The Believer and the Modern Study of the Bible, Edited by T. Ganzel, Y. Brandes, and C. Deutsch,, 2019
Biblical Criticism and the Dating of Biblical Sources-A Brief Survey The "documentary hypothesis,... more Biblical Criticism and the Dating of Biblical Sources-A Brief Survey The "documentary hypothesis," the most famous theory of critical biblical scholarship, originated in the eighteenth century from the examination of what appeared to be contradictions and repetitions in biblical stories and legislation. Scholars concluded that the Torah is comprised of four primary sources that differ from each other in language and content. Two of these sources are called after the names of God that characterize them: source "J" frequently uses the Tetragrammaton YHWH (in old scholarly literature "Jehovah" erroneously following the seemingly masoretic punctuation of this divine name), while source "E" uses often the name Elohim. There are two additional sources: "P," the Priestly source, which discusses sacrifices, ritual, and the priesthood, and favors numerical sums, and "D," the source of the book of Deuteronomy. Several chapters in the early prophets are also attributed to the Deuteronomic school. "D" mandates the centralization of the ritual in a location to be chosen by God, and takes special interest in the subject of exile and redemption and the fate of the Israelite people. Scholars usually date "D" to the end of the First Temple period and "P" to the Second Temple period. There have been, and continue to be, many adherents of these theories. There have also been many opponents-primarily, but not exclusively, Jewish and Christian religious fundamentalists. The greatest of the contributors to the documentary hypothesis in the nineteenth century was Julius Wellhausen. The most famous among the early critics of the theory was Rabbi David Zvi Hoffmann who, shortly after the publication of Wellhausen's research, published in 1903 a rebuttal entitled Decisive Evidence against the Graf-Wellhausen Theory.
Uploads
Papers by יואל אליצור