The Real Murders on Elm Street What Lies Beneath (Season 1, Episode 5)
TV Episode | 60 min | Crime, Reality-TV

The Real Murders on Elm Street

What Lies Beneath (Season 1, Episode 5)

TV Episode | 60 min | Crime, Reality-TV

What started as small-town hijinks leads two teenagers to go missing on Thanksgiving. When investigators get a call from a man who claims he is responsible for the deaths while defending his home, they must determine truth from madness.

Contacts

+ Add

Become a member to see contact information for What Lies Beneath.

Cast	+ Add Cast
12 cast members

Name	Known for
Adam Chisnall Detective Luberts Detective Luberts See fewer	The Upshaws (2021)
Corinne DeCost Haile Kifer & Ashley Williams Haile Kifer & Ashley Williams See fewer	Party of Darkness
Nancy Grace Self (archive footage) Self (archive footage) See fewer	Midnight Special (2016)
Sarah Katzenberger Self - Reporter, Brainerd Dispatch Self - Reporter, Brainerd Dispatch See fewer	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Jeremy Luberts Self - Retired Sergeant Morrison County SO Self - Retired Sergeant Morrison County SO See fewer	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Dan Milam Nick Brady Nick Brady See fewer	Firelight (2025)
Alfonso Milanese Steve Schaeffel Steve Schaeffel See fewer	Robbin (2024)
Ronald Pierson Byron Smith Byron Smith See fewer	Penny Dreadful: City of Angels (2020)
Steve Schaeffel Self - Nick and Haile's Grandpa Self - Nick and Haile's Grandpa See fewer	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Byron Smith Self (voice) Self (voice) See fewer	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Dakota Vanhercke Self - Nick and Haile's Friend Self - Nick and Haile's Friend See fewer	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Ashley Williams Self - Byron Smith's Neighbor Self - Byron Smith's Neighbor See fewer	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)