Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Women in Film and TV productions

2015

Women in Film Productions A closer look at women in film, as directors or as characters, provides a basic understanding of the situation of a society. Within this topic one is able to develop a much greater comprehension of if and how gender equality is represented and understood, through simple application of common sense. Gender role models are constructions, made common and perpetuated by media productions. Movies are reflecting cultural and social relationships in a society, and subsequently have an influence on society as well. Audience, the often-stressed unknown being, also includes women. In cinemas within some particular age groups, women are even the majority. We, the women, are an integral part of society; without us there would be neither society nor civilization. This is truism, but astonishingly enough it nevertheless has to be mention from time to time again. Contemporary movies and TV productions are mostly dominated by male producers, directors, commissioning editors and heads of program, yet tell not only stories from that of a male perspective. Even character design is coined by a male view of the world; among the women represented, female characters are frequently designed in a way that gives an overall impression that women would be unable to act as independent human beings. They could be neither able to act as a director nor as female characters embedded in a story that do more than acting as a secretary, nurse, housewife, shop keeper or sex worker. Those characters often lack a name or intelligent dialogue lines, and can be exploited or tortured and murdered more easily than male characters. Productions like FORBYDELSEN (Dk 2007-2012) or BORGEN (Dk 2010-2013), ARNE DAHL (1 st season, S 2011) still are the exception, not a standard. Having analyzed many movies and TV productions produced during the last decades, one can say about female characters depicted in (especially but not limited to) German productions, that if they are part of the action, they are designed as either bad mothers or cold 'career women'. In other words, female characters can be characterized as that of the 'Weak Woman' or 'Strong Woman'. 'Strong woman' is a term representing the male glance towards women and inheriting dominant conditions of power and the structure of society. This term is corresponding to 'a man from the boys' and is directing towards a peculiarity, which throughout that ironic approach is pointing at a nearly unattainable exception. This is expressing that with either a "Man From the Boys" or a "Strong Woman' a traditional married life will be impossible. Instead, the term is expressing that those kinds of characters are demanding a specific hierarchy and personal freedom. 'Strong Women' in film and TV productions-with the exception of the aforementioned productions-usually have to fail miserably. In terms of dramatic action those women are infringing upon the implicit engraved rules of the society, which in the case of the western German tradition, means women should act firstly as 'good' wives and mothers. Here one can see the long shadow of the gender role models developed and set with that propaganda machinery during 'Third Reich'

View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Bournemouth University Research Online Women  in  Film  Productions     A  closer  look  at  women  in  film,  as  directors  or  as  characters,  provides  a  basic   understanding  of  the  situation  of  a  society.  Within  this  topic  one  is  able  to  develop  a   much  greater  comprehension  of  if  and  how  gender  equality  is  represented  and   understood,  through  simple  application  of  common  sense.  Gender  role  models  are   constructions,  made  common  and  perpetuated  by  media  productions.     Movies  are  reflecting  cultural  and  social  relationships  in  a  society,  and  subsequently   have  an  influence  on  society  as  well.      Audience,  the  often-­‐stressed  unknown  being,   also  includes  women.  In  cinemas  within  some  particular  age  groups,  women  are   even  the  majority.  We,  the  women,  are  an  integral  part  of  society;  without  us  there   would  be  neither  society  nor  civilization.  This  is  truism,  but  astonishingly  enough  it   nevertheless  has  to  be  mention  from  time  to  time  again.     Contemporary  movies  and  TV  productions  are  mostly  dominated  by  male  producers,   directors,  commissioning  editors  and  heads  of  program,  yet  tell  not  only  stories  from   that  of  a  male  perspective.  Even  character  design  is  coined  by  a  male  view  of  the   world;  among  the  women  represented,  female  characters  are  frequently  designed  in   a  way  that  gives  an  overall  impression  that  women  would  be  unable  to  act  as   independent  human  beings.  They  could  be  neither  able  to  act  as  a  director  nor  as   female  characters  embedded  in  a  story  that  do  more  than  acting  as  a  secretary,   nurse,  housewife,  shop  keeper  or  sex  worker.  Those  characters  often  lack  a  name  or   intelligent  dialogue  lines,  and  can  be  exploited  or  tortured  and  murdered  more  easily   than  male  characters.  Productions  like  FORBYDELSEN  (Dk  2007-­‐2012)  or  BORGEN  (Dk   2010-­‐2013),  ARNE  DAHL  (1st  season,  S  2011)  still  are  the  exception,  not  a  standard.     Having  analyzed  many  movies  and  TV  productions  produced  during  the  last  decades,   one  can  say  about  female  characters  depicted  in  (especially  but  not  limited  to)   German  productions,  that  if  they  are  part  of  the  action,  they  are  designed  as  either   bad  mothers  or  cold  ‘career  women’.  In  other  words,  female  characters  can  be   characterized  as  that  of  the  ‘Weak  Woman’  or  ‘Strong  Woman’.     ‘Strong  woman’  is  a  term  representing  the  male  glance  towards  women  and   inheriting  dominant  conditions  of  power  and  the  structure  of  society.  This  term  is   corresponding  to  ‘a  man  from  the  boys’  and  is  directing  towards  a  peculiarity,  which   throughout  that  ironic  approach  is  pointing  at  a  nearly  unattainable  exception.  This   is  expressing  that  with  either  a  “Man  From  the  Boys”  or  a  “Strong  Woman’  a   traditional  married  life  will  be  impossible.  Instead,  the  term  is  expressing  that  those   kinds  of  characters  are  demanding  a  specific  hierarchy  and  personal  freedom.     ‘Strong  Women’  in  film  and  TV  productions-­‐  with  the  exception  of  the   aforementioned  productions-­‐  usually  have  to  fail  miserably.  In  terms  of  dramatic   action  those  women  are  infringing  upon  the  implicit  engraved  rules  of  the  society,   which  in  the  case  of  the  western  German  tradition,  means  women  should  act  firstly   as  ‘good’  wives  and  mothers.  Here  one  can  see  the  long  shadow  of  the  gender  role   models  developed  and  set  with  that  propaganda  machinery  during  ‘Third  Reich’   ©  Kerstin  Stutterheim    published  at  Glaz,  www.kino-­‐glaz.de,  19.11.2015   continued  with  post-­‐war  cinema  made  in  West  Germany.  In  terms  of  psychology  one   can  say  that  those  were  ‘priming’  the  view  and  opinions  of  the  audience,  setting  up   anchors  (Kahneman  2012)  for  an  understanding  of  society  and  their  codes.  Within   the  hierarchy  of  such  characters,  female  characters  were  almost  always  narrated  out   of  a  male  position.  Thus,  they  have  little  to  no  influence  on  the  narrated  action.  If  it   is  a  female  character  indulged  to  be  the  protagonist,  her  action  is  shown  as  personal,   fleshly  or  erotically  motivated,  not  because  of  a  societal  or  political  motivation  or   longing  of  the  character.       One  can  see  an  example  of  this  given  in  BARABARA  (D  2012,  Petzold),  the  adaptation  of   DIE  FLUCHT  (DDR  1977,  Gräf).  In  the  DEFA  movie  the  main  character,  a  male  doctor,  is   frustrated  about  the  political  and  economic  circumstances  hindering  his  research,   causing  him  to  flee  GDR  to  the  west;  in  BARABARA  the  female  doctor  wants  to  go  to   the  West  to  live  with  her  love  or  lover,  whom  she  is  meeting  for  short  events  to  have   sex  together  in  the  wood  or  a  hotel  while  he  is  crossing  GDR  for  business  trips,   causing  her  to  give  up  her  exceptionally  good  position  at  one  of  the  leading  research   hospitals,  Another  example  is  KRIEGERIN  (D  2011,  Wnendt),  like  BARABARA,  premiered   at  the  Berlinale  Film  Festival.  Within  the  action  the  young,  blonde  female  main   character,  called  Marisa,  (given  by  Alina  Levshin)  is  shown  as  driven  into  the  group  of   Neo-­‐Nazis  by  her  life  situation  and  circumstances–her  mother  unable  to  support  her,   a  bad  job,  a  region  undeveloped  and  of  no  hope  for  the  young  generation.  As  a  result   of  her  one  and  only  human  action  (helping  the  illegal  migrant  to  hide)  she  became   sacrificed  at  the  end.  Independent  decisions  made  by  a  female  character  ignoring   the  rules  of  the  group  she  belongs  to  were  not  endured.  The  body  of  the  death   Marisa  is  shown  aesthetically  exaggerated,  in  sense  of  ‘Edelkitsch’  (Friedländer,   1999)     This  dramaturgical  approach  to  analyze  the  significance  of  the  character  for  the   action  going  on,  is  within  sociology  defined  as  Agency.  Although  this  term  as  such   first  of  all  just  means  someone  is  able  to  decide  independently  (Holland,  1998)  and   still  not  the  active  influence  of  events  happening  because  of  a  person  character   acting  in  a  specific  way,  that  term  already  is  been  used  to  discuss  characters,   especially  female  ones,  in  media  productions.  But  to  establish  modern  /   contemporary  female  characters  to  show  them  as  independently  deciding  and  acting   is  a  progress,  but  is  not  enough.  Many  films  representing  female  characters  with   some  kind  of  ‘Agency’,  will  pass  as  well  the  so  called  ‘Bechdel  Test’  or  other  of  these   new  measurements,  but  at  the  same  time  nevertheless  stick  to  conservative  role   models.  To  change  the  ways  of  representing  women  in  media  productions  it  is   necessary  to  have  many  more  female  writers  and  directors,  who  should  in  numbers   correspond  to  the  percentage  of  women  in  society  and  the  audience.  It  is  time  to   change  the  representation  of  both  genders  in  media  productions  to  give  both  of   them  a  better  perspective  in  a  civilized  world  as  well.           That  this  is  possible  without  losing  audience  and  attraction  is  obvious  through   mentioning  productions  like  the  TV  series  I  mentioned  above  already  –  BORGEN,   FORBYDELSEN,  ARNE  DAHL  –  as  well  as  HATUFIM  (ISR  2009-­‐2012,  Raff).  Within  these   productions  characters  are  interacting  on  eyelevel,  especially  within  the   ©  Kerstin  Stutterheim    published  at  Glaz,  www.kino-­‐glaz.de,  19.11.2015   dramaturgical  structure.  Action,  hopes,  dreams  and  decisions  of  female  characters   are  of  the  same  weight  and  influence  for  the  action  going  on  as  those  of  the  male   characters.  Their  decisions  and  actions  are  not  body  directed  or  only  emotion  based-­‐   they  are  as  clear  and  rational  as  those  of  their  male  counterparts.       Of  course,  cinema  productions  written  and  directed  by  women  were  and  are   successful,  like  f.e.  movies  by  Agnès  Varda,  Agnieszka  Holland,  Deepa  Mehta,  Sally   Potter,  Małgośka  Szumowska,  Lucrecia  Martel,  Claire  Denis,  Jane  Campion,  Nora   Ephron,  Kathryn  Bigelow,  Sofia  Coppola,  Sussane  Bier,  Al  Mansour  Khairiya,  El   Deghedy,  Shafik  Viola  or  Natalya  Bondarchuk,  Ana  Carolina,  Věra  Chytilová  to  name   just  few  of  the  international  well  known  directors.  Based  in  socio-­‐cultural  structures   in  the  cinema  business  movies  directed  by  women  were  differently  discussed,   distributed  and  reviewed  than  those  directed  by  their  male  colleagues.  A  closer  look   and  analysis  shows  that  female  directors  more  often  tend  to  open  dramaturgical   forms  and  less  often  tell  classical  stories  of  a  hero.  Thus,  a  more  open  minded   reception  is  needed  to  give  them  same  respect  as  traditional  male  narrated  movies.       To  support  the  discussion  and  critical  thinking  of  representation  of  gender  in  Film   and  TV  productions  of  today  we  will  add  here  from  time  to  time  short  reflections  on   randomly  selected  examples  we  came  across.     One  of  those  will  be  the  BBC  production  FROM  DARKNESs  (BBC  2015)  written  by  Katie   Baxendale  and  directed  by  Dominic  Leclerc  or  the  2nd  season  of  ARNE  DAHL  (S  2015).     Kerstin  D.  Stutterheim,  November  2015     Literaturverzeichnis     FRIEDLÄNDER,  S.  1999.  Kitsch  und  Tod:  der  Widerschein  des  Nazismus,  Frankfurt   am  Main,  Fischer-­‐Taschenbuch-­‐Verl.   HOLLAND,  D.  C.  1998.  Identity  and  agency  in  cultural  worlds,  Cambridge,  Mass.,   Harvard  University  Press.     ©  Kerstin  Stutterheim    published  at  Glaz,  www.kino-­‐glaz.de,  19.11.2015