. The first is the belief that the
field is sufficiently vibrant and moving to keep its constant space and promise the need for
recurrent self-study, every ancient and new, not relying on some of the troubling social
archives. The quintessential twin premises that every day man no longer has an archive on
separate hands—contributed to the shaping of the generally increasingly quick facts that are
considered a cornerstone of business mobility, and that In particular a large variety of
62
Sadasivan, S. N. (2001). A social history in India. APH Publishing.p45
63
Sadasivan, S. N. (2000). A social history of India. ahp Publishing.p77-78
59
behavior will be discovered advantageously in the historical preceding (even if including the
addition of) the most familiar political staples legitimate on a variety of hands64. They
alternately offer an explanation as to why the region has passed the status of a fad, thought to
be an eternal area of historical arsenal whose limits are hard to trace. If a vary of the brashest
early hopes have now no longer been realized-records in modern have now no longer been
modified to social archives or to a social traditionally professional mannequin of popular
records, and a decisive socio historical periodization has now no longer modified higher
conventional, the commonly political markers-the neighborhood has though been
transformed. Maintain the transformation deserves and calls for a periodic exchange on
whereby social information stands. The future of discipline has been in the hands of more and
more people. It's a second one that invites a somewhat reflective picture with the
resourcefulness of using a somewhat old hand, and even the additional, somewhat clunky
with the beneficially useful resource of using samples of some promising new ones. A range
of mid-profession leaders active in, for example, social archives, collecting facts fluctuate
outside USA and Europe.65. While cultural strategies for social record emphasize the value of
beliefs and assumptions and attribute their reason to company behavior, yet, at least inside the
USA, spectacular vantage elements are organizing to regroup. There's even a slight revival of
quantized work, circular issues in its own right of very lovely collections and extraordinarily
excellent things, special covers. And some daring social historians are making big statements
based entirely on non-cultural factors with monetary structure, an administrative size, social
base or marriage pattern at the same time. Finally, even though references to Foucault,
Bourdieu, Habermas, and others continue, they demonstrate a diminution. As Lynn Hunt
notes, there is much more to it than some curiosity now, not a decline in the concept
undertaking. This provide up quit result opens each troubles and possibilities for social
history66. The strength of mind has surpassed by way of way of the use of dominant, although
in no way monopolistic, methodologies, quantitative and cultural.67 And there would maybe
moreover be risk in addition to invitation with indoors the loss of any overarching new
approach, due to the fact the cultural flip recedes.68. It modified into thrilling at the same time
as all things considered new, even as youthful human beings of hassle and youthful humans in
64
Ferrell, J. (2017). Making trouble: Cultural constraints of crime, deviance, and control. Routledge.p14-16
Bell, D., &b,craddle. (2014). Exceptional Socialists: The Case of the French Socialist Party. Springer.p4
66
Bell, D., & Criddle, B. (2015). Exceptional Socialists in India: The Case of the French Socialist Party.
Springer.p5
67
Denscombe, M. (2017). EBOOK: The good research guide: For small-scale social research projects.
McGraw-Hill Education (UK).p78
68
Deacon, D., Pickering, M., Golding, P., & Murdock, G. (2021). Researching communications: A practical
guide to methods in media and cultural analysis. Bloomsbury Publishing USA.p77
65
60
occupation combined, even as the vicinity wished conversion.
CONCEPT OF SOCIAL HISTORY IN INDIA
Introspection about one's personal place in our society, and its effectiveness, is no longer an
extraordinary neighborhood among Indian historians. Our historical essays usually tend to
emerge as separate groups or as informational bibliographies, feature surveys or strikes in
tutorial guilds, etc69. They overturn circular debates about beliefs, methods, and ideological
positions. Through these historians researchers are pigeonholed into the new and untold neocolonial, dynastic, nationalist, communal, Marxist, and lower classes. Now the existence of a
society changing forms not one but many levels of ancient focus attracts many tons very little
attention. But provincial universities and colleges, school teachers, in a way under the guise
of cosmopolitan centers of analysis and discovery, have a very diverse student population,
and before them, numbers of excellent size are large or the right deal little untouched. The
ability mode of formal courses, on the other hand, can be tempting to trace the memory,
character, and origins of many book archives to factors beyond perception and. What is no
longer explained is the tutorial information, and the full query of the dimension's creation and
reception conditions, its relationship with the specific type of now specific surrounding
experience?' We have a special lack of social facts of history-writing in wonderful words.This
dispute of boundaries in India has intensified in the current years, with some reactions to
Mandla's proposals at length and a positive resolution in favor of 'backward' castes at the
length of right-wing Hindu communal forces70. In a way, each of these instruments of virtue
has an influence on the supposed views of the Indian archetype, which is routinely practiced
in present-day high-directorial circles. More primarily, I really take into account the whole
controversy of the Ram Janma bhoomi issue, in which the well-established prescriptive data
has faced, no longer very effectively, a size of ready and now isolated neighborhoods in large
part have no experience71. Secular historians have refuted, with substantial documents and
indisputable arguments, the ability of the Hindu right to advocate the development of the
medium, which resulted in a successful marketing and advertising campaign to demolish the
four-hundred-year-old ancient mosque in Ayodhya, the region. Advertising campaign was
launched. Unquestionably he had a high standard of intellectual - and human - reasoning. Yet
a conclusive or for the views of the country's leading historians, the Center for Historical
69
Tarrow, S. (1996). Making social science work across space and time: A critical reflection on Robert Putnam's
Making Democracy Work, 90(2), 389-397.
70
Bhattacharya, S. (1982). Paradigms lost: notes on social history in India. Economic and political weekly, 690696iii.
71
Varma, P. (2011). Being Indian: inside the real India. Random House.p44
61
Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, had little effect on most college students in comparison
to the prescription of the Blood Order of Ram Janma bhoomi (of Rama's birthplace) bloody
history).72This discovery of the new for the historical factuality of the country has come to the
fore that in some Indian discourses, various or some specific records have done a tremendous
amount of work; on the other hand, in the making of many such histories, magnificent
universities, colleges the students often have a really restrained and regular character. The
development of one's historical consciousness, though quite prepared, systematic, and
spontaneous, has come a long way from but, naturally, cannot be equated with the thinking of
expert historians only because it tends to change. There is also a need to examine both the
importance of files and some of its levels. The production and spread of the ancient center of
meditation in present-day India, is very clear, and as a point really helpful. Many historians
write and train exclusively in English for the essential human instinctive inter-local and global
communication of the association. Most universities and colleges, however, have converted to
Hindi or adjacent languages, translations in abundance have come a long way, and historically
not uncommon anymore is done, the brilliance of very near quality textbooks, or largely
through media influence. But a simply offers clarification will now no longer take us very a
prolonged way. At present we see that apart from a mark of introspection about the centrality
of the documents, their personal place in society is no longer an extraordinary neighborhood
among Indian historians. Our historical essays usually have a tendency to emerge as strikes in
bibliographies, feature surveys or tutorial guilds, and the fact-checking that results from them
has given it a new dimension. They overturn circular debates about beliefs, methods, and
ideological positions. It is through these historians that pigeons are cast into the groove: neocolonial, nationalist, sectarian, Marxist, and the lower classes. Now the existence of several
levels in not one but ancient way attracts tons of attention very little. But in the backyards of
metropolitan centers of analysis and discovery are provincial universities and colleges, school
teachers, a very diverse student population, and before them, numbers of excellent size are
large or the right deal little untouched73. The ability mode of formal courses, on the other
hand, can be tempting to explore the memory, character, and origins of factors beyond and
beyond perception about archives. What is no longer stated is the full query of the terms of
the creation and reception of tutorial information leading to a new formulation, its relationship
with the particular kind of now specific surrounding experience?' We lack the social facts of
72
Van Willigen, J,Chadha, N. K., & Chada, N. (2000). Social aging in a Delhi neighborhood. Greenwood
Publishing Group.p56
73
Perry, J. (1979). The problem of the essential indexical. Noûs,3-21.
62
historiography in wonderful words. This problem of borders in India has become fantastically
intensified in the current years, with some reactions to Mandla's proposals at length and a
positive resolution in favor of 'backward' castes at the length of right-wing Hindu communal
forces74. In a way, each of these instruments of virtue has an influence on the supposed views
of the Indian archetype, which is routinely practiced in present-day high-directorial circles.
More mainly, I genuinely have in thoughts the controversy all through the Ram Janma
Bhoomi issue, in which well-installed instructional data has desired to confront, now no
longer too effectively, one shape of prepared and in big part synthetic now no longer distinct
neighborhood experience. Secular historian‘s refuted, with sufficient documents and
unimpeachable logic, the causes advocate via way of capability of the Hindu Right, for it‘s in
consequence a success marketing and advertising marketing campaign to demolish a fourhundred-yr.-antique masjid at Ayodhya. 75But a simply offers clarification will now no longer
take us very a prolonged way76. The centrality of documents today, in addition to its markedly
multi-stage features, does not appear to be significantly oftentimes used or herbal phenomena.
They are naturally associated with the techniques whereby records obtained proper right here
to be taught, written, and noticeably valorized beneath colonial after which postcolonial
situations. This subject will have to pass by once more to the nineteenth century, even as
typically manufacturer new strategies of questioning about archives are frequently alleged to
have begun in India.
Neatly multi-stage features do not appear to be significantly oftentimes used or herbal
phenomena. This subject will have to pass by once more to the nineteenth century, even as
typically manufacturer new strategies of questioning about archives are frequently alleged to
have begun in India.
THE NEW THEORY OF SOCIAL HISTORY
New social history motion broke onto the 1960s environment, initial in the United Kingdom,
then in the United States and Canada, the neighborhood it all of surprising grew to develop to
be one of the dominant patterns of historiography. 77It used to be a subset of historiography
that founded on social constructions and strategies at its most crucial level 78. It stood in stark
74
Chomsky, N., & Barsamian, D. (2011). Imperial ambitions: Conversations on the post-9/11 world.
Metropolitan Books.p4-7
75
Sharma, R. S. (1991). Śūdras in ancient India: A social history of the lower order down to circa AD 600.
Motilal Banarsidass Publ.p33
76
malhotra.S (1992). Śūdras in ancient India: A social history of the lower order down to circa AD 600. Motile
Banarsidass Publ.
77
Tilly, C. (1984). ―The old new social history and the new old social history.‖
(Fernand Braudel
Center), 7(3), 363-406.
78
Robson, B. T., Walton, J. R., Black, I., Cain, P. J., White, C., Colls, R.,& Heffernan, M. J. (1993). Review of
63
huge distinction to political and financial archives in this way. The 2nd connotation, which
the Germans referred to as Gesell‘s, used to be broader. From a social-historical standpoint, it
is the files of a whole society.
"Social history" piqued the pastime of new technological information of historians in the
Nineteen Sixties and Nineteen Seventies. It grew to be a most fundamental idea in
historiography revisionism, as desirable as a rallying point. At the equal time, it supposed a
lot of specific things. It placed a massive emphasis on constructions and strategies than on
characters and events. It pressured social science-based analytical techniques as a choice than
historical hermeneutics' standard methods. Most frequently, social historians empathized with
the motives of the poor, the well-known the working class, movements, etc. It used to be each
quintessential and first-class to write a social files. My very non-public advertising and
marketing advisor educated us that he desired statistics to give up a predictive social
science79. I in no way went that far. I used to be as soon as quickly as drawn to the new social
statistics by using the use of functionality of its democratic inclusiveness as hundreds as with
the resource of talent of its machine and precision.80The Civilization for Social Science and
Historical Studies used to be placed in 1976 to raise collectively pupils from a massive range
of fields fascinated in social history. It is notwithstanding the reality that energetic and
publishes the records of social sciences quarterly. This place is in addition the specialty with
the resource of way of Peter Stearns on the grounds that 1967. Cultural statistics emphasizes
the language and price of beliefs and assumptions, and their causal feature in collective
movement.
HISTORICAL DEMOGRAPHY OF SOCIAL HISTORY
The find out about of normal people's lives was once sophisticated in the 1960s, the usage of
census and neighborhood births, marriages, deaths, private records from tax records, and
theoretical fashions drawn from sociology and sociology. It revolutionized the introduction of
quantitative and demographic methods. Demo is an each day electronic mail dialogue team
that covers an extensive varies of areas in this area. Historical demographics are learning
about of censuses and demographic processes, commonly the usage of censuses or
comparable statistical data. It has come to be an essential self-discipline in social records and
Urban Population Development in Western Europe from the Late-Eighteenth to the Early-Twentieth Century, by
Richard Lawton and Robert Lee; Land, Labour and Agriculture, 1700-1920,. Light; The English Eliot, by S.
Ellis; Women and the Women's Movement in Britain 1914 .... Journal of Historical Geography, 19(2), 205-252.
79
Davidson, R. M. (2004). Indian esoteric Buddhism: Social history of the tantric movement. Motilal Banarsidass
Publ.p88-90
80
Davidson,r.m.(2005). Indian esoteric Buddhism: Social history of the tantric movement. Motilal Banarsidass
Publ.p18
64
has sturdy ties to broader demographic fields such as demographic research.
SOCIAL HISTORY OF WORKING LABOURE
It affords with the social information of change unions and workers. For example, see US
Labor History. The Research Group on the History of International Labor and the Working
Class used to be installed in 1971 and has a thousand members. She publishes the archives of
the international working class. Labors everyday email-based speak crew primarily based in
1993 for over 1,000 lecturers and senior university students. Kirk (2010) has been inspecting
British labor data due to the fact the Labor History Study Group used to be established in
196081. He critiques that labor files is specifically practical, eclectic, and empirical. He is
moreover mindful of the vogue towards conservative quarantine and academics. He
encourages broader and higher necessary involvement in comparative, cross-border, and
world troubles that are gaining cognizance amongst labor historians elsewhere, and public and
political on these issues. Request a resurgence of interest.
SOCIAL HISTORY REPRESENT WOMEN AND GENDER HISTORY
Women's records exploded prominently in the 1971s, and are now nicely represented in all
geographic themes. More and greater gender records are included. Social records make use of
a woman's historic strategy to apprehend the ride of normal female, as antagonistic to the
"superb female" of earlier. 82.
Gender records focuses on the classes of femininity and masculinity, discourse and
experience. Gender records got here to the fore after being devised and developed via Scott in
the 1986 essay Gender.
SOCIAL HISTORY DEALS WITH SOCIETY EDUCATION
There is an emphasis on, and an employer base for, the higher. It used to be a story of
ignorance, and the prevailing wisdom on humanity cost-cutting and thin traditionalism, and of
modernization, renewal, by which fathers and mothers try to prevent their kids' cognition
authority from permeating the broader universe83. Educator‘s reformers with an emphasis on
serving the people good broad-sightedness, and civic-minded neighborhood public resources
were heroes. Textbooks inspire college students to become instructors of public colleges and
thereby fulfill their individual civic mission. The 1960s brought a sense of devastation, when
a new generation of New Left students and university students often dismissed the accounts of
81
Burnett, P. J., & Burnett, J. (2013). Plenty and Want: a social history of food in England from 1815 to the
present day. Routledge.p55
82
Howkins, A. (2003). The death of rural England: a social history of the countryside since 1900. Routledge.p5
83
Thompson, f.m.l.(Ed.). (1990). ―The Cambridge social history of Britain, 1750-1950 (Vol. 1)‖. Cambridge
University Press.p16
65
the celebration, and criticized America's many weaknesses, failures, and crimes. Diagnosed
the academic machine as the villain. So that the order of the society continues and equality
remains.84. In contemporary ages, much educational information providers with businesses or
focuses on the data of top notch reformist ideas, then again greater recently, who are
university college students in phrases of social heritage and social mobility? A new
established social file has emerged. In the United States, minority and ethnic university
college students are often the focal factor of attention. In the nineteenth century they
developed an exceptional university gadget that mirrored now no longer completely their
relationship with Britain, alternatively moreover the good sized financial and social changes
taking region at the equal time. This article seeks to furnish the basis for comparative lookup
with the aid of the usage of figuring out the lookup undertaken in the route of this period,
imparting rapid analytical remarks on some imperative studies, and discussing the
enchantment of educational history.85.
UNDERSTANDING OF OCCUPATIONAL MOBILITY
Account for observed variations in the relationship of status consistency to a preference for a
change in the distribution of power for different strata. Both lines of interpretation suggested
above appear plausible, at least post hoc. It is impossible at present, however, to assess their
relevance. On the basis of the findings of this study, and the arguments are given,
the following specifications for further research can be made. Measurement of status
consistency should take into account the extent to which the status characteristics used
are likely to be simultaneously salient86. Second, the opportunities for alternative modes
of adjustment to status inconsistency should be controlled or systematically varied. Third, to
test the rationale underlying the hypothesis relating to status consistency and preference for a
change in the distribution of power, it would be desirable to measure the intervening variables
assumed to be important, e.g. tendency to locate the sources of discomfort in the environment,
and relate these to the independent and dependent variables. These would seem to be
minimum specifications for clarifying the relationship of status consistency to the preference
for a change in the distribution of power. There is some support for the hypothesis of an
inverse relationship between the degree of status consistency and preference for a change in
the distribution of power.
84
Moreau, J. (2006). Schoolbook nation: Conflicts over American history textbooks from the Civil War to the
present. University of Michigan Press.p33
85
Steinbach, S. (2013). Women in America 1760-1914: a social history. Hachette UK.p4-5
86
Akresh, I. R. (2006). Occupational and social mobility among legal immigrants to the United States.
International Migration Review, 40(4), 444-447.
66
The event is related to the state of the relationship. Two lines of interpretation of this finding
suggested that this line of thought was being pursued. At a guess it turns out that the broker or
other way of setting the position mismatch could be responsible for the variations. Others
suggest that status as well as prominence were not taken into account in the status quo
cracker.
The event is related to the state of the relationship. There were two interpretations of the
interpretation of this finding. One hypothesis asserts that brokerage or other methods of
setting the position discrepancy may account for variations in the relationship. Others suggest
that status as well as prominence were not taken into account in the status quo cracker. The
measurement of occupational mobility is a critical matter since contingent upon the outcome
of such measurement are issues of the highest relevance for social stratification, social
mobility, and the process of social change. Most frequently in current usage the total amount
of mobility of a society is measured by comparing the occupational situation of one
generation with that of the preceding generation, and intra-societal estimates are made by
comparing various social segments in the same terms87.
The most sophisticated technology for making these comparisons is the "goodness of fit"
analysis, as used by such students as Glass and Rogoff, where expected frequencies are
estimated by the distribution of the occupations of fathers, corrected for institutional changes
in the available places in the labor-force, and the observed frequencies are read from the sons'
occupational distributions88.
Studies employing this technique have provided valuable and challenging information and
ideas about social mobility. But like any measure designed to provide one type of
information, other areas of interest to the student of mobility are unavoidably ignored, and
certain assumptions, which may sometimes be unwarranted, must be made.
FIVE MAJOR PROBLEMS ARE RAISED BY THE USE OF CURRENT MEASURES:
1. Wide divergence between fathers' and sons' occupational distributions may occur without
significant change in the distribution of prestige, power, or property. This could occur, for
instance, when large numbers of workers move from low-rated agricultural occupations to
nominally higher-rated urban industrial employment. Little genuine vertical mobility in
prestige, property or power may actually transpire. This makes possible the introduction of
87
Gruber, J., &Madrian, B. C. (2006). Health insurance, labor supply, and job mobility: A critical review of the
literature.
88
Iversen, V., Krishna, A., & Sen, K. (2016). Rags to riches? Intergenerational occupational mobility in India
(No. 042016). GDI, The University of Manchester.p7-8
67
differential bias into the mobility scores of these nominally mobile groups.
2. A second and more fundamental problem concerns the subjective experience of mobility.
When mobility rates are computed by the "goodness of fit" technique, no inferences are
possible regarding the extent to which the groups said to be mobile so perceive them. Only if
sons compare themselves with their fathers will the divergence of sons from fathers' positions
give us some valuable clues about the actors' definitions of the situation. But if sons use other
reference groups, such as their age peers, or educational peers, or residential peers, then, wide
divergences between sons and fathers may be accompanied by very different subjective
experiences, even to the point where a group objectively defined as upwardly mobile may
perceive itself as downwardly mobile, if in its aspirations and self-images, it has been
surpassed by its effective others89. Since actors themselves probably use a peer group as
frequently their parental group for comparison, a measure of occupational mobility ought
perhaps to include some elements of both parental and peer position. The parental position
gives the point of entry into the labor force, the initial social capital; and the peer position
provides information on the relative outcome of persons who started at the same place.
3. Closely associated to the foregoing is the query of measuring the ride of mobility in such a
way that persons can be scored and companies of respondents then sorted on the foundation
of their mobility scores.'0 Since the trip of mobility, subjectively calculated, is regularly
referred to as an essential issue in motivation and in social integration in a altering society, the
potential to assign mobility ratings to people and for this reason make a contribution totally to
estimates of mobility, since, through definition, it is not possible for the sons of highest-rated
fathers to be upwardly-mobile and for the sons of lowest-rated fathers to be downwardly
mobile.
4. A final problem concerns the failure to control birth order, birth spacing and a number of
siblings. Older and younger sons are likely to have different mobility experiences. Younger
sons may be able to count upon working brothers to help them advance their educational
achievements. Children in large families have fewer per capita life chances as measured by
available capital than children in smaller families at comparable economic levels. Other
students have recognized these problems.
Here we have gathered data and performed the analysis necessary for an experimental try-out
of a measure of occupational mobility that meets some of the problems cited above. Our
measure is called the Generational Occupational Mobility Score, abbreviated as GOMS, and
89
Journy, Charles. Big Structures, Large Processes, Huge Comparisons (1964)p6-7
68
the required data and computational procedures are given below.
SUMMARY OF PROCEDURE
A. Raw Data
1. Occupation of ego
2. Occupation of ego father
3. Occupation of the entire ego's brothers
1. Changes in an occupational function that are nominal and now not consequential are much
less possibly to introduce differential bias into the measurements, considering that the GOMS
measures mobility in phrases of the extent to which the respondent deviates from the common
fulfillment of all others whose fathers had the equal occupational rank. Thus, anything new
meanings may additionally be inherent in the occupational shifts concurrently and besides
differential, bias applies to all concerned90.
2. Both father's and peers' statuses are built into the measure, since father's occupation is used
as the baseline, and the GOMS is itself a function of the occupational distribution of all sons
of these fathers. Such a measure may correspond more closely than estimates based on
divergence from the father with the subjective estimates of mobility made by the actors
themselves. This is not meant to be taken as a demonstrated advantage of the GOMS. Rather,
it is a specification of the conditions under which the GOMS would be more useful than
measures that do not use the peer group as the reference group 91.
3. Individuals can be assigned mobility rankings with the GOMS considering that in fact, the
averages have to be computed from such person scores. Thus, respondents can be said on the
foundation of their mobility experience, which can then be used as an unbiased or intervening
variable in a lookup design.
4. The full weight of the experiences of the sons of highest- and lowest-rated fathers enter into
the scores, since, for instance, the son of a expert can be scored as upwardly cellular if he
exceeds the common of all different sons of professionals, and the son of an agricultural daylaborer can be scored as downwardly cellular if he ratings decrease than the common of all
different sons of day-laborers.
5. Birth order, birth spacing and the number of siblings are controlled for by randomizing
their effects through the technique of taking an average of all the sons of any family (i.e., the
respondent and all his brothers) who are in the labor force and using their average score as the
90
Western, B. (2010). The impact of incarceration on wage mobility and inequality. American sociological
review, 526-546.
91
Western, B. (2006). The impact of incarceration on wage mobility and inequality, 522-530.
69
one assigned to the respondent.
1. Since the GOMS is calculated in standard scores, there is no way of measuring the concrete
distance moved by any respondent, nor of tracing the concrete places in the division labor or
into and out of which he has moved in his occupational history.
2. Because the GOMS is a standard score, persons within more dispersed distributions receive
lower mobility scores, even when normality exists. And if the distributions are skewed rather
than normal, a serious bias may occur. For example, a jump of two occupational categories
may be equal to only one standard deviation interval in some distributions but as much as
three in other distributions92.
These handicaps may be so substantial under some conditions that the use of the GOMS
would be contraindicated. However, when the necessary conditions can be met, the GOMS
suggests itself as a powerful tool of analysis. The GOMS is offered not as a substitute for
other measures but as a corollary measure of other aspects of the large and complex set of
experiences called social actions of "years of school completed," yielding 15 sampling boxes.
Information was gathered about the occupational history of each of 1,000 respondents, and
the occupations of their fathers and of each of their brothers ever in the labour force was
recorded. With this information, the GOMS were computed. All occupations were arbitrarily
classified into eleven categories and assigned numerical ratings of one to eleven, starting with
agro mobility. The extent to which this proves to be a useful measure depends upon the extent
to which (a) the specified conditions are met, (b) the requisite data are available, and (c) the
comparison with peer groups is important in the theory with which one is working. The data
here reported come from an intensive study of social stratification and social mobility in
Puerto Rico, principally sponsored by the Social Science Research Centre of the University of
Puerto Rico. Interviews lasting between three and four hours were conducted by well-trained
interviewers with a sample of 1,000 heads of household, drawn on an area-probability basis
from a master sample of the Bureau of Labor Statistics and stratified by three gradations of
urban-rural residence and five grad cultural day laborers at the bottom and ending with
professionals at the top93.
It will be seen that there is apparently considerable heterogeneity of variance in the various
distributions. Nevertheless, tests for the homogeneity of variance disclose that the conditions
92
Western, B. (2002). The impact of incarceration on wage mobility and inequality. American sociological
review, 525-546.
93
Anderson, Michael. Apparoaches to the History of the Western Family 1500-1914 (1995) 104pp
70
of homogeneity had been satisfactorily met. It ought to be pointed out, however, that every
category below "clerk" has more than twice as high a proportion in the upper tail as a normal
distribution would have. Similarly, in each category above "owners and managers of farms"
there are significantly smaller proportions of cases in the upper tail than would be present in a
normal distribution. Additionally, there are various other departures from normality scattered
throughout the eleven distributions, but no clear-cut patterns emerge that would permit
observations about concentrations of skewed distributions94.
In all but one case, the higher-rated occupational category scores higher on mobility as
measured by the GOMS. The single reversal is the comparison between clerks and skilled
laborers, and here the difference is not significant. The only other non-significant difference
occurs between service workers and unskilled laborers, but here the difference is in the
anticipated direction. These results strongly suggest a positive correlation between
occupational rank and occupational mobility, which holds with relatively equal strength
throughout the occupational ladder.
It will also be seen in that the four lowest categories are under-achievers-i.e.; men in those
occupations are at present located in lower positions than the average position now held by
those with whom they started. (All scores above 10 represent over achievement; below 10,
underachievement.)
In brief, these occupations appear to have selectively culled the
downwardly mobile members of the labor force. By contrast, the highest seven categories are
all overachievers,'5 in the sense that their average occupational positions now are higher than
the averages of those with whom they started.
We believe these findings are of interest most particularly in regard to what they permit us to
say about the GOMS itself. For since every higher occupational position but one is matched
by a higher GOMS, we may say that the GOMS, in this case at least, indicates (a) the relative
position of any respondent compared to those whose fathers had the same occupation as his,
and (b) also indicates the amount any respondent has moved relative to his peers. In short, the
same measure indicates that those who are now higher have moved farther than those with
whom they started.
When the size and direction of means are examined, further significance can be given to these
scores and differences. The non-significance of the difference between the high school and
upper-grammar school groups is due to the fact that while each of them has excelled over its
peers, neither has excelled by very much. The effects of education, in so far as they bear on
94
Grunberger, R. (2013). A social history of the Third Reich. Hachette UK.p66
71
occupational mobility, are cumulative, for in every case, the higher group has the slightly
higher mean. The difference between the upper-grammar school and high school groups is on
the threshold of significance. This threshold is reached and passed in the case of the college
group95.
To generalize these findings, education appears to be positively related to occupational
mobility at all points in the educational continuum but shows its sharpest effects at the
extremes. This informs us also about the bearing of the father's occupation on occupational
mobility. Relative to education, the father's occupation is of least significance at the top and
bottom of the occupational ladder, and of greatest significance in the middle educational
rungs.
From these findings, we reason that occupational opportunities seem to be opened wide with
even a few years of education as compared with the opportunities available for those who
have had none. But subsequent schooling after the first four years does not make as much
difference as the first four years. This trend continues until some college education has been
achieved. At this point, occupational horizons are once again opened wide relative to what
they are for those who stop at high school graduation or before96.
Putting these observations together, we note that the father's occupation and son's education
both clearly improve the son's chances to secure a relatively larger command over goods and
services than his predecessors. But the relative importance of each of these two key variables
shifts. Son's education outweighs the father's occupation at the beginning and ends of the
educational ladder, while the father's occupation is more strongly determinative in the middle
ranges.
This makes sense in terms of the structure of opportunity in Puerto Rico. For in its present
condition of development, some literacy makes a big difference; added amounts of literacy
make less difference in, and of available jobs; and educational training does not make a big
difference again until one has some college training.
Since most of the job mobility in future years is likely to take place in the middle range of
jobs for the majority of the further mobile population, the father's occupation is likely to play
a larger role than the son's education in determining where the son will ultimately land upon
the occupational ladder, and how well he will have done, in the process, relative to peers.
95
Hareven, Tamara K. "The History of the Family and the Complexity of Social Change," American Historical
Review, (1991) pp 95–124
96
Berger, J. B., Ramirez, G. B., & Lyons, S. (2005). Past to present. College student retention: Formula for
student success, 1.
72
The foregoing observations are illustrative of the kinds of observations about the dynamics of
stratification that can be made with the GOMS. We are helped toward a clearer understanding
of what it means to be in a given position, so far as the outcome in life chances is concerned;
and we are enabled to ask what it is about the several constituents of class position that makes
the difference. Moreover, populations can now be sorted out on the basis of their mobility
experiences, and a beginning can be made in understanding their motivational schemes, selfimages and role performances in terms of the history of their experiences in the social system,
without necessary resort to a wealth of historical material. The first sociological studies of
mental illness sought to correlate its incidence with various social variables, particularly those
associated with the complexities of urban living.' More recent urban community studies
attempt to go beyond a descriptive analysis of demographic variables and to explore value
patterns associated with them that could conceivably result in personality strain followed by
overt psychotic symptomatology.
The research methods used in the latter studies are more refined than those used in the former,
because the design permits more exact comparison of mentally ill and non-mentally ill
persons from the same socio-cultural environment. In both types of studies, however, the
variables are usually examined without respect to related demographic characteristics that
might show differential results in the groups studied. In the few instances where other
demographic characteristics are taken into account, the number of cases is too small to
warrant generalizations.
73
Chapter III
OCCUPATIONAL MOBILITY FACTORS
Productivity and mobility, bringing to light recent shifts in the research system, such as
internationalization, intersection mobility, collaboration, and career diversification, which
have made researcher mobility more relevant to the dynamics of knowledge creation and
dissemination. According to this review, we still don't know much about the effects and
reasons behind individual researchers' increased mobility. We make a contribution by
outlining a classification of researcher mobility and pondering the significance of a variety of
mobility occasions throughout a researcher's career. Last but not least, we go over the
modeling issues that arise when examining the impact of individual mobility on academic
performance97.
An important aspect of labor markets in industrialized nations is occupational mobility, which
is measured as a worker moves from one job to another. From one year to the next, nearly 3%
of employees in Europe switch jobs. This kind of mobility has a number of effects that have a
big impact on welfare. To begin, from the perspective of a worker, occupational mobility may
result in a better match between individual skills and job-specific requirements. Higher wages
typically reflect this improved matching. However, employees may have a negative
perception of increased labor market uncertainty as a result of high occupational mobility
because changing occupations typically also entail losing specific human capital and
associated wage premiums. In the end, these effects of occupational mobility may affect their
lifetime earnings in a positive or negative way. Second, according to Kwon and Myerson
Milgrom (2014), these mechanisms have implications for employers who can also benefit
from occupational mobility and the resulting improved match quality. While the loss of
skilled workers may result in costs for employers, this may reduce unit labor costs. Thirdly,
because of the associated costs of transition, occupational mobility is a significant factor in
both income inequality and labor market efficiency at the aggregate level (Cortes and
Gallipoli, 2018). Moreover, it is a significant facilitator for adapting to primary change, for
example changing ability and errand prerequisites, particularly the decrease sought after for
routine undertakings98.
97
Duncan, O. D., & Hodge, R. W. (1963). Education and occupational mobility a regression analysis. American
Journal of Sociology, 68(6), 632-644.
98
De Raeve, L., Jansen, N. W., van den Brandt, P. A., Vasse, R., & Kant, I. J. (2009). Interpersonal conflicts at
work as a predictor of self-reported health outcomes and occupational mobility. 66(1), 16-22.
74
UNDERSTANDING OF OCCUPATIONAL MOBILITY
Account for observed variations in the relationship of status consistency to a preference for a
change in the distribution of power for different strata. Both lines of interpretation suggested
above appear plausible, at least post hoc. It is impossible at present, however, to assess their
relevance. On the basis of the findings of this study, and the arguments are given,
the following specifications for further research can be made. Measurement of status
consistency should take into account the extent to which the status characteristics used
are likely to be simultaneously salient99. Second, the opportunities for alternative modes
of adjustment to status inconsistency should be controlled or systematically varied. Third, to
test the rationale underlying the hypothesis relating to status consistency and preference for a
change in the distribution of power, it would be desirable to measure the intervening variables
assumed to be important, e.g. tendency to locate the sources of discomfort in the environment,
and relate these to the independent and dependent variables. These would seem to be
minimum specifications for clarifying the relationship of status consistency to the preference
for a change in the distribution of power. There is a very good support for the hypothesis of
an inverse relationship between the degree of status consistency and preference for a change
in the distribution of power100.
The relationship appears to be directly related to level position. Two lines of interpretation of
this finding were suggested. One stresses the possibility that mobility or other methods of
adjusting to status incongruity may account for variation in relationships as they also affect
society to a large extent. Others suggest that the measure of position stability did not take into
account salience along with position characteristics.
The measurement of occupational mobility is a critical matter since contingent upon the
outcome of such measurement are issues of the highest relevance for social stratification,
social mobility, and the process of social change. Most frequently in current usage the total
amount of mobility of a society is measured by comparing the occupational situation of one
generation with that of the preceding generation, and intra-societal estimates are made by
comparing various social segments in the same terms101.
The most sophisticated technology for making these comparisons is the "goodness of fit"
99
Akresh, I. R. (2006). Occupational mobility among legal immigrants to the United States. International
Migration Review, 40(4), 854-884.
100
De Raeve, L., Jansen, N. W., van den Brandt, P. A., Vasse, R., & Kant, I. J. (2010). Interpersonal conflicts at
work as a predictor of self-reported health outcomes and occupational mobility. Occupational and environmental
medicine, 66(1), 16-22.
101
Gruber, J., &Madrian, B. C. (2002). Health insurance, labor supply, and mobility.
75
analysis, as used by such students as Glass and Rogoff, where expected frequencies are
estimated by the distribution of the occupations of fathers, corrected for institutional changes
in the available places in the labor-force, and the observed frequencies are read from the sons'
occupational distributions102.
Studies employing this technique have provided valuable and challenging information and
ideas about social mobility. But like any measure designed to provide one type of
information, other areas of interest to the student of mobility are unavoidably ignored, and
certain assumptions, which may sometimes be unwarranted, must be made.
OCCUPATIONAL MOBILITY IN KHEM KARAN TOWN
Society Various stories about the resilience of caste as a group, about its declining status as
an explanatory thing in social life in present-day India, rising hierarchies, descending order
and strength building, appreciation of the spirit of struggle It can also be seen in predictions.
There are changed thoughts of movement which have been defined by many sociologists and
economists, historians, politicians which are universal in general and pervasive everywhere.
Absolute mobility refers to whether or not now or not, and is dependent on how large
humans are from their society, but also on how they maintain each other's cooperation.
Relative mobility, on the specific hand, is the distribution of whether offspring exceeds its
society in terms of its characteristic in terms of whether or not both are likely to meet, it
seems: whether humans move up or down the ladder in difference of their social occupation
status Mobility refers to a change in one's work at some stage in one's life. As their actions
change, a new length of mobility appears, even as inter-generational mobility focuses on
this. Gagging social mobility is a data-heavy task, especially in work-related mobility
research, which requires long-term panel information on social penalties and your own. In
fact, data restrictions in many worldwide places make these measures impossible 103.
Occupational mobility is the relationship between occupational beginning (and private
occupation) and vacation spot (personal occupational outcome). Occupation has some
methodological blessings in contrast to analyzing earnings and earnings mobility and
suggests the extent to which person brain is given the opportunity. Job mobility is especially
necessary in India; the place the caste machine has robust job ties. Under hostilities
102
Iversen, V., Krishna, A., & Sen, K. (2016). Rags to riches? Intergenerational occupational mobility in India
(No. 042016). GDI, The University of Manchester.p9-10
103
Shniper, L. (2005). Occupational mobility, January 2004. Monthly Lab. Rev., 128, 30.
76
conditions, how in all likelihood are people to cease up somewhere? Instead, how in all
likelihood is it those human beings will stop up making them through hand elsewhere?
In any country, if a place is close to the border of that country, then it has many effects of its
own. Evacuation, frequent change of their place, etc. is such work, which affects, the society
there very badly and its result is visible in the form of social mobility and occupational
mobility. Khem Karan Tehsil of Punjab state is also one of those places. One is where people
not only lost their social environment during two wars but they also left many jobs. People of
Khem Karan Tehsil have seen their settled occupation change. In the year 1965 India-Pakistan
war during this, the entire area of this Tehsil had become empty and the people there saw, a
horrifying scene, whatever business the p; whatever should join, they were left out, and every
class was facing a financial crisis in some way or the other. The 1971 war and subsequent
terrorist incidents have affected the people living in the area. Khem Karan town has found its
people scattered on every occasion. Social mobility affected the people of Khem Karan the
most, which is the reason for the people here, Migration and their withdrawal from their main
trades. Time and again the tense atmosphere in the region has affected not only the people of
Khem Karan but also the employment there. When we see in Lesson 3 how Khem Karan has
become the social change of the people is seen during these wars and business changes are,
also visible on a large scale104.
GEOGRAPHICAL MOBILITYIt is referred to as "geographical mobility of labor" when a worker relocates within a country
or between nations. Geographical mobility is, for instance, the movement of labor from Khem
Karan to Delhi, Amritsar or India to Canada105.
WORKPLACE MOBILITY
The transition of workers from one occupation to another is referred to as occupational
mobility. These two types of mobility are further subdivided as follows:
a) Mobility in the Horizon:
Horizontal mobility refers to the transfer of workers within the same grade or level from one
occupation to another. For instance, a bank clerk joins a company as an accounts clerk.
b) Mobility from below:
Vertical mobility occurs when a worker of a lower grade and status moves to a higher grade
and status occupation. A clerk becomes a manager; a school lecturer becomes a college
lecturer, and so on.
104
105
Litwak, E. (1960). Occupational mobility and extended family cohension. American sociological review, 9-21.
Litwak, E. (1961). Occupational mobility. American sociological review, 13-18
77
3. Mobility across Sectors:
Industrial mobility is the movement of workers in the same job from one industry to another.
Factors Affecting Workers' Mobility:
The following factors influence the mobility of labor:
1. Training and education:
The degree to which laborers are educated and trained influences their mobility. A person's
chances of changing jobs or locations are higher the more educated and skilled they are.
Education and training are necessary for both horizontal and vertical mobility.
2. Demand or Outlook:
Mobility is determined by workers' outlook or desire to advance in life. They will change jobs
and locations if they are optimistic and open-minded. Contrasts in language, propensities,
religion, position, and so on, will not restrict their movement.
3. Social Situation:
The social structure also affects labor mobility. Mobility of labor is lacking in a society ruled
by the caste system and joint family. However, the mobility of labor increases in areas where
the caste and joint family systems do not exist or have disintegrated.
4. Transport Methods:
Mobility of labor is facilitated by well-developed transportation and communication
infrastructure. The worker is aware that, in the event of an emergency at home, he can easily
reach his family via phone, return by train within the nation, or fly home if he is abroad 106.
5. Agricultural Changes:
During busy seasons, labor moves from high- to low-population areas as a result of
agricultural development.
6. Industrialization:
Industrial development determines the mobility of labor. Factory work requires workers to
relocate from various occupations and locations. Workers move from semi-urban and rural
areas to industrial centers and big cities as a result of industrialization107.
7. Trade:
The spread of business and trade offices and institutions in various parts of the country is a
result of their expansion. Workers move around to work in a variety of settings and
professions, including banks, insurance companies, and trade and business offices.
106
107
Stuckert, R. P. (1963). Occupational mobility and family relationships. Social Forces, 41(3), 301-307.
Deshpande, R., & Palshikar, S. (2008). Occupational mobility: How much does caste matter.61-70.
78
8. Advertisement:
The mobility of labor is also influenced by job advertisements in newspapers. As a result,
workers switch jobs and locations.
9. State Aid:
When the government begins projects like industrial centers, estates, employment exchanges,
dams, public works, etc., they encourage workers to move around.
10. Security and peace:
The country's level of law and order is a significant factor in labor mobility. People won't
move from their current locations and occupations to others if their lives and property are in
danger.
Worker Mobility Challenges:
The mobility of labor is hampered by numerous factors. Climate, religion, caste, customs,
tastes, and other differences are among them. Other factors include poverty, economic
backwardness, and a lack of transportation and communication options, employment
opportunities, illiteracy, ignorance, debt, attachment to property and place, and other factors.
Benefits of Labour Mobility:
When workers move into jobs for which they are best suited, mobility of labor contributes to
an increase in productivity and efficiency. When they switch jobs that pay more, it also raises
their incomes.
When workers move to places where they are wanted, it solves the unemployment issue.
Further the versatility of work helps in monetary advancement when jobless work movements
to public works like dams, streets, trenches and so on, as well as factories. It hence expands
creation, business and pay108.
If we see change in any society, then we feel PTA about the social and professional changes
there too. Similarly, we see changes in Khem Karan also. The Indo-Pak war of 1965had put a
hold on the social and professional status of Khem Karan to a great extent. But after the war
gradually changes were visible in the social and occupational dynamics. The people of Khem
Karan also kept themselves at the global level and made changes accordingly 109. Started
looking for modern means of farming and other means of business like going out for business
and work etc. And in this sequence, fish farming also started. Women also started taking part
in this. In this way, Khem Karan kept increasing its commercial mobility in every way,
108
Simón, H., Ramos, R., & Sanromá, E. (2014). Immigrant occupational mobility: Longitudinal evidence from
Spain. European Journal of Population, 30, 223-255.
109
Klimova, E. M., Kamyshanov (2018). Subjective factors of occupational mobility. Modern Journal of
Language Teaching Methods, 8(12), 46-55.
79
decade after decade.
WESTERNIZATION
According to M.N. Srinivas, westernization is the alternate which has come because of the
impact of British rule in India. This alternate is pondered within side the techniques,
costumes, meals behavior and behavior and life of the human beings etc. The method of
westernization works at 3 levels: (1) number one, (2) secondary and (3) tertiary. There had
been a few human beings on the number one stage that got here into touch with Western
subculture, and had been additionally the various first to advantage from it. Secondary stage
westernization refers to the ones sections of the Indian society who got here into direct touch
with the primary beneficiaries. At the tertiary stage there are folks who had been capable of
get oblique facts approximately the hints brought via way of means of the British. Thus the
method of westernization has 3 stages 110. Unfold of this method in one of a kind sections of
the Indian society has been choppy or even unequal. Although Srinivas mentions humanism
and egalitarianism the various deserve of this method, Westernization is a method of cultural
and cognitive colonialism, consistent with different scholars, and "a version of an impersonal,
uncultured and non-widely wide-spread state." Westernization has contributed to the reemergence of a pan-Indian subculture on new grounds. Westernization has had its effect
within side the regions of training, law, technology and technology, new kinds of
politicization, urbanization, industrialization, the click and method of shipping and verbal
exchange. The emergence of those founding centers has been termed via way of means of
Yogendra Singh as a method of "cultural modernization". Through western impact, a super
culture of modernization has arisen. Of course, this has created a trouble of war among the
indigenous culture and the western culture. In the context of the elite sections of Indian
society, there's a synthesis among those traditions. In the early stages, the Western impact
become peripheral and localized because it remained restricted to the middle-magnificence
human beings within side the towns of Kolkata, Bombay and Madras. Educational
establishments had been additionally focused in those 3 towns. English training had a twin
effect: 1) Insertion of Western values and ideologies amongst knowledgeable human beings,
and (2) The upward push of social and cultural reform actions. We will talk the reform actions
in every other chapter. Education become additionally restrained to the higher and middlemagnificence city human beings. The British rule created a brand new shape of attention and
values. According to Yogendra Singh, westernization has the subsequent effects: 1.
110
Robinson, C. (2019). Occupational mobility, occupation distance, and specific human capital. Journal of
Human Resources, 53(2), 513-522.
80
Development of a widely wide-spread prison super-shape 2. Spread of training .These factors
contributed to modernization in the course of the country. Judiciary, Courts, Law (to save you
toddler marriage, toddler homicide and Sati etc.), Law Commissions had been installation and
installation for Marriage, Family, Divorce, Adoption, Transfer of Property, Minorities, Land
Rights, Transactions, Trade, Industry and Labor Implemented new law regarding this.
Changes in Rural Communities in the 1950s, several studies were published about the Indian
rural community. Indian Village of Shyamacharan Dubey in 1955, M.N. Srinivas's (Edited)
India's Villages, D.N. Rural profiles by Mazumdar (edited) and Village India (edited) by
McKim Marriott were published. All these studies explain the structure and process in rural
India. The main aspects in these studies were caste system, family, jajmani system, religious
practices and rituals, health conditions, village and caste panchayats, social mobility among
different caste groups and adult franchise, education, development and impact on rural people.
This effect is unequal in different villages and on different castes, communities and families
in the same village.111And due to cultural differences, it is no longer a convenient venture to
classify the villages of India. Significant modifications have taken location in the Indian
village after independence. The caste gadget is no longer restricted to social and monetary
family members primarily based on jajmani112. The fact is that due to the expanded in
connectivity with cities and the introduction of technological measures in the area of
agriculture, the jajmani machine has weakened. The regular device has been shaken by using
the market economy. But caste is nevertheless the principal supply of socio-cultural grouping
on birth, marriage, loss of life and different social occasions. Caste endogamy, gotra exogamy
in choice making of marriages and different associated guidelines are the basis. According to
caste endogamy, a character can marry inside his personal caste. There are many gotras in a
caste or sub-caste. Those human beings who belong to their personal gotra and these who
belong to the gotra of the maternal aspect is regarded backyard the circle of marriage. In spite
of the above-mentioned caste continuities, the inter-caste members of the family are now
fragmented, i.e. inter-caste interdependence has decreased, tensions have expanded and
opposition amongst one of kind castes has accelerated for getting most shares in village
resources. Castes and even exceptional clans and clans inside particular castes occasionally
behave as factional and rival groups. People vote in Panchayat elections maintaining in
111
Harper, B. (1995). Male occupational mobility in Britain. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 57(3),
349-369.
112
Hazelrigg, L. E., & Garnier, M. A. (1976). Occupational mobility in industrial societies: A comparative
analysis of differential access to occupational ranks in seventeen countries. American Sociological Review,
498-511.
81
thinking the caste. Castes have turn out to be a sort of egocentric group. Nevertheless, things
of some serious penalties for the whole caste and together conflicting and controversial things
are determined through a casual committee of contributors of the Jati Panchayat Prabhu. Such
possibilities are very rare113.
The motivational shape in accomplishing the goals is the foundation of the man or woman in
the use of handy opportunities and skill of communication. According to Mr. D'Souza,
whatever the occupational status of a human being today, its division is the most reliable
indicator of its status. Self-identification of exceptional classes of respondents has also been
used to understand the status of the category so that they can be studied more easily.
Objective standards are correlated and organized with the identity of the individual category.
The most important lessons are those that give you a sense of the definite nature of (1) the
upper class, (2) the middle class, (3) the working class, and (4) the lower class. D'Souza also
mentioned seven occupational classes which are associated with specific lessons in different
ways depending on the situation of the individuals. Cities have several types of enterprise
directives. This training function skilled works in teaching, scientific and felony offerings
etc114. Businessmen can get necessary insights about the method of social stratification and
mobility by means of reading social value. The percentage of commercial enterprise training
in India is very low in relation to all the employees as in contrast to different nations of Asia.
There are 171 commercial enterprise employees in India for each 10,000 workers. There are
489 in Japan, 349 in China, 446 in Sri Lanka, 314 in Malaysia and 294 in Philippine. This is
additionally evident from the reality that contributors of top castes and city human beings are
extra in occupations. Thus, contributors of the upper, upper-middle and center training
dominate most of the possibilities and positions in the professions. High-level political elites
additionally belong to the higher and upper-middle castes and classes. This reality is genuine
of all political events barring some specific persons, however in current years; the dominance
of city wealthy human beings has extended in politics. Some alternate is additionally seen in
the All India and Central Services, Medical and Engineering professions. According to
D'Souza, occupational status is the most dependable indicator of category status. Selfidentification of extraordinary classes of respondents has additionally been used to apprehend
classification status. Objective standards are correlated with person type identity. The
principal lessons are (1) higher class, (2) center class, (3) working class, and (4) decrease
113
Avola, M., & Piccitto, G. (2020). Ethnic penalty and occupational mobility in the Italian labour
market. Ethnicities, 20(6), 1093-1116.
114114
Byrne, J. J. (1975). Occupational mobility of workers. Monthly Lab. Rev., 98, 53.
82
class. D'Souza additionally stated seven occupational classes which are associated to unique
instructions in one of a kind approaches relying on the positions of the persons. There are
many kinds of enterprise lessons in cities. These training function educated work in teaching,
scientific and prison offerings etc. Businessmen can get vital insights about the method of
social stratification and mobility with the aid of reading social value. The share of commercial
enterprise lessons in India is very low in relation to all the people as in contrast to different
nations of Asia115. There are 171 commercial enterprise employees in India for each and every
10,000 workers. There are 489 in Japan, 349 in China, 446 in Sri Lanka, 314 in Malaysia and
294 in Philippine116. This is additionally evident from the reality that contributors of higher
castes and city humans are extra in occupations. Thus, contributors of the upper, upper-middle
and center lessons dominate most of the possibilities and positions in the professions. Highlevel political elites additionally belong to the top and upper-middle castes and classes. This
truth is proper of all political events barring some specific persons, but in current years, the
dominance of city wealthy human beings has elevated in politics. Some exchange is
additionally seen in the All India and Central Services, Medical and Engineering professions.
If we talk about the registered industries in the country, then we find that about 70 percent of
the employees of the country live in cities or live near urban areas. Most of these people
working at workplaces also live in cities and towns, due to which there are many reasons, this
is the past for all. The following lessons are seen in the social nature of towns and cities- it is
divided into the form by the status of its work (1) the best-class merchants, industrialists and
bureaucrats, (2) high-income businessmen, scientists and technologists, commercial
Enterprise managers and giant businessmen in industry, (3) clerks and low-level executives
working in private offices and private firms, college teachers, working journalists, struggling
businessmen, small shopkeepers and small-scale entrepreneurs, and (4) the working class , for
example operators and artisans, home industry workers, provider workers, hawkers and
watchmen, housing builders and untrained workers. We can say that urbanization refers to the
migration of human beings from rural areas to cities. The cost of urbanization in the twentieth
century has been much faster than before. The pace of urbanization and city reform has been
uneven. It has significantly affected the whole of India and certain regions in general,
irrespective of the region. The work of towns and cities in the improvement of an area has
been an essential element for the financial improvement of that area. In addition to gaps, the
115
Elder Jr, G. H. (1969). Occupational mobility, life patterns, and personality. Journal of Health and Social
Behavior, 308-323.
116
Anastasiadou, S. D., Batiou, V., & Valkanos, E. (2015). Occupational mobility dimensions in
Greece. Procedia Economics and Finance, 19, 325-331.
83
measurement of cities has also been of particular importance. These book factors, dimensions
and areas, are influencing rural-urban interactions to a great extent such as migration, supply
of goods in the city market and purchase of consumer goods from cities, etc. In this section,
we have defined the differences between rural and urban communities, the nature of the
pattern of urbanization, and the social size of the city in terms of the type of structure.
Social alternate in the shape and tradition of society is initiated by means of inner and exterior
sources. By the shape of the society we refer to the infrastructural facilities, its distribution
amongst the human beings and get admission to their services whereas the tradition of the
society consists of the traditions, religion, requirements of existence and interpersonal
behavior117. The shape and tradition of society has no longer remained static. Social alternate
consequently will become an inevitable process. Now chapter it used to be stated that the
course of social alternate can be upward or downward, unilateral, multilinker or cyclic. Social
exchange may additionally emerge in the structure of development or decline. Thus, social
exchange refers to an exchange in the shape and tradition of a unique society. Generally
speaking, social exchange is cost neutral. Sometimes social alternate is additionally in the
shape of ideological thoughts of a conservative or intense nature. Change is cumulative,
specifically in the subject of science and technology118. Apart from being cumulative and
emergent, exchange is additionally cyclical and curve-like. Interconnectedness and modernity
are concomitant; continuity and trade are empirical statistics of social life. Tradition and
modernity are concomitant additionally due to the fact all societies require steadiness and
social controls .Modernity and change are needed to achieve new levels of knowledge and
technical know-how, to meet the demands and challenges of change. Due to these
circumstances social change takes place. Social tension and conflict are also sources of social
change. Social change also occurs due to difference in values of old, young, educated,
uneducated and urban dweller and villager.
INDO-PAK WAR 1965 AND KHEM KARAN
In addition to the attacks by Pakistani Air Force airstrikes, Pakistan's ground forces also
carried out large-scale attacks on our border posts. Pakistani forces after heavily shelling the
Poonch sector started crossing the cease-fire line. Pakistan‘s heavy guns also shelled with
varying degree of intensity the border posts at Khem Karan. Khem Karan which was the
117
Pape, R. H. (2017). Touristy: A type of occupational mobility. In Organizational Careers (pp. 388-397).
Routledge.p17
118
Turner, R. J., &Lagerfeld, M. O. (1967). Occupational mobility and schizophrenia: an assessment of the social
causation and social selection hypotheses. American Sociological Review, 104-113.
84
scene of a famous 1965 tank battle was saved this time because of a neat infantry move by the
Indian Army. It was reported that the Pakistani battalion took the Indian army by surprise, at
night but our valiant soldiers, routed the well-entrenched regulars, rangers and mujahids
before sun-rise. With the enemy running, it only required the Indian troops to march and
occupy Pakistani posts interspersed among six small villages. The remaining couple of square
miles are now being cleared so that the neck of the bulge is completely sealed for enemy
movement119.
It may be recalled that Pakistani army spanned out from this bulge in the last war to attack
Khem Karan and making its defense untenable after the tank battle in which Havildar Abdul
Hamid covered himself with glory. Hamid‘s sacrifice would not be in vain if the Indian armor
now emulates the example of the infantry here in giving a good account of it in case the
Pakistani tanks attempt another break-through. Instances of individual velour in the night-long
battle that secured the Sehjra village were many. It was stated that Naib Subedar Ganesh
Bahadur Gurung attacked with two of his soldier's medium machine-gun position which was
hindering the advance of his platoon by keeping up steady firing on its flanks. His grenades
silenced the gun but he himself died of the burst in his stomach when he was just 20 yards
from the gun position120.
The company commander led the first attack on enemy positions and guided his boys from
post to post personally. Another major, after capturing his assigned objective, attacked on his
own initiative a second objective when found the enemy thinning out there and captured it.
Naib Subedar Gurung and six other ranks were the only dead on our side. The enemy left 30
bodies behind and 62 were captured.
Due to the war of 1965 most of the areas of Punjab confronted several matters though the
Forces lost Khem Karan, it secured all territories between the international border and the
Pakistani complication system, as tasked. It also created the largest churchyard of Patton
tanks witnessed in the modern history of warfare121.
When the clouds of war hover over a country, there are terrible changes in the social situation
there, the economy and social system remain disrupted for some time; similar was the
situation in Khem Karan where the people were scared of the war. During Common people
don't know where what is happening; even their food, drink and living arrangements were
119
Sisson, R., & Rose, L. E. (1990). War and secession: Pakistan, India, and the creation of Bangladesh. Univ of
California Press.
120
Dixit, J. N. (2003). India-Pakistan in war and peace. Routledge.
121
Chaudhuri, R. (2018). Indian “Strategic Restraint” Revisited: The Case of the 1965 India-Pakistan
War. India Review, 17(1), 55-75.
85
getting messed up. After the war people were only concerned about the changes in their social
status. Due to the war, there was an impact on agriculture and children's school. Nearby
markets and traffic were also disrupted for months due to which the people of Khem
Karan had to go through a lot of trouble.
If we see change in any society, then we feel PTA about the social and professional changes
there too. Similarly, we see changes in Khem Karan also. The Indo-Pak war of 1965had put a
hold on the social and professional status of Khem Karan to a great extent. But after the war
gradually changes were visible in the social and occupational dynamics. The people of Khem
Karan also kept themselves at the global level and made changes accordingly. Started looking
for modern means of farming and other means of business like going out for business and
work etc. And in this sequence, fish farming also started. Women also started taking part in
this. In this way, Khem Karan kept increasing its commercial mobility in every way, decade
after decade.
86
CHAPTER IV
Consequences of Occupational Mobility in Khem Karan
Section-1
Demographic Traits of the Sampled Respondents
The discussion has been made fewer than two sub-heads: Under the first sub-head, we shall
present the frequency distributions of different categories of each of the items pertaining to
the demographic traits of the sampled respondents, whereas under the second sub-head, we
have examined associations among the different traits.
1.1.Frequency Distributions of Different Categories of the Demographic Variables
In order to have a better visualization of the findings, we have presented 3-D Pie Charts along
with the frequency distributions for each of the demographic variables, as follows:
Table 1.1.1. Frequency Distribution of the Gender of the Respondents
Response
Quantity
Total
Male
Female
308
82
390
Frequency
78.97
21.03
100.00
%age
Female, 21.03
Male, 78.97
Figure 3 Frequency Distribution
As per Table 1.1.1 (and the corresponding Pie Chart), a large majority (nearly 79%) of the
respondents were males while only about 21% were females.
87
Table 1.1.2. Frequency Distribution of the Age Categories of the Respondents
Response#
Quantity
Total
A
B
C
D
E
4
80
237
69
390
Frequency 0
0.00
1.03
20.51
60.77
17.69
100.00
%age
#
A: 20 Yrs; B: 21-30 Yrs; C: 31-40 Yrs; D: 41-60 Yrs; E: 61 Yrs.
A
0%
B
1%
E
18%
C
20%
D
61%
Figure 4Frequency Distribution of the Age Categories of the Respondents
As is evident from Table 1.1.2, a large majority of the respondents (nearly 61 percent)
belonged to the age group 41 to 60 years, followed next (20.5 per cent) by the age group 31 to
40 years, and then (17.7 per cent) by the age group of more than 60 years. Only about 1 per
cent of the respondents happened to belong to the younger age group of 21-30 years, while
none of the respondent was less than 21 years of age. Evidently, the frequency distribution of
the respondents was in favor of relatively larger age group.
Table 1.1.3. Frequency Distribution of the Cast Categories of the Respondents
Response#
Quantity
Total
A
B
C
D
E
54
99
99
87
390
Frequency 51
13.08
13.85
25.38
25.38
22.31
100.00
%age
#
A: Brahmin; B: Jatt Sikh; C: Khatri; D: Mazhabi Sikhs; E: Others.
88
A
B
C
D
E
13%
22%
14%
25%
26%
Figure 5Frequency Distribution of the Cast Categories of the Responde
As per Table 1.1..3, ‗Khatri‘, ‗Mazhabi Sikhs‘ and ‗Others‘ had a relative share of nearly 25
per cent each, while ‗Brahmins‘ and ‗Jatt Sikhs‘ had a share of nearly 13 per cent each.
Table 1.1.4. Frequency Distribution of the Religion Categories of the Respondents
Response#
Quantity
Total
A
B
C
D
148
230
9
3
390
Frequency
37.95
58.97
2.31
0.77
100.00
%age
#
A: Hindu; B: Sikh; C: Christian; D: Others.
C
2%
D
1%
A
38%
B
59%
Figure 6Frequency Distribution of the Religion Categories of the Respondents
As per the information provided by the sample data, the area was dominated by ‗Sikhs‘
89
(Nearly 59 per cent), followed next by ‗Hindus‘ (Nearly 38 per cent), whereas ‗Christians‘
and ‗Others‘ taken together had a relative share of just 3 per cent.
Table 1.1.5. Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Marital Status of the Respondents
Response#
Quantity
Total
A
B
C
D
11
327
49
3
390
Frequency
2.82
83.85
12.56
0.77
100.00
%age
#
A: Unmarried; B: Married; C: Widow/ Widower; D: Divorced.
D
1%
A
3%
C
12%
B
84%
Figure 7Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Marital Status of the Respondents
A large majority (nearly 84 per cent) of the respondents were married, whereas less than 3 per
cent of the respondents were unmarried. Some 12.6 per cent of the respondents were widows/
widowers, whereas less than 1 per cent of the respondents were divorced. The findings are
thus indicative of the fact that the incidence of marital separation in the study zone is virtually
negligible.
Table 1.1.6. Frequency Distribution of Educational Qualification of the Respondents
Quantity
Frequency
%age
Response
Literate
269
68.97
Illiterate
121
31.03
90
Total
390
100.00
Illiterate
31%
Literate
69%
Figure 8Distribution of Educational Qualification of the Respondents
As revealed by the above table and pie chart, a hefty proportion (nearly 69 per cent) of the
respondents was literates, while only 31 per cent of the respondents were illiterates.
Table 1.1.7. Frequency Distribution of the Literacy Level of the Respondents
Response#
Quantity
Total
A
B
C
D
39
12
176
42
269
Frequency
14.50
4.46
65.43
15.61
100.00
%age
#
A: Primary/ Middle; B: High School; C: Higher Secondary; D: Graduate & Above.
A
16%
D
16%
B
4%
C
65%
Figure 9Frequency Distribution of the Literacy Level of the Respondents
91
Among the literates, nearly two-third (65.4 per cent) of the respondents had passed higher
secondary examination, followed next by graduates & above (15.6 per cent) and then by
primary/ middle standard (14.5 per cent). The proportion of high-school passed respondents
was just about 4.5 per cent.
Table 1.1.8. Frequency Distribution of the Occupational Categories of the Respondents
Response#
Quantity
Total
A
B
C
D
E
160
47
101
16
390
Frequency 66
16.92
41.03
12.05
25.90
4.10
100.00
%age
#
A: Agricultural Labour; B: Non-Agricultural Labour; C: Employed; D: Business; E: ExServiceman.
E
4%
A
17%
D
26%
C
12%
B
41%
Figure 10Frequency Distribution of the Occupational Categories of the Respondents
As regards occupational affiliation, a large majority (nearly 58 per cent) was reported to be
laborers; 41per cent of the respondents were associated with non-agriculture labor while about
17 per cent were associated with agriculture labor. Nearly 26 per cent of the respondents were
associated with business activities, 12 per cent were employed and merely 4 per cent were exservicemen.
92
Table 1.1.9. Frequency Distribution of the Categoriesof Annual Income (in ₹) of the
Head of the Family
Response#
Quantity
Total
A
B
C
D
E
5
9
153
223
390
Frequency 0
0.00
1.28
2.31
39.23
57.18
100.00
%age
#
A: < ₹ 30K; B: ₹ 30K-40K; C: ₹ 40K-50K; D: ₹ 50K-100K; E: ₹ 100K.
A B
0% 1%
C
3%
D
39%
E
57%
Figure 11Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Annual Income (in ₹) of the Head of the Family
Regarding income of the head of the family, a large chunk (nearly 57 per cent) of the
respondents fell in the category of more than ₹ 1 lakh per annum, followed next (nearly 39 per
cent) by the category of ₹ 50 thousand to ₹ 1 lakh per annum. Proportion of the respondents in
rest of the categories were either nil or just negligible.
93
Table 1.1.10. Frequency Distribution of the Status of Income Tax Paying by the Respondents
Status
Quantity
Total
Pay IT
Do Not Pay IT
140
250
390
Frequency
35.90
64.10
100.00
%age
Pay IT
36%
Do Not Pay IT
64%
Figure 12Frequency Distribution of the Status of Income Tax Paying by the Respondents
Only about 36 per cent of the respondents were reported to be income-tax payers, while the
rest (nearly 64 per cent) did not do so.
94
Table 1.1.11. Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Source of Income of the Respondents
Response#
Quantity
Total
G
A
B
C
D
E
F
65
7
153
103
45
2
390
Frequency 15
3.85
16.67
1.79
39.23
26.41
11.54
0.51
100.00
%age
#
A: Ex-Serviceman; B: Agriculture; C: Agricultural Labour Wage; D:OtherLabour Wage;
E: Business; F: Government/ Private Job; G: Others (Like Preacher, Priest, etc.)
G
0%
A
4%
F
12%
B
17%
C
2%
E
26%
D
39%
Figure 13Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Source of Income of the Respondents
For a large majority (more than 39 per cent) of the respondents, the source of income was
other labour wage, followed next (26.4 per cent) by business activities and then (16.7 per
cent) by agriculture. Nearly 11.5 per cent of the respondents earned through government/
private jobs. At the other extreme, just 0.5 per cent of the respondents earned through
preaching at religious places.
Table 1.1.12. Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Nature of Families of the
Respondents
Nature of the Family
Quantity
Total
Joint
Nuclear
Extended
174
216
0
390
Frequency
44.62
55.38
0.00
100.00
%age
95
Extended
0%
Joint
45%
Nuclear
55%
Figure 14Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Nature of Families of the Respondents
As regards nature of the families, more than 55 per cent of the families were nuclear, while
the remaining about 45 per cent was joint families. None of the respondents had an extended
family.
Table 1.1.13. Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Family Size of the Respondents
Response#
Quantity
Total
A
B
C
D
32
188
61
109
269
Frequency
8.21
48.21
15.64
27.95
100.00
%age
#
A: 3; B: 4-5; C: 6-7; D: 8.
A
8%
D
28%
B
48%
C
16%
Figure 15Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Family Size of the Respondents
Forty eight percent of the respondents had a family size ranging between four to five family
96
members. Nearly 28 per cent of the respondents had a large family size (of at least 8
members). Only about 8 per cent of the respondents had a small family (of up to 3 members).
Table 1.1.14. Frequency Distribution of the Categories
Respondents
Response#
Quantity
A
B
C
28
360
1
Frequency
7.18
92.31
0.26
%age
#
A: Kacha; B: Pacca; C: Mixed; D: Other.
C
0%
of Nature of House of the
D
1
0.26
Total
269
100.00
D
0%
A
7%
B
93%
Figure 16Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Nature of House of the Respondents
An exceedingly large number (more than 92 per cent) of the respondents were in the
possession of Pacca houses (which, of course, is a healthy sign), while nearly 7 per cent had
Kacha house. Proportions in the rest of the categories (viz., mixed and other) were just
negligible (0.26 per cent each).
Table 1.1.15. Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Status of House of the Respondents
Status of House
Quantity
Total
Own
Rented
Other
388
1
1
390
Frequency
99.49
0.26
0.26
100.00
%age
97
Other
0%
Rented
0%
Own
100%
Figure 17Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Status of House of the Respondents
Virtually, the entirety of the respondents (388 out of 390; 99.5 per cent) had their own houses.
The number of respondents living in ‗rented‘ and ‗other‘ types of accommodation were just
one each (0.26 per cent).
Table 1.1.16. Frequency Distribution of the Sanitary Facility to the Respondents
Availability of Sanitary Facility
Quantity
Total
Yes
No
373
17
390
Frequency
95.64
4.36
100.00
%age
No
4%
Yes
96%
Figure 18Frequency Distribution of the Sanitary Facility to the Respondents
98
As is obvious from Table 1.1.16, as many as 95.6 per cent of the houses in the study region
were reported to be availing the sanitation facility, which again is a very conducive sign from
the angle of availability of basic amenities. But, nearly 4.4 per cent of the houses remained
deprived of the facility.
Table 1.1.17. Frequency Distribution of the Status of Electrification of Houses of the Respondents
Status of Electrification of House
Quantity
Total
Yes
No
384
6
390
Frequency
98.46
1.54
100.00
%age
No
2%
Yes
98%
Figure 19Frequency Distribution of the Status of Electrification of Houses of the Respondents
As regards electrification, as high as 98.5 per cent of the houses were equipped with
electricity supply, whereas only about 1.5 per cent of the houses remained deprived of the
facility.
Table 1.1.18. Frequency Distribution of the Status of Ownership of Rural Agricultural/ Urban
Land by the Respondents
Quantity
Frequency
%age
Status of Ownership of Land
Yes
No
102
288
26.15
73.85
99
Total
390
100.00
Yes
26%
No
74%
Figure 20Frequency Distribution of the Status of Ownership of Rural Agricultural/ Urban Land by the Respondents
As is evident from Table 1.1.18 and the corresponding pie chart, only about one-fourth (26.1
per cent) of the respondents were found to be in the possession of rural agricultural/ urban
land, whereas a hefty three-fourth (73.9 per cent) of the respondents were land-less. The
figures thus speak of the poor economic status of the people in the study region.
1.2.Studying Association between Different Combinations of the Demographic Variables
For the purpose of studying, association, if any, between each of the combinations among the
demographical variables, we have generated two-way contingency tables, and have made use
of the Chi-square analysis of independence of attributes. Evidently, with 18 variables
included in this Section, the analysis had to be performed as many as (18 17)/2 = 153 times.
In this analysis, we actually tried to test the null hypothesis (H0) that there exists no
significant association between a given pair of the attributes against the alternative hypothesis
(H1) that there exists a significant association between the two attributes.
As an illustration, let us consider association between Gender and Age Categories of the
respondents. The resulting contingency table was as given below:
100
Table 1.2.1. Contingency Table for Gender (GNDR) and Age Categories (AGCT)
AGCT
GNDR
Row Total
B
C
D
E
3
57
190
58
308
M
1
23
47
11
82
F
Column
4
80
237
69
390
Total
2 at 3 D.F. = 4.190NS; p-value = 0.2416
190
200
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
57
47
58
23
3
11
1
A
B
C
Male (M)
D
Female (F)
Figure 21Contingency Table for Gender (GNDR) and Age Categories (AGCT)
As per the above table, the number of male respondents falling into B (21-30 Yrs), C (31-40
Yrs), D (41-60 Yrs) and E ( 61 Yrs) categories of age were 3, 57, 190 and 58.Whereas, the
number of female respondents falling into these age categories were 1, 23, 47 and 11,
respectively. As has already been reported (Table 1.1.2), none of the respondents belonged to
age category A ( 20 Yrs).
As per the application of Chi-square test to the above contingency table, value of the test
statistic (2) at 3 degrees of freedom was computed to be 4.190. Its p-value was 0.2416, which
was larger than the critical limit of 0.05. Accordingly, for this pair of attributes (viz., GNDR
and AGCT), the null hypothesis could not be rejected. This amounts to saying that Gender of
the respondents and their age categories did not bear any association. In other words, relative
frequencies of the different age categories among males were comparable to those among
females. For a better visualization, the relative frequencies in the above contingency table
have been displayed in Figure 1.2.1 below.
101
Table 1.2.2. Contingency Table for the Categories of Gender (GNDR) and Cast (CAST)
CAST
GNDR
Row Total
A
B
C
D
E
39
47
79
71
72
308
M
12
7
20
28
15
82
F
Column
51
54
99
99
87
390
Total
2 at 4d.f. = 6.237NS; p-value = 0.1821
Male - M
Female - F
79
72
71
47
39
28
20
12
A
15
7
B
C
D
E
Figure 22Contingency Table for the Categories of Gender (GNDR) and Cast (CAST)
Conclusion:
No association could be detected between Gender and Cast (2 = 6.237; p-value = 0.1821).
This implies that the frequency distribution of the respondents of different casts among males
was comparable to that among females.
Table 1.2.3. Contingency Table for the Categories of Gender (GNDR) and Religion (RLGN)
RLGN
GNDR
Row Total
A
B
C
D
116
182
7
3
308
M
32
48
2
0
82
F
Column
148
230
9
3
390
Total
2 at 3 D.F. = 0.841NS; p-value = 0.8395
102
Male -M
Female - F
182
116
48
32
7
A
B
3
2
C
0
D
Figure 23Contingency Table for the Categories of Gender (GNDR) and Religion (RLGN)
Conclusion:
No association could be detected between Gender and Religion (2 = 0.841; p-value =
0.8395). This implies that the frequency distribution of the respondents of different religious
groups among males and females were similar
Table 1.2.4. Contingency Table for the Categories of Gender (GNDR) and Marital Status (MRTS)
MRTS
GNDR
Row Total
A
B
C
D
8
273
25
2
308
M
3
54
24
1
82
F
Column
11
327
49
3
390
Total
2 at 3 d.f. = 27.600***; p-value < 0.0001
Male-M
Female-F
273
54
8
A
25 24
3
B
C
2
1
D
Figure 24Contingency Table for the Categories of Gender (GNDR) and Marital Status (MRTS)
103
Conclusion:
A very strong association (at 0.1 per cent probability level) was observed to be present
between Gender and Marital Status (2 = 27.600; p-value < 0.0001). This implies that the
frequency distribution of the Marital Status of the male respondents was grossly different
from the female respondents.
On similar lines, we have generated contingency tables for various other paired combinations
among the variables of Section-1. Since the total number of such paired combinations was
very large (= 153, as already indicated); therefore, in order to save space we have put the
computed values of the Chi-square test statistic along with their p-values in a consolidated
way in the form of a matrix (Table 3).
As could be seen from Table 3, the computed value of 2-statistic from the contingency table
for Gender (GNDR) and Educational Qualification (EDQL) was 16.364, and was associated
with a very low (=0.0001) value of p. Thus, gender and educational qualifications were highly
significantly (at 0.1 per cent probability level) associated with each other. That is, males and
females were not similarly educated.
Conclusions about the nature of association between rests of the pairs of the variables could
be made on similar lines with the help of the computations presented in Table 3.
104
Table 3. Comprehensive Table of Chi-square Analysis for Studying Association among Different Variables of Section-1
Variable
Varia
STAT AGC CAS RLG MRS EDQ LTL OCP INC ITP
SRC NTR FSZ NTR STT SNF
ble
T
T
N
T
L
V
N
M
Y
I
F
E
H
H
C
27.60 16.36 21.38 32.21 28.71 13.03 27.28
14.58
Chi4.190 6.237 0.841
6.355
2.738 4.028 3.170
0
4
1
7
5
3
2
4
Sq
<
<
<
0.241 0.182 0.839
0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.011 0.002 0.433 0.133 0.075
GND p0.000
0.000 0.000
1
5
1
1
3
1
7
2
8
5
0
R
Value 6
1
1
1
Rema
NS
NS
NS
***
***
***
***
***
***
***
*
**
NS
NS
NS
rk
32.04 20.06 177.3 23.41 56.14 61.43 23.54
51.90 14.61 29.75
Chi--3.995
9.012 4.527 3.541
2
0
59
2
1
3
1
4
9
7
Sq
<
<
<
<
<
0.001 0.017
0.005 0.262
0.002 0.000 0.436 0.605 0.315
AGC p--0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000
4
5
1
0
2
5
2
7
5
T
Value
1
1
1
1
1
Rema
--**
*
***
***
***
***
**
NS
***
**
***
NS
NS
NS
rk
386.7 23.83 106.6 48.24 346.8 170.0 90.77 353.5 14.15 17.32 47.42
32.19
Chi----6.434
91
9
19
7
92
69
6
75
2
7
2
6
Sq
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
0.021
0.006 0.137
0.598
CAS
p----0.000
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000
0.000
4
8
7
8
T
Value
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Rema
----***
*
***
***
***
***
***
***
**
NS
***
NS
***
rk
13.44 70.41
112.5 55.88 48.75 141.3
14.29 28.34
13.84
Chi------NC
2.335
2.332
1
9
23
3
3
09
0
4
8
Sq
<
<
<
<
<
0.143
0.505 0.112 0.000 0.886 0.003
RLG p------0.000 NC
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
7
9
4
8
8
1
N
Value
1
1
1
1
1
Rema
------NS
***
NC
***
***
***
***
NS
NS
***
NS
**
rk
105
ELC
C
LAN
D
0.000 1.956
1.000 0.161
0
9
NS
NS
2.148 8.814
0.542 0.031
2
9
NS
*
11.33 173.1
6
34
<
0.023
0.000
0
1
*
***
23.08
4.643
7
<
0.199
0.000
9
1
***
NS
MRS
T
ChiSq
---
---
---
---
pValue
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
Rema
rk
ChiSq
EDQ
L
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
LTL
V
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
OCP
N
INC
M
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
pValue
33.31
7
<
0.000
1
19.39 44.16 15.85
2
5
1
<
0.022
0.070
0.000
1
1
1
11.62 50.85
17.25 11.92
4.079
0.387 2.801 0.301 5.69
0
0
8
6
---
***
*
---
---
---
NC
---
---
---
---
NC
---
---
---
---
---
NC
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
-----
0.008 0.000 0.253 0.044 0.217
0.423 0.959 0.127
0.999
8
1
1
8
5
3
9
7
***
NS
**
***
131.1
42
<
0.000
1
91.89
5
<
0.000
1
78.93
8
<
0.000
1
139.9
32.56
0.975 2.698
2.675
36
9
<
<
0.323 0.440
0.262
0.000
0.000
4
6
5
1
1
24.46
2.123 9.153
2
<
0.145 0.002
0.000
1
5
1
***
***
***
***
***
124.7
00
<
0.000
1
55.19
6
<
0.000
1
35.90
0
<
0.000
1
153.1
10.05
7.949
86
2
<
0.047 0.346
0.000
1
3
1
22.27
NC
6
1.065 2.229 7.475
0.008
NC
0
0.785 0.526 0.058
6
2
2
---
***
***
***
***
*
**
NS
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
236.1
37
<
0.000
1
155.3
02
<
0.000
1
1306.
949
<
0.000
1
21.89 26.03 41.21
21.11
195.3
8.753
8.760
0
0
2
4
70
<
<
0.000 0.010
0.363 0.000 0.067
0.000
0.000
2
6
6
3
4
1
1
---
---
---
---
---
***
***
***
***
*
***
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
156.1
97
<
0.000
308.8
89
<
0.000
11.96
9
0.007
5
32.57
0
0.000
2
54.15
37.50
57.47
2.299
9.439
1
4
0
<
0.890 <
<
0.024
0.000 3
0.000
0.000
106
NS
NS
*
NS
NS
NS
***
NS
NS
NC
NS
NS
***
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
**
NS
***
Rema
rk
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
107
1
1
***
***
1
**
***
***
1
NS
***
1
*
***
Table 3.Contd…
Variable
Varia
STAT AGC CAS
ble
T
T
Chi----Sq
ITPY
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
SRCI
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
NTR
F
FSZE
NTR
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
pValue
Rema
rk
Chi-
RLG
N
MRS EDQ
T
L
LTL
V
OCP
N
INC
M
ITP
Y
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
SRC
I
176.5
60
<
0.000
1
NTR
F
FSZ
E
NTR STT SNF ELC
H
H
C
C
15.98
3.684 7.427
1.126 8.390 2.012
9
LAN
D
12.78
2
NS
NS
30.30
0
<
0.000
1
37.19 36.93
27.53
208.7
9.234
9.439
5
2
4
28
<
0.004 0.005 0.682 0.000 0.150
0.000
9
3
8
1
3
1
**
0.054 0.059 0.001 0.569 0.003 0.156 0.000
9
5
1
6
8
1
3
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
***
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
***
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
***
NS
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
4.769 6.479 1.967 5.985 6.497
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
0.854 0.371 0.579 0.112 0.089
0
7
4
3
8
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
NS
NS
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
13.04 128.0 0.848 11.06
108
**
**
NS
NS
**
***
NS
NS
***
***
162.2
1.668 2.496 0.293 3.246 1.929
69
<
0.644 0.287 0.588 0.071 0.164
0.000
1
1
4
6
8
1
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
H
Sq
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
STT
H
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
SNF
C
pValue
0
68
3
<
0.042
0.837 0.011
0.000
4
9
4
1
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
*
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
***
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
***
*
---
---
---
---
---
---
1.002
---
---
---
---
---
---
0.316
8
---
---
---
---
---
---
NS
Rema
--------------------rk
Chi--------------------Sq
ELC p--------------------C
Value
Rema
--------------------rk
***: Significant at 0.1 % probability level; **: Significant at 1 % probability level;
significant; NC: Non-computable due to certain inconsistencies in the contingency table.
109
***
NS
*
22.03
0.031 0.712
8
<
0.984 0.700
0.000
4
5
1
NS
NS
20.34
4.959
5
<
0.000 0.026
1
*: Significant at 5 % probability level; NS: Non-
Section-2
Occupational Mobility of the Sampled Respondents
Here again, the discussion has been made under two sub-heads: First, we shall present the
frequency distributions of different categories of each of the items pertaining to the
occupational mobility of the sampled respondents. And, then, we shall study associations, if
any, among the different traits.
2.1.Frequency Distributions of Different Responses of Occupational Mobility
In order to have a clearer picture emerging from the analytical findings, we have presented 3D Pie Charts along with the frequency distributions for each of the variables pertaining to the
occupational mobility, as follows:
Table 2.1.1. Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Present Occupation of the
Respondents
Response#
Quantity
Total
AGRI
LABR
BSNS
EMPL
EXSM
HSWF
Frequenc
64
153
109
46
16
2
390
y
16.41
39.23
27.95
11.79
4.10
0.51
100
%age
#
AGRI: Agriculture; LABR: Labour; BSNS: Business; EMPL: Government/ Semi-Govt/
Private Employee; EXSM: Ex-Serviceman; HSWF: House-wife
EXSM
4%
HSWF
1%
AGRI
16%
EMPL
12%
BSNS
28%
LABR
39%
Figure 25Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Present Occupation of the Respondents
As per Table 2.1.1 (and the corresponding Pie Chart), a large majority (39.2%) of the
respondents were presently associated with doing labor (39.2%), followed next by business
(27.9%), agriculture/farming (16.4%), employees (11.8%) and ex-servicemen (4.1%). Only
110
2 of the (female) respondents (out of the totality of 390) reported to be house-wives. The
figures thus indicate that the study zone was constituted largely by less-privileged society of
labor class and petty shop-keepers.
Table 2.1.2. Frequency Distribution of Traditional Occupation of the Respondents
Response
Quantity
Total
Traditional
Non-Traditional
253
137
390
Frequency
64.87
35.13
100.00
%age
Non-Traditional
35%
Traditional
65%
Figure 26Frequency Distribution of Traditional Occupation of the Respondents
Nearly two-third (64.9%) of the respondents reported their profession to be traditional,
whereas nearly one-third (35.1%) of the respondents indicated the profession to be nontraditional. Thus, nearly 35 per cent of the respondents had changed their family profession
due to one reason or the other.
Table 2.1.3. Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Traditional Occupation of the
Respondents
Response#
Quantity
Total
AGRI
LABR
BSNS
EMPL
RLSR
157
115
1
4
390
Frequency 113
28.97
40.26
29.49
0.26
1.03
100.00
%age
#
AGRI: Agriculture; LABR: Labour; BSNS: Business; EMPL: RLSR: Religious Services.
111
EMPL
0%
RLSR
1%
AGRI
29%
BSNS
30%
LABR
40%
Figure 27Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Traditional Occupation of the Respondents
Thus, as regards traditional occupation of the respondents, nearly 40 per cent of the
respondents were associated with labor, 29 per cent with each of agriculture and business, 1
per cent with religious services, while just 0.3 per cent was employees. Thus, over a period of
time (Table 2.1.1 and Table 2.1.3), major shift has occurred from agriculture (from 29.0 per
cent to 16.4per cent) to employment (from 0.3 per cent to 11.8 per cent). In other words,
there has been a temporal shift in employment from primary activities (i.e., Agriculture/
Farming) to tertiary activities (i.e., Services) which may be viewed as a conductive sign from
economics point of view.
Table 2.1.4. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Span of Time (Years) into
the Present Occupation
Response#
Quantity
Total
A
B
C
D
10
44
70
266
390
Frequency
2.56
11.28
17.95
68.21
100.00
%age
#
A: < 5 Years; B: 5-9 Years; C: 10-19 Years; D: > 20 Years
A
3%
B
11%
C
18%
D
68%
Figure 28Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Span of Time (Years) into the Present Occupation
112
As is evident from Table 2.1.4 and Fig 2.1.4, a large majority (more than 68 per cent) of the
respondents have been in the present profession for more than twenty years whereas, on the
other extreme, just 2.6 per cent of the respondents have been into their present profession for
the last less than five years.
Table 2.1.5. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on as to How the Respondents
Enter into their Present Occupation
Response#
Quantity
Total
A
B
C
D
138
2
250
0
390
Frequency
35.38
0.51
64.11
0.00
100.00
%age
#
A: On own efforts; B: Through the help of political leader/community leader/ activist/
relative; C: Through succession/ spouse/ patrimonial kin; D: Due to reservation in public
employment.
D
0%
A
35%
C
64%
B
1%
Figure 29Frequency Distribution of the Responses on as to How the Respondents Enter into their Present Occupation
Clearly, a large majority (64 per cent) of the respondents were in their present profession by
way of succession/ spouse/ patrimonial kin, followed next (35.4 per cent) by way of their own
efforts. Merely half percent of the respondents were in their present profession through the
help of political leader/community leader/ activist/ relative, whereas none of the respondents
had reported to be so by way of reservation in public employment.
113
Table 2.1.6. Frequency Distribution of Responses as to whether the Respondents
Changed their Occupation
Response
Quantity
Total
Yes
No
139
251
390
Frequency
35.64
64.36
100.00
%age
Yes
36%
No
64%
Figure 30Frequency Distribution of Responses as to whether the Respondents Changed their Occupation
As per the survey findings (Table 2.1.6 and Fig 2.1.6), 35.6 per cent of the respondents had
changed their profession, while a large chunk of only 64.4 per cent continued to remain in
their traditional/ community profession.
Table 2.1.7. Frequency Distribution of the Reasons of Changing Occupation by the
Respondents
Response#
Quantity
Total
FBEO
GJBS
WRTR WRCN BBLA
OTHR
Frequenc
58
39
30
4
3
5
139
y
41.73
28.06
21.58
2.88
2.16
3.60
100.00
%age
#
FBEO: For Better Economic Conditions/ Opportunities; GJBS: Government Job is Better
than Doing Labour/ Agriculture/ Business, and is Safe & Secure; WRTR: Due to Wars &
Terrorism; WRCN: Due to Wars and Conflicts; BBLA: BBLA: Business is Better Than Doing
Labour/ Agriculture; OTHR: Other Reasons
WRCN BBLA
3%
2%
OTHR
4%
WRTR
21%
FBEO
42%
GJBS
28%
Figure 31Frequency Distribution of the Reasons of Changing Occupation by the Respondents
114
According to 41.7 per cent of the respondents, the primary reason for shifting to their new
occupation was ‗For Better Economic Conditions & Opportunities‘, followed next due to
‗Government Job is Better than Doing Labour/ Agriculture/ Business, and is Safe & Secure
(28.1 per cent)‘ and ‗Due to Wars & Terrorism (21.6 per cent)‘. Nearly 2.9 per cent of the
respondents attributed ‗Wars &Conflicts‘ and 2.2 per cent attributed ‗Business is betterthan
Doing Labour/ Agriculture‘. Further, 3.6 per cent of the respondents indicated certain ‗Other
Reasons‘ (such as, ‗Motivation from Relatives‘, ‗Lack of Resources to Run the Business‘,
‗Post-partition, We Lost our Land due to Construction of Drain at the Border‘, ‗Due to
Terrorism, I Could not Study‘, ‗Due to Death of my Husband‘, etc.) for such a shifting.
Table 2.1.8. Frequency Distribution of Responses as to whether the Respondents Had
Any Subsidiary Occupation
Response
Quantity
Total
Yes
No
119
271
390
Frequency
30.51
69.49
100.00
%age
Yes
31%
No
69%
Figure 32Frequency Distribution of Responses as to whether the Respondents Had Any Subsidiary Occupation
Less than one-third (30.5 per cent) of the respondents were reported to have a subsidiary
occupation, whereas the remaining more than two-third (69.5 per cent) did not have any.
115
Table 2.1.9. Frequency Distribution of Responses as to whether the Respondents Had
Any Specific Restriction for Changing Their Occupation
Response
Quantity
Total
Yes
No
1
389
390
Frequency
0.26
99.74
100.00
%age
Yes
0%
No
100%
Figure 33Frequency Distribution of Responses as to whether the Respondents Had Any Specific Restriction for Changing
Their Occupation
Virtually, the entire set (389 out of 390) of the respondents did not have any specific
restriction for shifting their occupation.
Table 2.1.10. Frequency Distribution of Responses as to What are the Restrictions for
Changing Their Occupation
Response#
Quantity
Total
SOCL
NTAP
1
389
390
Frequency
0.26
99.74
100.00
%age
#
SOCL: Social; NTAP: Not Applicable
SOCL
0%
NTAP
100%
Figure 34Frequency Distribution of Responses as to What are the Restrictions for Changing Their Occupation
116
As per the lone respondent having reported the restrictions, the main restriction was ‗Social‘
in nature.
Table 2.1.11. Frequency Distribution of Responses as to whether the respondents/ Their
Families used to Work at Upper Cast/ Elite Families of the Village
Response
Quantity
Total
YES
NO
137
253
390
Frequency
35.13
64.87
100.00
%age
YES
35%
NO
65%
Figure 35Frequency Distribution of Responses as to whether the respondents/ Their Families used to Work at Upper
Cast/ Elite Families of the Village
The percentage of the respondents providing answer to this question in the affirmative was
only about 35. Thus, as per the survey findings, a majority of the respondents (or their
families) desisted from working in the houses of the upper cast/ elite families in the region.
Table 2.1.12. Frequency Distribution of Opinion of the Responses as to Whether Women
Should Work Out of Their Houses
Response
Quantity
Total
YES
NO
334
56
390
Frequency
85.64
14.36
100.00
%age
117
NO
14%
YES
86%
Figure 36Frequency Distribution of Opinion of the Responses as to Whether Women Should Work Out of Their Houses
As is evident from the above Table and Figure, as high as 86 per cent of the respondents
opined in favor of the women working out of their houses. This, of course, is a sign of liberal
view point of the respondents in the study region.
Table 2.1.13. Frequency Distribution of the Responses as to Whether the Respondents
Rear Cattle as Their Occupational Change in the Family
Response
Quantity
Total
YES
NO
103
287
390
Frequency
26.41
73.59
100.00
%age
YES
26%
NO
74%
Figure 37Frequency Distribution of the Responses as to Whether the Respondents Rear Cattle as Their Occupational
Change in the Family
In the study area, slightly more than one-fourth (26.4 per cent) of the respondents were
118
reported to have been rearing cattle as their occupational change.
Table 2.1.14. Frequency Distribution of the Responses as to Whether the Respondents
Migrate for Occupation with Their Family Members
Response
Quantity
Total
YES
NO
123
267
390
Frequency
31.54
68.46
100.00
%age
YES
32%
NO
68%
Figure 38Distribution of the Responses as to Whether the Respondents Migrate for Occupation with Their Family
Members
As per the survey findings, less than one-third (31.5 per cent) of the respondents migrated for
occupation along with their families, whereas more than two-third (68.5 per cent) did not do so.
Table 2.1.15. If Yes, Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Type of Migration
Type of Migration
Quantity
Total
Seasonal
Permanent
Semi-Permanent
Frequency
85
15
23
123
%age
69.11
12.19
18.70
100.00
119
SemiPermanent
19%
Permanent
12%
Seasonal
69%
Figure 39Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Type of Migration
Among those, who underwent migration, a large majority (69.1 per cent) were seasonal
migratory, followed next (18.7 per cent) by semi-permanent migratory and then (12.2 per
cent) by permanent migratory.
Table 2.1.16. Frequency Distribution of the Responses as to Whether the Respondents
Have Registered Themselves in the Employment Exchange
Response
Quantity
Total
YES
NO
39
351
390
Frequency
10.00
90.00
100.00
%age
YES
10%
NO
90%
Figure 40Frequency Distribution of the Responses as to Whether the Respondents Have Registered Themselves in the
Employment Exchange
120
Just 10 percent of the respondents were reported to have registered in the employment
exchange, whereas the remaining 90 per cent did not do so.
Table 2.1.17. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Status of Occupation of the
First Generation (Grand Father)
Status
Quantity
Total
Traditional
Non-Traditional
384
6
390
Frequency
98.46
1.54
100.00
%age
Non-Traditional
2%
Traditional
98%
Figure 41Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Status of Occupation of the First Generation (Grand Father)
As far as the first generation (of grand-parents) is concerned, they were in the traditional
occupation of the community to the tune of as high as 98.5 per cent. Thus, a mere 1.5 per cent
of the grand-parents of the respondents were reported to have engaged them-selves in the nontraditional occupation.
Table 2.1.18. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Status of Occupation of the
Second Generation (Father)
Status
Quantity
Total
Traditional
Non-Traditional
Frequency
354
36
390
%age
90.77
9.23
100.00
121
Non-Traditional
9%
Traditional
91%
Figure 42Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Status of Occupation of the Second Generation (Father)
As regards second generation (consisting of parents of the respondents), the percentage of
being in the traditional occupation of the community was still fairly high (at 90.8 per cent),
leaving about 9.2 per cent of the parents engaged in non-traditional occupation.
Table 2.1.19. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Status of Occupation of the
Third Generation (Respondent)
Status
Quantity
Total
Traditional
Non-Traditional
251
139
390
Frequency
64.36
35.64
100.00
%age
Non-Traditional
36%
Traditional
64%
Figure 43Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Status of Occupation of the Third Generation (Respondent)
122
However, in respect of the third generation (consisting of the respondents themselves), the
percentage of being in the traditional occupation of the community was reported to be
comparatively far less (at 64.4 per cent), leaving about 35.6 per cent of the respondents
engaged in non-traditional occupation. The findings are thus indicative of the phenomenon
that in the study region, the third generation (compared to the second generation) has
witnessed a major transformation in the occupation from traditional to non-tradition.
Studying Association between Different Combinations of the Variables on Occupational
Mobility
It may be clarified, once again, that for studying, association, if any, between each of the
combinations among the variables on occupational mobility, we have generated two-way
contingency tables, and have then resorted to the application of Chi-square analysis of
independence of attributes. Through the analysis, we have tried to test the null hypothesis (H0)
that there exists no significant association between a given pair of the attributes against the
alternative hypothesis (H1) that there exists a significant association between the two
attributes. It may be indicated that with 19 variables considered in the present Section, the
analysis had to be reiterated as many as (19 18)/2 = 171 times.
As an illustration, let us examine the extent of association between the ‗Present Occupation‘
and ‗Whether it is Your Traditional or Non-Traditional Occupation‘, through the construction
of Two-Way Contingency Table, as given below:
Table 2.2.1. Contingency Table for Present Occupation (OCPN) and Whether it is Your
Traditional Occupation (ISTO)
OCPN
Row
ISTO
Total
AGRI
LABR
BSNS
EMPL
EXSM
HSWF
61
128
64
YES
3
25
45
NO
Column
64
153
109
Total
2 at 5 doff. = 169.73***; p-value < 0.0001
0
46
0
16
0
2
253
137
46
16
2
390
As per Table 2.2.1, as high as 95.3% (61 out of the 64) of the respondents in the Agricultural
sector reported it to be their traditional occupation. Among labor class, such a percentage was
83.7 (128 out of 153). However, among Business class, only 58.7% (64 out of 109) of the
respondents had reported it to be their traditional occupation. Notably, the entirety of the 46
respondents among Employees, 16 respondents among Ex-Servicemen and 2 respondents
123
among Housewives reported it to be their non-traditional activity. Valueof the2 test statistic
(at 5 degrees of freedom) was computed to be as high as 169.73. Its p-value was exceedingly
small (< 0.0001), which implied that the 2-statistic was highly significant (at 0.1 per cent
probability level). Accordingly, for this pair of attributes (viz., OCPN and ISTO), the null
hypothesis stood clearly rejected, thus leading us to conclude that traditionally/ nontraditionally was very much linked with the very profession to which the respondents
belonged. For a better visualization, the relative frequencies in the above contingency table
have been displayed in Figure 2.2.1 below.
Yes
No
128
64
61
46
45
25
16
3
AGRI
0
LABR
BSNS
EMPL
0
EXSM
0 2
HSWF
Figure 44Contingency Table for Present Occupation (OCPN) and Whether it is Your Traditional Occupation (ISTO)
Let us now consider association between the present occupation and the traditional occupation
with the help of the Contingency Table 2.2.2, given below
Table 2.2.2. Contingency Table for Present Occupation (OCPN) and Traditional
Occupation (WTTO) of the Sampled Respondents
OCPN
Row
WTTO
Total
AGRI
LABR
BSNS
EMPL
EXSM
HSWF
60
7
27
13
6
0
113
AGRI
2
128
12
10
5
0
157
LABR
1
18
67
23
5
1
115
BSNS
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
EMPL
1
0
2
0
0
1
4
RLSR
Column
64
153
109
46
16
2
390
Total
2 at 20 d.f. = 377.82***; p-value < 0.0001
124
AGRICULTURE
LABOUR
BUSINESS
EMPLOYED
RLSR
128
67
60
27
12
18
2101
AGRI
7
12
00
LABR
23
1310
00
BSNS
EMPL
655
00
00101
EXSM
HSWF
Figure 45Contingency Table for Present Occupation (OCPN) and Traditional Occupation (WTTO) of the Sampled
Respondents
For this pair of attributes, value of the Chi-square statistic (at 20 d.f.) was computed to be
77.82 which, again, were tested to be statistically highly significant (p < 0.0001). It thus
implies that two attributes were very strongly associated. In other words, we may say that that
the extent of shift from traditional to non-traditional occupation was not similar among the
different occupational categories; rather, it was very much influenced by the original (i.e., the
traditional) occupation of the respondents.
On similar lines, contingency tables for various other paired combinations among the
variables of Section-2 were generated and the Chi-square analysis was performed. Since the
total number of such paired combinations was very large (= 171, as already indicated in the
starting paragraph of this Section); therefore, in order to save space we have put the computed
values of the Chi-square test statistic along with their p-values in a consolidated way in the
form of a matrix(Table 2).
As could be seen from Table 2, the computed values of 2-statistic from the contingency
tables for the present occupation (OCPN), on one hand, and a majority of rest of the variables,
on the other, were highly significant (First row of the Table). It means that such pairs of the
qualitative variables were very strongly associated with each other. However, in respect of a
few of the variables, such as ‗Any Specific Restrictions for Change of the Occupation
(SCRS)‘, ‗Which Particular Restrictions (WCRS)‘ and ‗Occupation of the First Generation
(GEN1)‘, the present occupation was found to be unassociated (because the p-values of the
2-statistics for these pairs were > 0.05. Furthermore, it is pertinent to mention that
125
‗Occupation of the Third Generation (GEN3)‘ was very strongly associated (2 = 46.500 with
p-value < 0.001; the last row of Table 2), which is in confirmation to the observation made
earlier that major occupational transformation has occurred from the 2 nd generation (of
parents) to the 3rd generation (of the present respondents). As per the penultimate row of the
table, it is evident that no significant occupational transformation has been witnessed from the
1st generation (of grand-parents) to the 2nd generation (of parents).
Conclusions about the nature of association between rests of the pairs of the variables could
be made on similar lines with the help of the computations presented in Table 2.
126
Varia
ble
OCP
N
ISTO
WTT
O
TMS
P
Table 2. Comprehensive Table of Chi-square Analysis for Studying Association among Different Variables of Section-2
Variable
STAT IST
WT
TMS CTE DDC WH SBO SCR WCS WR
WM RRC MG TPM RGE
O
TO
P
N
H
CH
C
S
R
KU
NW T
RT
G
M
169.7 377.8 85.86 166.1 153.8 183.5 70.80
233.3 73.05 138.3 60.69 105.7 53.25
Chi1.553 1.553
27
21
1
34
26
25
1
95
2
01
4
95
1
Sq
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
0.906 0.906
p0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
9
9
Value
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Rema
***
***
***
***
***
***
***
NS
NS
***
***
***
***
***
***
rk
41.00 19.87 305.3 351.6 79.13
62.66
51.86 12.00
Chi--0.386 0
0
0.432 1.869 8.415
3
4
11
75
8
7
9
7
Sq
<
<
<
<
<
<
0.000
0.534
0.511 0.171 0.003
0.000
p--0.000
0.000 0.000 0.000
1
1
0.000
0.000
2
3
2
6
7
5
Value
1
1
1
1
1
1
Rema
--***
***
***
***
***
NS
NS
NS
***
NS
NS
**
***
***
rk
23.09 39.58 40.05 195.2 83.66
255.2 46.64 120.2 47.94
11.78
Chi----1.488 1.488
NC
9
8
2
27
9
41
8
75
9
9
Sq
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
0.026
0.828 0.828
p----0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 NC
0.019
9
8
8
Value
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Rema
----*
***
***
***
***
NS
NS
***
***
***
***
NC
*
rk
23.93 16.98 40.93
10.46 11.55
10.57
Chi------4.236 0.467 0.467
6.24 2.795
27.13
6
9
9
6
2
8
Sq
<
0.000 0.000 0.262 0.237
0.009 0.100 0.424 0.102
p------0.926 0.926 0.015
0.000
5
7
6
1
1
5
3
3
Value
1
Rema
------***
***
NS
NS
NS
NS
*
**
NS
NS
NS
***
rk
127
GEN
1
GEN
2
37.40
3.915
8
<
0.561
0.000
8
1
GEN
3
170.9
19
<
0.000
1
NS
***
***
38.14
6
<
0.600
0.000
5
1
368.4
85
<
0.000
1
NS
***
0.274
***
16.58 39.21 36.40
1
9
3
<
<
0.002
0.000 0.000
3
1
1
**
***
2.841 1.466
***
19.35
6
0.416 0.690 0.000
8
2
2
NS
NS
***
CTE
N
ChiSq
---
---
---
---
pValue
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
Rema
rk
ChiSq
DDC
H
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
WHC pH
Value
Rema
rk
ChiSq
SBO
C
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
SCRS
pValue
290.2
51
<
0.000
1
30.58
0.416 0.561 0.561 61.94 1.741 5.557 8.316
3
<
0.166
0.755 0.755
0.418 0.062 0.015
0.812
0.000
2
2
2
8
1
6
1
48.58
6
<
0.000
1
21.76
39.89
3.413
2
5
<
<
0.181
0.000
0.000
5
1
1
313.3
2
<
0.000
1
---
***
NS
***
***
***
---
---
---
10.80
0.502 0
3
0
---
---
---
---
0.545 0.478
1
8
4
1
57.80
0.193 2.218 5.534
5
<
0.136 0.018
0.000 0.66
4
7
1
54.84
6
<
0.000
1
13.95
41.65
0.096
5
2
<
0.000 0.756
0.000
2
1
1
351.7
51
<
0.000
1
---
---
---
---
---
NS
NS
NS
NS
***
***
***
***
---
---
---
---
---
---
12.15
NC
2
NC
16.67
10.66 14.70
15.29
NC
4
3
8
---
---
---
---
---
---
0.433
NC
6
NC
0.162
0.257
0.226 0.558
NC
3
8
---
---
---
---
---
---
NS
NC
NS
NS
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
0.18
0.18
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
NS
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
NS
NS
NS
***
NS
NS
NS
NS
*
*
***
16.33 16.81 10.73 56.94
9
5
8
5
<
0.176 0.156 0.551
0.000
2
7
5
1
NS
19.77
3
<
0.671 0.671
0.000
7
7
1
17.69
2
<
0.000
1
76.53
0.514 1.601 0.344 0.087 0.318 0.502
8
<
0.473
0.557 0.767 0.572 0.478
0.449
0.000
2
5
6
7
4
1
---
NS
***
***
NS
---
---
---
0
---
---
---
1
96.99
0.097 0
9
<
0.755
1
0.000 1
128
NC
NS
***
NS
***
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
***
NS
NS
NS
0.158 0.451 0
0
0
0
0.690 0.798
1
8
2
1
1
1
1
Rema
rk
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
***
129
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
Table 2. Contd…
Variable
Varia
STAT IST
WT
ble
O
TO
Chi----Sq
WCS p----R
Value
Rema
----rk
Chi----Sq
WRK
U
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
WM
NW
pValue
RRC
T
Rema
rk
ChiSq
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
MGR
T
TMS
P
CTE
N
DDC
H
WH
CH
SBO
C
SCR
S
WCS WR
R
KU
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
WM
NW
RRC
T
MG
RT
0.097 0
0
---
0.755
1
1
---
---
NS
---
---
---
---
TPM
G
GEN
1
GEN
2
GEN
3
0.158 0.451 0
0
0
0
1
0.690 0.798
1
8
2
1
1
1
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
30.21
4
<
0.000
1
20.20
6
<
0.000
1
***
NS
RGE
M
NS
15.68
11.23 61.22
0.274
3
4
2
<
<
<
0.000 0.600 0.000
0.000 0.000
0.000
1
5
8
1
1
1
57.76 70.31
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
***
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
***
*
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
7.373 6.899 3.377 0.73
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
0.006 0.031 0.066
0.111 0.083
0.393
6
8
1
8
8
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
**
*
NS
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
NC
1.034 0.121 0.186 5.534
130
***
***
***
NS
***
***
26.47
6.433 2.767 1.022 0.561 1.773 1.088
9
<
0.011 0.250 0.312 0.453
0.000
0.183 0.297
2
7
1
8
1
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
NS
2.529 2.99
NS
NS
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
TPM
G
RGE
M
GEN
1
GEN
2
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
pValue
Rema
rk
ChiSq
pValue
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
NC
0.309 0.728 0.666 0.018
1
3
1
7
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
NC
NS
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
NS
NS
*
17.47
33.39
0.451
5
4
<
0.000 0.798
0.000
2
2
1
61.49
6
<
0.000
1
---
***
NS
***
---
---
---
0.019 2.86
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
NS
NS
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
0.006 1.981
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
0.939
0.159
3
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
NS
NS
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
46.5
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
<
0.000
1
***
13.95
5
0.890 0.090 0.000
9
8
2
***
Rema
----------------------------------***
rk
***: Significant at 0.1 % probability level; **: Significant at 1 % probability level; *: Significant at 5 % probability level; NS: Nonsignificant; NC: Non-computable due to certain inconsistencies in the contingency table.
131
132
Section-3
Political Aspects in respect of the Sampled Respondents
Once again, we shall first present the frequency distributions of different categories of each
of the items pertaining to the political aspects of the sampled respondents. And, then, we shall
study associations, if any, among the different political attributes.
3.1. Frequency Distributions of Different Responses of Political Aspects
In order to have a clearer picture emerging from the analytical findings, we have presented 3D Pie Charts along with the frequency distributions for each of the variables pertaining to the
political aspects, as follows:
Table 3.1.1. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on Whether the Subjects are
Aware of the Indian Democracy
Response
Quantity
Total
Yes
No
390
0
390
Frequency
100.00
0.00
100.00
%age
Yes
No
0%
100%
Figure 46Frequency Distribution of the Responses on Whether the Subjects are Aware of the Indian Democracy
As per the compiled information (Table 3.1.1 and Fig 3.1.1), all the 390 respondents reported
that they were aware of the Indian Democracy which, of course, is a healthy sign from the
angle of one‘s‘ fundamental rights and duties.
133
Table 3.1.2. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on Whether the Subjects are
Aware of the Political Constitution Rights
Response
Quantity
Total
Yes
No
390
0
390
Frequency
100.00
0.00
100.00
%age
Here again, the picture was the same as in the previous case in the sense that the entirety (i.e.,
100%) of the respondents were aware of their political constitution rights.
Yes
No
0%
100%
Figure 47Distribution of the Responses on Whether the Subjects are Aware of the Political Constitution Rights
Table 3.1.3. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on Whether the Subjects are
Aware of the Party of Their Constituency’s MP and MLA
Response
Quantity
Total
Yes
No
390
0
390
Frequency
100.00
0.00
100.00
%age
Here too, the survey findings (Table 3.1.3 and Fig 3.1.3) indicate that all the 390 (i.e., 100%)
of the respondents were aware of the party to which their constituency‘s MP and MLA
belonged.
Yes
No
0%
100%
Figure 48Frequency Distribution of the Responses on Whether the Subjects are Aware of the Party of Their
Constituency’s MP and MLA
134
Table 3.1.4. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on Whether the Subjects Go In for
Voting
Response
Quantity
Total
Yes
No
390
0
390
Frequency
100.00
0.00
100.00
%age
No, 0
Yes, 100
Figure 49Frequency Distribution of the Responses on Whether the Subjects Go In for Voting
As per the compiled information, all the 390 respondents (i.e., 100%) have been exercising
their franchise in the poling.
Table 3.1.5. Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Membership of any Political
Party by the Respondents
Response
Quantity
Total
Yes
No
151
239
390
Frequency
38.72
61.28
100.00
%age
Yes
39%
No
61%
Figure 50Frequency Distribution of the Categories of Membership of any Political Party by the Respondents
135
As per Table 3.1.5 and Fig.3.1.5, only about 39 percent of the respondents had membership
of some political parties, whereas the remaining about 61 percent of the respondents did not
have any such membership.
Table 3.1.6. Frequency Distribution of the Main Issues on Which the Respondents
Decide to Vote
Response#
Quantity
Total
A
B
C
D
387
0
2
1
390
Frequency
99.23
0.00
0.51
0.26
100.00
%age
#
A: Development; B: Representation; C: Self-Respect; D: Redistribution.
Yes
39%
No
61%
Figure 51Frequency Distribution of the Main Issues on Which the Respondents Decide to Vote
The major issue for voting for more than 99 percent of the respondents was development of
the area, thus leaving less than 1 percent to the other factors (like, Self-respect and
Redistribution).
Table 3.1.7. Frequency Distribution of the Factors that Influence the Respondents in
Voting and Supporting a Political Party
Quantity
Response#
1
2
3
4
5
6
Total
Frequenc
82
237
42
7
10
12
139
y
21.03
60.77
10.77
1.79
2.56
3.08
100.00
%age
#
1: Agenda of the Party; 2: Leader‘s Ability; 3 Leader‘s Cast; 4: National; 5: Regional; 6:
Other Factors.
136
1
2
2% 2%
3
4
5
6
3%
21%
11%
61%
Figure 52Frequency Distribution of the Factors that Influence the Respondents in Voting and Supporting a Political Party
The most important factor that Influenced the respondents in voting & supporting a political
party was ‗Leader‘s Ability (by 60.8% respondents), followed next by ‗Agenda of the Party
(21.0 % of the respondents) and, then, by ‗Leader‘s Cast (10.8% of the respondents). Rest of
the less important factors were: ‗Others‘ (by 3.1% respondents), ‗Regional‘ (by 2.6%
respondents, and ‗National‘ (by 1.8% respondents).
Table 3.1.8. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Span of Time (Years) for
which They Have Been Voting for a Particular Party
Response#
Quantity
Total
A
B
C
D
96
162
91
41
390
Frequency
24.62
41.54
23.33
10.51
100.00
%age
#
A: 5-10 Years; B: 11-15 Years; C: 16-20 Years; D: > 20 Years
D
10%
A
25%
C
23%
B
42%
Figure 53Frequency Distribution of the Responses on the Span of Time (Years) for which They Have Been Voting for a
Particular Party
137
As revealed by the above Table and Figure, a majority of the respondents (41.5%) have been
voting for a particular party for the last 11-15 years, followed next for the last 5-10 years
(24.6%), 16-20 years (23.3%) and, then, for the last more than 20 years (10.5%).
Table 3.1.9. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on Whether the Subjects were
Aware of the President of Nagar Panchayat and Ward Members to Develop the Town
Response
Quantity
Total
Yes
No
390
0
390
Frequency
100.00
0.00
100.00
%age
No
0%
Yes
100%
Figure 54Frequency Distribution of the Responses on Whether the Subjects were Aware of the President of Nagar
Panchayat and Ward Members to Develop the Town
All the 390 respondents (i.e., 100%) expressed that they were aware of the work of president
of Nagar Panchayat and ward members towards development of the town.
Table 3.1.10. Frequency Distribution of the Responses on Whether the Subjects have
been casting their Vote in Nagar Panchayat Elections
Response
Quantity
Total
Yes
No
390
0
390
Frequency
100.00
0.00
100.00
%age
No
0%
Yes
100%
Figure 55Frequency Distribution of the Responses on Whether the Subjects have been casting their Vote in Nagar
Panchayat Elections
138
Once again, all the 390 respondents (i.e., 100%) expressed that they have been voting in the
Nagar Panchayat elections.
3.2.Studying Association between Different Combinations of the Variables on Political
Aspects
For the purpose of studying associations, if any, between different combinations among the
variables on political aspects of the respondents, we have again sought the help of Chi-square
analysis of independence of attributes. But, since the contingency tables could be generated
only in respect of those variables which had at least two categories; therefore, this part of the
analysis could be carried out in respect of four variables only, viz., Membership of a Political
Party (MPPT); Issues on which the Respondents Decide to Vote (ISSV); The Factors which
Influence in Voting & Supporting a Political Party (FCTS); and The Number of Years for
which the Respondents have been Voting for a Particular Party (NOYV). From these four
variables, we could generate six contingency tables. And, through the Chi-square analysis as
applied to these tables, we have tried to test the null hypothesis (H0) that there exists no
significant association between a given pair of the attributes against the alternative hypothesis
(H1) that there exists a significant association between the two attributes. The results have
been discussed in brief, as follows:
Table 3.2.1. Contingency Table for Membership of a Political Party (MPPT) and the
Issues on which the Respondents Decide to Vote (ISSV)
ISSV#
MPPT
Row Total
A
C
D
150
1
0
151
Yes
237
1
1
239
No
2
1
390
Column Total 387
#
A: Development; C: Self-Respect; D: Redistribution.
2 at 2 d.f. = 0.739NS; p-value = 0.6910
Yes
No
237
150
1
A
1
C
0
1
D
Figure 56Contingency Table for Membership of a Political Party (MPPT) and the Issues on which the Respondents Decide
to Vote (ISSV)
139
As per Table 3.2.1, the computed value of the2 test statistic (= 0.739) at 2 degrees of
freedom was tested to be statistically non-significant (p = 0.6910). Accordingly, the two
attributes in the table (viz., MPPT and ISSV) were unassociated. It implies that the
distributions of the three issues for voting were alike, whether or not the respondents were
members of any political party.
Table 3.2.2. Contingency Table for Membership of a Political Party (MPPT) and the
Factors that Influence the Respondents in Voting and Supporting a Political Party
(FCTS)
FCTS#
Row
MPPT
Total
1
2
3
4
5
6
43
77
20
2
4
5
151
Yes
39
160
22
5
6
7
239
No
Column
82
237
42
7
10
12
390
Total
#
1: Agenda of the Party; 2: Leader‘s Ability; 3 Leader‘s Cast; 4: National; 5: Regional; 6: Other
Factors.
2 at 5 d.f. = 12.139*; p-value = 0.0329
Yes
No
160
77
43 39
20 22
2 5
1
2
3
4
4 6
5
5 7
6
Figure 57Contingency Table for Membership of a Political Party (MPPT) and the Factors that Influence the Respondents
in Voting and Supporting a Political Party (FCTS)
Conclusion: The two attributes are significantly (at 5% probability level) associated with
each other, thereby implying that the distribution of the different factors, which influence the
respondents in voting and supporting a political party was influenced by the respondents‘
status (being member/ non-member of the party).
140
Table 3.2.3. Contingency Table for Membership of a Political Party (MPPT) and the
Span of Time (Years) for which they have been Voting for a Particular Party
(NOYV)
NOYV#
MPPT
Row Total
A
B
C
D
60
68
13
10
151
Yes
36
94
78
31
239
No
Column
96
162
91
41
390
Total
#
A: 5-10 Years; B: 11-15 Years; C: 16-20 Years; D: > 20 Years
2
at 3 d.f. = 50.049*; p-value < 0.0001
Yes
No
94
78
68
60
36
31
13
A
B
C
10
D
Figure 58Contingency Table for Membership of a Political Party (MPPT) and the Span of Time (Years) for which they have
been Voting for a Particular Party
Conclusion: The two attributes (MMPT and NOYV) are highly significantly (at 0.1%
probability level) associated with each other, thereby implying that the distribution of the
different spans of time for which the respondents have been voting for a particular political
party was very strongly influenced by their status (being member/ non-member of the party).
Table 3.2.4. Contingency Table for Different Issues (ISSV) and the Factors that
Influence the Respondents in Voting and Supporting a Political Party (FCTS)
FCTS#
Row
$
ISSV
Total
1
2
3
4
5
6
82
236
41
7
9
12
387
A
0
0
1
0
1
0
2
B
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
C
Column
82
237
42
7
10
12
390
Total
$
A: Development; C: Self-Respect; D: Redistribution;
#
1: Agenda of the Party; 2: Leader‘s Ability; 3 Leader‘s Cast; 4: National; 5: Regional; 6: Other
Factors.
2 at 10 d.f. = 22.894*; p-value = 0.0111
141
A
B
C
236
82
41
0 0
0 1
1 0
1
2
3
7 0 0
9 1 0
4
5
12
0 0
6
Figure 59Contingency Table for Different Issues (ISSV) and the Factors that Influence the Respondents in Voting and
Supporting a Political Party (FCTS)
Conclusion: The two attributes ISSV and FCTS are significantly (at 5% probability level)
associated with each other, thus implying that distribution of various factors in voting &
supporting was influenced by the issues on which the respondents decide to vote.
Table 3.2.5. Contingency Table for Different Issues (ISSV) and the Span of Time
(Years) for which they have been Voting for a Particular Party (NOYV)
NOYV#
ISSV$
Row Total
A
B
C
D
A
95
161
90
41
387
C
1
0
1
0
2
D
0
1
0
0
1
Column
Total
96
162
91
41
390
$
A: Development; C: Self-Respect; D: Redistribution;
A: 5-10 Years; B: 11-15 Years; C: 16-20 Years; D: > 20 Years
2 at 6 d.f. = 3.586NS; p-value = 0.7325
#
142
180
160
140
120
100
A
80
B
60
C
40
20
0
A
B
C
D
Figure 60Contingency Table for Different Issues (ISSV) and the Span of Time (Years) for which they have been Voting for
a Particular Party (NOYV)
Conclusion: The two attributes ISSV and NOYV were tested to be unassociated (2 = 3.586;
p = 0.7325), thus implying that the distribution of the time spans since voting for a particular
party was independent of the issues for voting.
Table 3.2.6. Contingency Table for Different Factors that Influence the Respondents in
Voting and Supporting a Political Party (FCTS) and the Span of Time (Years) for
which they have been Voting for a Particular Party (NOYV)
FCTS#
Row
NOYV$
Total
1
2
3
4
5
6
22
49
19
0
2
4
96
A
41
103
10
3
2
3
162
B
15
59
7
2
5
3
91
C
4
26
6
2
1
2
41
D
Column
82
237
42
7
10
12
390
Total
$
A: 5-10 Years; B: 11-15 Years; C: 16-20 Years; D: > 20 Years
#
1: Agenda of the Party; 2: Leader‘s Ability; 3 Leader‘s Cast; 4: National; 5: Regional; 6: Other
Factors.
2 at 15 d.f. = 28.590*; p-value = 0.0181
A
B
C
D
103
41
22 15
4
1
49 59
26
2
1910 7 6
0 3 2 2
2 2 5 1
4 3 3 2
3
4
5
6
Figure 61Contingency Table for Different Factors that Influence the Respondents in Voting and Supporting a Political
Party (FCTS) and the Span of Time (Years) for which they have been Voting for a Particular Party (NOYV)
143
Conclusion: The two attributes FCTS and NOYV are significantly associated with each other
(2 at 15 d.f. = 28.590*; p-value = 0.0181), thus implying that distribution of the time span
since voting was significantly influenced by various factors in voting & supporting a party.
Finally, as done in the previous sections, we shall present the Chi-square computations for the
different pairs of the attributes in a consolidated form (Table 3), as follows:
Table 3. Comprehensive Table of Chi-square Analysis for Studying Association among
Different Variables of Section-3
(Wherein the Analytical Computations were
Possible)
Variable
Variable
STAT
ISSV
FCTS
NOYV
0.739
12.139
50.049
Chi-Sq
0.6910
0.0329
< 0.0001
MPPT
p-Value
NS
*
***
Remark
--22.894
3.586
Chi-Sq
--0.0111
0.7325
ISSV
p-Value
--*
NS
Remark
----28.59
Chi-Sq
----0.0182
FCTS
p-Value
----*
Remark
***: Significant at 0.1 % probability level; *: Significant at 5 % probability level; NS:
Non-significant.
144
CHAPTER V
CONCLUSION
The town of Khem Karan in Punjab, India, stands as a microcosm of the intricate interplay
between social history, occupational mobility, and the enduring impact of war and terrorism.
Khem Karan's historical journey is deeply entwined with the larger narrative of Punjab. It
emerged from the annals of a predominantly agrarian society, where agriculture was not just
a means of sustenance, but a way of life. The fertile lands of Punjab fostered a prosperous
farming community, establishing agriculture as the cornerstone of the region's economy.
However, as the tides of history shifted, so did the social and economic realities of Khem
Karan. From a general perspective, emergence of occupational mobility in Khem Karan can
be attributed to a confluence of factors. Education played a pivotal role in expanding horizons
beyond traditional agrarian pursuits. Increasing access to formal and vocational education
empowered individuals with skills and knowledge to explore diverse professions. Moreover,
technological advancements and the advent of new industries broadened the scope of
occupational choices, facilitating transitions from agrarian occupations to specialized fields.
However, Khem Karan's journey towards occupational diversification was significantly
influenced by the specters of war and terrorism. The Indo-Pakistani conflicts, particularly the
1965 and 1971 wars, and the shadow of insurgency that followed, left an indelible imprint on
the town's socio-economic fabric. Disruptions in agriculture, population displacements, and
economic uncertainties became defining features of Khem Karan's post-war landscape. The
onset of terrorism in the 1980s further complicated the pursuit of occupational stability. The
pervasive atmosphere of insecurity hampered economic growth and led to an exodus of
skilled labor. Local industries faced unprecedented challenges, and the once-thriving trading
hubs were profoundly affected. In the face of adversity, the people of Khem Karan
demonstrated remarkable resilience and adaptability. Communities rallied together, creating
support networks and diversifying their economic activities. New professions emerged,
driven by necessity and a collective determination to rebuild.
Khem Karan's social history and occupational mobility serve as a testament to the
intricate dance between global forces and local ingenuity. The enduring impact of war and
terrorism, while formidable, could not dampen the spirit of a community determined to forge
a path forward. Khem Karan stands not only as a microcosm of Punjab's larger story but also
as a testament to the indomitable human spirit in the face of adversity. It is a beacon of hope
and a testament to the power of communities to shape their own destiny, even in the most
145
challenging circumstances. Present study has been a modest attempt to explore the social
history and occupational mobility in bordering town of Punjab. This research discussed the
history, society, and occupational mobility of Khem Karan. Khem Karan has faced two wars
1965 and 1971. This is historical bordering town of Punjab. It has also faced terrorism 1980
to 1992. Due to wars this town has been destroyed. This affected their Occupation of its
natives. As we are aware that generally, mobility is referred to as the movement from one
region to another and from one sector to another for more earning and better opportunities of
employment (McCollum et al., 2018). There can also be some other reasons due to which
mobility is observed. Mobility especially for improved employment and income opportunities
is a hallmark and quite a natural tendency in a developing nation. The system of market
emergence and regional inequality have respectively pulled and pushed individuals from their
native land in search of better fortunes.
The borderlands between India and Pakistan have witnessed a complex interplay of historical,
political, and agricultural challenges. The region of Khem Karan, like many other border
towns, has a rich agricultural history deeply rooted in traditional farming practices. For
generations, agriculture has been the lifeblood of the community, with the fertile lands of
Punjab providing sustenance and livelihoods. However, the partition of India in 1947 brought
about profound disruptions, leading to the displacement of millions and a radical shift in the
socio-economic fabric.122 The proximity to the border brings forth unique challenges. The
need for stringent security measures can limit access to agricultural lands, leading to
decreased cultivation in border areas. Additionally, land mines and border fencing can restrict
the efficient utilization of arable land, adversely affecting agricultural productivity.
The scars of the partition were deeply engraved upon the whole nation, Punjab being of the
worst hit along with Bengal. The demography of these two states was drastically changed. In
case of Punjab, the percentage of Hindus and Sikhs in Pakistani Punjab dropped from 22%
(1931) to 0.16% (1951), while the percentage of Muslims in Indian Punjab fell from 32%
122
During the war of 1965 in the Majha area of Khem Karan town, Abdul Hamid smashed the Pakistan-based
tank located in the Khem Karan sector. Therefore, Khem Karan is also known to be the ―graveyard of tanks‖.
The region of Khem Karan was destroyed during the 1965 war. People were forced to take shelter in some
different safer regions for securing their lives as well as their families. As the region was recovering from the
1965 war, the people and the condition of the region were made extremely severe with a massive war, which
took place in 1971 (Kumar & Kumar, 2020). Besides, during the terrorism of 1984 to 1992, maximum people
from the Hindu community moved to UP and Haryana to save themselves. The same situation of mobility was
seen in Khem Karan town during the Kargil war of 1999. The raging ―communal '' war in Punjab made it
essential for the minor individuals to flee to a safer region as soon as possible. In this regard, swiftness of
mobility was the prime criterion to ensure the protection and survival of one's family and self. This implies that
occupational mobility particularly in the war-affected area is quite difficult unlike that of the other developing
areas. Moreover, the pace at which a person flees is needed for one's very survival and safety. The ―swift escape
route‖ cannot be reached without the mode to manage for prohibitively developed technology.
146
(1931) to 1.8%. The demographic changes thus brought in the social changes as well. The
vacuum thus created was filled by the inward movement of the other castes that led to drastic
change in the occupation mobility. Such a change was certainly involuntary. Since then, the
line separating India from Pakistan created a zone we generally know as borderland and made
it prone to security concerns, limited access to basic amenities and matrimonial issues. All
these issues made borderlands vulnerable to uncertain conditions whenever there is escalation
at the borders. In that sense, Punjab acts as the main sentry of India, facing always the first
wave of aggression whenever it arrives. Not only the border related issues in Punjab, but in
the further northernmost region of Kashmir, if there is an intrusion or escalation, the
borderlands in Punjab like Khem Karan are directly influenced. With such situations, the
region becomes fragile to sustain the modern means of education, healthcare and other
infrastructure. In such scenario, there is natural quest for better life which leads to
occupational mobility by movement of the people from Khem Karan to much farther regions
from border in Punjab or elsewhere in India or abroad. During 1966-67 which was considered
as the era of the green revolution especially in an agrarian region like Khem Karan, fell a
victim to the brazen war, shunning all the hopes of having neck to neck progress in terms of
the green revolution with other parts of India. The region stayed under occupation of Pakistan
for more than six months, scrapping all the progress it had made hitherto.
In the data analysis part, firstly it focuses on the Demographic traits of the sampled
respondents. The discussion has been made fewer than two sub-heads: Under the first subhead, it presents the frequency distributions of different categories of each of the items
pertaining to the demographic traits of the sampled respondents. Where 390 respondents were
interviewed out of which 308 males and 82 females were taken. From all the community data
was collected. Further political awareness and engagement of the respondents were discussed
and found peoples less awareness on the democracy and, but political participation is
average. Next to it, discussion on educational development is there. On this part it found that
due to war and conflict education of the peoples is not up to the mark. Lesser educational
development is there in the town and peoples are associating more to their traditional work.
Finally, this research discuss on the occupational mobility of the peoples of Khem Karan
town of Punjab. Through this research it found that occupational mobility of people of this
town is static, they are more associated with their traditional occupations. Only few changed
their occupation and shown upward mobility. Thus, the direction of recommendation or
future suggestion particularly depends on the direction of the gained findings. The
interpretation of the data clearly shows that the supra cited factors have played a great role in
147
the occupational mobility of the region which in turn has drastically influenced its social
history. Though the borderland issues has been one of the prime factors for this, other factors
like the internal terrorism that arose in in the 80's of the 20th century CE, played an equally
rather more part in the migration of the people from Khem Karan. As the borderlands were a
sort of safe heaven for the terrorists to amass weapons and escape to Pakistan during the
operations conducted by the security forces, the activities were more concentrated in this
region which perhaps was one of the major causes in lagging of this region in the required
infrastructure for education and health. With a population of 13446 as per census 2011, the
region is having the lower literacy rate (61.55%) as compared to rest of Punjab (75.84%).
What is more worth to note is the even lesser literacy rate in the females, only 54.85% as
compared to their male counterparts with 67.00 %. The reasons that acme to forefront during
the interpretation of the data accumulated via field study was the non-availability of the
education infrastructure and the concentration of the more low caste population 38.09%. The
social traditions which have not been substituted by the modern reason based ideas stand one
of the important factor for the low literacy rate of the women in Khem Karan.
Awareness about the constitutional rights like right to vote is good and most of the
people who are not presently staying in the region vote as per their existing circumstances not
taking into consideration the plight of the people in the region which hampers the public
opinion regarding the various existing issues faced by Khem Karan. As private sector
educational institutes play an important role in enhancing the literacy rate, is also weak in the
region mostly because of least chances of the profit making. Availability of the schools in the
distant towns with a weak economy, the dropout rate has increased over all in Punjab from
1.6% in 2019-20 to 17.2% in 2022-23.123
Recommendations/ Suggestions:
This research is on the social history and occupational mobility in Khem Karan town of
Punjab. Through this research following suggestions and recommendations are given.
1. Occupational mobility of the Khem Karan town of Punjab is static and there need
of more inclusive economic plans from central and state governments to improve
economic status of the peoples of the bordering town.
2. There is a need of strong policy to make the Khem Karan town of Punjab stable
and away from the issues of war and terrorism.
123
Hindustan Times, https://tinyurl.com/mrj85yes Retrieved on 15 October 2023.
148
3. There should be a public and private partnership develops the Khem Karan town of
Punjab.
4. Taking inferences from this research it suggested that Government of India at
national level and Government of Punjab at state level should encourage the social
welfare programs and inclusive policies for overall development of all bordering
town i.e., taking from Redcliff line, Durand, Mc Mohan (LAC & LOC) and
Northeast including costal lines.
5. This research suggests number of policy initiatives in the field occupational
mobility, educational development, and political stability in the Khem Karan town
of Punjab at micro level and in bordering towns of India at macro level.
149
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Primary Work
Questionnaire
National Archives of India, New Delhi
Files and proceedings of the following departments of the Government of India:
Home Judicial, Home Political, Home Public, Home Sanitary, Home Municipal,
Military and Foreign Secret Departments.
Desh Bhagat Yadgar Library, Jalandhar
Manuscripts, Personal Testimonies, Letters, Periodicals, and Archival Material on the Ghadar
Movement.
Punjab State Archives, Chandigarh
Files and proceedings of the following departments: General Administration, Judicial
(Criminal), Sanitation, Municipal, Police, Political, and Revenue.
Punjab Regional Archives, Tarn Taran
Files of the Judicial (Criminal), Municipal, Police and Sanitation departments.
Annual Administration and Expenditure Reports of Tarn Taran Municipality.
Nehru Memorial Museum and Library
Private and Institutional Records:
All India Congress Committee Papers, 1930-31p23
United Provinces Congress Committee Papers, 1930-1931.p12
Narayan Prasad Arora Papers .p04
New Paper
Times of India
The Hindu
Punjab Kesari
Dainik Bhaskar
DainikJagrn
Reports
Defense ministry repots
District defense report
Migration report
Rehabilitation committee report
Report on the Census of India, Punjab, 1911, Part 1.
150
Report on the Census of India 1921, Punjab, Part I, Vol. xv.
Report on the Census of India: Punjab, 1931, part iii.
Report on the Census of India: Punjab, 1931, Vol. xiv.
Report on the Census of India: Punjab, 1931, Vol. xvii.
Report on the Census of India: Punjab, 1941.
Report on the Census of India: Punjab 1951-52
Report on the Census of India: Punjab 1961.p312-315
Report on the Census of India: Punjab 1971.p117-25
Report on the Census of India: Punjab 198.p218-219-303
Report on the Census of India: Punjab 1991.p114-22
Report on the Census of India: Punjab 2001.p115-256
Report on the Census of India: Punjab 2011.317-334-667
A Student of Indo-Pakistani Affairs, 'Tashkent and After', Indi~ S4arterly, XXII: 1
(January-March 1966),3-18.
Abhimanyu Kumar and Pragya Baseria, ―The study of Social mobility among
scheduled castes of Blocks.p16-17
Adas, Michael. "Social History and the Revolution in African and Asian
Historiography," Journal of Social History 19 (1985): 335–378.
Aiyar, S (1994): Violence and the State in the Partition of Punjab, Department of
History, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, p 20.
Amin, Shahid. ‗Agrarian Bases of Nationalist Agitations in India‘, in D.A. Low (ed.)
the Indian National Congress: Centenary Hindsights, Oxford University Press, Delhi,
1988, pp. 99-128. Anand Publishers).
Anand, S (2001): ‗An Unforgettable August‘ in Ahmad Salim (ed), Lahore 1947,
India Research Press, New Delhi, pp 133-48.
Anderson, Michael. Approaches to the History of the Western Family 15001914 (1995) 104pp excerpt and text searchCabrera, Miguel A. Post social History: An
Introduction. (2004). 163 pp.
Atkinson, A.B. (1998), ―Social Exclusion, Poverty and Unemployment‖ in A.B.
Atkinson and J. Hills (eds.) Exclusion, Employment and Opportunity, CASE Paper 4,
Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion, London School of Economics, London.
Barrier, N. Gerald. Roots of Communal Politics, Arnold Heinemann, 1976.
Bayly, C. A. ‗Patrons and Politics in Northern India,‘ Modern Asian Studies, 7 (3),
151
1973, pp349-388.
Bayly, C. A. Local Roots of Indian Politics: Allahabad 1880-1920, Oxford University
Press, 1975.p67
Beall, J. (2002), ―Globalisation and Social Exclusion in Cities: Framing the Debate
with Lessons from Africa and Asia‖, Working Paper No. 02-27, Development Studies
Institute, London School of Economics and Political Science, London.p322
Beall, J. and Clert, C. (2000), ―Globalisation and Social Exclusion: Implications for
Urban Social Policy‖, Paper prepared for ―African Families II: Macroeconomics‖,
World Bank, Washington DC. P54
Becker, G.S. and Tomes, N. (1979), ―An Equilibrium Theory of the Distribution of
Income and Intergenerational Mobility‖, Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 87, No.
6, pp. 1153-89(1986), ―Human Capital and the Rise and Fall of Families‖, Journal of
Labour Economics, Vol. 4, No. 3, pp. S1-S39.
Behrman, J.R. and Taubman, P. (1976), ―Intergenerational Transmission of Income
and Wealth Intergenerational Transmission of Income and Wealth‖, The American
Economic Review, Vol. 66, No. 2, pp. 436-40.(1990), ―A Comparison and Latent
Variable Test of Two Fertile Ideas‖, Journal of Population Economics, Vol. 3, No. 1,
pp. 19-30.
Behrman, J.R. and Wolfe, B.L. (1984), ―The Socio-economic Impact of Schooling in
a Developing Country‖, The Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol. 66, No. 2, pp.
296-303.
Besant, Annie. How India Wrought for Freedom: The Story of the National Congress
Told from Official Records. Adyar, Madras: The Theosophical Publishing House,
1915.p12-13
Bhakna, Sohan Singh. Jivan Sangram: Atam Katha. (Punjabi manuscript). Jalandhar:
Yuvak Sewak Parkashan, 1967.
Bhalla, A.S. and Lapeyre, F. (1999), ―Global Integration and Social Exclusion with
Special Reference to Poland and Hungary‖, European Journal of Development
Research, Vol. 11, No. 1, pp. 101-24.
Bhattacharya, Sabyasachi (ed.) Rethinking 1857, Orient Longman, Hyderabad, 2007.
Bhoomi Thakore and David G. Embrick, ―Encyclopedia of Race, Ethinity and
society‖ Ed. Thousand Oaks, CA Sage Publications 2008.
Bhowmik, S. (1992), ―Caste and Class in India Caste and Class in India‖, Economic
and Political Weekly, Vol. 27, No. 24/25, June 13-20, pp. 1246-1248.
152
Black, Sandra E.; Devereux, Paul J. and Salvanes, Kjell G. (2003), ―Why the Apple
Doesn‘t Fall Far: Understanding Intergenerational Transmission of Human Capital‖,
IZA Discussion Paper No. 926, November, IZA, Bonn. (AQ: please mention the place
of publication of the paper.)p11
Bose, Saugata and Ayesha Jalal. Modern South Asia: History, Culture, Political
Economy, Oxford University Press, Delhi, 1997.
Brass, Paul. Language, Religion and Politics in North India, Cambridge University
Press, 1974.
Breen, R. (2005). The Comparative Study of Social Mobility. In: R, Breen. (Eds),
Social Mobility in Europe. Oxford: Oxford University press.
Carr, M. and Chen, M.A. (2004), ―Globalization, Social Exclusion and Work: With
Special Reference to Informal Employment and Gender‖, Working Paper No. 20,
Policy Integration Department, ILO, Geneva.
Chakravarty, U. (2003). Gendering Caste: Through a Feminist Lens. Kolkata: Street
Publication.
Chatterjee, Partha. The Partha Chatterjee Omnibus, Oxford University Press, Calcutta,
1999.p3-4
Chatterjee, R. L. (1989). Social Decision of Scheduled Castes in India. New Delhi:
Intellectual Publication House.p-56
Chatterji, Joya, Bengal Divided: Hindu Communalism and Partition, 1932-1947,
Cambridge University Press, Indian edition, 1995.p6-7
Chatterji, Joya. The Spoils of Partition: Bengal and India, 1947-67, Cambridge
University Press, 2007.p23-25
Chattopadhyay, Swati. Representing Calcutta: Modernity, Nationalism and the
Colonial Uncanny, Routledge, London and New York, 2005.p11-13
Checchi, D. (1997), ―Education and Intergenerational Mobility in Occupations‖,
American Journal of Economics and Sociology, Vol. 56, No. 3, pp. 331-52.
Checchi, D. and Flabbi, Luca (2007), ―Intergenerational Mobility and Schooling
Decisions in Germany and Italy: The Impact of Secondary School Tracks‖, IZA
Discussion Paper No. 2876, June, IZA, Bonn.p11-17
Chopra (1997): ‗1947: A Soldier‘s Story‘, from the records of Major General
Choudhary, D. C. Violence in the Freedom Movement in Punjab (1907-1942). Delhi:
B. R. Publishing Corporation, 1986.p55
Chowdhary, Prem. Punjab Politics: The Role of Sir Chhotu Ram. Delhi, 1984. Colvin,
153
Ian. The Life of General Dyer. London: Blackwood, 1929.p23
Clayton, Mary Kuiper, Elliott J. Gorn, and Peter W. Williams, eds. Encyclopedia of
American Social History (3 vol 1993) 2653pp; long articles pages by leading scholars;
see v I: Part II, Methods and Contexts, pp 235–434
Clert, C. (2000), ―Policy Implications of a Social Exclusion Perspective in Chile:
Priorities, Discourse and Methods in Question‖, Unpublished PhD Thesis, Social
Policy Department, London School of Economics and Political Science, London.
Corak, M. (2006), ―Do Poor Children Become Poor Adults? Lessons from a Cross
Country Comparison of Generational Earnings Mobility‖, IZA Discussion Paper No.
1993, March, IZA, Bonn.p33
Couch, K.A. and Dunn, T.A. (1997), ―Intergenerational Correlations in Labour
Market Status: A Comparison of the United States and Germany‖, The Journal of
Human Resources, Vol. 32, No. 1, Winter, pp. 210-32.
Cristina Lannelli and Lindsay Paterson, ―Does education promote Social mobility‖ p.
no. 35, June 2005.p9
Cross, C. M. P. The Development of Self Government in India, 1858-1914, The
University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1922.p17-19
Cross, Michael S. and Kealey, Gregory S., eds. Readings in Canadian Social
History (5 vol 1984). 243 pp.
Cross, Michael S. "Social History," Canadian Encyclopedia (2008) online
Curzon, Lord, of Kedleston. ‗British Rule in India,‘ the North American Review, Vol.
192, No. 656, July 1910, pp 1-13.
Dalrymple, William. The Last Mughal: The Fall of a Dynasty, Delhi, 1857, Penguin
Viking, New Delhi, 2006.p22-23
Darnton, Robert. ―Literary Surveillance in the British Raj.‖ In Book History. Vol. 4.
(2001), The John Hopkins University Press.p12-14
Darnton, Robert. The Kiss of Lamourette: Reflections in Cultural History, Norton,
London and New York, 1990.p5-7
Das, Suranjan. Communal Riots in Bengal, 1905-1947, Oxford University Press,
Delhi, 1991.
Das, Veena (ed.) Mirrors of Violence: Communities, Riots and Survivors in South
Asia, Oxford, 1990.p43-45
Das, Veena. Critical Events: An Anthropological Perspective on Contemporary India,
Oxford University Press, Delhi, 1995.p9
154
Datta, Nonica. Forming an Identity: A Social History of the Jats. Delhi: Oxford
University Press, 1999.
Datta, V. N. and S. Settar (eds). Jallianwalla Bagh Massacre. Delhi: Pragati
Publication, 2000.p12-13
Datta, V. N. Madan Lal Dhingra and the Revolutionary Movement. New Delhi:
VikasPublishing House Pvt Ltd, 1986.
Davis, K., & Moore, W. E. (1967). Some Principles of Stratification. In Bendix and
Lipset (Eds.). Class, Status and Power (pp. 242-249). London: Routledge and Kegan
Paul.p41-42
Dayal, Har. ‗Shabash,‗ San Fransisco: Hindustan Ghadar Party, folder 2, box 2, South
Asians in North America, 1913.
Dayal, Har. Karl Marx: A Modern Rishi. Jalandhar: Desh Bhagat Yadgar Committee
Publication.
Deb, P. C. (1975). Social Stratification and Mobility in Rural Setting. Delhi: Research
Co. Publications.
Desai S.B, Dubey A, Joshi B L, Sen M, Shariff A and Vanneman R, ―Human
Development in India: Challenges for a Society in Transition‖, Oxford University
Press, 2010.
Devji, Faisal Fatehali. A Practice of Prejudice: Gandhi‗s Politics of Friendship,‖ In
Subaltern Studies XII: Muslims, Dalits, and the Fabrications of History, eds.
ShailMayaram, M.S.S. Pandian, Ajay Skaria. New Delhi Permanent Black, 2005.
Dewald, Jonathan. Lost Worlds: The Emergence of French Social History, 18151970. (2006). 241 pp.
Dewey, Clive. The Settlement Literature of the Greater Punjab: A Handbook. Delhi:
Manohar, 1991.
Dewitt C. Ellinwood and S.D. Pradhan. India and World War One. Delhi: Manohar,
1978.
Dignan, Don. The Indian Revolutionary Problem in the British Diplomacy, 19141919. New Delhi: Allied Publishers Private Limited, 1983.
Donogh, W. R. A Treatise on the Law of Sedition and Cognate Offences in British
India. Calcutta: Thakkar, Spink and Co., 1911.
Driver, Edwin D. (1962), ―Caste and Occupational Structure in Central India‖, Social
Forces, Vol. 41, No. 1, October, pp. 26-31.
Dustmann, C. (2004), ―Parental Background, Secondary School Track Choice, and
155
Wages‖, Oxford Economic Papers, Vol. 56, No. 2, pp. 209-30.
Dwyer, Michael O‗. India As I Knew It. Chandigarh: Unistar, 2015.
Eden, Emily. Up the Country: Letters Written to her Sister from the Upper Provinces
of India,
Educational Research and Reveiw Vol. 1(3) pp. 35-40 April-2012
Edwardes, Michael. Red Year: The Indian Rebellion of 1857, London, Hamish
Hamilton, 1973.
Edwards, William. Reminiscences of a Bengal Civilian, Smith, Elder and Co,
London, 1866.
Eley, Geoff. A Crooked Line: From Cultural History to the History of
Society. (2005). 301 pp.
Erikson, R. and Goldthorpe, J.H. (1992), The Constant Flux: A Study of Class
Mobility in Industrial Societies, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Fairburn, Miles. Social History: Problems, Strategies and Methods. (1999). 325 pp.
Fanon, Franz. The Wretched of the Earth. Transl. Constance Farrington. London:
Penguin Books, 2001.
Farooqui, Mahmood. Besieged: Voices from 1857, Penguin Viking, New Delhi, 2010.
Gandhi, Mahatma. What is Hinduism, Indian Council of Historical Research, National
Book Trust, India, 1994.
Farooqui, Mahmood. Jahan se Dekhiye Yak Shor-e Shor-angezNikle Hai (A Riot of
Fass, Paula, ed. Encyclopedia of Children and Childhood: In History and Society, (3
vols. 2003).
Fertig, Michael and Schmidt, Christoph M. (2001), ―First- and Second-Generation
Migrants in Germany—What Do We Know and What Do People Think‖, CEPR
Discussion Papers 2803, C.E.P.R., London.
Fletcher, Roger. "Recent Developments in West German Historiography: the
Bielefeld School and its Critics." German Studies Review 1984 7(3): 451–
480. ISSN 0149-7952 Fulltext: in Jstor
Ganachari, Aravind. "First World War: Purchasing Indian Loyalties." In Economic &
Political Weekly, February 19, 2005, pp. 780-81.
Gandhi, M.K. Hind Swaraj or Indian Home Rule, Ahmadabad: Navjivan Trust, 2015.
Gandhi, Rajmohan. A Tale of Two Revolts: India 1857 and the American Civil War,
Penguin, Viking, 2009.
Gandhi, Rajmohan. Punjab: A History from Aurangzeb To Mountbatten. New Delhi:
156
Aleph Book Company, 2015.p12-13
Gang, Ira N. and Zimmermann, Klaus F. (1999), ―Is Child Like Parent? Educational
Attainment and Ethnic Origin‖, IZA Discussion Papers No. 57, IZA, Bonn.
Gaur, Ishwar Dayal. Martyr as Bridegroom: A Folk Repesentation of Bhagat Singh.
New Delhi: Anthem Press, 2008.p32
Ghassem-Fachandi, Parvis. Pogrom in Gujarat: Hindu Nationalism and Anti-Muslim
Violence in India, Princeton University Press, Princeton and Oxford, 2012.
Ghurye, G. S. (1969). Caste and race in India (5th ed.).Bombay: Popular Prakashan.
Ghurye, G.S. (1932). Caste and Race in India. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Giddens, A., & Giddens, A. (1973). The Class Structure of the Advanced Societies.
London: Hutchinson.p9-10
Gilmartin, David. ‗A Networked Civilization?‘ in Miriam Cooke and Bruce B
Lawrence (eds.) Muslim Networks: From Medieval Scholars to Modern Feminists,
Permanent Black, 2005, pp. 51-68.
Glen, M., & Bose, S. (1978). Social Mobility among Untouchables, in Gupta, G. R.
(Eds). Cohesion and Conflict in Modern India. New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House.
Goldthorpe, J.H. (1980), Social Mobility and Class Structure in Modern Britain,
Oxford University Press, Oxford.p67-68
Gooptu, Nandini. "The Urban Poor and Militant Hinduism in Early TwentiethCentury Uttar Pradesh." In Modern Asian Studies, 31, no. 4 (1997): 879-918.
Gooptu, Nandini. The Politics of the Urban Poor in Early 20th century India,
Cambridge University Press, 2001.
Gopal, S. The Viceroyalty of Lord Ripon, 1880-1884. London: Oxford University
Press 1953.
Gore, C. and Figueiredo, J. (eds.) (1999), Social Exclusion and Anti-poverty Policy:
A Debate, IILS/UNDP, and Geneva.
Gould, William. Hindu Nationalism and the Language of Politics in Late Colonial
India, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2004.
Govind, Rahul ―Revenue, rent…profit? Early British imperialism, political economy
and the search for a differentia specifica (inter se).‖ In Indian Economic and Social
History Review, 48, 2 (2011).p6-7
Kaviraj, Sudipto. "The Imaginary Institutions in India." In Subaltern Studies VII:
Grawe, N. (2004), ―Intergenerational Mobility for Whom? The Experience of High
and Low Earnings Sons in International Perspective‖ in M. Corak (ed.), Generational
157
Income Mobility in North America and Europe, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge.p1-2
Griffin, Lepel H. Ranjit Singh and the Sikh Barrier between our Growing Empire and
Central Asia. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1892.p34
Halsey, A.H.; Heath, A.F. and Ridge, J.M. (1980), Origins and Destinations: Family,
Class and Education in Modern Britain, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Hansen, A B (2002): Fortnightly Report (FR) second half of March 1947, India
Hareven, Tamara K. "The History of the Family and the Complexity of Social
Change," American Historical Review, (1991) 96#1 pp 95–124 in JSTOR
Harte, N. B. "Trends in publications on the economic and social history of Great
Britain and Ireland, 1925-74." Economic History Review 30.1 (1977): 20–41. online
Heckman, J.J. and Hotz, V.J. (1986), ―An Investigation of the Labour Market
Earnings of Panamanian Males Evaluating the Sources of Inequality: An Investigation
of the Labour Market Earnings of Panamanian Males Evaluating the Sources of
Inequality‖, The Journal of Human Resources, Vol. 21, No. 4, Autumn, pp. 507-42.
Henretta, James. "Social History as Lived and Written," American Historical
Review 84 (1979): 1293-1323 in JSTOR
Himmelfarb, Gertrude. ―The Writing of Social History: Recent Studies of 19th
Century England.‖ Journal of British Studies 11.1 pp. 148–170. online
Hobsbawm, Eric. The Age of Revolution: Europe 1789-1848.
http://indpaedia.com/ind/index.php/1965_War:_Pakistani_accounts-1 – ―Battles of
Khem.p5
http://www.claws.in/images/journals_doc/1902138004_PKChakravorty.pdf,
―Battle
of Asal.p4
Ibettson, Denzil. 'Panjab Castes: Being a Reprint of the Chapter On ―The Races,
Castes and Tribes of the People‖ in the Report on the Census of the Panjab published
in 1883 conducted in 1881.' Delhi: Low Price Publications, 2014.
Intergenerational Mobility in India‖ May 2011, East Mall, Vancouver, BC V6I IZI,
Canada.p13-14
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Intervention, Vol. 2 Issue 3
march 2013 pp. 55-59.
Jain, P.C., & Jain, S. (1986). Scheduled Caste Women. Delhi: Perfect Book Agency.
Jain, S. (1988). Status and Role – Perception of Middle Class Women. New Delhi:
Pooja Publisher.p33-34
158
Jena, S. K. (1993). Working Women and Modernization. New Delhi: South Asia
Books.
Jodhka, S. S., &Jodhka, S. S. (2012). Caste. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Jogdand, P. G. (2013). Dalit Women in India, Issues and Perspectives. New Delhi:
Gyan Publishing House.
Judge, P. S. (Ed.). (2013). Readings in Indian Sociology: Towards Sociology of Dalits
(Vol.1). New Delhi: Sage Publications.
K. N. Seenivasa, ―Occupational mobility among the Kurubas in Karnatka: A
sociological study‖
Kabeer, N. (2000), ―Social Exclusion, Poverty and Discrimination: Towards an
Analytical Framework‖, IDS Bulletin, Vol. 31, No. 4, pp. 83-97.
Kanner, Barbara. Women in English Social History, 1800-1914: A Guide to
Research (2 vol 1988–1990). 871 pp.
Keith, A.B. A Constitutional History of India 1600-1935. London: Methuen and Co.,
1936.
Kharan and Chawinda – Pakistani Version‖
Knight, F.H. (1935), ―Professor Hayek and the Theory of Investment‖, the Economic
Journal, Vol. 45, No. 177, March, pp. 77-94. Kumar, S.; Heath, A. and Heath, O.
(2002a), ―Determinants of Social Mobility in India‖, Economic and Political Weekly,
Vol. 37, No. 29, pp. 2983-2987. (2002b), ―Changing Patterns of Social Mobility:
Some Trends over Time‖, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 37, No. 40, pp. 409196.
Kumar Pradeep. "Hindu Nationalism and Lala Lajpat Rai‗s Discourse." In Lala Lajpat
Kumar, Ravinder. ed. Essays in Gandhian Politics: The RowlattSatytagraha of 1919.
Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1971.
Lal, Chaman. "Revolutionary Legacy of Bhagat Singh." In Economic and Political
Weekly 42, no. 37 (2007): 3712-3718.
Lloyd, Christopher. Explanation in Social History. (1986). 375 pp.
Lorenz, Chris. "'Won't You Tell Me, Where Have All the Good Times Gone'? On the
Advantages and Disadvantages of Modernization Theory for History." Rethinking
History 2006 10(2): 171–200. ISSN 1364-2529 Fulltext: Ebsco
Loury, G.C. (1981), ―Intergenerational Transfers and the Distribution of Earnings.‖
Econometrica, Vol. 49, No. 4, pp. 843-67.
Lovering, J. (1998), ―Globalisation, Unemployment and ‗Social Exclusion‘ in Europe:
159
Three Perspectives on the Current Policy Debate‖, International Planning Studies,
Vol. 3, No. 1, pp. 35-56.
Lt Gen Hanut Singh, PVSM, MVC, ―Fakhr-e-Hind‖ – Story of the Poona Horse
(Dehradun: Agrim Publishers, 1993), pp.191-218.
Maj Gen Joginder Singh (Retd), Behind the Scenes (New Delhi: Lancer International,
1993).p12
Maj Gen KS Bajwa (Retd) India‘s National Security – Military Challenges
&Responsesy.p9
Mandelsohn, O., &Vicziany, M. (1998). The Untouchables: Subordination, Poverty
and the State in Modern India. (No.4) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Manifestation of Violence in Punjab 1937-47, India Research Press, New Delhi, p
117.
Marcotte, D.E., ―Continuing education, job training, and the growth of earnings
inequality‖, Industrial and Labour Relations Review, 53, 4, 602-623, 2000.
Marriot, M. (1955). Little Community in an Indigenous Civilization. In Marriot,
McKim (Ed.). Village India: Studies in the Little Community. Chicago: Chicago
University Press.p7
Marx, K. (1977). Critique of Hegel‘s‘ Philosophy of Right‘. CUP Archive.
Marx, W. (1922). Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft, Vol.3. J. C. B. Monr, Paul Siebeck and
Mazumder, B. (2001), ―Earnings Mobility in the US: A New Look at
Intergenerational Inequality‖, Working Paper No. 34, Centre for Labour Research,
University of California, Berkeley, March.p65-66
Minister Y.B. Chavan‘s Diary of India-Pakistan War (Atlantic Publishers &
Distributors, 2007).p4-6
Mintz, Steven and Susan Kellogg. Domestic Revolutions: A Social History Of
American Family Life (1989) excerpt and text searchMintz, Steven. Huck's Raft: A
History of American Childhood (2006).
Mishra, R. (1999), ―Beyond the Nation State: Social Policy in an Age of
Globalisation‖ in C. Jones-Finer (ed.), Transnational Social Policy, Blackwell,
Oxford.
Modhinagar in Ghazibad districts of UP India‖ Global Advanced Research Research
and Journal of
Mohindar Singh Chopra, the Military Studies Convention, New Delhi.
Mosley, Stephen. "Common Ground: Integrating Social and Environmental
160
History," Journal of Social History, Volume 39, Number 3, Spring 2006, pp. 915–933,
relations with Environmental History, in Project MUSE
Muehlbauer, Matthew S., and David J. Ulbrich, eds. The Routledge History of Global
War and Society (2018).p55-56
Myhre, Jan Eivind. "Social History in Norway in the 1970s and Beyond: Evolution
and Professionalisation." Contemporary European History 28.3 (2019): 409-421
Neal Derek, ―The Complexity of Job Mobility among Young Men‖, Journal of
Labour Economics, 17(2), 237-61, 1999.
Office Library (IOL) quoted in A B Hansen, Partition and Genocide:
Palmer, Bryan D., and Todd McCallum, "Working-Class History" Canadian
Encyclopedia (2008).p22
Parsons, D.O. (1975), ―Intergenerational Wealth Transfers and the Educational
Decisions of Male Youth‖, Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 89, No. 4, pp. 60317.
Partha Nath Mukherji, ―Social Mobility and Social Structure: Towards a conceptual
methodological reorientation‖ Institute of Social Sciences, New Delhi.
Pomeranz, Kenneth. "Social History and World History: from Daily Life to Patterns
of Change." Journal of World History 2007 18(1): 69–98. ISSN 1045-6007 Fulltext:
in History Cooperative and Project Muse
R.D. Pradhan and Yashwantrao Balwantrao Chavan. 1965 War, the Inside Story:
Defense.p5
Rai in Retrospect: Political, Economic, Social and Cultural Concerns, ed. J. S. Grewal
and InduBanga, 101-119. Chandigarh: Panjab University, 2000.p111
Randhawa (1954): Out Of Ashes: An Account of the Rehabilitation of Refugees from
West Pakistan in Rural Areas of East Punjab, Punjab Public Relations Department,
Chandigarh, p25.
Riphahn, Regina T. (2001), ―Cohort Effects in the Educational Attainment of Second
Generation Immigrants in Germany: An Analysis of Census Data‖, IZA Discussion
Papers No. 291, IZA, Bonn.
Schnepf, S.V. (2002). ―A Sorting Hat that Fails? The Transition from Primary to
Secondary School in Germany‖, Innocenti Working Paper No. 92, UNICEF Innocenti
Research Centre, Florence.
Simon, Sheldon w., 'The Kashmir Dispute in Sino-Soviet Perspective; Asian Survey,
VII:3 (March 1967), 176-187.
161
Singh, Chetan. Region and Empire: Punjab in the Seventeenth Century. Delhi: Oxford
University Press, 1991.
Singh, Ditt. Sultan Puara. Lahore, 1896, reprint, Amritsar, 1976.p3-4
Singh, Gajendra. The Testimonies of Indian Soldiers and the Two World Wars:
Between Self and Sepoy. New York: Bloomsbury Academic, 2014.p77
Singh, Ganda ed. "Deportation of Lala Lajpat Rai and Sardar Ajit Singh." In History
of the Freedom Movement in the Panjab, Vol. IV. Patiala: Punjabi University, 1978.
Singh, Harbans and Barrier, N. Gerald. Punjab Past and Present: Essays in Honour of
Dr. Ganda Singh. Patiala: Publication Bureau, Punjabi University, 1996.
Singh, Khushwant and Satindra Singh. Ghadar 1915, India's First Armed Revolution.
New Delhi: R & K Publishing House, 1966
Singh, Vishal, 'India, Pakistan and South•East Asia', International Studies 0New
Delhi), 8:1-2 (July•October 1966), 167•176.
Skocpol, Theda, and Daniel Chirot, eds. Vision and method in historical
sociology (1984).p2-4
Solon, G.R. (1992), ―Intergenerational Income Mobility in the United States‖,
American Economic Review, Vol. 82, No. 3, pp. 393-408. World Bank (2000), World
Development Report 2000-2001: Attacking Poverty, World Bank, Washington DC.
Stearns, Peter N. "Social History Present and Future." Journal of Social History.
Volume: 37. Issue: 1. (2003).p7-8
Stearns, Peter N. "Social History Today ... And Tomorrow," Journal of Social
History 10 (1976): 129–155.
Stearns, Peter, ed. Encyclopedia of European Social History from 1350 to 2000 (5 vol
2000), 209 essays by leading scholars in 3000 pp.
Stearns, Peter, ed. Encyclopedia of Social History (1994) 856 pp.
Stein, Arthur, 'India and the USSR: The Post-Nehru Period', Asian Survey, VII: 3
(March 1967), 165•175.
Subrahmanyam, K., 'The Challenge of the Seventies to India's Security', India
Quarterly, XXVI:2 (April-June 1970) 1. 134-142.
Sutherland, Neil. "Childhood, History of," Canadian Encyclopedia (2008)
Syed 1 Anwar, 'China and the Indo-Pakistan War of 1965 1 1 Orbis X:3 (Fall 1966~ 1
859•880.
Talbot, Phillips, The American Posture Toward Indi and Pakistan 1 1 The Annals 1
July 1970r87•97•
162
Tandon, P (2000): Punjabi Saga 1857-2000: The Monumental Story of Five
Generations of a Remarkable Punjabi Family, Rupa, New Delhi, p 131.
Taylor, Edmond, 'The Soviet Bi~ for India', The Reporter, 33:9 (18 November 1965),
18Q23.p4
Thompson, E. P. The Essential E. P. Thompson. (2001). 512 pp. highly influential
British historian of the working class.p7
Thompson, F. M. L., ed. The Cambridge Social History of Britain, 1750-1950." Vol.
1: Regions and Communities. Vol. 2: People and Their Environment; Vol. 3: Social
Agencies and Institutions. (1990). 492 pp.
Tilly, Charles. "The Old New Social History and the New Old Social
History," Review 7 (3), Winter 1984: 363-406
Tilly, Charles. Big Structures, Large Processes, Huge Comparisons (1984).
Timmins, Geoffrey. "The Future of Learning and Teaching in Social History: the
Research Approach and Employability." Journal of Social History 2006 39(3): 829842. ISSN 0022-4529 Fulltext: History Cooperative and Project Muse
Tubingen, now published as Economy Society (Eds.) by Guenther Roth and Claus
Wittich, New York: Bedminster Press.p5
Turbulence, Wherever You Look): The DehlviGhadar, in Sarai Reader 2006:
Turbulence, CSDS, Delhi, pp. 254 – 270.
Uttar‖ by Maj Gen PK Chakravorty.
Vaidyanath, R., 'Some recent trends in Soviet policies towards India and Pakistan',
International Studies (New Delhi), VII:3 (January 1966), 429-447.
Viktoria Hnatkovska, Amartya Lahiri and Sourabh B. Paul, ―Breaking the caste
barriers:
Virilio, Paul (1977): Speed and Politics: An Essay on Dromology, Semiotexte, New
York.p3-4
Weinstein 1 Franklin B.,'The Second Afro-Asian Conference: Preliminary Bouts',
Asian Survey, V:7 (July 1965) 1 359•373.
Wilcox,- Wayne, 'China's Strategic Alterna~ives in South Asia', in Tang Tsou (Editor
), 1 China in Crisis :II, China's Policies in Asia and America's Alternatives, Chicago,
1968 1 395-44.
Wilson, Adrian, ed. Rethinking Social History: English Society, 1570-1920 and Its
Interpretation. (1993). 342 pp.
163
APPENDIX
INTERVIEW SCHEDULE
Social History and Occupational Mobility: A Study of Khem Karan Town in
(1950-2011)
Research Guide: Dr. Mohammad Ashraf Dar
Assistant Professor, Department of History
Center for Distance and Online Education
Lovely Professional University, Punjab India.
Punjab
Research Scholar: Ashwani Kumar
Section-I
Personal data
Ward NoName of the Town: - Khem Karan
District:-Tarn Taran
1. Name of the respondent _________________________________
2. Sex: Male/ Female
(
)
3. Age
A. Less than 20, B. 21 to 30, C. 31 to 40, D. 41 to 50
4. Caste
(
)
A. Brahmin, B. Jatt Sikh, C. Khatri, D. Mazbi Sikh, E. Other.
5. Religion
(
)
A. Hindu, B. Sikh, C. Christian, D. Other
6. Marital Status
(
)
A. Unmarried, B. Married, C. Widow, D. Divorced
7. Educational Qualification
(
)
A. Literate, B. Illiterate
8. Literacy Level
(
)
A. Primary, B. Secondary, C. Intermediate, D. B/MA/M.Sc./Medical/Technical
9. Occupation
(
)
A. Agricultural Labour,
B. Non- Agricultural Labour,
C. Employed
D. Business
E. Other
10. Head of the family Annual Income (Rupees)
(
)
A. 20000-30000
B. 30001-40000
C. 41000-50000
D. 50000 and above
E. Not applicable.
11. Are you income tax payer? (i)Yes (ii) No
(
)
12. What are the sources of your family income? Rank them
A. Primary occupation
164
(
)
B. Agriculture
C. Agriculture Labour wage
D. Wage Labour
E. Business
F. Government Jobs
13. Nature of family
A. Joint family, B. Nuclear family, C. Extended family
14. Size of the family
A. 3, B. 5, C. 7, D. 8 and above
15. Nature of house
A. Kacha, B. Pucca, C. Mixed, D. Other
16. Status of home
A. Own, B. Rented, C. Other
17. Do you have sanitary facility?
A. Yes, B. No.
18. Do you have electrification of your house?
A. Yes, B. No.
19. Do you own rural agricultural land and urban land?
A. Yes
B. No
(
(
(
(
(
(
)
)
)
)
)
)
(
)
(
)
(
)
(
)
(
)
(
)
Section-II
Occupation Mobility1. What is your occupation? _______________________________
2. Is it your traditional occupation?
A. Yes
B. No
3. How, past of your community is associated to your occupation?
4. What is the traditional occupation of your Community?
5. From how much years you are into this occupation?
A. Less than 5 year
B. Less than 10 year
C. More than 10 year
D. More than 20 year
6. How did you enter into the present occupation?
(i)
On own efforts
(ii)
Through the help of a political leader/ community leader/ activist/ relative
(iii) Through succession/ spouse/ patrimonial kin
(iv)
Reservations in public employment
7. Did you change your occupation?
A. Yes
B. No
8. Why you changed your traditional occupation?
______________________________________________________________
165
9. Do you have subsidiary occupation?
A. Yes
B. No
10. Are you having any social restriction for changing your occupation? (
)
A. Yes
B. No
11. If yes, what are they? Rank them
A. Social, B. Religious, C. Cultural, D. Verna / Caste based abolitions, E. Patriarchal
12. Do you and your family used to work at upper caste/ elites families of the village? (
)
Yes
No
13. Do you think women should work out side? Discuss
______________________________________________________________
14. Do you rare cattle as your occupational change in the family?
A. Yes
B. No
15. Do you migrate for occupation with your family members?
(
A. Yes, B. No
16. If yes, which type of migration is it?
(
A. Seasonal, B. Permanent, C. Semi-permanent, D. Any other
17. Have you registered yourself in the employment office of Patti?
A. Yes
B. No
18. Status of traditional and nontraditional occupation of inter-generations
S.N.
Occupation
1
Grand
Father Traditional
(First
Generation)
Father (Second Traditional
Generation )
Respondent
Traditional
(Third
Generation)
2
3
Non-Traditional
Total
Non-Traditional
Total
Non-Traditional
Total
)
)
Section-III
1. Do you know about Indian Democracy?
A. Yes, B. No.
2. Do you know your Political constitutional rights?
A. Yes, B. No.
3. Do you know which party of your constituency M P and MLA?
A. BJP, B. AAP, C. SAD, D. Congress.
4. Do you go for voting?
A. Yes, B. No
5. Do you have membership of any political party?
A. Yes
B. NO
6. What are the issues on which you decide to vote? Rank them
166
(
)
(
)
(
)
(
)
(
)
(
)
A. Development. B. Representation, C. Self respect, D. Redistribution, E. Any other,
specify.
7. What are factors influences you in supporting and voting for any political party?
S.N.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Category
Agenda of the party
Leaders ability
Leaders Caste
National
Regional
Other
Remark
8. What is reason behind choosing the candidate?
S.N.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Category
Religion
Caste
Class
Gender
Region
Personal ability of candidate
Remark
9. Since how long you are voting for a particular party?
A. 5-10 Years
B. 11-15 Years
C. 16-20 Years
D. 21-25 Years
10. Do you think the Dalit men in to politics will make difference?
A. Yes
B. No
11. Do you know the work of President of Nagar Panchayat and ward members to
develop town?
A. Yes, B. No
12. Do you exercise your vote in Nagar Panchayat elections?
A. Yes, B. No
Section-IV
Educational Status-
1. What is your educational qualification? Or Distribution of education level of
respondents.
(
)
A. Illiterate
B. Primary Level
C. Middle Level
D. Secondary Level
E. Senior Secondary Level
167
F. Graduation Level
G. Post Graduation Level
2. How many members of your family are studied or studying?
A. 1, B. 2-3, C. 4-5, D. More than 5
3. Which type of schools is available in your town?
A. Primary, B. Middle School, C. High School, D. College, E. None
4. In which type of school your children are studying?
A. Government School
B. Private
5. How your school environment is?
A. Very good, B. Good, C. Poor, D. Very poor
6. Do you face gender biasness in acquiring education against male candidate in the
family?
A. Yes
B. No
7. Do your children face discrimination in their class?
A. Yes
B. No
8. Do you face problem of dropout in your study period? What are the reasons for this?
A. Economic issues B. Gender, C. Patriarchy, D. Caste, E. Religion, and F. Other
9. Do you think that your family status is increased due to education?
A. Yes, B. No
10. Do you think that equal status of Dalit will come through education?
A. Yes, B. No
11. Are you encouraging for education in your society?
A. Yes, B. No.
12. How you are getting financial support for education?
A. Parents. B. Relatives, C. Scholarships, D. Other.
13. Have you or your any family member get job through reservation?
A. Yes, B. No.
14. Would you like to provide higher education to your children?
A. Yes, B. No
15. If yes what type of education
A. Arts, B. Sciences, C. Professional, D. Technical, E. Any other(specify)
16. What is the impact of migration on your/ yours child education? Discuss
_______________________________________________________________
17. Are you aware government schemes of education?
A. Yes
B. No
Section V
Expenditures, Indebtedness and Savings
1. What is your monthly expenditure?
A. 5000-10000
B. 10001-15000
C. 15001-20000
D. 20001-30000
2. Do you have any habit?
(I)Smoking (ii) Drinking wine (iii) Chewing tobacco/Gutka (IV) Gambling (v) any
other addiction
3. Expenditure on it: Monthly Rs.
A. 500-1000
168
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
B. 1001-1500
C. 1501-2000
D. More than 2000
Have you taken any loan?
(i)
Yes (ii) No
What is the source of debt amount?
a) Community person(s)/Relative b) Friends c) Government agency d) Money
lender e) Other(s)
For what purpose the loan was taken?
a) Occupation b) Education c) Housing construction/purchase of land/plot d)Family
maintenance, e) Marriage f) Any other
Do you save of the income?
A. Yes
B. No.
Where did you deposit your saving amount?
a) Bank b) Credit Society c) Post Office d) Insurance, e) Any other
What would you prefer for your savings
a) FD b ) RD c) PPF d) Mutual Fund
169
Appendixes 2
Data collection survey, Gurnam Singh wards no 2, Khem Karan
170
Data collection survey, Gurnam Singh wards no 2, Khem Karan
171
Data collection survey, Palwinder Singh wards no 5, Khem Karan
172
Data collection survey, Vinay Sethi wards no 9, Khem Karan
173
Data collection survey, Manjit Sharma wards no 9, Khem Karan
174
Data collection survey, Sh. Karam Mohan Monga President Shri Ramayan Sewa Society
Wards no 1, Khem Karan
175
Data collection survey, Nindar Kaur wards no 5, Khem Karan
176
Fauja Singh resident of Khem Karan honored with Tamara Patra on 15 Aug 1972 (source personal meeting with
Fauja Singh‘s family)
177
Pakistani Army Troop occupied Khem Karan town in 1965 war (Source Wikipedia)
178
Condition of Khem Karan Railway Station on 1965 war (Source Wikipedia)
Historical Baoli at outs tricks of Khem Karan Town (Source field survey)
179
Palace of Raja Khem Karan (Source field survey) Palace of Raja Khem Karan
180
Historical Monument of Martyrs of Battle of 1965 (Source field survey)
Monument
181
182
183
184
185
186
Image Source: - Dainik Jagran (Hindi Newspaper)
187
188
Image Source: - Jag Bani (Punjabi Newspaper)
Image Source: - Punjabi Jagran (Punjabi Newspaper)
189
Image Source: - Punjabi Jagran (Punjabi Newspaper)
190