The Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission of UNESCO
1993
An IOC Newsletter on toxic algae and algal blooms
No. 7
~ i ~ h l i ~ofh Sixth
t s International
Whoproduces PSP?
Conference on Toxic Marine Phytoplankton It is well known that paralytic shellfish
Nantes, France, 18-22 October 1993
The first New Zealand outbreak of human shellfish poisoning, an 'Ambush
Predator' of fish and the apparent global increase in red tides dominated the
Sixth International Conference on Toxic
Marine Phytoplankton, held in Nantes,
France, 18-22 October 1993.
In the austral summer of 1992193,
New Zealand reported 180 cases of
shellfish poisoning. This was the first
outbreak of Neurotoxic Shellfish Poisoning (NSP) outside the Atlantic and
it involved a complex of poisons plus a
new Gymnodinium breve-like species.
Shifting winds and altered sea surface
temperatures associated with 'El Nifio'
were implicated.
Lurking in the murky depths of the
Parnlico Estuary (USA east coast) is a
strange beast indeed: amoebas, sensing
warmer waters and passing fish shoals,
sprout flagella, then swarm up for a
gruesome kill. Aerosolization of the
unidentified toxins from this mainly
bottom-dwelling dinoflagellate, called
Pfiesteria piscimorte, caused eight days
of amnesia in one investigator, and researchers now wear protective shields.
Large fish-kills (>l000 fish) occurred
in 1991, and recently from points north
(Delaware) and south (Gulf of Mexico)
of Parnlico.
A total of 122 papers were reviewed
describing fish-kills from harmful algal
blooms (HABs). Mechanisms include
anoxia, intoxication (of fish and larvae),
and clogging of gills (with spiked
Chaetoceros concavicornis and C.
convolutus in Alaska, British Columbia
and Washington State). Nations dependent on fish for food or income are
most immediately threatened.
The role of ship ballast water in 'hierarchical' dispersion of alien species
(see Lockwood, 16 Oct. 1993, The Lancet) received considerable attention.
Australian authorities have begun regular monitoring for toxic algae and for
(Cont'd on p. 3)
poisoning (PSP) toxins are produced by
Alexandriurn catenella, A. tamarense, A.
cohorticula,A. findyense, A. fiaterculus,
A. minutum, Gymnodinium catenatum,
Pyrodinium bahamense var compressum
and Prorocentrum minimum, but not by
other species of Alexandrium,
Gymnodinium and Pyrodinium.
Silva (Proc. IV IUPAC Symp. on
Mycotoxins and Phycotoxins, Lausanne.
Proc. Pathotox Publ. 1979) suggested
that dinoflagellate toxin production may
be due to bacteria living in association
with the dinoflagellate. Recently
Kodama & Ogata (Mar. Poll. Bull. 19,
559-564, 1988) also pointed out the
possible association of bacteria in cell
interiors with toxin production by A.
tamarense, and suggested that toxin
production is not a hereditary characteristic of A. tamarense. We thought that
this hypothesis has not as yet been supported with sufficient evidence, given
that (1) the algal cultures were not
axenic, and (2) there were only a few
bacteria in the nuclei of 10-15% of the
many algal cells present. However, we
cannot deny the possible association of
factors other than bacteria, such as
(Cont'd on p. 3)
Gymnodinium catenatum in German coastal waters
The unarmoured, chain-forming dinoflagellate Gymnodinium catenatum
Graham is the subject of intensive research in several countries because of
its obvious association with outbreaks
of paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP).
As part of its sexual life cycle, G.
catenatum produces a brown, spherical,
micro-reticulate resting cyst with a
prominent red accumulation body. The
occurrence and distribution of dinoflagellate resting cysts is of interest because
cysts represent stable populations assuring geographical maintenance in contrast
to the transient bloom from which they
may be derived. Because of their small
size, cysts are chiefly transported with
residual currents and can infect areas
where they are not endemic. The fact
that resting cysts can be collected and
enumerated during non-bloom periods,
offers a potential tool for the prediction
of future toxic blooms.
As pointed out by T. Wyatt in
Hannfil Algae News no. 2, the presentday distribution of cysts and vegetative
cells of G. catenatum in European waters extends only to the Atlantic coast
of the Iberian peninsula, where it was
first recorded in 1976. This species has
never been recorded in any of the numerous investigations of living
phytoplankton from northern European
waters (Elbrachter, pers. comm.). However, large numbers of subfossil G.
catenatum cysts where found in
sediments of the Kattegat area from a
period about 2000 until 300 years ago
and it is suggested that in former times
the species was widespread throughout
(Cont'd on p. 4)
Toxic shellfish event in New Zealand
attributed to Gymnodinium cf. breve and Alexandrium minutum
By January 1993 a full-scale dinoflagellate bloom was under way in Northland,
New Zealand, and reports emerged of
intoxicated animals, associated with
eating shellfish scraps.
At this point events escalated rapidly.
There were indicatioasof illness in human shellfish consumers. Mouse
bioassays carried out by the Communicable ~ l s e a s e sCentre in Wellington
confirmed the presence of algal toxins
in aqueous extracts of shellfish gathered
from right around the country. The
government ordered the closure of shell
fisheries around the entire New Zealand
coast.
Extensive surveys of the
phytoplankton were undertaken, and
aerial surveys carried out to help pinpoint bloom fronts. It soon became apparent that the South Island aquaculture
regions, the Malborough Sounds and
Big Glory Bay, had productive waters
for the time of year, but with 'harmless' species predominating. Coccolithophores and diatoms were particularly abundant. With this information,
and following an adjustment to the
method for preparing shellfish for the
mouse bioassay (a return to the use of
0.1N HC1 instead of 1.ON HC1 in the
aqueous extracts), false positives were
minimized and South Island was reo~enedto shellfish harvesting.
In the north-east of ~[rth Island,
several dinoflagellate species came under suspicion. Alexandrium minutum, a
species new to New Zealand waters, was
found in Tauranga Harbour, and this
linked well with both the epidemiological data and the mouse bioassay results.
Paralytic shellfish toxins were later
confirmed in shellfish from this area by
HPLC analysis. However, this species
was not widespread, and did not explain
the majority of the illnesses.
During the second week of February,
four things occurred almost simultaneously, implicating a Gymnodinium species which had persisted as a sub-dorninant throughout the bloom.
First an outbreak of coughing
amongst the residents of Orewa Beach,
on the north-east coast, followed exposure to sea-spray aerosols, generated by
heavy surf at the tail of a cyclone. (This
well known phenomenon in the Gulf of
Mexico/Florida area in the USA is related to blooms of Gymnodinium breve).
Reports followed of mass mortalities of marine fauna on reefs within the
more northern Bream Bay, again a classic phenomenon associated with blooms
of G. Breve. Thirdly, a sophisticated
analysis of the contaminated shellfish
by Professor Yasumoto, Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan, revealed the
presence of toxins closely resembling
the 'brevetoxins'. Fourthly, samples
taken from Orewa Beach by Dr. Hoe
Chang (New Zealand Oceanographic
Institute), and samples received at that
time by the Cawthron Institute from
Coromandel (further to the south), contained abundant Gymnodinium cells that
on scanning electron microscope examination closely resembled G. breve.
Although G. breve has tentatively been
identified outside USA waters, there
have never been records of an association with shellfish toxicity elsewhere,
until now.
The main factor contributing to late
diagnosis of the toxin, and consequently
the microalgal culprit, was the failure
to determine the toxicity of lipid extracts
of shellfish.
Initially, because the nature of the
predominant toxins involved was unknown, observation of mice following
the injection of aqueous shellfish ex-
tract was continued for up to 24 hours.
A positive toxicity score was regarded
as causing the death of 2 out of 3 mice
during that time. Subsequently it was
shown that most of the toxicity was associated with a lipid soluble fraction.
The delayed toxicity observed with
aqueous extracts was shown to be irrelevant to human intoxications and the
l to 24 hour observations were reduced
to 1 hour, to monitor for PSP toxicity
only. Once this was done the situation
immediately became clearer, with lipidsoluble breve-like toxins being the predominant toxicity.
Research relating to the toxic event
is still being carried out, and cyst surveys
should help determine whether a seed
bed exists from which further toxic
blooms might arise in the future.
In retrospect, the event, involving
both microalgal species and toxins new
to New Zealand, was handled conservatively. This has resulted in confidence
amongst consumers. New Zealand will
certainly be well prepared for any future events, should they occur.
Lincoln MacKenzie and Lesley Rhodes,
Cawthron Institute, Private Bag 2, Nelson, New Zealand.
(Cont'd from p. I , 'Highlights')
Vibrio cholerae (Hallegraeff, Rigby,
personal communication), and with the
emergence of K cholerae non-01 CT+
in Asia and new algal blooms occurring in Indonesia, Australia, New Zealand and the Philippines, the need to
monitor ballast water and coastal algal
blooms for vibrios is even more urgent.
The International Maritime Organization
is considering measures.
Marine bacterial-algal interactions
. were another subtheye. Included are:
bacterial production of saxitoxins, bacterial enhancement of algal toxins
(domoic acid), and algae as vectors of
vibrios and other bacteria. In addition
reports of toxic Cyanobacteria are increasing. In 1990 and 1992. in the Gulf
of inland, blue-greens produced centimetre-sized aggregates, which emphasizes the interaction of physical with biotic factors (e.g. with gels and fibres)
that may enhance net growth and provide protection from grazing.
Explanations for the apparent spread
of HABs could be: (1) increased awareness, (2) natural variability or (3) a real
increase in the extent and the number
of species involved, as a result of
anthropogenic factors. The factors considered include eutrophication (nutrients), loss of wetlands, altered predation
pressures (from over-fishing and fish
diseases), and superimposed global
change. The New Zealand outbreak and
one off South Africa involving the
Benguela Current involved changes in
winds and sea surface temperatures associated with El Nifio, whose increased
frequency in the past decade (4 X) suggests increasing climate instability.
Everyone agreed that the costs of
HABs to finfish harvesting, aquaculture
and tourism have grown considerably.
The apparent spreading of coastal algal
blooms and their role as a reservoir and
dispersal mechanism for cholera increases the urgency for an early warning
system.
Paul R. Epstein, Harvard Medical
School, Cambridge,MA 02139, USA.
Zan R. Jenkinson, Agence de Conseil et
de Recherches Ockanographiques,
19320 La Roche-Canillac, France.
Editors note: Z j as some forecasters
feel, the El Niiio system is 'locked in
the on mode' (see Richerd Kerr, Science, 262: 656-657,29 Oct. 1993),New
Zealand's troubles may be just beginning. A shortened version of this article
appeared in: The Lancet, 342,1108,30
Oct. 1993.
PARENT
IA) OF152
(B) OF191
S
(a) 001519 1.
(b) 001519 2
(c) 001519 3
(d) 001519 4
rnl
Average toxin composition (as % total toxin, +1.0 S.D. n=8) of A. tamarense, parent
strains OF152(A),OF191(B)and those 4 F1 strains (a-d).
(Cont'd from p. I , 'PSP')
diphtheria toxin production by phageinfected cells.
We tried to determine whether the
source of PSP toxins is encoded by nuclear DNA, chloroplast DNA,
mitochondrial DNA, or bacterial DNA
in Alexandrium, by studying the inheritance of toxin composition by F1 cells
from parents with different toxin compositions. A. catenella and A. tamarense
were examined in clonal-axenic cultures.
We noted that the mole percentage
toxin composition in several strains did
not change significantly until the late
exponential phase. This indicates that
PSP toxin composition in A. catenella
and A. tamarense is a stable genetically
determined trait.
Crosses of parents (mt+ and mt-)
with different PSP toxin compositions
were made and the toxin composition
patterns of the F1 cells compared with
those of the parents. Chromosome genes
in crosses are inherited in a 2:2 Mendelian pattern, whereas chloroplast genes
and mitochondrial genes are inherited
uniparentally. Other symbiotic factors
such as bacteria phages and plasmids
are also inherited uniparentally or at
random. Which gene codes for PSP
toxin-synthesizing enzymes of Alexandrium?
PSP toxins composition pattern of
the parents OF152(mt+) and OF191
(mt-), and a representative pair of mt+
and mt- F1 progeny (0015 19-1 and
001519-3) are shown in figure. In the
parental strain OF152, the major part
corresponded to gonyautoxin GTX l +4.
In the other parental strain OF19l (mt-) ,
the toxin composition corresponded to
Cl+C2, neosaxitoxin (neoSTX) and
GTX1+4. The F1 progeny 001519-1
and 001519-3 showed the same toxin
composition as the parental OF152, and
the other F1 001519-2 and 001519-4
showed the same toxin composition as
the parental OF191. F1 progenies from
A. catenella parents also show either one
or the other parental toxin composition
(Ishida et al., Toxic Phytopl. Bloom in
the Sea, 881-887, 1993; Sako et al.,
Biosci. Biotech. Biochem., 56,692-694,
1992).
Thus toxin compositions of F1
progenies in A. tamarense and A.
catenella are inherited on a 1:1 Mendelian pattern, referred to as biparental inheritance, and not in a uniparental pattern nor randomly. The genes for PSP
toxin-synthesizing enzymes must be
coded in the chromosomal DNA of
Alexandrium.
However, more evidence is needed
before a definitive statement can be
made. Experiments continue to detect
and isolate PSP toxin synthesizing enzymes, especially transforming enzymes
(saxitoxin + gonyautoxin + C-toxins).
The isolation of these enzymes and their
DNA sequences should be decisive in
settling this problem in the near future.
Yuzaburo Ishida, Laboratory of Microbiology, Department of Fisheries, Faculty of Agriculture, Kyoto University,
Japan.
Further details appear in Sako, Y., Kirn,
C. H., and Ishida, Y., 1992. Mendelian
inheritance of paralytic shellfish poisoning toxin in the marine dinoflagellate
Alexandrium catenella. Biosci. Biotech.
Biochem., 56: 692-694 (eds.).
(Cont'd from p. I , 'Gymnodinium ')
the water column of the region (Dale et
al., 1993. In: Smayda & Shirnizu, Toxic
Phytoplankton Blooms in the Sea.
Elsevier, 47-52). Interactions between
climatic change and local hydrography
seem to be important factors regulating
these fossil 'blooms', with the migration of relatively warmer waters contributing to the establishment of G.
catenatum. It is suggested that the cool. ing of the Little Ice A y caused its disappearance in present times (Dale &
Nordberg, 1993. In: Smayda & Shirnizu,
Toxic Phytoplankton Blooms in the Sea,
Elsevier, 53-57).
This is in keeping with investigations from the adjacent North Sea area,
especially in the German Bight in October 1991, which showed that G.
catenatum cysts are apparently absent
in recent sediments (Nehring,
Helgolander Meeresunters., in press).
This also holds true for other investigations of North Sea sediments (e.g. Dale,
1976, Rev. Palaeobot. Palynol. 22, 3960; Reid, 1977,Nova Hedwigia 29,429463). However, in March 1992, living
G. catenatum cysts were found at two
stations in the German Bight (mentioned
as 'cyst of Diplopsalid group' in
Nehring, op. cit., in press) and were
discovered in sediments of the Danish
coast bordering the Kattegat (Ellegaard
et al., J. Phycol., in press). During an
additional survey of the German Bight
and Baltic Sea (Kiel Bight) in April
1993, living and empty cysts of G.
catenatum were found in the topmost
centimeter of sediments at numerous
stations in both areas, showing maximal abundance of 17.0 living cysts/cm3.
The cysts of G. catenatum from Kiel
Bight comply with the specimens isolated from German Bight sediments (3035 pm in diameter) and with the description given by Ellegaard et al. (op.
cit.) from the Kattegat area, but are
slightly smaller than specimens from
other parts of the world (for review see
Ellegaard et al., op. cit.). The second
important feature is that chains longer
than two cells were never seen. This
agrees with the comprehensive germination experiments and observations on
motile cells of G. catenatum by
Ellegaard et al. (op. cit.). Also they have
found chains with only two cells under
conditions where chain formation was
induced in other studies (Blackburn et
al., 1989, J. Phycol. 25, 577-590) and
speculated that G. catenatum is in reality a species complex, with the Danish
strain a different ecotype or a non-
Outline of Northwestern Europe showing distribution of recent
and subfossil Gymnodinium caterlatum resting cysts.
chainforming variant. The site nearest
to northern Europe where motile cells
of G. catenatum are known is the Atlantic coast of Spain (Estrada et al.,
1984, Inv. Pesq. 48,31-40) but Paulrnier
(1992, Rapports intemes de la Direction des Ressources Vivantes de
1'IFREMER- 92.007, 107pp.) recorded
G. cf. catenatum from the Channel coast
of France in 1983 and 1984 as single
cells and chains of two cells.
At present no motile cells or shellfish toxicity have been detected in waters of the North and Baltic Seas, but
the positive germination experiments
with filtered seawater from the sample
locations show that the occurrence of
G. catenatum in the water column is
very likely, and has probably so far been
overlooked.
These findings suggest that the toxic
G. catenatum was introduced to German
coastal waters by increased water influx through the English Channel into
the North Sea and then transported with
the residual currents to the Skagerrakl
Kattegat area. This scenario is very
likely because the current system of the
North Sea should not allow infection of
the German Bight with cysts from the
SkagerrakJKattegat area (see Lee, 1980,
North Sea: Physical Oceanography, II,
Elsevier Oceanogr. Ser. 24B). If so,
cysts of this species must be present in
recent sediments of the Atlantic and
Channel coast of France as well as on
the Danish North Sea coast and in the
Kattegat area. In January 1993 a massive salt water influx from the Kattegat
through the Great Belt into the Western
Baltic took place, and may have infected
this area with G. catenatum cysts.
It has been shown for Tasmanian
waters that infection of the area with
Gymnodinium catenatum cysts resulted
in recurrent toxic blooms leading to human PSP and to temporary closure of
shellfish farms (Bolch & Hallegraeff,
1990, But. Mar. 33, 173-192;
Hallegraeff et al., 1988, Aust. Fisheries
47, 32-34). In the same manner G.
catenatum cysts in North and Baltic Sea
sediments may represent potential seedbeds for spontaneous bloom initiation.
Phytoplankton monitoring programmes
need to be aware of this. To get a comprehensive idea of F e spreading of G.
catenatum cysts in northern European
waters, further surveys of the quantities
and spatial and temporal distribution of
these cysts in sediments are needed.
Cyst studies provide an important but
relatively cheap additional tool for the
evaluation of areas with potential toxicity problems. The potential impact of
such species on commercial fisheries,
aquaculture and the natural environment is of increasing concern. After
three centuries of absence, a potential
recolonization of G. catenatum in
northern European waters may have
taken place. With respect to global
change, it is now a question of whether
hydrodynamic, chemical and biological
factors in the water column will favour
germination of cysts and the proliferation of vegetative cells of G. catenatum
in the future.
Stefan Nehring, Institut fir Meereskunde
an der Universitat Kiel, Dustembrooker
Weg 20, 0-24105 Kiel, Germany; tel:
(49-431) 5973993; fax: (49-431)
5973994.
Advanced workshop on HAB ecophysiology
,
An advanced workshop on the ecophysiology of harmful algae was
planned at the first,.meeting of the
SCOR-IOC Working Group 97 on the
Physiological Ecology of Harmful Algal Blooms. It was held at CREMA
L'Houmeau, CNRS-IFREMER, La
Rochelle, France, 23-24 October 1993.
The WG is chaired by Dr. D.M.
Anderson (USA).
Having outlined central questions in
future research on the ecophysiology of
harmful microalgae, the WG decided
to organize an advanced scientific
workshop to review the state of knowledge and to identify and discuss areas
of future research.
The key questions identified included the roles of toxin production,
bacteria, and mixo- and heterotrophy in
the ecophysiology of harmful algae, as
well as the importance of genetic variability in harmful algal species, and the
role of UV on harmful algal succession
and occurrence.
The WG decided to prepare a proposal for a NATO 'Advanced Study
Institute'. A NATO AS1 has a duration
of 10 days and has 60 to 80 participants
and includes both lectures and demonstrations. SCOR and IOC will co-sponsor the workshop, and the presentations
and the results will be published.
The workshop is proposed for November 1994 or June 1996 in Bermuda.
A detailed proposal was prepared and
an organizing committee was identified.
A set of recommendations were
adopted as follows:
(1) Convene within 3 years an advanced
workshop to summarize the state of
knowledge, exchange ideas, disperse
new technologies, establish interaction,
and identify themes of future research
relating to the physiological ecology of
harmful algae.
(2) Begin to contact individuals potentially interested in the workshop (at the
direction of the Chairperson).
(3) Convene a second SCOR-IOC
workshop in conjunction with the 7th
International Conference on Toxic Marine Phytoplankton, Sendai, Japan, July
1995.
Joint ICES-IOC action planned for 1994
The joint Study Group of the International Council for the Exploration of the
Sea (ICES) and IOC on the Dynamics
of Algal Blooms has been re-established
as an ICES-IOC Working Group on
Harmful Algal Bloom Dynamics that
works in close connection with the IOC
Harmful Algal Bloom Programme. The
Chairperson of the WG is Beatriz
Reguera (Spain).
The setting up of this group was
recommended at the last ICES Statutory
Meeting by the Chairpersons of the Hydrography and the Biological Oceanography Committees. The terms of reference were: 'to plan and propose a
programme to study the dynamics of
HABs in coastal oceans'.
The activities to be carried out during 1994 are:
H ICESIIOC Workshop on 'Modelling
the Population Dynamics of Harmful
Algal Blooms', Vigo (Spain), 4-7 May
1994. Convenors: W. Fennel (Germany)
and P. Tett (UK).
H Meeting of ICESIIOC Working
Group on Harmful Algal Bloom Dynamics, Vigo (Spain), 9-12 May 1994.
Chairperson: B. Reguera (Spain); including a joint session, 9-10 May, with
the Working Group on Shelf Seas
Oceanography, chaired by H. Dahlin.
H ICESIIOC Workshop on Intercomparison of in situ Growth Rate Measurements, Aveiro (Portugal), 25-29 July
1994. Chairperson: M.A. Sampayo
(Portugal).
Participants from countries outside
ICES, especially those interested in establishing HAB dynamic studies in other
geographical regions, are invited to attend the WG meeting on Harmful Algal
Bloom Dynamics and the Workshop on
Modelling the Dynamics of HABs.
Intergovernmental
panel sets priorities
The IOC-FAO Intergovernmental Panel
on Harmful Algal Blooms held its Second Session in Paris 14-16 October 1993
to set priorities and identify resources
for the Harmful Algal Bloom (HAB)
Programme. Twenty-one Member
States, WHO, ICES, IUPAC(') and
SCOR were represented.
The Panel decided to establish four
Task Teams to address critical issues
requiring specific priority and action:
A Task Team on Algal Taxonomy
will provide taxonomic recommendations, develop identification standards
for preparation of manuals and training,
and help coordinate activities;
A Task Team on Aquatic Biotoxins
will prepare a report on the current status
of algal toxin chemistry and toxicology,
and in particular facilitate the preparation and supply of algal toxins;
A Task Team on Design and Implementation of Monitoring Programmes
will assist in the preparation of a report
where examples of monitoring systems
on harmful algae worldwide are presented in detail, and assist in the organization of an international workshop
directed toward improved design of
HAB monitoring systems;
A Task Team on HAB Project Development will work with the preparation of HAB project proposals.
The development of a comprehensive training and capacity building programme on harmful algae was agreed
upon. The training programme will include courses and workshops on taxonomy, toxin chemistry, monitoring, and
management of harmful algae. The first
taxonomy course has already been held
and both taxonomy and toxin chemistry courses are planned for 1994.
The Summary Report of the Second
Session of the IOC-FAO Intergovernmental Panel on Harmful Algal blooms
is available from the HAB Programme
Office, IOC Secretariat.
IUPAC = International Union for Pure
and Applied Chemistry.
(l)
Ciguatera Management Workshop, Bribie Island, Australia
An internationalWorkshop on Ciguatera
Management was held on Bribie Island
near Brisbane on 12-16 April 1993. The
Workshop was sponsored by the Australian Fisheries Research and Development Corporation and,the Queensland
'Department of Prihary Industries
(QDPI). Scientists, medical practitioners and fisheries managers attended and
focussed on current research having
implications for the management of
ciguatera. (Sources of comments are indicated in brackets.)
A total of 56 people from Japan,
mainland USA, Hawaii, France, French
Polynesia, New Caledonia, Germany
and Australia attended. The Workshop
specifically addressed (i) the detection
of ciguateric fishes and (ii) the management of ciguatera cases. P. Scheuer
opened the scientific program with an
historical perspective of modern
ciguatera research initiated by the late
A. H. (Hank) Banner and outlined some
of the challenges for the future. The
major themes of the Workshop were:
chemical and immunological aspects of
the detection of toxins involved in
ciguatera; pharmacology and treatment
of ciguatera; origin of the toxins involved in ciguatera; clinical aspects and
epidemiology of ciguatera.
Detection of ciguateric fish
A cost-effective screen for ciguateric
fish was recognized as an important
management tool able to directly reduce
the adverse effects of ciguatera on public health, fisheries, trade and tourism
(R. Lewis, D. Park). Several different
approaches to the detection of ciguateric
fish were presented. Two approaches
measured the interaction between
ciguatoxin and the voltage-dependent
sodium channel through either (i) the
inhibition of brevetoxin binding to sodium channels in a rat brain synaptosome preparation (A. M. Legrand) or
(ii) the cytotoxic effects of ciguatoxin
on sodium channel-containing cell lines
pre-exposed to ouabain and veratridine
(R. Manger). Both assays were more
sensitive than the mouse bioassay, and
may replace in vivo assay in laboratories
possessing the specialized equipment
required. However, it is unlikely that
these approaches, as they stand, can be
used for the routine screening of suspect fish.
Antibody-based screens still appear
to hold most promise for the cost-effective detection of ciguateric fish (R.
Lewis). This approach is the basis of a
potential commercial test to detect
ciguateric fish being developed by Hawaii Chemtect International (Pasadena
California, USA). D. Park presented a
summary of the performance of this
solid-phase immunobead assay
(CiguatectTM)which was claimed to be
able to detect most, if not all ciguateric
fish. However, the test was reported to
be unsuitable for detecting ciguatera
toxins if the fish flesh being screened
was slightly acidic (pH G 6.5), a factor
that may considerably limit the usefulness of the test. Y. Hokama commented
that the test may not work satisfactorily
because the solid-phase used in the
CiguatectTMtest may not be as efficient
at extracting ciguatoxins from fish as
the correction fluid used for the solidphase in the original stick test he developed (apparently the same antibody was
used for both tests). When compared
with the results of a well conducted
mouse bioassay, predictive indices from
5% to 75% were obtained with the
CiguatectTMtest in an independent study
of ciguateric fish from the Caribbean
(R. Dickey). These results suggest that
the test may not be responding to the
major toxins (as yet unidentified) present
in these Caribbean fish. Lack of ready
access to samples of pure ciguatoxin or
its analogues, and an inability to independently validate the levels of
ciguatoxins present in fish samples being screened, hamper attempts to validate (or otherwise) the CiguatectTMtest.
Pharmacology and
treatment of ciguatera
Major advances are being made into
how ciguatoxins cause human poisoning (J. Molgo, E. McLachlan, J. Brock,
P. Hamblin, E. Beniot, K. Terao, C.
Purcell, M. Capra). However, the precise mechanism by which mannitol, the
present treatment for acute ciguatera,
acts to relieve the symptoms of ciguatera
remains unclear. A double-blind clinical study of mannitol treatment is being
conducted (N. Palafox) but the results
of this study were not available at the
time of the meeting. Clinical experiences
with mannitol therapy (D. Blythe, N.
Palafox) continue to be positive, and
mannitol remains the treatment of choice
for acute ciguatera. Confirmation of the
clinical findings would be assisted by
the development of an animal model
for ciguatera that responds to mannitol.
Clinical aspects and
epidemiology of ciguatera
While most of the clinical features of
ciguatera are well documented, the longterm effects of ciguatera and how frequently these occur are poorly understood (T. Ruff). Follow-up research on
victims is required to establish the true
extent of long-term effects, especially
the allergy-like reactions that can persist after a single exposure to toxic fish.
J. Pearn reported that ciguatera remains
typically a poorly recognized and managed disease, despite the introduction
of mannitol therapy. QDPI maintains a
database that covers 27 years of
ciguatera cases reported in Queensland.
An analysis of this database using recently developed statistical modelling
approaches revealed major shifts in the
species and the nature of poisoning in
Queensland (M. Chaloupka).
Origin and identification of
toxins involved in ciguatera
Gambierdiscus toxicus is now widely
accepted as the organism that produces
ciguatera toxins. Indeed this organism
may be the only source of these toxins.
T. Yasumoto reported the structure for
GTX-4A (52 epi-GTX-4B), the major
gambiertoxin produced by a Rangiroa
Atoll strain of G. toxicus grown in culture. This study c o n f m s that G. toxicus
is indeed the origin of the ciguatoxins
isolated from fish. Long and short range
inverse detected NMR of CTX-1 confirmed the structure originally proposed
for ciguatoxin (R. Lewis). The structure of a maitotoxin produced by culture G. toxicus was also presented by T.
Yasumoto. Maitotoxin is the largest nonrepeating unit compound for which a
structure is known and elucidation of
its structure represents a significant
milestone in natural product chemistry.
Maitotoxin's structure is only distantly
related to the ciguatoxins, thereby ending speculation that the maitotoxins may
be a precursor of the ciguatoxins.
The environmental factors that cause
the upsurges of ciguatera remain poorly
understood (M. Holmes, R. Lewis, Y.
Hokama, D. Ichinotsubo, R. Bagnis, U.
Kaly). The origin of ciguatera was
questioned by J-P. Vemoux based on
studies conducted in French Polynesia.
A rapid extraction method for isolation
of ciguatoxins from G. toxicus may assist studies on toxin production in culture (J. Babinchak). Studies of the vectors which transfer gambiertoxins to
carnivorous fish revealed that shrimps
may be involved $some communities,
and herbivorous fish such as
Ctenochaetus striatus in others (R.
Lewis).
A record of the meeting will be published in a special issue of the 'Memoirs
of the Queensland Museum' by mid1994. For further information on the
published proceedings please contact:
Richard J. Lewis, QDPI, Southern Fisheries Centre, PO Box 76, Deception
Bay, Queensland 4508, Australia; tel.:
(61-7) 203 1444; f a : (61-7) 203 35 17.
It was shown using confocal laser
microscopy that ciguatoxin causes
oedema of adaxonal Schwann cells and
nodes of Ranvier in myelinated nerve
fibers, and that mannitol (a product successfully usedin ciguatera therapy) acts
via its osmotic effects (J. Molgo).
The association of ciguatoxin with
specific proteins may explain its lack of
toxicity to Na+ channels of fish, even
though fish nerves respond to ciguatoxin
in a similar manner to those of mammals (F. Capra).
Hindsight on Arctic toxic bloom
Toxic blooms of marine algae are often
attributed to pollution, as in the case
with Chrysochromulinapolylepis in the
North Sea in 1988. Therefore, a toxic
bloom of Chrysochromulina leadbeaten
in Norwegian coastal waters, to the north
of the Arctic circle in June 1991, came
as a real surprise and needed other
models to explain it. The affected area
was the Vestfjord, situated between the
Lofoton Islands and the Norwegian
mainland. The area is very sparsely
populated and has little agriculture and
no heavy industry. So, why here?
The case developed from late May,
when farmed salmon started to die and
a diver reported a layer of yellow water
below the cages. Eventually, a total of
nearly 550 metric tons of salmon were
reported lost, from different farms isolated from each other and with unharmed farms in between. In one case,
dead and dying salmon were taken out
of a farm while samples were taken
close to the cages, showing that cell
concentrations were lower than 2 X
1061-l. So, if salmon mortality was not
related to the abundance of toxic algae,
to what was it related?
Several research institutes in Norway became involved in the operation,
mapping the distribution of the bloom
and doing experiments to explain its
causes. Compared to the C. polylepis
bloom, the C. leadbeateri bloom had
lower maximal concentrations,occurred
at lower temperatures and higher
salinities. Its distribution was more restricted and it did not affect the natural
flora and fauna.
C. leadbeateri was present in areas
to the south of the Vestfjord as well,
but was then part of a flora dominated
by diatoms, causing Secchi depths to
be 2-7 m. Secchi depths in the Vestfjord
were 8-21 m and the flora consisted almost exclusively of C. leadbeateri. In
the Vestfjord proper, as well as in
branching fjords, the mixed layer was
rather deep, often causing the highest
concentration of the algae to be found
in depth. The mixed layer contained little nutrients and the algae seemed to
optimize its growth by tactical positioning in a gradient of light and nutrients,
which occurred in a deeper layer.
Growth experiments with added nutri-
Detection
ciguatera-related toxins is available from
Hawaii Chemtect International (D. L.
Park). It has high potential for screening marketplace fish for ciguatera toxicity. Nevertheless, improvement of this
kit is needed since a significant number
of false negative and false positive values were obtained in an FDA trial (R.
W. Dickey).
Derivatization experiments with the
chromophore-poorciguatoxin-l yielded
a fluorescent coumarin-carbamic acid
ester of the biotoxin. HPLC with
fluorimetric detection produces a moderately intense detector response to 2
nanograms of the CTX-1 derivate (R.
W. Dickey). The derivate shows potential for the detection of ciguatoxins. To
separate toxic from non-toxic fish, the
detection limit by HPLC should be
l picogram, a threshold of sensitivity
which has never been obtained for
ciguatoxins by any described procedure.
This limits the use of HPLC with
fluorimetric detection of ciguatoxins to
the research laboratory only.
Ciguatera results predominantly from
the effects of the most potent ciguatoxin
(CTX-1) which is present at > 0.1 ppb
(10-10 K g ) in the flesh of carnivorous fish. Significant levels of the less
potent CTX-2 and CTX-3 also accumulate in fish (R. J. Lewis).
By using the specific binding propOrigin
erty of ciguatoxins to voltage-dependent sodium channels two detection
For the first time ciguatera was reported methods were developed: the first one
(M. J. Holmes) in an area (Platypus Bay, (A. M. Legrand) measures the ability of
Australia) not typically associated with ciguatoxins to displace by competition
ciguateric fish, without corals but with ratio-labelled brevetoxins from sodium
a sandy bottom covered by unattached channels. The second (R. Manger)
green macroalgae (Cladophora sp.). measures the enhancement of toxicity
Nevertheless, G. toxicus was attached on caused by ciguatoxins when added with
this algae and contained ciguatoxins, ouabain and veratridine to neurosuggesting that this G. toxicus popula- blastoma cells; it is simple, uses readily
tion is the origin of toxins found in available reagents (Mm), is well within
ciguateric fishes caught in this bay. Thus the scope of even modest tissue culture
the presence of corals is not essential facilities and has the potential to serve
for ciguatera development. In this area as an alternative and complementary
invertebrates such as shrimps were method to the standard mouse bioassay.
shown to contain detectable levels of A new mouse bioassay protocol adapted
ciguatoxin and to transfer these toxins to 50,100 or 200 g of fish was presented
in the ciguatera food chain (R. J. Lewis). by J. P. Vemoux.
CiguatectTM,the solid-phase imIt is the first time that shrimps were
implicated in the ciguatera phenomenon. munobead assay for the detection of
(Cont'd on p. 9)
Jean Paul Vernoux, Universite' de Caen,
Laboratoire de Physiologie Cellulaire
et Mole'culaire, Esplanade de la Paix,
14032 Caen Cedex, FRANCE.
South Korean oysters gave ASP symptoms
We analyzed Korean shellfish prodAn illness similar to Amnesic Shellfish
Poisoning (ASP) beset two persons after ucts for domoic acid (DA) contaminaeating smoked oysters in South Korea. tion, the causative agent of ASP.
The event occurred as follows: On 16 Twenty-five cans of smoked Korean
February 1992, approximately 5 hours oysters and two cans of smoked Koafter eating six canned oysters each from rean mussels were tested with high pera smoked Korean oyster product, the formance liquid chromatography meth-symptoms of ASP be@. to show. One ods. The cans represented different
person, a male, suffered seizures, diso- brands and lot numbers including the
rientation, confusion, vomiting, and same brand and lot number the two pergeneral weakness. Tests at a hospital for sons consumed on 16 February. Domoic
stroke, brain tumour, and heart attack acid was not detected in any of the
were negative. The other person, a fe- smoked Korean products.
From two of the cans, oyster gut
male, complained of a headache, was
unable to make decisions and had swol- contents were analyzed for diatom
len hands and feet. Approximately 24 frustules from the Pseudonitzschia
hours after she had ingested the oysters, complex. To date, only phytoplankton
she was stricken with a vomiting spell, from this group of diatoms produce DA.
followed by seizures, and went into a No forms known to be toxic were found,
coma that lasted for 48 hours. She had but the non-toxic diatom P. pungens f.
extremely low blood pressure, low so- pungens was present.
The HPLC analyses do not provide
dium, malfunctioning kidneys and liver,
and was left with muscle damage. At supporting evidence that the Korean
present, she suffers memory loss of these products were contaminated with DA.
events. She was tested for the same dis- However, we believe that the products
orders as the male victim as well as for we analyzed may not have been repretetanus, botulism, Rocky Mountain sentative of what the two people ate on
spotted fever, Lyme's disease and bac- 16 February, despite testing cans of
terial infection. All tests were negative. oysters from the same brand and lot
The house where the two victims live number that were consumed. Within a
was tested for carbon monoxide and ra- can of oysters variation in oyster size
don gas poisoning, and the water sup- was small. However, variation in the
ply was tested for numerous toxins; all oyster size between cans was large, even
when the cans were from the same brand
tests proved negative.
On 26 March 1992, both persons ate and lot number. This implies that the
seafood gumbo. The following day, the oysters were harvested from different
male had another attack with a seizure locations or times, despite identical lot
and symptoms similar to the 16 Febru- numbers on the cans.
Although smoked Korean oysters
ary attack. Again he was rushed to the
hospital andbundenventthe same tests tested negative, it may have been that
as before. All proved negative.
the oysters analyzed were harvested
Both persons were in good physical from a non-toxic area, and that the oyscondition before the illness appeared. ters consumed by the two people were
They did not drink or take drugs, and harvested from a toxic area, or even a
had not shown any previous reactions 'pocket' of toxicity. The oyster
when eating shellfish. Neither of the Crassostrea virginica accumulates DA
victims suffered from stomach problems, at low levels over short feeding periods
diarrhea, paralysis, or experienced tin- (Roelke, 1993). It is likely that oyster
gling sensations in the mouth during the species from Korea are similar to
Crassostrea virginica in their feeding
attack.
Therefore it does not seem likely that behaviour and may accumulate DA if
the victims suffered from Paralytic toxic diatoms are ingested over time.
As stated earlier, a non-toxic diatom,
Shellfish Poisoning. The symptoms
shown by the two persons, however, in- P. pungens f. pungens was found in the
dicate that they suffered from ASP. gut contents of the oysters analyzed.
Common symptoms of ASP include Fryxell et al., (1992) and Dickey et al.,
choking, vomiting, diarrhea, abdominal (1992) reported that two forms of P.
cramps, incapacitating headaches, sei- pungens are present together year-round
zures, and permanent short-term in Galveston Bay, Texas, with the nontoxic form, P. pungens f. pungens more
memory loss (Per1 et al., 1990).
common in warmer months and the
toxic form, P. pungens f. multiseries in
colder months. P. pungens f. multiseries
was found in small numbers from net
hauls with many P. pungens f. pungens
cells from Jinhae Vay, Korea, ApriI
1983 (Fryxell et al., 1990). The same
trend of seasonal relative dominance
observed in Galveston Bay is a possibility in Korean waters as well.
During the preparation process of
smoked Korean oysters, they are first
shucked, then smoked, put into cans
with oil, sealed in a vacuum, and fmally
sterilized by heating (Crown Prince,
pers. comm.). Domoic acid is a heatstable molecule. It does not appear likely
that the preparation process for smoked
Korean oysters would remove the toxin
from the product.
The distribution of DA-producing
diatoms is world-wide in temperate climates (Villac et al., in press). If appropriate environmental conditions arise
that favour a bloom of these toxic species, ASP events could also occur worldwide in temperate climates. Phytoplankton monitoring for DA-producing
species in Korean and Chinese waters
has only just begun (Fryxell, pers.
comm.). If a toxic bloom occurred in
1992 it is likely that it would have gone
unnoticed.
In summary, we know that two people suffered from an illness similar to
ASP after eating smoked Korean oysters. We know that a related oyster species along North America accumulates
DA, and that at least one toxic diatom
species occurs in Korean waters. We
also know that the canning process of
smoked Korean oysters is not likely to
destroy DA. Finally, we know that a
toxic bloom of diatoms in Eastern waters would have most likely gone unnoticed. There is, no direct evidence that
an ASP event occurred due to consumption of a Korean oyster product,
but these two cases serve as a warning.
As the scientific community increases its understanding of DA occurrences around North America and Europe, we also need to consider Eastern
waters. It is essential that monitoring of
the phytoplankton community be carried out in temperate climates worldwide where shellfisheries exist. The understanding of population dynamics and
life strategy of the species we know to
produce the toxin and the possible dis-
covery of other DA sources are crucial
in our effort to better protect
shellfisheries and consumers.
D. L. Roelke, G. A. Fryxell, L. A. Cifientes,
Department of Oceanography, Texas A&M
University, College Station, 7X 77843, USA.
Raphidophyte algal bloom
preceded New Zealand shellfish poisoning
Rhaphidophytes dominated an extensive
bloom which occurred along the northeast coastline of New Zealand from
August to December 1992. A dramatic
Literature cited:
increase in chlorophyll content was
Crown Prince, Inc., P. P. Box 3568, City of noted at that time in coastal waters off
Industry, CA 91744.
Leigh Marine Reserve, in Northland,
New
Zealand. The event was associated
Dickey, R. W., Fryxell, G. A., Granade,
with
the
'El Nifio' phase of the SouthH. R. and Roelke, D/ L., 1992. Detection
of the marine toxins okadaic acid and ern Oscillation Index, which resulted in
domoic acid in shellfish and phytoplankton unusually cold sea temperatures.
in the Gulf of Mexico. Toxicon, 30, 3: 335The microalgal species involved in359.
cluded the potentially ichthyotoxic speFryxell, G. A., Reap, M. E. and Valencic, cies Fibrocapsa japonica, Heterosigma
D. L., 1990. Nitzschia pungens Grunow f. akasiwo (Raphidophytes), Dictyocha
multiseries Hasle: Observations of a known speculum (Silicoflagellate) and a
neurotoxic diatom. Nova Hedwigia, 100: dinoflagellate initially described as
171-188.
Gyrodinium cf. aureolum. On closer
examination,
by SEM (scanning elecFryxell, G. A., Roelke, D. L., Valencic,
D. L. and Cifuentes, L. A., 1992. The toxin- tron microscopy), the dinoflagellate reproducing Nitzschia pungens f. multiseries sembled the Florida red tide microalga
Hasle: Field and laboratory results. Abstract. Gymnodinium breve. The coccolithoFifth International Conference on Toxic phore Gephyrocapsa oceanica was in
Marine Phytoplankton, Newport, RI, USA. constant and significant presence
Perl, T. M., Berdard, L., Kosatsky, T., throughout the bloom. Fibrocap,sa
Hockin, J. C., Todd, E. C. D. et al., 1990. japonica had only been noted once beAn outbreak of toxic encephalopathy caused fore in New Zealand - it was observed
by eating mussels contaminated with in north-eastern waters the previous
domoic acid. The New England Journal of October. Early in the bloom, Dictyocha
Medicine, 322,25: 1775-1780.
speculum occurred in its naked form,
Roelke, D. L., 1993. Feeding experiments but by December, when the bloom had
of Crassostrea virginica on two forms of temporarily diminished, the unarmoured
Pseudonitzschia pungens: Behaviour and form was predominant.
toxicity. Masters thesis. Department of
Oceanography, Texas A&M University.
(Cont'dfrom p. 7, 'Arctic toxic bloom')
Villac, M. C., Roelke, D. L., Villaral, T. A. ents revealed that both nitrogen and
and Fryxell, G. A. Comparison of two phosphorus had to be added to gain
domoic acid-producing diatoms. Hydro- growth in cultures.
biologia (in press).
A national report which sums up
most of the observations, suggests that
high freshwater outflow in winter led to
stGtification that was beneficial to C.
leadbeateri. After the normal spring
bloom in April, when diatoms and
Phaeocystis poucheti deplete the nutrient reserves in the mixed layer, C.
leadbeateri may have been the only
species able to maintain a population
under the prevailing conditions. The
species seemed to become toxic in
salmon farms localized in bays which
exchange tidally mixed water through
shallow channels. Thus, there is a possibility that admixture of new nutrients
from deep water made the algae toxic.
However, local eutrophication from the
farms themselves should be considered,
and also the saprobial faeces and feedspill. The heterotrophic and bacteriophagous behaviour of Chryso-
Maximum cell numbers were
reached in October, and although not
particularly high for individual species
(e.g. Fibrocapsa japonica reached no
more than 107,000 cells per litre), the
combined numbers result in a patchy
discoloration of the coastal waters for
over 200 km of the coastline. Bioassays
for both shellfish toxins and for
ichthyotoxicity were negative during this
period, but there were many anecdotal
accounts of unusual events. These included dieback of kelp beds, mass mortalities of penguins, skin irritations
among fishermen and peppery tasting
mussels in some areas.
The end of the raphidophyte-dominated bloom proved to be a brief respite.
Dinoflagellates proceeded to dominate
the water column along the same coastline, and in late December animal deaths
and human illnesses linked to the eating of shellfish were reported. It is
tempting to speculate that the conditioning of the water column by the earlier bloom, which was triggered by the
unusual weather patterns, was a critical
factor in the toxic event that followed.
Lesley Rhodes and Allison Haywood,
Cawthron Institute, Private Bag 2, Nelson, New Zealand.
chromulina genus could make fish farms
feasible habitats matching its niche.
Another speculation suggests that
wintering herring may have contributed
to the conditions for algal growth. Most
of the spring-spawning Norwegian herring spent the-winterin the irkermost
part of the Vestfjord, leaving a water
body characterized by low levels of
oxygen and high levels of plant nutrients. In fact, ammonia, which was not
recorded regularly during the bloom,
turned up in high concentrations when
measured, lending support to this view.
The bloom terminated in late June, possibly due to competing algae or grazers. Thus, the research does indicate a
complex matrix of causes and may have
raised more questions than answers, not
least because so many features deviated
from previous experience.
Stig Skreslet, Kristin Heidal and Age
Mohus, School of Fisheries, Nordland
College, N-8002 Bodo, Norway.
Information on algal blooms
and other hazardous events
in Swedish Baltic
The Information Office for the Baltic
Proper was established in June 1992 as
a direct result of a Swedish government
proposal. According' to the proposal,
three information offices should be established for those County Administrative Boards in whose counties Centres
for Marine Research had already been
established in 1989. The information
offices are to report especially on the
following topics:
Algal blooms, predominantly on
toxic blooms but also on the occurrence
of non-toxic blooms of major extent.
The reports should include information
about the toxicity of the algae and how
to avoid negative effects.
Oxygen deficiency situations. It is
valuable if early warnings about expected deficiencies can be given.
Fish kills, partly in connection with
oxygen deficiency and partly with other
causes, like diseases. It is valuable if
early warnings can be given.
Extensive diseases andlor kills of
organisms other than fish, e.g. seals and
birds.
Major spills of oil and chemicals
which may cause harm to the marine
environment.
The information office arranges telephone conferences with a limited
number of scientists involved in, or in
close contact with, field sampling programmes within the area of interest.
These conferences are held at predetermined intervals (ranging from about one
week up to about every second month)
depending on the expected development
of the situations monitored. If necessary, conferences can be held at very
short notice. During the conferences the
participants present available information and formulate a prognosis of the
expected development. The information
office staff puts the material presented,
including the prognosis, into a short re-
port or 'newsletter' (maximum about
one A4 page). The report is then sent
by telefax to interested receivers (all
County Administrative Boards and local authorities along the coast within the
area concerned, research institutes, the
Coast Guard, the Navy, fishermen's organizations, mass media and others)
immediately after the conference.
The Stockholm information office
(Informationskontoret for egentliga
~stersjonor Information Ofice for the
Baltic Proper) is currently reporting only
in Swedish. We hope to report also in
English in the near future. Before that
can be done we have to establish good
contacts with suitable instituteslauthorities in other Baltic countries in order to
achieve a reliable system for the exchange of information. We are now trying to establish such contacts. Therefore,
any suitable source of information in
other Baltic countries is welcome to
contact us. We are equally happy to be
able to provide information to those interested in receiving it.
Our area of interest ranges from the
northern h a n d Sea to the southern part
of the Sound (0resund) between Sweden and Denmark, and includes primarily Swedish coastal waters and the open
Baltic proper. The information office in
UmeA (to be established) is to cover the
Sea of Bothnia and Bothnia Bay. The
office in Gothenburg covers the area
from the southern part of the Sound up
to the Norwegian border, including the
Kattegat and the Skagerrak.
Contact persons are: Gunnar Anner
and Kerstin Bohm, The Information
Office for the Baltic Proper, Stockholm
County Administrative Board, Department of Environment Protection, Box
22067, S-104 22 Stockholm, Sweden;
tel: (46-8) 785 51 18 or 785 51 21; fax:
(46-8) 651 57 50.
Future events
4th Canadian Workshop on Harmful
Marine Algae; 3-5 May 1994; Sidney, B.C.
Canada. Contact: Rod ForbesIBrenda
Lacroix, Institute of Ocean Sciences, PO
Box 6000, 9860 West Saanich Road,
Sidney, B.C. V8L 4B2, Canada; tel: (1-604)
363 644316533; fax: (1-604) 363 6390.
5th International Phycological Conference; 26 June - 2 July 1994; Qingdao, P.R.
China. Contact: The Secretary, 5th Int.
Phyc. Conf., EMBL Institute of Oceanography, 7 Nanhai Road, Qingdao 266071,
P.R. China.
Modelling & Control of Activated Sludge
Processes; 21-23 August 1994; Copenhagen, Denmark. Contact: Mia Clausen,
Conference Secretariat, c10 Dept. of Environmental Engineering, Technical University of Denmark, DK-2800 Lyngby, Denmark.
13th International Diatom Symposium;
1-7 September 1994; Acquafredda di
Maratea, Italy. Contact: Jean Gilder
Congressi snc., Via G. Quagliariello 35/E,
1-80131 Napoli, Italy; tel: (39-81) 546 3779
or 545 4617; fax: (39-81) 546 3781.
Coastal Zone Canada '94; 20-23 September 1994; Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Contact: Bedford Institute of Oceanography, P.O. Box 1006, Dartmouth, N. S., B2Y
4A2, Canada; tel: (1-902) 429 9497; fax:
(1-902) 429 949 1.
24th International Conference on Coastal
Engineering (ICCE '94); 23-28 October
1994; Kobe, Japan. Contact: Secretariat,
c10 Inter Group, Shiroguchi Bldg., 2-15,
Kakutacho, Kita-ku, Osaka 530, Japan; fax:
(81-6) 372 6127.
Pollution of the Mediterranean Sea; 3-4
November 1994; Nicosia, Cyprus. Contact:
M. Nicolaou, WTSAC, PO BOX 1735,
Limassol, Cyprus.
IOC International Oceanographic Conference - 'Towards sustainable use of the
oceans and coastal zones'; 7-12 November
1994; Lisbon, Portugal. Contact: Secretary,
IOC, 1 rue Miollis, 75732 Paris cedex 15,
France; fax (33-1) 4056 93 16.
HARMFUL
ALGAENEWS
Chief editor: Tim Wyatt
Assisted by: Yolanda Pazos,
lnstituto de lnvestigaciones Marinas, Consejo
Superior de lnvestigaciones Cientificas,
Eduardo Cabello 6, 36208 Vigo, Spain.
Tel.: (34-86) 23 19 30 /23 19 73;
fax: (34 86) 29 27 62
o I INFSCO
190.?i Print.4 in France
The opinions expressed herein are those of
the authors indicated and do not necessarily
reflect the views of UNESCO or its IOC. Texts
may be freely reproduced and translated
(except when reproduction or translation rights
are indicated as reserved), provided that
mention is made of the author and source and
a copy sent to the Editor. Project Coordinator:
Henrik Enevoldsen, IOC, UNESCO, 1 rue
Miollis, 75732 Paris Cedex 15; tel: (33-1) 4568
4016; fax: (33-1) 4056 9316; omnet:
ioc.secretariat.
Production Editor: Galy Wright, IOC/MRI.
Layout: Micheline Turner.
ISSN 0020-7918
International Directory of Experts
in Toxic and Harmful Algal Blooms
Questionnaire
An updated and expanded edition of this international directory is being prepared as a joint effort of the
Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission (of UNESCO) and the NOAA National Marine Fisheries Service of
the United States. The purpose of the directory is to assist countries facing toxic and harmful algal bloom emergencies
by facilitating r,&d access to scientists, fisheries managers, public health officials, and physicians who are
experienced in dealing with toxic and harmful algal blooms and their consequences to fisheries, aquaculture, and
public health. The directory will also serve to expedite contact among the international community of experts in
harmful algal blooms and related issues.
Please complete this questionnaire if you are involved in basic scientific, fisheries, public health, or medical
aspects of harmful algal blooms, and wish to be included in the directory. Please copy this form for use by other
appropriate colleagues in your country. A copy of the directory will be sent to all those who reply to the questionnaire.
Send the completed questionnaire to the address on the reverse side.
II
I
I
Surname (last name): .....................................................................................................................................
Given names (first names): ............................................................................................................................
I
Title (Pro$, Dr., Mr., Ms., etc.): ......................................................................................................................
I
I
I
Academic degrees: ........................................................................................................................................
I
I
I
Position (Director, Chairman, Research Scientist etc.): ....................................................................................
I
Institution or affiliation (include department if applicable): ............................................................................
I
Postal address: ..............................................................................................................................................
I
I
I
I
I
City:
I
State or province: ................................................................. Postal code:
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
....................................................
Telephone (include country and city codes): ....................................................................................................
I
I
I
.....................................................................................Country: .........................................................
.
Telex: ............................................................................................................................................................
Fax: ...............................................................................................................................................................
E-mail (include system, e.g. BITNET, INTERNET, OMNET, etc.): .....................................................................
OVER PLEASE
General expertise (you may indicate more than one):
Biology
Chemistry
Physics
Ecology
Genetics
Taxonomy
Physiology
Toxicology
Fisheries
Aquaculture
Public Health
Medicine
Vet. Medicine
Management
Other (specify)
Harmful algal bloom specialty/expertise (summarize in a few sentences your background, experience,
and specific subject areas in which you feel most able to provide expert advice regarding harmful algal
blooms and their effects):
/'
Species of harmful algae, shellfish, fish, etc., with whlch you are most familiar:
Algal toxins with which you have worked most:
Number of years experience with harmful algaelbiotoxins:
Geographic areas of the world where you have worked:
...............................................................................................................................................................
Regional/international programmes related to harmful algal blooms, in which you participate:
Languages in which you have a working knowledge:
Citizenship: ............................................................................................................................................
Please send completed questionnaire by 28 February 1994 to:
Dr. Alan W. White
Northeast Fisheries Science Center
National Marine Fisheries Service
166 Water Street
rrr
1
TT
1
mm A
n m r
A-
A