Steven Rubenstein
As a graduate student at Columbia University I focused on Amazonian ethnology, globalization and development, and interpretive anthropology. As a postdoctoral fellow at Cornell university's Society for the Humanities, and as a summer fellow of the School for Criticism and Theory, I pursued my interest in post-colonial and post-structuralist theory. Through graduate school, my postdoctoral year, and eight years as an assistant and then associate professor at Ohio University, my primary commitment has been to the Shuar nation in the Ecuadorian Amazon. Prior to Ecuadorian colonization of the region in the 20th century, Shuar (like many other sub-Andean hunter-gardeners) lived in small clusters of semi-nomadic households, connected by the loosest of kin and political ties. In the 1950s, with the support of Catholic missionaries, they coalesced into nucleated settlements called centros, and in the 1960s they formed a federation - the first indigenous political organization the Amazon, and arguably the first indigenous political organization in Ecuador - with an elected, centralized, and hierarchically organized leadership. My dissertation research documented this ongoing process through a history of changing conflicts, both among Shuar and between Shuar and settlers. My research has since shifted to two other themes that were implicit in my dissertation and fundamental to the study of colonialism: the processes (material as well as discursive practices) through which historical subjects emerge, and how they take shape in shifting fields of power and desire.
I am currently pursuing three projects that explore the ongoing transformation of ethnic identity as Shuar participate in new economic and political arenas. (1) One area of research concerns the intersection of gendered and ethnic identities. For much of the twentieth century, most anthropologists portrayed Amazonian women as subordinate to men. Over the past twenty years several researchers have proposed more sophisticated models of indigenous notions of "power," and have called attention to complex forms of gender politics hitherto ignored. I have recently collected life histories of Shuar women that clearly illustrate the important role women play in Shuar politics. (2) Another area of research focuses on the way indigenous identity and modernity are constructed through "community-based eco-tourism." Currently, Shuar are interested in developing tourism not only as a way to underwrite community development, but as a way to resist state-promoted oil-exploration. After finishing a book on Shuar women and politics, I hope to begin a year-long collaborative study that will assess the current impact of tourism, discuss expectations and aspirations, and explore alternative models for tourism and tourism-based development. (3) A third area of research focuses on the involvement of Shuar Federation leaders in the national indigenous movement and the plurinational political movement. Although indigenous people constitute as much as 40% of Equador's population, prior to 1996 they were practically excluded from all political institutions. Since then, indigenous people have been elected to mayorships and to the National Congress. Through local and national political participation, the plurinational movement is explicitly challenging prior notions of indigenous identity, as well as the viability of the modern liberal nation-state.
Supervisors: Professor Robert F. Murphy, Dr. Libbet Crandon-Malamud, and Professor Michael T. Taussig
I am currently pursuing three projects that explore the ongoing transformation of ethnic identity as Shuar participate in new economic and political arenas. (1) One area of research concerns the intersection of gendered and ethnic identities. For much of the twentieth century, most anthropologists portrayed Amazonian women as subordinate to men. Over the past twenty years several researchers have proposed more sophisticated models of indigenous notions of "power," and have called attention to complex forms of gender politics hitherto ignored. I have recently collected life histories of Shuar women that clearly illustrate the important role women play in Shuar politics. (2) Another area of research focuses on the way indigenous identity and modernity are constructed through "community-based eco-tourism." Currently, Shuar are interested in developing tourism not only as a way to underwrite community development, but as a way to resist state-promoted oil-exploration. After finishing a book on Shuar women and politics, I hope to begin a year-long collaborative study that will assess the current impact of tourism, discuss expectations and aspirations, and explore alternative models for tourism and tourism-based development. (3) A third area of research focuses on the involvement of Shuar Federation leaders in the national indigenous movement and the plurinational political movement. Although indigenous people constitute as much as 40% of Equador's population, prior to 1996 they were practically excluded from all political institutions. Since then, indigenous people have been elected to mayorships and to the National Congress. Through local and national political participation, the plurinational movement is explicitly challenging prior notions of indigenous identity, as well as the viability of the modern liberal nation-state.
Supervisors: Professor Robert F. Murphy, Dr. Libbet Crandon-Malamud, and Professor Michael T. Taussig
less
InterestsView All (20)
Uploads
Books by Steven Rubenstein
In his own words, Alejandro Tsakimp tells of his lives and relationships, the practice of shamanism, and the many challenges and triumphs he has encountered since childhood. He was born at the time when Shuar were first confronting the impact of Ecuadorian colonialism, which had triggered devastating intertribal conflict over the production and trade of shrunken heads and intratribal feuding fueled by accusations of witchcraft. Tsakimp was first exposed to healing practices when he was cured in the womb by a shaman. Later he actively pursued this knowledge in the hopes of curing his father, another shaman, who was ill from witchcraft. His father's death in 1990 created conflict among his heirs, who were the first generation of Shuar to inherit property. Tsakimp's family fiercely competed for the property and eventually accused one another of witchcraft and parricide.
Anthropologist Steven Rubenstein, who began working with Tsakimp in 1989, has skillfully edited Tsakimp's stories and provides essential background information. Ruben-stein argues that although these stories reveal tensions between individual and collective autonomy on the colonial frontier, they also resist simplistic dichotomies such as state versus indigene and modern versus traditional.
Alejandro Tsakimp provides a revealing look at the relationship between anthropologist and shaman and an insightful glimpse into the complicated lives of South American Indians today.
Border Crossings is a collection of fourteen essays about the evolving focus and perspective of anthropologists and the anthropology of North and South America over the past two decades. For a growing number of researchers, the realities of working in the Americas have changed the distinctions between being a “Latin,” “North,” or “Native” Americanist as these researchers turn their interests and expertise simultaneously homeward and out across the globe.
Contributors: Barbara Burton, Les W. Field, Kathleen S. Fine-Dare, Sarah Gammage, Lêda Leitão Martins, Peter McCormick, John M. Norvell, David L. Nugent, Steven L. Rubenstein, Enrique Salmón, Jean N. Scandlyn, Linda J. Seligmann, and James A. Zeidler
Papers by Steven Rubenstein
Shuar, indigenous to the Ecuadorian Amazon. Formerly an acephalous society of hunter-gardeners, the Shuar now constitute a federation with a democratically elected, hierarchical leadership and are at the forefront of indigenous movements in Latin America. The author analyzes this trans-
formation in the context of colonialism but argues that colonialism involves far more than the movement of people from one place to another or the extension of state authority over new
territory. Rather, he reveals colonialism to hinge on the transformation of sociospatial boundaries. Such transformations were critical not only to Shuar ethnogenesis but also to Ecuadorian state-building. That is, colonialism involves a dialectical reorganization both of the state and of its new subjects.
Talks by Steven Rubenstein
In his own words, Alejandro Tsakimp tells of his lives and relationships, the practice of shamanism, and the many challenges and triumphs he has encountered since childhood. He was born at the time when Shuar were first confronting the impact of Ecuadorian colonialism, which had triggered devastating intertribal conflict over the production and trade of shrunken heads and intratribal feuding fueled by accusations of witchcraft. Tsakimp was first exposed to healing practices when he was cured in the womb by a shaman. Later he actively pursued this knowledge in the hopes of curing his father, another shaman, who was ill from witchcraft. His father's death in 1990 created conflict among his heirs, who were the first generation of Shuar to inherit property. Tsakimp's family fiercely competed for the property and eventually accused one another of witchcraft and parricide.
Anthropologist Steven Rubenstein, who began working with Tsakimp in 1989, has skillfully edited Tsakimp's stories and provides essential background information. Ruben-stein argues that although these stories reveal tensions between individual and collective autonomy on the colonial frontier, they also resist simplistic dichotomies such as state versus indigene and modern versus traditional.
Alejandro Tsakimp provides a revealing look at the relationship between anthropologist and shaman and an insightful glimpse into the complicated lives of South American Indians today.
Border Crossings is a collection of fourteen essays about the evolving focus and perspective of anthropologists and the anthropology of North and South America over the past two decades. For a growing number of researchers, the realities of working in the Americas have changed the distinctions between being a “Latin,” “North,” or “Native” Americanist as these researchers turn their interests and expertise simultaneously homeward and out across the globe.
Contributors: Barbara Burton, Les W. Field, Kathleen S. Fine-Dare, Sarah Gammage, Lêda Leitão Martins, Peter McCormick, John M. Norvell, David L. Nugent, Steven L. Rubenstein, Enrique Salmón, Jean N. Scandlyn, Linda J. Seligmann, and James A. Zeidler
Shuar, indigenous to the Ecuadorian Amazon. Formerly an acephalous society of hunter-gardeners, the Shuar now constitute a federation with a democratically elected, hierarchical leadership and are at the forefront of indigenous movements in Latin America. The author analyzes this trans-
formation in the context of colonialism but argues that colonialism involves far more than the movement of people from one place to another or the extension of state authority over new
territory. Rather, he reveals colonialism to hinge on the transformation of sociospatial boundaries. Such transformations were critical not only to Shuar ethnogenesis but also to Ecuadorian state-building. That is, colonialism involves a dialectical reorganization both of the state and of its new subjects.