I'm not familiar with cake or its database layers, but maybe you can add a little bit of sql.
The relevant sql would be something like
order by field(myTable.myID, 35, 15, 25)
-- or alternatively, more cross database compatible
order by case when myTable.myID = 35 then 1
when myTable.myID = 15 then 2
when myTable.myID = 25 then 3
end
however, the most universal approach would be to just reorder in php code.
$products = array(35,15,25);//the ordered array
$records = array_flip($products);
foreach ($list as $row) {
$id = $row['Product']['id'];
$records[$id] = $row;
}
print_r($records);