Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Geotechnical characterisation of Busan clay

2012, KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering

In the Nakdong River delta, the depositional environment is slightly different in every locality. An attempt was made to conduct a geotechnical characterization of clay in the floodplain of the delta area, where a series of field and laboratory tests was executed at five sites. The results indicate that variations in the slope of cone resistance change with depth are utilized to stratify the deposits and to extend a paleoenvironmental profile that has been investigated at a neighboring site. Some of the index properties and the compression index appear to correlate with the depositional environment, so that they have a well-defined trend with depth irrespective of location and empirical formulas may be developed between them. However, on the top 10 m layer deposited during regression, several properties are different in the tested sites. The ratio of the field vane strength to the effective overburden stress shows a poor correlation with water content, indicating no relationship with the plasticity index. The in-situ void index I v0 shows that clays of the Tidal Flat (TF) and Inner Shelf (IS) units are more structured than other normally consolidated clays, whereas that of the Shallow Marine (SM) unit, which is overconsolidated, is not. The sensitivity (S t), ranging from 5 to 9 at a location, vary in a manner similar to a well-defined trend of the properties. Based on the I v0 , recompression, and C c-e 0-S t relation, the clay is moderately or highly structured but weakly bonded, where C c is compression index and e 0 is initial void ratio.

KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering (2012) 16(3):341-350 DOI 10.1007/s12205-012-1433-8 Geotechnical Engineering www.springer.com/12205 Geotechnical Characterisation of Busan Clay Sung Gyo Chung*, Choon Kil Ryu**, Se Chan Min***, Jung Man Lee****, Yang Pyo Hong*****, and Enkhtur Odgerel****** Received December 17, 2010/Revised 1st: April 5, 2011, 2nd: May 8, 2011/Accepted June 14, 2011 ··································································································································································································································· Abstract In the Nakdong River delta, the depositional environment is slightly different in every locality. An attempt was made to conduct a geotechnical characterization of clay in the floodplain of the delta area, where a series of field and laboratory tests was executed at five sites. The results indicate that variations in the slope of cone resistance change with depth are utilized to stratify the deposits and to extend a paleoenvironmental profile that has been investigated at a neighboring site. Some of the index properties and the compression index appear to correlate with the depositional environment, so that they have a well-defined trend with depth irrespective of location and empirical formulas may be developed between them. However, on the top 10 m layer deposited during regression, several properties are different in the tested sites. The ratio of the field vane strength to the effective overburden stress shows a poor correlation with water content, indicating no relationship with the plasticity index. The in-situ void index Iv0 shows that clays of the Tidal Flat (TF) and Inner Shelf (IS) units are more structured than other normally consolidated clays, whereas that of the Shallow Marine (SM) unit, which is overconsolidated, is not. The sensitivity (St), ranging from 5 to 9 at a location, vary in a manner similar to a well-defined trend of the properties. Based on the Iv0, recompression, and Cc-e0-St relation, the clay is moderately or highly structured but weakly bonded, where Cc is compression index and e0 is initial void ratio. Keywords: clay, geology, geotechnical properties, structure, correlation ··································································································································································································································· 1. Introduction A thick clay deposit unusually covers the Nakdong River delta, which lies west of Busan City in Korea. The clay, which is called Busan (or Pusan) clay, sometimes reaches a maximum of 70 m thick. Since the early 1990s, a number of ground investigations have been carried out based on a routine local practice for several huge projects such as a new port, industrial and residential complexes, and others. Such investigations were extremely insufficient to clarify the geotechnical characteristics even in a limited area (Chung et al., 2002b, 2003). This resulted in the highly underestimation of the settlement (Chung, 1999) and failure of the breakwater (Chung et al., 2006b), which are typical examples of unacceptable evaluations of the geotechnical properties in the area. Thereafter, a comprehensive investigation was conducted, which involved improving sampling techniques, geological investigation, and others. Particularly, geological and geographical investigations were carried out to better understand the variations in depositional history in the delta (Chung et al., 2002c, 2003; Ryu et al., 2005). However, most of the investigations were largely performed along the coastlines of the delta (Chung et al., 2005, 2006a, 2007, 2010). Thus, to evaluate the effects of different depositional environments in the localities, there is a need to conduct such investigations exclusively in as many locations as possible in the delta area and to correlate between the geological and the geotechnical characteristics. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the geological and geotechnical characteristics of the clay as well as their correlation in the floodplain of the delta area. To achieve this aim, a comprehensive geotechnical investigation is conducted at five sites in the area, where there is a plan to build a distribution industry complex. The investigation includes an advanced sampling technique, field tests such as CPT and vane shear tests, and laboratory tests. The stratification is carried out using the CPT result and is also utilized to extend the paleoenvironmental profile which has been investigated at a neighboring site (Ryu et al., 2005). Variations in the index properties of the sites are used to determine the relationship with the depositional environment, and the level of structure is evaluated on the clay. The compress- *Member, Professor, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Dong-A University, Busan 604-714, Korea (Corresponding Author, E-mail: [email protected]) **Researcher, National Research Laboratory for Soft Ground, Dong-A University, Busan 604-714, Korea (E-mail: [email protected]) ***Member, Design Engineer, Civil Engineering Department, KORPEC, Seoul 100-032, Korea (E-mail: [email protected]) ****Member, Ph.D. Student, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Dong-A University, Busan 604-714, Korea (E-mail: [email protected]) *****Member, Civil Engineer, Keangnam Enterprises, Co., Ltd., Hai Doung Province 34000, Vietnam (E-mail: [email protected]) ******Lecturer, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Mongolian University of Science and Technology, Ulaanbaatar 210-646, Mongolia (E-mail: [email protected]) − 341 − Sung Gyo Chung, Choon Kil Ryu, Se Chan Min, Jung Man Lee, Yang Pyo Hong, and Enkhtur Odgerel ibility and undrained shear strength are also evaluated considering the effect of geological history. Moreover, an attempt is made to correlate between the geotechnical properties and to discuss the structure of the clay. 2. Geological Characteristics 2.1 Testing Sites The Nakdong River delta, which lies west of Busan City and its vicinities, is covered with very thick clay that sometime reaches a maximum thickness of 70 m. The deltaic area is divided into four categories (upper and lower delta plains, floodplain, and delta-front or pro-delta) according to physiography (Kwon 1973; Kim 1988), as shown in Fig. 1. Tested sites are situated in the floodplain (i.e., marginal basin) which is in the west and middle of the plain. The locations from DIS-1 to DIS-5 are for field soil tests and sampling, while location SB-14 is for geological investigation which has been carried out by Ryu et al. (2005). 2.2 Depositional Environment Investigated at SB-14 Late Quaternary paleoenvironmental changes at several locations in the floodplain have been investigated by Ryu (2002). A representative result obtained at SB-14 is summarized as shown in Fig. 2, where the solid circles indicate the results of radiocarbon dating (Ryu et al., 2005). The Late Quaternary deposits at the location consist of four sedimentary units in ascending order: Unit I, II, III, and IV; they have been governed by the sea-level change since the last interglacial period. Unit I, which unconformably overlies the Cretaceous basement rocks, is composed of sandy gravel and sand deposited in a Fluvial Channel (FC) before the first marine transgression. Unit II is composed of stiff massive mud, which is deposited in the Shallow Marine (SM) during the last interglacial period (probably MIS 5). In the upper part, the development of the fissures coated with oxidized materials is evidence of subaerial exposure, which indicates erosional contact with the upper Unit III. Unit III is made up of Fig. 1. Testing Locations in the Marginal Basin Fig. 2. Stratigraphy and Depositional Units with Sediment Accumulation Curve (Ryu et al., 2005) soft massive mud and soft, shelly massive mud that have been formed in a Tidal Flat (TF) and an Inner Shelf (IS), respectively, since the Holocene transgression (about 9,000 yr BP). Unit IV consists of soft, shell-bedded mud and yellowish sandy mud deposited in the delta environments during the regression (after about 5,000 yr BP). The lower shell-bedded mud is deposited in a TF, and the upper sandy mud is deposited in the floodplain corresponding to the present site of the delta. 2.3 Interpretation of the Depositional Environment Based on CPT An attempt was made to extend the depositional environment investigated at SB-14 to those at the five tested sites. To achieve this, CPT profiles (qc and u2) were extensively utilized as one of most effective tools (Powell and Quarterman 1995; Plant et al., 1998; Chung et al., 2003, 2005). The CPT apparatus used for this study was a cone of 60o apex angle with a friction sleeve of 15 cm2 and a porous element mounted immediately behind the cone (u2). The apparatus was calibrated periodically, and its porous element was saturated using glycerin and water. The penetration rate was 20 mm/s. Figure 3 shows the combined profiles of cone resistance (qc) and pore pressure (u2) for the locations. Note that the values of qc greater than 2.0 MPa were truncated to enlarge the variations in the clay. The variations in qc and u2 in the clay appeared similar to each other, indicating different distributed depths and thicknesses of sand layers. An unusually thick and dense sand layer (8 − 342 − KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering