Talk:Race and intelligence/FAQ: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
Undid revision 367006138 by Captain Occam (talk) it no longer enjoys support |
You don't appear to understand how this works. You can't just remove something without any discussion, when there have been no content-based objections to it at all; that's WP:IDONTLIKEIT. |
||
| Line 27: | Line 27: | ||
|a= |
|a= |
||
* '''Fringe issue''' - Research into race and intelligence is not "fringe", some of the conclusions drawn from that research are highly contentious and need to be presented as such in the article. |
* '''Fringe issue''' - Research into race and intelligence is not "fringe", some of the conclusions drawn from that research are highly contentious and need to be presented as such in the article. |
||
* '''Hereditarian viewpoint''' - The "hereditarian" viewpoint is not "fringe" science, and should not be presented as such in the article. {{disputed-inline}} |
|||
* '''Race/intelligence link''' - The article will discuss the sources that show there is currently no established genetic link/correlation between race and intelligence, note that the research is inconclusive and ongoing, and give a brief summary of the 'Genes and Intelligence' article (or use other sources) as necessary to give proper balance to genetics-based research. it is understood that this resolved may be subject to clarification as we flesh out the article and sources. |
* '''Race/intelligence link''' - The article will discuss the sources that show there is currently no established genetic link/correlation between race and intelligence, note that the research is inconclusive and ongoing, and give a brief summary of the 'Genes and Intelligence' article (or use other sources) as necessary to give proper balance to genetics-based research. it is understood that this resolved may be subject to clarification as we flesh out the article and sources. |
||
* '''SIRE data''' - All current research on race in relation to IQ scores is based in SIRE information. |
* '''SIRE data''' - All current research on race in relation to IQ scores is based in SIRE information. |
||
Revision as of 17:44, 9 June 2010
 | Below are answers to frequently asked questions about the corresponding page Race and intelligence. They address concerns, questions, and misconceptions which have repeatedly arisen on the talk page. Please feel free to change this material in light of new discussion. |
Many of these questions arise frequently on the talk page concerning Race and intelligence.
To view an explanation to the answer, click the [show] link to the right of the question.
Q1: Should this article be called Race and IQ? (No.)
Q2: Should the terms White, Black, Hispanic and Asian be used in the lead graphic? (No.)
A1: No. It is divisive.
Q3: Decisions reached in mediation in the beginning of 2010
- Fringe issue - Research into race and intelligence is not "fringe", some of the conclusions drawn from that research are highly contentious and need to be presented as such in the article.
- Hereditarian viewpoint - The "hereditarian" viewpoint is not "fringe" science, and should not be presented as such in the article. [disputed – discuss]
- Race/intelligence link - The article will discuss the sources that show there is currently no established genetic link/correlation between race and intelligence, note that the research is inconclusive and ongoing, and give a brief summary of the 'Genes and Intelligence' article (or use other sources) as necessary to give proper balance to genetics-based research. it is understood that this resolved may be subject to clarification as we flesh out the article and sources.
- SIRE data - All current research on race in relation to IQ scores is based in SIRE information.
- SIRE & genetic markers - Some research shows that race (defined by SIRE) correlates highly with certain genetic markers (markers which are obviously inherited, but which are chosen because they are highly informative of biogeographical ancestry.)
- Distribution of phenotypes -Research suggests that some genes whose distributions vary between races affect the distribution of phenotypic traits. Obvious examples are skin and eye color; additional examples include blood type, lactase persistence, sensitivity to alcohol, and degree of risk for certain diseases. However, the functions of the majority of these genes remain unknown or poorly understood.
- No specific research - There is no definitive research (as yet) that speaks to whether the genes that affect intelligence in individuals are part of the cluster of genes mentioned above.