International Journal of Advance and Applied Research

International Journal of Advance and Applied Research www.ijaar.co.in ISSN – 2347-7075 Peer Reviewed Vol.5 No. 22 Impact Factor – 8.141 Bi-Monthly July-Aug 2024 The Importances, Related aspects and Implementation of Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) in Education in India Saifulla Sardar Ph.D Research Scholar, School of Women Studies, Jadavpur University Corresponding Author: Saifulla Sardar Email: [email protected] DOIAbstract: Intellectual property rights are crucial for stimulating and promoting education, research and development. Because of its influence on innovation, research, and accessibility to educational resources, intellectual property rights (IPR) have become more important in the field of education. This study looks at the various dimensions of intellectual property rights (IPR) in the field of education, with a particular emphasis on how these rights affect the production, sharing, and use of knowledge. The study sheds light on the opportunities and problems that intellectual property rights (IPR) bring in supporting academic research, safeguarding educational resources, and encouraging knowledge exchange by examining the interaction between IPR and educational institutions. It explores how IPR regulations are implemented in educational contexts, examining the moral and legal ramifications as well as their efficacy. The study also looks into faculty and student awareness and comprehension of intellectual property rights (IPR), highlighting the necessity of including thorough IPR education in university curricula. The different approaches and their effects are further illustrated by a comparative review of IPR legislation around the world in educational environments. The results imply that although intellectual property rights (IPR) can protect intellectual property and foster innovation, a careful balance must be struck to prevent IPR from impeding knowledge access and educational equity. In order to improve both the promotion of educational goals and the protection of intellectual property, this research offers insights into the strategic integration of IPR in education. Keywords: Academic Research, Education, Educational Resources, Intellectual Property Rights, Innovation. Introduction: The term "intellectual property" (IP), which is used in studies of the human mind, refers to creations of the intellect for which a monopoly (derived from the Greek word monos, which meaning single pole in to sell) is granted to designated owners by law. Some common types of intellectual property rights (IPR), also known as industrial property, copyright, patent and trademarks, and trade secrets, include words, phrases, symbols, and designs. These rights also cover music, literature, and other artistic works, as well as discoveries and inventions. Intellectual property rights are a type of intangible property in and of themselves. The word "intellectual property" did not first appear until the 19th century, and it was not until the late 20th century that it became widely accepted throughout much of the world, despite the fact that many of the legal rules governing IP and IPR have developed over decades. In just the first twenty years, the educational landscape of the twenty-first century has seen a number of changes. especially the attention and concern for research ethics and academic honesty. The majority of the patent and copyright types used in the education sector also include utility or model designs and, in certain cases, trade secrets. The best academic innovations can be safeguarded by various patent and copyright regulations, preventing the misuse of one's labour of love. Because they forbid copying another person's work, these patent and copyright rights also indirectly aid in the discovery of new ideas. The contemporary information economy has grown to be centered around intellectual property rights (IPR), which are essential for promoting economic expansion, innovation, and creativity. IPR is especially important in the field of education since it touches on the fundamental tasks of knowledge creation, distribution, and utilization. Since they are the main locations for research and development, educational institutions are greatly impacted by IPR laws and procedures. With an eye toward addressing both the potential and challenges it brings, this study attempts to investigate the significance, ramifications, and application of IPR in the educational sector. However, too strict intellectual property rights laws might make it difficult to obtain knowledge and educational materials, which could impede academic cooperation and the free exchange of ideas that is vital to the growth of education (Benkler, 2006). There is a fine line between preserving intellectual property and guaranteeing that information is accessible, and it calls for thorough evaluation of 45 IJAAR Vol.5 No. 22 practical, ethical, and legal factors. Furthermore, there are particular difficulties in implementing IPR regulations inside educational contexts. To safeguard their inventions and foster an open academic environment, universities and other educational institutions must negotiate the complexity of intellectual property rights (IPR) (Geuna & Rossi, 2011). This entails creating efficient IPR regulations, training academic staff and students on IPR, and cultivating an environment that honors both creativity and open access. For these regulations to be implemented effectively, faculty and students must be aware of and comprehend IPR. Research indicates that comprehensive IPR education is frequently absent from university curricula, which results in IPR misunderstandings and misuse (O'Reilly, 2005). By addressing this gap with focused instructional initiatives, academic communities can become more adept at navigating IPR challenges. Moreover, a comparative examination of international intellectual property rights laws in educational settings uncovers various strategies and their consequences. Reflecting cultural, economic, and legal distinctions, different nations have chosen different approaches to strike a compromise between the need for accessible education and the protection of intellectual property (Drahos, 2010). History of IPR: IPR is not a novel idea. IPR is thought to have first emerged in North Italy during the Renaissance. A statute governing patent protection that gave the owner an exclusive right was published in Venice in 1474. When Johannes Gutenberg created the printing press with interchangeable/movable wooden or metal letters in the year 1440, the copyright was first established. Many nations saw the need to establish legislation governing IPR towards the end of the 19th century. The Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property (1883) and the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works (1886) are the two conventions that serve as the cornerstone of the IPR system globally. Act VI of 1856 was India's first patent-related legislation. The goal was to promote inventions and get innovators to divulge their inventions' secrets. Act XV of 1859, a new piece of legislation, was then introduced to grant exclusive privilege. Types/tools of IPR: The phrase "intellectual property" is typically understood to include the following distinct legal areas - 1. Patents. 2. Trademarks. 3. Copyrights and related rights. 4. Geographical Indications. 5. Industrial Designs. 6. Trade Secrets. 7. Layout Design for Integrated Circuits. 8. Protection of New Plant Variety. There are seven different categories of intellectual property rights in India, including copyright, ISSN – 2347-7075 trademarks, patents, geographical indications, plant varieties, industrial designs and semiconductor integrated circuit layout designs. Objectives:  To Analysis the Importances of IPR in Indian Education.  To Explore the Related Aspects of IPR in Education.  To Evaluate the Current Implementation of IPR Policies in Indian Educational Institutions. Research Questions:  What is the significance of IPR in fostering innovation and creativity within Indian educational institutions?  How are IPR related to Indian educational system?  How are IPR policies currently implemented in Indian educational institutions? Research Methodology: The current study's conceptual discussion approach is composed of analytical and descriptive research methods based on various books, journals, research papers, websites, etc. Importances of IPR: IPRs are crucial to the advancement and development of society. IPRs encourage healthy competition among inventors, which ultimately advances society. They also give incentives to the originator of a certain product. The following are a few importances of IPR:  Students and teachers are encouraged to create new concepts, innovations, and creative works by the protection of intellectual property. IPR makes sure that authors get credit where credit is due and can even result in financial awards, which encourages more creativity.  The importance of IPR in education is multifaceted. On one hand, robust IPR frameworks can incentivize innovation by ensuring that creators and inventors receive recognition and financial rewards for their contributions (Boldrin & Levine, 2008). This, in turn, encourages further research and development, fostering an environment where new ideas and technologies can flourish. For example, the Bayh-Dole Act in the United States has been credited with significantly increasing the commercialization of university research by allowing institutions to retain ownership of inventions made with federal funding (Mowery et al., 2004).  The significance of intellectual property rights escalating Keeping Intellectual Property Rights Safe Technology has increased public awareness of IP Some people and businesses just provide knowledge. Computer consultants, advertising firms, online businesses, and software developers thus solely market brainpower. Additionally protected are domain Saifulla Sardar 46 IJAAR      Vol.5 No. 22 names and moving pictures. Today, more than half of American exports are subject to some kind of intellectual property protection. The speed with which information may be shared on the Internet has made protecting intellectual property more difficult. A company's intellectual property assets are its most precious possessions. Companies must take aggressive action to safeguard these priceless assets against theft or misuse by third parties. Protecting the value of such investments is the goal of the discipline of intellectual property law. The primary goal of intellectual property rights (IPRs) is to encourage and protect the creation, distribution, and sale of new goods and services based on the development and use of innovations, trademarks, designs, creative works, and other intangible assets. The exclusive rights for an inventor's or creator's valuable innovation or production are granted by the intellectual property rights (IPR), which are intangible in nature. In the current era of globalisation, IPR is a key component of international trade and daily life. These rights encourage innovation by providing creators and inventors with recognition and financial rewards, but a lack of understanding of IPR and its ineffective implementation may impede the economic, technological, and appropriate implementation, which is a crucial prerequisite for every country. The current paper discusses a number of IPR concepts, including patents, trademarks, industrial designs, geographic indications, copyright, etc., along with their associated rules, regulations, needs, and roles, particularly in the context of India. The state of India's involvement in IPR-related activities around the world has also been briefly discussed. IPRs are crucial for the free flow of energy to further research and development. Individuals are encouraged to create new things thanks to IPRs. IPRs allow creators to be credited, including artists and inventors. These rules give them the tools and the encouragement to produce fresh works, goods, and services. By defending the rights of artists and innovators, intellectual property rights foster innovation and creativity. Others can use and build upon this shared knowledge to produce newer and/or better products because the use of patents necessitates the disclosure of information that would enable others to duplicate the inventor's finding. IPRs guarantee financial compensation for intellectual property. IPRs guarantee that genuine, original products are readily available. Patents and copyrights are two examples of intellectual property rights that businesses can employ to protect their ISSN – 2347-7075 investments in invention (Shankar Narayanan, 2010).  IPRs may aid in the development of low cost medicines for the poor and the development of alternative energy sources, new products for farmers, and other solutions to global problems. IPRs are essential to promoting economic expansion. In order to keep the economy growing, intellectual property rights must be protected. They promote ethical business practises, which would advance both the economy and society. Maintaining economic growth across all industries and globally depends on the effective enforcement of intellectual property rights.  Strict IPR regulations discourage plagiarism and the unapproved use of other people's work, helping to maintain high standards of academic integrity. Promoting a culture that upholds intellectual property rights encourages moral conduct in educational and scientific endeavors.  Respecting IPR standards improves Indian educational institutions' standing internationally and increases their ability to compete in the global academic market. Robust intellectual property rights safeguards draw highly skilled researchers, instructors, and learners from throughout the globe, establishing a thriving scholarly community. How IPR related to Indian educational system: Understanding intellectual property rights (IPR) is essential to creating a climate that encourages innovation & creativity in the nation. Children in schools are one of the main areas of concentration since it is crucial to foster creativity and the capacity for innovation from a young age. The IP in Education project includes all educational levels, including tertiary and secondary education. The goal of the Intellectual Property in Education Network is to encourage young Europeans to engage responsibly in the digital world while being creative and innovative. Creativity, innovation, entrepreneurship, and a stronger digital skill set are at the core of European economic, cultural, and social prosperity more than ever in the globalised and digitalized 21st century. When the lecturer's lectures' content is sold, offered, exposed for sale or hire, the lecturer's copyright will be violated. During the educational process, lecturers' and tutors' ideas should be protected as intellectual property.  Intensify the interaction and cooperation of the IP in Education network, which consists of national education ministries or authorities, national IP offices, and other education specialists.  Work together with all necessary institutions and bodies of the European Union. Saifulla Sardar 47 IJAAR  Vol.5 No. 22 Enhancing collaborations with text book publishers, teachers' unions, and other pertinent parties.  Encourage the inclusion of the European Key Competencies for Lifelong Learning Related to Intellectual Property in national curricula.  Provide fresh instructional materials for IP for students at all levels.  Investigate the demand for IP knowledge training materials and create them for schools of teacher preparation, universities of applied science, and vocational education and training (VET) facilities.  Create new, digital teacher training resources on intellectual property (IP), as well as specialised teacher training and train-the-trainer workshops, both for in-person and online training.  Keeping in mind the adoption of the EU copyright regulation and the teaching exception, update and promote the copyright FAQs for teachers by Member State.  Distributing digital IP resources for primary through tertiary education in close coordination with network members.  Including IPR courses in the curriculum aids in the understanding of the importance of intellectual property and its legal implications by educators and students alike. Students from different disciplines are encouraged to have a complete understanding of IPR by include themes related to IPR in their studies in engineering, business, law, and the arts, for example.  Intellectual property rights (IPR) safeguard research results from educational institutions, including copyrights and patents, guaranteeing that inventors can profit from their labors. IPR encourages the monetization of research and innovation by facilitating collaborations between academic institutions and business sectors.  Tight IPR regulations deter plagiarism and guarantee that teachers and students create original work while honoring the intellectual contributions of others. Academic institutions cultivate a climate of academic integrity by enforcing rules of behavior that include adherence to IPR principles.  Numerous Indian institutions have set up specialized IPR offices or cells to oversee and safeguard the intellectual property generated on campus. Institutions create thorough IPR policies that specify how to file for patents, copyrights, and trademarks and deal with infringement complaints.  One issue that needs to be addressed by institutions through focused educational activities is the lack of knowledge and comprehension of intellectual property rights Saifulla Sardar ISSN – 2347-7075 (IPR) among educators and students. For IPR to be implemented effectively, professors and staff must be given the tools they need to manage and safeguard intellectual property.  As the only intermediary between owners of protected content and users, librarians play a unique role. For a very long time, these librarians were accustomed to doing nothing but watching while the content was used and disseminated. The repercussions are noticeable in every academic discipline, but libraries are at the top of the hit list since they act as simple content mediators.  A type of E-learning called distance education uses communication and information technology to organise the training process. It makes it possible to access information without having to personally interact with an instructor or mentor and from a distance. Some academics consider distance learning to be a form of advanced training or education. Those who are unable to travel to the major educational facilities can still receive a quality education through distance learning. Some professors and educators contend that online textbooks, tests, video readings, and other forms of distant learning can take the place of traditional classroom instruction. In this case, a teacher who is essential to the educational process may disappear. Implementation of IPR in Indian education system: The legal foundation for intellectual property rights in the Indian context must also be discussed. The following table lists the numerous legislation and the relevant departments with relation to the application of IPR.  Comprehensive IPR policies that specify the steps for filing, maintaining, and safeguarding intellectual property are created by educational institutions. These regulations offer precise instructions on intellectual property ownership, licensing, and commercialization. Legal compliance and consistency are guaranteed when institutional policies are in line with national IPR laws and standards. Institutions frequently make reference to the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) and the Government of India's frameworks.  Numerous academic institutions have set up specialized offices or cells for intellectual property rights, which are in charge of handling such issues. These cells support the registration of copyright, the filing of patents, and the handling of trademark disputes. IPR cells make sure that creators have access to resources by offering support services including legal counsel, patent searches, and help preparing patent applications. 48 IJAAR       Vol.5 No. 22 Students, professors, and staff are taught about the value of intellectual property rights (IPR), its legal implications, and the process of protecting it through regularly scheduled workshops, seminars, and training sessions. Students gain an understanding of the importance of IPR in their areas through the inclusion of IPR subjects in the curriculum. There are new courses in intellectual property management, patent preparation, and IPR legislation. Research projects that have the potential to result in the production of intellectual property are funded and granted grants by institutions. This kind of assistance promotes creativity and the creation of new technology. The commercialization of research outputs is facilitated by partnerships with industry and research organizations. Agreements on income sharing and IPR ownership are frequently included in collaborative ventures. This leads to the conclusion that IPR is now a must for academia. We must comprehend the significance of having integrity and morality. IPR upholds high moral standards and defends our rights. IPR comes in a variety of forms. Researchers and educators must register their intellectual property and safeguard their rights. IPR promotion has been freely started by NEP, NAAC (A&A), UGC (CARE), state government (Maharashtra Public University Act 2019), universities (via Academic and Administrative Audit), and the top colleges. The term "intellectual property rights" (IPR) refers to legal protections for mental works, including inventions, literary and creative productions, as well as signs, names, and pictures used in commerce. IPR in education might include trademarks for educational institutions and their logos, patents for cuttingedge teaching methods, and copyrights for instructional materials like textbooks. While IPR can encourage creativity and innovation in the educational sector, it can also restrict access to information and learning resources. The use of textbooks, course packs, and online resources in education is protected by copyrights, which also protect original literary, musical, and artistic works. The Copyright Act of 1957 governs copyright laws in India. Unauthorised use of copyrighted materials is permitted under the fair use theory of copyright law in some circumstances, such as for criticism, commentary, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research. Innovative teaching technologies like online learning environments, instructional games, and virtual reality tools can all be protected by patents. The Patents Act, 1970, controls patent ISSN – 2347-7075 law in India. When businesses or institutions employ patented technologies without authorization or licence, patent infringement actions may be brought against them in the educational sector.  Trademarks provide protection for names, logos, and symbols used in commerce, including names and logos of educational institutions. India's trademark law is governed by the Trade Marks Act, 1999, which also permits the registration of trademarks for educational institutions' names and logos. When one institution adopts a name or logo that is similar to another institution's, confusing customers, trademark infringement litigation may result in the educational sector. Conclusion: In conclusion, intellectual property rights are crucial to the educational sector because they safeguard cutting-edge teaching methods, educational resources, and institution brands and logos. IPR can encourage innovation and creativity, but it can also restrict access to information and learning resources. The stakeholders in the IPR field need to be properly educated and trained in order to address this issue. Without an interdisciplinary perspective, this is a challenging and complicated task. It is always simpler to say than to do. But it is possible if the universities create the policies and programmes that mix the faculties of economics, management, and law in order to promote effective IP training and for developing new models for Research & Development. This leads to the conclusion that IPR is now a must for academia. We must comprehend the significance of having integrity and morality. IPR upholds high moral standards and defends our rights. IPR comes in a variety of forms. Researchers and educators must register their intellectual property and safeguard their rights. IPR promotion has been freely started by NEP, NAAC (A&A), UGC (CARE), state government (Maharashtra Public University Act 2019), universities (via Academic and Administrative Audit), and the top colleges. As the majority of information exchange in the field of education occurs online, intellectual property rights are a very important rule. The rapid and continual advancements in technology have greatly broadened the scope of intellectual property. Intellectual property is becoming more and more important to the agendas of both governments and businesses as a result of the development of communications and information technology, biotechnology, ecommerce, and a number of other developing industries. In order to improve both the promotion of educational goals and the protection of intellectual property, this research offers insights into the strategic integration of IPR in education. This study underscores the need of establishing a Saifulla Sardar 49 IJAAR Vol.5 No. 22 conducive atmosphere that stimulates creativity and guarantees fair access to information by examining the correlation between intellectual property rights (IPR) and academic establishments. References: 1. Mingaleva, Z., & Mirskikh, I. (2013). The protection of Intellectual property in educational process. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 83, 1059-1062. 2. Starkey, L., Corbett, S., Bondy, A., & Davidson, S. (2010). Intellectual property: what do teachers and students know?, International Journal of Technology and Design Education, 20, 333-344. 3. Lakhan, S., & Khurana, M. (2008). Intellectual property, copyright, and fair use in education. Academic Leadership: The Online Journal, 6(4), 7. 4. E Lakhan, S., & k Khurana, M. (2007). The State of Intellectual Property Education Worldwide. Academic Leadership Journal, 5(2), 49-55. 5. Geuna, A., & Rossi, F. (2011). Changes to university IPR regulations in Europe and the impact on academic patenting. Research Policy, 40(8), 1068-1076. 6. Gillies, M. (2006). The impact of intellectual property rights on the university culture: Research and higher education in the digital environment. International Journal of Cultural Property, 13(3), 341-370. 7. Merges, R. P., Menell, P. S., & Lemley, M. A. (2012). Intellectual property in the new technological age (6th ed.). Wolters Kluwer Law & Business. 8. O'Reilly, D., (2005). Higher education and intellectual property: An analysis of university policies in Europe. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management, 27(2), 187-198. 9. Pénin, J., Hussler, C., & Burger-Helmchen, T. (2011). Academic patenting: How universities and public research organizations are adapting to the new IPR regime. World Patent Information, 33(1), 41-46. 10. Van Overwalle, G. (2012). Patent pools and clearinghouses in the life sciences. In S. Bostyn & K. Schock (Eds.), IP and licensing in the life sciences (pp. 279-311). Springer. 11. Brewer, J. (2007). Creative industries and intellectual property rights. Routledge. 12. Goldstein, P. (2001). International intellectual property law: Cases and materials. Foundation Press. 13. Helfer, L. R., & Austin, G. W. (2011). Human rights and intellectual property: Mapping the global interface. Cambridge University Press. 14. Jaffe, A. B., & Lerner, J. (2004). Innovation and its discontents: How our broken patent system is ISSN – 2347-7075 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. endangering innovation and progress, and what to do about it. Princeton University Press. Landes, W. M., & Posner, R. A. (2003). The economic structure of intellectual property law. Harvard University Press. Murray, F., & Stern, S. (2007). Do formal intellectual property rights hinder the free flow of scientific knowledge? An empirical test of the anti-Commons hypothesis. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 63(4), 648-687. Sampat, B. N. (2006). Patenting and US academic research in the 20th century: The world before and after Bayh-Dole. Research Policy, 35(6), 772-789. www.wikipedia.com http://www.naac.gov.in/ https://ipindia.gov.in/policy-pages.htm https://www.ugc.ac.in/UGC_Regulations.aspx https://www.ugc.ac.in/page/OtherPublications.aspx https://www.wipo.int/about-ip/en/ Saifulla Sardar 50