zyx
Taurine’s role
in clinical
practice
INTRODUCTION
zyxwvut
zyxwvutsrqp
P.D. Pion* and M. D. Kittlesont
Taurine (2-aminoethane sulphonic acid) is a
sulphur containing amino acid first isolated from
ox bile (Tiedemann and Gmelin 1827). Taurine
has been frequently studied in animals, and is
seldom encountered in plants. It is not a constituent of proteins. It is present in relatively
high (mmol) concentrations dissolved in the
cytosolic fluid of cells (Jacobsen and Smith
zyxwvutsrq
zyxwvutsrqpo
School of Veterinary Medicine, Departments of Physiological
Sciences* and Medicine,t University of California, Davis,
California 95616,USA
Journal of Small Animal Practice (1990)31,510-518
ABSTRACT
Dilated cardiomyopathy has been recognised
as a significant heart disease and cause of death
in pet cats in the United States. The cause of
dilated cardiomyopathy which was unknown
and the prognosis grave. An association between
low plasma taurine concentrations and dilated
cardiomyopathy was established. Daily administration of taurine (250-1000 mg) orally increased
plasma taurine concentrations and reversed the
clinical signs. It was previously thought that cats
became taurine deficient when fed commercial
dog food or unbalanced home-cooked diets. We
found a high association between the type of diet
fed, plasma taurine concentrations and the incidence of myocardial failure and feline central
retinal regeneration. Many commercial cat foods
were found to cause taurine depletion associated
with myocardial failure or central retinal degeneration. It is now established that taurine deficiency is a major cause of myocardial failure in
cats and that modification of commercial cat
food formulations with regard to taurine content
has resulted in a dramatic decrease in the
incidence of dilated cardiomyopathy in cats in
the United States.
1968).
Taurine is generally associated with excitable
tissues. Tissues with the highest taurine concentration include the heart, retina, central nervous
system and skeletal muscle (Sturman and others
1986, Huxtable and others 1979). Taurine is also
present in high concentrations in leucocytes and
platelets (Hino 1956, Nour-Eldin and Wilkinson
1955, Laidlaw and others 1987). The presence of
taurine in numerous cell types in most animal
species has been accepted as circumstantial evidence that taurine serves a vital role in animal
biology (Jacobsen and Smith 1968). However,
despite its ubiquitous nature, taurine’s biological
function is not well understood.
Areas of investigation which have received significant attention from researchers interested in
taurine’s biological function include osmoregulation (Thurston and others 1981, Trachtman and
others 1989), neuromodulation (Kuriyama 1980),
modulation of transmembrane ion fluxes (Lombardini 1985) and intracellular calcium concentration (Lombardini 1985, Huxtable 1987,
Franconi and others 1982), interactions with
insulin (Maturo and Kulakowski 1987) and inactivation of free radicals (Wright and others 1986).
Central to these investigations is a relationship
between taurine and biological membranes.
There are several excellent reviews of taurine’s
biological role (Jacobsen and Smith 1968, Chesney
1985, Wright and others 1986, Huxtable 1989).
In this paper we emphasise areas which are or
may be significant to clinical veterinary practice.
Particular emphasis is placed on what we know
about the relationship between taurine and dilated
cardiomyopathy in the cat. (See the paper by Morris and others, also in this issue, for coverage of
taurine’s role in nutrition and biology function.)
TAURINE IN CLINICAL
PRACTICE
This paper was presented at the Waltham symposium number
13,1989
510
Ophthalmology, theriogenology, neurology, cardiology and possibly immunology are clinical
fields in which taurine is relevant to veterinary
practice. Taurine may also find a role in the management of feline diabetes.
zy
zyxwv
Taurine's role in clinical practice
TAURINE AND THE EYE
0
II
I -
Taurine is the predominant amino acid in the
retina. It is highly concentrated in the photoreceptor cells of the outer nuclear layer. It is not
surprising that the first and best defined clinical
role for taurine in practice was its relationship to
the development of feline central retinal degeneration (FCRD). Many papers describe the lesion in
practice (Bellhorn and others 1974, Ricketts
1983), but it was Hayes and others (1975a) who
first made the association between FCRD and
taurine deficiency. Feline central retinal degeneration appears as bilateral symmetric hyper-reflective lesions of the fundus, dorsotemporal to the
optic disc (Fig 1).Lesions vary in size and shape
from pin-point to an ellipsoid extending in a
band from the temporal fundus across the top of
the disc to the nasal fundus. Electroretinographic
studies demonstrate diffuse cone dysfunction
progressing to a generalised disorder affecting the
rods and cones. Histologically, there is degeneration of the retinal layers or full thickness atrophy
of the area centralis (Hayes and others 1975a,
1975b). In most clinical cases, the diagnosis of
FCRD has probably been an incidental finding
during a fundic examination. FCRD usually
causes insignificant vision loss but can result in
blindness.
Although cats with FCRD should be tested for
concurrent taurine deficiency, the presence of
this lesion is not proof that a cat is presently taurine deficient: it may only be an indication that
the cat has been at some time in the past.
Contrary to what most veterinarians have been
taught, FCRD and taurine deficiency are not
zy
zyx
-
Taur ine
FIG 2. The structure of taurine (after Huxtable and Sebring
1986)
primarily the result of negligent owners feeding
their cats dog food or home formulated diets.
Many cats with this lesion have developed taurine deficiency while eating commercial cat
foods.
REPRODUCTION
The number of reproductive problems experienced in catteries, or seen in clinical practice,
related to taurine deficiency is unknown. However, there is experimental evidence suggesting
that taurine deficient queens have low fecundity
(Sturman and others 1986, Rogers and Morris
unpublished). These observations should be
directly applicable to clinical reproductive problems. The nature of the low fecundity, whether it
is associated with fertilisation, implantation, or
early or late abortion, is being investigated.
NEUROLOGY
In mammals, taurine is present in high concentration in the central nervous system. It is
actively transported into cells in the brain (Lombardini 1978) and it may be necessary for brain
development (Sturman 1986). Taurine has been
thought of more as a neuromodulator than a
classical neurotransmitter because specific post
synaptic receptors for taurine have not been
identified. As demonstrated in animal models of
epilepsy (Mutani and others 1978, van Gelder
1983), taurine may be an effective anticonvulsant
agent in some human (Takahashi and Nakane
1978) and feline (van Gelder and others 1977,
Tanizawa and others 1986) seizure patients.
Taurine is a small (MW 125.1), zwitterionic
(Fig 2), poorly diffusible compound and is thus a
potent osmotic agent. Its osmoregulatory role is
well defined in marine animals. Some invertebrates and fish utilise it for balancing the osmotic
pressure of their cells with the extracellular
environment, as the concentration of salts change
in the surrounding water (Jacobsen and Smith
1968). That this function may be important in
mammals is illustrated by the finding that the
taurine concentration in the heart of iatrogenically hypernatraemic mice is elevated to a degree
consistent with the additional extracellular
z
zyxwvut
FIG 1 . Fundic photograph taken from a patient with dilated
cardiomyopathy. The characteristic hyper-reflective lesion of
feline central retinal degeneration is easily visualised
511
zyxwvutsrqp
zyxwvutsrqpo
P. D.PION AND M. D.KITTLESON
osmotic load induced by the hypernatraemia
(Thurston and others 1981). A recent study has
strengthened arguments that cerebral taurine
concentration in cats may be a significant factor
in maintaining normal cerebral hydration and
volume during periods of osmotic stress (Trachtman and others 1988). Taurine may be one of the
idiosmolar compounds which protect the brain
of diabetic patients against the hyperosmolar
effects of hyperglycemia [Chesney 1985).
IMMUNOLOGY
Lymphocyte and neutrophil function may be
suboptimal in taurine deficient animals
(Schuller-Levis and Sturman 1989). In addition,
interactions between taurine [or its precursor,
hypotaurine) with free radicals may be important
in the modulation of immunological defense
mechanisms, Oxidative processes involving free
radicals are utilised by neutrophils to defend
against microbial invasion and may play an
equally self-destructive role in immune mediated
diseases, such as systemic lupus erythematosis.
Taurine is found in high concentration in neutrophils (Laidlow and others 1987). Taurine
(Wright and others 1985) and hypotaurine (Fellman and Roth 1985) react with, and inactivate
free radicals similar to those synthesised by neutrophils. It is not unreasonable to hypothesise
that taurine may protect the cell and organism
from these potentially self-destructive reactions
[Wright and others 1986).
TAURINE AND DIABETES
Taurine has metabolic effects and may interact
with, or be synergistic with, insulin. Like insulin,
taurine induces hypoglycaemia and stimulates
glycolysis and glycogen synthesis (Maturo and
Kulakowski 1987). The clinical implication of
these findings with respect to the diabetic cat are
presently under investigation.
TAURINE AND THE HEART
In 1987 we reported that taurine deficiency is
the underlying cause of most cases of feline
dilated (congestive) cardiomyopathy (Pion and
others 1987). The mechanism[s) underlying the
effects of taurine on the heart are unknown. All
of the possible mechanisms outlined above
deserve consideration.
There is a large body of literature that preceded
OUT findings which make the association between
taurine deficiency and myocardial failure in cats
more a result of past predictions than a novel
finding [Huxtable and Sebring 1983). Taurine is
512
present in high concentration in the heart. This
high concentration (100-250 times that found in
plasma) is maintained by active transport processes which consume energy and are stimulated
by D-adrenergic stimulation (Azari and Huxtable
1980). Teleologically it makes little sense that
mechanisms for concentrating and maintaining a
high intracellular myocardial taurine concentration would have evolved had it not been advantageous, If the cat with dilated cardiomyopathy
secondary to taurine deficiency illustrates what
would happen to any mammal with inadequate
myocardial taurine concentration, then the
advantages of these concentrating mechanisms is
obvious.
Prior clinically applicable findings include the
effects of taurine on arrhythmias induced by high
doses of cardiac glycosides and epinephrine.
(Read and Welty 1963, Hinton and others 1975,
Huxtable and Sebring 1983). Humans exhibiting
congestive heart failure (Huxtable and Bressler
1974) and animals with induced heart failure
(Newman and others 1977) have increased
myocardial taurine concentration. Administration of taurine to humans with valvular heart disease is reported to result in clinical improvement
(Azuma and others 1982). Rabbits with induced
aortic regurgitation survived longer when taurine
was added to their water, compared to animals
with similar valvular lesions which did not
receive taurine (Takihara and others 1986). These
findings among others have led investigators to
hypothesise that taurine has an essential function
in the heart. However, previous attempts to
demonstrate significant decreases in mechanical
myocardial function in taurine depleted animals
have not succeeded (Mozaffari and others 1986).
This may be explained by the fact that previous
trials have utilised species which do not have
dietary requirements for taurine. Thus, the
results of previous attempts are probably not
unexpected or incongruous with our findings. A
recent report proposes a similar finding in silver
foxes (Moise and others 1989).
TAURINE DEFICIENCY
MYOCARDIAL FAILURE
zyxwv
The first cat identified as having taurine
deficiency in conjunction with dilated cardiomyopathy was presented with posterior paresis
associated with an aortic thromboernbolus. It was
an eight-year-old male castrated domestic shorthaired cat. The owner chose to actively pursue
therapy for the cat even though it had dilated
cardiomyopathy, a condition in the majority of
cases incurable and fatal within days to months.
Blood flow to the legs was restored after one
day of thrombolytic therapy (Pion 1988) but
zyxw
zy
Tourine3 role in clinical practice
vided this history and asked whether the dilated
cardiomyopathy or clot might be related to the
taurine deficiency? This question, previously
published data relating to taurine's effects on the
heart and the lack of any effective therapy for
this devastating disease, stimulated our interest
enough to begin examining the eyes and blood of
all cats with dilated cardiomyopathy.
Three more cases of dilated cardiomyopathy
were presented. All three had FCRD, low plasma
taurine concentration, and were eating similar
commercial diets. We therefore designed a set of
studies to answer three questions: (1) is plasma
taurine concentration decreased in all or most
cats with dilated cardiomyopathy; (2) would supplementing affected cats with oral taurine be beneficial and (3) would depleting cats of taurine
cause dilated cardiomyopathy?
The first and second questions were answered
with the cooperation of many veterinarians who
referred cats with dilated cardiomyopathy to our
clinic and cat owners who agreed to allow us to
attempt treatment with taurine. As we reported
(Pion and others 1987), all cases of feline dilated
cardiomyopathy diagnosed in our hospital since
December 1986 have had low plasma taurine
concentration and most cases that we treated
with taurine recovered. Not only have they
recovered to live more comfortably, but surprisingly the function of the heart muscle and the
cats' clinical appearance actually returned to normal (Figs 3, 4,5). This was previously thought to
be impossible. Most cardiologists believed that in
the majority of cases, dilated cardiomyopathy
in cats was an irreversible disease process.
Previously there had been anecdotal reports of
cats with dilated cardiomyopathy resolving
spontaneously but these cases were certainly the
zyxwvutsrqpon
zyxwvutsrq
zyxwvutsrqp
FIG 3. M-mode echocardiogram from a cat with dilated cardiomyopathy treated with taurine. (A) First examination. fB]
Ten weeks after beginning taurine therapy. The ultrasound
beam is passing through (top to bottom] the right ventricular
wall, right ventricular cavity, interventricular septum, left
ventricular cavity (chamber with labels], and left ventricular
wall. EDD, end-diastolic diameter; ESD, end-systolic diameter. [Used with permission, P. D. Pion and others (1987).
Copyright 1987 AAAS]
unfortunately the cat died two days later from
the heart disease.
One year earlier, the owner had been told that
the cat had feline central retinal degeneration
(FCRD). The clinician was surprised to learn that
it was eating a popular commercial cat food, as it
was generally believed that cats only get low taurine and FCRD from eating dog food or home
cooked diets. The plasma taurine concentration
measured in the plasma was 10 to 20 per cent of
normal. The reason for this deficit was unknown
and no therapy was prescribed. The owner pro-
--
40
25
I
ESC
EDD
35
20
30
26
15
15 -
zyxwv
zyxwvutsrqponmlkjih
E
E
E
E
10
L
w
10
20
15
I !
10
5 -
5
6
zyxwvutsrqp
0
0
1
2
3
PERIOD
4
5
0
0
1
2
3
4
5
PERIOD
FIG 4. Mean f SEM of (left to right] end-diastolic diameter (EDD], end-systolic diameter (ESD], and shortening fraction (SF,
defined as: [EDD-ESDl/EDD) for 15 taurine-supplemented cats with dilated cardiomyopathy. Period 0 (PO), date of presentation;
PI, 1-2 weeks after presentation; P2, 3-4 weeks; P3, 5-6weeks: P4, 7-8 weeks: P5,9-12weeks. The horizontal dotted lines represent the upper (EDD and ESD) and lower (SFI limits of clinical normality at the time the studies were performed [used with
permission, P. D. Pion and others (1987).Copyright 1987 AAAS]
513
P. D. PION AND M. D. KITTLESON
zyxwvutsrq
FIG 5a. Thoracic radiographs (lateral projection) of a 4-year-old cat with dilated
cardiomyopathy before [top) and six
months after (bottom) beginning taurine
supplementation. This cat received taurine supplementation (in crystalline form)
for a total of four months. Altering the
cat’s diet to a taurine-supplemented diet
then maintained adequate plasma taurine
concentrations and normal myocardial
function as assessed by echocardiography
(used with permission, P. D. Pion and
others 1989b)
I
zyxwvutsrqpo
FIG. 5b. Thoracic radiograph [dorso-ventral projection) of the same cat as in Fig 5a
before (left) and six months after [right)
taurine repletion (used with permission,
P. D. Pion and others 1989b)
I
exception and not the rule.
The answer to the third question (would
depleting cats of taurine cause dilated cardiomyopathy?) could have taken months or years to
arrive at had it not been for work in progress by
Rogers and Morris. They had been studying the
effects of feeding marginally low amounts of taurine to 11 cats for four years. Echocardiographic
evaluation of these cats, six eating amounts of
taurine slightly less (250 mg/kg dry diet) than the
minimum amount recommended by the National
Research Council (400 mg/kg dry diet) and five
eating slightly more (500 mg/kg dry diet),
revealed that two had dilated cardiomyopathy.
Re-evaluation of these cats 2, 4, 8 and 1 2 weeks
after beginning to supplement their diets with
taurine demonstrated a remarkable recovery of
left ventricular function similar to that we were
seeing after taurine supplementation [treatment)
of clinical cases of dilated cardiomyopathy.
Subsequent to these early findings we have
demonstrated that: 11) most cases of dilated cardiomyopathy, a previously lethal and incurable
cardiac disease in cats, are associated with low
plasma taurine concentration (Pion and others
1988a); (2) feeding cats experimental diets low in
taurine causes dilated cardiomyopathy in some
animals (Pion and others 1988b); (3) feeding certain commercial diets containing amounts of taurine previously thought to be adequate, resulted
in low plasma taurine concentration and eventually results in dilated cardiomyopathy in some
cats (Pion and others, 1988b) and (4) administering taurine to cats with dilated cardiomyopathy
associated with low plasma taurine results in an
apparently permanent recovery of the function of
the heart in most cases (Pion and others 1988a).
Due to the poor prognosis, in cats, associated
with dilated cardiomyopathy it has always been
a frustrating condition to treat. It should now be
considered a disease which is associated with a
guarded prognosis in the critically ill patient, but
which can be reversed with appropriate therapy.
The prognosis is good to excellent in cats that
survive longer than four weeks after starting therapy [see clinical management below).
There is no known relationship between taurine and other forms of heart disease in cats.
zyxwvut
514
zyx
zyx
zy
zyxwv
Taurine’s role in clinical practice
COMMERCIAL CAT FOODS,
PLASMA TAURINE
CONCENTRATION
’
Why did cats eating certain commercial cat
foods have measurably low plasma taurine concentration? It is presumably not because of intentional negligence on the part of pet food
companies. Most pet food companies strive to
provide the proper nutrients needed for cats and
dogs. They claim to meet or exceed government
recommendations regarding the minimum
amount of each nutrient the foods should contain. Many of these companies fund nutritional
and veterinary research in an attempt to (among
other reasons) improve the science upon which
their formulations are based.
During 1987, most cat food manufacturers
began to increase the amount of taurine in their
diets. Prior to that time, most of the diets we
analysed contained 1 to 15 times the published
National Research Council (NRC) recommendation for dietary taurine concentration (ie, 5007500 mg/kg of dry diet). To explain why many of
these cat foods were associated with plasma taurine depletion we hypothesised that either the
recommendation was too low, or the taurine present in the diets was not adequately absorbed or
retained. Both hypotheses may be true.
Many dry foods produced before this time contained 500-750 mg of taurine/kg of dry diet. Most
cats fed commercial diets containing 500 mg/kg of
dry diet maintain a plasma taurine concentration
lower than our research indicates is safe. At the
time the NRC recommendation for adequate dietary
taurine content was made, the evidence indicated that these plasma concentrations were safe.
Most canned (wet) foods that we evaluated contained 2 to 10 times the recommended amount of
taurine. Despite this apparently adequate dietary
level, many were associated with low plasma taurine concentrations in client-owned cats (Pion and
others 1987) and some were shown to cause low
plasma concentrations when fed to cats. Adding
more taurine to these foods appears to provide
enough taurine to maintain adequate plasma concentrations (see paper by Morris, Rogers and
Pacioretty in this publication for details).
In our original report (Pion 1987), certain cat
foods were implicated as possibly causing low
plasma taurine concentration associated with
myocardial failure (dilated cardiomyopathy). The
foods mentioned in that paper are not the only
foods that were capable of inducing this syndrome. We do not believe that any manufacturer’s implicated food was more or less able to
deplete plasma taurine concentration than diets
produced by other manufacturers. The incidence
of dilated cardiomyopathy associated with individual diets in our clinic appears to have been
related to the popularity and marketing practices
of certain manufacturers.
A survey of the pet cat population in three
clinics in the United States, around the time that
manufacturers began supplementing their formulations with additional taurine, indicated that 1020 per cent of cats eating commercial cat foods
had low plasma taurine concentration (Pion
unpublished). Had this deficiency not been corrected, some of these cats might have developed
eye problems (FCRD), heart problems (dilated
cardiomyopathy), both or neither. Adding more
taurine to the diets appears to prevent the associated clinical problems. However, to prevent the
possibility of this problem recurring it is important that the factors responsible for this phenomenon are identified.
Most manufacturers, that we have communicated with in the USA, have supplemented their
foods with taurine. Since that time, the subjective impression of our group and those at other
institutions in the USA is that the incidence of
dilated cardiomyopathy in cats has decreased
markedly. Studies to validate these impressions
are in progress.
~
~
MANAGING CATS WITH
SUSPECTED TAURINE
DEFICIENCY
The most efficient way to determine if a cat is
at risk is to submit a plasma sample to a laboratory for taurine analysis. Interpretation of plasma
taurine values is dependent upon several variables. There is not a ‘normal’ plasma concentration. Plasma taurine concentration is dependent
upon dietary intake. A cat eating a tuna diet
(high in taurine) will have a higher plasma taurine concentration than a cat eating a commercial
dry diet. Clinically, the critical value of plasma
taurine concentration, below which a cat may be
at risk for developing dilated cardiomyopathy, is
approximately 20 nmol/ml. To ensure a margin of
safety, any cat whose plasma taurine concentration is less than 40 nmol/ml should be changed
to another diet known to maintain a higher concentration. Submitting a plasma sample requires
special handling and can be facilitated by
requesting instructions from the laboratory.
Recent evidence suggests that taurine concentration measured from whole blood provides more
useful information than that obtained from measurement from plasma (Pacioretty and others
1988, Pion 1989a).
zyxwv
zyxw
515
zyxwvutsrqpon
zyxwvutsrqpo
P.D. PION AND M. D. KITTLESON
Cats with a presumptive diagnosis of dilated
cardiomyopathy should be prescribed standard
therapy as previously recommended in textbooks
and publications. The major points to remember
are: (1) minimise stress; (2) if the patient is not
severely dyspnoeic, obtain a thoracic radiograph
to evaluate the patient’s cardiac size and shape,
and determine whether pleural effusions or pulmonary oedema is present; (3) if the patient is
severely dyspnoeic radiography may be too
stressful. Pleurocentesis to identify and remove
any pleural effuision followed by cage rest (with
enriched oxygen concentration) and a diuretic
(furosemide [Lasix, Hoechst Roussel, Somerville,
N.J., USA] 0.5-2.0 mg/kg, intramuscularly) are
required; (4) maintenance therapy for congestive
heart failure, if present, should include diuretics
(furosemide 0-25-2.0 mg/kg orally two or three
times daily) and if necessary, the angiotensinconverting enzyme inhibitor, captopril (Capoten
3-6 mg orally two or three times daily).
Pleurocentesis and diuretic therapy should be
utilised as indicated clinically. Excessively dehydrating these patients should be avoided as it
will cause them to become more depressed and
anorexic. The use of digoxin is controversial; the
majority of patients successfully treated in our
study were not given digoxin.
To confirm the diagnosis of dilated cardiomyopathy, an echocardiogram is generally required.
Non-selective angiograms can be utilised but may
prove deleterious to the compromised patient. A
plasma sample for taurine analysis should be
obtained before commencing therapy with taurine. Once plasma samples have been acquired, it
is time to begin treatment with taurine (250 mg
orally twice daily). Taurine tablets may be
obtained from health food stores and are also
available through veterinary supply companies,
Cats with dilated cardiomyopathy associated
with a low plasma taurine concentration and
treated with taurine, that live more than one
week, have a high probability of recovering and
may be ‘normal’ within four months. In most
cases diuretic and vasodilator therapy can be discontinued within 12 weeks of beginning taurine
therapy. Beyond the initial treatment period,
dietary alteration is usually all that is necessary
to maintain the needs for taurine. It is our usual
policy to discontinue taurine supplementation
when echocardiographic parameters improve significantly, usually within 16 weeks of beginning
therapy. After discontinuing taurine supplementation, a plasma or blood taurine concentration
should be determined after 1, 2 and 4 months to
confirm that the diet fed is maintaining adequate
plasma or whole blood taurine concentration
(above 50 and 250 nmol/ml, respectively). If not,
the diet fed should be changed to one which
maintains blood taurine above these concentra-
tions. A more detailed discussion on diagnosis
and treatment has been published elsewhere
(Pion and others 1989b).
The four major points to emphasise are as
follows.
(1)There is no evidence that other cardiac conditions in cats will respond favourably to taurine
therapy. The diagnosis of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy has not in any way been correlated with
plasma taurine concentration or diet.
(2) The clinical signs of pleural effusion, pulmonary oedema and, or, ascites, with or without
electrocardiographic changes, do not constitute
sufficient evidence to support a diagnosis of
dilated cardiomyopathy (or any other specific
condition). Nor is a measured low plasma or blood
taurine concentration sufficient evidence for a
diagnosis of dilated cardiomyopathy. The ultimate
cardiac diagnosis should be determined by correlating all of the available physical and radiographic
findings with an echocardiogram performed and
interpreted by a skilled diagnostician.
(3) Most cases of dilated cardiomyopathy diagnosed at the University of California at Davis
have been associated with taurine deficiency.
However, not all cases of feline dilated cardiomyopathy are due to deficiency. It is important to
measure plasma taurine concentration in all cats
with dilated cardiomyopathy to confirm or rule
out taurine deficiency. Cases of dilated cardiomyopathy not associated with a low plasma taurine
concentration, when identified, must still be
thought of as a condition with a grave prognosis.
(4) It is important to correlate the diagnosis
with diet, so that foods which are not maintaining normal plasma taurine concentrations may be
identified and corrected.
(5) The attending veterinarian must emphasise
to clients that cats with dilated cardiomyopathy
associated with low plasma taurine concentrations, have a favourable prognosis if they survive
1-2 weeks (the time necessary to see the initial
clinical improvement - note that echocardiographic signs of improvement do not become
apparent for three to six weeks after commencing
therapy (Fig 4). A cat that is presented dying of
cardiomyopathy will probably die despite taurine therapy if diuretics, vasodilators and, or,
pleurocentesis do not provide sufficient symptomatic relief. Our clinical impression is that
these cats, no matter how ill, have a better
chance of survival if sent home to be nursed by
the client. The stress of hospitalisation can be
fatal to these severely compromised patients,
zyxwvutsr
516
CONCLUSIONS
Although we emphasise the importance of
echocardiography in the diagnosis of dilated
Taurine’s role in clinical practice
zy
zyxwvut
cardiomyopathy we are aware that echocardiography may not be readily available in all practice
areas. There are no contraindications to beginning taurine therapy in the absence of a definitive diagnosis. However, it is difficult to confirm
the diagnosis and response. A satisfactory
response in these cases may be related to the
diuretic or vasodilator therapy, or reported beneficial effects of taurine in patients with congestive heart failure not associated with myocardial
failure (Azuma and others 1982). In the latter situations, withdrawal of therapy for congestive
heart failure may be followed by a recurrence of
clinical signs.
As an obligate carnivore with an absolute
dietary requirement for taurine, the cat has provided researchers with a unique model in which
to study the role of taurine in mammals. This
same dietary requirement has proven to be a significant and recurring clinical problem for veterinarians dealing with cats in daily practice. The
extent of this problem is yet to be fully defined
and we believe that these problems would have
been difficult to predict. However, perhaps findings like these may make us all (veterinarians,
nutritionists and pet food manufacturers) a little
less cavalier about what we understand regarding
the nutrition of our pets and worry more about
what we do not know.
HINTON,J. R., SOUZA,J. D. & GILLIS,R. A. (1975)Deleterious
effects of taurine in cats with digitalis-induced arrhythmias. European lournal of Pharmacology 33,383-387
HUXTABLE,
R. & BRESSLER,
R. (1974)Taurine concentration in
congestive heart failure. Science 184,1187-1188
HUXTABLE,
R. J. (1987)From heart to hypothesis: a mechanism
for the calcium modulatory actions of taurine. Advances in
Experimental Biology and Medicine 217,371-387
HUXTABLE,
R.J. & SEBRMG,
L. A. (1983)Cardiovascular actions
of taurine. In Sulfur Amino Acids: Biochemical and Clinical Aspects. Liss, New York. pp 5-37
HUXTABLE,
R. J., LAIRD,H. E. & LPPINCOTT, S. E. (1979)The
transport of taurine in the heart and the rapid depletion of
tissue taurine content by guanidinoethyl sulfonate. Journal
of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics 211, 465-
471
HUXTABLE,
R. J. (1989)Taurine in the central nervous system
and the mammelian actions of taurine. Progress in NeurobiOlOgy32,471-533
JACOBSEN, J. G. & SMITH,
L. H. (1968)Biochemistry and physiology of taurine and taurine derivatives. Physiological
Reviews 48,424-511
KURIYAMA,
K. (1980)Taurine as a neuromodulator. Federation
Proceedings 39,2680-2684
LAIDLAW,S. A.,STWAN, J. A. & KOPPLE,1. D. (1987)Effect of
dietary taurine on plasma and blood cell taurine concentrations in cats. Journal of Nutrition 117,1945-1949
LOMBARDINI,
J. B. (1985) Effects of taurine on calcium ion
uptake and protein phosphorylation in rat retinal membrane preparations. Journal of Neurochemistry 45, 268-275
LOMBARDINI,
J. B. (1978)High-affinity transport of taurine in
the mammalian central nervous system. In Taurine and
Neurological Disorders. Ed B. A. & R. Huxtable. Raven,
New York. pp 119-135
MATUOR,
J. & KULAKOWSKI,
E. C. (1987)Insulin-like activity of
taurine. Advances in Experimental Biology Medicine 217,
217-226
MOISE,N. S., PACIORETTY,
L. M., KALLFELZ,F. A, & GILMOUR,
R.
F. (1989) Association between low plasma taurine and
dilatative cardiomyopathy in silver foxes. (Abstract) FASEB
3,A1265
MOZAFFARI,
M. S., TAN,B. H., LUCIA,M. A. & SCHAFFER,
S. W.
(1986)Effect of drug-induced taurine depletion on cardiac
contractility and metabolism. Biochemical Pharmacology
35, 985-989
MUTANI,R., BERGAMINI,
L. & DURELW,
L. (1978) Taurine in
experimental and human epilepsy. Taurine and Neurological Disorders, pp 359-373
NEWMAN,
W. H., FRANGAKIS,
C. J., GROSSO,
D. S. & BRESSLER,
R.
(1977)A relation between myocardial taurine content and
pulmonary wedge pressure in dogs with heart failure. Physiological Chemistzy and Physics 8 , 259-263
NOW-ELDIN,
F. & W I W S O N , J.F. (1955)Amino acid content of
whole blood cells in human leukaemias. British Journal of
Haematology 1,358-366
PACIORETTY,
L. M. (1988) The effect of dietary taurine on
plasma, serum, whole blood, and skeletal muscle taurine
concentrations in the cat. Masters Thesis, University of California at Davis
PION,P. D. (1988)Feline aortic thromboemboli and the potential utility of thrombolytic therapy with tissue plasminogen
activator. Veterinary Clinics of North America: Small Animal Practice 18, 79-86
PION,P. D.,KITTLESON,
M. D., ROGERS,
Q. R. & MORRIS,J. G.
(1987) Myocardial failure in cats associated with low
plasma taurine: a reversible cardiomyopathy. Science 237,
764-768
PION,P. D., KITILESON,M. D., DELELLIS,
L. A., NEWHOUSE,
C. A.
& ROGERS,
Q. R. (1988a)Recovery of myocardial function
in cats with dilated cardiomyopathy secondary to taurine
deficiency: one year followup. (Abstract) Circulation 78
(Supplement), 340
zyxwvutsrqponmlkj
zyxwvutsrqp
zyxwvutsrqpo
zyxwvutsrqp
zyxw
REFERENCES
AZARI, J. & HUXTABLE,
R. J. (1980)The mechanism of the
adrenergic stimulation of taurine influx in the heart. European Journal of Pharmacology 61, 217-223
AZUMA,
J,, HASEGAWA,
H., SAWAMURA,
A,, AWATA,
N., HARADA,
H., OCURA,K. & KISHIMOTO,
S. (1982)Taurine for treatment
of congestive heart failure. International Journal of Cardiology 2,303-309
BELLHORN,
R. W., AGUIRRE,
G. D. & BELLHORN,
M. B. (1974)
Feline central retinal degeneration. Investigative Ophthalmology 13, 608-619
CFIESNEY,
R. W.(1985)Taurine: its biological role and clinical
implications. Advances in Pediatrics 32,l-42
FELLMAN, J. H. & ROTH, E. S. (1985)The biological oxidation of
hypotaurine to taurine: hypotaurine as an antioxidant. In
Taurine: Biological Actions and Clinical Perspectives, Eds
S. S. Oja. L. Ahtee, P. Kontro and M. K. Paasonen, Liss,
New York. pp 71-82
FRANCONI,
F., MARTINI,
F., STENDARDI,
I., MATUCCI,
R., LUCILLA,
Z. & GIOTTI,A. (1982)Effect of taurine on calcium levels
and contractility in guinea-pig ventricular strips. Biochemical Pharmacology31, 3181-3185
HAYES,K. C., CAREY,
R. E. & SCHMIDT,
S. Y. (1975a)Retinal
degeneration associated with taurine deficiency in the cat.
Science 188,949-951
HAYES,K. C.,RABIN,A. R. & BERSON,E. L. (197513)An ultrastructural study of nutritionally induced and reversed retinal degeneration in cats. American Journal of Pathology 78,
505-524
HINO,A. (1956)Amino acids in blood. 11. Amino acids in normal human blood fractions. Nippon Naika Gakkai Zasshi
45,601-619
zyxwv
517
zyxwvutsrq
zyxwvuts
zyxwvutsrq
zyxwvutsrqp
zyxwvutsrqpo
zyxwv
zyxwvutsrq
P. D. PION AND M. D. KITTLESON
PION,P. D., STURMAN,
J. A., ROGERS,
Q. R., KITTLESON,M. D. &
HAYES,K . C (1988b)Feeding diets that lower plasma taurine concentrations causes reduced myocardial mechanical
function in cats. (Abstract) FASEB 2,A1617
PION,P. D., GREENE,
K., LEWIS,J. & KITTLESON,M. D. (1989a)
Fasting causes significant reductions in plasma taurine concentrations. (Abstract) Journal of Veterinary Internal
Medicine, in press
PION,P. D., KITTLESON,
M. D. & ROGERS,
Q. R. (1989h)Cardiomyopathy in the cat and its relation to taurine deficiency.
In Current Veterinary Therapy: Small Animal Practice 10th
edn. Ed R. W. Kirk and J. D. Bongura. Saunders, Philadelphia, pp 251-262
READ, W. 0.& WELTY,J. D. (1963) Effect of taurine on
epinephrine and digoxin induced irregularities of the dog
heart. Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics 139,282-289
RICKETTS,
J.D. (1983) Feline central retinal degeneration in
the domestic cat. Journal of Small Animal Practice 24,221227
SCHULLER-LEVIS,
G.& STURMAN,
J. (1989)Evaluation of immunity in taurine-deficient cats. Proceedings of the Functional
Neurochemistry of Taurine Symposium, Huelva, Spain, in
press
STURMAN,
J. A. (1986)Nutritional taurine and central nervous
system development. Annals of the New York Academy of
Sciences 477, 196-213
STURMAN,
J. A., GARGANO,
A. D., MESSING,
J. M. & IMAKI, H.
(1986)Feline maternal taurine deficiency: effect on mother
and offspring. Journal of Nutrition 116,655-667
TANIZAWA,
K.,MIZUNO,T. & KOYAMA,I. (1986)Taurine treatment for spontaneous epilepsy in the cat. Japanese Journal
ABSTRACTS
Cutaneous rnucinous vesiculation
in a dog with hypothyroidism
A FOUR-year-old St Bernard was presented with
vision problems, associated with drooping eyelids. Clinical examination revealed severe obesity, bilateral entropion and blepharoptosis, a
widespread superficial bacterial folliculitis and
multiple papular, vesicular lesions on the forehead and face. The folliculitis remarkably
improved after treatment with oral erythromycin
and medicated shampoo. The other skin lesions
persisted. Hypothyroidism was diagnosed and a
skin biopsy confirmed mucinous vesiculation.
Thyroid supplementation was begun and all the
eyelid and skin lesions resolved; improvement
began within a week.
MILLER,
W. H. & BURGER,
R. G. (1990)Journal of the American
VeterinaryMedical Association 196,757
Effects of medetomidine in dogs
and influeace of anticholinergics
THE cardiovascular and respiratory effects of
medetomidine, a new sedative and analgesic
518
of Veterinary Science 48,1041-1043
TAKAHASHI,
R. & NAKANE,
Y . (1978)Clinical trial of taurine in
epilepsy. In Taurine and Neurological Disorders, Raven,
New York. Ed B. A. & R. Huxtable. pp 375-385
TAKIHARA,
K., AZUMA,
J., AWATA,N., OHTA,H., HAMAGUCHI,
T.,
SAWAMURA,
A., TANAKA,
Y., KISHIMOTO,S. & SPERELAKIS,
N.
(1986)Beneficial effect of taurine in rabbits with chronic
congestive heart failure. American Heart Journal 112,12781284
THURSTON,
J. H., HAUHART,
R. E. & NACCARATO,
E. F. (1981)
Taurine: possible role in osmotic regulation of mammalian
heart. Science 214,1371-1374
TIEDEMANN,
F. & GMELIN,
L. (1827)Einige neue bestandtheile
der galle des ochsen. Physik Chem 9,326-337
TRACHTMAN,
H.,BARBOUR,R., STURMAN,
J. A. & FINBERG,
L.
(1988) Taurine and osmoregulation: taurine is a cerebral
osmoprotective molecule in chronic hypernatremic dehydration. Pediatric Research 23,35-39
VAN GELDER,
N.M., KOYAMA,I. & JASPER,
H. H. (1977)neatment of spontaneous chronic epilepsy in a cat. Epilepsia
18,45-54
GELDER,
N. M. (1983)A central mechanism of action for
taurine: osmoregulation, bivalent cations and excitation
threshold. Neurochemical Research 8,687-699
WRIGHT,
C. E., LIN, T. T., LIN, Y. Y.,STURMAN,
J, A. & GAULL,
G.
E. (1985)Taurine scavenges oxidized chlorine in biological
system. In Taurine: Biological Actions and Clinical Perspectives, Liss, New York. Ed. S. S. Oja, L. Ahtee, P. Kontro,
and M. K. Paasonen, pp 137-147
WRIGHT,
C. E., TALLAN,
H. H., LIN,Y. Y . , & GAULL,
G. E. (1986)
Taurine: biological update. Annual Review of Biochemistry
VAN
55,427-53
drug, were investigated in 10 laboratory beagles.
Medetomidine initially induced hypertension,
which was followed by a longer lasting period of
hypotension. Bradycardia with second degree
atrioventricular blocks and a decrease in respiratory frequency were also observed. Atropine
sulphate and glycopyrrolate temporarily abolished the bradycardiac effect of medetomidine.
Xylazine induced a similar cardiovascular and
respiratory pattern to medetomidine.
VAINO,0. & PALMU,
L. (1990)Acfa Veterinaria Scandinavica
30,401
Mast cell tumours in three ferrets
OPEN, 5 mm diameter, pruritic skin lesions were
found on the head, neck or thorax of three ferrets.
All had been present for some time (up to 14
months). Mast cell tumour was identified in each
case by skin biopsy. Excised tumours did not
reoccur, neither were there signs of metastases.
All three animals died from unrelated conditions; two from other types of neoplasia. Mast
cell tumours do not appear to be as virulent in
ferrets as in other mammals.
STAUBER,
E., ROBINETTE,
J. & BASARABA,
R. (1990)Journal of the
American VeterinaryMedical Association 196,766